Scott McKnight posted a blog entry by Alexandra Greenley that argues that John's elect lady is a pastor. Let's explore the reasons why this is the worst possible interpretation of this phrase given what we know about 2 John's context.
1. The woman is never called a pastor or elder, or talked about as one performing the job of a pastor/elder.
2. Johannine theology sees the church as a woman who is elected by God. The phrase likely refers to the church to which he is writing, and the children the individual members of the church. Evidence of this is the fact that he ends the letter by saying that the "children of your elect sister greet you" (v. 13), referring to the church at which he resides currently.
3. All evidence points to the fact that there were multiple elders in the earliest church, not one single pastor, so it makes little sense for John to be writing to one and not acknowledging the others.
4. One must believe that the Bible is errant, and that John contradicts the Pauline prohibition concerning women in authoritative and teaching roles over men.
5. John moves in and out of the singular and plural even though he is talking to the same lady and her children throughout, evidencing that he is really addressing a group of people, and not one pastor/elder.
6. He also doesn't name her, which would be hightly unusual for an epistle addressed to an actual person. The personal address is to make sure the letter gets to the right place, but is also commonstance. John employs it in the very next letter we have from him when writing to Gaius (3 John 1:1). The absence likely indicates that the term kyria "lady" is being used metaphorically.
In Greenley's interpretation, one must suppose that this is a literal woman by ingnoring all of the above, and then supplying the word "pastor" as the meaning of the word "elect" and proper referent of the children as spiritual children over which she resides. In other words, speculation trumps what is there in her interpretation, and thus, it is the worst possible interpretation to take out of these two offered.
I will agree with Greenley in her comments that this is some of the best evidence we have of women in leadership in the time of the New Testament--which is to say that there is none.
Saturday, September 15, 2018
Biblical Theology XXXVI: Matthew
The unique material in Matthew, along with his use of other synoptic material, evidences that Matthew is arguing against a Jewish-Gentile conflict within the church, where certain Jewish leaders who have become Christians are incorporating Jesus into rabbinical Judaism’s interpretation of Old Testament religion as heavily ritualistic, and Gentiles are arguing for a complete abandonment of the teachings of the Hebrew Bible, and using Jesus as a means to live as they please. This has created a rift where Jewish leaders are using their positions to shun Gentiles and any other Jewish-Christians who fellowship with them. Matthew argues for both a rejection of these two false interpretations of Christianity and a reconciliation of all who would claim to belong to Christ. Jew and Gentile alike. Hence, Matthew’s argument solely concerns those within the covenant community.
Theology: Only the apostles have the right to interpret Christianity, and therefore, all other interpreters with contradictory interpretations concerning who Jesus is, what He did, and what He required of His followers are false prophets. Hence, rabbinical and antinomian interpretations of Christianity are false religions, and not merely different ways to practice Christianity.
Since Christ is the King of the Kingdom,, He determines who is a true follower, and His criteria concerns whether or not someone actual lives according to what He has taught. Since He is the true Israel, all who are truly His followers belong to Israel. Everyone who constructs a different Christianity that ignores the love of other covenant members by following the law, either by emphasizing ritual and deemphasizing the moral law by placing rituals over actions toward others, as rabbinic Judaism had done, or merely sets aside what was moral because he sees Christianity as a different religion than that established by God in the Hebrew Bible, as the antinomians were arguing, have rejected Christ as Lord by rejecting the apostles as His divinely ordained interpreters, and are thus, rejected as false Christians.
God has every right to save Gentiles as Gentiles, and not to require them to become Jewish in their customs, even if those customs were confirmed in the law. What God does require of everyone, however, is that they obey the moral law to the fullest expression possible because these are the righteous deeds of Christ’s reign. Any other practice is not of the kingdom because it is not of the King.
Ethics: Jesus relates that how one treats his fellow covenant member evidences whether he will truly be saved in the end. If he hates his brother, refuses to reconcile with him, and slanders him instead, he breaks the law prohibiting murder, and is thus damned to the Gehenna of fire. If he desires someone other than his spouse, or divorces his wife, or marries one who is divorced, he breaks the law prohibiting adultery, and is therefore damned to the Gehenna of fire. If he breaks an oath made before God, he lifts up YHWH’s name in vain. If he does not take care of his parents financially, he does not honor his father and mother. If he does not care for fellow covenant members, he rejects the law that commands him to do so. If he does not restore his relationships with other covenant community members, he will not be restored to God in eternity either.
Ultimately, those who do not repent of these sins by seeking to do otherwise do not have Jesus as Lord, and therefore, have no basis to claim the promise of the eternal kingdom spoken about by the prophets as that which is offered under the reign of the Messiah. Only those who obey the King will remain in the kingdom forever.
All of this makes up what Jesus calls the “will of the Father,” and those who hear His teachings on it, but don’t actually do what He teaches, are considered “lawless” fools who build their houses on sand. They are told to depart from Him into everlasting punishment. Those who do what He says, however, are His true disciples. They are called the righteous who are good and faithful servants, and build their houses on the rock (i.e., the teachings of Jesus). Any true teacher will serve Jesus and His people by teaching these, and disciplining over them, and not use his authority for his own honor/respectability. Hence, the idea of the servant leader is repeated throughout the book, as well as the contrast of those who seek their own honor by annulling Christ’s teaching and teaching his own version of what Christian practice within the kingdom/church should look like.
Friday, September 7, 2018
Biblical Theology XXXV: Malachi
The Book of Malachi is written sometime after the temple is rebuilt in the post-exilic era, and life and worship has resumed as ordinary, and has even become stale. The designation, “Malachi” means “My Messenger/Angel.” The book is structured on a series of accusations made by God that are then questioned by the accused (1:2, 6, 7, 12-13; 2:13-14, 17; 3:7, 8, 13).
Theology: The message of the prophet is, again, described as a burden given to the prophet (1:1).
God’s love is defined by His choosing Jacob’s descendants over Esau’s in terms of saving the one and not the other (1:1-5). What this means is that love and hate have to do with choosing to save one over another, and to destroy the enemy of the one who is loved. Hence, God argues that, in destroying Edom, He has shown love toward Israel. Love is placing a higher priority on one’s life over another, so as to save the one and destroy his destroyers. Ergo, to love Jacob and to hate Esau is to save Jacob from Esau by destroying Esau who would do harm to him. Hence, God says, “I turned Esau’s mountains into a deserted wasteland and gave his territory to the wild jackals” (v. 3).
Yet, the Book of Malachi argues that this love was not returned as it should have been. The Lord was not chosen over the people’s sins.
As a result of Israel’s evil, God will send His messenger to cleanse His temple and His people, so that proper worship is restored once the people fear and honor God by seeking His purposes, and not their own, for their marriages and lives in general (3:1-5).
God will send Elijah, the prophet of warning, before the judgment, indicating that God will offer salvation through repentance first before He destroys the wicked among His covenant community (4:4-6).
Ethics: Yet, the Book of Malachi argues that this love was not returned as it should have been. The Lord was not chosen over the people’s other desires.
1. They show hatred for God by choosing to offer substandard forms of worship to Him because they do not honor and fear Him as the Great King. Their sacrifices are leftovers and they blend what is holy with what is common (1:6-14).
2. The priests show hatred for God by not teaching the whole Scripture to the people and by not observing it themselves. Hence, they cause the people to be in violation of the law because they are picking and choosing out of it what they wish to teach. As a result God will curse the priesthood, rather than bless it, and cause the people to ignore the priests and think of them as a joke (2:1-9).
3. The people show hatred for God by committing sins of idolatry and then give to Him worship as the leftovers of their lives. They do this by worshiping a foreign god, which Malachi argues is not necessarily done literally by bowing down to another god, but by divorcing one’s believing wife and marrying an unbeliever—hence, betraying the covenant made with God to bring up godly offspring, i.e., to fulfill the role of the image in Genesis and fill the earth with His covenant people. Hence, their divorcing their spouses and wasting their seed with unbelievers was anti-creational.
You also do this: You cover the altar of the Lord with tears as you weep and groan, because He no longer pays any attention to the offering nor accepts it favorably from you. Yet you ask, “Why?” The Lord testifies against you on behalf of the wife of your youth, to whom you have become unfaithful even though she is your companion and wife by law. Has He not made them one? And the rest of the creative activity belongs to Him. And for what reason did He make them one? Because He was seeking the offspring of God. Guard your own creative activity then. Hence, one should not be disloyal to the wife he took in his youth. “I hate divorce,” says the Lord God of Israel, “and the one who covers his garments with chaos,” says the Lord who rules over all. “Pay attention to your conscience, and do not be unfaithful.” (2:13-16)
To top it all off, they argue that those who do this evil are perfectly acceptable in the eyes of the Lord and that He has not condemnation for them (2:17).
4. They show their hatred for God in other ways that they do not fear and honor God—i.e., getting revelation through omens, committing adultery, breaking promises, mistreating workers, widows, and orphans, and refusing to help the Gentile worshipers of God among them who are in need (3:5),
5. They show their hatred for God by not making it a priority to give to His ministry, and God calls them to repent of it if His promises are to be restored to them (3:6-12).
6. They show their hatred for God by envying the wicked because of their successes in the immediate, and look selfishly at the worship of God as being that which robs them of a better life. Hence, their idolatry is the worldly man or woman’s better life, and they choose to love that, i.e., prefer that, over fearing and honoring God by following His commands instead (3:13-16).
As in all the prophets, Malachi records those who repent of all of this, and the promises of God are given to them that those who serve Him by obeying His laws will be spared from the coming wrath of the day of judgment, and be fully restored, but the wicked who do not repent will be burned up like chaff (3:16-4:3).
Sunday, September 2, 2018
Biblical Theology XXXIV: Zechariah
The Book of Zechariah begins with eight visions given only a few months later than Haggai, and is a vision of the new temple and Jerusalem that will encompass the entire world, connecting it to the Book of Haggai’s end vision of the same. Together with Ezekiel, the Book of Zechariah has the distinction of being a semi-prophetic/semi-apocalyptic book. It establishes the stewardship of the position of high priest until the Branch of David comes (6:9-15).
Theology: The Book asks the question, “How long until You have compassion on Judah and the other cities of Judah with which You have been angry for these 70 years?” This is another indication that the exile is not over until the promises of God are fulfilled and the rule of Israel is over all of the earth.
The answer comes in the form conveying God’s intention to do far more than just rebuilding Jerusalem (1:16-17). The Book of Zechariah argues, however, that all of the temporary restorations are symbols of the larger restoration of creation to come. God will expand the borders of Jerusalem to encompass the entire world, so that the people of all nations will be a part of Israel/God’s people. “Sing out and be happy, Zion my daughter! For look, I have come; I will settle in your midst,” says the Lord. “Many nations will join themselves to the Lord on the day of salvation, and they will also be my people. Indeed, I will settle in the midst of you all.” Then you will know that the Lord who rules over all has sent me to you. The Lord will take possession of Judah as his portion in the holy land and he will choose Jerusalem once again. Be silent in the Lord’s presence, all people everywhere, for he is being moved to action in his holy dwelling place.” (2:10-13; also see 8:19-9:10).
The Book argues, therefore, that what is needed until that time is a high priest that stands before the Lord so that the Israel of today can be preserved into the Israel of tomorrow. Without a high priest, Israel cannot survive one minute due to the fact that the Adversary stands always to accuse it of its sins (Chap 3). These are set in contrast to false prophets who are viewed as wicked shepherds looking to deceive the people for profit (Chap 13).
Likewise, Israel’s empire will not come through political or military power, but by the Spirit of God, represented by the menorah and the witnesses of peace He will bring about this vision (4:6). But the wicked of all the nations will be set against God’s people and He will destroy them and redeem His people through the death of the Davidic King (Chaps. 12-13). Before the Davidic King stands victorious on the Mount of Olives, God will send half of Jerusalem back into exile and only redeem the remnant by destroying the nations that attack them, establishing everlasting peace for this eschatological Jerusalem (14:1-11) that expands over the whole earth. The Book ends by arguing that the whole world will observe the Feast of Booths, a memorial feast that commemorates the time in the wilderness journey. The last statement of the book is that there will no longer be any Canaanite, i.e., pagan, in the house of the Lord. They have been all either converted or removed.
Ethics: God must overlook the iniquity of the high priests he installs over His people, so that they can mediate for them. Hence, He strips Joshua of his dirty clothes and puts clean ones upon him instead. Ultimately, this must look forward to the basis for doing this for every high priest, which would be a High Priest who has no sin and removes sin from the people, including all other high priests, so God says that these sinful high priests are only a symbol for the Branch of David who will function as this High Priest (3:8). Through Him, the iniquity of God’s people will be removed in a single day (3:9).
4:10, which is usually taken out of context, “For who dares make light of small beginnings?” actually refers to these rudimentary symbols of the new creation/kingdom to come. An application would be that the work of the church today that does not seem very impressive represents in a very small and imperfect way the world to come.
Whoever does evil, however, and does not obey God’s law will be removed from the community of God to come (5:1-4) and exiled (5-11) as God had exiled Israel for the same before (7:11-14). In contrast, the people who belong to God’s true Israel are those who seek the Lord and do good rather than evil to one another, including taking care of those who are in need within the community (7:1-10). Hence, to be a part of the future kingdom, one must truly worship YHWH by acting like a member of that future kingdom today (8:14-18).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)