I thought this was an insightful comment about a former member of an Acts 29 church. I've seen this over and over again in Evangelicals and their leaning toward liberalism.
"I am wondering about whether this is part of a trend that I see. I used to attend a former Acts 29 church. When i first started attending 8 years ago the church was solid theologically, would discuss theological topics, sermons were solidly biblical etc (we had James N Anderson give lectures!). Oddly though, over the last few years political liberalism has seeped into the congregation, the church has began to move leftward in subtle ways. During this shift I noticed a marked reduction in theology talk, and more talk about “apologizing” to minorities (gays became a very important group to apologize to.). Many in the congregation also began to flirt with the idea that we need to be more “Inclusive” etc.
It seems that if you think “inclusion” is an ultimate good, and many in our era do so, then it’s not a big step to say, “ if xtianity is against inclusion it’s false” people come to the reasonable conclusion that xtianity is not inclusive and walk away. Because of course God would be inclusive."
Monday, July 29, 2019
The Sexual Prosperity Gospel
Like Harris, I was raised in a dating culture and saw no issues with it until later. Unlike Harris, I still think courtship is biblical and dating is not. However, I don't think Harris' courtship model was ever really true courtship that incorporated parents in the mix as much as it should have. I always looked at his model as a more conservative form of dating.
In any case, however, I do think that the element brought out in this article is very real and very important to understand. We do what we do with our relationships to glorify God, not to get a better life or anything in life from it. One only need read the dispute literature in Scripture like Ecclesiastes or Job to know that doing something right does not neccesarily lead to getting a better anything in life, especially since it is through hardship and suffering and God withholding our desires from us often that is the means through which He is creating us/conforming us to the image of His Son.
/https://religionnews.com/2019/07/26/joshua-harris-and-the-sexual-prosperity-gospel/
In any case, however, I do think that the element brought out in this article is very real and very important to understand. We do what we do with our relationships to glorify God, not to get a better life or anything in life from it. One only need read the dispute literature in Scripture like Ecclesiastes or Job to know that doing something right does not neccesarily lead to getting a better anything in life, especially since it is through hardship and suffering and God withholding our desires from us often that is the means through which He is creating us/conforming us to the image of His Son.
/https://religionnews.com/2019/07/26/joshua-harris-and-the-sexual-prosperity-gospel/
Good Bereans?
Evangelicals love to quote the passage in Acts 17:11 about the faithful Bereans searching the Scriptures to make sure Paul's interpretations are correct. They're great examples of the low-church, Individualist's paradigm that gives responsibility to the laity to judge the teachings of the church given to them.
However, is this what the text is actually teaching? Here are some key points that indicate that this is an abuse of this text.
1. They're in a synagogue with rabbis, not in their homes with their individual Bibles. They are being led by teachers to evaluate Paul's statements.
2. Paul's interpretations are given to him by Christ supernaturally in visions, etc. How exactly are they judging his interpretations in Scripture? They could just give those verses a Jewish spin, or apply anachronistically apply the historic-grammitcal approach and refute what Paul is saying. This gives us an indication that what they are searching is whether or not the Scriptures actually contain the things that Paul is quoting, i.e., that it actually says something Paul says that it says. They're not evaluating his interpretations. How exactly does one evaluate an interpretation that had to be revealed to him? In fact, in the Greek it literally just says that they daily examined the Scriptures, not to check his interpretations, but to see τὰς γραφὰς εἰ ἔχοι ταῦτα οὕτως "whether they held these things likewise," i.e., as Paul had said the Sciptures held these things.
3. How was it Luke's point in including this verse to argue that every laymen should check his Bible teachers if, in fact, the average laymen did not own his own Bible and study it personally, nor would he until the advent of the Gutenberg Press 1500 years later?
4. Ephesians 4 lays out that God gives teachers in various forms to the church in order to equip and grow it. Paul instructs Timothy to preach and teach the Word. Elders are also to teach and are qualified by their teaching ability in contrast to even deacons much less laymen. Laymen are never told to study their own Bibles in order to become equipped and discern for themselves what is true and false in a person's teaching. Again, they don't even have them. This means that God would actually require laymen to be faithful in an area they cannot be for another 1500 years. That narrative fits the common Evangelical/Baptist idea that the church essentially fell off the planet until they came along, but it doesn't fit Jesus words very well that the gates of Hades would never prevail against the church.
5. Evangelicalism's individualism is very much a rejection of the biblical and historical means by which believers are equipped and given discernment. As such, it is both unbiblical and historically anachronistic.
I realize that children of the post-enlightenment world have a radical mistrust of authority. They don't want to be dependent upon others. Such ideas scare them. "Sounds like a cult!" they proclaim with zeal as they comfort themselves in their radical departure from the biblical means of discipleship. But everyone is already dependent upon other people who have taught them, books, music, etc. The issue is what source the Bible wants people to be dependent upon. Ultimately, it is a trust in God, upon Whom we are all dependent, that He will lead His people to the right place and into the truth, but that trust must be coupled with an attitude of teachableness toward His Word and faithfulness in one's life.
However, is this what the text is actually teaching? Here are some key points that indicate that this is an abuse of this text.
1. They're in a synagogue with rabbis, not in their homes with their individual Bibles. They are being led by teachers to evaluate Paul's statements.
2. Paul's interpretations are given to him by Christ supernaturally in visions, etc. How exactly are they judging his interpretations in Scripture? They could just give those verses a Jewish spin, or apply anachronistically apply the historic-grammitcal approach and refute what Paul is saying. This gives us an indication that what they are searching is whether or not the Scriptures actually contain the things that Paul is quoting, i.e., that it actually says something Paul says that it says. They're not evaluating his interpretations. How exactly does one evaluate an interpretation that had to be revealed to him? In fact, in the Greek it literally just says that they daily examined the Scriptures, not to check his interpretations, but to see τὰς γραφὰς εἰ ἔχοι ταῦτα οὕτως "whether they held these things likewise," i.e., as Paul had said the Sciptures held these things.
3. How was it Luke's point in including this verse to argue that every laymen should check his Bible teachers if, in fact, the average laymen did not own his own Bible and study it personally, nor would he until the advent of the Gutenberg Press 1500 years later?
4. Ephesians 4 lays out that God gives teachers in various forms to the church in order to equip and grow it. Paul instructs Timothy to preach and teach the Word. Elders are also to teach and are qualified by their teaching ability in contrast to even deacons much less laymen. Laymen are never told to study their own Bibles in order to become equipped and discern for themselves what is true and false in a person's teaching. Again, they don't even have them. This means that God would actually require laymen to be faithful in an area they cannot be for another 1500 years. That narrative fits the common Evangelical/Baptist idea that the church essentially fell off the planet until they came along, but it doesn't fit Jesus words very well that the gates of Hades would never prevail against the church.
5. Evangelicalism's individualism is very much a rejection of the biblical and historical means by which believers are equipped and given discernment. As such, it is both unbiblical and historically anachronistic.
I realize that children of the post-enlightenment world have a radical mistrust of authority. They don't want to be dependent upon others. Such ideas scare them. "Sounds like a cult!" they proclaim with zeal as they comfort themselves in their radical departure from the biblical means of discipleship. But everyone is already dependent upon other people who have taught them, books, music, etc. The issue is what source the Bible wants people to be dependent upon. Ultimately, it is a trust in God, upon Whom we are all dependent, that He will lead His people to the right place and into the truth, but that trust must be coupled with an attitude of teachableness toward His Word and faithfulness in one's life.
Saturday, July 27, 2019
I Kissed Evangelicalism Goodbye: My Thoughts on Joshua Harris' Apostasy
Every once in a while, when he was alive, my dad would watch Abbot and Costello. Bud Abbott was the straight man, and Lou Costello the comic, or "banana man." This made up what is called a comic duo, where one man sets up, or "feeds," another in an act. It was all entertaining because one would identify with Bud Abbott as a rational man, and then get hit by the humor of the irrational funny man, as though the two were at odds with one another. In reality, they were both working together, one to set up the other, and to draw the audience in.
I remember sitting in the lounge of my dorm at Moody with some fellow classmates and hearing one of them talk about his belief that Evangelicalism was dying out. I said to him, "Really, I view Evangelicalism as orthodox Christianity." He said, rather astonished, "Really?"
Over the years, I came to realize why he was so astonished, and just how ignorant my belief was. That's because my true education began, not at Moody, but at Trinity and Westminster, where I started to learn the Bible and Christian theology at an advanced level. This allowed me to begin to see how much modern Evangelicalism was a superficial counterfeit of orthodox Christianity, not the champion of it that it had made itself out to be.
There are, of course, elements of orthodox Christianity within Evangelicalism, which is why it had become such a convincing counterfeit. It originally held up the Bible as the infallible Word of God, affirmed core Christian doctrines like the Trinity and justification by faith, etc.
However, that is all that it affirmed. There was never a fullness to its orthodoxy, a healthy weight on its bones. It always somewhat resembled an anorexic teenager, just enough skin on it to pass as living, but largely malnutritioned and dying.
What I realized over the years is that Evangelicalism is a part of a larger American religion that assumes all sorts of Enlightement and Post-Enlightment ideas in its view of knowledge, God, experience, sexuality, etc. In fact, what I came to realize at a certain point was that it was simply a more conservative form of the liberal theology that it pretended, and still pretends, to fight against.
I often use the term "Americanity" to describe the cult of American "christianity" that includes the flavors of liberalism, fundamentalism, evangelicalism, emergings, etc.; but in reality, they are all the same slurpee with different food coloring.
This is largely due to the fact that, at the end of the day, they all get their ideas from the same source, the self.
Oh, I know, Evangelicalism says it gets its ideas from the Bible, but does it really? The most important practice to grow as a Christian in Evangelicalism is to study your own Bible. Where is this concept in Scripture? The most important practice that leads to growth in Scripture is to set yourself under the discipleship of an apostolic church that teaches the Bible (Eph 4). That's quite a difference. It also means that one is connected to the Christianity that has been taught and learned for 2000 years before.
What that means is that one is constantly reforming, questioning one's secular culture and religious traditions, not by the standard of his Evangelical cult or the wider consensus of American culture, but by the Word of God as it has been understood throughout history and is exegeted in the community of the Holy Spirit that is the church. It is this measuring stick that gives a framework for thinking about any issue.
But Evangelicalism, at the very first, was primarily concerned for how the world around it perceived it. It wanted to be more respected by the larger culture. It argued that Christians should be more involved secular academics, which coupled with the desire to be accepted, resulted in the apostasy of many an academic Christian who soon realized that acceptance by the secular academy meant abandonment of Christian orthodoxy, not just an adoption of critical methods of study. It was meant to be less divisive over secondary issues, a designation it gave to anything outside of the skeleton of what it considered orthodox.
The effect that this had was that Evangelicals reduced what was required of one to believe he was a Christian. Some stayed on an inerrant Bible and the Trinity. Some went so far as to simply believe that one had to believe in Jesus in some way or another. Others believed that one needed only affirm that one is saved by grace. Whatever the boundary marker, it was so narrow a path that one could hardly blame the weary traveler from falling off of it.
And therein lies the problem of Evangelicalism. It isn't a robust worldview. It doesn't provide anyone a framework for thinking through issues and living them out in the Christian life. It's designed specifically as a blanket to be placed over whatever worldview one already has. It's much like the Roman Empire, desiring to grow bigger by assuming the cultures of everything in its path to the point where there is nothing distinctive about the Empire from the world before it was conquered by it. It certainly obtained for Evangelicalism bigger buildings and masses of people, but that's only because there was nothing to offend anyone anymore. People could just believe whatever they wished without the threat of walking outside the faith. After all, they still believe in the Trinity even though their ethics all came from superficial music, movies, newsmedia, school, etc.
Since you can believe all sorts of things, there isn't much left to distinguish Evangelicalism from any other American belief system. Even Hindus and Muslims believe in Jesus in some way. Even Roman Catholics and EO's believe in the Trinity (which is why many Evangelicals think they're just another denominational option for them). Every religion on the planet has an idea of grace.
What does all of this have to do with the apostasy of Joshua Harris? His apostasy, and the statements he makes in his declaration, are a further reminder that Evangelicals are more influenced by their culture than they would like to admit.
For instance, he states that his previous views, i.e., the ones that were closer to orthodox Christianity, were "bigoted." This is an odd assessement from someone who no longer has a transcedent measuring stick. Where did he get the idea that such was bigotry? Oh yes. Popular opinion among the unbelieving masses. He also states that he is in a state of deconstruction; but how exactly would one know one's trajectory of thought without a standard? Oh yes, the standard is culture. One is moving toward culture and further away from an orthdox Christian worldview.
My point is that Harris already had a framework in place that eventually convinced him that orthodox Christianity was false, even while truly believing certain doctrines and practices that belonged to orthodox Christianity. I see this in every apostate that Evangelicalism produces. It is a system bereft of understanding.
I say this because anyone who thinks long and hard about it, anyone who is actually educated in the matter, would not come out acting like he knew a better way. The only options are Christianity or radical skepticism to the point that one cannot identify what is bigoted, what is right, what is harmful, etc.
But Harris comes out of Evangelicalism bright-eyed and bushy-tailed, knowing that everything is going to be alright, that he should apologize to unbelievers because the views he critiqued in the past are morally valid after all, and that his former views were wrong. How exactly does he know any of this? Because the real religious authority for the Evangelical is not the Bible or the historical church, or even his modern local church. It is culture. Evangelicalism, because it does not present the whole counsel of God as vital to its members, does not teach it, and now does not know it, ends up just being the straight man setting up the comic of secular culture. Only the punch line isn't all that funny. It leads to destruction, to divorce, to hopelessness, and to ruined lives that are convinced they are happy because they were living in some sort of legalism rather than in a loving relationship toward God that sought the truth and good in everything from the sources God commanded they be sought.
In essence, Evangelicalism is a rebellious movement form the get go. It is not a surprise that what is begun in apostasy ends in apostasy. So I am an apostate too. I apostasized from the cult of Evangelicalism. I kissed it goodbye. But I did not give up one chair in the cult meeting just to sit down in another as Harris did. By adopting genuine Christianity as a comprehensive worldview obtained from the whole counsel of God, I walked out of the building altogether.
I remember sitting in the lounge of my dorm at Moody with some fellow classmates and hearing one of them talk about his belief that Evangelicalism was dying out. I said to him, "Really, I view Evangelicalism as orthodox Christianity." He said, rather astonished, "Really?"
Over the years, I came to realize why he was so astonished, and just how ignorant my belief was. That's because my true education began, not at Moody, but at Trinity and Westminster, where I started to learn the Bible and Christian theology at an advanced level. This allowed me to begin to see how much modern Evangelicalism was a superficial counterfeit of orthodox Christianity, not the champion of it that it had made itself out to be.
There are, of course, elements of orthodox Christianity within Evangelicalism, which is why it had become such a convincing counterfeit. It originally held up the Bible as the infallible Word of God, affirmed core Christian doctrines like the Trinity and justification by faith, etc.
However, that is all that it affirmed. There was never a fullness to its orthodoxy, a healthy weight on its bones. It always somewhat resembled an anorexic teenager, just enough skin on it to pass as living, but largely malnutritioned and dying.
What I realized over the years is that Evangelicalism is a part of a larger American religion that assumes all sorts of Enlightement and Post-Enlightment ideas in its view of knowledge, God, experience, sexuality, etc. In fact, what I came to realize at a certain point was that it was simply a more conservative form of the liberal theology that it pretended, and still pretends, to fight against.
I often use the term "Americanity" to describe the cult of American "christianity" that includes the flavors of liberalism, fundamentalism, evangelicalism, emergings, etc.; but in reality, they are all the same slurpee with different food coloring.
This is largely due to the fact that, at the end of the day, they all get their ideas from the same source, the self.
Oh, I know, Evangelicalism says it gets its ideas from the Bible, but does it really? The most important practice to grow as a Christian in Evangelicalism is to study your own Bible. Where is this concept in Scripture? The most important practice that leads to growth in Scripture is to set yourself under the discipleship of an apostolic church that teaches the Bible (Eph 4). That's quite a difference. It also means that one is connected to the Christianity that has been taught and learned for 2000 years before.
What that means is that one is constantly reforming, questioning one's secular culture and religious traditions, not by the standard of his Evangelical cult or the wider consensus of American culture, but by the Word of God as it has been understood throughout history and is exegeted in the community of the Holy Spirit that is the church. It is this measuring stick that gives a framework for thinking about any issue.
But Evangelicalism, at the very first, was primarily concerned for how the world around it perceived it. It wanted to be more respected by the larger culture. It argued that Christians should be more involved secular academics, which coupled with the desire to be accepted, resulted in the apostasy of many an academic Christian who soon realized that acceptance by the secular academy meant abandonment of Christian orthodoxy, not just an adoption of critical methods of study. It was meant to be less divisive over secondary issues, a designation it gave to anything outside of the skeleton of what it considered orthodox.
The effect that this had was that Evangelicals reduced what was required of one to believe he was a Christian. Some stayed on an inerrant Bible and the Trinity. Some went so far as to simply believe that one had to believe in Jesus in some way or another. Others believed that one needed only affirm that one is saved by grace. Whatever the boundary marker, it was so narrow a path that one could hardly blame the weary traveler from falling off of it.
And therein lies the problem of Evangelicalism. It isn't a robust worldview. It doesn't provide anyone a framework for thinking through issues and living them out in the Christian life. It's designed specifically as a blanket to be placed over whatever worldview one already has. It's much like the Roman Empire, desiring to grow bigger by assuming the cultures of everything in its path to the point where there is nothing distinctive about the Empire from the world before it was conquered by it. It certainly obtained for Evangelicalism bigger buildings and masses of people, but that's only because there was nothing to offend anyone anymore. People could just believe whatever they wished without the threat of walking outside the faith. After all, they still believe in the Trinity even though their ethics all came from superficial music, movies, newsmedia, school, etc.
Since you can believe all sorts of things, there isn't much left to distinguish Evangelicalism from any other American belief system. Even Hindus and Muslims believe in Jesus in some way. Even Roman Catholics and EO's believe in the Trinity (which is why many Evangelicals think they're just another denominational option for them). Every religion on the planet has an idea of grace.
What does all of this have to do with the apostasy of Joshua Harris? His apostasy, and the statements he makes in his declaration, are a further reminder that Evangelicals are more influenced by their culture than they would like to admit.
For instance, he states that his previous views, i.e., the ones that were closer to orthodox Christianity, were "bigoted." This is an odd assessement from someone who no longer has a transcedent measuring stick. Where did he get the idea that such was bigotry? Oh yes. Popular opinion among the unbelieving masses. He also states that he is in a state of deconstruction; but how exactly would one know one's trajectory of thought without a standard? Oh yes, the standard is culture. One is moving toward culture and further away from an orthdox Christian worldview.
My point is that Harris already had a framework in place that eventually convinced him that orthodox Christianity was false, even while truly believing certain doctrines and practices that belonged to orthodox Christianity. I see this in every apostate that Evangelicalism produces. It is a system bereft of understanding.
I say this because anyone who thinks long and hard about it, anyone who is actually educated in the matter, would not come out acting like he knew a better way. The only options are Christianity or radical skepticism to the point that one cannot identify what is bigoted, what is right, what is harmful, etc.
But Harris comes out of Evangelicalism bright-eyed and bushy-tailed, knowing that everything is going to be alright, that he should apologize to unbelievers because the views he critiqued in the past are morally valid after all, and that his former views were wrong. How exactly does he know any of this? Because the real religious authority for the Evangelical is not the Bible or the historical church, or even his modern local church. It is culture. Evangelicalism, because it does not present the whole counsel of God as vital to its members, does not teach it, and now does not know it, ends up just being the straight man setting up the comic of secular culture. Only the punch line isn't all that funny. It leads to destruction, to divorce, to hopelessness, and to ruined lives that are convinced they are happy because they were living in some sort of legalism rather than in a loving relationship toward God that sought the truth and good in everything from the sources God commanded they be sought.
In essence, Evangelicalism is a rebellious movement form the get go. It is not a surprise that what is begun in apostasy ends in apostasy. So I am an apostate too. I apostasized from the cult of Evangelicalism. I kissed it goodbye. But I did not give up one chair in the cult meeting just to sit down in another as Harris did. By adopting genuine Christianity as a comprehensive worldview obtained from the whole counsel of God, I walked out of the building altogether.
Thursday, July 25, 2019
Romantic or Blessed Language When Speaking to or about God?
The ladies have been writing some good posts over at BoneofBones. April had a great article concerning contemporary speech and music that displayed romantic gestures toward God. To this article I would add just two things.
Jesus as my boyfriend is certainly a different picture of Christ than the one where He stands up to the most furocious powers of nature, the wind and the sea, and tells them to be silent . . . and they obey Him! Jesus isn't our boyfriend. He's our Lord and our God.
1. Although we often have to point out that God is neither male nor female, it is actually not true that His own self-expression to us is genderless. God overwhelmingly communicates Himself to us through maleness. The pronouns used for Himself, the imagery, the designations as Father rather than Mother, King rather than Queen, Lord rather than Mistress are important. His incarnation is that of a man, Christ Jesus, who is the Son and not the Daughter of God.
Although God does use analogies a couple times between Himself and a woman, it is always to compare His love for His people with a mother's love for her children (or a hen's love for its chicks). It is never as a woman to be desired.
This creates a potential issue for men who speak romantically of God. In essence, it is not only an effeminization of men, but perhaps, even a type of homosexuality rather than ordered, heterosexual sex that is being pictured in this type of language.
Truly, sex is an analogy between our relationship with God. It is meant to communicate in an earthly relationship the joy and pleasure one has in the presence of God. The Song of Songs is meant to display this. But this is an analogy, not a vocabulary presented by the Bible of direct speech one should employ when speaking to God or about Him. This is much in the same way that analogies, like God being a hen or a mother, are made of God and His relationship to us, but should not form our language in speaking to God (as though referring to God as our Mother or the Great Chicken is appropriate for creatures claiming to have reverence toward their Creator).
2. On the flip side of things, the romantic language used for people often crosses the line of worship. Talking about another person as one's "everything." or "sole desire," or "rock in life," etc. are all things that should actually be said of God and not of other human beings. In this regard, not only are modern songs and declarations about one's partner sappy and empty (I often have to wonder if a particular song declaring one's eternal love for another is said of a girlfriend that he had twenty girlfriends ago), they are outright idolatrous.
Human beings are not meant to function as the fulfillment of one another's purpose and meaning. God does that for humans who have been made to worship Him and Him alone.
So on the one hand, language that should not be used of God is spilling over into our vocabulary toward God, and on the other, language that should not be used of humans is spilling over into our vocabulary toward one another. In essence, we are a people who have transgressed the boundaries of the Creator/creature distinction, the holy and the profane. We are polytheists and polygamists, looking for our gods and our lovers wherever we can find them, even mixing them together as the Greek myths of old.
We likely do this because we have been trained to think that our relationships are only meaningful and fulfilling if they are emotionally exciting, and romantic relationships cause our dopamine fountains to runneth over more than any other relationship. But God is not valuable to my life because of the way He makes me feel. His value is not subjective to me. It is intrinsic to Him, and this causes me to value Him beyond my subjective feelings. There is no need to become sappy about God in some futile effort to allow Him to compete with all of the other drugs around me, including romantic relationships. Instead, it is through the truth that our eyes are opened, we see God's beauty and value, and therefore, make application to our lives that God is worthy to be worshiped, not because He makes me feel a certain way, but because all things were made by Him and for Him. I would call this blessed language. It is a language which acknowledges the greatness of God and what He has done for us without the degrading of Him into a means to meet my emotionally romantic needs. Romantic relationships in our culture are one of the many drugs with which we intoxicate ourselves in our self worship, but God is not an aspirin to be used as pain medication to hide a broken life, as we use our other drugs. He is life and health itself. Our language, as it does in the Bible, should reflect this sort of exaltation, and call the winds and waves of emotionally romantic speech to be silent.
Jesus as my boyfriend is certainly a different picture of Christ than the one where He stands up to the most furocious powers of nature, the wind and the sea, and tells them to be silent . . . and they obey Him! Jesus isn't our boyfriend. He's our Lord and our God.
1. Although we often have to point out that God is neither male nor female, it is actually not true that His own self-expression to us is genderless. God overwhelmingly communicates Himself to us through maleness. The pronouns used for Himself, the imagery, the designations as Father rather than Mother, King rather than Queen, Lord rather than Mistress are important. His incarnation is that of a man, Christ Jesus, who is the Son and not the Daughter of God.
Although God does use analogies a couple times between Himself and a woman, it is always to compare His love for His people with a mother's love for her children (or a hen's love for its chicks). It is never as a woman to be desired.
This creates a potential issue for men who speak romantically of God. In essence, it is not only an effeminization of men, but perhaps, even a type of homosexuality rather than ordered, heterosexual sex that is being pictured in this type of language.
Truly, sex is an analogy between our relationship with God. It is meant to communicate in an earthly relationship the joy and pleasure one has in the presence of God. The Song of Songs is meant to display this. But this is an analogy, not a vocabulary presented by the Bible of direct speech one should employ when speaking to God or about Him. This is much in the same way that analogies, like God being a hen or a mother, are made of God and His relationship to us, but should not form our language in speaking to God (as though referring to God as our Mother or the Great Chicken is appropriate for creatures claiming to have reverence toward their Creator).
2. On the flip side of things, the romantic language used for people often crosses the line of worship. Talking about another person as one's "everything." or "sole desire," or "rock in life," etc. are all things that should actually be said of God and not of other human beings. In this regard, not only are modern songs and declarations about one's partner sappy and empty (I often have to wonder if a particular song declaring one's eternal love for another is said of a girlfriend that he had twenty girlfriends ago), they are outright idolatrous.
Human beings are not meant to function as the fulfillment of one another's purpose and meaning. God does that for humans who have been made to worship Him and Him alone.
So on the one hand, language that should not be used of God is spilling over into our vocabulary toward God, and on the other, language that should not be used of humans is spilling over into our vocabulary toward one another. In essence, we are a people who have transgressed the boundaries of the Creator/creature distinction, the holy and the profane. We are polytheists and polygamists, looking for our gods and our lovers wherever we can find them, even mixing them together as the Greek myths of old.
We likely do this because we have been trained to think that our relationships are only meaningful and fulfilling if they are emotionally exciting, and romantic relationships cause our dopamine fountains to runneth over more than any other relationship. But God is not valuable to my life because of the way He makes me feel. His value is not subjective to me. It is intrinsic to Him, and this causes me to value Him beyond my subjective feelings. There is no need to become sappy about God in some futile effort to allow Him to compete with all of the other drugs around me, including romantic relationships. Instead, it is through the truth that our eyes are opened, we see God's beauty and value, and therefore, make application to our lives that God is worthy to be worshiped, not because He makes me feel a certain way, but because all things were made by Him and for Him. I would call this blessed language. It is a language which acknowledges the greatness of God and what He has done for us without the degrading of Him into a means to meet my emotionally romantic needs. Romantic relationships in our culture are one of the many drugs with which we intoxicate ourselves in our self worship, but God is not an aspirin to be used as pain medication to hide a broken life, as we use our other drugs. He is life and health itself. Our language, as it does in the Bible, should reflect this sort of exaltation, and call the winds and waves of emotionally romantic speech to be silent.
The Rationale between Old Testament and New Testament Differences in Marital Ethics
According to Jesus, Genesis presents God's ultimate will in creation concerning marriage. There is to be one woman and one man and the two are to become one flesh. That's it. He then goes on to argue that this is why if a man and woman are divorced and remarried they are committing adultery. But, as the Pharisees objected, wasn't this permitted in the Law?
And whatever happened to good ol' polygamy? Wasn't that permitted as well?
And there is no law against prostitution, so why is it condemned in the New Testament?
Some would argue that it just reflects the changing ethics of marriage in culture. When in an ancient Near Eastern society that accepted polygamy, the Bible was OK with it. When in a monogamous culture like that of the Graeco-Roman empires, the Bible changed its mind. This, of course, is not the reason for the Bible's stance on these things.
For one, this doesn't explain why the New Testament takes a stricter stance against prostitution and divorce and remarriage than the Law does, since both are perfectly acceptable in Graeco-Roman culture.
Secondly, what is used and permitted by God is not necessarily pleasing to God and in accordance with His ultimate will. In other words, it may be the case that God merely tolerated these things, creating through a slow process of weaning His people off of bad ideas and practices until the fulness of Christ and the Spirit would come to restore the vision presented at creation.
But how would we know this? We would have to have some indications in the Old Testament that God was only tolerating these things, even though they were not in accordance with His ideal. Do we have such indications? Yes, we do.
Let's start with prostitution. There is no law against it. Men used prostitutes (e.g., Judah, the spies who end up at Rahab's brothel, etc.) in the same way that men use them in many third world countries around the world. But even though they are not outlawed, God does not view the sleeping with a prostitute favorably.
For one, He prohibits men from making their daughters prostitutes (Lev 19:29). Leviticus 21:7 prohibits his priests from marrying prostitutes, who are said to be defiled. If God had no problem with prostitution, then why are they viewed as defiled and priests forbidden to marry them? God frequently uses prostitution as a way of talking about the disgusting acts of other nations and even of rebellious Israel. A girl who whores herself and then attempts to marry a man without telling him first is to be put to death. Why all of this fuss if God has no problem with prostitution? In fact, God does make a law that no ethnic Israelite woman or man is to be a cult prostitute, even though a non-ethnic Israelite member of the community could be (Deut 29:17), and no money gained from prostitution was to be given to the Lord to fulfill a vow (29:18).
So was prostitution permitted? Yes. Was it in complete accordance with the will of God for male and female? No. Hence, when the New Testament comes along, Christ has died and ascended as High Priest, unification with God through Christ via the Holy Spirit has occurred, the ultimate will of God in creation is to be sought and all else abandoned as evil.
But what about polygamy? Any indication that the Old Testament sees it as a bad thing, even though it is never prohibited explicitly and even used by God to communicate ideas? Yes, lots.
First of all, polygamy is almost always viewed as a hostile environment for everyone involved. Jealousy between the wives (e.g., Sarah and Hagar, Leah and Rachel, Hannah and Peninnah), as well as rivalry between the sons (e.g., the rilvaries between Abraham's sons, Isaac's sons, Jacob's sons, David's sons, Solomon's sons, etc.). This also created an exhausting environment for the husband. In Deuteronomy 17:17, the law forbids the king to take numerous wives because there is a threat that it will turn his heart away (i.e., cause him to focus on them and not the Lord or the people he is to rule in righteousness). Instead, the godly instruction of Proverbs speaks only of devotion to one's wife (singular), and the Greatest Song, the Song of Songs, that allegorizes the relationship between God and His people does so by presenting only one man and one woman in that relationship, displaying that God's idealic picture is for one man and one woman to join together in a pleasure and joy not shared with anyone else.
Finally, we come to divorce. It is permitted in the Law, as the others are as well, but along with the others, it is not in accordance with God's will as it is manifested in creation. Hence, God hates divorce (Mal 2:16). His priests are not to marry a divorced woman (Lev 21:7). Even for a former husband to marry a woman now divorced from a second husband is a defilement and an abomination to the Lord (Deut 24:1-4). Why would these things be said if God had no problem with it? If He was not just tolerating it, but really did not see it as outside the boundaries of His created will?
Now, here is why I believe God did tolerate it in the Old Testament, but does so no more. These are all in line with the main aspect of the creation ethic, which is the creation of a covenant human being, but not in line with the preservational aspect, as it created a hostile environment for the children and their possible upbringing. The sexual act between a prostitute, a concubine, a divorced woman is ordered in terms of it having the possibility of creating human life among the covenant people. These are, therefore, tolerated, even though they are not completely in accordance with the preservational and fully ordered ideal of the creation ethic (i.e., that which is in accordance with the creation mandate in Gen 1:28-30).
Because they are not fully ordered and in accordance with His ultimate will, God does not like them. There is something disordered about them, something defiled and corrupt, but tolerable enough to be used for His purposes until the time of Christ.
When Christ comes, however, He is unifying His people to God, whereby they partake of the very divine nature, and demands now that they be fully ordered in all of their marital and sexual practices. Hence, we get the conversation between Christ and the Pharisees, where Christ tells them that anything less that the ideal of the one male and one female becoming one flesh is of the sin of adultery. This would include prostitution and polygamy.
This is also why things that are completely disordered and a complete rejection of the creation ethic are not tolerated at all. Homosexuality, bestiality, incest, strictly defined adultery, etc. are all in this group.
An analogy of this might be the fact that God does not prohibit the belief in many gods in the original giving of the law, but instead only that the Israelites are to worship Him as their God alone. It is only later, as God teaches them slowly, that there actually are no other gods beside Him. God creates with patience over time. He is not an instructor that pulls the rug out from underneath His people before the time when they can handle it. When the Holy Spirit is given to them in Christ, then, and only then, are they able to receive all things fully.
What this means, therefore, is that those who believe that divorce is acceptable today are arguing against the rationale of the Bible. If divorce is acceptable, why not polygamy? In fact, the same type of disorderliness that is in divorce (i.e., a threat to children due to there being a non-biological parent, often with his or her own children, creating a hostile environment for them, and the unfaithfulness to a one flesh union between one man and one woman while they live) is also in polygamy. It is not that such hostile environments could not be created by more ordered situations, but that these disordered situations have been created by the people involved and not just by circumstance (as would be in the case of one marrying a widow with children for instance).
The fact that all of these are presented in a negative light throughout the Old Testament and rejected by the New, tells us that God has called the people of the kingdom to His original ideal and will concerning the one flesh union in marriage between one man and one woman until death do they part, to its restoration in becoming what marriage was meant to become as a means of God's work in completing creation.
And whatever happened to good ol' polygamy? Wasn't that permitted as well?
And there is no law against prostitution, so why is it condemned in the New Testament?
Some would argue that it just reflects the changing ethics of marriage in culture. When in an ancient Near Eastern society that accepted polygamy, the Bible was OK with it. When in a monogamous culture like that of the Graeco-Roman empires, the Bible changed its mind. This, of course, is not the reason for the Bible's stance on these things.
For one, this doesn't explain why the New Testament takes a stricter stance against prostitution and divorce and remarriage than the Law does, since both are perfectly acceptable in Graeco-Roman culture.
Secondly, what is used and permitted by God is not necessarily pleasing to God and in accordance with His ultimate will. In other words, it may be the case that God merely tolerated these things, creating through a slow process of weaning His people off of bad ideas and practices until the fulness of Christ and the Spirit would come to restore the vision presented at creation.
But how would we know this? We would have to have some indications in the Old Testament that God was only tolerating these things, even though they were not in accordance with His ideal. Do we have such indications? Yes, we do.
Let's start with prostitution. There is no law against it. Men used prostitutes (e.g., Judah, the spies who end up at Rahab's brothel, etc.) in the same way that men use them in many third world countries around the world. But even though they are not outlawed, God does not view the sleeping with a prostitute favorably.
For one, He prohibits men from making their daughters prostitutes (Lev 19:29). Leviticus 21:7 prohibits his priests from marrying prostitutes, who are said to be defiled. If God had no problem with prostitution, then why are they viewed as defiled and priests forbidden to marry them? God frequently uses prostitution as a way of talking about the disgusting acts of other nations and even of rebellious Israel. A girl who whores herself and then attempts to marry a man without telling him first is to be put to death. Why all of this fuss if God has no problem with prostitution? In fact, God does make a law that no ethnic Israelite woman or man is to be a cult prostitute, even though a non-ethnic Israelite member of the community could be (Deut 29:17), and no money gained from prostitution was to be given to the Lord to fulfill a vow (29:18).
So was prostitution permitted? Yes. Was it in complete accordance with the will of God for male and female? No. Hence, when the New Testament comes along, Christ has died and ascended as High Priest, unification with God through Christ via the Holy Spirit has occurred, the ultimate will of God in creation is to be sought and all else abandoned as evil.
But what about polygamy? Any indication that the Old Testament sees it as a bad thing, even though it is never prohibited explicitly and even used by God to communicate ideas? Yes, lots.
First of all, polygamy is almost always viewed as a hostile environment for everyone involved. Jealousy between the wives (e.g., Sarah and Hagar, Leah and Rachel, Hannah and Peninnah), as well as rivalry between the sons (e.g., the rilvaries between Abraham's sons, Isaac's sons, Jacob's sons, David's sons, Solomon's sons, etc.). This also created an exhausting environment for the husband. In Deuteronomy 17:17, the law forbids the king to take numerous wives because there is a threat that it will turn his heart away (i.e., cause him to focus on them and not the Lord or the people he is to rule in righteousness). Instead, the godly instruction of Proverbs speaks only of devotion to one's wife (singular), and the Greatest Song, the Song of Songs, that allegorizes the relationship between God and His people does so by presenting only one man and one woman in that relationship, displaying that God's idealic picture is for one man and one woman to join together in a pleasure and joy not shared with anyone else.
Finally, we come to divorce. It is permitted in the Law, as the others are as well, but along with the others, it is not in accordance with God's will as it is manifested in creation. Hence, God hates divorce (Mal 2:16). His priests are not to marry a divorced woman (Lev 21:7). Even for a former husband to marry a woman now divorced from a second husband is a defilement and an abomination to the Lord (Deut 24:1-4). Why would these things be said if God had no problem with it? If He was not just tolerating it, but really did not see it as outside the boundaries of His created will?
Now, here is why I believe God did tolerate it in the Old Testament, but does so no more. These are all in line with the main aspect of the creation ethic, which is the creation of a covenant human being, but not in line with the preservational aspect, as it created a hostile environment for the children and their possible upbringing. The sexual act between a prostitute, a concubine, a divorced woman is ordered in terms of it having the possibility of creating human life among the covenant people. These are, therefore, tolerated, even though they are not completely in accordance with the preservational and fully ordered ideal of the creation ethic (i.e., that which is in accordance with the creation mandate in Gen 1:28-30).
Because they are not fully ordered and in accordance with His ultimate will, God does not like them. There is something disordered about them, something defiled and corrupt, but tolerable enough to be used for His purposes until the time of Christ.
When Christ comes, however, He is unifying His people to God, whereby they partake of the very divine nature, and demands now that they be fully ordered in all of their marital and sexual practices. Hence, we get the conversation between Christ and the Pharisees, where Christ tells them that anything less that the ideal of the one male and one female becoming one flesh is of the sin of adultery. This would include prostitution and polygamy.
This is also why things that are completely disordered and a complete rejection of the creation ethic are not tolerated at all. Homosexuality, bestiality, incest, strictly defined adultery, etc. are all in this group.
An analogy of this might be the fact that God does not prohibit the belief in many gods in the original giving of the law, but instead only that the Israelites are to worship Him as their God alone. It is only later, as God teaches them slowly, that there actually are no other gods beside Him. God creates with patience over time. He is not an instructor that pulls the rug out from underneath His people before the time when they can handle it. When the Holy Spirit is given to them in Christ, then, and only then, are they able to receive all things fully.
What this means, therefore, is that those who believe that divorce is acceptable today are arguing against the rationale of the Bible. If divorce is acceptable, why not polygamy? In fact, the same type of disorderliness that is in divorce (i.e., a threat to children due to there being a non-biological parent, often with his or her own children, creating a hostile environment for them, and the unfaithfulness to a one flesh union between one man and one woman while they live) is also in polygamy. It is not that such hostile environments could not be created by more ordered situations, but that these disordered situations have been created by the people involved and not just by circumstance (as would be in the case of one marrying a widow with children for instance).
The fact that all of these are presented in a negative light throughout the Old Testament and rejected by the New, tells us that God has called the people of the kingdom to His original ideal and will concerning the one flesh union in marriage between one man and one woman until death do they part, to its restoration in becoming what marriage was meant to become as a means of God's work in completing creation.
If God Is Love, Only the Christian God Is True
I think it's an important argument to point out that if, in fact, there is a God, and love is one of His attributes (or even if one wants to argue God is only love), that only the Christian God can be the One that actually exists.
First, let me say that we must only consider the religions that have historically claimed to be revelations from God from the beginning of humanity. Any Johnny-come-lately religions that want to counter my argument below with something new are self-admittedly to be rejected. This is because any God who is loving would not have left humanity without revelation of Himself and the truth in general for thousands of years. Such would be unloving, and we are discussing a God who is loving.
This means that the pool from which we have to choose is reduced to a bit of a puddle. We are left with pantheism/monism, where god is everything and a singularity (only existing in multiplicity as an illusion), panentheism, which, again, is monistic and god, which includes creation, is one and usually evolving (so its attributes are not eternal), polytheism, which is almost always pantheistic or monotheistic in its original state, where the multiplicity of gods are created at a point in time, but not eternally distinguished, the monotheism of Judaism and Islam, and the triune monotheism of Christianity.
Now, if God's love is an inherent attribute, then panentheism is immediately dismissed, as love would be a created thing that is produced in time. It isn't really something that is inherent to god at all, but a created thing that god was not at one time. It should also be said that if God's attributes are not eternal then neither is God, and if God is not eternal, He is not God.
The other views have even bigger problems. To say that one is loving implies an object. If love is an eternal attribute of God, then God must have an eternal object of His love, or merely saying that God is eternally loving is reducing love to nothing, as when there is nothing to love, one cannot be declared to be loving.
One cannot say that creation functions this way for God, as creation would either have to be God (as in panentheism) or be as eternal as God, but non-god. Since creation is not eternal in all of these religions (as either creation does not exist and is the one god, or it is created by god), it cannot be the eternal object of God's love.
Likewise, God merely seeing and knowing a creation that at one time was not but will come about is to argue that God's existence is contingent upon creation. If God is eternally loving as an inherent and eternal attribute, then creation must exist in the "future" of God in order for God to exist, but this is like saying that a chicken exists because he will lay the egg from which he himself will hatch. He must exist in order to lay the egg and the egg must exist in order for him to exist in order to lay it. This is nonsense. Hence, creation cannot function as the eternal object of God's love in any of these systems.
Since they all claim that God is eternally loving, they are all proven to be false. This includes Judaism and Islam.
The only religion left is that of Christianity, where the Father has an eternal object of love in the Son and the Holy Spirit, the Son has an eternal object of love in the Father and the Holy Spirit, and the Holy Spirit has an eternal object of His love in the Son and the Father.
Hence, of all of the religions that claim that love is an attribute of God, only one among the historic religions making the claim can be true. As strange as we find the Trinity, it ends up being the most logical option of all.
First, let me say that we must only consider the religions that have historically claimed to be revelations from God from the beginning of humanity. Any Johnny-come-lately religions that want to counter my argument below with something new are self-admittedly to be rejected. This is because any God who is loving would not have left humanity without revelation of Himself and the truth in general for thousands of years. Such would be unloving, and we are discussing a God who is loving.
This means that the pool from which we have to choose is reduced to a bit of a puddle. We are left with pantheism/monism, where god is everything and a singularity (only existing in multiplicity as an illusion), panentheism, which, again, is monistic and god, which includes creation, is one and usually evolving (so its attributes are not eternal), polytheism, which is almost always pantheistic or monotheistic in its original state, where the multiplicity of gods are created at a point in time, but not eternally distinguished, the monotheism of Judaism and Islam, and the triune monotheism of Christianity.
Now, if God's love is an inherent attribute, then panentheism is immediately dismissed, as love would be a created thing that is produced in time. It isn't really something that is inherent to god at all, but a created thing that god was not at one time. It should also be said that if God's attributes are not eternal then neither is God, and if God is not eternal, He is not God.
The other views have even bigger problems. To say that one is loving implies an object. If love is an eternal attribute of God, then God must have an eternal object of His love, or merely saying that God is eternally loving is reducing love to nothing, as when there is nothing to love, one cannot be declared to be loving.
One cannot say that creation functions this way for God, as creation would either have to be God (as in panentheism) or be as eternal as God, but non-god. Since creation is not eternal in all of these religions (as either creation does not exist and is the one god, or it is created by god), it cannot be the eternal object of God's love.
Likewise, God merely seeing and knowing a creation that at one time was not but will come about is to argue that God's existence is contingent upon creation. If God is eternally loving as an inherent and eternal attribute, then creation must exist in the "future" of God in order for God to exist, but this is like saying that a chicken exists because he will lay the egg from which he himself will hatch. He must exist in order to lay the egg and the egg must exist in order for him to exist in order to lay it. This is nonsense. Hence, creation cannot function as the eternal object of God's love in any of these systems.
Since they all claim that God is eternally loving, they are all proven to be false. This includes Judaism and Islam.
The only religion left is that of Christianity, where the Father has an eternal object of love in the Son and the Holy Spirit, the Son has an eternal object of love in the Father and the Holy Spirit, and the Holy Spirit has an eternal object of His love in the Son and the Father.
Hence, of all of the religions that claim that love is an attribute of God, only one among the historic religions making the claim can be true. As strange as we find the Trinity, it ends up being the most logical option of all.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)