Saturday, February 9, 2019

Biblical Theology L: 1 Timothy


The First Letter to Timothy is the first of a series of letters designated often as “The Pastorals.” A better designation for them might be the “Ecclesiological Epistles,” since they seek to set the church in order in terms of its positions and practices. The purpose is stated in 3:14–15: “I write these things to you in case I am delayed, to let you know how everyone must live in the household of God, because it is the church of the living God, the pillar and support of the truth.” Chapters 1–3 lay out a right theology of ordering the church and Chapters 4-6 lay out a right practice in ordering the church.

Theology: Paul presents the church as a household, specifically the household of God (3:15). It is “a pillar and stay for the truth.” The household is the place of nurture for the children that trains them up to adulthood and provides sanctuary from destructive forces outside. In this regard, rightly ordering the household of God is an act of love and care for the people of God (1:5). It protects them from heretics who, like the serpent of old, attempt to penetrate the sanctuary/household and destroy the people of God inside (1:3–10, 18–20; 6:20–21). Rightly ordering and honoring the household and those who head it up through position and example will allow it to function in the role of a healthy household that grows its children in the truth and goodness of Christianity, which is the purpose for which God created the church.   

If it is to function this way, however, it must be ordered according to God’s creative purposes. This means that men must take upon themselves the position of leadership and not abandon the women, who are created not for fatherhood, but for motherhood, to take the responsibility for which God has made the men. They are to lead as fathers lead their households in prayer (2:1–8) and the instruction of godliness (2:11–15). 

Women are to be examples of faithful mothers who are committed to godliness rather than being flirtatious, inviting vanity, as well as sexual corruption and inappropriateness into the household (2:9–10; 5:). Nor are they to disorder the household by seeking roles of teaching and authority over other men, since they have not been made to be the leaders in the household from the beginning of creation. Disorder invites the devil into the household as it did in the garden. Hence, men are to become mature in their faith and alone are allowed to seek the role of the elders, who function as spiritual fathers, over the church (3:1–7). The deacons and women who serve function as older brothers and sisters who aid the elders in carrying out physical responsibilities within the church over the other children (3:8–13).

Ethics: The tendency is for people to fall into apostasy by believing false teaching, lies, myths, etc. in order to justify wayward living, and many will do so (4:1–10). The remedy for this is for leaders to live in a manner worthy of Christ and to publically read Scripture, teach it and exhort believers with it (vv. 11–16).

As a right ordered household (5:1–2), fathers and mothers must be honored through financial support when they are in need (5:3–21). People who qualify are only those who have no other support and are serving, or have served, the church faithfully. Widows receive “honor” (v. 3), which refers to that which takes care of all of their financial needs. Elders are to receive “double honor” (v. 17), which refers to a financial amount that totals to twice the amount of their needs. Financial blessing is not to be given to anyone in sin, lest whoever gives it partake in their sin (v. 20–22).

He warns Timothy that if leaders care more about getting more money, they will bring in false teaching that flatters rather than that which nurtures and protects believers. This will destroy them. Timothy, therefore, is to exhort everyone to be content with what they have and not to desire riches which is the root of all sorts of evil, and leads to the destruction of the faith (6:2–10). 

He ends by exhorting all believers who are well-off to share with those who are not, so that all of the Christians in the church grow together as a caring family. In this way, their savings account will be eternal life (11–19).

Thursday, February 7, 2019

The Gospel according to the Three LIttle Pigs and Its Modern Adaptation

I was watching the Disney version of the Three Little Pigs the other day with my kids. It had been since I was a kid when I last saw it. Something dawned on me about the Disney version in comparison to the original, as it reflects the modern evangelical view of the gospel quite well. I say "original" to refer to the earliest book including pigs (the same story appears with pixies and bunnies in variation).

Everyone knows the story. The first two pigs build houses out of perishable material that disinigrates when the wolf comes and blows it in. The last pig builds his house out of sturdy material that will last the onslaught of the wolf's fierce gale. 

Both the original story and the modern Disney one are the same at this point. What is different in each is what happens to the pigs.  

Now, at this point, it probably important to point out what the building of the houses means. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to know that the houses represent what one does in life, i.e., what he builds his life out of by what he does with this time. 

The first two little pigs spend their time on their pleasures in the Disney version to represent this fact. The original story is more implicit with the analogy.  The last pig spends his time working while being intentional about building his house out of the material that is going to endure. 

There are political interpretations and applications of the story, but the imagery itself seems to come from the Bible. Two ideas in the Bible seem present: The idea of building one's house on the rock rather than sand in order to endure the storms to come, and the idea that one should build his house (i.e., doctrines of the faith and living) out of enduring material rather than wood, hay and straw.

The perishable material seems to be taken from 1 Corinthians 4, but the idea of wind that knocks a house down and moral of the story from Matthew 7. 

Matthew 7 argues that one should not merely claim to have Christ as his Lord, but that one only truly has Christ as his Lord when he lives according to Christ's teaching in the Sermon on the Mount in Matthew 5-7. In other words, if one lives accordingly, then when the storms, i.e., judgment comes, his life will stand in terms of being a witness to the fact that Christ was His Lord during life. His claim is true, he may enter eternal life with Christ. However, if he has lived according to lawlessness, i.e., his own religious ideas instead of Christ's commands, this is building on human ideas which are sand and the storm, i.e., judgment, will come and show his claim to have Christ as his Lord to be false. He will receive the words of Christ, "Depart from Me, I never knew you, You who practice lawlessness, i.e., live according to your own human ideas/morals." 

Understanding this principle, the original Three Little Pigs relates that when the two little pigs who built their houses out of perishable material have their houses blown in by the wolf, he eats them. They die horrible deaths. The story parallels Matthew 7, where people who claim to be Christians do not live as Christians, and thus, show themselves to be of the world and destined to receive the damnation of the world.

The modern Disney version, however, looks very different. The first two little pigs live according to their pleasures in disregard of any judgment to come, and when their houses are blown in, they simply end up running into the third pig's house and all survive because of it.

There are a couple different directions I could take with that idea. One is that some think they can ignore Christ and will somehow be saved by virtue of their being associated with people who do live for Christ, as though salvation is through association. The other, however, is the way that evangelicals treat the gospel and talk about grace. 

Since Jesus built His house out of brick, i.e., lived a life of obedience to God, I can live my life in whatever manner I please and still be saved because Jesus is my Savior. He's got a brick house so I can build mine out of straw or furze. I have no need to be inentional about living for God since Jesus did it for me. 

This is where a misunderstanding of justication and sanctification come in. Most evangelicals think that Christians don't need to do good works and refrain from evil because that would be legalism and we're saved by grace. Hence, Jesus' brick house ensures that I have no need to be loving toward God, wise in the world, and follow Him by obeying His commandments.  

Christians obeying Christ by living out Christ's commands as evidence of their unification/salvation with Christ, however, is exactly what Matthew 7 is talking about. It isn't talking about Christ's active obedience that covers Christians in justification. It's distinguishing between true and false Christians, those who follow Christ and truly have Him as their Lord and those who only say that they do and live according to their own moral laws, traditional or mixed between traditional/cultural and biblical while setting other biblical teachings and morals aside. 

In Matthew 7, and the original Three Little Pigs, those who do not live out their lives by making choices for that which is eternal over temporary will perish. In the new version, living out such wisdom is optional. Jesus saves me with His house of bricks either way. 

In this regard, the modern Three Little Pigs is a deadly lie. It comforts the ungodly and assures them of their salvation when there is none. It cries out, "But this is the temple of God, the temple of God, the temple of God!" with the pre-exilic Judahites who trust in the promises of God given to those who repent and obey Him, even though they neither repent nor obey Him (Jeremiah 7:1-15). 

The original story actually continues after the wolf fails to blow in the last pigs house, as even the pig who built his house out of brick must continue to live wisely, aware of the judgment/death/wolf that seeks to destroy him. In the end, he ends up eating the very wolf that desired to eat him (perhaps a fitting metaphor for Christians overcoming the judgment of eternal death in resurrection--i.e., devouring that which once attempted to devour them during their lives).

Evangelicals continue to repeat their mantras, "We're saved by grace, by grace, by grace," even though grace and the promises of God are still for those who repent and have Jesus Christ as their Lord by seeking to obey Him in all things. When they fail, they continue to repent by ceasing to do evil and learning to do good. This house built out of the stuff that Christ commands is evidence that one has been actually building his room in Christ's house, under His Lordship, and if he has done so, though the waves crash down, the winds howl, and the wolves blow, his house will remain forever.

Do not be deceived: God cannot be mocked. A man reaps what he sows. Whoever sows to please their flesh, from the flesh will reap destruction; whoever sows to please the Spirit, from the Spirit will reap eternal life. (Gal 6:7-8)

Saturday, February 2, 2019

Biblical Theology XLIX: 2 Thessalonians

 The Second Letter to the Thessalonians was written to readdress the same issues Paul had addressed in the first letter. The issues had gotten worse rather than better. Persecution had gotten worse, there were some arguing that the judgment of Christ had already come and the Thessalonians had missed it, and some were living undisciplined and had ceased working, perhaps, because they believed they were in a new era. The letter is brief since Paul already addressed these issues previously.The letter is organized into three sections, each ending in a prayer.


Theology: The wicked who are persecuting the Thessalonians may have the upper hand now, but when Christ returns He is going to destroy all of them. Paul relates the divine warrior concept seen throughout the Old Testament to Christ.

God sends a deception upon everyone who does not receive a love of the truth of the gospel. Hence, His judgment begins now by giving the wicked over to believing their lies, and is a sign and seal of the judgment to come. If one is given over to deception now, it means that he or she will be destroyed when the Lord Jesus comes.

Paul wants to inform the Thessalonians that, despite what others may be arguing, the day of the Lord, i.e., His coming and judgment of the world, has not yet taken place. As mentioned before, His judgment is taking place now in the sense that He is giving people over to their deceptions, but the final judgment has not yet come. The only way to make this argument, of course, is by arguing that the judgment is spiritual and the second coming is likewise a spiritual event. This type of thing was likely argued by Greeks who had a tendency toward Platonism and proto-gnosticism that taught that the coming of Christ, the resurrection, and the judgment was a spiritual event. It is easy to see, then, that this spiritual event may have already passed the Thessalonians by. Paul argues, however, that the Lord will destroy all of their persecutors with fire when He appears visibly, that a great apostasy will happen first, and that the man of lawlessness must first appear. 

The man of lawlessness concept comes from Antiochus IV who is spoken of in Daniel. Paul uses some of that imagery here when he refers to him exalting himself above every god and seating himself in the temple, i.e., desolating it. This is likely a political figure who will attempt to subvert the religion of God’s people, the church, as Antiochus IV attempted to subvert the religion of Judaism in the second century B. C. Since the man of lawlessness exalts himself above every god, he does so above Christ, and probably even claims to be Christ, since the temple here likely refers to the church and not the literal temple in Jerusalem. The church that testifies that this figure is the true Christ is actually the false prophet that has apostasized against the apostolic teaching concerning Christ. This is the same concept found in Revelation, where the beast is the political/religious figure (i.e., the Emperor Domitian) is the one who exalts himself above all gods and the false church, i.e., false prophet, gets the world to follow him instead of the true Christ.

Ethics: Since Christ will destroy their persecutors, the Thessalonians display their worthiness of the kingdom to come by persevering in their love of one another and faith in the truth the apostles proclaimed to them. God has chosen them to suffer and their perseverance through it is evidence of God’s just judgment to make them worthy of the kingdom. Hence, salvation is through sanctification in the spirit and much of that sanctification is being produced by their sufferings.

Since the Lord is coming in judgment of the wicked, however, the Thessalonians should make every effort to both be disciplined in their daily lives, working for their livelihood, and to practice a form of church discipline on those who are living unruly lives and gossiping/meddling in other people's affairs. However, full discipline is not enacted in such cases, since Christians are to consider these people as fellow Christians still, unlike those put out of the church and are to be considered pagans by the Lord in Matthew 18.

Paul is encouraged by their love for one another, their strong faith in apostolic teaching given to them, and their growth in Christ even in the face of such adversity.

Wednesday, January 30, 2019

Saturday, January 26, 2019

Biblical Theology XLVIII: 1 Thessalonians


Paul writes his first letter to the Thessalonians because he is concerned that their hearing of his persecutions/sufferings might cause them to turn away from the faith. The bulk of the letter is actually personal. Only in Chapters 4 and 5 does Paul give instructions in theology and ethics that go beyond what they already know or are doing.

Theology: Paul divides the letter up between faith, love, and hope in that order (1:3). He first encourages them in their strong faith that led them to turn from idols to a living God (1:9-10), and to endure severe persecution/suffering, becoming a model for all the saints everywhere (1:7-8). Paul conveys his love for them in Chapters 2 and 3, and then remarks that they know they are to love the brethren (4:9), but instructs them further to let that love be expressed in the obedience of Paul’s instructions to live in sexual purity with one another. Finally, Paul further solidifies their hope by explaining that even those who have died have not perished, but will return with Christ in the resurrection (4:13-18). 

He encourages them to live in a manner worthy of Christ, knowing that Christ’s return is not known, nor does it need to be known, by those who live according to the world to come, and not in accordance with this world (5:1-11). Those who live according to the thought and life patterns of this world now will perish, but God has not appoint His people for wrath, so He pushes them to live in light of the world to come in holiness so that they do not perish as the world. He finishes this with an inclusio started in 1:3 by saying, “But since we belong to the day, let us be sober, putting on faith and love as a breastplate, and the hope of salvation as a helmet” (5:8).

Paul ends the letter in a blessing upon them that the Lord would purify/make them holy completely in body, spirit, and soul (5:23-24). Hence, sanctification is tied, not only to the inward man, but to the body, as the Christian looks forward in hope to the resurrection at the coming of the Lord.

Ethics: The faith, hope, and love of the Thessalonians is what has produced their continued work and perseverance in the faith (1:3). Hence, they have not given up the faith, but have continued to grow stronger. Paul informs them of what an encouragement they have been to him and now wishes to encourage them in the fact that they have done so well in their repenting from false theology and living out a godly life. He encourages them, however, to go even further, to keep growing, and not to think they merely have arrived (4:1-8). 

He warns them to be careful to continue in their sanctification, specifically to refrain from sexual immorality and the defrauding of a brother or sister when it comes to sexuality. This could refer to avoiding adultery, where a brother or sister are defrauded by another believer stealing his or her spouse, or it could refer to defiling a fellow brother or sister by engaging in sexual activity with them when he or she is not married to them. Either way, Christians are not to take the rights with other Christians that only their spouses would have with them, nor are they to defile other Christians by taking advantage of them in a sexual way because God will be the avenger of these Christians (4:6). The word “avenger” here refers to God as the One who will issue the death penalty upon a person. Paul is basically saying that God will damn the one who does it, so it is a much harsher warning than many realize. He ends by saying that anyone who does not heed this warning is not rejecting human opinion, but God (v. 8).

Paul further expresses his encouragement that they love other believers, but urges them to go even further as a witness to outsiders by leading a quiet life and working if they are able so that they are not in need (vv. 9-12). In other words, they have their theology and ethics in place, but now they are to set their lives in order by being disciplined even more than they are already for the sake of the gospel.

Paul ends with various ethical instructions that should flow from their faith, love, and hope. They are to “mind those who labor among you, preside over you, and rebuke you,” and that they are to be held in “high esteem” (5:12-13). They are to not be at odds with one another (v. 13), rejoicing, always praying, and giving thanks (vv. 16-18), not grieving the spirit or ignoring God’s revelation to them (vv. 19-20). He sums up by saying they are to stay away from all forms of evil.

Assurance of Salvation in the First Epistle of John

One often hears that the assurance of salvation is based on assurance itself. This is a rather odd concept. It simply is not found in Scripture. I think it might be taken from Hebrews 11:1, where the definition of faith there is "the assurance of things hoped for, the conviction of things not seen." Of course, Auctor is arguing that these Jewish Christians need to keep their faith that God will give them what was promised in the future Sabbath and resurrection to come. This should help them from being tempted from apostasy. However, he is not giving a full definition of faith in Christ. It is partial in that it is dealing specifically with the issue of doubt leading to abandonment of Christianity.

Never are they told here that they can have assurance they are saved because they have faith, however; and they are certainly not told that they can have assurance by being sure of God's promises. The Judahites about to be punished in exile were sure of God's promises. That's why they ignored Jeremiah. They were so sure that God's grace for them would save them, they didn't feel the need to listen to the message of repentance this judgmental radical was preaching to them.

Lutherans talk about assurance based on their baptism. Again, where is this in Scripture? Luther argued that baptism was an objective means by which God assured an individual that his promises were for him; but how exactly does baptism do this unless no one who is baptized is ever damned? Was the BTK killer a baptized Lutheran? Can he rest in his baptism? Baptism may be a good sign, perhaps, a better sign than any a pagan has, but it cannot say one way or another whether someone is saved.

Scripturally speaking, the New Testament tells Christians how they can know that they are saved. First John argues that there are four things that let the Christian know, and therefore, have assurance, that he is saved.

The first is whether he is repentant of his sins, rather than continuing on in his sins. John argues that if, and only if, we confess our sins, Christ will cleanse us from all unrighteousness. Anyone who refuses to live in the truth and be honest with his sins so that he confesses them, is not saved and should have no assurance therefore (1:5-10; 3:6, 9; 5:18). "No one who is born of God will continue to sin, because God’s seed remains in them; they cannot go on sinning, because they have been born of God" (3:9).

The second is whether someone keeps his commandments and lives as Jesus in holiness (2:3-6). He purifies himself in anticipation of Christ's return, desiring to be like Christ, not just then, but now (2:28-3:3). The one who does what is right is righteous (3:7, 10). "We know that we have come to know him if we keep his commands" (2:3).

The third indicator that one is saved or not is whether he believes the apostolic/orthodox teaching concerning who Christ is (2:18-25; 4:1-4). This may be broadened to understand the Person of Christ representing all core apostolic theology concerning God, Christ, the gospel, etc. If one believes orthodoxy, it is one of the indicators, when accompanied by the others, that he is saved. If one does not, he should have no confidence that he is saved. "No one who denies the Son has the Father; whoever acknowledges the Son has the Father also" (2:23).

The fourth indicator is whether one loves God by loving other Christians (2:9-11; 3:10-18; 4:7-21; 5:2-4). Love is expressed in two ways in John. First, it is giving resources to a Christian in need (3:16-18). Second, it is praying for his repentance when he is in sin (5:14-18). "This is how we know who the children of God are and who the children of the devil are: Anyone who does not do what is right is not God’s child, nor is anyone who does not love his fellow Christian" (3:10). "We know that we have crossed over from death to life because we love our fellow Christians. The one who does not love remains in death (v. 14).

All of these are put together by John to form a visible basis for assurance that goes beyond mere wishful thinking and false assurance. John has written these things down so that "you may know that you have eternal life" (5:13). If one believes apostolic orthodoxy, loves God by keeping God's instructions, repents when he fails to do so, and loves his fellow Christians by seeking his physical and spiritual restoration with whatever means he has, he may know with full assurance that he knows God, has come out of darkness into light, has become a child of God, and has eternal life.