Monday, September 9, 2019

The Biblical Definition of the Image of God, Part IV

Finally, I wanted to look at 1 Corinthians 11, and other New Testament passages that indicate that the image is only to be understood as a role man takes on, and cannot be taken also as ontological.

In 1 Corinthians 11:1-16, Paul, as I've argued in other posts, is arguing that gender roles have not been abolished by the new covenant, and therefore, the physical displays of gender distinctions, specifically hair length in the context, should still be observed. It is essentially arguing that women should look like women and men should look like men, and I would argue that this should be done to the most it is possible in one's culture to do so (but that's for another day).

In the process of making his argument, Paul ends up implying that the woman is not the image of God herself. He states:

"A man ought not to have anything hanging down from his head, since he is the image and glory of God; but woman is the glory of man."

The argument here implies that the man should not have long hair because he is the image of God. However, if the woman is also the image of God then this argument makes no sense. If she is the image of God then she shouldn't have long hair either. 

Instead, he says that the woman, in contrast to being the image of God, is actually the glory of man who is the image of God. In other words, she is not the image, but does, in fact, participate in it by being the shine/glory of the image.

To quickly refer back to the ancient view of images, it is important to note that an image does not fulfill its role if defiled/unclean. An image that loses its glory does not function as the image and must be discarded. This is how Genesis sees the woman as well. She is man's helper by allowing him to fulfill the creation mandate given to him. She is thus his glory that allows him to function as the image. Hence, she is part of the image as the shine and glory of that image, but is not the image herself.

This is significant to our debate, as it indicates that the ontological view, that sees the image as various intrinsic characteristics given to humanity in general, such as intellect, affection, spirituality, etc. is false.

If the woman is not the image, and the image is parallel to what is human, then Paul would be saying that the woman is not human.

Now, one could simply retort concerning all of these biblical texts that the biblical text only addresses the righteous aspect of the image as a role in relationship with God, but there is still a part of the image they do not address, and this is the problem.

To say the Bible does not address an aspect of the image being assigned to it by theologians is to admit that the idea is not gained from the Bible. It is a philosophical idea. In fact, the reason why Berkhof cannot muster up verses that support his definition of the image as consisting of intellect, affections, moral will, etc. is because there aren't any. 

The consistent image of God in Scripture is portrayed as only belonging to the righteous who enter into covenant with God and engage in creational activity (good, justice/righteousness/truth). Hence, the New Testament describes the image as a part of redeemed humanity's new nature (Col 3:10; Eph 4:24; Rom 8:29). Christ is the image of God, and hence, only those in Christ are the image. It is a role one takes on. It is a role in which women can participate as the glory of the image, but it is not to be defined as the ontological nature of a human being, regardless of whether he is a Christian or non-Christian.

The Biblical Definition of the Image of God, Part III

Another text quoted by Berkhof and others is James 3:9. Traditionally, this is read as a generic statement referring to all mankind. The verse states as follows.

"With the tongue we praise our Lord and Father, and with it we curse human beings, who have been made in God’s likeness."

The question becomes here who is James talking about as those who are being cursed by "we." The "we" is clearly to be understood as Christians, as they are those who praise the Lord and the Father. So he is not talking generically about human beings who bless and curse, but Christians who do so.

The important question, then, is whether those with whom James is primarily concerned are fellow Christians as God's images or if the images to whom he refers are all mankind in general. The context indicates that he is talking about fellow Christians who are spoken of poorly or slandered by those who should not be teachers in the church and cannot control their tongues (3:1-8). These people who do not have a mature character slander others out of selfish ambition in a way to lift themselves up over other teachers in the church (vv. 10-18 and 4:1-12). The concern is dissension in the church due to teachers biting and devouring one another as they contend for positions in the church (4:1-12). This contending for high positions was already condemned in Chapter 2. He makes it clear that these are believers fighting other believers in 4:11-12.

"Brothers, do not slander one another. Anyone who speaks against a brother or condemns them speaks against the law and judges it. When you judge the law, you are not keeping it, but sitting in judgment on it. There is only one Lawgiver and Judge, the one who is able to save and destroy. But you—who are you to judge your neighbor?"

The context, again, indicates that this is talking about believers. Those who are being condemned and cursed are fellow believers. They are being cursed by those who have a selfish ambition to lift themselves up in the community by becoming teachers, likely something akin to self-proclaimed internet theologians on facebook or whatnot, who primarily use name-calling and condemnation as their debate tactic to win an argument. 

In no way, therefore, does James 3:9 support the idea that all of mankind, wicked or otherwise, is the image of God. 
 

The Biblical Definition of the Image of God, Part II

Berkhof writes, "Notice that man even after the fall, irrespective of his spiritual condition, is still represented as the image of God, Gen. 9;6; I Cor. 11:7; Jas. 3:9. The crime of murder owes its enormity to the fact that it is an attack on the image of God. In view of these passages of Scripture it is unwarranted to say that man has completely lost the image of God."

It is odd that he quotes 1 Corinthians 11:7, as this passage, I will argue, negates this idea rather than supports it; but the other two are often cited as supporting the idea that the image is ontological, and therefore, rebellious mankind still has it. 

In this post, I want to deal specifically with Genesis 9:6.

The passage reads as follows.

ויברך אלהים את נח ואת בניו ויאמר להם פרו ורבו ומלאו את הארץ
 ומוראכם וחתכם יהיה על כל חית הארץ ועל כל עוף השמים בכל אשר תרמשׁ האדמה ובכל דגי הים בידכם נתנו
 כל רמשׁ אשר הוא חי לכם יהיה לאכלה כירק עשׁב נתתי לכם את כל
 אך בשׁר בנפשו דמו לא תאכלו
 ואך את דמכם לנפשתיכם אדרש מיד כל חיה אדרשנו ומיד האדם מיד איש אחיו אדרש את נפש האדם
 שפך דם האדם באדם דמו ישפך כי בצלם אלהים עשׁה את האדם
 ואתם פרו ורבו שרצו בארץ ורבו בה ס

And God blessed Noah and his sons and said to them, 
"Be fruitful and multiply and fill up the earth. Every land animal and every bird of the sky will be terrified of you. Everything that creeps on the ground and all the fish of the sea are under your authority.  

You are to eat any moving thing that lives. As I gave you the green plants, I now give you everything. 
 
“But you must not eat meat with its life (that is, its blood) in it.
  
And I will surely exact punishment for your blood, your life, from every living creature I will exact punishment. From the hand of mankind, from each man, his brother, I will exact punishment for the life of the man. 
“Whoever sheds the blood of the man,
by man his blood is to be shed;
for in God’s image
God has made man.
“So you are to be fruitful and multiply; increase abundantly on the earth and multiply on it.”

Notice first that there is an inclusio created by the creation mandate in order to put all that is said in between in the context of the role of the image.

Now, this text is often used to support the idea that since man is the image of God, something ontological and intrinsic to human nature, he ought not be killed. Hence, the man who kills a man should be killed.

You may pick up the irony in that statement already, as if there is something intrinsic to man's nature that makes it wrong for him to be killed, then killing a man, even for killing another man, would also be inherently wrong. If the reason why a man should not be killed is because he is the image, ontologically speaking, then the one who kills is also the image and should not be killed. 

Beside the contradiction, however, this traditional reading ignores three contexts that would clarify what is going on.

The first is the immediate context. In each of the things commanded (i.e., be fruitful, eat meat, don't eat meat with blood, kill the murderer, be fruitful), it is the image doing the what is commanded. In other words, the image is the subject, not the object. Hence, the reason given, that man is made to be God's image, in 9:6 follows the executing of murderers. It does so because the role of the image is to thwart chaos. It does this by being fruitful and multiplying, expanding its food sources to survive, refraining from eating meat with blood that would likely diminish it, and by ridding the earth of chaotic agents that reduce humanity upon the earth. In other words, the text is  not necessarily saying that all mankind are God's image. Instead, it is saying that because man is made to be God's image, he must take upon himself the role of the creation mandate in new and expanded ways to create and preserve covenant human life. Hence, he must execute murderers to preserve humanity, expand his food sources, etc., not just be procreative in his personal sexual activity.

This means that the text is not saying it is wrong to kill a man because he is the image of God, but that murder is wrong and the image of God needs to execute those who do it.

This is the distinction between the murderer and the image of God who executes him. One is unauthorized and one is authorized by God to kill a human being. One steals mankind from God and works against Him, and the other preserves mankind and works with His creative purposes. This means that what is wrong with killing a human being in the act of murder is that it is not authorized by God who is the sovereign King and owner of all things. This is why God can command the Israelites not to murder and then turn around and command them to kill those who break the law or engage them in war.

Hence, if we are to follow the pattern in the immediate context in terms of its structure, the image is the one doing the activity that is procreative. It is not said whether the victim is the image of God at all, only that he is a man.

The larger literary context of the book also indicates this. As argued before, the image of God is a role that is only assigned to the woman's seed who join God in overcoming chaos and the serpent who wishes to spread it. Both Genesis 1 and 5 indicate that the designation of image belongs only to those who do the procreative work of the creation mandate in covenant relationship with God. It never describes those who do not join God in this. Even in this text, it is the activity of the creation mandate that defines all of it.

Finally, the larger biblical context indicates that the image is only those who are in Christ. He is the image of the invisible God, and the Bible says that the image is something that must be created in us through Him (Heb 1:3; 2 Cor 4:4; Col 1:15; 3:10; Eph 4:24; Rom 8:29).
That means that the larger biblical context would have us believe that Christ alone is the image of God and we are not until we have been united to Him and begin to be conformed to His image. We are a new creation in Him. The old man is never described as God's image. Furthermore, I would argue that 1 Corinthians 11:7 implies the image to be a role, and not something ontological--otherwise, the text implies that the woman is not God's image, contradicting Genesis 1:26-27 (we'll discuss this more in Part IV).

That means the immediate context, the larger literary context of the book, and the larger canonical context all push in favor of reading the image of God as a role one takes upon himself in the activity of the creation mandate, and nothing is said here that would indicate that all mankind is the image.


The Biblical Definition of the Image of God, Part I

It's always interesting to engage modern Presbyterians on the question of the image. As many know, there are two kinds of Presbyterians, those who think the WCF is the 67th book of the Bible and those who are always reforming. This post is for the latter.

This series will likely be in 4 parts. First, I'll look at the biblical definition of the image, second, I'll look at whether Genesis 9 teaches that all mankind is the image of God, and third, I'll look at whether James teaches that all mankind is the image, and finally, I'll look at the implications of what Paul says in 1 Corinthians 11 and other passages for the ontological view.

What always emerges in a debate like this are the extrabiblical presuppositions that are being imposed upon words in the Bible. For instance, Berkhof concludes that the image is both the righteousness of man and his ontological constitution.

"But the image of God is not to be restricted to the original knowledge, righteousness, and holiness which was lost by sin, but also includes elements which belong to the natural constitution of man. They are elements which belong to man as man, such as intellectual power, natural affections, and moral freedom. As created in the image of God man has a rational and moral nature, which he did not lose by sin and which he could not lose without ceasing to be man. This part of the image of God has indeed been vitiated by sin, but still remains in man even after his fall in sin"

Now, Berkhof gives scriptural support for the idea that the image if bound up in the righteous obedience of man toward God, but none in support of the ontological definition. Instead, the argument, as it is usually given by those who hold an ontological view, is that men outside the covenant with God are still called the image after the fall.

Before we get to that idea in Part II, let's got back to Genesis 1, where the term originates, in order to get our definition from there. This is important because all other uses in the Bible are references back to this one.

Many scholars now note that the image of God is not an ontological description of man, but a role that God assigns to him at creation. As the bodies of heaven are given a role to provide light for man and give him signs and seasons, as fruit is given a role to feed mankind, etc., man is given a role that is pro-creative toward God's purposes of reversing the chaotic state of a humanless world and filling it up with created/ordered human beings. What this means is that the image is a role assigned to man, not man himself.

This is further understood by what is happening in the narrative. The cosmos is being depicted as a cosmic temple that represents God's sovereignty over all things. A temple is the domain of the deity. He rules over that area. But a temple is a house that surrounds what actually represents the deity, an image.

The image is a physical statue, object that represents the presence and sovereignty of the deity over that domain.

So this means that Genesis 1 gives us two ideas: (1) Man is the representative of God that displays His dominion over the physical cosmos, and (2) this representation is through his joining with God to take upon a creative role in the world in undoing chaos through pro-creative activity. In other words, he is united to God in His work to undo the chaos of a humanless world and fill it up with human beings who will do the same.

An image that no longer functions as it should (by being defiled or cracked in some way) no longer represents the deity in the ancient Near East, but must be either melted down and remade into a new image (if made with precious metals) or buried and discarded. The spirit of the deity has left it and it is no longer to be considered his or her image.

This same pattern is followed by the Genesis narrative in that only those who function as the image in being pro-creative are referred to using the image language (Seth's line in Genesis 5 contrasted with Cain's in Genesis 4).

We'll deal with Genesis 9 in Part II, but for now, I would simply say that it too evidences that the image is a role that some people take on and others do not. There is no evidence anywhere in Genesis that the image is ontological. It is a symbolic way of describing how man functions in relationship with God, the role he takes on when he adopts the good work of God in reversing chaos through creational activity, i.e., the creation and preservation of covenant human life.

What this means is that angels are not the image, Satan is not the image, Balaam's donkey is not the image, etc. simply because they have a higher consciousness, moral reasoning ability, or natural affections (don't all animals have natural affections?). Intellectual power and moral reasoning is given to angels, but they are not physical representatives in the physical cosmos. The same is given to Balaam's donkey, but neither he nor angels can make physical covenant human beings, and therefore, they cannot be the image. But unbelievers don't make covenant human beings either. Unbelievers are not agents of the reveral of chaos, therefore, but agents of chaos itself. Hence, unbelievers cannot be the image either.

This is why the image is restored in Christ. Christ is the true image of God and all those federally connected to Him, whether in the OT or NT, become the image once again. They become life-bearers rather than murderers as Paul describes the unregenerate man in Romans 3.


Saturday, September 7, 2019

John the Baptist's Rebuke of Herod and Its Implications for the Divorce and Remarriage Debate

One of the passages pertinent to the marriage and divorce debate is that describing Herod's marriage to Herodias.

In Luke 3:19, he states, "But when John rebuked Herod the tetrarch because of Herodias, his brother’s wife, and because of all the evil deeds that he had done . . ."

The variation in Mark 6:17-18 states more fully:

For Herod himself had sent men, arrested John, and bound him in prison on account of Herodias, his brother Philip’s wife, because Herod had married her. For John had repeatedly told Herod, “It is not lawful for you to have your brother’s wife.”

Again, in Matthew 14:3-4:

For Herod had arrested John, bound him, and put him in prison on account of Herodias, his brother Philip’s wife, 4 because John had repeatedly told him, “It is not lawful for you to have her.”

Two observations become important here: (1) Herod is married to Herodias, and (2) Every Gospel writer and John the Baptist himself calls her "his brother's wife" or "his brother Philip's wife."

This becomes important because she is still considered by John and the Gospel writers to be Philip's wife even though she is married to Herod now.

The reason why this is significant is that if adultery breaks the marriage union, then she should no longer be Philip's wife. Likewise, if abandonment breaks the marital union, she should no longer be Philip's wife. 

Herodias has divorced Philip (abandonment) and has sexually joined herself to another in marriage, consummating a marriage with Herod (adultery). Yet, neither one of these has caused the Gospel writers or John to think that she is no longer in a marital union with Philip. 

The only reason I can think of for this is that neither adultery nor abandonment break the union, and therefore, she is still in a marital union with Philip. 

But wait. There's more.

Because by calling her Philip's wife, and arguing that it is unlawful for him to have her, we know that they are referring to the incest laws. But these laws only function on the idea that someone like Herodias is only one with Philip in the marriage union so that if while she is one with Philip she is joined with his brother, she and Herod are committing incest. Hence, it is unlawful. There is no law against divorce and remarriage in the law before Jesus, so it is not referring to that. This means she must still be bound to Philip, as Philip's wife (as they all call her) in order to be commiting incest which is unlawful. 

Hence, neither adultery nor abandonment (which is what divorce is) breaks the marital union, and the one who is joined to another is committing adultery (and in this case, incest) with whomever else he or she is married. 

Saturday, August 17, 2019

Augustine on Love

"We find people made fierce by love; and by wickedness made seductively gentle. A father spanks a boy, while a kidnapper caresses him. Offered a choice between spankings and caresses, who would not choose the caresses and avoid the spankings? But when you consider the people who give them you realize that it is love that spanks, wickedness that caresses. This is what I insist upon: human actions can only be understood by their root in love. All kinds of actions might appear good without proceeding from the root of love. Remember, thorns also have flowers: some actions seem truly savage, but are done for the sake of discipline motivated by love. Once and for all, I give you this one short command: love, and do what you will. If you hold your peace, hold your peace out of love. If you cry out, cry out in love. If you correct someone, correct them out of love. If you spare them, spare them out of love. Let the root of love be in you: nothing can spring from it but good. …" 

------Augustine

Saturday, August 3, 2019

Pelagianism and the Placebo of Liberal Solutions to the Problem of Evil

It is interesting to see who theological presuppositions come into play even in a political world that often pretends to be void of religious mandates. I personally think that there is more secularism in play in conservative politics than in liberal politics. Liberalism is basically a religious cult with its own advancement of theological and ethical ideas that are pushed on others like a new Spanish Inquisition.

One of these theological ideas, however, is present, not explicitly, but implicitly presupposed in liberal solutions to problems concerning crime, and that is Pelagian anthropology.

In Pelagian thought, humans are basically a blank slate when they are born. There is no disposition of their spiritual nature that hinders them from achieving goodness. It is merely the choices them make.

Hence, in the Pelagian paradigm, if there are bad choices being made, it is merely because the person chooses them. So the liberal concludes that if man is basically a blank slate, and he is choosing wrong, it is because his environment has convinced him to choose wrong. Ergo, the environment is the problem. It must be changed.

If bad choices, therefore, come from an environment of poverty, then everyone should be given the same amount of money and some of those bad choices will go away. If bad choices come from a lack of education, then giving people the best education possible will cause some of those bad choices to go away. If the presence of guns causes people to make bad choices, then getting rid of guns will cause some of those bad choices to go away.

It is never considered whether the reason why people make bad choices is because they love evil, and would make those choices regardless of whether they were privileged with wealth, education, a non-violent environment, etc. This is the Augustinian, i.e., orthodox and biblical view concerning why man makes bad choices.

It is not his environment. It is his nature that must be changed.

This is not to say that environment does not direct one's nature to a particular expression of his love for evil, but that the problem of man's evil cannot be solved by a change of environment. This is a lesson that the Bible teaches in a few places, but particularly with the flood narrative, where Noah and his family are placed in an environment now free from the evils of the world, and yet, fall into sin because "man is evil from his earliest existence."

The problem isn't guns. It's man who wants to murder when he's angry or apathetic toward others. The problem isn't poverty. It's man who is lazy or who wants to oppress others even when they are not lazy. The problem isn't lack of education. If you educate a theif, as the saying goes, he'll become a better thief. The problem is man.

As such, the only solution can be found in what changes man's nature, and the only thing that changes man's nature is the gospel and the Word of God that builds upon the regeneration found therein. Apart from this, everything else is a band-aid put on a wound created by cancerous cells. It may cover up the problem to where it looks like it was a good solution, but in the end, the cancer continues to grow unchecked. It will consume the body because the right remedy requires the right diagnosis. The nations that have come before, and continue to fall because of their theological malpractice are the corpses of the mistreated.

As such social reform is futile. Our culture is just as immoral, if not more so, as it was before all of this activity of social reform. Social justice is nothing more than the administration of a placebo to calm those who are dying.