Saturday, September 17, 2016

Preterist Time References, Part XII

Crushing Satan Underfoot 

There are a few verses left that are largely taken out of context. For instance, Romans 16:20 says, "the God of peace will soon crush Satan under your feet." The context is not the eschaton, but overcoming false teachers at Rome. The heretics are referred to as their source, i.e., Satan, and the God who brings shalom to His community will soon give victory to the faithful over these heretics. There is no mention of the end times. That is simply being assumed because of the use of Genesis 3:15, as though it were Christ crushing the serpent. Paul is clearly using this as his framework, but he applies it in way of application to this smaller victory of the saints over Satan's minions. It is simply eisegetical to insert some sort of time reference to the end of the age here.


The Antinomians under the Judgment of Christ's Final Victory

Jude 1:4, 14-15 states: . “For certain persons have crept in unnoticed, those who were long beforehand marked out for this condemnation. …About these also Enoch…prophesied, saying, 'Behold, the Lord came with many thousands of His holy ones, to execute judgment upon all, and to convict all the ungodly…'”

Now, notice the way Preterists chop this passage up. The question is whether this is talking about these specific men only, or these type of men, the group that makes up false believers, of which these First Century men are a part. The context makes it clear that this is a type of men that make up the group considered to be false believers. That is why the references are to OT false believers. These men are a part of that group. But none of that is quoted in order to make it seem like this verse is only talking about these men and not the larger group of which they are a part. 

It is the same thing here as we have in many places in the Bible and elsewhere, where the contemporary wicked will be placed in the larger context of those who have been predetermined for destruction. 

Jesus does the same thing with the Pharisees. "Rightly did Isaiah prophecy of you . . ." But it is clear that the prophecy in Isaiah is of disobedient and unbelieving Israelites in his own day. How can Jesus say that it is about the Pharisees? Because they are a part of the larger group that is being condemned. It is simply absurd to suggest that Jude is talking only about these specific false believers and no other false believers in other churches, throughout time, etc. And the partial quotation that leaves out that fact seems to indicate that the Preterist who quotes the passage this way knows it must be edited to give credence to his interpretation. The same can be said for 2 Peter 2:3, and any time a general judgment is associated with a people, whether for damnation or salvation. We speak to the part as partaking in the judgment of the whole. That is simply a common way of speaking for all languages throughout time.


The Way into the Holy Place
Hebrews is often taken out of context more than any other book, with the exception of Revelation perhaps. In Hebrews 9:8-10, Preterists argue that the temple still stands as a symbol that the old covenant still remains. Hence, the old covenant is still in effect until it is destroyed and that is in A.D. 70. The texts states:

“The Holy Spirit is signifying this, that the way of the [heavenly] Holy Places has not yet been revealed, while the outer tabernacle is still standing, which is a symbol for the present time. Accordingly both gifts and sacrifices are offered which cannot make the worshiper perfect in conscience, since they relate only to food and drink and various washings, regulations for the body imposed until a time of reformation.”

The problem is that Auctor nowhere talks about the temple. He does not even use the word once. He makes no reference to it at all. What Auctor is talking about is what the tabernacle IN THE PENTATEUCH symbolizes to the Israelites in the Pentateuch. He is arguing that the tent of meeting is a symbol for the old covenant because he wants to show the temporal nature of that covenant communicated through rituals, which then also were meant to be temporary.

We know this because, not only does he not refer to the temple (and the temple is never referred to in Hebrews as the tabernacle--they are two different structures), but also because he describes the tabernacle he is talking about, and guess what? That tabernacle has the ark of the covenant in it (v. 4). That is a dead give away that he is talking about the tabernacle in the Pentateuch, as the ark is lost after the exile, and the Second Temple does not have contain it. If someone wants to take issue with that and argue that they have a replica inside, he mentions that the ark has Aaron's rod and the two tablets of stone carved out by Moses in it. He is simply not talking about the Second Temple. These passages are completely taken out of context.

Now, when the New Testament authors relate a larger narrative they can often use the present tense to describe the narrative in a more vivid fashion ("it has [present aspect] the golden pot and Aaron's budded rod" v. 4), in order to place the audience back into the context of the story. Storytellers today do the same thing. This may be deceiving to the English reader sometimes when one does not realize the practice of storytelling is being utilized. But it is also clear that most authors are not consistent and will go back to narrative tenses. In 9:1, Auctor does just that. Notice that he speaks of this as something in the past.

"The first covenant had (imperfect) regulations . . ."

"There had been (aorist passive) a tabernacle . . ."

The point is simply that Auctor is arguing the old covenant has already passed away at the cross. It is no longer valid in God's eyes in his own day. All of the tabernacle passed away, and thus, all that it symbolizes (i.e., the ritual expression of teaching the law) is displayed as temporal as well. The passage, and the book, is simply being ripped out of context to make it refer to the Second Temple.

The translation that states it is a symbol for the present time is a bit misunderstood as well. Auctor is actually saying that it is a symbol for them, the ancient Israelites. He states.

This was a symbol for the time then present, when gifts and sacrifices were offered that could not perfect the conscience of the worshiper. They served only for matters of food and drink and various washings; they are external regulations imposed until the new order came. (9:9-10)

There are two ways one can understand the verse. It can be translated as "this had been a parable for the contemporary time period," i.e., the current time of which the Auctor is speaking; or it can be understood as referring to the tabernacle in the Pentateuch serving as a parable of the old covenant up to the present. Either way, the temporary nature of the tabernacle symbolizes the temporary nature of the ritual communication of the holiness of the law, i.e., as said before, the old covenant is the manner in which the moral law is communicated and its external versus internal nature, not the moral law itself, which is now written on the hearts/minds of God's people. The tabernacle signifies this in the Pentateuch to the people, and it frankly can continue to symbolize the temporal nature of the first covenant to the Auctor, his audience, and to us, a couple thousand of years later. That is because it exists both for Auctor and us in the text of the Torah, not literally standing in Jerusalem.

So what this passage does not mean is that the tabernacle is still standing in the form of the temple in Auctor's day. That is not to what Auctor is referring. He is immersed in the Pentateuch and attempting to take his audience there. This passage, then, also is taken out of context, and in order to get a temple out of a tabernacle one simply has to change the context and ignore what Auctor is actually saying.


The Antichrist Is Already in the World
John indicates that the antichrist is already in the world. It is suggested that the antichrist marks the time of the end. This may or may not be true, but we will adopt it's truth for the sake of argument.

Preterists will often quote this passage: “This is that of the antichrist, of which you have heard that it is coming, and now it is already in the world" (1 John 4:3).

In context, however, John, in his typical already-not yet fashion, sees the antichrist as already come through the spirits of false prophets that have gone out into the world. Specifically, he is speaking of the alternate christs offered up by the proto-gnostics. So through these people, who have the same spirit as antichrist, the antichrist has already come--not because he is already here, but because those who typify him are.

John states:  "Who is the liar but the person who denies that Jesus is the Christ? This one is the antichrist: the person who denies the Father and the Son" (2:22). 

Notice, the person who denies that Jesus is the Christ, what some proto-gnostics were doing by divorcing the Christ Logos/Aeon from the human Jesus, is the antichrist. 

In 4:1-3, John makes it clear that he is talking about the spirit of antichrist that has gone out to many false prophets in the world. In fact, in 2:18, John flat out says that he is talking about these many antichrists (plural) that have already gone out (same terminology used of the spirit of antichrist in the false prophets) into the world. It is the spirit of the antichrist (4:3) in these false prophets that displays the presence of the antichrist in the present. Again, this is just another text taken out of context.

Putting the Prophets to Death
Another passage taken out of context is Revelation 18:24: "And in her [the Great City Babylon] was found the blood of prophets and of saints and of all who have been slain on the earth." 

This is then compared to texts like Matthew 23:35-36 // Luke 11:50-51, where the Lord sent them messengers and prophets who they persecuted and killed.

Woe to you! You build 147 the tombs of the prophets whom your ancestors 148  killed. So you testify that you approve of the deeds of your ancestors, because they killed the prophets and you build their tombs! For this reason also the wisdom of God said, ‘I will send them prophets and apostles, some of whom they will kill and persecute,’ so that this generation may be held accountable for the blood of all the prophets that has been shed since the beginning of the world, from the blood of Abel to the blood of Zechariah, who was killed between the altar and the sanctuary.  Yes, I tell you, it will be charged against this generation. (Luke 11:47-51).

Notice first that the quote that God will send them prophets and messengers is a prediction made in the past. The generation is only being charged for the blood shed from Abel to Zechariah, not for the deaths of the New Testament apostles and prophets, so apostles and prophets here do not refer to New Testament apostles and prophets. They refer to the apostoloi/mal'akim "messengers" and prophets sent to Israel in the Old Testament. 

Revelation, however, is not referring to these people, as is made clear by who they are in the book. These are the prophets, apostles, and saints of the New Testament who overcome the beast, i.e., Domitian, by the blood of the lamb and the word of their testimony (6:9-11; 7:14; 12:11; 18:20). 

In 20:4, we see that these people are New Testament believers, not anyone who was executed between the times of Abel and Zechariah.

Then I saw thrones and seated on them were those who had been given authority to judge. I also saw the souls of those who had been beheaded because of the testimony about Jesus and because of the word of God. These had not worshiped the beast or his image and had refused to receive his mark on their forehead or hand. They came to life and reigned with Christ for a thousand years. 

Notice that these people are beheaded because they would not worship the beast and his image, i.e., Domitian, and because of their testimony about Jesus and the gospel. Notice also that the nation killing them is Rome. The Roman Emperor Domitian executed people for treason and to not worship him or his image was treason against Rome and the gods. Notice also the manner of execution. It is not stoning or most of the ways the prophets are said to have died (e.g., sawed in half, thrown off of cliffs, stoned to death, stabbed, etc.). Instead, they are beheaded, which is the most common manner of execution for Roman citizens. They would likely crucify Jews, and Jews stone others to death, even though they are not officially allowed to execute anyone at the time, but this death is by beheading by the one who Paul describes in Romans as not "having the sword for nothing." The sword is a synecdoche for the death it causes via beheading. 

So this is not Israel killing Old Testament prophets and messengers. It is Rome executing New Testament Christians, who live long after Zechariah, for the treason against gods and man that exists in not worshiping its emperor, Domitian. The cross references, therefore, are deceptive in that two different contexts with different characters involved are at play. The Preterist who uses this passage as a proof text has simply failed to note this.

The Coming of Christ in the Apocalypse of John
Revelation 2:25 is quoted as a reference to Christ's return in A.D. 70. "Nevertheless what you have, hold fast until I come.” 

The problem with this interpretation is that Christ's coming in context is not about the destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70, but encouraging believers to remain faithful under the pressure of the beast to worship him and his image. If they are faithful, they will receive the reward of confirmation that they are Christ's true people. If they are not, they will have their lampstands removed from His presence.

"Therefore, remember from what high state you have fallen and repent! Do the deeds you did at the first; if not, I will come to you and remove your lampstand from its place – that is, if you do not repent" (2:5).

This text, and the book itself, is all about encouraging Christians to remain faithful. Christ's future judgment of the world and the false church is seen as something that breaks into history before the time, where Christ comes now to judge His church and keep it pure. Hence, this coming is merely one of Christ's methods of receiving His purified kingdom/bride. It is not the macro coming, which is future, but a micro coming which is present with the believers in the First Century. Hence, He is coming to them (2:5, 16, 21-23; 3:3, 19-20).

So this is Christ coming to His churches and disciplining them. He is viewed as both coming and having already come and judged some churches/people; but this is not talking about the final judgment and coming of Christ, which the book depicts as something still to come after His people have overcome the world by His blood and their testimony, when the total destruction of the world's kingdoms takes place. 

Friday, September 16, 2016

Preterist Time References, Part XI

One of the arguments that Preterists often give is that the apostles seem to believe that Christ was returning in their lifetime.

Paul states that the "time is short" and that the form of this world is passing away" (1 Cor 7:29, 31) and that Christ will give "us" rest when He returns with His holy angels and burns up his adversaries.

For it is right for God to repay with affliction those who afflict you, and to you who are being afflicted to give rest together with us when the Lord Jesus is revealed from heaven with his mighty angels. With flaming fire he will mete out punishment on those who do not know God and do not obey the gospel of our Lord Jesus. They will undergo the penalty of eternal destruction, away from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his strength, when he comes to be glorified among his saints and admired on that day among all who have believed – and you did in fact believe our testimony. (2 Thes 1:6-10)
And I say this, brothers and sisters:  The time is short. So then those who have wives should be as those who have none, those with tears like those not weeping, those who rejoice like those not rejoicing, those who buy like those without possessions, those who use the world as though they were not using it to the full. For the present shape of this world is passing away. (1 Cor 7:29-31)
The apostles simply speak to believers in a way that these events (Christ's return, resurrection from the dead, transformation of their bodies, destruction of the wicked, etc.) will be happening to them. Peter does the same as he speaks of sharing in this glory that is to be revealed when Christ returns and rewards the believers to whom he is speaking (1 Pet 5:1-4).
Now, what Preterists will say is that Paul includes himself in this rescuing, and therefore, believes that the Lord will come back in his lifetime. Yet, Paul is martyred by Nero before the Lord is said to return in A.D. 70. Peter. The problem. of course, immediately emerges that if Peter and Paul are dead, then they are not going to be around for Christ's return, nor be relieved and given rest from the enemies through the event, since they are not a part of the event in A.D. 70.
If it is true that these apostles believe that the Lord will come back within their lifetimes, then everyone, including Preterists, must conclude that they are wrong. Paul is wrong. Christ does not return to deal out fire on his enemies and give to him relief from persecution. Peter is wrong, since Christ does not return in his lifetime.
But there is more than this to consider, and that is the nature of what the apostles believe is going to happen. In 1 Corinthians 7:29-31, notice what Paul says of this age to come. He is arguing to the Corinthians that they might want to think twice about getting married since the time is short and those who are married will soon be as those who are not. The present world that is passing away includes the marriage institution. It also includes buying things, weeping, and rejoicing about the things of the present world. Did all of that end in A.D. 70? Did commerce end in A.D. 70? Did having joy and sorrow about situations that arise in the world end in A.D. 70? Did the form of this world pass away in A.D. 70 because God knocked down a city in the Middle East? Paul's entire point is about marriage. He is arguing that one needs to consider the brevity of time until those who are married will no longer be married. As Christ argued as well, the age to come is one in which resurrected saints do not marry (Luke 20:35), something that would cause a problem if marriage was restored once a person's body was restored, and the one flesh union made in that body was reestablished, as the Sadducees point out.
One might argue that marriage and buying ends in Jerusalem at that time, but why is Paul arguing that the Corinthians in Corinth might not want to get married because the time is short and marriage is going to come to an end? Paul's argument would make no sense. If marriage ends in Jerusalem, it certainly doesn't end in Corinth, or any other city to which believers could move if they want to get married. 
Furthermore, the enemies upon which Christ deals out a fiery destruction are in Thessalonica, not Jerusalem. And, as discussed before, Paul is relieved from their persecution by death, not Christ's return. 
This is not even to mention the fact that the apostles believe the coming of Christ will do away with death, sin, sorrow, the wicked and their kingdoms, and bring about a resurrection of the dead for both the righteous and the wicked. None of this happens in A.D. 70. 
So are the apostles wrong? This is a possibility, since we believe that the Scripture is inspired to instruct Christians, not in timelines, but in theology and ethics. 
In fact, we know that the apostles do not know when Christ is returning because Christ Himself repeats to them twice that no one knows when He is returning in terms of the macro event, nor does it belong to them to know.
In Acts 1:6-7, the apostles ask when He will restore the kingdom to Israel. He replies that such knowledge does not belong to them, but is solely the Father's prerogative to know such things. This is reminiscent of His response to the apostles' question in the Olivet Discourse concerning the macro event. He relates to them the micro event and says that it will happen within some of their lifetimes, but the timing of the macro event is said to only be known by the Father. Not even the Son knows it, so obviously, Jesus could not be revealing when it was occurring. Hence, the timing of Christ's return is not something God gives to men.
But there is another interesting possibility, and that is that what is given to men, even commanded of them, is to look forward to Christ's return. In other words, the expectation of Christ's return is something the New Testament considers important. So important, for that matter, that it provides the basis for our sanctification. In fact, it seems that the New Testament authors believe it to be a necessary element in motivating believers to purify themselves.
Jesus places it as the basis for treating one's fellow Christians well in Matthew (24:42-51). In Mark's version, one reads the common theme found in all of the Synoptics.
“But as for that day or hour no one knows it – neither the angels in heaven, nor the Son– except the Father. Watch out! Stay alert!  For you do not know when the time will come. It is like a man going on a journey. He left his house and put his slaves in charge, assigning to each his work, and commanded the doorkeeper to stay alert. Stay alert, then, because you do not know when the owner of the house will return – whether during evening, at midnight, when the rooster crows, or at dawn – or else he might findyou asleep when he returns suddenly. What I say to you I say to everyone: Stay alert!” (Mark 13:32-37)
The ignorance of when He is coming plays into the command to stay alert. If one knew the timing of the event, one would merely be tempted to doze off until that time. So looking forward to His coming, and not knowing when He is coming, plays a vital role in staying alert, something God considered necessary for Christians to have in terms of motivating them toward sanctification.
Likewise, John places it as the basis for sanctification in both his epistles and apocalypse. He states of Christ's return,
And now, little children, remain in him, so that when he appears we may have confidence and not shrink away from him in shame when he comes back. If you know that he is righteous, you also know that everyone who practices righteousness has been fathered by him. (See what sort of love the Father has given to us: that we should be called God’s children– and indeed we are! For this reason the world does not know us: because it did not know him. Dear friends, we are God’s children now, but what we will be has not yet become visible. We know that whenever He is made visible we will be like him, because we will see him just as he is. And everyone who has this hope focused on him purifies/sanctifies himself, just as Jesus is pure). (1 John 2:28-3:3)
Indeed, Paul seems very aware that he is going to die. The prophet Agabus tells him news that leads Paul to declare that he might die in the Book of Acts (21:10-14) , and he indicates this in 2 Timothy 4:6-8. Peter also indicates this (2 Pet 1:12-15) referencing the Johannine scene about which we have discussed before.
So the apostles know that they are going to die. Yet, they include themselves in the "we," "us," etc. when speaking of something that will happen to other Christians. This is a type of speech that is quite common. The "we" does not necessarily refer to the literal group (i.e., I and you together), but to the representative group. In other words, the "we" and "us" can refer to Christians in general, apostles in general, those who preach the gospel in general, Christians who are alive rather than dead in general, etc. 
This is true for any small part of a group that represents the whole in a synecdoche. The part represents the whole, and sometimes the part even represents others in the group. This means that the apostles, both in terms of relating he necessity of looking forward to Christ's return for sanctification, and in terms of speaking to all Christians for all time, can use language that describes a participation in events, or here, an event, in which they will not literally partake.
Hence, Paul can say of Christ's return and the resurrection, 
We will not all sleep, 30  but we will all be changed – 15:52 in a moment, in the blinking 31  of an eye, at the last trumpet. For the trumpet will sound, and the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed. 15:53 For this perishable body must put on the imperishable, and this mortal body must put on immortality. 15:54 Now when this perishable puts on the imperishable, and this mortal puts on immortality, then the saying that is written will happen,
“Death has been swallowed up in victory.” 32 
15:55 “Where, O death, is your victory?
Where, O death, is your sting?” 33 
15:56 The sting of death is sin, and the power of sin is the law. 15:57 But thanks be to God,who gives us the victory through our Lord Jesus Christ! 15:58 So then, dear brothers and sisters, 34  be firm. Do not be moved! Always be outstanding in the work of the Lord, knowingthat your labor is not in vain in the Lord.
Notice that this passage relates both the necessity in looking forward to Christ's return and the resurrection of this mortal body for purposes of sanctification, and it relates Paul as being one of those people who is alive at the time it occurs, using representational language. If the "we" and "this mortal body" putting on immortality while alive were literal then Paul was simply mistaken, as he died before this event took place in everyone's eschatological scheme, Preterist or otherwise.
Instead, these verses make up what is likely God's desire to communicate imminence to all Christians in the First Century, but knowing that looking forward to Christ's return is a necessary motivation for Christians in general, has the apostles use language that can apply to every generation of believers. After all, God did not simply wish to sanctify the first generation of believers by continually reminding them of imminent Christ's return, but somehow did not see the necessity of giving that same motivation to the following generations.
So one is given two options with these passages. Either the apostles are wrong about Christ's return because they did not know when He would, as the Bible indicates, or they are using language that includes believers (themselves and other Christians who would not see the return of Christ) as representative of all believers who are looking forward to the event. 
I personally think that the real answer exists in combining these two. In other words, it is since the apostles did not know when Christ would return, they were free to use language that included every believer of their day, even if they did not believe everyone would live until His coming (e.g., Paul and Peter). And God, who is the One who inspires the text, gears it this way so that the text will cause all Christians everywhere throughout time to look forward to Christ's return as a central motivation for their sanctification. 
But Preterist proof texts they are not. The nature of the event negates that idea, the fact that the apostles saying it do not live to see A.D. 70 negate that idea, and neither the language nor the nature of inspiration, frankly, demands such an interpretation.  
All of these remaining verses fall under this category:

“…we who are alive, and remain until the coming of the Lord… …We who are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds… …You, brethren, are not in darkness, that the Day should overtake you like a thief.” (1 Thes 4:15, 17; 5:4).

“May your spirit and soul and body be preserved complete, without blame at the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.” (5:23).


“I charge you …that you keep the commandment without stain or reproach until the appearing of our Lord Jesus Christ.” (1 Tim 6:14
) 

“But the day of the Lord will come like a thief, in which the heavens will pass away with a roar and the elements will be destroyed with intense heat, and the earth and its works will be burned up. Since all these things are to be destroyed in this way, what sort of people ought you to be in holy conduct and godliness, looking for and hastening the coming of the day of God.” (2 Pet 3:10-12)