Monday, December 15, 2014
Friday, December 12, 2014
Tuesday, November 25, 2014
What Leads to Divorcing God?
Originally posted July 9, 2012
Our relationship with God is often described (collectively at least) as a marriage. So many seem to enter into that marriage covenant, but end up turning away from the true God in the long run. Why is that?
One of the major reasons I think this is the case is because people often don't "fall in love" with the whole person to whom they are married. Instead, a person will latch on to certain attributes and overemphasize those attributes as encompassing the whole person. Thus, these loveable attributes overshadow other attributes that may be less charming to the specific individual. This is called the halo effect.
We see it when a young girl can't see that the guy she's dating is a complete jerk. That's because there is some charming quality, or qualities, about him that diminish the less than charming attributes and he is perceived just in terms of those charming attributes.
What happens then is that she gets married to the guy. The halo effect slowly disappears, and she ends up seeing all of him. She then thinks, "Who is this? I don't even know this person anymore." Actually, it was that she never knew him in the first place. Her love was never based on knowledge of his whole person, and so her love was never of his whole person, just of an imaginary character that her husband once played in her delusion. She then begins to look for a "better" partner (what this usually means is she looks for someone else with whom she can do the exact same thing), or no partner at all. In other words, she chooses detachment from her covenant promise by divorce/adultery. She chooses either to remain single at that point, perhaps, realizing that the guy she imagined is not out there at all, or she chooses a different guy. The point is that she never knew the person to whom she was married. She never made a commitment to him at all. She merely had a fanciful relationship with a delusion. Her spouse was never loved by her, because he was never really known by her, and once he was known, all of his attributes displayed, he was rejected by her for having said attributes.
This is the same thing that often happens with God. People love someone who loves them. People love someone who is sacrificial, merciful, compassionate, etc. But people do not love someone who demands obedience, is condemning of their wayward beliefs and deeds, and who is exclusive, rejecting those who are not in accord with his standards. Hence, when God is accepted by many individuals today, He is accepted as the "loving and gracious God," which then overshadows His other attributes of holiness and being just. He hates sin and is wrathful toward those who practice it without the fear of retribution. But all of this is not usually seen by so many. When they finally come into contact with all of who God is, they are appalled, as our rebellious and corrupt minds and hearts hate authority and a holiness that places us in a less than positive light.
When one of these individuals comes into contact with all of who God is, they want a divorce. They may become atheists, or they go off to some other religion that is "less judgmental," which is connected to the idea of God's holiness and justice, or they may simply still attend a fellowship and call themselves "Christians," but simply reject the God of the whole Bible for the God of half the Bible.
This last group is sort of like the woman who never finds out who her husband is, and instead, desires to live in a delusion. She, in all reality, hates her husband and loves someone else who is not her husband. She just thinks of her husband as that someone else.
Churches have helped in this delusion, as many pastors are equally deluded. They have a half-revealed God, because half truths allow us to distort the truth via willful ignorance. A half truth is a lie, not because it is not true in context of other truths, but because it lacks those other truths to clarify and define the whole truth. It's like saying, "If you jump out of a plane, you'll be fine," and leave out the part where such is only true in the context of one wearing a parachute. Half truths are false truths (if I can put it that way). Likewise, loving half the character of a person is not loving the person at all, as in reality, the truth of who that person really is is not known, and in fact, he would be hated if he was fully known. That person has been rejected for another within the imagination of his spouse.
This is why Jonathan Edwards once argued that one can only finally come to know that he is a Christian who has fully embraced God when he loves God's holiness as much as His other attributes. By nature, we are children of wrath, but we want to see ourselves as good and saved. God's holiness tells us otherwise, so it is something we hate. We hate God's condemning of sins of which we approve. We hate God's wrath upon the Canaanites for their sins when their sins look a lot like ours. We hate God's wrath upon sinners in hell when those sinners look a lot like us as well. We hate God's holiness because it demands of us that we must be holy as well, and we don't want a Holy God, just a gracious God who overlooks sin.
But the Christian has been transformed by God's love to see all of God as good and loveable. He is given a new heart to love what is good despite himself. He understands the gospel fully, rather than only partially, because he understands the holiness of God and what it demanded of us. And, through trial and tribulation, he seeks to become what he loves. The real Christian never divorces God, because he fell in love with all of who God is, not just a god who was glued together from different parts of the Bible outside of their context of His whole character revealed upon all of its pages.
The truth is, we have a lot of "Christians" who divorced God a long time ago. We also have a lot of atheists and other religious adherents who were supposedly once married to God as well. But the point I'm making here is that none of these people were ever married to Him, because they never knew Him, nor were they known by Him. They were always lovers of another god. Such a thing always leads to divorce in one way or another, and so it does with God as well.
For this is a rebellious people, false sons, Sons who refuse to listen To the instruction of the Lord; Who say to the seers, "You must not see [visions]"; And to the prophets, "You must not prophesy to us what is right, Speak to us pleasant words, Prophesy illusions. "Get out of the way, turn aside from the path, Let us hear no more about the Holy One of Israel." (Isa 30:9-11)
"For your husband is your Maker, Whose name is the Lord of hosts; And your Redeemer is the Holy One of Israel, Who is called the God of all the earth. (Isa 54:5)
God says, "If a husband divorces his wife And she goes from him And belongs to another man, Will he still return to her? Will not that land be completely polluted? But you are a harlot [with] many lovers; Yet you turn to Me," declares the Lord. (Jer 3:1)
Our relationship with God is often described (collectively at least) as a marriage. So many seem to enter into that marriage covenant, but end up turning away from the true God in the long run. Why is that?
One of the major reasons I think this is the case is because people often don't "fall in love" with the whole person to whom they are married. Instead, a person will latch on to certain attributes and overemphasize those attributes as encompassing the whole person. Thus, these loveable attributes overshadow other attributes that may be less charming to the specific individual. This is called the halo effect.
We see it when a young girl can't see that the guy she's dating is a complete jerk. That's because there is some charming quality, or qualities, about him that diminish the less than charming attributes and he is perceived just in terms of those charming attributes.
What happens then is that she gets married to the guy. The halo effect slowly disappears, and she ends up seeing all of him. She then thinks, "Who is this? I don't even know this person anymore." Actually, it was that she never knew him in the first place. Her love was never based on knowledge of his whole person, and so her love was never of his whole person, just of an imaginary character that her husband once played in her delusion. She then begins to look for a "better" partner (what this usually means is she looks for someone else with whom she can do the exact same thing), or no partner at all. In other words, she chooses detachment from her covenant promise by divorce/adultery. She chooses either to remain single at that point, perhaps, realizing that the guy she imagined is not out there at all, or she chooses a different guy. The point is that she never knew the person to whom she was married. She never made a commitment to him at all. She merely had a fanciful relationship with a delusion. Her spouse was never loved by her, because he was never really known by her, and once he was known, all of his attributes displayed, he was rejected by her for having said attributes.
This is the same thing that often happens with God. People love someone who loves them. People love someone who is sacrificial, merciful, compassionate, etc. But people do not love someone who demands obedience, is condemning of their wayward beliefs and deeds, and who is exclusive, rejecting those who are not in accord with his standards. Hence, when God is accepted by many individuals today, He is accepted as the "loving and gracious God," which then overshadows His other attributes of holiness and being just. He hates sin and is wrathful toward those who practice it without the fear of retribution. But all of this is not usually seen by so many. When they finally come into contact with all of who God is, they are appalled, as our rebellious and corrupt minds and hearts hate authority and a holiness that places us in a less than positive light.
When one of these individuals comes into contact with all of who God is, they want a divorce. They may become atheists, or they go off to some other religion that is "less judgmental," which is connected to the idea of God's holiness and justice, or they may simply still attend a fellowship and call themselves "Christians," but simply reject the God of the whole Bible for the God of half the Bible.
This last group is sort of like the woman who never finds out who her husband is, and instead, desires to live in a delusion. She, in all reality, hates her husband and loves someone else who is not her husband. She just thinks of her husband as that someone else.
Churches have helped in this delusion, as many pastors are equally deluded. They have a half-revealed God, because half truths allow us to distort the truth via willful ignorance. A half truth is a lie, not because it is not true in context of other truths, but because it lacks those other truths to clarify and define the whole truth. It's like saying, "If you jump out of a plane, you'll be fine," and leave out the part where such is only true in the context of one wearing a parachute. Half truths are false truths (if I can put it that way). Likewise, loving half the character of a person is not loving the person at all, as in reality, the truth of who that person really is is not known, and in fact, he would be hated if he was fully known. That person has been rejected for another within the imagination of his spouse.
This is why Jonathan Edwards once argued that one can only finally come to know that he is a Christian who has fully embraced God when he loves God's holiness as much as His other attributes. By nature, we are children of wrath, but we want to see ourselves as good and saved. God's holiness tells us otherwise, so it is something we hate. We hate God's condemning of sins of which we approve. We hate God's wrath upon the Canaanites for their sins when their sins look a lot like ours. We hate God's wrath upon sinners in hell when those sinners look a lot like us as well. We hate God's holiness because it demands of us that we must be holy as well, and we don't want a Holy God, just a gracious God who overlooks sin.
But the Christian has been transformed by God's love to see all of God as good and loveable. He is given a new heart to love what is good despite himself. He understands the gospel fully, rather than only partially, because he understands the holiness of God and what it demanded of us. And, through trial and tribulation, he seeks to become what he loves. The real Christian never divorces God, because he fell in love with all of who God is, not just a god who was glued together from different parts of the Bible outside of their context of His whole character revealed upon all of its pages.
The truth is, we have a lot of "Christians" who divorced God a long time ago. We also have a lot of atheists and other religious adherents who were supposedly once married to God as well. But the point I'm making here is that none of these people were ever married to Him, because they never knew Him, nor were they known by Him. They were always lovers of another god. Such a thing always leads to divorce in one way or another, and so it does with God as well.
For this is a rebellious people, false sons, Sons who refuse to listen To the instruction of the Lord; Who say to the seers, "You must not see [visions]"; And to the prophets, "You must not prophesy to us what is right, Speak to us pleasant words, Prophesy illusions. "Get out of the way, turn aside from the path, Let us hear no more about the Holy One of Israel." (Isa 30:9-11)
"For your husband is your Maker, Whose name is the Lord of hosts; And your Redeemer is the Holy One of Israel, Who is called the God of all the earth. (Isa 54:5)
God says, "If a husband divorces his wife And she goes from him And belongs to another man, Will he still return to her? Will not that land be completely polluted? But you are a harlot [with] many lovers; Yet you turn to Me," declares the Lord. (Jer 3:1)
Friday, November 21, 2014
Tuesday, November 18, 2014
The Human Faces of Polemics: What Thom Stark's Book Reveals When It Gets Scholarly Methodology Wrong (And Why Liberal Scholarship Tries to Hide It)
This is a short critique of Thom Stark's The Human Faces of God: What Scripture Reveals When It Gets God Wrong (And Why Inerrancy Tries to Hide It) published by Wipf & Stock.
Apart from noting the incredibly arrogant title, the idea that "inerrancy" tries to hide something, rather than "inerrantists," may sound less confrontational, but is extremely nonsensical nonetheless. Ideas don't try to hide things. People do. But, in good humor, I've done the same above to mimic this. Now on to a more serious critique.
Stark's main argument, that the Bible is full of contradictory
theological teachings (and therefore, sometimes "gets God wrong," is supported by a host of misinterpretations garnered
from Stark’s ignorance of the historical, social, and literary context of the
passages he cites. This leads him into a host of logical, factual, and
linguistic errors in his overly-sensationalized attempt to show the Bible to be
riddled with theological error.
1.
Stark argues that the Bible contradicts itself
in terms of whether God judges children for the sins of their parents. He fails
to note in the passages he cites, however, the very nuanced approach the Bible
takes toward such an idea.
a.
The Bible never teaches the idea that children
in the household are separate individuals from their parents. Hence, to punish
a man is to punish all of his possessions, which includes all of the people
(e.g., children) of a household. This is clear from the passages that Stark
mentions concerning children being punished with their parents.
b.
The claim that God does not judge the sons for
the sins or righteousness of the fathers is referring to sons who are no longer
of the household and have made individual choices as independent entities. This
is made clear by the description of what the sons might do in passages such as
Ezekiel 18 (i.e., murder, commit adultery with another man’s wife, etc.). This
is hardly referring to little children, and indeed, refers to an individual who
has parted ways with the ways of his father.
c.
That God visits the judgment of fathers upon
their sons, even to the third and fourth generation, refers to those who
continue to hate God (i.e., those who do not part from the ways of the father
but instead continue in their father’s rebellion, thus receiving the wrath of
God, which the Bible pictures as something that is cumulative when sons do not
depart from the wicked ways of their fathers.
d.
One may not like this idea, but this hardly
shows the Bible to contradict itself. Instead, the contradiction is between our
contemporary culture, its modern sensibilities, and the Bible; but this is
hardly what Stark intends to show. Hence, his argument fails here.
2.
Stark attempts to argue that some passages argue
in favor of “xenophobic” behavior, whereas others argue for more open relations
with people of other nations.
a.
What Stark calls “xenophobia” is a religious concern
in the passages he cites, not an ethnic one. In fact, in the same books that
make such claims against taking women who worship other gods are indications
that such is merely religious in nature (e.g., The Book of Numbers, which
presents Moses as taking an Ethiopian woman for a wife, after having been
married to a Midianite woman, and yet, presents marrying Midianite women as
evil. There are nuances in the text that Stark’s approach simply misses,
intentionally so, in order to make his argument. Another example might be the
fact that Malachi is in the context of Ezra-Nehemiah, and vice versa. The
problem is clearly marrying the daughters of foreign gods, not ethnicity. (See
also the Deuteronomic passages that both forbid marriage with pagans under
condemnation for idolatry and permit marriage with foreign women who are not.)
b.
Stark here, of course, commits an egregious
fallacy in his argument; and as it pervades his entire discourse, we will see
it time and time again. This fallacy is a linguistic one and a bit of sleight
of hand by Stark, one which I am sure he does not realize he is making. This,
of course, is that his argument is intending to show that the Bible contradicts
itself; but he does this by critiquing individual passages that are not the
Bible. Let me explain. The Bible is the entire entity of what orthodox
Christians believe is the Word of God. This is what Stark is attempting to pull
apart as errant. However, in order to do so, Stark must make the Bible into
individual pieces that are no longer the Bible, but passages ripped out of that
context and placed within alternate contexts in order to say something
different than what they say in the context of the Bible as a whole. The
problem is that orthodox Christians don’t believe these individual passages
communicate what the Bible says as a whole. They merely contribute to the
larger picture of what the whole Bible says. Hence, it is much like hearing a
point made by a speaker and ignoring any qualifications and nuances that
speaker makes to clarify his point. One could then take the whole discourse of
that speaker and turn it against itself by ignoring these nuances, taking them
out separately from one another, and then pitting them against one another, as
though the speaker had contradicted himself, rather than clarified his
statements with nuanced qualifications. It’s really a major fallacy of
communication that refuses to participate in the communicative process with the
speaker simply because one either doesn’t have the linguistic and logical
ability to take things in context, or because one merely wants to prove that
the speaker should not be trusted. I’m afraid Stark’s book seems to be a bit of
both. If Stark wants to make his case against the Bible of evangelicals (his
foil), he’s going to have to engage with their concept of the Bible, not a
linguistically fallacious hybrid that seems to make up his own. Unfortunately,
Stark not only does this with the Bible as a whole, but also with individual
texts, as we will see.
3.
Stark attempts to argue that the Bible teaches
child sacrifice. This is accomplished by taking a text out of its current
context and speculating as to what the history of a word, phrase, or sentence
may have been in an ancient Canaanite/Paleo-Israelite context.
a.
The problem, of course, is that this commits the
fallacy above. All scholars agree that when one takes these passages in their
literary biblical contexts, they do not teach child sacrifice, but rather child
dedication. This etymological fallacy is well known by most scholars, and yet,
such a diachronic methodology to answer a question that only a synchronic
investigation can answer is absolutely needed if one is to buy into Stark’s
argument here. For those of us who are linguistically trained, we’ll keep our
money in our pockets.
b.
Not only is the methodology of concern, but the
speculative nature of such reconstructions assumes a knowledge of the original
authors of such an idea that we simply do not have. Yet, again, one absolutely
needs to confirm such knowledge in order to make the claim that the original author
intended to convey such and such an idea. No such confirmation is, or can be,
made by those scholars who peddle this idea, as the original context (if there
really was one) is lost and cannot confirm such an interpretation (and, as said before, all
admit that the idea has been radically transformed in the biblical texts, so
that the “Bible” of orthodox Christians does not actually teach such an idea at
all).
4.
Stark also argues along the same lines that the
Bible teaches polytheism as well as henotheism and monotheism.
a.
The same etymological fallacy can be pinned on
this wildly popular idea. This, again, ignores that a phrase may or may not
carry its implicatures depending upon whether the context repeats the
contextual referents of the original context. In other words, as I’ve argued
before, an implicature does not carry in a foreign context, and it certainly
cannot be assumed in a context where the implicature is often contradicted,
such as the idea of polytheism in the religious context of ancient Israel, and
especially, within the literary context of the Bible. Instead, words and
phrases that once carried a particular implicature in a foreign context often
become figurative expressions that convey a specific meaning that no longer
carries the implicature. For instance, the phrase, “Aphrodite is the goddess of
love” in an ancient Graeco-Roman polytheistic context implies that “goddesses [literally]
exist.” However, change the context to a non-polytheistic one, and a phrase
such as, “Tyra is the goddess of fashion,” does not carry the implicature that
goddesses exist in a literal sense at all, but rather that, in a figurative/analogical
sense only, Tyra is the highest of all other fashionistas. The implicature has
been lost in a monotheistic/agnostic/atheistic context.
Stark, as well as others who advocate this position (Mark Smith being the
most prominent), fails to note this, and by doing so, begs the question as to
whether a text conveys polytheism.
b.
He further commits the same fallacy along these
same lines by failing to note that in its biblical context (whether within that
of a book or section of books, such as Deuteronomy or the Deuteronomistic
History) polytheistic phrases exist inside the context of monotheistic theology,
and hence, do not carry their implicatures. Hence, his argument, yet again, has
him arguing for the errancy of a fictitious Bible of his own making, not the
one in which orthodox Christians believe. If Stark were to have entitled his
book, “Why My Reconstructed and Dissected Bible Is Errant” one would have no
problem with agreeing with him. However, Stark’s Bible is clearly meant to be
conflated with the Bible in which the average evangelical believes, which makes
the argument a bit of a bait and switch.
5.
Finally, in an effort to try and catch
evangelicals in a pickle, Stark argues that if inerrancy is true then Jesus was
errant because He predicted that the end of the world would occur within the
lifetime of the apostles, and it didn’t.
a.
Of course, Jesus could have been wrong about the
time of His coming, since immediately after He states this, He states that He
doesn’t actually know when the time of the end will occur. In fact, this should
be the first clue that there are two different things going on here, since He
states with great certainty what time frame the event He is addressing will
occur, and then continues to say that He has no knowledge of when it will
occur.
b.
Stark seems to be unaware of the more likely
interpretation of this passage, which is the partial-Preterist view that Jesus
is talking about the destruction of Jerusalem in this context. Along with it,
as apocalypticism almost always does, is a description of the micro-event as
though it was the macro-event of the end. Again, it is likely this distinction that
Christ has in mind by saying that He both knows when it (i.e., the destruction
of the temple/Jerusalem) will occur and does not know when it (i.e., the end of
the world/the Second Coming) will
occur. This would take more than a paragraph to demonstrate, but Second Temple
Jewish apocalyptic texts often mesh a micro-event with the macro-events (i.e.,
either the commencement of the creation of the world or the consummation of
that creation) as though they were one single event. That John Collins, a
Second Temple scholar, endorsed and wrote the foreword to the book is all the more surprising, but apparently
liberal apologetics wins out over genuine scholarship when evangelicals are the
target. We see this often with the nonsense over at Peter Enns’s blog (another
liberal Second Temple commentator that Stark thanks in his preface).
6.
There is, of course, an epistemological naïveté
in the book. Stark seems to think that one does not need an inerrant source of
truth in order to know truth, and this is simply rubbish to anyone who has
studied the issue. If a finite being with finite knowledge does not have an
inerrant source of truth that stems from a transcendent infinite being then one
cannot know anything. He can only guess at everything in the dark without any
knowledge of whether he is moving closer or further away from the truth and the
good. What Stark is essentially arguing for, as most liberals do, is for an
intuitive inerrant source, where one patches into the divine truth from one’s
own nature. Much theology can be added to this ad hoc, such as the Holy Spirit
guides humans into truth and whatnot, but the question will always be how one
knows any of this. If liberals want to argue that they believe in their intuition
in the same way that orthodox Christians believe in the Bible, that’s fine with
me. I agree that they do. The problem is simply that this is not a version of
Christianity. It is simply one more expression of the anti-Logos, in replace of
the one who is Christ Himself revealed in words, and a completely different
religion than that of orthodox Christianity which is an externally-oriented, revealed
religion and not an internally-oriented revealed one, as all pagan religions
and non-religions are. With liberalism, Stark carries in a host of presuppositions (not merely bias--note the difference please) concerning the nature of God, man, the Bible, etc. that cannot be critically evaluated without first assuming a different set of presuppositions by which to measure them. Hence, we are left with faith, not scholarship, and this is merely one faith telling another faith that it is wrong. But, again, this was not the claim made in the book. Stark
did not set out to counter orthodox Christianity with his alternate religion,
at least that is not what he claimed to be doing. Instead, if he wanted to
reach the goal of his argument, he needed to accept the Bible that orthodox
Christians have accepted, and show that their beliefs concerning it are
internally invalid. He could not do that. Hence, we got the argument he gave,
and not the one that we needed in order to see his position as a valid one.
There is a lot more I could say
about his other minor arguments that also have to do with particular
interpretations of passages, but I think the above should suffice in showing
that this book was received well by the liberal community of scholars either
because (1) they’re so bent on undermining traditions and traditional
Christianity that they don’t mind supporting an M.A.R. student who is willing
to use any bad argument possible to undermine it, or (2) that they simply make
the same mistakes daily in their classrooms and works that they think that
Stark’s scholarship is sound. I’m going to be generous and say that it’s likely
a mixture of both. In either case, however, the substandard state of
scholarship in terms of being critical of its own methodologies is put on
display for all eyes to see if one is so inclined to see it.
Friday, October 31, 2014
Begotten or Made?
The boys over at Mere Fidelity had a nice little conversation about the book Begotten or Made? by Oliver O'Donovan, a book that discusses all sorts of issues about procreation, what makes a human, abortion, artificial insemination, adoption, etc. If you get a chance, check it out.
Wednesday, October 1, 2014
The Time In Between
Much is made that almost 2,000 years has passed since Christ died, rose, and said He would return. In Preterist thought, the interval of 40 years seems more palatable than one which is of such a great length. Hence, the millennium, i.e., the time in between, is interpreted to be a figurative number representing that 40 years.
It should be noted that the thousand year period in Revelation is, in fact, a figurative number. John adds chiliads to various representative numbers to display the vastness of the number. Hence, the 12 tribes of Israel, each described with the number 1,000, multiplied by the 12 apostles who sit as judges to guide Israel are said to be 144,000 (i.e., a number that represents the church).
The idea here is not that the church is made up of only 144,000 people, nor is it to convey the idea that there are literally 144,000 virgin Jewish men from each tribe that will become Christians, but rather it exists to communicate the idea that the number that belong to Christ, the size of His Church, is vast. The idea is that there are so many that they can be simply represented by a sizable number like 1,000. In other words, the number is figurative and represents another number, but the the number it represents is vastly larger than the literal number itself. It is never used in Revelation of a number that is lower than itself--indeed, such a use would negate the very purpose of the number.
Hence, it cannot be that the number represents 40 years, and indeed, makes more sense that it represents 2,000 or more years instead.
But something else is interesting about which I don't hear a lot of discussion, and that is that the work of Christ is pictured in the Bible, and in early Christianity, as framed by the festivals, especially in terms of the Spring Feasts and the Fall Feasts with an interval period in between that is characterized by harvesting. Christ fulfills, not just certain festivals, but all of them. Hence, His ministry looks more like the following.
Spring Feasts
Christ's Death (historia salutis) - Passover
Christ in the Grave - Feast of Unleavened Bread (Removing the Leaven from Bread [i.e., removing sin among His people].
Christ's Resurrection - First Fruits (Christ's resurrection is referred to as this in some passages: 1 Cor 15:20, 23;
Pentecost (The Feast of Weeks) - The Holy Spirit Is Given as a Promise of Our Full Future Redemption (This is the day we are in).
The intermediate period between the feasts is harvest time, a time of ingathering. This is likely the time that represents the ingathering of the Gentiles as Christ's.
Fall Feasts
Proclamation of Victory in the Return of Christ - The Feast of Trumpets
The Full Application of the Redemption Christ has done on the Cross (ordo salutis) - The Day of Atonement (the day where cleansing takes place by applying the blood of the sacrifice to both the people and the tabernacle/temple, which represents all of creation in ANE and biblical society).
The Consummation of the New World at the Wedding Feast - Feast of Tabernacles (a gathering in of the year's final harvest and the remembrance of when we were in the wilderness)
Now, of course, one might take issue with the way these are used here, as the purpose of the feasts in relation to what Christ did are not that explicitly clear, but I do think it is interesting that ingathering of the harvest of Israel's various crops begins around the time of the first feast and ends at the time of the Feast of Tabernacles. If we do make a correspondence here, we might ask why we would consider the current time in which we are living as the consummation of the new world after the Feast of Tabernacles has taken place, rather than the intermediate period where the harvest is still being gathered in, a harvest said not to be completed until Christ returns to gather His elect from the four corners of heaven and earth.
This is really more of a "think about this" argument than it is some knock-down argument, but I do find it interesting at least to think about in terms of how long the millennium might be. If it is characterized by Christ gathering in His elect, then it could actually continue for some time, especially when we take note of the previous idea that the number 1,000 represents a larger amount of X than the literal number represents, not a lower amount of X than the literal number represents.
It should be noted that the thousand year period in Revelation is, in fact, a figurative number. John adds chiliads to various representative numbers to display the vastness of the number. Hence, the 12 tribes of Israel, each described with the number 1,000, multiplied by the 12 apostles who sit as judges to guide Israel are said to be 144,000 (i.e., a number that represents the church).
The idea here is not that the church is made up of only 144,000 people, nor is it to convey the idea that there are literally 144,000 virgin Jewish men from each tribe that will become Christians, but rather it exists to communicate the idea that the number that belong to Christ, the size of His Church, is vast. The idea is that there are so many that they can be simply represented by a sizable number like 1,000. In other words, the number is figurative and represents another number, but the the number it represents is vastly larger than the literal number itself. It is never used in Revelation of a number that is lower than itself--indeed, such a use would negate the very purpose of the number.
Hence, it cannot be that the number represents 40 years, and indeed, makes more sense that it represents 2,000 or more years instead.
But something else is interesting about which I don't hear a lot of discussion, and that is that the work of Christ is pictured in the Bible, and in early Christianity, as framed by the festivals, especially in terms of the Spring Feasts and the Fall Feasts with an interval period in between that is characterized by harvesting. Christ fulfills, not just certain festivals, but all of them. Hence, His ministry looks more like the following.
Spring Feasts
Christ's Death (historia salutis) - Passover
Christ in the Grave - Feast of Unleavened Bread (Removing the Leaven from Bread [i.e., removing sin among His people].
Christ's Resurrection - First Fruits (Christ's resurrection is referred to as this in some passages: 1 Cor 15:20, 23;
Pentecost (The Feast of Weeks) - The Holy Spirit Is Given as a Promise of Our Full Future Redemption (This is the day we are in).
The intermediate period between the feasts is harvest time, a time of ingathering. This is likely the time that represents the ingathering of the Gentiles as Christ's.
Fall Feasts
Proclamation of Victory in the Return of Christ - The Feast of Trumpets
The Full Application of the Redemption Christ has done on the Cross (ordo salutis) - The Day of Atonement (the day where cleansing takes place by applying the blood of the sacrifice to both the people and the tabernacle/temple, which represents all of creation in ANE and biblical society).
The Consummation of the New World at the Wedding Feast - Feast of Tabernacles (a gathering in of the year's final harvest and the remembrance of when we were in the wilderness)
Now, of course, one might take issue with the way these are used here, as the purpose of the feasts in relation to what Christ did are not that explicitly clear, but I do think it is interesting that ingathering of the harvest of Israel's various crops begins around the time of the first feast and ends at the time of the Feast of Tabernacles. If we do make a correspondence here, we might ask why we would consider the current time in which we are living as the consummation of the new world after the Feast of Tabernacles has taken place, rather than the intermediate period where the harvest is still being gathered in, a harvest said not to be completed until Christ returns to gather His elect from the four corners of heaven and earth.
This is really more of a "think about this" argument than it is some knock-down argument, but I do find it interesting at least to think about in terms of how long the millennium might be. If it is characterized by Christ gathering in His elect, then it could actually continue for some time, especially when we take note of the previous idea that the number 1,000 represents a larger amount of X than the literal number represents, not a lower amount of X than the literal number represents.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)