Thursday, September 27, 2012

It's What Makes Liberals Liberal

Liberals, even if they are conservatives (I know that sounds contradictory but it isn't), eventually come to more liberal positions when they have to make some room within their theological and ethical framework for friends and family that may beyond the bounds of that framework and therefore stand condemned by it. It's no wonder, then, that experience-oriented theology, a.k.a. "liberalism," runs with the tide of whatever cultural conditioning within which it finds itself. If you have this sort of self-based assessment of truth and good, and you have a son who is gay, you'll end up affirming his sin rather than correcting it. In any case, I found this to be illuminating, because it explains why, at least for McLaren, there was, and is, an emotional need to destroy the orthodox doctrines of hell, exclusivity, and to fight against the Christian ethic that condemns homosexuality, coupled with the idea that one ought to be disciplined by the Church for such acts rather than celebrated.



Progressive Covenantalism


http://triablogue.blogspot.com/2012/09/progressive-covenantalism.html

Another Good Article on Method in Evaluating the Jesus' Wife Forgery

This one seeks to correct an argument against its authenticity, although it does not argue in favor of its authenticity. Again, it's just good to get our methods straight.



Wednesday, September 26, 2012

For My Next Trick . . .

I know I said I pretty much predicted that the new "fragment" was a forgery, but I'm going to predict, ahead of time now, that Karen King will fight to the finish that it's legit, even if there is no more proof that it is and so many other scholars reject it as legitimate. That's because scholars are the most dogmatic group in the world. They only change their minds if they absolutely have to, and even then, they usually just let things fade rather than make explicit retractions. I don't mean to be cynical, and maybe I'll turn out to be wrong on this one, since so many scholars are against her on this one. I'm just giving you a general assessment though that it's easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for a scholar to admit he (or she in this case) is wrong. Behold, I have told you in advance.

UPDATE: Now HTR is presenting it as needing verification before it is published. Of course, it really depends upon who is doing the verifying. We'll have to see how this fake makes out.

Reflections on the Jesus' Wife Forgery

Charles Halton had some great advice here.



 
I, for one, thought this fragment was either going to turn out as a forgery (it just looks like something you'd buy at the Oriental Institute gift shop), or if it was genuine, irrelevant, since it supposedly came from a later time period, another cultural and religious context, and would be, therefore, about as relevant as any gnostic text to who Jesus really was and what He actually did. In any case, I found it to be a bore, so didn't comment on it. But I'm always interested in refining our methodology of inquiry within our scholarly pursuits, so this article is worth reading, regardless of the subject.

When I Get the Chance . . .

When I get the chance, these are some of the subjects I would like to address in some upcoming posts:

1. The similarity and uniqueness of Israelite aniconism in its ancient Near Eastern context.
2. Discuss the only orthodox Christian route one who denies the historical Adam can take if he wants to remain orthodox, as well as discussing why any other path he might take assumes systems that have been historically condemned as heretical for good reason.
3. Discuss why most books slamming inerrancy aren't from positions of errancy, but from alternate positions of inerrancy that largely undermine the authority of the Bible. I maintain that there is only one form of true errancy, and it is rarely held by any books written by self-professed believers. In essence, Thom Stark has a section in his book as to why inerrantists don't actually exist, but I would counter by saying that there are very few errantists that exist within the Christian context, and that most are advocating a species of canonical inerrancy, including Thom.
4. To trace monergistic and synergistic ideas within church history before the Reformation in an effort to show that semi-Pelagianism and gnostic assumptions stayed within the church largely untouched during the medieval period, but were finally exposed during the Reformation and Counter-Reformation (i.e., the true official beginning of the Roman Catholic Church).
5. To discuss the purpose of primeval history in the ancient Near East and the Bible in order to display the theological purposes of creation accounts and historical reporting of that period.
6. To blog the book of Genesis that I'm writing.
7. To discuss why placing the Bible on a pedestal and considering it divine is not what is traditionally understood as "bibliolatry," but is in fact the divinely sanctioned form of "idolatry" in the Bible to which everyone who claims to worship God must bow (i.e., that only visual idols are condemned, not the spoken Word that functions in place of an idol).
8. To do a series on the biblical texts used in the seven ecumenical councils of the Early Church.
9. To look at the Council of Orange and whether it supports or condemns what has become modern Roman Catholicism.
10. To look at divine determinationism within Samuel-Kings.

I have some other ideas I'd like to pursue as well, but if you have anything you might want me to pursue, feel free to make a request.

Monday, September 24, 2012

Frustrating

One of the most frustrating things for me is when people who should know better participate in the same diversion tactics in which people who don't know better engage (thus, emboldening the stupidity of those who don't know better).

I say this because I occasionally read one of my former professors (who will remain nameless) blogs and am so frustrated by what has obviously become some need to "get back" at evangelicals who harmed him by retreating to his constituents behind the emerging movement's wall and lop "your close-minded and intolerant in your traditions" grenades over the wall at as many evangelicals as possible.

I read a post he wrote a bit ago where he accuses evangelicals of being a closed group that feels threatened by questions, which is the common caricature of evangelicalism by liberals. Of course, church is nothing but questions. The issue is that he doesn't like the answers, or that there are even answers provided in the first place with any certainty behind them (evidence of being completely consumed by the postmodern monster with all of its atheistic assumptions).

But let's get this very clear. No question is heretical. Not one. Only assertions are heretical. That doesn't mean that you can't be heretical by putting an assertion together in a rhetorical question. It means that if you are really asking a question, then it is not heretical to do so.

As I've said before, every church I have ever attended, and I have attended churches within multiple traditions, even going outside of evangelicalism for that matter, wants questions asked. The issue isn't questions. The issue is answers. My former professor doesn't like the answers. That's fine. I don't always agree that they are accurate either. The problem is that if you paint your opponent with broad brushes, he'll do the same to you, and all you have left is name-calling and division. If you want more dialogue, then engage the answers, not the person. That's called an ad hominem.

Let's say for a moment that the evangelical church was absolutely close-minded. So what? Does that mean that its answers are wrong? If my doctor is close-minded about the fact that I need to remove a tumor in order to deal with my cancer, does that mean he's wrong?

So what does this sort of caricature and name-calling accomplish? Well, to be honest, it's probably pseudo-therapeutic, some lame attempt in which we all seek some sort of catharsis from wounds given to us by our opponents. I don't like liberalism because I see it as sub-human and an enshrinement of the religion of the self in our culture, but another reason I don't like liberals is because liberalism destroyed my family and friends growing up, and I perceive those who advocate it as destroyers of the innocent. That's why I have a pretty nasty bite when I deal with people who have a more liberal view than I do, usually in terms of their rebellious attitude toward biblical ethics. I'm not as lacking in generosity toward you if I perceive you as trying to give yourself over to the Lord in understanding something (even if your views are more liberal), as long as you evidence an attitude that is sacrificial of the self. But if I only engage in name-calling, instead of primarily dealing with arguments, then everything is just pure emotion and nothing sound and logical. What good is that? So you get an angry mob and feel some community with those who want to lop off heads with you. Whoopie!

But what really frustrates me more than this, as I read my former professors blog, is how many errors he makes in his argumentation, and how hypocritical he is when addressing his opponents, and how unaware he seems to be in making those mistakes. And I think this is the case for one primary reason: when you are hurt or angry or bitter, you can't think straight. We say stupid things when we're hurt. We just want to lash out at those who hurt us, and that makes our thinking rather sloppy, even about things with which we would normally have some clarity.

For instance, he makes this statement that the Bible is about an unfolding history, not a rule book to live by, an obvious attack on evangelicals, and all orthodox Christians throughout the ages btw, who seek to get clarity on what they should believe and do in life from the Scripture. But this is a false dichotomy and clearly isn't the Bible's take on itself, nor is it Christ's take on the Bible, and Jesus is supposedly his whole paradigm for interpreting the text. As an example, are we to believe that the guy picking up sticks on the Sabbath was killed by God because God is a fundamentalist who doesn't understand how to interpret His own Bible, since He used it to convict the man by a single rule given by which he was to live? He didn't judge him for not living within the unfolding narrative. In other words, God judges men throughout the Scripture for not obeying individual rules He laid down in Scripture, so does God not get it now either? Is God misunderstanding that the Bible is just a history book about redemption? And does Christ, the very One about Whom the Bible is centered, not get it either? After all, doesn't He condemn the Pharisees for putting aside the Scripture for their traditions, and by that He's not referring to the redemptive story, but the single rule of honoring father and mother (in fact, an application of that rule that was never even explicit in the text, thus showing that we are to make rules from the rules). This false dichotomy between the Bible as a rule book and the Bible as story is sloppy thinking that does not let the Bible, or God for that matter, define what it is for itself.

As another example, on one post he'll show that it's OK for the biblical authors to use midrash in their exegesis, because he's hitting against evangelicalism that thinks it's not OK, but then he'll turn around and talk about the only way to get to the truth of what the Bible teaches is to examine in within its contextual environments (i.e., the historical-grammatical hermeneutic is the only way to achieve the right interpretation). Which is it? I would say that both can be used because theological presupps guide the interpreter, not the methodology of inquiry.

Which leads me yet to another example. On one hand he continually slaps evangelicals down for using their theological traditions as contexts for what the Bible says, and then turns around and says that evangelicals don't understand the legitimacy of apostolic/2d Temple interpretation because they had, not a methodology, but Jesus as their goal (i.e., a theology of Christ that guided their hermeneutic much like modern evangelicals who guide their hermeneutic with those same types of theological goals).

Of course, what is said of the evangelical being in a box can be said for any human group, simply because that is the nature of culture. You need transcendence to fight cultural boxes or your just going to be fighting one fallen culturally-limited, philosophical box with another; and that is why the Holy Spirit with us is mandatory in the age of interpretation and teachers that has seen the passing of the age of revelation and prophets. But I don't see much of the necessity of the  supernatural/metaphysical element mentioned in these rages against the machine. All they do is take one box to smash another, never breaking their own current box, just ones that they may have lived in once and others live in now. That's the trap we're in. To act like only your opponent is in it, and you have a way out, and can grow beyond it, is nonsense without a transcendent revelation and interpretation. But that's for another day.

I'm mainly just frustrated because I feel like he gave up on orthodoxy for nothing but to get even, because I don't find his reasons reasonable, and that makes me think they aren't coming from the mind but from the gut, and we all know that when guts are spilled, there's a lot of refuse and nothing worth salvaging there.

In any case, I will continue to pray for my professor in the hope that he will stop trying to burn down the world that did him harm and regain some balance in his thinking.