Tuesday, February 11, 2020

The Errors of Errancy, Part VI: The Abuse and Misuse of Romans 1 and 2

When one reads certain statements in Romans 1 and 2, he or she may think that the Enlightenment had a point that humans can discover the truth and morality through reasoning and intuition, since God has given humanity the ability for both. In vv. 19-20, the text indicates that God has given an ability to man to understand him through reason applied to the book of nature. It states:

Because what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them. For since the creation of the world his invisible attributes—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, because they are understood through what has been made. So people are without excuse. 

In 2:14-15

For whenever the Gentiles, who do not have the law, do by nature the things required by the law, these who do not have the law are a law to themselves. They show that the work of the law is written in their hearts, as their conscience bears witness and their conflicting thoughts accuse or else defend them,

The problem with applying both of these ideas to the errancy debate, arguing that humans can judge the Bible's reliability by what they know through reason and intuition is that the context indicates that both are not only insufficient, but have brought men to a state of falsehood and depravity, not truth and righteousness. 

The whole text of Romans 1 states that even though God gave this natural revelation to humans (specifically the nations here), they "suppressed the truth in unrighteousness" (v. 18), meaning they argued against the truth in order to accommodate their sin. Hence, God did not give them greater understanding through it, but established their lies they believed as truths further by giving them over to sin that would cause them to become entrenched in their falsehoods. Hence, what men did with the light of nature was as follows:
  
For although they knew God, they did not glorify him as God or give him thanks, but they became futile in their thoughts and their senseless thoughts were darkened. Although they claimed to be wise, they became fools and exchanged the glory of the immortal God for an image resembling mortal human beings or birds or four-footed animals or reptiles. (vv. 21-23)

Because of this, God gives them over to their sin, and as a result they further "exchanged the truth of God for a lie and worshiped and served the creation rather than the Creator, who is blessed forever! Amen (vv. 24-25).

Likewise, the idea that Romans 2:14-15 are talking about unregenerated unbelievers who can discover morality on their own, even if true, does not support the idea that this morality is contradictory to the one found in special revelation. Indeed, the passage actually affirms that when Gentiles do these things (it does not say that they actually do them completely), they are doing the things of the Jewish moral law, meaning that they are one and the same, not two different laws, one which can judge the other. 

Second to this, Romans 1 has just established that unbelieving Gentiles do not obey the law, and that Jews also break the law, even though they may have it. This is the entire point of Romans 3 when Paul concludes that both Jews and Gentiles (all of them) are under sin and are in need of redemption. There is not a single one of them (Jew or Gentile) that does what is righteous and good. Hence, Paul is either using a hypothetical in order to make the point in Chapter 2 that one could consider even a Gentile righteous when he does some of the things that are in the law, even though he does not have them, and hence, having the law does not make one righteous (which is the actual point being made), or he is referring to God-fearers in Old Testament times who evidence some of the things in the law in their character. Either way, the point is not to argue that humans can discover a reliable morality through conscience/intuition, but rather that humans sometimes stumble upon it. Whether they do, however, cannot be known unless one has a reliable source of morality to judge whether they have stumbled upon it, as Romans 1 makes clear that they seem to stumble a whole lot more upon immorality and consider it moral instead. As 3:11 states, "There is no one who understands; there is no one who seeks for God."

But what of the regenerated believer? Does he possess a reliable source for his knowledge of truth and morality apart from special revelation? The answer to this must be, No. The reason why it is impossible is due to the dual nature of the believer. He is not regenerated completely, but now has two minds, one of the spirit and one of the flesh. The mind of the flesh may work to convince him that falsehoods and immoral behaviors are true and moral. Hence, even if he has the mind of the spirit as part of his new makeup, it cannot function as a reliable source to confirm to his mind which is which at any given time. This is especially true if his religious culture has convinced him of the truth and good of an untruth or immoral behavior. For example, if love is defined in such a way so as to be all-inclusive, it is doubtful he will exclude certain behaviors that are considered immoral by the Bible, precisely, because he is trying to be loving as God commands. Hence, he is still wholly reliant upon the Scripture to judge the matter as to what love really is and how it should be expressed.

Hence, John argues that every spirit is not to be believed, but rather tried by the apostolic witness that we today now have in Scripture (1 John 4:1-6). Hence, the light of nature through reason and the light of conscience or intuition is not sufficient to function as a reliable source due to the sinful nature of man, whether believers or not.  

The Errors of Errancy: Part IV: The Epistemic Impossibility of Judging Whether the Bible Is Errant or Inerrant without an Inerrant Standard


The ability to judge whether the Bible is inerrant without an inerrant standard that stands outside of the Bible is an impossibility. Yet, this is exactly what both religious and nonreligious errantists alike argue. What is really being assumed here is that the moral reasoning and/or intuition of the individual or culture is the inerrant, and therefore reliable, standard by which all other truths and moralities ought to be judged. This assumption is not often noticed even by those making it. However, this human-centered standard must be assumed in order to judge the Bible as a lesser reliable standard due to its inability to find compatibility with the truth or morality of the errantist. 

The problem, of course, is that one only need compare the contradictory conclusions of individual and communal compasses of when it comes to truth and morality with one another in order to easily refute the idea that humans have such an ability to arrive at the correct truth or morality. 

Enlightenment thinkers argued one could reason to it, but men reason to different moralities. Slave-traders of the Transatlantic slave trade reasoned that their work was a good in the world that helped the progression of the modern world step closer to their utopian vision. Hitler and Stalin saw the necessity of executing those who they viewed as standing in the way of their own utopian vision and the good of mankind. Pol Pot did the same thing. All of them using both reason to do so. Feelings do not fare much better. As Ravi Zacharias has often quipped in referring to the Copleston/Russell debate, where Russel told Copleston that he distinguished between good and evil by feeling, “Mr. Russell, in some cultures they love their neighbor; in other cultures they eat them, both on the basis of feeling. Do you have a preference?”

Truths and morality go together, and they are elusive to the one guessing at them. One must know the nature of reality to conclude anything as true, that there is an objective moral mind from which something gains its inherent goodness or badness, and the clear and reliable communication to human beings from that mind what these truths and principles of morality are. Yet, individuals and communities alike, using both reason and intuition/feelings, have come to contradictory conclusions, and therefore, categorically disqualify themselves as reliable guides to either.
This means that without any reliable guide to know what is true or what is good, what is false and what is evil, it is impossible to judge any document claiming to be the reliable guide of both. Ergo, the Didactic Errantist can make no genuine objection to the claim that the Bible is inerrant. He is incapable of making any claim about any particular morality or truth in the Bible, or any claim generically about the Bible’s inerrancy. 

This is also true when it comes to the method of comparing what he thinks are two contradictory truth or moral claims he thinks the Bible is making. In point of fact, if he is incapable of distinguishing truth from error because he does not know the truth otherwise; and he is incapable of distinguishing good from evil because he does not know otherwise, then he is incapable of judging whether the truths and morality presented are contradictory or facets of the same reality or principles presented in different situations and contexts. For instance, Thom Stark claimed in his book on errancy that the Bible taught two contradictory claims concerning divine justice. On the one hand, the Bible presents that divine justice works itself out by rewarding the righteous and punishing the evil. On the other hand, the Bible presents the idea that God’s justice works itself out according to whatever God decides is in accord with His will, sometimes letting the evil be rewarded, and the righteous to be defrauded. However, in such a situation as this, since there is no way to know what is true apart from a reliable source, and human reasoning and intuition is not that reliable source, as argued above, then it must be assumed that if the Bible is that reliable source, these two ideas complement rather than contradict one another. In fact, we witness that if one does good, he often receives good, and if one does bad, he often receives bad as a general rule of life. If one robs a bank, he most often is caught and goes to prison. If one is nasty toward people, people tend to be nasty toward him. If one is kind to others, he often receives kindness in return. However, we also witness that it is also true that the kind can be met with hatred, and the bank robber can get away and live out a carefree life. The Book of Job is a piece of dispute literature in the Bible, and as a work of dispute literature presents all sides as true from certain perspectives. It presents all of these as true. However, the ultimate reality is that the righteous are rewarded and the wicked punished in the long run, even though the present may or may not reflect that future reality.

In other words, if a source of truth and morality is reliable, it must be assumed that any supposed contradictions are actually complements, supplements, caveats, and a filling out of the truth and morality it presents. In point of fact, nothing in the Bible’s teaching can be absolutely proven to be contradictory. It remains, therefore, a belief of Errantists who are simply guessing that they are contradictory, but have no ability to assess whether they truly are since that would assume a full and complete knowledge of all truth and morality (i.e., a complete and full knowledge of the nature of reality) that must be gained from an alternatively reliable source that they do not possess.

The Errantist is left either to admit that the Bible cannot have didactic errors in it if reliable, and therefore, its variations must complement one another in some way, or that he must remain agnostic as to whether the Bible is inerrant because he has no way of assessing its truth and moral claims, whether in variation or not. Either way, he proves the position of didactic errancy to be a mere belief, a guess, in what the Bible apart from any of its truth and moral claims, not because of them. In other words, he cannot assess the Bible’s claims of truth and morality, and so must decide apart from what it says, and apart from what he knows, that it is not a reliable source of reality, and that the only reason for concluding such is because it has fallen out of favor with the zeitgeist obtained through the source of human reasoning and intuition that has proven time and again with examples that are legion to be an unreliable and erroneous source of truth and morality when left without any other inerrant guide to confirm its many speculations.

Friday, February 7, 2020

Trust the Experts?

One of the most interesting scenes in the Matrix is when one character decides that he likes the bliss of believing that the Matrix is reality, as true reality did not bring him the peace of mind that he wanted. He becomes a traitor to all reality in the process, the Judas of the story, who turns on those who have been unplugged.

I read a post the other day that was attempting to argue that the consensus of scholarship on any given issue is due to expertise and not some liberal worldview and whatnot. Let me just say how utterly ridiculous this claim is. This is pure Enlightenment brainwashing at work telling us all that scholars who are immersed in the presuppositions of the Enlightenment, and are never taught to be critical of the methodologies of inquiry that stem from it, are not brainwashed but just concluding from their studies and expertise what's what.

Now, let me say, I don't appreciate laymen contradicting me from their ignorance, and that is half of the thrust of the article with which I actually agree. Overconfident laymen usually replace study with unfounded confidence in their own extremely limited education and unsharpened reasoning skills, which only serve to further entrench them in whatever they want to believe. Yes, I am an elitist in terms of believing that only trained pilots should fly the airplane. I am an "anti-Enlightenment, anti-everybody gets to be included, and anti-everyone should have their opinion heard" sort of guy. That doesn't mean there aren't brilliant laymen who study even harder than those who have a formal education (Nick Norelli in the field of Trinitarian studies comes to mind), but I wouldn't consider them laymen, so my definitions are not "people who went to school versus people who didn't." I know plenty of people who jumped through their hoops and got degrees and are clearly incompetent in their fields, even though they write book after book and hold prestigious positions at various schools. The Wizard gave them a diploma, they write books, and so now they're somehow qualified even though their knowledge and ability to assess it is severely limited. So this is not an all-or-nothing statement.

However, the idea that one should accept the scholarly consensus, let's say on something like the origins of Israel, simply because it stems from their expertise is absolute nonsense. This is the type of rhetoric one expects from someone who has drunk all the Matrix Kool-Aid, and just wants to sit in peace in his pod as the machines tell him he's eating a steak. It is historically and philosophically ignorant of the fact that modern scholarship has been in a polemic against the Bible and orthodox Christianity since the dawn of the Enlightenment, precisely, because it needs to replace the Bible with a more inclusive spirituality rooted in the individual self or community. The Bible was and always will be in the way, and therefore, even when new information comes about, that new information has been/is used to undermine the orthodox teaching of the Bible in some way (even though it did/does not usually do so).

Saying that these scholars are just doing scholarship is philosophically naive. And appealing to their intentions, or whether or not they know they are merely arguing in circles as apologists for their cult, absolutely muddies the issue. This has nothing to do with whether or not they know what they are doing. We are in the cult of the Enlightenment. I would expect almost no one to know, or they would become aware of their brainwashing.

It's like trying to argue to someone who lives among the Mormons that all of those scholars at BYU aren't concluding what they do because they're either intentionally or unintentionally committed philosophically to the truths of Mormonism and the presuppositions at the foundations of their methodologies of inquiry. It's just because they're educated and experts in their fields.

And all of those great German scholars who had a consensus among them that Jews weren't really humans weren't racists. They were just experts in their fields.

What is truly scary is that anyone would be so blinded by his philosophical cult that he thinks it is just the reality that these scholars discover. That means that everyone else is trading in fantasy, and they need to be silenced because reality should be honored over fantasy. And that is exactly why there is a liberal/Enlightenment-oriented worldview that dictates the consensus among scholars in universities. Because you have to sign on to the Enlightenment project to be accepted into one, and certainly, to teach in one. The consensus is due to their having the same worldview, not to their expertise. That's why many uneducated people hold those same views without having set one foot in an academic institution. It isn't because they're educated. It's because they have the same worldview. If it were due to academic training, these people, who are just as arrogant, wouldn't hold the view.

That doesn't leave us with a solution that includes uneducated laymen espousing whatever theory they wish regardless of its probability of being true given the research. It leaves us with the need to be epistemologically wary of our culture's philosophical and theological commitments so that we become self-aware of our own methodologies of inquiry from which we draw conclusions and make claims of any sort.

And that was probably the biggest irony of the post. The idea that going to school makes you more self-aware. I find this a rather laughable idea, having been to numerous schools, both secular and Christian alike. The goal of any cult is conformity, not of various ideas you may hold on the surface (you're allowed to espouse all sorts of views, just not orthodox ones in your papers), but to presuppositions that will make the student more acceptable to the modern scholarly guild. A student with epistemic commitments that are linked to the Bible's absolute reliability in what it teaches, for instance, will be a priori rejected in favor of students who have epistemic commitments to the absolute reliability of the self and academic community. One must presuppose all sorts of things in both of these, primarily to Augustinianism or Pelagianism, that cannot be judged by the amount of one's education, but solely by one's faith commitment. Yet, the latter are accepted in droves and the former rejected in the same numbers. That the cult has a consensus as to what is true, therefore, is of no weight to those of us who have been deprogrammed. It is only weighty to some who are still plugged in to the Matrix and want to believe that what they're eating really is a steak.

The Neighbor and the Good Samaritan

This article says it well. I would argue that Matt 5 and Gal 6:10 are about the covenant community, but other than that he did a good job explaining the issue. I would just add that the blindness of those commenting stems not from peer pressure or political correctness but an unquestioned assumption of Enlightenment ethics that have formed a tradition around these verses so that the contexts are never considered. http://www.affinity.org.uk/foundations-issues/issue-61-article-2---so-who-is-my-neighbour

Thursday, February 6, 2020

Biblical Eschatology and the Millennium: Part V: Conclusion


The generic eschatology of the Bible seems to be that of the already-not yet scheme in terms of the spiritual rule of Christ has now come, but the physical rule is still future. 

There are verses that indicate that a specific eschatology is not, nor will be, communicated to the apostles. KEY VERSES: Mark 13:32-33 // Matt 24:36, 42; Acts 1:6-7.

Hence, they are left to put the generic eschatology into possible future scenarios as to how the end might occur that exist within Second Temple Judaism.

This is displayed in Revelation by itself when it uses multiple scenarios of the end throughout the book, as argued before. If John knew the specifics concerning the time-frames and events that would occur exactly at the end then why did he not only use multiple scenarios in the book that conflict, but scenarios that conflict with the rest of the New Testament?

Since the specifics are not given, the New Testament authors are free to place the generic eschatology given to them into the language and eschatological concepts of the culture into which it is speaking. This means that how the end will come about apart from all of the generally consistent elements given throughout the New Testament, is not revealed to them. Hence, any of the above eschatologies could be true, and others as well. The specifics in New Testament eschatology include that of hope of a completed and renewed creation, the judgment of the wicked, the bodily salvation of the righteous, the coming of Christ and His eternal rule upon the earth. The spiritual fulfillment of these things were obtained in Christ’s Person and work on the earth, as well as His continual work as a Mediator and Reigning King in Heaven. The physical fulfillment is the “not-yet” that is still future (John 5:24–29; Rom 6–8; Eph 1:3–2:6; 1 Pet 1:3–5).

Hence, biblical eschatology is not a crystal ball into the future. It is more generic with a purpose of exhorting Christians to live in light of the new world that will be ruled by Christ that has come and is still coming. Our fascination with how things take place, rather than accepting that a limited amount of information is given to us for the purpose of living holy lives, may display a desire to know secret knowledge more than a desire to know anything we really need to know for that purpose. 

This should give us more humility toward one another in seeing that others hold their views because they accept certain verses as controlling and are attempting to harmonize the other verses with them in an effort to support their paradigm, which is exactly what everyone else is doing as well. Those who are confused about what the Bible teaches concerning eschatology have likely stumbled upon what I have concluded here without knowing it. In any case, I believe Deuteronomy 29:29 applies here.

The secret things belong to the Lord our God, but those that are revealed belong to us and our children forever, so that we might obey all the words of this teaching.




Biblical Eschatology and the Millennium, Part IV: Postmillennialism


Postmillennialism is the view that Christ slowly takes hold of the world, its people and political systems, through the gospel so that when He returns, it will be to a Christianized world. Hence, Christ returns after the millennial kingdom has run its course. This view became popular in the Enlightenment due to a newfound positivism toward human moral development and society. It was the majority view in America before Dispensational Premillennialism took hold of the populace in the twentieth century.

Arguments For:
 
1.      Daniel 2 talks about the rock cut out of the mountain taking over the other kingdoms as it grows larger and larger, eventually taking over everything.

2.      Matt 13:31–32 // Mark 4:30–32 talks about a mustard seed starting small and then growing into a giant tree. The giant tree that shades the whole earth in Daniel is sometimes combined with this idea to argue that this is the kingdom of God taking over the world.


3.      Isaiah 66 talks about a new heavens and new earth, and a promise of a kingdom in which people will live a really long time, there is peace and harmony among men and nature, but they still die and unbelievers still exist to serve believers. So these types of prophecies must refer to a stage in the earth that has been affected by the life-giving gospel kingdom, but is not the eternal state itself, where all of the enemies of Christ, death being the last one, are wiped away from the earth.

Arguments Against:
 
1.      2 Thessalonians 1:6–10 and 2:1–12  indicate that Paul is looking for relief from his persecution (both Jews and Gentiles) and the persecution of the Thessalonians (their own countrymen [1 Thes 2:14], i.e., Gentiles in Thessalonica) when Christ returns and destroys their persecutors, including the man of lawlessness, who is yet to be revealed (i.e., not a false teacher Paul knows of yet) exalts himself above every god, performs signs and wonders, and is destroyed by Christ at His coming. There is no indication that Paul is looking for a distant millennial kingdom that gradually changes the world and will bring Christians relief from persecution, or that any of this happens in the first century. The preterist theories often presented to answer this claim tend to disregard the entirety of what is said in these passages, and attempt to assign these statements to first century referents that do not fulfill all of what is said. The passages are as follows.

6 God is just: He will pay back trouble to those who trouble you 7 and give relief to you who are troubled, and to us as well. This will happen when the Lord Jesus is revealed from heaven in blazing fire with his powerful angels. 8 He will punish those who do not know God and do not obey the gospel of our Lord Jesus. 9 They will be punished with everlasting destruction and shut out from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his might 10 on the day he comes to be glorified in his holy people and to be marveled at among all those who have believed. This includes you, because you believed our testimony to you. (1:6–10)

Concerning the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our being gathered to him, we ask you, brothers and sisters, 2 not to become easily unsettled or alarmed by the teaching allegedly from us—whether by a prophecy or by word of mouth or by letter—asserting that the day of the Lord has already come. 3 Don’t let anyone deceive you in any way, for that day will not come until the apostasy occurs and the man of lawlessness is revealed, the man doomed to destruction. 4 He will oppose and will exalt himself over everything that is called God or is worshiped, so that he sets himself up in God’s temple, proclaiming himself to be God. 5 Don’t you remember that when I was with you I used to tell you these things? 6 And now you know what is holding him back, so that he may be revealed at the proper time. 7 For the secret power of lawlessness is already at work; but the one who now holds it back will continue to do so till he is taken out of the way. 8 And then the lawless one will be revealed, whom the Lord Jesus will overthrow with the breath of his mouth and destroy by the splendor of his coming. 9 The coming of the lawless one will be in accordance with how Satan works. He will use all sorts of displays of power through signs and wonders that serve the lie, 10 and all the ways that wickedness deceives those who are perishing. They perish because they refused to love the truth and so be saved. 11 For this reason God sends them a powerful delusion so that they will believe the lie 12 and so that all will be condemned who have not believed the truth but have delighted in wickedness. (2:1–12)

2.      Those who enter the millennial kingdom in Revelation 20:4 are not Christians who are regenerated but physically resurrected Christians who have been martyred for their faithfulness to Christ. The text states:
4 I saw thrones on which were seated those who had been given authority to judge. And I saw the souls of those who had been beheaded because of their testimony about Jesus and because of the word of God. They had not worshiped the beast or its image and had not received its mark on their foreheads or their hands. They came to life and reigned with Christ a thousand years.
This cannot be regeneration because these Christians had already become Christians, lived faithfully for Christ, had been executed because of it, and are souls that then come to life to reign with Christ for a thousand years. The physical resurrection of Christians (assuming the martyrs represent all Christians who live for Christ), therefore, is at the beginning of the millennium, not the end.
Furthermore, “came to life” in this passage does not refer to regeneration because the rest of the dead do not “come to life” until the thousand years are up (v. 5), and only those who partake in the first resurrection are considered blessed. These seem to be the dead of vv. 11–15 who are judged and damned. 

3.      Daniel 2 does not teach that the kingdom of God slowly grows and eventually takes over the kingdoms of the world. It actually teaches that the kingdom of God wipes out all of the other kingdoms so that there are none left, and then grows immediately to take over the world. Daniel 2:31–35, 44–45 are as follows.

31 “You saw, O king, and behold, a great image. This image, mighty and of exceeding brightness, stood before you, and its appearance was frightening. 32 The head of this image was of fine gold, its chest and arms of silver, its middle and thighs of bronze, 33 its legs of iron, its feet partly of iron and partly of clay. 34 As you looked, a stone was cut out by no human hand, and it struck the image on its feet of iron and clay, and broke them in pieces. 35 Then the iron, the clay, the bronze, the silver, and the gold, all together were broken in pieces, and became like the chaff of the summer threshing floors; and the wind carried them away, so that not a trace of them could be found. But the stone that struck the image became a great mountain and filled the whole earth . . . 44 And in the days of those kings the God of heaven will set up a kingdom that shall never be destroyed, nor shall there be any other kingdom left to another people. It shall break in pieces all these kingdoms and bring them to an end, and it shall stand forever, 45 just as you saw that a stone was cut from a mountain by no human hand, and that it broke in pieces the iron, the bronze, the clay, the silver, and the gold. A great God has made known to the king what shall be after this.

Notice that the rock destroys all of the kingdoms so that there is no other kingdom left for another people. They are destroyed at the violent and sudden coming of the rock, not its growth. It’s growing occurs after it strikes the statue and destroys all of the kingdoms that make it up. Daniel is not working off an already-not yet view, where the kingdom comes spiritually first and then physically. He is referring to the physical coming of the kingdom, the final coming, when all other kingdoms are wiped away. So this is not a gradual growing of the kingdom side-by-side with other kingdoms until they are wiped away, but a violent upheaval of these, and then the kingdom grows and fills the whole earth.

4.      I will say again what I have said before in dealing with Premillennial uses of prophecy in the Old Testament. Isaiah 66 and other prophecies that relate a promise of a “this age” physical kingdom that has some microcosmic similarities to the eternal state, even using the language of the eternal state (“new heavens and new earth” for example) are contingent promises given to Judah/Israel concerning what God will do for them when He brings them back into the land from deportation and exile. The contingency, like all prophecy, is based on their faithfulness. If they are faithful when they get back in the land, they will receive this earthly picture of eternity in the here and now. They, however, are not faithful when they get back in the land and so these promises of a this-worldly physical kingdom are never realized. They could have been the priests God made them to be and pictured the eternal state in harmony with God, but decided to reengage in idolatry and sexual immorality when they got back in the land by marrying daughters of foreign gods, disregarding the ministry of God, the poor, etc. The use of prophesy by those seeking to establish some millennial view is mistaken in its methodology. As God promises judgment to Nineveh without any sign of offering them an alternative if they repent, those promises are not carried out in Jonah’s story because all prophecy, whether explicitly stating it or not, is contingent upon the repentance or lack thereof of its recipients. Hence, these passages only present what could have been had Israel been faithful to its physically-beneficial Mosaic covenant. They were not. Hence, the New Testament looks toward the physically-beneficial eternity promised to it while enjoying the fruit of its spiritual benefits and promises now. There are no physical promises of a this-worldly/already nature repeated in the New Testament. The already is spiritual and the not-yet is physical (e.g., resurrection of the spirit in regeneration already, but resurrection of the physical body not yet). Hence, none of these Old Testament prophecies should be used to secure a particular view of the millennium. What they depict, even according to some of their own language, is the eternal state of the new heavens and new earth promised to Christians (Rom 8; Rev 20–21).

5.      This last objection to Postmillennialism I will mention here will be the most difficult to communicate, as it takes a lot of background information to undo the traditional reading of this text, but the mustard seed growing into a large tree: (1) has nothing to do with Daniel’s tree, and (2) is talking about the spiritual growth of the kingdom within a true believer, not the expansion of the kingdom upon the earth. 

First, Daniel 4:20–22 makes it clear that the tree that overshadows the whole earth in that context is Nebuchadnezzar.

Second, although the passages in Mark and Luke give a little context to bring out its meaning, Matthew 13 gives the most context for the reader to understand what Christ is talking about. The parables in Matthew 13 all have to do with the same thing. This is why only a couple are interpreted. The interpretation is meant to provide a key by which one can interpret the others that are given no explicit interpretation otherwise. 

The first parable given in vv. 3–23 deals with the fruit of a genuine believer versus false believers within the believing community (something very much connected to Matthew’s message, as well as Mark’s concern with true discipleship in following Jesus in general and Luke’s concern that true disciples take care of the poor and marginalized within the church). In other words, these things give some characteristics of true and false believers/disciples within the covenant community. The concern is not evangelism in these Gospels, but rather a correction of antinomian tendencies popping up in the church.

The Parable of the Weeds to follow, surrounds the two analogies of the mustard seed and the leaven in flour. First the parable, then the two analogies, then the interpretation of the parable, which signifies to the reader that he is to interpret these analogies in light of the parable that surrounds them, and frankly, all of the parables in the section, which is signified not only by subject matter but the parallel framework of the previous parable to this one. 

That this parable is about the nature of true and false believers within the kingdom is evidenced by the fact that “the Son of Man will send his angels, and they will gather out of his kingdom all causes of sin and all lawless ones,  and throw them into the fiery furnace” (vv. 41-42a). This connects to those calling Christ, “Lord, Lord” in Chapter 7, who think themselves to be Christ’s servants, but practice “lawlessness.” 

The remaining analogies/parables all present characteristics of true and false believers/disciples within the church. True believers give up all they have to have God rule over them, as demonstrated by the parables of the treasure in a field and the pearl of great price. Likewise, the final parable in the sequence presents the kingdom as a fish net (v. 47) that holds both evil and righteous men that must be gathered from the net, not the world in general. 

Back to the analogies within the Parable of the Weeds pericope. The kingdom of God is like a mustard seed and leaven that grows to fill up the place where it is planted. What is helpful is to understand that if these are all about what characterize true believers or false believers (these short parables/analogies exist only to characterize the true believer), then these are talking about a characteristic of true believers, not how the kingdom of God grows in the world, which is no commentary on the nature of those who are the kingdom of God.

And that is the important point. The kingdom of God is the people, and the kingdom is planted within them and grows within them. In fact, “kingdom” often confuses us. We think of something external. However, in the already-not yet scheme that exists in the NT, the kingdom is the dominion of God and His Christ over His people. “God’s rule” might be a better translation. God’s rule begins with seeds that are planted within individuals, or are the individuals themselves. The Son plants the seeds, which are characterized by their origin in God or their fruit. Matthew is all about the true and false believer that is known by his fruit. He wants to say that the true believer bears much fruit because he is planted by God, and even though the seed begins as a small dominion given to God within a true disciples life, God eventually grows from that seed a faith and practice that takes over the entire person, so that God reigns over every aspect of his life (in contrast to Pharisaical righteousness that only technically obeys superficially). As a result, the true disciple gives all else up to follow Christ, and becomes righteous in his deeds. This is the already invisible kingdom within in contrast to the already invisible kingdom seen in the professing church. The not-yet visible kingdom in the age to come can only be accessed by those who are of the former and the latter, and not by the latter.
Hence, the mustard seed is what is planted in a believer and grows within him to produce a all-encompassing righteousness that distinguishes him from the false believer. It has nothing to do with evangelism or the takeover of the physical world by the Christian church.

The biblical evidence for Postmillenialism, therefore, is the weakest, as it not only contradicts other passages in the New Testament, but it takes many of its supporting Scripture out of context, and they do not end up being solid prooftexts for it at all. However, as I have argued, that does not exclude it from being a possibility concerning how Christ might bring about His eternal kingdom upon the earth, since the Bible does not give us a definite framework.