Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Wars Are Fought over What?

You often hear the claim that religious wars make up the vast majority of wars throughout history. However, this is one of those common folk myths spread by unscrupulous rhetoricians.

In reality, only six percent of wars throughout history have been fought over religion, and if we exclude the wars fought by Islam, it reduces to almost half of that at around 3.3%.

In what world exactly does 3.3% make up the majority? And that 3.3% isn't all Christian either. That means the amount of Christian wars fought over religion are even less than that.

So why does Christianity get so much blame for war? I think it has to do with three factors:

1. The Crusades were a massive event in Western history. That war was primarily between Christians and Muslims (as well as Christians and Christians). Then the wars that took place after the Reformation between Christians became a sad part of our history in the West as well. So it just seems like a lot of war was caused by religion.

2. The culture wars are often divided in America between those who are more conservatively religious versus those who are more liberal or secular. Hence, it is surmised that the reason these conservative Christian troublemakers start so much conflict in our culture is because they've always been starting wars, and the Crusades and Reformation wars confirm that liberal narrative.

3. If one is to make an argument for inclusivist pluralism, he must first knock down any exclusivism that stands in its way. That's conservative religion. Hence, one needs to present it in the worst light possible. Hence, the liberal Western narrative becomes one where religion, not land, honor, oil, weapons, tribute/money, vendettas, tribalism, politics, etc. is the main cause of war. Enlightened people who are less dogmatically religious stay out of wars and even prevent them. Of course, Stalin, Hitler, Mao, and Pol Pot are merely interpreted as exceptions rather than the rule.

In any case, it's a false narrative. The conflict is surely wrought in differing beliefs, but some beliefs are more tolerant than others. Christianity does not believe in forcing beliefs upon people, but in Islamic and atheistic beliefs, the primary vehicle for conversion is through control of influential authorities and ultimately force when such an influence is rendered ineffective. The real conflict for Christians, however, is not of flesh and blood.

For an interesting read, see:


http://www.psmag.com/culture/myth-of-the-modern-religious-war-34617/

As well as:

The Futility of Knowing Jesus via Neo-Marcionism



Sunday, August 18, 2013

Saturday, August 17, 2013

Ἀνήρ Doesn't Mean "Husband"

I'm preparing for my sermon tomorrow on the exclusivity of Christ and how it relates to our union with Christ, and came across this translation by the NET Bible.

But to all who have received him – those who believe in his name – he has given the right to become God’s children – children not born by human parents or by human desire or a husband’s decision, but by God.

Now, I generally like the NET Bible translation, but occasionally I come across a translation that I think misunderstands some important exegetical rules. This is one of them. Notice, that the clause that reads "or a husband's decision" has taken anēr as "husband." 

This is a common misunderstanding of the word. One often hears that anēr means "husband."

Of course, anēr means "man," usually in distinction from anthrōpos that can be used for individuals or collectively, since anēr usually only refers to an individual man. 

Now, this is where it gets tricky. The word anēr can refer to any sort of individual man, including a husband. It can also refer to an individual man who is not a husband. It can refer to an individual man who is a anything, because it just means "man."

Liddel and Scott attempted to argue that anēr was distinguished from anthrōpos by positing that the former was in distinction from women and the latter was in distinction from animals (LSJ). Hence, the former is one of gender of the human species and the latter one of species.

However, it is clear that the word refers to man in terms of species as well. Instead, most examples seem to emphasize individuals, even within a group of men, as opposed to seeing the group as a collective whole. Of course, the two can be interchangeable in the sense that anthrōpos can refer to an individual man as well, but anēr seems to be used mostly to refer to individuals, and thus, may be used in order to emphasize an individual focus.

When the word can be used to refer to a husband, that reference must be contextual. In other words, since the word does not mean "husband," one cannot plug in that meaning when the context does not speak of family or wives.

Now, one might argue, as some scholars have done, that John is attempting to show that the human father in a patriarchal society does not decide who becomes a son of God, but this is a bit far-fetched. Human fathers didn't choose such things anyway. Also, if this is what John really meant, why did he not say, "or by the will of human father"? Why does he, instead, supposedly say, "husband"? John already emphasized that flesh and blood does not produce sons of God. It may refer to what a human father desires, but it makes little sense to describe the man as a husband.

There are also issues of seeing John's larger theology, which is to argue that salvation is the result of God's will, not a human individual's will. Hence, it is likely that "man" here should be understood as any individual man, not just "husbands," which, again, makes little sense here, even if a father is in view.

This is why it is important to understand meaning versus referent. A meaning can be understood and nuanced in any passage. It is the nucleus of a lexeme which can everywhere be transferred in some way to the context in which the word occurs. A referent is a nuance a word can only take upon itself in a particular context where the word references something specific. Hence, the context, not the word, provides the referent, and it is not transferable to another context that does not contain that same referent.

Hence, the word anēr does not mean "husband." It can refer to a husband in some contexts that refer to husbands specifically, but it cannot produce that referent in a context that does not.