I want to jump in with a time indicator that is actually not used by Preterists, but often explained away; and that is the millennium. I've been able to track down two main views within full preterism. In one view, the thousand year reign of Christ begins in A.D. 30, which is guessed to be when Christ was crucified, resurrected, and ascended.
In this view, the thousand years represents forty years, and merely represents a transitional time period between the old heavens and earth and the new heavens and earth.
The idea that it is a transitional period of time is held by all views of the millenium, and most views, with the exception of more literal readings, would espouse the idea that it is a figurative period of time.
The idea that it is a smaller period of time is, of course, something that goes against the grain of John's use of the number in the book, as the number always refers to something greater than itself, and indeed, likely conveys vastness rather than completeness, as Beale would suggest.
In the premillennial preterist view, the millennium begins at A.D. 70 and extends to an indefinite period, perhaps, even forever.
In both of these views, the problem exists in a couple things that are said about the millennium. In the view that holds its duration from A.D. 30-70, there seems to be little acknowledgement concerning who enters the millennium and reigns with Christ for a thousand years.
What saints were beheaded for not worshiping the beast and his image in A.D. 30? Furthermore, what saints, who were beheaded for not worshiping the beast and his image in A.D. 30 were resurrected in A.D. 30 from that martyrdom?
One might be able to argue that these saints just catch the very end of the millennium when Nero puts Christians to death in the late sixties, but there are numerous problems to this.
1. This all occurs in Revelation after the destruction of the Great City and the beast is thrown into the lake of fire in Chapters 18-19 (19:1 meta tauta "after these things" indicates a sequence and the Satan's bondage for a thousand years and then release, where he is ultimately thrown in where the beast and false prophet are already indicates that the thousand years is subsequent to the destruction of the city and the judgment of the beast). Not only is the city of Jerusalem destroyed in A.D. 70, not before, but after the demise of Nero, but Nero dies two years before. If all of this is before the resurrection of the saints in A.D. 70, and the millennium ends in A.D. 70, then how exactly are these saints entering into it with Christ for a thousand years?
2. Nero never persecutes Christians for not worshiping at the emperor cult, but instead, for burning the city, the crime for which he falsely condemned them. Domitian is the one who puts Christians to death for not worshiping him.
3. These saints are first resurrected and then enter into this thousand year reign with Christ, but in the preterist paradigm the resurrection does not occur until A.D. 70 when the millennium actually came to an end. So not only are these resurrected saints not reigning with Christ for the entire period, they are not reigning with him, as resurrected saints, during the thousand years at all.
4. This resurrection cannot refer to their regeneration or something that happens spiritually in their lives, since they have already been executed because of their overcoming the beast by not worshiping him, were put to death because of their faithfulness, and are now resurrected. In other words, they were already regenerated Christians who passed the test and did not love their lives even to death. They remained faithful to their testimony of Jesus. Hence, this must refer to something other than their regeneration or some spiritual empowerment during their lives.
The premillennial preterist view attempts to get past all of this by denying that the millennium is the forty year period from 30-70. For the premillennial preterist view, there are still remaining problems.
1. This resurrection is related to their physical deaths, as those who have been beheaded for their faith. These faithful believers are already in heaven, not in some paradisal dungeon in Hades, as is often suggested (6:9-11; 7:9-17; 13:6; 19:14). The physical resurrection is related to their physical deaths/being beheaded. It is from this being beheaded that they come to life and reign with Christ for a thousand years, for the transitional period.
2. If the millennium is a transitional period between the old heavens and earth and the new heavens and earth, then the old heavens and earth did not pass away in A.D. 70 and the new did not come in A.D. 70, since the time of transition is still here.
3. The book clearly indicates the millennium as a time of transition between the old and new cosmos, which preterists understand as covenants. Yet, the judgment of Satan, all nations from the four corners of the earth who attack Christ and His people, and the establishment of the new cosmos occurs after the millennium is over, not when it begins. This is made clear by the book: kai hotan telesthe ta chilia ete "and when the thousand years has ended." This is why most preterists have held the millennium to be the forty year period between 30-70, which, as seen above, is not plausible either.
Ultimately, the best play for a preterist is to argue that there is no millennium and transitional period, which then would take these symbols as not representing any literal historic thing at all. I would tend toward that view, but would also say that this is inconsistent with the preterist hermeneutic of Revelation which is to attempt to find literal historical events in the symbols. They could also argue that all of the time indicators in the language of Revelation are just a way of presenting the data and not to be taken literally, something I would also suggest to a degree; but again, this would undo the argument that there is a transitional period between the cross and A.D. 70, as well as undo the hermeneutic that hangs its hat on supposed time indicators.
Tuesday, August 16, 2016
Wednesday, August 10, 2016
Preterist Time References, Part VII
Some of these perceived time statements are actually
just loose readings of texts that are taken out of context.
In John 21:18-23, we have the following scene
described.
“I
tell you the solemn truth, when you were young, you
tied your clothes around you and went wherever you
wanted, but when you are old, you will stretch out your
hands, and others will tie you up and bring you
where you do not want to go.” (Now Jesus said this to
indicate clearly by what kind of death Peter was
going to glorify God.) After he
said this, Jesus told Peter, “Follow me.” Peter turned
around and saw the disciple whom Jesus loved following them. (This
was the disciple who had leaned back against Jesus’
chest at the meal and asked, “Lord, who is the
one who is going to betray you?”) So when Peter saw him,
he asked Jesus, “Lord, what about him?” Jesus replied, “If I want him to remain
until I come back, what concern is that of yours? You follow me!” So the
saying circulated among the brothers that this disciple was not going
to die. But Jesus did not say to him that he
was not going to die, but rather, “If I want him to
remain until I come back, what concern is that of yours?”
Preterists
often take this passage as a statement by Jesus that John would remain until
Christ comes. What is really odd about this interpretation is that it is the
same mistake made by “the brethren” that John is trying to correct. A rumor
goes out among them that John is not going to die, but John must correct them
by saying that Jesus did not say that he was not going to die, but only said “if
I want him to live until I come . . .” The hypothetical is meant to convey to
Peter that it is none of his business what Jesus does with another disciple.
The
fact that Preterists ignore the hypothetical “if” is simply an oddity that I
can only explain by a willingness to find proof texts in any place they can.
But
what is even more fascinating about this verse is that, once placed back into
its context, it ends up being a text that would reject the Preterist
understanding of Christ’s second coming, as it ties the idea that once Christ
comes back, physical death would be abolished.
Notice
that the context here is that Jesus has just told Peter how he is going to
physically die. Peter then asks Jesus how John is going to physically die.
Jesus responds by saying, “If I want him to remain until I come, what is that
to you?” This is an important statement in that it basically has Jesus stating
that if John were to remain until He comes, he wouldn’t die.
In
fact, this is clearly the implication, as the brethren miss the hypothetical,
as do the Preterists, and therefore conclude that John is not going to
physically die.
John
merely corrects them by pointing out that it was a hypothetical statement, and that
those who think he will not die because Christ is coming back in his lifetime
have simply missed the “if” in the statement.
There
are strange ways that some try to get around this. For instance, the idea that
Lazarus is the disciple whom Jesus loved here, and that the brethren think he
won’t die because he was raised by Christ is not only nowhere in the text, but
it ignores what is in the text, which is that the statement is directly linked
to Peter’s question and the implication of Jesus’ response. This is not even to
mention that the disciple whom Jesus loved is clearly one of the eleven, as the
upper room is made up of Jesus and the twelve (Matt 26:20; Mark 14:17; Luke
22:14), and the disciple whom Jesus loved is one of the twelve (the one who
leaned upon him at the supper and asked who would betray him—v. 20).
Either
way, however, this interpretation has no merit, as it ignores the context of
the statement in an attempt to create an alternative context, which can then be
used to reinterpret the scene.
However,
the implication of Jesus in the context is clear. If John were to have remained
until His coming, he would not have died. This means that Jesus believed His
own coming would mark the end of physical death itself. This also means that
the early Christians understood the statement this way because they believed
that the coming of Christ would mark the end of physical death.
Rather
than a proof text for Preterism, therefore, this passage actually contradicts it.
Friday, August 5, 2016
Preterist Time References, Part VI
The biggest part of the Preterist argument are time
statements concerning the destruction of Jerusalem in the Synoptics. The Olivet
Discourse is often a fall back passage when one seems to be getting hammered
with another passage that indicates that resurrection is of this physical body
or Christ’s return is physical, etc. However, as apocalyptic discourse, these
passages cannot be read as though they are some literal layout of the coming of
Christ.
The following six statements made in the Synoptic
Gospels make up the sum total of what I would consider time statement evidence
that the Synoptics are talking about the fall of Jerusalem in A.D. 70 (I think
a couple other verses often cited are actually referring to something else).
1."The axe is already laid at the root of the trees." (Matt. 3:10; Luke 3:9).
2. "His winnowing fork is in His hand." (Matt. 3:12; Luke 3:17).
3. "'When the owner of the vineyard comes, what will he do to those vine-growers?' '....He will bring those wretches to a wretched end, and will rent out the vineyard to other vine-growers, who will pay him the proceeds at the proper seasons.' '....Therefore I say to you, the kingdom of God will be taken away from you, and be given to a nation producing the fruit of it.' ....When the chief priests and the Pharisees heard His parables, they understood that He was speaking about them." (Matt. 21:40-41, 43, 45; Luke 20:15-16, 19).
4. "This generation will not pass away until all these things take place." (Mark 13:30; Matt. 24:34; with some variation in Luke 21:32).
5. “These are days of vengeance, in order that all things which are written may be fulfilled.” (Lk. 21:22).
6. "Daughters of Jerusalem, stop weeping for Me, but weep for yourselves and for your children. For behold, the days are coming when they will say, 'Blessed are the barren, and the wombs that never bore, and the breasts that never nursed.' Then they will begin to say to the mountains, 'Fall on us,' and to the hills, 'Cover us.'” (Lk. 23:28-30).
1."The axe is already laid at the root of the trees." (Matt. 3:10; Luke 3:9).
2. "His winnowing fork is in His hand." (Matt. 3:12; Luke 3:17).
3. "'When the owner of the vineyard comes, what will he do to those vine-growers?' '....He will bring those wretches to a wretched end, and will rent out the vineyard to other vine-growers, who will pay him the proceeds at the proper seasons.' '....Therefore I say to you, the kingdom of God will be taken away from you, and be given to a nation producing the fruit of it.' ....When the chief priests and the Pharisees heard His parables, they understood that He was speaking about them." (Matt. 21:40-41, 43, 45; Luke 20:15-16, 19).
4. "This generation will not pass away until all these things take place." (Mark 13:30; Matt. 24:34; with some variation in Luke 21:32).
5. “These are days of vengeance, in order that all things which are written may be fulfilled.” (Lk. 21:22).
6. "Daughters of Jerusalem, stop weeping for Me, but weep for yourselves and for your children. For behold, the days are coming when they will say, 'Blessed are the barren, and the wombs that never bore, and the breasts that never nursed.' Then they will begin to say to the mountains, 'Fall on us,' and to the hills, 'Cover us.'” (Lk. 23:28-30).
At this point, I have no pushback on these verses. I think they clearly refer to the destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70. So these are not verses that prove Preterism, as many partial Preterists, and even someone like me who does not consider myself a Preterist at all, at least in terms of what that view often assumes about books outside of the Synoptics, would agree that these are talking about the destruction of Jerusalem.
The problem, as I see it, is that Preterists tend to carry with these verses certain unwarranted assumptions that stem from a lack of familiarity with apocalyptic literature and speech. These assumptions can be summed up as follows.
1. An assumption that any macro language used means that the macro-event is occurring here.
2. That there is only one “coming” and parousia of Christ, rather than multiple comings and instances of Christ’s future parousia breaking into the here and now.
Let’s take the first
one to start. Part of the thrust of many apocalyptic texts is to take an event
that is occurring in the author’s day and place it within the context of the
future restoration of God’s people and judgment of the world.
This is done for a
variety of reasons, but the main one seems to be that it provides perspective
to those who are witnessing the microcosmic event in their own lifetime. For
instance, in Daniel, under the persecution of Antiochus IV, the people of God
were hopelessly being oppressed and killed for worshiping YHWH. What Daniel did
was to take that persecution and place it in the context of the ultimate end,
the macrocosmic event in an effort to give the faithful perspective. They may
die for their faith, but there will be a resurrection of the dead. They may
lose their possessions and property now, but they will take possession of the
whole world in the time to come.
Hence, Daniel took the
two events and mixed them together as one, precisely, to argue that the
microcosmic event is really a spark of a larger fire to come. The persecution
of God’s people would end in victory.
In Daniel, then, the
kingdoms are all wiped away. As the Aramaic states, “ In the days of those kings [i.e., the Seleucid
kings in the second century B.C.] the God of heaven will raise up an everlasting kingdom that will not be destroyed, and there will be no kingdom that is left for another people. It will break in pieces and bring about the demise of all these kingdoms. But it will stand forever.”
Here we see that all of the kingdoms of the earth
will be utterly destroyed, and there will be no other kingdom left for another
people. Only the people of God will rule in the kingdom of God. Yet, we know
that this did not happen in the second century B.C. In fact, it has not
happened yet at all. One might argue that the kingdom of God is spiritual and
exists in the world today, but that is not what this passage says. It does not
say that the kingdom of God will exist side by side with kingdoms of other
people. According to this, there are no other kingdoms left. Instead,
what the author of Daniel has done is to combine the event of Antiochus’
persecution, which becomes more clear as the reader progresses through the
work, with the macrocosmic event in the end.
Again, in Chapter 12, we are told of the great
victory and resurrection of the saints.
“At that time Michael,
the great prince who watches over your people,
will arise.
There will be a time of distress
unlike any other from the nation’s beginning
up to that time.
But at that time your own people,
all those whose names are found written in the book,
will escape.
Many of those who sleep
in the dusty ground will awake –
some to everlasting life,
and others to shame and everlasting abhorrence.
But the wise will shine
like the brightness of the heavenly expanse.
And those bringing many to righteousness
will be like the stars forever and ever.” (12:1-3)
This text clearly has
macrocosmic language all over it. We are told that all of these things happen “at
that time.” This, of course, begs the question, “At what time?” The answer is
found in the preceding chapter that indicates the time that this all occurs is
the time of Antiochus IV and his demise. Despite the forced idea that Chapter
11 somehow splits at the end and refers to Rome, the entire book, chapter, and
flow of narrative indicate that there is no change in person or time. Daniel
has joined the microcosmic and macrocosmic events together in order to argue
that, despite the severity of oppressive powers and even death among God’s
people, if they trust in God, they will have victory in the end.
Likewise, 1 Enoch, one of
the most important books in 2d Temple Judaism, is an apocalyptic book that
takes the event of the flood and combines it with macrocosmic language to
convey that the flood was a foreshadowing of a larger event to come at the end of
the fallen world.
In the context of the
flood, Enoch tells us that the flood will bring about a total destruction of
the wicked, something it does in the biblical narrative, but this destruction
soon takes on another event all together in that the wicked are removed from
the earth forever. They will never again set foot on it. The righteous will
live upon it forever instead and it will never again be corrupted by the
wicked. This clearly does not happen in the flood, and the author of Enoch
knows this. So why does he present the flood as a futuristic judgment of the
world in which the wicked are wiped away in fire (fire itself seems odd for a cosmic
deluge)? Because he is combining the flood event with what he sees as the
future judgment of the world. They are two events spoken of together as though
they are a singular event because, in the author’s mind, they are.
In the apocalyptic mind,
all micro events are like streams of water that flow from the larger ocean of
creation. On one side of creation, the inauguration at the beginning, there is
an ocean of creational language, and on the other side of creation, there is
destruction and recreation the ends in the consummation of creation, the
finishing of everything God has made and the filling up of His earth full of
His covenant people, which was His original purpose in creation. Hence,
everything is creation. Every event that occurs is a part of that larger event.
All is one in that regard. Hence, events like the Exodus have creation language
attached to them, not as an act of hyperbole, but to display the unification of
the two events as one. Likewise, an event like the destruction of Babylon has
with it destruction and recreation language since such events are also one with
the future renewal of the cosmos.
This is the view of
apocalyptic speech. It combines events together. As such, the prophets can
place the destruction of cities in the context of that larger event, and Second
Temple and New Testament authors, especially within an apocalyptic context that
is characteristic of this practice, can do the same with events like that of
the persecution under Antiochus IV, the flood event, Christ’s coming to His
churches in judgment in Revelation, the Mount of Transfiguration, Christ coming
to render a verdict for the oppressed workers in James, and Christ coming as a
judgment upon the city of Jerusalem and its leaders. All of these things can be
described in terms of the macrocosmic events of Christ’s final return and
consummation of His kingdom because they are all a part of that final
consummation in one way or another. They are microcosmic events occurring in
time that are branches from a larger tree that exists in the future.
Now, that all speaks to
the idea that macro language means the macro event is occurring. Such an
understanding of apocalyptic helps us see that the claim that macro language
means the macro event is actually occurring at that time and place is false.
So what about the other
claim? What about the idea that there is only one coming, only one parousia? In some way, I’ve already
given an answer above. If smaller events in time are all a part of the larger
event in the future, and can be spoken of as one, then there can be many
smaller events that are in some way connected to the larger one.
But there are some
statements on top of this, within the New Testament, that confirm this idea of
multiple “comings” “parousias.”
For instance, in Luke
17:22, Christ states to the disciples that “the days are coming when you will
desire to see one of the days of the
Son of Man and you will not see it.”
Not only does this seem
to indicate that there is more than one day/time that belongs to Christ’s
coming, but that the main day that they long to see will not be seen by them.
Again, in a verse cited
by many Preterists, but not read closely, Christ reveals to the priestly court
that “from now on, you will see the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of the Power and coming on the clouds of heaven” (26:64).
Using the same macrocosmic language
from Daniel, Christ argues that this will be a continuous thing that occurs,
not forty years from His court hearing, but “from now on.” This is because the language
of Daniel, where the Son of Man “comes” has to do with His coming up to the
Father to receive His kingdom. This is why his reception of the Father’s
blessings on the Mount of Transfiguration is considered a “coming” and a “parousia”
by the Synoptic Gospels that place the prediction of His coming in parallel to
His ascending to the Father on the mountain. It is also why Peter joins them
together in his epistle (2 Pet 1:16-18).
It is also why Christ’s
judgment over His Church, as its King, can be referred to as His coming (Rev
2-3), and why James can refer to His coming to render a fair verdict to His
oppressed people as His parousia (4:7).
As Luke indicated, there are many days of the Son of Man, not just the final
one. There are many receptions of His kingdom, many times He will come in the
clouds of heaven from the time He speaks to the priests to His final return.
The Preterist’s assumptions
fail on both of these accounts. To say that macrocosmic language means that the
macrocosmic event is occurring, and therefore, if it doesn’t happen literally,
it all needs to be reinterpreted into something spiritual, is a non sequitur.
To say that this must be true because there is only one coming and
manifestation of the parousia is also
false.
Without these two
assumptions, there is simply no reason to read the Olivet Discourse, one of
many instances of Christ’s coming and parousia
as the final one. In fact, in light of the nature passages, it becomes obvious
that the Preterist reading is not the correct reading of the text.
Hence, Preterists are right
that all six of these statements refer to the microcosmic event of the
destruction of Jerusalem. Their assumptions about how to read apocalyptic
literature, however, have led them to misunderstand the nature of the larger
event to which some of its language gives witness.
Preterist Time References, Part V
Along the lines of misunderstanding some other terms, there are a few phrases that are misunderstood such as John's statement concerning "the last hour" (1 John 2:18), or Paul's statement that "the night is almost gone" (Rom 13:12).
These statements are interpreted by Preterists to refer to the small remaining time that exists until the end of the age in A.D. 70.
However, there is no indication of time at all in these phrases. For instance, in 1 John, we are told what John is talking about just a few verses before.
He makes the statement, "On the other hand, I am writing a new commandment to you which is true in him and in you, because the darkness is passing away and the true light is already shining" (2:8).
John is not describing the last hour of an age, but giving us the imagery that the apostles often give, which is the last hour of night. He is referring to the time of night when it is still dark, but light from the sun has shone in it, mixed with it, so that both light and darkness exist at the same time.
He says this because the type of proto-Gnostics he is addressing in the epistle seem to have the idea that the new age has already come. Their view of resurrection and Christ's spiritual return would foster this idea. Hence, many think the dark age is gone, and they themselves have been spiritually resurrected to new life, where they are free from moral constraints and are without any guilt of sin (1:5-10).
John counters this by arguing that actually Christians still sin and are in need of confession and the advocacy of the Righteous One, Jesus Christ to forgive them, as well as having a need to walk according to His commandments (2:1-6). The new age of amoralism has, therefore, not come. Christians are still bound to the commandments of Christ, specifically those concerning loving fellow Christians.
John then confirms that the Light has come, and the darkness is passing away, but that the two exist now together. It is this mixture of the two that he calls "the last hour," referring to the "last hour of night." John proves that darkness still exists with the light by citing the fact that there are many antichrists that have appeared in the world. Hence, the kingdom of the devil is not gone, but merely going, as darkness is passing and light growing in the last hour of night.
Paul makes this imagery more clear in Romans 13:12, where he actually uses terminology that talks about the far advancement of night (he nux proekopsen) in the hour that the day has come ("is here" "in one's presence," engizo in the perfect aspect). The time of night described is the time that John talks about above. It is the time when night is coming to an end and the light is beginning to come out, even though it is still the time before the dawn.
Paul states that this is "already the hour for you to awaken from sleep," which is a reference to his exhortation to the Roman Christians to see that light has broken into the world and they should live accordingly. They ought to live, not according to the pattern of the world that is passing away, described by night and darkness, but according to the light that has come in, described by day.
2 Peter 1:19 uses the same concept, evidencing that this is a common metaphor in the early church to describe the existence of two kingdoms and two ages existing simultaneously together, one where Christ is honored and followed in righteousness and one where the world still follows the devil and his pattern of rebellion and sin.
"Moreover, we possess the prophetic word as an altogether reliable thing. You do well if you pay attention to this as you would to a light shining in a murky place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts."
Peter expresses the need here for the church to give their ear to the testimony of the apostles to withstand the onslaught of heretics in the church, as a "light shining in a dark place." This is needed until the day actually dawns and the morning comes in terms of spiritual maturity.
The author of Hebrews has this same concept in mind when he states that Christians need to remain faithful "as they see the day drawing near (engizo in the present aspect, 10:25)."
None of these expressions convey when the sun will rise and the night will be completely over. They all convey the idea that, while there are false prophets, sin, antichrists, heretics, i.e., the things of the night, in the world, the night is still here. The assurance that the apostles give to Christians is that the darkness is on its way out, not on its way in. The light, however, is on its way in, and the day, even though still dark outside, has come.
These statements are interpreted by Preterists to refer to the small remaining time that exists until the end of the age in A.D. 70.
However, there is no indication of time at all in these phrases. For instance, in 1 John, we are told what John is talking about just a few verses before.
He makes the statement, "On the other hand, I am writing a new commandment to you which is true in him and in you, because the darkness is passing away and the true light is already shining" (2:8).
John is not describing the last hour of an age, but giving us the imagery that the apostles often give, which is the last hour of night. He is referring to the time of night when it is still dark, but light from the sun has shone in it, mixed with it, so that both light and darkness exist at the same time.
He says this because the type of proto-Gnostics he is addressing in the epistle seem to have the idea that the new age has already come. Their view of resurrection and Christ's spiritual return would foster this idea. Hence, many think the dark age is gone, and they themselves have been spiritually resurrected to new life, where they are free from moral constraints and are without any guilt of sin (1:5-10).
John counters this by arguing that actually Christians still sin and are in need of confession and the advocacy of the Righteous One, Jesus Christ to forgive them, as well as having a need to walk according to His commandments (2:1-6). The new age of amoralism has, therefore, not come. Christians are still bound to the commandments of Christ, specifically those concerning loving fellow Christians.
John then confirms that the Light has come, and the darkness is passing away, but that the two exist now together. It is this mixture of the two that he calls "the last hour," referring to the "last hour of night." John proves that darkness still exists with the light by citing the fact that there are many antichrists that have appeared in the world. Hence, the kingdom of the devil is not gone, but merely going, as darkness is passing and light growing in the last hour of night.
Paul makes this imagery more clear in Romans 13:12, where he actually uses terminology that talks about the far advancement of night (he nux proekopsen) in the hour that the day has come ("is here" "in one's presence," engizo in the perfect aspect). The time of night described is the time that John talks about above. It is the time when night is coming to an end and the light is beginning to come out, even though it is still the time before the dawn.
Paul states that this is "already the hour for you to awaken from sleep," which is a reference to his exhortation to the Roman Christians to see that light has broken into the world and they should live accordingly. They ought to live, not according to the pattern of the world that is passing away, described by night and darkness, but according to the light that has come in, described by day.
2 Peter 1:19 uses the same concept, evidencing that this is a common metaphor in the early church to describe the existence of two kingdoms and two ages existing simultaneously together, one where Christ is honored and followed in righteousness and one where the world still follows the devil and his pattern of rebellion and sin.
"Moreover, we possess the prophetic word as an altogether reliable thing. You do well if you pay attention to this as you would to a light shining in a murky place, until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts."
Peter expresses the need here for the church to give their ear to the testimony of the apostles to withstand the onslaught of heretics in the church, as a "light shining in a dark place." This is needed until the day actually dawns and the morning comes in terms of spiritual maturity.
The author of Hebrews has this same concept in mind when he states that Christians need to remain faithful "as they see the day drawing near (engizo in the present aspect, 10:25)."
None of these expressions convey when the sun will rise and the night will be completely over. They all convey the idea that, while there are false prophets, sin, antichrists, heretics, i.e., the things of the night, in the world, the night is still here. The assurance that the apostles give to Christians is that the darkness is on its way out, not on its way in. The light, however, is on its way in, and the day, even though still dark outside, has come.
Preterist Time References, Part IV
The word tachu becomes relevant as a time reference only in the Book of
Revelation. It is repeated there at the beginning and the end of the book (2:16;
3:11; 22:7, 12, 20), forming an inclusio
that creates a general feel for the whole book that Christ’s “coming”/judgment
of the matters discussed therein will fall tachu.
Preterists often argue that, since the word means "soon," this means that the events in Revelation must be taking place in the first century, in John's day. I, of course, agree that the events are taking place in the first century and in John's day, but do not agree that the word must be understood as "soon" in order to get this idea, nor do I agree with the non sequitur that this somehow means that the even describe therein is the destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70. That just doesn't pan out, as I'll discuss in a more extensive upcoming post.
Of the two most prominent meanings
put forth by people, translating it as “soon” or “suddenly,” my interpretation
of Revelation allows me to look at the evidence rather objectively, since
either one of them fit into my interpretation of the book. I believe the events
taking place in the background of the book refer to the persecution of
Christians during the reign of Domitian toward the end of the first century
A.D. BDAG relates that it can refer to a brief period of time with an emphasis
on the speed of an activity or it can just refer to something that is done “without
delay,” “quickly,” “at a rapid rate” (993). In other words, one meaning may be
that it describes the time frame
until which the action is performed (i.e., “soon”) and the other, and what I
think is more likely the case in the context of Revelation, describes the manner in which the action is done (“quickly,”
“suddenly”).
In fact, the word tachu itself seems to be used mainly in
the New Testament to describe things that are done quickly (Matt 5:25; 28:7;
28:8; Luke 15:22; John 11:29), although one occurrence in Mark 9:39 seems
ambiguous and could be interpreted either way. The meaning of “soon” seems most
intended by its cognate tacheos,
which does not appear in the Apocalypse. The other cognate, tachos, that does appear in Revelation
twice (1:1; 22:6) is more ambiguous, however, sometimes evidencing a meaning of
“quickly” (Luke 18:8; Acts 12:7; 22:18) and sometimes more ambiguous so as to
possibly have either meaning (Acts 25:4; Rom 16:20; 1 Tim 3:14). Although, even
here, BDAG states that the word can refer to a period of time that focuses on
the “speed of an activity or event” (992).
Revelation is made difficult, not
so much by the argument of the book itself, but because our presuppositions of
what the book is about often don’t accord with what the book says, and hence,
it becomes incomprehensible. These things either must be made up of an obscured
symbolism because of their taking place in the distant future, or they make up
a symbolic description of some past event. Both of these positions tend to
think that the Apocalypse is about detailing the “end” (whether the end of a
covenant age or the end of the world), whether in literal or symbolic form.
Both of these positions, however, could not be more wrong.
The Apocalypse is not about the
end of anything. It simply references the end (what I refer to as the
macro-event) and puts it together with an immediate judgment that Christ is
making upon the churches, arguing that if Christians align themselves with the
world via a compromised form of idolatry and worshiping the beast, they will
meet the same fate as the world, typified in the Roman Empire. This judgment
consists of a micro-event in terms of the fact that it is not a universal or
cosmic event, but rather a localized event that foreshadows the larger one, and
should be seen in light of the larger event. What this means is that the book
is not attempting to describe the macro-event, but merely to place the
micro-event in the context of the macro-event, whatever it may look like, in
order to communicate a message to the first century church concerning Christ’s
coming to it in judgment (e.g., “I am
coming to you” 2:5, 16; 3:3).
Hence, even though the words tachu and tachos convey more of an idea concerning something happening
suddenly or someone doing something quickly/hastily, rather than conveying the
time frame from what is said to the execution of the event, it becomes a moot
point, since Christ is saying to the churches that He is coming quickly to
render judgment upon them (which is why the rest of the book should be read in
light of the ecclesiastical letters in the beginning of the book, which
function as the book’s key). He is already at the door, judgment is about to
take place for these churches, and He will come suddenly, like lightening and
like a thief in the night to render that verdict. Hence, the churches are told
to repent of their living like the world, and further shown by the rest of the
book that those who live in a Christless antinomianism really belong to the
world, and hence, will receive its judgment. The book, therefore, is not about
describing end time events, but rather merely references common apocalyptic
themes of the end times in order to convey the concepts of the visible and
invisible church and where their respective allegiances truly lie.
The book has absolutely nothing to
do with the fall of Jerusalem. Christ’s “coming” in the context is His coming
to judge the church, and that is merely linked to His future eschatological
coming in the flesh, where every eye will see Him. This joining the micro and
macro events together as a single event is a common literary feature in
apocalyptic literature. It does not intend to convey the idea that the
micro-event and the macro-event actually occur at the same time, or that the
micro event is the macro event. To read it as such is to misunderstand the
ancient worldview at work in these texts.
The book itself is set in the
backdrop of Domitian’s persecution, as the book is primarily concerned with
condemning Christians who compromise and “eat food sacrificed to idols” (2:14,
20) in order to participate in the larger culture. This has its specific
reference in John to those who participate in idolatry and the imperial cult
(e.g., worshiping the beast and his image is condemned numerous times
throughout the book, Rev 11:7; 13:4, 12-14; 14:9, 11; 15:2; 16:2; 17:3-7;
19:19; 20:4). As the beast is the enemy of Christ and His people, worshiping the
beast is antithetical to worshiping God through Jesus Christ. Christ, in
Revelation, therefore, comes to judge His Church concerning the matter.
When Christ tells the church that
He is coming tachu. He is not saying
that He is coming soon, since He is actually already there among them (2:1).
What He is saying is that when judgment falls, it is going to fall suddenly and
without warning. In fact, the rebuke He gives is already a part of that judgment.
It, hence, has already begun, and unless they repent, they will be removed from
being considered His people (2:5).
This sudden judgment is captured
in the image of a thief who comes quickly in the night (3:3). It is sudden and
before one knows it.
In fact, the thief in the night
imagery is supplemented with other images throughout Scripture that describe
judgment as a sudden event for which unrepentant people are not prepared. It is
described as birth pangs coming upon a pregnant woman (1 Thes 5:3), and a trap
that suddenly springs on you (Luke 21:34). The word in Luke here is aiphnidios “suddenly.” The only way to
avoid a surprise judgment that suddenly falls is to repent and be ready by
living in faith, love, and hope (1 Thes 5:8). The final imagery is lightening
flashing from one side of the sky to the other (Matt 24:27; Luke 17:24).
Lightening is not flashing “soon,” but suddenly and without warning.
This is what tachu conveys, then. It is not that the trap shuts “soon,” or that
birth pangs come upon a woman “soon,” or that the thief comes “soon,” or that
lightning flashes “soon.” It is that the trap shuts suddenly, abruptly, without
warning. Birth pangs come upon a pregnant woman seemingly out of nowhere. They
fall upon her suddenly and without warning. The thief does not come soon in the
night, but rather quickly. He comes without warning and at a great haste so
that he can quickly leave with one’s goods. The lightning flashes quickly
across the sky. It is sudden and without warning.
This suddenness is the type of
judgment conveyed throughout the book. All of the plagues fall upon Babylon the
Great in one day (18:8) and with a sudden violent force (v. 21). In another
description the city, the mountains, and all of the islands of the world fall
with a sudden, violent earthquake (6:14-17; 16:20).
The Lord conveys with the word tachu, then, that those who do not
repent will also be overtaken suddenly along with the world (2:16; 3:3). Since
they wish to partake of the benefits of attending the festivals that honor the
gods and the emperor, they can also partake of its sudden judgment and
destructive end that leads to the lake of fire and brimstone.
Hence, the message of the book is
a message of repentance so that the faithless are restored to right worship and
those who have overcome the beast by not loving their lives even to death are
encouraged. The suddenness of Christ’s judgment strikes fear in the unfaithful
and gives hope to the faithful.
Giving in the Early Church
"What we do see in the writings of the Apostolic Fathers are various Christian communities concerned with putting acts of charity into practice among their own people. The second century Christian would not have the same kind of global concern as ours in this century. In the Apostolic Fathers there is nothing to indicate that the charitable concern of the Christian extended beyond the faith community. On the contrary, in almost every passage concerned with the same issues as Matt 25:35-36 there is some restricting element, a word or a phrase, that makes it clear that the good works being discussed are envisaged in terms of other Christians" (Sherman W. Gray, The Least of My Brothers, Matthew 25:31-46: A History of Interpretation SBL Dissertation Series 114, Scholars Press: Atlanta, GA, 11-12).
Preterist Time References, Part III
We are met with a series of verses that use the word
engus which supposedly conveys the idea that the time of Christ’s coming or the
end is “near.”
For instance, James states, “You also be patient and strengthen your hearts, for the Lord’s parousia is near” (5:8). James encourages them to wait on the judgment of the parousia that has already become accessible to them.
Also 1 Peter 4:7
states, “the end of all things is near.”
There are, of course, numerous issues concerning, not only what the word engus means, but what nuance of the word
telos is being coveyed.
Again, the texts that state, "the kingdom of God is near," or the "time is near" are all understood by Preterists to mean that the kingdom of God, the time, the end, the Lord's judgment of His parousia, etc. is approaching, but has not yet arrived at the time these things were written down by the apostles.
By “near,” the English reader thinks of the idea as
something that is almost here. It’s on its way, but not quite here yet. This is
a great example of why English glosses are not sufficient to convey the
concepts of words from a foreign language. The receptor language may carry
nuances in it that are not carried by the original language that the translator
is attempting to bring over into his target language. In other words, when an
English person thinks of the word “near,” he thinks of the two nuances the
English word has and then assigns them to the Greek word engus.
Hence, the word near can convey something that is in
one’s presence, in a spatial sense, or something that is close to arriving, but
not currently in one’s presence. The same can be said of the temporal idea of
“near.” In other words, if something is “near,” it is either in your present
time frame or it is about to be in your present time frame, but is not
currently in your present time frame. This thinking, however, is completely
fallacious. The word engus doesn’t
have a nuance that indicates something is “almost but not currently in one’s
presence.”
Instead, the word simply conveys the opposite of something remote,
something distant, something not currently in one’s presence or present. Likewise,
its verbal form engizo, specifically
in its perfect form, refers to something that has already come and is in one’s
presence.
In fact, both James and 1 Peter, cited above, are in
the perfect aspect, which conveys the stative idea that the Lord’s presence and
the telos “maturity/end
goal/completion” of the ages has come already and exists at the time of the
author’s writing.
The specific parousia
“presence” of the Lord in James refers to the eschatological judgment of
Christ that is present in a small part now, and is ready to render judgment (I’ll
discuss this use of the parousia in
another post). In fact, we are told that the judge is not on his way, but
instead the judge stands (perfect aspect) at the gates. The gates were the
place of judgment, which means that the Lord is already in the place of
judgment and the verdict of his eschatological parousia is something that Christians will experience in their lives,
and something that to which they will have access, not just in a distant
future, but now, since it has already arrived.
Likewise, in 1 Peter 4:7, the statement that “the
end/culmination of all things is near”
is not a statement that the culmination/maturation/end goal is about to come,
but that it has come already. Peter presents the “end” as the current state of
all things as he is writing, not as something that is on its way, but has not
yet occurred.
Luke 21:31 is an interesting verse,
as it indicates that the meaning is not “almost here.” “When you see all these things happen, know
that the kingdom of God is engus.”
Now, if the word means “almost here,” rather than “here,” then that creates
quite a problem, since the phrase, “all these things” includes the Son of Man
arriving in the clouds of heaven, which would mean that redemption is not
almost here, but it has, in fact, arrived. Likewise, in v. 20, the surrounded
Jerusalem indicates that the city’s abandonment by God has come (again, perfect
aspect).
The verbal idea, however, is more fluid in that one
could take it to mean that something is in the process of drawing near, mainly when appearing in the present aspect, but it
would be unlikely that the perfect form would be the best choice to convey this
idea.
The noun engus
is much more concrete. It conveys something that is in one’s presence,
spatially or temporally. It conveys the idea that something is here more than
it conveys the English concept of something that is near, but not here. Hence,
a better translation might be “here,” “accessible,” “within one’s reach,” etc.
The common translation “at hand” would have sufficed if it did not now take
upon itself different connotations within certain circles that interpret the
phrase “at hand” to refer to something that is almost here, rather than
something that is here. This has led to the misunderstanding of a series of
verses. For instance, Matthew 24:32 states:
|
“Now learn a parable of the fig
tree; When its branch is yet tender, and it puts forth leaves, you know that
summer is near.”
One would think this verse
confirmed the idea that summer is almost here but not quite yet due to the
fig tree blossoming in Spring. However, what it fails to note is that there
is no Spring in ancient Israel. Ancient Israel only had two seasons, winter
and summer. There were many festivals, harvests, rains, etc. that also
tracked time, but only two actual seasons. Hence, the fig tree does not
blossom in Winter, but in Summer. When you see it blossom, it tells you that
Summer is here. It has arrived
already. It is not on its way, but has come.
The point of the analogy conveys
the same idea, “So also you, when you see all these things, know that he is near,
right at the door” (Matt 24:33). He is not in His place. He is
not on the road on the way to the house, He has arrived. He is at the door.
He is here.
Hence, when Paul says, “the word
is near you” (Rom 10:8), he means
that it is there in their presence at that time, and therefore, accessible
now, not something that is on its way, but not yet in their presence. It is
not at a distance anymore. It has arrived in their proximity. They can access
it right then and there. Hence, he follows up by clarifying where this word
that is “near” is actually located, i.e., “it is in your mouth and in your
mind.”
Philippians 4:5 encourages
Christians to be gentle, as they are mindful of the presence of the Lord,
since “the Lord is near.”
Ephesians 2:13 says, “But now in Christ Jesus you who used to be far away have been
brought near by the blood of Christ.”
All of the benefits of the kingdom have been made accessible to
the believer through the blood of Christ. They are his to access “now.”
In Matthew (e.g., 3:2; 4:17; 10:7),
the preaching of the gospel is framed in the message, “Repent, for the
kingdom of Heaven is engus.” It is
clear that the kingdom of Heaven has been made accessible to them right then
and there through the very preaching. It is in their presence and accessible
to them, not something that is almost there and not yet in their presence so
as to be accessible.
The grammar of engus in Luke 10:9 indicates that the
message of the gospel was that “the kingdom of God has come upon you” (BDAG 270 s.v. ἐγγίζω 2;
W. R. Hutton, “The Kingdom of God Has Come,” ExpTim 64
[Dec 1952]: 89-91; and D. L. Bock, Luke [BECNT], 2:1000). It has been made
accessible to you is the idea.
In fact, Luke 17:20-37 states that
“the kingdom of God is in your midst.” It was present with them then and
there.
Christ also indicates that the
disciples will long to see the day of His coming (i.e., the macro-event) and
will not see it. So if the kingdom of God is something that is still to come
from the standpoint of the apostles who are proclaiming that it is near, then
this poses quite the conundrum, since it is said to be in their midst and yet
it is something that is not yet in their midst. This problem is removed when
we understand the word properly. Instead, the kingdom of God has come
already. It is there, in their midst. Everything else is an indication that
it is here and has already come (Matt 12:28; Luke 21:31).
|
Mark makes this more explicit by stating the
proclamation as “the time has been fulfilled and the kingdom of God is here (engus). Repent and believe” (1:15).
In Matthew 12:28, Jesus argues that “if I cast out
demons by the Spirit of God, then the kingdom of God has already come upon you.”
Hence, as Paul indicates to the Corinthians, the end
of the ages “have come” (perfect aspect, 1 Cor 10:11). It is not on its way in
twenty some odd years. It has already come by the time Paul writes to the
Corinthians, as he presents it as the state in which they live. The kingdom of
God is here, “in your midst.” The end/the maturity of the age to come/the goal
of the ages is among us, here, at hand, where one can reach out and grab it
because it is not “on its way shortly,” but rather has arrived and is standing
in one’s presence. The time is here. The judge is in the gates ready to render
a verdict. He walks among the lampstands, His churches. He is at the door. He
is here. That’s what engus, and in
most cases engizo, actually mean. Engus doesn’t carry the English nuance “almost
but not yet in one’s presence” in the New Testament. Yet, it is that English
nuance upon which the Preterist argument is dependant.
In truth, all of these verses, then, do not convey
that the end, the kingdom of God, the parousia
of Jesus, etc. “is nearing, but not yet arrived,” but rather that the end,
the eschatological presence of the Lord, the kingdom of God, etc. is here. It has come. It is standing in the
midst of them . It has arrived and is present with the apostles BEFORE AD 70. And
this is a strong argument for the already-not yet sense of the NT, where the
end is broken up between the spiritual fulfillment of the end taking place from
the first coming of Christ to the physical fulfillment taking place at the
Second Coming. It is accessible now, so that Christians (before and after A.D.
70) do not need to wait until the end of this world to receive its power,
blessings, and judgments. Hence, there is a sense in which the coming kingdom
is already here, and words like engus
describe that present reality, even in the pre-A.D. 70 period.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)