Tuesday, March 5, 2019

Notes on Revelation 6-8:1


The Lamb alone is worthy to open the seals, which is a way of John communicating the same exclusivity of the Son that he communicates in his Gospel.
Everything inside a document that one can open belongs to the one who opens it, meaning all judgment and salvation belong to the Son, another idea from John’s Gospel; and an important point to communicate that all people ultimately should be loyal to the Son, not to the world or its authorities, since to Him belongs all things.

The Son’s general judgment upon the world is conquest, war, famine, and death. All people experience this as part of the general judgment upon fallen mankind and creation. The command to go forth is given to the horsemen from the throne of God and the Lamb. The salvation in Revelation is the act of giving the inheritance of Christ, i.e., the whole world and resurrection life, to His people. This act, therefore, also means taking away the earth from the wicked and those who have corrupted and destroyed Christ’s people. Hence, all acts of judgment upon those who ruin God’s people are acts of salvation for God’s people. It is a double-edged sword.

Those who follow the Son, true Israel, however, are sealed (same word as the other seals) so that they belong to the Son alone, and not to the devil or his wicked world. Hence, the judgments of Christ upon the world will not lead to their spiritual destruction, even though it may lead to their physical suffering and death in the here and now. Hence, the seal is on their foreheads to protect their minds/faith through the suffering they will endure by being in the world that is under judgment.

The number 144,000 refers to the true church among the visible church upon the earth (7:1-8). The number is likely meant to parallel those who make up the new Jerusalem in Chapter 21. These are the faithful among the churches in Chapters 2-3 who overcame/were victorious by not compromising with the world and following the Lamb wherever He went (14:1-5). The scene then looks to another scene where John sees an enormous crowd made up of every tribe, nation, language, and people group, and these are identified as those who have come out of the great tribulation and rather than succumbing to the pressures of those persecutions have washed themselves in the blood of the Lamb (i.e., repented and received cleansing—which is another element taken from Johannine literature, where one who confesses his sin is made clean by the blood propitiation of Christ. These are likely the same group, not two different groups. One is merely a picture of these faithful witnesses as they lived in the time of tribulation in the wicked world and the other when they have come into God's presence both in the future creation.

The judgment of the wicked in the first cycle uses stock apocalyptic/prophetic speech that refers to the macrocosmic event at the end of the wicked world’s rule. Here it is coupled with a cataclysmic earthquake, whereas later it will be war and fire that burns the wicked world. The salvation here also mimics that found in the end of the book, e.g., wiping away every tear from their eyes, give them waters of life and will never thirst again, no more sun to beat down on them, etc.

The sky being rolled up is likely imagery that comes from the symbolic idea that the sky is a protective ceiling from cosmic waters that represent chaos. What it would essentially mean is that God now lets all chaos, including both natural and spiritual, i.e., demonic (there could be this sense in Revelation since stars are falling to the earth and the natural and spiritual are not divided so sharply in the ancient worldview), forces loose upon the created order. This is made more explicit in the second cycle, where Christ is clearly unleashing demonic/chaotic forces upon the world. Creation that has been corrupted is unraveling and undone to the point that all men just look to be covered upon by the avalanche of rocks to avoid any more of God’s wrath upon the earth.

The right response to God and Christ destroying the wicked and saving His people is worship and thanksgiving. The response we often hear today from those who think God must act only lovingly toward all if He is to be worthy of worship and praise is a symptom of the wicked in Revelation, who curse God rather than give Him glory. It means that those who think this way are the damned, even if they claim the name of Christ.

The reader is not told what the temple and throne are in the first cycle. It is only said that those who come out of the times of trouble and whose works are cleaned up through repentance will serve God in His temple perpetually and be forever sheltered by the Lamb. In the second cycle, it is clear that this refers to the resurrected people of God in the renewed created order upon the earth.

All of this is to point out on a smaller scale than what is discussed more specifically in the second cycle that all Christians who repent and follow Christ will receive Christ’s reward and those “Christians” who compromise and follow the world are part of the corrupting influence of the world that destroy Christians and will receive the judgment of the world.

The chapter break is poor. It should end with the breaking of the seventh seal in 8:1, and silence, which is likely to represent the original creation account where God rests on the seventh day.

Friday, March 1, 2019

Biblical Theology LI: 2 Timothy


The Second Epistle to Timothy is a work that depicts the Apostle Paul writing again to Timothy as a personal letter of encouragement to remain faithful in the ministry. 


Theology: What will ultimately counter destructive false teaching is the proclamation of the Scriptures. Unlike the heretical view that experiential and cultural traditions and stories are a source of truth, Timothy is to uphold Scripture as the source for truth that is breathed out by God (3:16). Hence, it is not to be questioned with human reasoning and argument, but rather human reasoning and argument must be questioned by it (2:14-19). Paul, therefore, continually contrasts teachers who do not get their teaching from God’s Scriptures and the apostles with Timothy who has gotten his teaching from those sources (e.g., 3:13-17).


Ethics: Ministry is a hard job. It will sometimes be encouraging and other times being discouraging. There will be people who support you, people who hate you, people who try to undermine you in secret, and people who oppose you openly. There will be people who don’t hear what you teach and continue to do the things you preach against without even knowing it, and others who will continue on and disregard what is said even when they fully understand. They will set their feelings, religious sentiments and traditions above the Scripture and apostolic teaching (4:3). Some will be your cheerleaders and others your jeerleaders. And people who at first love you can quickly become your haters when you teach things they hate. It is important for ministers to recognize that the life of ministry is the life of Christ, specifically His earthly ministry, played out again and again through His servants. There is always a triumphal entry to be followed by lots of hard teaching from the Word of God that ultimately leads to God making disciples and enemies of Christ. And there is always a crucifixion to be carried out at the end of that path. Always (3:12). Ministry is ultimately the road to Calvary. 

As such, Timothy finds it hard to proclaim the Word of God in the midst of so much opposition and pressure, and Paul encourages him that he must do this if God’s people are to be made complete and the heretics and apostates are to be pushed back. Paul himself is an example of this. Here he is at the end, the apostle who gave up so much and loved so much of the church, abandoned by all but a few. Just like Christ in His hour of death, the majority Paul served have run off. Only a few remain after a long faithful life of ministry. In the face of Christ’s hardship, Timothy must stay the course and teach the Scripture anyway. When it is easy and when it is hard. When people are open to it and when they are not (4:2). He must rebuke people he wants to like him and so risk their hatred of him instead because this is what a minister does. He is a picture of Christ in his teaching, faithfulness, love, suffering, etc. as Paul is (3:10-11), as all who seek to live according to the godliness of Scripture are (v. 12).


What Paul wishes to convey to Timothy, then, is that the faithful preaching and teaching from the Word of God, the admonishing of believers from it when they are in error or sin, is not just one style of ministry among others. It is the only ethical choice in choosing what kind of ministry a minister will employ. It alone is what a faithful ministry looks like because God has uniquely designed the Scripture to disciple His people in the community of the church, to equip the man of God for every good work. It alone has the knowledge that leads to salvation, not human experience or cultural religious ideas gained from commonly believed worldviews. By lifting Scripture up the man of God lifts God up high upon His throne, and calls all of His people to bow down and worship Him by bowing to His revealed will. If Timothy is to be faithful in ministry, then, he must rekindle the fire of his gift to instruct in God’s Word with boldness, love, and sober-mindedness without being ashamed and afraid to say anything (1:6-8). He must protect the apostolic teaching given to him by teaching it to others who will then teach it as well (1:13-14; 2:2).

Wednesday, February 27, 2019

Arguments against Making Images of Christ

http://www.alliancenet.org/christward/the-second-commandment-westminster-and-images-of-jesus

http://solareformed.blogspot.com/2012/03/2nd-commandment-and-pictures-of-jesus.html

https://protestantreformed.wordpress.com/2016/04/10/images-of-christ-and-the-violation-of-the-second-commandment/


John Murray on Images of Christ

The question of the propriety of pictorial representations of the Saviour is one that merits examination. It must be granted that the worship of Christ is central in our holy faith, and the thought of the Saviour must in every instance be accompanied with that reverence which belongs to his worship. We cannot think of him without the apprehension of the majesty that is his. If we do not entertain the sense of his majesty, then we are guilty of impiety and we dishonor him.

It will also be granted that the only purpose that could properly be served by a pictorial representation is that it would convey to us some thought or lesson representing him, consonant with truth and promotive of worship. Hence the question is inescapable: is a pictorial representation a legitimate way of conveying truth regarding him and of contributing to the worship which this truth should evoke?

We are all aware of the influence exerted on the mind and heart by pictures. Pictures are powerful media of communication. How suggestive they are for good or for evil and all the more so when accompanied by the comment of the spoken or written word! It is futile, therefore, to deny the influence exerted upon mind and heart by a picture of Christ. And if such is legitimate, the influence exerted should be one constraining to worship and adoration. To claim any lower aim as that served by a picture of the Saviour would be contradiction of the place which he must occupy in thought, affection, and honour.

The plea for the propriety of pictures of Christ is based on the fact that he was truly man, that he had a human body, that he was visible in his human nature to the physical senses, and that a picture assists us to take in the stupendous reality of his incarnation, in a word, that he was made in the likeness of men and was found in fashion as a man.

Our Lord had a true body. He could have been photographed. A portrait could have been made of him and, if a good portrait, it would have reproduced his likeness.

Without doubt the disciples in the days of his flesh had a vivid mental image of Jesus' appearance and they could not but have retained that recollection to the end of their days. They could never have entertained the thought of him as he had sojourned with them without something of that mental image and they could not have entertained it without adoration and worship. The very features which they remembered would have been part and parcel of their conception of him and reminiscent of what he had been to them in his humiliation and in the glory of his resurrection appearance. Much more might be said regarding the significance for the disciples of Jesus' physical features.
Jesus is also glorified in the body and that body is visible. It will also become visible to us at his glorious appearing "he will be seen the second time without sin by those who look for him unto salvation" (Hebrews 9:28).

What then are we to say of pictures of Christ? First of all, it must be said that we have no data whatsoever on the basis of which to make a pictorial representation; we have no descriptions of his physical features which would enable even the most accomplished artist to make an approximate portrait. In view of the profound influence exerted by a picture, especially on the minds of young people, we should perceive the peril involved in a portrayal for which there is no warrant, a portrayal which is the creation of pure imagination. It may help to point up the folly to ask: what would be the reaction of a disciple, who had actually seen the Lord in the days of his flesh, to a portrait which would be the work of imagination on the part of one who had never seen the Saviour? We can readily detect what his recoil would be.

No impression we have of Jesus should be created without the proper revelatory data, and every impression, every thought, should evoke worship. Hence, since we possess no revelatory data for a picture or portrait in the proper sense of the term, we are precluded from making one or using any that have been made.

Secondly, pictures of Christ are in principle a violation of the second commandment. A picture of Christ, if it serves any useful purpose, must evoke some thought or feeling respecting him and, in view of what he is, this thought or feeling will be worshipful. We cannot avoid making the picture a medium of worship. But since the materials for this medium of worship are not derived from the only revelation we possess respecting Jesus, namely, Scripture, the worship is constrained by a creation of the human mind that has no revelatory warrant. This is will worship. For the principle of the second commandment is that we are to worship God only in ways prescribed and authorized by him. It is a grievous sin to have worship constrained by a human figment, and that is what a picture of the Saviour involves.

Thirdly, the second commandment forbids bowing down to an image or likeness of anything in heaven above, or in the earth beneath, or that is in the water under the earth. A picture of the Saviour purports to be a representation or likeness of him who is now in heaven or, at least, of him when he sojourned upon the earth. It is plainly forbidden, therefore, to bow down in worship before such a representation or likeness. This exposes the iniquity involved in the practice of exhibiting pictorial representations of the Saviour in places of worship. When we worship before a picture of our Lord, whether it be in the form of a mural, or on canvas, or in stained glass, we are doing what the second commandment expressly forbids. This is rendered all the more apparent when we bear in mind that the only reason why a picture of him should be exhibited in a place is the supposition that it contributes to the worship of him who is our Lord. The practice only demonstrates how insensitive we readily become to the commandments of God and to the inroads of idolatry. May the Churches of Christ be awake to the deceptive expedients by which the archenemy ever seeks to corrupt the worship of the Saviour.

In summary, what is at stake in this question is the unique place which Jesus Christ as the God-man occupies in our faith and worship and the unique place which the Scripture occupies as the only revelation, the only medium of communication, respecting him whom we worship as Lord and Saviour. The incarnate Word and the written Word are correlative. We dare not use other media of impression or of sentiment but those of his institution and prescription. Every thought and impression of him should evoke worship. We worship him with the Father and the Holy Spirit, one God. To use a likeness of Christ as an aid to worship is forbidden by the second commandment as much in his case as in that of the Father and Spirit.

The Difference between Reformed and Lutheran Perspectives on the Use of Icons in Ecclesiastical Architecture

I find that, in the debate over the use of icons, when it comes to Lutheran and Reformed arguments, the two groups are speaking past one another.

First, some Reformed folk often speak of the Lutheran veneration of images and use the second commandment to argue against it. Lutherans do not view themselves as venerating images, but instead using images didactically, i.e., to remind, inspire, teach about the story or idea that the image represents. No one, at least no one who understands Lutheran theology, is worshiping or venerating the images.

Second, Lutherans often counter by saying that many images are used in the Old Testament, but this is a bit of a straw man fallacy, as the Reformed are not arguing against the use of any image, or at least they shouldn't be, but against images of God and Christ.

Third, Lutherans often think that the entire debate is centered around whether they worship or venerate the images; but this is not the issue. The issue is whether the Bible prohibits the act of representing God or Christ with an image, regardless of whether the image is being used as an object or vehicle of worship or veneration. Hence, Lutherans tend to think that if they can show the second commandment is about worshiping through an idol, or about other gods, etc. then they have won the debate and their Reformed counterparts simply need to study more.

The problem is that the Sinai Theology in Exodus and Deuteronomy indicate that God does not want to be represented by an image at all, for any reason, and so prohibits the making of an image that would represent Him. The contrast in the texts are not between a rightly used image and a wrongly used image, but between image and word. For instance, in Deuteronomy 4:12-20, YHWH instructs His people to make no image of Him because they saw no image of Him on Sinai. Since He did not reveal Himself in an image, but through what was spoken, they are to pay extra close attention to what He has spoken, i.e., what He did reveal on Sinai.

Then the Lord spoke to you out of the midst of the fire. You heard the sound of words, but saw no form; there was only a voice. And he declared to you his covenant, which he commanded you to perform, that is, the Ten Commandments, and he wrote them on two tablets of stone. And the Lord commanded me at that time to teach you statutes and rules, that you might do them in the land that you are going over to possess. “Therefore watch yourselves very carefully. Since you saw no form on the day that the Lord spoke to you at Horeb out of the midst of the fire, beware lest you act corruptly by making a carved image for yourselves, in the form of any figure, the likeness of male or female,  the likeness of any animal that is on the earth, the likeness of any winged bird that flies in the air, the likeness of anything that creeps on the ground, the likeness of any fish that is in the water under the earth.  
And beware lest you raise your eyes to heaven, and when you see the sun and the moon and the stars, all the host of heaven, you be drawn away and bow down to them and serve them, things that the Lord your God has allotted to all the peoples under the whole heaven. But the Lord has taken you and brought you out of the iron furnace, out of Egypt, to be a people of his own inheritance, as you are this day.

One might argue that the additional warning about worshiping other gods means that the entire prohibition is just about other gods, but this ignores the context. The additional warning is just that: additional. The original command is connected to the fact that they saw no form of God and so must represent Him by what He has spoken, and not by what is seen.

This is a continuation of the larger Sinai Theology that one sees in Exodus 32. A golden calf is made, not representing other gods, but representing YHWH. Hence, Aaron says that it is the God who brought them out of Egypt, and the following day, therefore, will be a feast to YHWH.

This is in the context that contrasts Moses receiving the written law on tablets with the Israelite desire to have a physical image that represents God. Note that the physical image is not meant to look like God. No one thought YHWH was a young bull anymore than they thought Baal was a young bull (a symbol that often represented him). It was simply meant to teach about YHWH (the bull represents the strength with which YHWH delivered them out of Egypt and the fertility of the land that flows with milk and honey into which He was bringing them). It is a fitting image for YHWH. No one thought that it was YHWH, only that it represented Him. In other words, this image, as all images in the ancient Near Eastern world, is constructed for didactic purposes and for veneration.

So the issue is whether God only had a problem with the use of the image for veneration, but not a problem with the didactic use. Because of the contrast between the word as God's representative and the image as represenatative in Sinai Theology, it seems clear that God has a problem with the physical image representing Him for any reason, i.e., with it being created at all. This is why there simply is no "right use" of any image of God found in Scripture.

Some Lutherans will acknowledge this when it comes to God (as do the Eastern Orthodox), but not when it comes to Christ, since, in line with the Seventh Ecumenical Council, the incarnation means that God has now expressed Himself through a physical form. Unlike the council, however, Lutherans do not conclude what logically follows from that idea, i.e., that one can worship Christ through the image and venerate it. Either way, the idea that the incarnation changes things is an argument made by the Eastern theologians like John of Damascus.

It is clearly a prohibition against representing the invisible God.  But when you see Him who has no body become man for you, then you will make representations of His human aspect.  When the Invisible, having clothed Himself in the flesh, become visible, then represent the likeness of Him who has appeared.  When He who, having been the consubstantial Image of the Father, emptied Himself by taking the form of a servant, thus becoming bound in quantity and quality, having taken on the carnal image, then paint and make visible to everyone Him who desired to become visible (in Ouspensky 1978:44).

The problem with this idea is that John's Gospel adopts the Sinai Theology and applies it to Christ. His adoption of it is seen clearly in John 4, where He argues to the woman at the well that God is not worshiped through a physical representation, like a temple or hill, but through Spirit and Truth, i.e., the unseen Person of the Trinity creating through what God has spoken. John then applies this to Christ when Christ declares that it is actually beneficial that He goes away, so that the Spirit of Truth comes to the disciples and reveals all things to them, reminds them of Christ's words, convicts, etc. Until then, the disciples see Christ, but not really. Only after He leaves will they really see/comprehend Him. Hence, the physical is a hindrance, not a help to following Christ. This is why it is said to Thomas that those who do not see and believe are blessed. Hence, Christ is called the "Word," He alone has words of eternal life, the words He speaks are Spirit and life, to abide in His word is to abide in Him and Him to abide in His disciples, etc. 

John argues this because the apostles are dying off. He is likely the last one. He wants to convey that no physical presence of the apostles is necessary to worship and know Christ because Christ's physical presence is not necessary, and even a hindrance because it causes one to think he sees and follows Christ by following Him physically. To truly follow Christ is to abide in His words. This is the truth of the Sinai Theology that negates the idea that because Christ is now incarnate representing Him as a teaching aid is somehow helpful rather than a hindrance that would be prohibited.

It should be said that all scholars agree (how could they not) that no images of Christ or God were ever used in the first couple centuries of the Christian church. It was not until the church had become more Greco-Roman than Jewish that images of Christ that began to resemble the gods like Zeus were created to replace the images of the Empire's former paganism.

The issue of debate, therefore, is not over whether one venerates the image, but whether God has a problem with the making of divine images for any reason at all. In this regard, I find the usual path of argumentation from both sides to be off course.



We have taught that the knowledge of God, otherwise quite clearly set forth in the system of the universe and in all creatures, is nonetheless more intimately and also more vividly revealed in his Word (John Calvin, Institutes 1.10.1).

Q 96. What is God's will for us in the second commandment.
A. That we in no way make any image of God nor worship him in any other way than has been commanded in God's Word.
Q 97. May we then not make any image at all?
A. God cannot and may not be visibly portrayed in any way. Although creatures may be portrayed, yet God forbids making or having such images if one's intention is to worship them or to serve God through them.
Q 98. But may not images be permitted in churches in place of books for the unlearned?
A. No, we should not try to be wiser than God. God wants the Christian community instructed by the living preaching of his Word—not by idols that cannot even talk. (Heidelberg Catechism)


Tuesday, February 26, 2019

The Sin of God in Fundamentalist Ethics

If placing something in someone's presence that can be a huge temptation to them is wrong, then God is the biggest sinner in the history of sinners for placing the tree of the knowledge of good and evil in the garden, knowing full well that the man and woman would be tempted by it. Indeed, everything we are tempted with has been created by Him and placed near us, i.e., made accessible to us, by Him.

In biblical ethics, however, there is no sin in the matter. Placing a created thing that can become a temptation in someone's presence is not a sin, but instead must be seen as a good. The difference is that God does not tempt Adam and Eve with it. The serpent does that. God merely creates the good thing and makes it accessible to the man and woman, but the devil distorts its use and tempts with it. Hence, the world of created things and people is a world of good things placed in our presence that only our corrupt nature and the wicked around us use to tempt us for evil. The things themselves are not tempting, nor the situations in which they are placed. The problem is us, not what is created or where it is placed.

Notes on Revelation 2-5

The letters of Revelation, often treated as though they are less interesting than the vivid imagery of future things, are actually the key to understanding the purpose of the book. John is writing to argue that a true Christian is one who values Christ above all other things, even his own life. As such, those who value Christ more than all else are encouraged to continue on in their work, since it will result in the reception of all of the promises of God's new creation and victory; and those who do not are told to repent lest they are cast out and partake of the damnation of the devil, beast, and false prophet.

Along these lines, John desires to communicate that there are three groups in the world: professing believers who are truly saved, the non-professing world that is damned, and professing believers who are not truly saved. Each is known by its faith and works together (as is a common theme in the Synoptics and General Epistles).

The seven churches likely represent the whole church, and not just the specific churches that are being addressed in the chapters. This is confirmed by the fact that each letter to a specific church ends with the statement, "He who has an ear to hear, he better listen to what the Spirit says to the churches (plural)." These churches, therefore, merely stand as representative of the entire church.

All of them are encouraged to continue in those things that are faithful to Christ. All but two (Smyrna and Philadelphia) are encouraged to repent where they are not faithful.

An inclusio is created from what is said to the first church, Ephesus, and the last church, Laodicea, where those in Ephesus were compromising by not having Christ as their primary love, i.e., choosing Him above all other things, and those in Laodicea who were doing the same by not choosing Christ over other things, but instead mixing their "love" of Christ with their love of a rich and comfortable lifestyle. In other words, Christ is not valued above all other things. He is not their "first" or "preeminent love." This then gives the framework for the rest of the letters. The real problem of theological and ethical compromise is not merely in actions, but in not loving and valuing Christ, not choosing Him, above all other things with the result that one loves his or her life and the things the world offers to that temporary life, more than Christ.

Hence, with this rejection of Christ is the warning that those who do not repent will not inherit the promises of the new creation. They do not do so because inheritance has to do with unification with Christ (i.e., taking upon oneself His name) and one who professes Christ while denying Him through either his compromised worship and activity does not take upon His name, i.e., is not united to Him, and thus, is not saved.

The eating things sacrificed to idols and sexual immorality is stock New Testament language that utilizes the figure of speech called synecdoche (a part represents the whole). Eating meat sacrificed to idols refers to pagan worship, i.e., the worship of other gods/theology of another religion. Hence, it represents pagan ideas concerning who God is, what is true, etc. In that regard, we might just summarize it as bad theology, false doctrine. Likewise, the practice of sexual immorality refers to a distortion of the creational activity of the image of God that undergirds all biblical ethics. As such, it stands at the head of all ethical understanding, and represents bad, chaotic, anticreational ethics. It is why the Gentiles are told in Acts 15 that, although they do not need to worry about practicing the rituals of the law that are mere pictures of holiness and have been fulfilled in Christ, they do need to observe biblical theology and ethics, i.e., abstaining from pagan worship and sexual immorality.

This is the book's concern. Christians are being pressured by the world to compromise in their theology and ethics by partaking in the worship and practices of the Roman world. This will culminate in the description of worshiping the beast and his image.

But John's point will be that one is made to be a priest of the kingdom today, a martyr/witness in one's life, not just in one's death. One who gives his life for Christ by being executed is one who has been giving his life for Christ all the while before it. This is what it means to be a victor (nikon) in life as a Christian. To the victor is given the spoils, and John's point is that only those who are victors will be given them.

Thus, after the rebuke and exhoration of the letters, John moves on to give the heavenly vision of God and Christ as the only Ones worthy of being worshiped and followed, the only Ones who should be valued above all other things. God the Father, who is described as having the beauty of precious jewels and halos of light, who is worshiped by angels and all of the patriarchs of the Old and New Testament, hands His scroll over to the Son, who alone is worthy to open it. It contains the power of rule and judgment upon the world that also saves His people from the oppression of the world. He is also said to have achieved victory via His death. He is described both as a lamb that is slain and the Lion of Judah who has a crown of seven horns (i.e., complete rule and authority), displaying that His path to life, victory, and rule was suffering and death, as He now calls His people to follow.