Mark A. Proctor wrote an interesting article for JBL that discusses the parable of the Good Samaritan within the context of Luke, specifically identifying Luke's interchanging terms like "brother," "friend." "neighbor (one who is close)," "parent," "partner," "relative," etc. The article is entitled, "'Who Is My Neighbor?' Recontextualizing Luke's Good Samaritan (Luke 10:25-37) and appears in volume 138.1 (2019) 203-219.
Proctor's conclusions are both my own and not my own, as I think that he takes it in a direction that creates a non sequitur, but the information and observations he provides in his article support what I have been arguing for some time. Namely, that "not just any person may count as 'neighbor', but only those with whom one shares a covenantlike relationship of mutual entitlement" (213). He quotes Diane G. Chen (Luke: A New Covenant Commentary, 151) as stating that the very designation of someone as a "neighbor" "presupposes the existence of a non-neighbor, since a boundary simultaneously excludes as well as includes" (ibid., fn. 30).
Likewise, he argues:
Since Jesus' conversation with the lawyer takes the meaning of Lev 19:18b LXX as its starting point, it seems reasonable to begin the attempt to assess Luke's implied understanding of πλησίον there.
According to Johannes Fichtner, the command of Lev 19:18b "applies unequivocally towards the members of the covenant of Yahweh and not self-evidently towards all men. That πλησίον can carry such a covenantal nuance finds confirmation in LXX passages such as Gen 26:26-33, Ruth 4:1-12, Pss 14:1-5, and 23:1-10, all of which use the term to speak about participants in social contracts . . . Each of these four contexts thus deploys πλησίον to designate parties involved in mutually beneficial and binding agreements, the purpose of which is to secure fair and equitable treatment for both parties. The material surrounding Lev 19:18b, moreover, makes it abundantly clear that this exhortation likewise concerns covenantal responsibilities; this section of Leviticus enumerates laws that aim to secure the shared interests of YHWH's followers by prescribing and proscribing reciprocal social responsibilities. (212)
Johannes Fichter observes that "in a legal statement of this kind [in Lev 19:18b] extension beyond this circle [of the covenant community] is not to be expected in advance. (Ibid., fn 29)
Likewise, Fitzmeyer points out that "in Leviticus 'neighbor' stands in parallelism with 'the children of your own people', i.e., fellow Israelites." He further points out that this extends to the גר "sojourner" in 19:4, but not to others like the Goyim, i.e., nations/pagans. (210, fn 20)
Proctor's observations that the neighbor in Luke sees its companion terms with those within social contracts with one another (e.g., parents, friends, partners, etc.) is interesting since Luke's overall thrust is that what makes up the activity of a true covenant member is the care of other covenant members. Proctor wants to expand this to the generalized community of Jews having obligations to the general community of the Samaritans, or rather to see them all as one community, but this isn't quite Luke's point. The point in Luke-Acts is that Christians have obligations to Christians regardless of ethnicity or class or any other worldly divide that would normally excuse one within the community from helping another in the community who was in need.
This is why the story of the rich man and Lazarus is important for the interpretation of Luke. The rich man is Jewish, the poor man is Jewish, Both are visible members of the covenant community, but one goes to paradise and the other to punishment, precisely, because the rich man proves himself to be a false member of the community by his lack of concern for his fellow covenant member in need. Hence, the Book of Acts displays the activity of taking care of one another's needs in the Christian community as a sign of receiving the Holy Spirit that is more significant than even speaking in tongues is in the book.
Laudably, Proctor rejects the interpretation that Jesus is telling His audience that everyone is a neighbor or that the real question to answer is whether one is a neighbor to everyone without making any distinctions about who is who (206, fn 10). Proctor comments on Bock's statements that attempt this contradictory interpretation, and states that "while Bock's suggestion that 'a neighbor does not make distinctions in offering care' might ring true for some altruistically minded contemporaries, such sentimentality would be grossly anachronistic should one try to impose such an understanding of either γείτων or πλησίον on a first-century text like Luke's Gospel" (213, fn 31).
Indeed, not only would it be anachronistic but eisegetical by reading in modern ideas of inclusivism and egalitarianism into a Christocentrically exclusive theology conveyed by Lukan volumes and the New Testament (following the Old) as a whole.
Tuesday, May 19, 2020
Monday, May 18, 2020
Was Junia an Apostle?
A recent feminist article brings up information to the public that most within New Testament scholarship are already aware of, namely, that Paul mentions a Junia as someone who is "well known among the apostles" in Romans 16:7. Of course, this is riddled with misinformation for feminist propagandistic purposes in order to somehow show that the early church had women in authoritative positions (against the clear teaching of Paul elsewhere).
But let's examine this claim.
First, it is important to note that the difference of the name Junia/Junias of being male or female is based on the placement of the accent in Greek. The earliest texts, and likely the originals, did not contain accents and so we are left to context or guessing at which it may be. The argument that it could be a husband and wife missionary team is valid, but there are groups mentioned together in Romans who are all female or all male and thus this interpretation is not definitely supported. Both would be either well known by the apostles or missionaries, since it is plural, i.e., "they are well known among the apostles."
Second to this, the Greek reads εἰσιν ἐπίσημοι ἐν τοῖς ἀποστόλοις, which can either mean that they were well known among the apostles in terms of their being apostles or well known by the apostles.
Third, and what is most important to note here, is that either way the word ἀπόστολος just means "one who is sent." By whom he or she is sent and for what purpose is contextually determined. Paul and Barnabas are called apostles of the church of Antioch because they were sent out by the church. But this does not make Barnabas one of the twelve. In fact, it is important to understand that Luke's argument in Acts is that Paul is the twelfth apostle and Matthias is not because Matthias is chosen and sent out by the apostles, but an apostle of Christ must be sent out by Christ. It would seem obvious but if one is a messenger of someone else that means that said someone else actually sent them. Only the twelve are actually commissioned by Christ as His representatives/emissaries/messengers from whom all other messengers get their marching orders (whatever they may be). Hence, Christ sends Paul in the Book of Acts, not Matthias, making him the last of Christ's apostles. This is why context is important that the twelve are named Christ's apostles in distinction from those who may be sent by others and for varying purposes.
What this means is that even if Junia is female, and even if she is called an apostle with her husband Andronicus, this does not mean she has any authority at all. They are not apostles of Christ. They may be a missionary couple, where she is a helper to her husband in missionary work. They may simply be messengers who carry messages back and forth from churches along with financial aid. Who knows? The text does not tell us, and thus, we are left to speculate. However, if speculation is authoritative over explicit and clear teaching where women are prohibited from taking upon any authority in the church over men then someone skipped hermeneutics class when they taught hermeneutics that day.
Lin makes the following two arguments.
If this seems like a strange debate for academics to be having, then your instincts aren’t wrong. Lin told me “I doubt there would be arguments about what this phrase means if Junia was understood to be male. But since it's virtually impossible for Junia to be male, some interpreters have then focused on the Greek of the phrase ‘esteemed among/by the apostles’ to argue that she was not an apostle.”
When scholars (who are all, you won’t be surprised to learn, male) try to make this argument they appeal to the use of this language and grammatical form elsewhere in ancient Greek. There are two problems with these arguments, Lin told me. In the first place, the ancient examples cited by other scholars do not definitively prove anything and, thus, cannot be used to “exclude Junia from apostolicity.” The second problem is that grammar is ambiguous while logic is not. Lin used famous athletes as an example of how this ambiguity works: “[The statement that]‘Michael Jordan is esteemed by basketball players’ does not necessarily exclude or include Jordan from the category ‘basketball player’ - the grammar tells us nothing here, and we can only deduce that Jordan IS a basketball player because we already know who Jordan is.”
The first argument is just an ad hominem. Apparently, someone skipped logical fallacies on the day they taught logic at school as well. As though male scholars point out different possibilities of interpretation based on their gender. Did the facts of the text's ambiguity change because of the gender of the one studying them? As I argued above, scholars would still bring these facts out and debate them if they are real scholars, male or female, because they are relevant to the correct interpretation of the text. As the Fathers who are cited in the article indicate, there is no threat to male-only authority in identifying Junia as a female who is an apostle because she isn't one of the twelve and doesn't have any authority over men anyway. So scholars are free from the need to make it one way or another, even if they are male scholars.
Second, her argument from logic is actually illogical. To say that someone is esteemed by a group does not mean that they are a part of that group. If an employee is well known by the board of a company it does not mean that he is a part of the board. If someone is well known by the police it does not mean that he or she is part of the police force. Her analogy only works with Michael Jordan because we already know that he is a basketball player, but what if a cheerleader was well known to all of the basketball players? Does that mean she is one? So the grammatical question is important on the one hand for identifying whether Junias is merely known by the apostles or a missionary herself, but the ambiguity does not lend itself to any definitive interpretation.
What does box in the possibilities is the biblical view of gender roles and therefore what would have been considered an acceptable role of Junias (if female) by Paul. This is simply a matter of good exegesis. One does not interpret what is clearly stated by an ambiguous scenario that may possibly be true absent of any other indicators to the contrary. If the Bible prohibits homosexuality as being godlessness and I then interpret the relationship between David and Jonathan, both who are accepted as godly men in the narrative, as a homosexual one, then I have ignored the limitations of the possibilities that the author's beliefs provide in order to expand possibilities that would run contrary to them. This means I am ignoring a key component of context. If Ezekiel's view of the world does not allow for aliens, but it does allow for angels/supernatural beings, then interpreting the creatures in his visions as aliens is fallacious nonsense. Likewise, if I try and interpret an ambiguous statement like Andronicus and Junia being noted among the apostles as something that contradicts biblical gender roles that the very apostle writing about Junia affirms in his writings then my interpretation is built on a faulty methodology and lacks the context that would bring me to the right conclusions.
So, no, Junia is not an apostle of Christ. She may be a she or she may be a he. She may be in some sort of missionary ministry with her husband or she may just be known as a godly woman with her husband by the apostles of Christ, but if she was exercising authority or teaching over men she would not be commended by the apostle, as his own teaching suggests.
The same goes for Phoebe in the now popular idea that those who delivered letters sometimes read them and even more rarely explained them. So Phoebe, it is argued, may have read the letter (which is not a problem for any position on gender roles of which I am aware) but maybe if our speculation and imagination can stretch from what sometimes occurred to what definitely occurred then she also explained the text of Romans, exegeting it for congregations like an elder would. Except Paul doesn't allow such things as he states so that is not a possibility. This is why a denial that Paul wrote the excerpt in 1 Corinthians and the first letter to Timothy is so popular. Feminists desire to remove that context in order to expand their possibilities, but for those who believe the text is inspired and inerrant, whether from Paul's hand or from the Pauline school that recorded his teachings, it remains as a vital part of the context that eliminates the interpretive possibility that such is the case.
The complementarian view is built on the rock of clear explicit teaching and the feminist/egalitarian view stands on eisegetical sand.
But let's examine this claim.
First, it is important to note that the difference of the name Junia/Junias of being male or female is based on the placement of the accent in Greek. The earliest texts, and likely the originals, did not contain accents and so we are left to context or guessing at which it may be. The argument that it could be a husband and wife missionary team is valid, but there are groups mentioned together in Romans who are all female or all male and thus this interpretation is not definitely supported. Both would be either well known by the apostles or missionaries, since it is plural, i.e., "they are well known among the apostles."
Second to this, the Greek reads εἰσιν ἐπίσημοι ἐν τοῖς ἀποστόλοις, which can either mean that they were well known among the apostles in terms of their being apostles or well known by the apostles.
Third, and what is most important to note here, is that either way the word ἀπόστολος just means "one who is sent." By whom he or she is sent and for what purpose is contextually determined. Paul and Barnabas are called apostles of the church of Antioch because they were sent out by the church. But this does not make Barnabas one of the twelve. In fact, it is important to understand that Luke's argument in Acts is that Paul is the twelfth apostle and Matthias is not because Matthias is chosen and sent out by the apostles, but an apostle of Christ must be sent out by Christ. It would seem obvious but if one is a messenger of someone else that means that said someone else actually sent them. Only the twelve are actually commissioned by Christ as His representatives/emissaries/messengers from whom all other messengers get their marching orders (whatever they may be). Hence, Christ sends Paul in the Book of Acts, not Matthias, making him the last of Christ's apostles. This is why context is important that the twelve are named Christ's apostles in distinction from those who may be sent by others and for varying purposes.
What this means is that even if Junia is female, and even if she is called an apostle with her husband Andronicus, this does not mean she has any authority at all. They are not apostles of Christ. They may be a missionary couple, where she is a helper to her husband in missionary work. They may simply be messengers who carry messages back and forth from churches along with financial aid. Who knows? The text does not tell us, and thus, we are left to speculate. However, if speculation is authoritative over explicit and clear teaching where women are prohibited from taking upon any authority in the church over men then someone skipped hermeneutics class when they taught hermeneutics that day.
Lin makes the following two arguments.
If this seems like a strange debate for academics to be having, then your instincts aren’t wrong. Lin told me “I doubt there would be arguments about what this phrase means if Junia was understood to be male. But since it's virtually impossible for Junia to be male, some interpreters have then focused on the Greek of the phrase ‘esteemed among/by the apostles’ to argue that she was not an apostle.”
When scholars (who are all, you won’t be surprised to learn, male) try to make this argument they appeal to the use of this language and grammatical form elsewhere in ancient Greek. There are two problems with these arguments, Lin told me. In the first place, the ancient examples cited by other scholars do not definitively prove anything and, thus, cannot be used to “exclude Junia from apostolicity.” The second problem is that grammar is ambiguous while logic is not. Lin used famous athletes as an example of how this ambiguity works: “[The statement that]‘Michael Jordan is esteemed by basketball players’ does not necessarily exclude or include Jordan from the category ‘basketball player’ - the grammar tells us nothing here, and we can only deduce that Jordan IS a basketball player because we already know who Jordan is.”
The first argument is just an ad hominem. Apparently, someone skipped logical fallacies on the day they taught logic at school as well. As though male scholars point out different possibilities of interpretation based on their gender. Did the facts of the text's ambiguity change because of the gender of the one studying them? As I argued above, scholars would still bring these facts out and debate them if they are real scholars, male or female, because they are relevant to the correct interpretation of the text. As the Fathers who are cited in the article indicate, there is no threat to male-only authority in identifying Junia as a female who is an apostle because she isn't one of the twelve and doesn't have any authority over men anyway. So scholars are free from the need to make it one way or another, even if they are male scholars.
Second, her argument from logic is actually illogical. To say that someone is esteemed by a group does not mean that they are a part of that group. If an employee is well known by the board of a company it does not mean that he is a part of the board. If someone is well known by the police it does not mean that he or she is part of the police force. Her analogy only works with Michael Jordan because we already know that he is a basketball player, but what if a cheerleader was well known to all of the basketball players? Does that mean she is one? So the grammatical question is important on the one hand for identifying whether Junias is merely known by the apostles or a missionary herself, but the ambiguity does not lend itself to any definitive interpretation.
What does box in the possibilities is the biblical view of gender roles and therefore what would have been considered an acceptable role of Junias (if female) by Paul. This is simply a matter of good exegesis. One does not interpret what is clearly stated by an ambiguous scenario that may possibly be true absent of any other indicators to the contrary. If the Bible prohibits homosexuality as being godlessness and I then interpret the relationship between David and Jonathan, both who are accepted as godly men in the narrative, as a homosexual one, then I have ignored the limitations of the possibilities that the author's beliefs provide in order to expand possibilities that would run contrary to them. This means I am ignoring a key component of context. If Ezekiel's view of the world does not allow for aliens, but it does allow for angels/supernatural beings, then interpreting the creatures in his visions as aliens is fallacious nonsense. Likewise, if I try and interpret an ambiguous statement like Andronicus and Junia being noted among the apostles as something that contradicts biblical gender roles that the very apostle writing about Junia affirms in his writings then my interpretation is built on a faulty methodology and lacks the context that would bring me to the right conclusions.
So, no, Junia is not an apostle of Christ. She may be a she or she may be a he. She may be in some sort of missionary ministry with her husband or she may just be known as a godly woman with her husband by the apostles of Christ, but if she was exercising authority or teaching over men she would not be commended by the apostle, as his own teaching suggests.
The same goes for Phoebe in the now popular idea that those who delivered letters sometimes read them and even more rarely explained them. So Phoebe, it is argued, may have read the letter (which is not a problem for any position on gender roles of which I am aware) but maybe if our speculation and imagination can stretch from what sometimes occurred to what definitely occurred then she also explained the text of Romans, exegeting it for congregations like an elder would. Except Paul doesn't allow such things as he states so that is not a possibility. This is why a denial that Paul wrote the excerpt in 1 Corinthians and the first letter to Timothy is so popular. Feminists desire to remove that context in order to expand their possibilities, but for those who believe the text is inspired and inerrant, whether from Paul's hand or from the Pauline school that recorded his teachings, it remains as a vital part of the context that eliminates the interpretive possibility that such is the case.
The complementarian view is built on the rock of clear explicit teaching and the feminist/egalitarian view stands on eisegetical sand.
Sunday, May 17, 2020
Saturday, May 9, 2020
An Outline of What We Are Doing in Gathering through Online Means
I thought I would write this down and hopefully be helpful to other churches who are looking to be faithful in this time.
Sunday:
A Sunday School lesson is given through Youtube. Afterward, those who listened can gather through the Jitsi app and ask questions about the lesson and fellowship with one another.
Then the church service begins on Jitsi where we go through an entire liturgy with one another. Announcements, creeds/confessions, songs, prayers, declarations of forgiveness, and communion are all included. Each household secures the physical elements of the communion and an elder prays and directs the ceremony. We partake of it in unison. A final prayer and/or benediction is given.
Then a sermon is given through Youtube followed by a song. Afterward, there is fellowship and questions about the sermon on Jitsi.
Tuesday:
Bible study through Youtube. Afterward, we meet in Jitsi for questions and fellowship.
Wednesday:
Book study is held on Jitsi.
Friday:
Anchored Bible Study through Youtube.
Right now our studies are through Romans, Psalms, Leviticus, Hebrews, and the Prayers of Paul.
On top of all of this, the elders remain praying for the congregation, keep in touch through text, phone calls, facetime, etc. The physical and spiritual needs of the church are still all being met. All are still encouraged to text, phone, facetime one another.
The Word, sacrament, fellowship, and the church's responsibility in meeting needs are all being met.
It is really important to note that if your church is not meeting in such a way where these are all still being met then it is being disobedient. Listening to sermons online or through podcasts is not church. Calling some Christians during this time without the central element of the Word taught is not church. Fellowship is the meeting of spiritual needs by taking the Word that has been taught and expressed through sacraments by elders, in submission to the elders, and edifying one another with it in prayers, songs, counsel, etc., and the meeting of one another's physical needs. The church cannot take any of these elements away and still be the church.
Some have used Jitsi, as we have. Others are using Zoom or similar apps.
Sunday:
A Sunday School lesson is given through Youtube. Afterward, those who listened can gather through the Jitsi app and ask questions about the lesson and fellowship with one another.
Then the church service begins on Jitsi where we go through an entire liturgy with one another. Announcements, creeds/confessions, songs, prayers, declarations of forgiveness, and communion are all included. Each household secures the physical elements of the communion and an elder prays and directs the ceremony. We partake of it in unison. A final prayer and/or benediction is given.
Then a sermon is given through Youtube followed by a song. Afterward, there is fellowship and questions about the sermon on Jitsi.
Tuesday:
Bible study through Youtube. Afterward, we meet in Jitsi for questions and fellowship.
Wednesday:
Book study is held on Jitsi.
Friday:
Anchored Bible Study through Youtube.
Right now our studies are through Romans, Psalms, Leviticus, Hebrews, and the Prayers of Paul.
On top of all of this, the elders remain praying for the congregation, keep in touch through text, phone calls, facetime, etc. The physical and spiritual needs of the church are still all being met. All are still encouraged to text, phone, facetime one another.
The Word, sacrament, fellowship, and the church's responsibility in meeting needs are all being met.
It is really important to note that if your church is not meeting in such a way where these are all still being met then it is being disobedient. Listening to sermons online or through podcasts is not church. Calling some Christians during this time without the central element of the Word taught is not church. Fellowship is the meeting of spiritual needs by taking the Word that has been taught and expressed through sacraments by elders, in submission to the elders, and edifying one another with it in prayers, songs, counsel, etc., and the meeting of one another's physical needs. The church cannot take any of these elements away and still be the church.
Some have used Jitsi, as we have. Others are using Zoom or similar apps.
Monday, May 4, 2020
Not by Might, Nor by Power, Nor by the Spirit, Says the Lord, but by Geographical Location and Proximity
http://triablogue.blogspot.com/2020/05/spectral-koinonia.html?m=1
I don't know what new thing Hodge has in mind. The electronic church isn't new. Jews and Christians have practiced physical fellowship for millennia. Christians have continued to worship during time of plague for centuries. Perhaps Hodge means his own understanding of the church.
I don't know what new thing Hodge has in mind. The electronic church isn't new. Jews and Christians have practiced physical fellowship for millennia. Christians have continued to worship during time of plague for centuries. Perhaps Hodge means his own understanding of the church.
This seems
rather confused. Electronic church is new, as Steve admits here. It hasn’t been
practiced for millennia as when we did not have it. Even if the electronic
church was as old as the internet, it would still be considered new. Likewise,
this comment, and others, tell me that Steve doesn’t really have a grasp on
what I am arguing because a widespread phenomenon of having live church meetings
that are being held through apps like Jitsi or Zoom are new even for the age of
the internet. Again, if Steve thinks I am talking about someone who is only listening
to sermons online and making private prayers, that is not assembling for
corporate worship, and therefore, not for that which I am arguing.
i)
That,
of course, is the stock excuse to suspend public worship. During times when
it's deemed to be riskier to meet together than to avoid meeting
together.
Because it’s a good one. If you still meet in a building when there is a bomb threat, that's up to you, but wisdom would say to suspend it. However, we are not suspending public worship unless Steve is conflating "public worship" with "being in the same geographical location." We are all still performing public worship services online.
ii)
One problem, as I recently noted, is that it's a matter of degree:
How
risky is too risky? Does Hodge think there should be a moratorium on public
worship until we develop a vaccine?
Sure it is.
I never said otherwise. I’m not the one to decide what is too risky as I am not
an expert on the matter. That is why deferring to medical researchers who track
and study plagues and have been assigned to this one, i.e., experts, is
crucial.
As
I noted in another post, the ancient church didn't practice social distancing:
Of course it
didn’t. It couldn’t refrain from meeting in the same physical geographical area
and be obedient. There was no other way to meet or minister to the sick.
Likewise, they likely didn’t take more precautions with the sick because they
had no concept that illness was spread through viruses and bacteria. This is
simply an “is-ought” fallacy. Because people in church history didn’t do X, we
ought not to do X. According to what? The authority of a tradition that had no
alternative means available to them. If there is only one means to be obedient,
then there is no choice to between options. There are no options. Were they
choosing between physical contact and the internet? Of course not. So this isn’t
even a good argument from tradition as it isn’t parallel to the church today
and what choices it needs to make. These choices have never been made before
because these options have never existed before.
So
is it essential or just ideal?
Ideal. That’s
been my entire argument. If it was essential then there could be no exceptions
even in the first century. If being in the same physical geographical location
with one another is essential to perform the ministries and receive from the
ministry what needs to be performed and received, i.e., the reasons why the
assembly meets, then to even have one exception to these ministries is to be
disobedient. The very reason there are exceptions is because physicality is not
an essential component.
i)
To begin with, it's revealing that Hodge has no categories for what I describe,
so he substitutes categories like "sacramental" and
"mystical" that I don't use. Classic examples of sacramentalism would
be baptismal regeneration, penance, and reception of the real body and blood of
Christ in the eucharist. But I haven't used those
examples because I don't subscribe to that kind of sacramentalism.
ii)
Another kind of supernaturalism would be something like xenoglossy, miraculous
healing, prophetic insight and foresight. But I haven't used those examples.
iii)
Take more mundane examples like answer to prayer. An answer to prayer is
supernatural in the sense that it's something that wouldn't naturally happen.
God must grant the petition. It may not be supernatural in a spectacular or
sensational sense, but it's not just something that was going happened whether
or not the prayer request was made. Does Hodge think answered prayer is
"mystical"?
Another
example is sanctification. That's supernatural, but it can use the means of
grace. Ordinary public worship can facilitate sanctification.
This is
exactly what a sacrament is. The idea that some physical thing is being used as
a means of grace, has a greater power in getting prayers answered, etc.
Perhaps, Steve’s category of what makes a sacrament is too narrow, as it has
not allowed him to see that he is arguing sacramentally.
Furthermore,
his last statement again begs the question. I have been arguing that what we
are doing is public worship, but Steve keeps inserting the idea that public,
corporate worship of the assembly necessarily entails our meeting in the same
geographical location. His argument demands it. Yet, this is the very idea I
refuted in the original post.
It
looks like the electronic church.
No, it doesn’t.
See, we can all make assertions. LOL. One would have to be disembodied in order
to have disembodied worship, like the saints in heaven.
He
keeps missing the point of coming together for physical fellowship.
For
some reason, Hodge is hung up on "geography". The primary principle
is physical assembly. A common space is simply a necessary instrumental means to
that end. It could be inside or outside, although weather can be a practical
factor.
First, I don’t
think Steve realizes that he is hung up on geography. His entire argument demands
it. My point is that geography is irrelevant if one can be in unity through the
Word and Spirit as they are assembled whether geographically or online. But
Steve seems to be arguing that something special happens through the
geographical proximity of Christians to one another, along with the other
elements I’m sure. This is what he cannot prove biblically so it’s a matter of
just assuming it.
But what of
the original assemblies under Moses when you have (possibly) a couple million
people involved? There are no mics so the elders of the clans likely heard
Moses, Aaron, the priests, and then taught what was heard to the rest of the tribes.
So they are not hearing the Word directly from the mouths of those who speak
it. They are not participating directly in the sacrifices. Is the blood being
sprinkled on everyone in the congregation or everyone by proxy?
My only
point here is that those in the rest of the congregation are not geographically
near enough to technically be in the assembly. Yet, they are a part of it.
Likewise, what
about meeting in an outdoor location like a Park. Everyone can hear the
ministers, thanks to those non-normative electronic microphones we all use now,
so that all are receiving the same Word in unity, all are speaking the same
truth to one another in liturgy, all singing the same songs, all praying
together, etc. Yet, is the guy who is a quarter of a mile away at the edge of
the crowd from the guy on the opposite side and aren’t in a close geographical
proximity in unity and fellowship in the assembly? I would say so because it is
the same Word heard and spoken in preaching, confession, prayer, and song that
binds them. They partake of the same communion service together. But if this
qualifies, why not two people a mile away doing the same thing? Why not 10
miles? 500? 1000? Steve acts as though geography is not the issue when it is
the only issue his position could argue for unless he wants to say that two
people who don’t physically touch one another aren’t in the same assembly.
i)
There's
a sense in which heaven (i.e. the intermediate state) is deficient. It's a
temporary stopgap until the resurrection of the just.
Agreed when it comes to the saints,
not Jesus. Jesus isn’t in an intermediate state. He has His eternal body and
yet exclusively fellowships with His people through the non-physical means of
the Spirit.
However, I am arguing for deficiency
in being able to obey the necessary requirements for something to be defined as
an obedient assembly. If physical touch is necessary for fellowship then
spirits can’t fellowship. If physical touch is necessary to worship God in
obedience to the assembly, then spirits can’t do that. Neither the saints nor
Jesus are unified with one another in the assembly either in heaven or on
earth.
ii)
However,
the comparison is off because, to judge by visions of heaven in Scripture, it's
like a collective dream where the saints have simulated bodies and interact
with each other as if they were embodied agents.
You mean like we do online? A spirit
has a projection of his former bodily form. That is true. So does speaking to
one another through cameras.
ii)
Hodge trivialized the role of touch, but consider how much physical touch
figured in the public ministry of Christ. Consider the role of touch in
ecclesiastical prayer for healing:
Touching was
a common way of transferring blessing in the first century. Steve can argue that
this is normative. I’m not sure I would agree. Do we confer blessing now
through physical touch when we do meet in the same location? Sometimes, but I
doubt many think that a blessing does not transfer without physical touch. It
certainly isn’t necessary for Christ or the early church to touch people in
order to do it since Christ and the apostles don’t always do it to heal people.
iii)
Embodied
experience, embodied interaction are part of Christian worship, not in the
first place because we're Christian, but because we're human, and so that's
something we bring to the proceeding, whether inside church or outside church.
That's just how God made us. It conditions our humanity.
1. If it is an essential part then we
are back to the saints in heaven incapable of partaking in worship. Steve’s
idea of what is “embodied” keeps slipping back and forth between definitions.
On the one hand, it cannot be through the internet because that does not allow
our physical bodies to be near each other, and on the other it can be done by
spirits in heaven because they have projected images of their bodies that
interact with one another, although not through physical touch.
2. We are embodied. Everything we do as
physical creatures on earth is embodied, even when we are talking through
cameras and microphones. Does Steve think that using a microphone is
disembodied because it is now not a direct interaction between my vocal chords
and the ear drums of the congregation? The microphone and camera are mediums of
our physical, embodied interactions, not a disembodied replacement of them.
iv)
Physical
interaction can mean many things. Eye-contact. Speaking face-to-face. Singing
alongside each other. Praying in unison.
This is where I think that Steve is
not tracking with my argument. We are making eye-contact through the camera. We
are speaking face-to-face through the camera and mic. We are singing with one
another in unity. We are praying as one through the app. Has Steve actually
participated in this kind of service before? Or is again arguing for
geographical proximity as a means of grace?
v)
By Hodge/s logic, a married couple might as well conduct their marital life
entirely through cellphones. They could raise their kids entirely through
cellphones. No physical interaction required. Just the electronic voice and the
image on the screen. Have domestic robots provide for the physical necessities
while we communicate with our kids through cellphones.
Here is
where Steve’s argument goes off the rails. Is he actually arguing that the
relationship between husband and wife, that is of a physical nature, is the
same as what makes up the essential components of how the church should
interact? Pagan worship is pretty physical. You could probably make this analogy
in that setting, but Christian worship is in truth and Spirit and those who
worship the Father do so through those means, not through the physical location
(that’s Christ’s whole point to the woman at the well). Our fellowship is in
the One Spirit given to us, not touch. Our communion with Christ is through the
Spirit, not through physical touch. The nature of the spousal relationship can
only occur physically. The two become one flesh, not one spirit. Without the
physical interaction, the marriage relationship is not made nor sustained, but
is a practical divorce and disobedient. Such is not true of the assemblies of
God so this is simply a false analogy.
That
just begs the question. Were conjugal relations never normative but just a
temporary stopgap until we developed artificial insemination?
No, because
the nature of the relationship is physical. That is not true of the Christian’s
relationship with other Christians in the assembly.
Nowadays
you don't need to hug your kids or hold their hands or take them in your arms
or give them piggyback rides if you have domestic robots can do that. You don't
need to read to your kids. A computer can do that.
I’ve already
argued for the basic necessity of humans to touch one another and be physically
present with one another. Parents give this health benefit to their children in
their show of physical affection. Friends can. Family can. Christians can. That
is ideal. Is it necessary for Christians to give it to one another rather than
family and other friends? No, but it is ideal that they participate in it. I’ve
never said otherwise. However, should men and women who aren’t married be
physical with one another? I personally don’t think that should be the norm,
nor was it for most of church history. Does that mean that men aren’t fellowshipping
with the women and that they are of two different assemblies? Of course not.
By
Hodge's logic, there was never any intrinsic necessity in Christians meeting
together for worship. Why bother with house-churches or the agape feast?
Why bother?
Because there is an intrinsic necessity for Christians to meet together in
houses or catacombs or buildings or outdoor settings, etc. because there is no
other way to assemble and meet the ministry requirements, i.e., the very
reasons for which those meetings take place (the feast is done away quite early
so is Steve arguing that we haven’t been in the church for a couple thousand
years because we no longer meet in what was a normative way for the early
church?).
Me: “Now that isn’t the case. If by “normative,” Steve means “an
essential component of the command” then my entire post refuted that idea. If
it was normative then none of these things could be done by proxy, and they
were even in the early church.”
Steve: That's a non sequitur.
No, it isn’t.
If an essential component, i.e., a component of X that must be present in order
for X to be performed, then X is not performed when that necessary component is absent. Ergo, to
obediently perform X without that component of being physically present with
other believers in the same geographical location is to show that such is not
an essential component Steve should have read my original post more carefully.
The
fact that some things can be done by proxy doesn't mean that's a permanent
alternative. Is bottle-feeding preferable to breastfeeding? Is it preferable
for able-bodied teenagers to use electric skateboards instead of using their
own muscles to walk?
I’ve
maintained the whole time that this isn’t permanent or preferable/ideal.
However, what is preferable depends upon the situation. It’s preferable to
breastfeed all things being equal. However, if the mother has a debilitating disease
that can be transferred through breastfeeding, it is preferable in that
situation to use formula. Again, all things being equal, it is preferable that
the guy use his legs for exercise, but if late for work or he is feeling weak,
the skateboard is preferable. No one wants these alternate situations to last,
however, so it is the situation that is not ideal that makes the alternative
preferable. Once the situation changes back to normal, the means with more
benefit becomes preferable.
Why
did God institute public worship in the first place unless he reserves certain
kinds of blessings for public worship?
I’ve already
answered this in the original post I wrote. Notice, again, that Steve conflates
public worship with being physically in the same geographical location. The
entire argument is over whether the blessings through the ministries of the
assembly are still being delivered and received by the church because it is
publically assembling online. My post argued that they are because the medium
of the internet allows for all of these ministries to still thrive.
This
reminds me of Televangelists who instruct viewers to put their hands on the TV
screen to receive healing.
And Jesus
resurrecting reminds atheists of a cosmic zombie. Everything can be reduced to
an absurd description, which is why mockery isn’t an argument. The same goes
for calling these things “spectral,” as that has connotations of quackery. I
could just as easily say that Steve’s touching ministry reminds me of a Benny
Hinn Crusade or Todd Bentley kicking people in the congregation in the face. But
on another note, isn’t Jesus’ ministry spectral? In fact, isn’t it the only ministry He has to us right now?
Isn’t it the only fellowship He has had
with His church for the past two thousand years? Though embodied, He communes
and transfers every blessing that exists through the Spirit. No physical touch
needed, that is, unless one wants to argue for Jesus being physically present in the Mass.
Preaching
has always been physical. I think what he means is that the message is
abstract.
I mean the
actual message that goes out is not through physical touch. Obviously, preaching,
even through the internet or a microphone, is physical. It just doesn’t require
being physically in the same geographical location.
But
Hodge doesn't seem to think there's any spiritual benefit to physical
fellowship. Certainly nothing to outweigh the alleged physical risk.
Steve
himself argued that the benefit of touch wasn’t spiritual, but a basic human
need. I’ve argued against the sacramental idea of physical proximity.
i)
But
Hodge is very selective and one-sided about the experts he listens to. He's
totally sold on the social distancing model. He shrugs off the herd immunity
model. Or discriminating quarantine based on individuals who test
positive.
The experts are sold on the model.
If they were sold on the herd immunity model, I’d do that. I should also be
clear that by "experts" I do not mean politicians in government or general practitioners or doctors in other fields or statisticians, etc. I mean people who
follow pandemics, chase them and track them, medical researchers, who are now assigned
to studying and given all they need to study, this particular pandemic. They
seem to be suggesting that herd immunity isn’t ideal because many infected may
not be obtaining immunity. In any case, wisdom is an assumption that the opinions
of the novice and the experienced are not to be trusted equally.
Saturday, May 2, 2020
Are We Disembodied and Digitized by Meeting Online?
Steve
responded to my previous post. I appreciate the discussion. It’s good for
people to think through this new territory and I understand the suspicion
toward what is completely new. We should be suspicious. We should ask, Why is
this new thing presented to us? Is it harmful or helpful?
“But
is online media a permanent alternative to corporate worship? Is that what's
meant by corporate worship?”
No. I’ve
tried to make this clear. The ideal is to be physically present with one
another, but such is not the ideal because it is somehow more obedient to meet physically than meeting
online in a time when the risk of physically meeting is assessed to be a greater threat than not meeting physically. It is ideal because it provides a basic human component to human
health, as Steve mentions below. But this is a basic human need that all
humans, believer or unbeliever, have. I just believe it should be primarily met
with other believers when possible. So if the church can meet physically in the
same place without this threat, it should. Furthermore, when the church does again meet physically, anyone not doing so would be in sin, since they are not in submission to the elders nor partaking in a church that is meeting in all of the aspects of ministry I mentioned before. Along those same lines, watching Youtube videos or listening to podcasts alone is not meeting as the church online. Fellowship and all it assumes, the meeting of needs, spiritual and physical, must remain as essential components of the assembly.
i)
I
haven't referred to the sacraments or sacramental grace. I'm Zwinglian. I
haven't suggested that physicality is sacramental.
Steve hasn’t
referred to it with the word “sacrament.” That is true. However, when he speaks
as though there is something supernatural or mystical happening due to our
physical presence in the same place, as though a grace, a transformation, or a
power is given to us through it, then this is, in fact, a sacramental idea. It
isn’t biblical, but you can see how tradition has shaped our thinking, even if subconsciously.
We think there is something mystical happening when we physically meet in the
same place. But what does physically meeting in the same place do that meeting
through some other means not do?
Now, I would
argue for the sacramental nature of the assembly as God’s temple, but as argued
before, this is not limited by what geographical area we occupy. The church is
the temple when they do not meet. The temple is enlarged when they do meet so
that sacred space is enlarged to a greater geographical area. God’s life-giving
glory/presence occupies and flows from sacred space. This is only magnified
when meeting online, not diminished.
ii)
However,
human beings aren't angels. We're embodied agents, Embodied souls. Even the
intermediate state is a temporary stopgap.
Two things here. 1. Steve seems to
be suggesting that we are becoming digitized ourselves, disembodied. We aren’t
living in the Matrix. Everyone online is still embodied. Everyone meeting is
still physical. I don’t how physical church gets for people, but I’ve never
heard anyone make the argument that you did not go to church unless you
physically touched someone. So what exactly does disembodied worship/fellowship
look like? Have we been practicing it even when we do physically meet in the
same room? Our physical brains engaged, our physical mouths take communion, our
physical vocal chords sing, our physical tongues speak the truth. I’m one of
the biggest adversaries toward gnostic thinking in our culture that I know of,
but online worship is very physical and hardly disembodied.
2. The problem with this line of
argumentation is that it will eventually have to argue that Christ can’t join
us in our worship/fellowship in the way that He should because He is not
meeting with us physically but through the Spirit. Likewise, those in heaven
can have no real worship and fellowship with Christ because they are spirits
and disembodied at the moment. If embodied worship is a necessity, then they
all are deficient in it.
We
are physical beings by design. Physical interaction is natural component of
corporate worship. In person fellowship. The role of touch in human relations.
Face-to-face conversation. Singing together. Praying to gather.
What does “physical
interaction” mean? I agree that what is devoid of technology is natural, but
confusing what is natural with what is ultimately good or ideal has
implications on numerous things. If Christians must shun technology for the
natural as an ethical good then we must all reconsider becoming Amish. What is
natural is normative by necessity in a non-technical age, not something that is
ideal. I see no biblical argument in suggesting otherwise. We sing together,
have face-to-face interactions with one another online, so the only thing
missing is physical touch. Is that actually necessary for fellowship? Have you
not fellowshipped or gone to church until you physically touch someone? Does
that mean that men should never fellowship or worship with women? Certainly, in
church history, unmarried men and women did not touch one another in the
assembly. I’m not sure that even married people did so. Does this mean they
were all out of fellowship and had forsaken the assembly? Is it necessary to
just touch one person or all of them? All joking aside, touch is a part of a
physical need that Christians can provide for one another and should when they
are able. It is not a necessary component of fellowship and worship though. If
you are a leper, and it's not Jesus or an apostle with a healing gift you're
reaching out for, please love people and keep your hands to yourself.
iii)
It's
not necessarily about meeting in the same room, but meeting together. Weather
permitting, it could be an out-door event, although buildings provide shelter
from the inclement elements.
iv)
By
Hodge's logic, to assemble in public worship was never a normative feature of
Christian (or Jewish?) worship? There's no obligation or necessity for
Christians to ever meet together in physical worship. There are no supernatural
blessings that God reserves for public worship. It could all be cubical and
disembodied.
That’s really not my argument at
all. It was normative because it was the only way a church could meet together.
Now that isn’t the case. If by “normative,” Steve means “an essential component
of the command” then my entire post refuted that idea. If it was normative then
none of these things could be done by proxy, and they were even in the early
church. This is a new technology which allows for it in our day, which is
really why what I am saying is so shocking to people. It simply is unfamiliar,
and therefore, uncomfortable, not disobedient. It certainly is not ideal
because we should want to be with one another in order to meet one another’s needs
concerning physical interaction, but my argument is that this is not a
necessary component of the believer’s ministry to one another. Other humans can
fill it, but believers can only fulfill the ministries to one another the Lord
has assigned to them and them alone. There is a longing to be with the people that
you love in every way that you can. We long to be in the physical presence of
Jesus, and as Paul says, we are absent from Him right now. That is the ideal
that we would try and fulfill while being obedient in any way that we can. But
that phrase “while being obedient” is important. We don’t off ourselves to be
present with Christ. Hence, we need to ask whether we are doing what is right
and most loving first and then ask if there is more that we can do to be
present with Christ and one another in our love and obedience.
There
are situations where representatives communicated through letter rather than in
person. In some cases that's a practical necessity. And it can have the
advantage of a permanent verbal record for posterity. But worship and
instruction of distinct, if often related.
Instruction in
a letter is not distinct from the instruction in the assembly. They assembly
was instructed by the letter. Paul taught the Corinthian congregation through
letter and was there in spirit with them through it. It is one and the same in
that regard. Corporate worship requires the assembly to meet together and
receive that instruction though. I never argued otherwise. That is accomplished
both through physically meeting and meeting online.
v)
Hodge
has an oddly ghostly view of Christian worship, as if embodied agency is
generally expendable or superfluous. Simulated physical fellowship. Spectral
worship. Digitized communion.
Maybe I have
an oddly Holy Ghostly view. LOL. Here we see again this idea that if one is
communicating through video he is somehow disembodied. Does everyone who speaks
to someone through a camera go out of their bodies? Is Steven suggesting again
that some mystical thing happens through the physical body being present in the
same geographical location with other physical bodies? Certainly, chemical
things happen. This is why people like going to places where there are lots of
other people. It’s why they like visiting friends and family. There is something
very natural that happens, but I don’t see anything supernatural about it that only believers can fill.
Again, is
the communion digitized? Are we all eating gigabytes? No. We’re all eating
physical bread and drinking physical wine while we meet and see one another’s
faces as an elder conducts the communion ceremony. It remains a very physical
thing we are doing with our physical bodies. We are all still connected because
of the digital media. We are not digital nor is our partaking in the body and
the blood. Furthermore, worship is in spirit and truth, not physical presence,
as Jesus instructed the woman at the well. Isn’t all worship “spectral worship”?
Isn’t it all the Holy Spirit working with our inner beings, our spirits, since
the body right now is dead in sin? Certainly, worship is performed with our
bodies, but this isn’t different when meeting online. As I said, we are still
doing everything in our bodies, singing with our physical vocal chords, eating
the bread and wine with our mouths, speaking the truth in love with our
tongues, etc. Preaching has always been non-physical. The non-physical word is
the medium through which we worship God and are transformed as His church.
Whether digitized or in person, the Word is used by the Spirit to transform the
physical temple of the church on earth by their hearing it and receiving faith
and grace through it. This is all accomplished through an online meeting.
Indefinite
lockdowns will cause churches to go broke. They will never reopen. Moreover,
Tech Giants are cracking down on the electronic church.
Sure, but my argument wasn’t about
the economics of the localized church either. It was solely about whether
believers are being obedient to their ministry by meeting online in order to protect
the church’s members from plague. Whether a local church has enough money
should not be brought into the ethical equation until the money is the ethical
question itself. Certainly, if the spiritual risk outweighed the physical risk,
then the physical risk would have to take a backseat. But Steve’s statement
confuses what I am arguing. I am not arguing anything about the larger economy,
even though the larger economy certainly will affect the church’s finances. I
am arguing about whether we further a risk to members because we believe it a
necessity to ministry to physically meet in the same place (we are meeting in
the same places online, but are not in the same geographical area). The risk to
church finances is related to another question concerning the risk assessment
of going to work versus staying at home. I have not addressed that question.
Expert
opinion isn't monolithic. At the same time, expert opinion can become insular
and ingrown.
I never
suggested expert opinion was monolithic, but the people equipped to disagree
with experts are other experts, not some armchair experts who read a bunch of
articles on the internet and watched Youtube videos that are contrarian to
expert opinions. It reminds me of the documentaries about the exodus and Jesus
that were done by Simcha
Jacobovici. Lots of data without the ability to understand it that comes with
being in the fields of study he attempts to use in his arguments. This happens
in every field.
I
don trust "experts" on the co-ed military or indoctrinating students
about trangenderism or obliterating the distinction between boys teams and
girls teams. I don't delegate that to the "experts". Credulity is not
intellectual or theological virtue for Christians to cultivate. That's not
something we're entitled to delegate to unaccountable experts driven by a
secular social agenda.
I actually
do trust experts on all of these things because the experts are the orthodox
teachers of the church using the Bible to assess ethics. All of these issues
are ethical issues and in the realm of ecclesiastical authority. The secular
state has no authority or expertise on these issues at all. So these are not
good examples. In this case, we’re the experts the secularists aren’t trusting,
which makes them just as much fools, if not more so, as we are when we do not
trust them in their actual fields of expertise God has given over to them.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)