Allison and I have finally found our church. It's a reformed church that's a little far from us, but it will be worth the drive. One of the things I liked about it was the fact that they change some words to popular songs to be more biblical and theologically accurate. One of the songs they changed was the one entitled "Above All."
I've always hated this song, precisely, because it was so "me-centered" and self-focused. The song originally reads, "And thought of me above all," as the primary motivation for Christ to have died on the cross. But this isn't biblical, and it shows how distorted love really is within our modern (self deified) understanding.
The Bible tells us that Christ was seeking God, the Father's, glory above all. He was seeking to humble Himself to the obedience of the Father in love of God above all. His love for us flows out of that. In fact, He cannot love us at all if He does not first love and seek the glory of God above all, precisely, because to love man more than God is to respect what man wants above what God wants.
That is a flipping upside down of the command to love God and then love one another. If I love others more than God then I have to just respect their ideas that dishonor Him. I have to respect their choices in life instead of exalt His demands and call them to repentance.
In fact, it is only through Christ's love of God that the love of others is accomplished. If Christ never exalted God over men, then He would have never offended anyone in order to get Himself crucified in the first place. It was through His love of the Father that He could love others.
And that is true for us as well. No one can love another human being outside of loving God first, since if God is not exalted above all in another person's life, their life will come to death and judgment. Actions that contribute to this can only be seen as hatred and evil toward another, not love. Hence, to "love" others outside of seeking to exalt God in both your words to them and your own example is hatred, not love.
It is Christ who demonstrates, then, that His love for us is not greater than His love for God. And this is why the first commandment is about loving God. It is the second commandment that flows from it that then becomes possible. Without the first, there is no possibility of the second. And that is why Christ did not think of me, but rather the exaltation and love of God ABOVE ALL.
Sunday, April 7, 2013
Saturday, April 6, 2013
The Wisdom of Drew
At least she's sacrificing the right thing now that she knows better. Most women who haven't achieved the "success" she's had in the world are like the poor with the lottery. The poor think, "If only I can get my hands on that money, my life would be so much more worthwhile." That's what women who sacrifice their families for worldly success believe about it. "If I only achieve this or that, then I'll be fulfilled and feel my sense of worth."
I meet a lot of older women, who have a child, or children, now grown, when I'm walking along with my kids who tell me, "I wish I had spent more time with my kids." "I wish I had more of them." "I wish I had just an hour more with them being young."
Not one of them has ever commented that they wish they had worked more and had more success in other pursuits. Not one. Yet, how many younger and middle-aged women, going through a midlife crisis, have given up their families, whether practically or literally, in an effort to be all they can be?
Incline your ear to wisdom. Listen to Drew.
Friday, April 5, 2013
Actually, It's Not OK
I went to school with Peter. I was on the student council with him, and there were some issues back then that made it clear where his theological trajectory was headed, so none of this surprises me. However, I just want to point out how arrogant it is to make these following statements:
Step #1 “It’s OK to see God differently”
Step #2 “It’s OK to see the Bible differently”
Step #3 “It’s OK to see salvation differently”
Step #4 “It’s OK to see the earth differently”
Step #5 “It’s OK to see prayer differently”
Step #6 “It’s OK to see sex differently”
Step #7 “It’s OK to see your destiny differently”
Who is Haas, or anyone else for that matter, to say what is OK and what isn't? I hear liberal apostates say this all the time, and yet, what is the basis for saying it? Unless you have a direct line with God, then actually, you have no basis for saying this. It would just be as equally viable to say that it's not OK to see any of this differently. And the thing is, if we're talking about the biblical view of these things, then there is more warrant for evangelicals to argue that it's not OK than it is for liberals, who have only their own self appointed authority, gained via experience, to judge what is OK and what is not.
But what is to decide between us? I say orthodoxy, both in and outside the Bible would reject these claims. Imagine if Haas had said them to the heretics. It's OK because Peter Haas said so.
"Sabellius, it's OK to see God differently."
"Marcion, it's OK to see the Bible differently."
"Judaizers, it's OK to see salvation differently."
"Valentinus, it's OK to see the earth differently."
"Jezebel, it's OK to see sex differently."
"Mary Baker Eddy, it's OK to see your destiny differently."
Um, no, according to real Christianity, it isn't. This is one of the main problems with contemplatives that I was talking about. They end up going into this type of spirituality because they cannot submit themselves to God's Word.
Now, if you want to say that evangelicalism has gotten all of these things wrong because they have failed to submit to the Bible, that's one thing. But that's not what is really being said here. You should understand that when liberals say "evangelicalism" what they really mean is "historic orthodox Christianity." BTW, just another irony, most contemplative monks throughout Church History would have condemned Peter as a heretic for saying the above. That's because many contemplatives remained orthodox on many of the issues above.
"Corrupters of families will not inherit the kingdom of God. And if they
who do these things according to the flesh suffer death, how much more
if a man corrupts by evil teaching the faith of God for the sake of which
Jesus Christ was crucified? A man who becomes so foul will depart into
unquenchable fire: and so will anyone who listens to him" (Letter to the Ephesians 16:1–2 [A.D. 110]).
When are people going to stop eating the self-deification fruit of that tree? These pronouncements don't belong to you. You may repeat what God says about them. Nothing more. Humble yourself in the sight of the Lord and tremble at His Word.
Why Contemplative Christianity Is Neither Contemplative Nor Christianity: Part I
As I've noted before here, heresies often come in waves. The first waves are usually more explicit. Christians deal with their challenge to the faith by contemplating theological truths more deeply. They have the ability of moving immature Christians, who don't think much of deeper theological truths, into a firmer understanding and beatification of that theological truth. Hence, God is said to place them among His people for that very reason. Those who stand against the heretics and move into deeper maturity in the truth show themselves approved by God.
But heresy, once largely defeated, comes around again for a second swing at things. This time it comes implicitly in other more acceptable doctrines that assume its truth.
Because of this, heresies, such as Gnosticism, in the early church, were rejected explicitly, but many times accepted implicitly through the adoption of other theological ideas or practices, absent of its more extreme forms of dispute, that assumed it. One of these theological ideas, really an entire theological framework, is found in the apophatic theology of contemplatives.
Apophatic theology is a theology of the negative. In other words, it can only look at the world around it and say what God is not, since to say positively that God is X is merely an analogy built upon the world, and God is not equal to anything in the world. The world is therefore not sufficient to describe God as He is. It can only describe Him in approximation, but approximation is as accurate as it is inaccurate. Hence, kataphatic theology, a theology of positive statements built upon the analogy used by language is a necessary, but insufficient step on one's journey toward truly knowing God.
As Gregory of Nyssa argued, the more one says about God, the less he knows about Him. To attempt to know God through language as the goal of one's faith is to remain in an immature state of spirituality. God's essence must be known directly and experientially. Hence, the mature believer must transcend language in order to know God.
The link to Gnosticism is really found in a couple of the ideas assumed by apophatic theology. The first is that there is a higher secret knowledge of God that can only be attained by those most spiritually in tune with the divine. It is not accessible to babes (contra Matt 11:25), and it cannot be attained through any medium in this crude world.
The second link is found in the idea that language and the world of analogy it utilizes are too below God to speak of Him accurately. There is a higher knowledge of God that must transcend the base world. God is completely other than this crude world, and as such, cannot be described by it. There is thus a disdain for the material world and its abilities to bring one to a mature knowledge of/relationship with God.This often leads to a rejection and replacement of the God, Jesus, and gospel of the Bible with some other God, some other Jesus, and some other gospel, as well as, in our day, a denial of all sorts of biblical ethics. We might say that the apophatic theology of the mystics often leads to practical Marcionism as opposed to theoretical Marcionism, where one does not explicitly deny the teaching of the whole Bible, but rather rejects it via alternate interpretations and uses of the texts that were once meant to convey that teaching.
Hence, language, such as that used by the Bible to communicate God, and therefore the Bible itself, is just one lower step on the staircase upon which one must step to get closer to the top, but there are many other steps beyond it that leave it far behind in one's spiritual journey.
What this does is to allow the contemplative to experience God directly without a medium, since a medium is inadequate to communicate God anyway. It is an attempt to remove the darkness of the created world from our knowing God, which is really what blinds us from knowing Him, since it hides God when we think we know Him through it rather than reveals who He really is, and allows us to experience God in pure light and mystical enlightenment.
Thus, this allowed contemplatives to turn the Bible itself into a book of allegories, especially when it conflicted with the contemplative's own religious ideas, since His knowledge of God came from his own personal and direct experience of God and he was capable now of critiquing the lesser medium made up of analogy and approximate claims about God.
Ergo, one sees Gregory of Nyssa speaking of certain texts needing to be reinterpreted because they were unworthy of God. One would only presumably know this if there was some other standard besides the Bible with which to critique the biblical portrait of God.
But what this really does is make the individual the final arbiter of truth. The Bible must bow to his own religious ideals. And this clearly happens to most contemplatives. Hence, they end up denying all sorts of scriptural teachings in favor of their own visions of God (e.g., Gregory Nyssa rejected the idea that hell was eternal and that it merely functioned as a way, albeit painfully, to save both men and devils alike--thus, rejecting the necessity of trusting the gospel for salvation). Similar biblical teachings are denied when they do not accord with the contemplative's experience, a view of those teachings that bears striking similarity with the positions trending within the contemporary world of the mystic.
But an emptying of the mind of language is hardly worthy of the designation "contemplative." In reality, it is the exact opposite of that. Instead, the goal is to, in the words of Obiwan Kenobi, "put away your conscience self," and "feel the force," oh, I mean, "God." This is Self getting to define God as it experiences Him. This is Ego getting to dictate to the Bible what it can and cannot say about God. It is not that mystics have nothing to say about God. Of course they do. They just use this ploy as a way of arguing that their own visions of God are more reliable and accurate than the biblical relation of God. Hence, they make all sorts of dogmatic statements about God in practice, and retreat to the idea that God cannot be described adequately in language only in theory.
But my primary point here is not that mysticism is Gnosticism. It does assume ideas very similar to it. Nor is it my point to merely say that one should not experience God. My point is to say, however, that an attempt to bypass the Scripture as the supreme authority by which one must interpret all experiences of "God" is yet another manifestation of the religion of the Self. It puts me in control of even the Bible itself. The Bible now can say nothing contradictory to my own preconceived views of God gained from my personal and direct experience of Him. That's because I am the supreme authority now. And I should be if I am experiencing God directly and biblical language is only capable of relating God approximately.
My point in bring this up in Part I is to say that any religion of the Self is not a religion of Christianity, and that is why Contemplative Christianity is neither contemplative nor Christianity. It is another religion that seats the Self as the receiver of God's true essence that cannot be known through any other medium, and it, therefore, does not seek contemplation of the Scripture, but rather to remove the analogies that Scripture puts in one's mind in an effort to achieve a higher vision of God directly experienced.
Part II will discuss the charge of bibliolatry and why it is necessary to have a supreme authoritative medium that is external to self in order to achieve both genuine contemplation of who God is and true Christian maturity.
But heresy, once largely defeated, comes around again for a second swing at things. This time it comes implicitly in other more acceptable doctrines that assume its truth.
Because of this, heresies, such as Gnosticism, in the early church, were rejected explicitly, but many times accepted implicitly through the adoption of other theological ideas or practices, absent of its more extreme forms of dispute, that assumed it. One of these theological ideas, really an entire theological framework, is found in the apophatic theology of contemplatives.
Apophatic theology is a theology of the negative. In other words, it can only look at the world around it and say what God is not, since to say positively that God is X is merely an analogy built upon the world, and God is not equal to anything in the world. The world is therefore not sufficient to describe God as He is. It can only describe Him in approximation, but approximation is as accurate as it is inaccurate. Hence, kataphatic theology, a theology of positive statements built upon the analogy used by language is a necessary, but insufficient step on one's journey toward truly knowing God.
As Gregory of Nyssa argued, the more one says about God, the less he knows about Him. To attempt to know God through language as the goal of one's faith is to remain in an immature state of spirituality. God's essence must be known directly and experientially. Hence, the mature believer must transcend language in order to know God.
The link to Gnosticism is really found in a couple of the ideas assumed by apophatic theology. The first is that there is a higher secret knowledge of God that can only be attained by those most spiritually in tune with the divine. It is not accessible to babes (contra Matt 11:25), and it cannot be attained through any medium in this crude world.
The second link is found in the idea that language and the world of analogy it utilizes are too below God to speak of Him accurately. There is a higher knowledge of God that must transcend the base world. God is completely other than this crude world, and as such, cannot be described by it. There is thus a disdain for the material world and its abilities to bring one to a mature knowledge of/relationship with God.This often leads to a rejection and replacement of the God, Jesus, and gospel of the Bible with some other God, some other Jesus, and some other gospel, as well as, in our day, a denial of all sorts of biblical ethics. We might say that the apophatic theology of the mystics often leads to practical Marcionism as opposed to theoretical Marcionism, where one does not explicitly deny the teaching of the whole Bible, but rather rejects it via alternate interpretations and uses of the texts that were once meant to convey that teaching.
Hence, language, such as that used by the Bible to communicate God, and therefore the Bible itself, is just one lower step on the staircase upon which one must step to get closer to the top, but there are many other steps beyond it that leave it far behind in one's spiritual journey.
What this does is to allow the contemplative to experience God directly without a medium, since a medium is inadequate to communicate God anyway. It is an attempt to remove the darkness of the created world from our knowing God, which is really what blinds us from knowing Him, since it hides God when we think we know Him through it rather than reveals who He really is, and allows us to experience God in pure light and mystical enlightenment.
Thus, this allowed contemplatives to turn the Bible itself into a book of allegories, especially when it conflicted with the contemplative's own religious ideas, since His knowledge of God came from his own personal and direct experience of God and he was capable now of critiquing the lesser medium made up of analogy and approximate claims about God.
Ergo, one sees Gregory of Nyssa speaking of certain texts needing to be reinterpreted because they were unworthy of God. One would only presumably know this if there was some other standard besides the Bible with which to critique the biblical portrait of God.
But what this really does is make the individual the final arbiter of truth. The Bible must bow to his own religious ideals. And this clearly happens to most contemplatives. Hence, they end up denying all sorts of scriptural teachings in favor of their own visions of God (e.g., Gregory Nyssa rejected the idea that hell was eternal and that it merely functioned as a way, albeit painfully, to save both men and devils alike--thus, rejecting the necessity of trusting the gospel for salvation). Similar biblical teachings are denied when they do not accord with the contemplative's experience, a view of those teachings that bears striking similarity with the positions trending within the contemporary world of the mystic.
But an emptying of the mind of language is hardly worthy of the designation "contemplative." In reality, it is the exact opposite of that. Instead, the goal is to, in the words of Obiwan Kenobi, "put away your conscience self," and "feel the force," oh, I mean, "God." This is Self getting to define God as it experiences Him. This is Ego getting to dictate to the Bible what it can and cannot say about God. It is not that mystics have nothing to say about God. Of course they do. They just use this ploy as a way of arguing that their own visions of God are more reliable and accurate than the biblical relation of God. Hence, they make all sorts of dogmatic statements about God in practice, and retreat to the idea that God cannot be described adequately in language only in theory.
But my primary point here is not that mysticism is Gnosticism. It does assume ideas very similar to it. Nor is it my point to merely say that one should not experience God. My point is to say, however, that an attempt to bypass the Scripture as the supreme authority by which one must interpret all experiences of "God" is yet another manifestation of the religion of the Self. It puts me in control of even the Bible itself. The Bible now can say nothing contradictory to my own preconceived views of God gained from my personal and direct experience of Him. That's because I am the supreme authority now. And I should be if I am experiencing God directly and biblical language is only capable of relating God approximately.
My point in bring this up in Part I is to say that any religion of the Self is not a religion of Christianity, and that is why Contemplative Christianity is neither contemplative nor Christianity. It is another religion that seats the Self as the receiver of God's true essence that cannot be known through any other medium, and it, therefore, does not seek contemplation of the Scripture, but rather to remove the analogies that Scripture puts in one's mind in an effort to achieve a higher vision of God directly experienced.
Part II will discuss the charge of bibliolatry and why it is necessary to have a supreme authoritative medium that is external to self in order to achieve both genuine contemplation of who God is and true Christian maturity.
Wednesday, April 3, 2013
Why Being a Pastor Is Better Than Being a Scholar
When I was in school, I learned all sorts of tools to study the Bible properly. I learned proper lexicography using a more robust linguistic analysis of the text that employed, yet distinguished diachronic and synchronic methodologies, discourse analysis, advanced grammatical and syntactical studies of Hebrew and Greek, ancient Near Eastern and Second Temple archaeology and texts as the sociological and conceptual context, etc.
But all of these tools brought me only so far in understanding a text. Of course, at the time, since I understood it a little better than I had before, I never realized that I didn't quite get it. I thought these methodologies gave me the key to understand the Scripture, so I employed them as I sought to advance within the academic community.
But something happened that disrupted my plans to get a PhD in Hebrew Bible from Harvard, a PhD in New Testament from Cambridge, and a Habilitation in Theology at the University of Tübingen, along with lesser M.A.'s in Philosophy, Egyptology, Assyriology, and Church History. Life.
Of course, the best laid plans are often interrupted by real life, and I had gotten married, had my first son, and didn't get into Harvard. So I simply fell back on what I viewed as a temporary occupation while I waited a year to reapply to more schools. I entered into ministry as a pastor, and it is there that I began to use all of the tools I had learned in school for a different purpose than I had done before.
I didn't use them for my own personal understanding of the Scripture or for my own academic advancement within a highly competitive field, but instead in the service of God's people. As I did this, the Scripture opened up to me. I was able to see what these books were actually saying. What I thought I understood before by mere tools applied with technical precision became a joke to what I understood in the light of really seeing these texts for the first time in ministry.
To back up a little, when I first learned Hebrew, I would use a lot of lexicographical, grammatical, and syntactical sources. I would rely upon them as though they were like the bibles of Hebrew language study. But I remember reading in Waltke and O'Conner one day and suddenly beginning to critique it. That's when I knew that my knowledge of Hebrew had gone from novice to more advanced. It's when I began to understand Hebrew rather than just work in it as something foreign to me.
The same happened when I began to work through the Bible in ministry. I began to understand the texts and critique commentaries I read. In fact, to this day, I'm not quite so sure that the majority of commentaries/scholars I've read understand the books upon which they spend countless hours studying to write. That doesn't mean that I don't think they are all valuable in their own way, but they miss the point of these books often, and frankly, that leads to other misunderstandings in their general outlook of the Bible.
I truly believe that being a pastor is better than being a scholar, not simply because it gives you more pastoral concerns, but because the interpretation of the Bible is really missing a key element of the Spirit's aid when it is not in service of a local congregation, where the Spirit has clearly expressed that He exclusively works in the discipleship of His people. Even the books of the New Testament itself, even if circulated later, are written to local congregations in service of God's people (and that is also true for those books that are disputed to be general epistles---they are meant to be read by local churches).
It is not that I don't see value in employing all of the tools I learned in school. To the contrary, they are my constant companions in biblical exegesis. But it is the Spirit who made them worthwhile and potent in my attempt to understand the biblical text.
This is why I shake my head when you have young Bible students who merely employ these tools in some mechanic fashion without having much artistic skill in employing them. It evidences a lack of the Spirit to me, which in turn displays a problem in the interpreters intent.
This is also why sin issues must be considered when someone attempts to interpret Scripture.
The Bible was interpreted throughout the centuries by men who lacked many of the tools I learned in school, and yet, as I read them, even in what appears to me as strange hermeneutics, I find their theological and ethical conclusions to be the same as mine. Our unity is in the Spirit, not in our interpretive methods. And without Him, we have a spiritually dead guild of scholars ruling over the Church that was given by the Holy Spirit pastors seeking the growth of God's people (Eph 4:11-13), not scholars seeking an academic prestige and tenure.
Scholars often look down on pastors as second tier, but in reality, that should be reversed. A scholar is second tier to a pastor. Woe to us because we've forgotten it.
It is through the pastor that unity will be attained in the Church. It is through the guild of scholars, always attempting to look at texts in new ways and find new problems and new answers to write new dissertations and books, who contribute more to disunity in the name of academic innovation. It is scholars who have broken up the Church, but pastors led by the Holy Spirit who will bring it back together (and they can do this without ignoring scholarship, but instead by employing it for a better purpose than the advancement of self). Why would anyone ever think that an enterprise employed in the advancement of self would actually yield the truth of the Spirit of Christ who pulls people under His Lordship anyway?
I still read everyone. I don't look at scholars as those who are not worthy to be read. They occasionally have some good insights. But I don't take their abilities as seriously as I used to, simply because I tend to be capable of seeing past them now. I appreciate their hard work, but their hard work needs to be critiqued and salvaged by the Spirit-led pastor/teacher/evangelist for the work of God, to build up rather than to tear down the unity of the Church in the truth.
But all of these tools brought me only so far in understanding a text. Of course, at the time, since I understood it a little better than I had before, I never realized that I didn't quite get it. I thought these methodologies gave me the key to understand the Scripture, so I employed them as I sought to advance within the academic community.
But something happened that disrupted my plans to get a PhD in Hebrew Bible from Harvard, a PhD in New Testament from Cambridge, and a Habilitation in Theology at the University of Tübingen, along with lesser M.A.'s in Philosophy, Egyptology, Assyriology, and Church History. Life.
Of course, the best laid plans are often interrupted by real life, and I had gotten married, had my first son, and didn't get into Harvard. So I simply fell back on what I viewed as a temporary occupation while I waited a year to reapply to more schools. I entered into ministry as a pastor, and it is there that I began to use all of the tools I had learned in school for a different purpose than I had done before.
I didn't use them for my own personal understanding of the Scripture or for my own academic advancement within a highly competitive field, but instead in the service of God's people. As I did this, the Scripture opened up to me. I was able to see what these books were actually saying. What I thought I understood before by mere tools applied with technical precision became a joke to what I understood in the light of really seeing these texts for the first time in ministry.
To back up a little, when I first learned Hebrew, I would use a lot of lexicographical, grammatical, and syntactical sources. I would rely upon them as though they were like the bibles of Hebrew language study. But I remember reading in Waltke and O'Conner one day and suddenly beginning to critique it. That's when I knew that my knowledge of Hebrew had gone from novice to more advanced. It's when I began to understand Hebrew rather than just work in it as something foreign to me.
The same happened when I began to work through the Bible in ministry. I began to understand the texts and critique commentaries I read. In fact, to this day, I'm not quite so sure that the majority of commentaries/scholars I've read understand the books upon which they spend countless hours studying to write. That doesn't mean that I don't think they are all valuable in their own way, but they miss the point of these books often, and frankly, that leads to other misunderstandings in their general outlook of the Bible.
I truly believe that being a pastor is better than being a scholar, not simply because it gives you more pastoral concerns, but because the interpretation of the Bible is really missing a key element of the Spirit's aid when it is not in service of a local congregation, where the Spirit has clearly expressed that He exclusively works in the discipleship of His people. Even the books of the New Testament itself, even if circulated later, are written to local congregations in service of God's people (and that is also true for those books that are disputed to be general epistles---they are meant to be read by local churches).
It is not that I don't see value in employing all of the tools I learned in school. To the contrary, they are my constant companions in biblical exegesis. But it is the Spirit who made them worthwhile and potent in my attempt to understand the biblical text.
This is why I shake my head when you have young Bible students who merely employ these tools in some mechanic fashion without having much artistic skill in employing them. It evidences a lack of the Spirit to me, which in turn displays a problem in the interpreters intent.
This is also why sin issues must be considered when someone attempts to interpret Scripture.
The Bible was interpreted throughout the centuries by men who lacked many of the tools I learned in school, and yet, as I read them, even in what appears to me as strange hermeneutics, I find their theological and ethical conclusions to be the same as mine. Our unity is in the Spirit, not in our interpretive methods. And without Him, we have a spiritually dead guild of scholars ruling over the Church that was given by the Holy Spirit pastors seeking the growth of God's people (Eph 4:11-13), not scholars seeking an academic prestige and tenure.
Scholars often look down on pastors as second tier, but in reality, that should be reversed. A scholar is second tier to a pastor. Woe to us because we've forgotten it.
It is through the pastor that unity will be attained in the Church. It is through the guild of scholars, always attempting to look at texts in new ways and find new problems and new answers to write new dissertations and books, who contribute more to disunity in the name of academic innovation. It is scholars who have broken up the Church, but pastors led by the Holy Spirit who will bring it back together (and they can do this without ignoring scholarship, but instead by employing it for a better purpose than the advancement of self). Why would anyone ever think that an enterprise employed in the advancement of self would actually yield the truth of the Spirit of Christ who pulls people under His Lordship anyway?
I still read everyone. I don't look at scholars as those who are not worthy to be read. They occasionally have some good insights. But I don't take their abilities as seriously as I used to, simply because I tend to be capable of seeing past them now. I appreciate their hard work, but their hard work needs to be critiqued and salvaged by the Spirit-led pastor/teacher/evangelist for the work of God, to build up rather than to tear down the unity of the Church in the truth.
Monday, April 1, 2013
Oz, the Good and Faithful
I went to "Oz, the Great and Powerful" this weekend. It was a great movie. If you haven't seen it yet, I suggest you don't read this. SPOILER ALERT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What I liked about the movie, apart from the great success the movie has in immersing its audience in a fantasy world, is a couple of its messages (there were a couple messages I didn't like either however).
But the first message I thought was interesting is how pain, especially when brought on by someone you love, if dealt with improperly, can make you hateful and ugly.
The second message, which was one of the stories main messages, was critiquing our modern view of greatness.
At the beginning of the movie, Oz, who is a womanizing bachelor, is confronted with possibly marrying the girl he seems to care about the most. She has been given a proposal by another man, but she wants to give Oz the opportunity to propose instead. He says, instead, that the man who has proposed to her is a good man and that she should marry him.
She replies, "You're a good man."
To which he replies, "No, I'm not a good man." He then goes on to say that there are many good men in the world, men who go to church, settle down and get married and raise families. He didn't want to be a good man. He wanted to be a great man, a man of renown, like one of the great inventors or magicians of his time.
The movie continues as Oz is given an opportunity to be the King of Oz, as the people believe he's the great wizard prophesied to save their people. In the end, he admits that he is not a great wizard and that he cannot help them, but decides to help them in the only way that he can.
He defeats the witches and saves the people. The movie closes with a conversation between himself and Glenda, where she says to him, "For the record, I knew you had it in you all along." He replies, "Greatness?" To which she replies, "No, better than that, goodness."
I loved this inclusio to the movie, because it summed up the movie well. It is goodness, the faithfulness to people and doing what is right that saved the day in the end, not prestige and pomp, not fame and fortune. It wasn't his name that saved them. It was his laying down his life to serve them that was better than "greatness."
Our "American Idol, Kim Kardashian, everybody look and acknowledge me and give me a sense of worth of my own greatness" society needs to hear that. It's going to church, settling down and raising a family, being faithful to those around you, that makes you a good man. And that is better than being a great one.
What I liked about the movie, apart from the great success the movie has in immersing its audience in a fantasy world, is a couple of its messages (there were a couple messages I didn't like either however).
But the first message I thought was interesting is how pain, especially when brought on by someone you love, if dealt with improperly, can make you hateful and ugly.
The second message, which was one of the stories main messages, was critiquing our modern view of greatness.
At the beginning of the movie, Oz, who is a womanizing bachelor, is confronted with possibly marrying the girl he seems to care about the most. She has been given a proposal by another man, but she wants to give Oz the opportunity to propose instead. He says, instead, that the man who has proposed to her is a good man and that she should marry him.
She replies, "You're a good man."
To which he replies, "No, I'm not a good man." He then goes on to say that there are many good men in the world, men who go to church, settle down and get married and raise families. He didn't want to be a good man. He wanted to be a great man, a man of renown, like one of the great inventors or magicians of his time.
The movie continues as Oz is given an opportunity to be the King of Oz, as the people believe he's the great wizard prophesied to save their people. In the end, he admits that he is not a great wizard and that he cannot help them, but decides to help them in the only way that he can.
He defeats the witches and saves the people. The movie closes with a conversation between himself and Glenda, where she says to him, "For the record, I knew you had it in you all along." He replies, "Greatness?" To which she replies, "No, better than that, goodness."
I loved this inclusio to the movie, because it summed up the movie well. It is goodness, the faithfulness to people and doing what is right that saved the day in the end, not prestige and pomp, not fame and fortune. It wasn't his name that saved them. It was his laying down his life to serve them that was better than "greatness."
Our "American Idol, Kim Kardashian, everybody look and acknowledge me and give me a sense of worth of my own greatness" society needs to hear that. It's going to church, settling down and raising a family, being faithful to those around you, that makes you a good man. And that is better than being a great one.
Denouncing Tribalism
Ever notice that people who speak against the "us/them" mentality, decrying it as tribalism, and seeking unity via good feelings, don't get the contradiction?
We don't have that "us/them" mentality like THEM. They should have an accepting mentality like US!
In case you were wondering, Yes, morons do actually grow on trees.
We don't have that "us/them" mentality like THEM. They should have an accepting mentality like US!
In case you were wondering, Yes, morons do actually grow on trees.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)