The idea that the Bible exists primarily to teach us theology and ethics should not negate the fact that often biblical theology has its root in God's saving acts in history. The call to believe in God as mighty enough to overcome harsh realities is supported by the fact that God saved His people from the powerful hands of the Egyptians in the exodus. This implies that the exodus story is true, i.e., that it really happened through Moses, which in turn implies that Moses was a real person.
Many today deny that Moses existed. Even more deny that Adam existed. But caution is needed, as whenever we have been given a chance to verify the existence of a biblical figure in history, it seems to turn out that they are not merely metaphors in the text. Some of these were even thought to be made up until they were found elsewhere (although I think that waiting to see if you can verify a biblical figure from some other source evidences too much reliance upon extrabiblical texts). Some people just want to wait and see if they'll be proven wrong in heaven when they meet some of these people, but that's a bit silly to argue against a text without much evidence to the contrary. It argues a negative from silence. In any case, here are seven biblical characters mentioned outside of the Bible as real people.
1. David. David's name is mentioned both in the Mesha Inscription and in the Tel Dan Inscription as the patriarch of the royal dynasty in Israel.
2. Omri. Omri is also menioned in the Mesha Inscription as Mesha's enemy king from the line of David. He is also mentioned on the Black Obelisk of Shalmaneser III as the dynastic head of Israel.
3. Jehu. Jehu is the only biblical figure who both gets mentioned and is depicted on the Black Obilisk. He is said to give tribute, is of the "house of Omri," and is depicted as bowing down before Shalmaneser III.
4. Hezekiah. Hezekiah is mentioned in the Taylor Prism that relates some of the conquests of Sennacherib. The chronicle actually records what happens in the same way the Bible does, but Sennacherib, of course, does not paint it as a loss, but emphasizes the fact that he shut Hezekiah up in his city like a "bird in a cage," and that he was paid tribute. The Bible says this too, but also mentions the fact that the troops he deployed there were wiped out.
5. Pontius Pilate. Pilate is mentioned by Philo, Josephus, Tacitus, and the Pilate Stone, which mentions him as prefect.
6. John the Baptist. John is mentioned by Josephus as one who baptized the Jewish people after calling them to act righteously toward one another and to be devoted to God. Josephus details why he thinks Herod put him to death ("because he was afraid John would stir up trouble among the people").
7. Jesus. The Lord Jesus is mentioned by Josephus (although perhaps altered to some degree, the core of what is said about Him is thought to be original), Tacitus, and Suetonius.
Now, this doesn't mean that the Bible is not theologizing their words and actions, because the Holy Spirit wishes to mold them into a message; but to argue that since the Bible's primary purpose is to teach theology and ethics that this means the people never existed is a non sequitur, and you may end up even being proven wrong in this life as well.
BTW, what's the deal with Jehu's crown here? Is it just me, or does it look like he stole it from one of the seven dwarves?
Friday, August 17, 2012
Thursday, August 16, 2012
Are Those Who Have Never Heard Saved Anyway?
I've often argued that the worst shows on TV were never shows like "Married with Children" or "South Park," but shows like "Seventh Heaven" or "Touched by an Angel." Explicit rebellion against what God has said is easy to spot. You can take note of it and avoid it. Instead, it is that which looks good to us, but brings in subtle rebellion against the truth, that is far more dangerous. You have to really be paying attention to catch it. The yearly build up of these subtle departures from truth eventually take their toll on our thinking.
There are explicit ways to deny the necessity of the gospel and there are more subtle ways of doing so. The more subtle is the worst, as it creeps in, not through the explicit denials of the necessity of the gospel, but through other issues that assume ideas that end up denying it's necessity.
This is what I find to be the case when we discuss whether there exist elect people who never exercise faith in response to the audible gospel preached, whether they be people in other lands who have never heard, the mentally disabled, or infants.
There are numerous issues I would take with the idea that people are saved apart from exercising faith in the spoken gospel.
1. The gospel call is an audible call made by those who are sent to preach it. It is not an inward call. There is no such thing in Scripture as in inward call. Such is the stuff of evangelical fiction. A call is just that, an audible invitation/command to take action of something. In the gospel's case, the call is to believe in Jesus Christ as Lord. The word for "call" is always an audible command/invitation to respond to what one is being called. Hence, Paul argues that people need to go preach the gospel, precisely because they will not hear without a preacher, and therefore, cannot believe on Him about whom they have not heard (Rom 10:14). In Romans 8:28-31, Paul argues that salvation comes about through the process of predestination, a calling, justification, and glorification. One does not happen without the other. Hence, one must hear the gospel of Christ (i.e., the call), as a result of being predestined, in order to be justified and glorified (i.e., the same group that is predestined is called and justified and glorified--there aren't different groups here that are saved in different ways as a result of their election).
2. The elect are not elected to be saved, but to hear and believe in order to be saved. The idea that one is elected to salvation without being elected to go through the means by which he might be saved is actually an extreme form of Hyper-Calvinism. Yet, most of the people who make this argument are either Calvinists, Arminians, or Pelagians (i.e., people who deny that Hyper-Calvinism is true). I would deny it as well, as it is not biblical to say that one is elected to salvation, but to obtain salvation through the means of exercising faith in the spoken gospel message. Again, Romans 8:28-31, tells us that those who are predestined are called and then justified. There is no group that is predestined and justified without the call.
3. It turns the gospel into a works righteousness, where people follow Christ, not by trusting in His righteousness and work on the cross that they are consciously relying upon; but instead, are relying upon their good works and faith toward false deities and their religions as a means to salvation. The Bible is clear that those within the other nations, who have never heard of YHWH, who trust in false gods will fall, as their gods cannot save them, and the true God will judge them for trusting in these gods. He may be the One who provides for all mankind, but they instead attribute His good to them to other gods who are not said to merely represent Him, but through which the world is deceived and damned.
4. The Bible says in Acts 17:30 that God was not as harsh upon the nations as He could have been, and so tolerated their false religions, but now He commands all men everywhere to repent (i.e., turn to the truth through the gospel), because He has appointed a day to judge the world through His Son. Hence, people are not simply worshiping God and following Christ through their own religions.
5. The biblical pattern is that God has elected someone and so sends preachers to tell him the gospel message, i.e., to give him the gospel call. We never hear of anyone who is saved regardless of whether they have exercised faith in the spoken gospel. When God purposes to call a people to repentance, such as the city of Nineveh, he sends a preacher. Salvation is through repentance and faith, and repentance and faith come through the message preached.
6. The above is true because fallen man needs to be regenerated in order to believe, and this regeneration and drawing to Christ comes through the preaching of the gospel message, not apart from it. Hence, faith comes through the means of hearing and hearing of the message of God (i.e., the gospel message). Without this preaching, there is no regeneration, and therefore, no faith and repentance exercised toward God. Again, this is not something that happens apart from the preached gospel that binds one to Christ as Lord and Savior.
7. The idea that men don't need to be regenerated through the gospel message may assume the heresy of Pelagianism, where people do not need any sort of transformation in order to believe and be saved. They can use the grace of God, which Pelagius saw as natural revelation, as the means of salvation because it is possible for a man to be drawn to God through that alone. But the Scripture argues that the unregenerate man is hostile toward God, and that those who are not in Christ by faith are in the flesh which "cannot please God" (Rom 8:7-8).
Now, someone in the inclusivist camp, no doubt, will bring up verses like Luke 12:48: But he who had not been told it and yet did what deserved the scourge, will receive but few lashes. To whomsoever much has been given, from him much will be required; and to whom much has been entrusted, of him a larger amount will be demanded. But this verse actually teaches the opposite of what the inclusivist is trying to make of it. The passage acknowledges that those who haven't heard and didn't know what to do, still get punished for their sins. Their punishment, like those who lived in Sodom and Gomorrah, is simply less than those who are given more knowledge. Hence, Sodom and Gomorrah will find it more tolerable on the day of judgment, according to what Christ said, than the Pharisees and scribes who did not believe, because the Pharisess were given the gospel message and the people of Sodom were not. But Sodom was still destroyed, and are said to still be going off to judgment as a wicked city nonetheless. So a lesser punishment does not mean "salvation" for those who have not heard.
So, it seems that one either needs to assume Pelagianism (the person who hasn't heard is innocent or can be saved through his use of natural revelation) or Hyper-Calvinism (the person who has never heard is elect to salvation but not to the means to obtain salvation through faith in the preached gospel of Christ), both of which I consider to be heretical, in order to believe that people are saved apart from the means of faith in the spoken gospel. Both of these work against the idea that exercising faith in the expliicit gospel preached is necessary as the means through which one is saved. What this breaks down to is simply that a faith relationship with Christ is not necesssary or can be had, not through the gospel, but through having a relationship with a false god through a false religion that, ironically, is the exact opposite of Christianity (as all religions are).
What this means is that we need to preach the gospel for the glory of God that works with His election that works through the means He has ordained for salvation of an individual to take place. And we need to pay attention to the "smaller" doctrines we believe in so that we are not overthrown from behind while we're busy guarding the main gates.
There are explicit ways to deny the necessity of the gospel and there are more subtle ways of doing so. The more subtle is the worst, as it creeps in, not through the explicit denials of the necessity of the gospel, but through other issues that assume ideas that end up denying it's necessity.
This is what I find to be the case when we discuss whether there exist elect people who never exercise faith in response to the audible gospel preached, whether they be people in other lands who have never heard, the mentally disabled, or infants.
There are numerous issues I would take with the idea that people are saved apart from exercising faith in the spoken gospel.
1. The gospel call is an audible call made by those who are sent to preach it. It is not an inward call. There is no such thing in Scripture as in inward call. Such is the stuff of evangelical fiction. A call is just that, an audible invitation/command to take action of something. In the gospel's case, the call is to believe in Jesus Christ as Lord. The word for "call" is always an audible command/invitation to respond to what one is being called. Hence, Paul argues that people need to go preach the gospel, precisely because they will not hear without a preacher, and therefore, cannot believe on Him about whom they have not heard (Rom 10:14). In Romans 8:28-31, Paul argues that salvation comes about through the process of predestination, a calling, justification, and glorification. One does not happen without the other. Hence, one must hear the gospel of Christ (i.e., the call), as a result of being predestined, in order to be justified and glorified (i.e., the same group that is predestined is called and justified and glorified--there aren't different groups here that are saved in different ways as a result of their election).
2. The elect are not elected to be saved, but to hear and believe in order to be saved. The idea that one is elected to salvation without being elected to go through the means by which he might be saved is actually an extreme form of Hyper-Calvinism. Yet, most of the people who make this argument are either Calvinists, Arminians, or Pelagians (i.e., people who deny that Hyper-Calvinism is true). I would deny it as well, as it is not biblical to say that one is elected to salvation, but to obtain salvation through the means of exercising faith in the spoken gospel message. Again, Romans 8:28-31, tells us that those who are predestined are called and then justified. There is no group that is predestined and justified without the call.
3. It turns the gospel into a works righteousness, where people follow Christ, not by trusting in His righteousness and work on the cross that they are consciously relying upon; but instead, are relying upon their good works and faith toward false deities and their religions as a means to salvation. The Bible is clear that those within the other nations, who have never heard of YHWH, who trust in false gods will fall, as their gods cannot save them, and the true God will judge them for trusting in these gods. He may be the One who provides for all mankind, but they instead attribute His good to them to other gods who are not said to merely represent Him, but through which the world is deceived and damned.
4. The Bible says in Acts 17:30 that God was not as harsh upon the nations as He could have been, and so tolerated their false religions, but now He commands all men everywhere to repent (i.e., turn to the truth through the gospel), because He has appointed a day to judge the world through His Son. Hence, people are not simply worshiping God and following Christ through their own religions.
5. The biblical pattern is that God has elected someone and so sends preachers to tell him the gospel message, i.e., to give him the gospel call. We never hear of anyone who is saved regardless of whether they have exercised faith in the spoken gospel. When God purposes to call a people to repentance, such as the city of Nineveh, he sends a preacher. Salvation is through repentance and faith, and repentance and faith come through the message preached.
6. The above is true because fallen man needs to be regenerated in order to believe, and this regeneration and drawing to Christ comes through the preaching of the gospel message, not apart from it. Hence, faith comes through the means of hearing and hearing of the message of God (i.e., the gospel message). Without this preaching, there is no regeneration, and therefore, no faith and repentance exercised toward God. Again, this is not something that happens apart from the preached gospel that binds one to Christ as Lord and Savior.
7. The idea that men don't need to be regenerated through the gospel message may assume the heresy of Pelagianism, where people do not need any sort of transformation in order to believe and be saved. They can use the grace of God, which Pelagius saw as natural revelation, as the means of salvation because it is possible for a man to be drawn to God through that alone. But the Scripture argues that the unregenerate man is hostile toward God, and that those who are not in Christ by faith are in the flesh which "cannot please God" (Rom 8:7-8).
Now, someone in the inclusivist camp, no doubt, will bring up verses like Luke 12:48: But he who had not been told it and yet did what deserved the scourge, will receive but few lashes. To whomsoever much has been given, from him much will be required; and to whom much has been entrusted, of him a larger amount will be demanded. But this verse actually teaches the opposite of what the inclusivist is trying to make of it. The passage acknowledges that those who haven't heard and didn't know what to do, still get punished for their sins. Their punishment, like those who lived in Sodom and Gomorrah, is simply less than those who are given more knowledge. Hence, Sodom and Gomorrah will find it more tolerable on the day of judgment, according to what Christ said, than the Pharisees and scribes who did not believe, because the Pharisess were given the gospel message and the people of Sodom were not. But Sodom was still destroyed, and are said to still be going off to judgment as a wicked city nonetheless. So a lesser punishment does not mean "salvation" for those who have not heard.
So, it seems that one either needs to assume Pelagianism (the person who hasn't heard is innocent or can be saved through his use of natural revelation) or Hyper-Calvinism (the person who has never heard is elect to salvation but not to the means to obtain salvation through faith in the preached gospel of Christ), both of which I consider to be heretical, in order to believe that people are saved apart from the means of faith in the spoken gospel. Both of these work against the idea that exercising faith in the expliicit gospel preached is necessary as the means through which one is saved. What this breaks down to is simply that a faith relationship with Christ is not necesssary or can be had, not through the gospel, but through having a relationship with a false god through a false religion that, ironically, is the exact opposite of Christianity (as all religions are).
What this means is that we need to preach the gospel for the glory of God that works with His election that works through the means He has ordained for salvation of an individual to take place. And we need to pay attention to the "smaller" doctrines we believe in so that we are not overthrown from behind while we're busy guarding the main gates.
Wednesday, August 15, 2012
The Fruit of the Spirit?: A Tale of Four Misunderstood Words in the New Testament
In postmodern thought, ideas are merely expressions of the person. They reflect that person's experience, and that experience becomes that person's identity. To speak against an idea, then, is to speak against a person, their experience, and their identity. Hence, to speak harshly toward an idea, have no patience for an idea, speak unkindly toward an idea, or say that such an idea is false in view of another idea is to do all of these things toward people. Hence, when the Scripture commands us to be patient, gentle, humble, kind, and loving, it supposedly is commanding us to not speak about ideas this way, or to people in any sort of harsh, angry, or sarcastic tone.
Postmodernity hasn't just affected that other guy down the street. It has affected even the most astute of Christians. It has affected all of scholarship. It has affected everyone everywhere. And so, it has also had an effect upon lexicography (scholarly and lay lexicography alike). I've read numerous commentaries that displayed no more insight and correction in these four terms I'm about to discuss than of which the average joe sitting in the pew is capable. I think it's simply because we take the terms for granted on the one hand, and it seems "natural" for us, largely due to our postmodern worldview to take them as such on the other. Hence, we just don't bother to question what we're reading. The words to which I'm referring are these: "gentleness," "kindness," "patience," and "humility."
Of course, the biggest word that is misunderstood is "love," of which all of these are a part; but I've discussed that many times elsewhere. Today, I want to just clarify what these terms actually mean in their biblical contexts. I'm not going to do a major study with all of the verses present, but simpy give you a summary of what those contexts indicate.
Gentleness
Gentleness is often taken to mean that you are to have a certain tone in your speech, that you are not to speak harshly. One who does so does not exhibit the fruit of the Spirit. That fits well in our pomo understanding that truth is less important than how you speak and make another feel, simply because truth is elusive, but how you make another person feel when you speak to him or her is empirically verifiable. It's not about honoring God and how He feels with the truth, but about the person's feelings in front of you.
However, this isn't what the term means. The word group praos/praus/prautes has to do with one not being uncontrollably violent. In other words, it has to do with one who has control of himself in terms of what he says and does, so as to not become wildly violent. The term is used of animals who are tame, as opposed to wild. Obviously, it does not refer to the tone of their speech. We can apply it to that, but it does not necessarily and automatically condemn a harsh tone, since it primarily refers to restraining oneself from abuse in speech and physical action. In other words, the fruit of the Spirit here is using one's speech and actions for the sake of the benefit of others rather than to vent, which is an act of self worship at the sacrifice of others.
If we apply this to discipline, one should discipline his children for their sake, harshly spoken or not, not to simply release pent up anger upon his kids. The same goes for the man who is to be gentle. As Trench noted (Synonyms of the New Testament, 142) the term does not refer to a lack of temper, but falls short of a hot temper, i.e., something in between, something controlled. In fact, in the same letter that talks about gentleness as the fruit of the Spirit, Paul confronts Peter "to his face," which is a phrase relating the harshness and severity with which he confronted him, precisely because Paul was being gentle (i.e., in control of himself in looking out for another), as Peter was damned for what he was doing. Again, later in the letter, Paul expresses his harsh tone by saying that he wished these people, who were doing spiritual harm to the Galatians by telling them they needed to be circumcised in order to be acceptable to Christ, would just go all the way and castrate themselves. His harsh tone expresses how much of a harmful error this is, and that the Galatians should draw themselves away from such an error now.
Likewise, when James and Peter use the term, it always has to do with control of oneself versus becoming violent in speech or action in order to take out frustrations on others. Wisdom brings control for James, and those who are under harsh authorities in their lives should not violently revolt or speak without humility toward those authorities. But as we have discussed, this has little to do with the idea that being harsh, angry, or direct in one's tone as a sin. If that is true, the Christ, who is certainly said to be gentle, is, in fact, not. We need to remember that gentleness includes flipping over tables in anger, calling a friend "Satan," calling false teachers "children of hell," "children of demons" (i.e., "brood of vipers), "white-washed tombs," "liars," etc. If we fail to do so, we're going to argue that Christ, and people who are equally filled with the Holy Spirit who act like Christ, are acting "unChristlike."
Humility
Humility is actually linked to gentleness. They often come from the same word group or appear together. As I said above, gentleness is control of oneself for the benefit of another. That control may lead one in anger to speak harshly, or simply without anger to speak directly without much sugar coating. Humility, likewise, has to do with our general mindset to do things for the sake of God and others. It is lifting God up above ourselves first and foremost. This means we put His Word over our words and opinions. It may be then that we put His Word over the words and opinions of others; and to others in our pomo culture, then, this looks arrogant. In all actuality, however, we are actually lifting both God and others up over ourselves when we lift up God's Word over theirs, because we are seeking to redeem them from the tyranny of themselves. We are seeking to show them that God is life and must be exalted above them so that they might have life too.
Again, what humility in our cultural context looks like and what humility the Bible calls us to are completely different concepts. We can't just see the word "humility" and assume that it refers to the same things that our culture refers to when it speaks that term. I speak a lot on this blog about not carrying the referents from one context over to the other in the attempt to find the meaning of words. The same goes for not importing our contemporary referents back into the biblical context when attempting the same thing. Our lexicography needs to be based upon the biblical referents, not our own.
Hence, humility is placing others before ourselves; but unlike our current culture, that does not mean you don't tell someone that they are wrong. In fact, if one has humbled himself toward God, and exalts God's Word above his own, then humility is doing the same thing when one encounters the opinions of others. Humility wants to exalt God's Word as the means of deliverance from the devil's delusions, and so it seeks the glory of God and salvation of others. Only in our flip-flopped culture does biblical humility look like arrogance, since God's Word is not sought as the means to know truth, but rather the individual's subjective experience of life is. Hence, it looks like we're simply exalting our own experience over others. That, actually, is arrogant; but exalting God's Word over our experience is the humblest thing one can do, because it removes the exaltation of the Self in oneself and seeks to do the same in others (i.e., to pass humility on to another for redemptive purposes).
Patience
Patience used to be translated as "long-suffering." I think this is a better translation, because in our modern context, patience means you don't speak harshly (yet again) or with a certain tone, precisely because it means, to us, that you don't get angry.
The term, however, doesn't have to do with showing a lack of anger. It has to do with endurance. You don't give up on the person. You may get angry with ideas and even people who espouse them for being so careless with life and thought; but you don't give up on the person himself. You continue to seek his or her redemption. You don't try and make someone conform through physical force because you're tired and weary of them. You don't become abusive and dismissive toward the person. But notice, this is toward the person, not ideas. I see absolutely no tolerance by any of the biblical writers, or even the Lord Himself, for false teachings. They have absolutely no "patience" toward destructive ideas, as they are the means of damnation and defaming the true God in others. Patience is toward people, and patience has to do with persevering in one's desire and quest to see others repent and grow in the truth. It has absolutely nothing to do with whether one gets angry or speaks harshly. But in a pomo context, there is no truth to be had, so patience is not only about persons but ideas as well. One cannot be angry or speak poorly or in a harsh tone about another person's ideas. Again, this is not what the Bible is talking about when it speaks of having patience, i.e., long-suffering.
Kindness
Finally, we come to the word "kindness." This word is also taken to mean someone who does not hurt the feelings of others by speaking harshly, but is rather a "nice" person. In fact, we often conflate the ideas of kindness and being nice. But this term is most often used in the NT to refer to God's desire to save us. The term itself is linked to the others above in that it seeks what is best, from an eternal perspective, for the individual. It seeks to save them. It seeks their redemption. It seeks their good. Hence, it seeks to give what is good to them. A kind man, then, may be one who is angry at you for destroying yourself and others.
The Fruit of the Spirit
It is important to note that the fruit of the Spirit is singular, perhaps, not because all of the characteristics describe the one fruit, as it's often said, but because the one fruit is love and the rest of the attributes describe what love looks like (de Boer 362-66; Luhrmann 111; Dunn 310). As de Boer explains it, it might be understood as "The fruit of the Spirit is love [which is accompanied or marked by] joy, peace patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, humility, self control" (362). This makes sense in the context, since love is Paul's subject, and it also reflects his great love chapter in 1 Cor 13. Love is not one of the attributes of the fruit. It is the fruit. The rest are to be understood within the concept of biblical love, and biblical love seeks the good of others from an eternal perspective, not from a temporal "feel" of a conversation or action. It seeks the glory of God in the salvation of others. Hence, all of the attributes mentioned are geared toward that goal rather than the goal of having good feelings amongst ourselves at the expense of the truth that might have exalted God above ourselves and saved those with whom we interact.
A kind, gentle, humble, and patient man may whip the animals out of the temple, call a friend "Satan," call false teachers "children of hell." Again, Christ is our example of the most kind man who ever lived. Paul says of Him that He is the manifestation of God's kindness and love toward us. Yet, He is far from the Messiah of postmodern ideals, who never speaks harshly, never gets angry, never speaks sarcastically. Jesus is YHWH, the Divine Warrior. He wars against chaos, against what damns, precisely because He loves, has patience, is humble toward God and others, is gentle, is kind. War is not often pretty. It doesn't always make people feel good. And this type of war against the dethroning of God and His truth that would save others from exalting themselves certainly doesn't allow the ego of the other to remain intact; but it is a war of love nonetheless. In fact, it is a war of love precisely due to the fact that it does not allow the ego to stand. We are sparing lives, not feelings. No discipline, either of circumstances brought on by God or of words that are spoken by His Spirit through His people, are pleasant at the time; but they yield for those who heed them the fruit of life and salvation. If these terms mean anything else to you beside that, then I'm afraid you're just reading them wrong.
I was not trying to get praise and fame through my writings and little books, for almost everyone I knew condemned my harsh and stinging tone. Martin Luther
Postmodernity hasn't just affected that other guy down the street. It has affected even the most astute of Christians. It has affected all of scholarship. It has affected everyone everywhere. And so, it has also had an effect upon lexicography (scholarly and lay lexicography alike). I've read numerous commentaries that displayed no more insight and correction in these four terms I'm about to discuss than of which the average joe sitting in the pew is capable. I think it's simply because we take the terms for granted on the one hand, and it seems "natural" for us, largely due to our postmodern worldview to take them as such on the other. Hence, we just don't bother to question what we're reading. The words to which I'm referring are these: "gentleness," "kindness," "patience," and "humility."
Of course, the biggest word that is misunderstood is "love," of which all of these are a part; but I've discussed that many times elsewhere. Today, I want to just clarify what these terms actually mean in their biblical contexts. I'm not going to do a major study with all of the verses present, but simpy give you a summary of what those contexts indicate.
Gentleness
Gentleness is often taken to mean that you are to have a certain tone in your speech, that you are not to speak harshly. One who does so does not exhibit the fruit of the Spirit. That fits well in our pomo understanding that truth is less important than how you speak and make another feel, simply because truth is elusive, but how you make another person feel when you speak to him or her is empirically verifiable. It's not about honoring God and how He feels with the truth, but about the person's feelings in front of you.
However, this isn't what the term means. The word group praos/praus/prautes has to do with one not being uncontrollably violent. In other words, it has to do with one who has control of himself in terms of what he says and does, so as to not become wildly violent. The term is used of animals who are tame, as opposed to wild. Obviously, it does not refer to the tone of their speech. We can apply it to that, but it does not necessarily and automatically condemn a harsh tone, since it primarily refers to restraining oneself from abuse in speech and physical action. In other words, the fruit of the Spirit here is using one's speech and actions for the sake of the benefit of others rather than to vent, which is an act of self worship at the sacrifice of others.
If we apply this to discipline, one should discipline his children for their sake, harshly spoken or not, not to simply release pent up anger upon his kids. The same goes for the man who is to be gentle. As Trench noted (Synonyms of the New Testament, 142) the term does not refer to a lack of temper, but falls short of a hot temper, i.e., something in between, something controlled. In fact, in the same letter that talks about gentleness as the fruit of the Spirit, Paul confronts Peter "to his face," which is a phrase relating the harshness and severity with which he confronted him, precisely because Paul was being gentle (i.e., in control of himself in looking out for another), as Peter was damned for what he was doing. Again, later in the letter, Paul expresses his harsh tone by saying that he wished these people, who were doing spiritual harm to the Galatians by telling them they needed to be circumcised in order to be acceptable to Christ, would just go all the way and castrate themselves. His harsh tone expresses how much of a harmful error this is, and that the Galatians should draw themselves away from such an error now.
Likewise, when James and Peter use the term, it always has to do with control of oneself versus becoming violent in speech or action in order to take out frustrations on others. Wisdom brings control for James, and those who are under harsh authorities in their lives should not violently revolt or speak without humility toward those authorities. But as we have discussed, this has little to do with the idea that being harsh, angry, or direct in one's tone as a sin. If that is true, the Christ, who is certainly said to be gentle, is, in fact, not. We need to remember that gentleness includes flipping over tables in anger, calling a friend "Satan," calling false teachers "children of hell," "children of demons" (i.e., "brood of vipers), "white-washed tombs," "liars," etc. If we fail to do so, we're going to argue that Christ, and people who are equally filled with the Holy Spirit who act like Christ, are acting "unChristlike."
Humility
Humility is actually linked to gentleness. They often come from the same word group or appear together. As I said above, gentleness is control of oneself for the benefit of another. That control may lead one in anger to speak harshly, or simply without anger to speak directly without much sugar coating. Humility, likewise, has to do with our general mindset to do things for the sake of God and others. It is lifting God up above ourselves first and foremost. This means we put His Word over our words and opinions. It may be then that we put His Word over the words and opinions of others; and to others in our pomo culture, then, this looks arrogant. In all actuality, however, we are actually lifting both God and others up over ourselves when we lift up God's Word over theirs, because we are seeking to redeem them from the tyranny of themselves. We are seeking to show them that God is life and must be exalted above them so that they might have life too.
Again, what humility in our cultural context looks like and what humility the Bible calls us to are completely different concepts. We can't just see the word "humility" and assume that it refers to the same things that our culture refers to when it speaks that term. I speak a lot on this blog about not carrying the referents from one context over to the other in the attempt to find the meaning of words. The same goes for not importing our contemporary referents back into the biblical context when attempting the same thing. Our lexicography needs to be based upon the biblical referents, not our own.
Hence, humility is placing others before ourselves; but unlike our current culture, that does not mean you don't tell someone that they are wrong. In fact, if one has humbled himself toward God, and exalts God's Word above his own, then humility is doing the same thing when one encounters the opinions of others. Humility wants to exalt God's Word as the means of deliverance from the devil's delusions, and so it seeks the glory of God and salvation of others. Only in our flip-flopped culture does biblical humility look like arrogance, since God's Word is not sought as the means to know truth, but rather the individual's subjective experience of life is. Hence, it looks like we're simply exalting our own experience over others. That, actually, is arrogant; but exalting God's Word over our experience is the humblest thing one can do, because it removes the exaltation of the Self in oneself and seeks to do the same in others (i.e., to pass humility on to another for redemptive purposes).
Patience
Patience used to be translated as "long-suffering." I think this is a better translation, because in our modern context, patience means you don't speak harshly (yet again) or with a certain tone, precisely because it means, to us, that you don't get angry.
The term, however, doesn't have to do with showing a lack of anger. It has to do with endurance. You don't give up on the person. You may get angry with ideas and even people who espouse them for being so careless with life and thought; but you don't give up on the person himself. You continue to seek his or her redemption. You don't try and make someone conform through physical force because you're tired and weary of them. You don't become abusive and dismissive toward the person. But notice, this is toward the person, not ideas. I see absolutely no tolerance by any of the biblical writers, or even the Lord Himself, for false teachings. They have absolutely no "patience" toward destructive ideas, as they are the means of damnation and defaming the true God in others. Patience is toward people, and patience has to do with persevering in one's desire and quest to see others repent and grow in the truth. It has absolutely nothing to do with whether one gets angry or speaks harshly. But in a pomo context, there is no truth to be had, so patience is not only about persons but ideas as well. One cannot be angry or speak poorly or in a harsh tone about another person's ideas. Again, this is not what the Bible is talking about when it speaks of having patience, i.e., long-suffering.
Kindness
Finally, we come to the word "kindness." This word is also taken to mean someone who does not hurt the feelings of others by speaking harshly, but is rather a "nice" person. In fact, we often conflate the ideas of kindness and being nice. But this term is most often used in the NT to refer to God's desire to save us. The term itself is linked to the others above in that it seeks what is best, from an eternal perspective, for the individual. It seeks to save them. It seeks their redemption. It seeks their good. Hence, it seeks to give what is good to them. A kind man, then, may be one who is angry at you for destroying yourself and others.
The Fruit of the Spirit
It is important to note that the fruit of the Spirit is singular, perhaps, not because all of the characteristics describe the one fruit, as it's often said, but because the one fruit is love and the rest of the attributes describe what love looks like (de Boer 362-66; Luhrmann 111; Dunn 310). As de Boer explains it, it might be understood as "The fruit of the Spirit is love [which is accompanied or marked by] joy, peace patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, humility, self control" (362). This makes sense in the context, since love is Paul's subject, and it also reflects his great love chapter in 1 Cor 13. Love is not one of the attributes of the fruit. It is the fruit. The rest are to be understood within the concept of biblical love, and biblical love seeks the good of others from an eternal perspective, not from a temporal "feel" of a conversation or action. It seeks the glory of God in the salvation of others. Hence, all of the attributes mentioned are geared toward that goal rather than the goal of having good feelings amongst ourselves at the expense of the truth that might have exalted God above ourselves and saved those with whom we interact.
A kind, gentle, humble, and patient man may whip the animals out of the temple, call a friend "Satan," call false teachers "children of hell." Again, Christ is our example of the most kind man who ever lived. Paul says of Him that He is the manifestation of God's kindness and love toward us. Yet, He is far from the Messiah of postmodern ideals, who never speaks harshly, never gets angry, never speaks sarcastically. Jesus is YHWH, the Divine Warrior. He wars against chaos, against what damns, precisely because He loves, has patience, is humble toward God and others, is gentle, is kind. War is not often pretty. It doesn't always make people feel good. And this type of war against the dethroning of God and His truth that would save others from exalting themselves certainly doesn't allow the ego of the other to remain intact; but it is a war of love nonetheless. In fact, it is a war of love precisely due to the fact that it does not allow the ego to stand. We are sparing lives, not feelings. No discipline, either of circumstances brought on by God or of words that are spoken by His Spirit through His people, are pleasant at the time; but they yield for those who heed them the fruit of life and salvation. If these terms mean anything else to you beside that, then I'm afraid you're just reading them wrong.
I was not trying to get praise and fame through my writings and little books, for almost everyone I knew condemned my harsh and stinging tone. Martin Luther
Tuesday, August 14, 2012
Why Most Baptist Ministers Don't Think They're Arminian
Although I'm not a Baptist, I've run in Baptist circles here and there for much of my Christian life, and had many friends who were Baptists in one way or another (in fact most of my friends are Baptists), so I feel I now have somewhat of a good understanding of what goes on there. The big claim that almost every Baptist minister with whom I discussed soteriology (with the exception of Reformed Baptists) is that they are not Calvinist or Arminian. They usually try to explain their positions, and of course, it's almost always the Classical Arminian position.
Why is this? Why do so many Baptist ministers hold to Arminian theology, but think they're in the middle? Along these same lines, why do so many think that regular Calvinism is "Hyper-Calvinism"? Well, here's why I think they're confused. It's because the guys who claim to be Arminian, or are at least labeled as such in their churches, are actually full blown Pelagians.
I've talked to A LOT of these "Arminian" baptists who run in these circles, and I've got news for everyone, they're not Arminians. The pastors are usually Arminians, but these guys who have the label hung on them within these churches are usually Pelagians. They believe that man has free will and is capable of choosing good on his own. They don't believe man needs prevenient grace. In an attempt to argue that each man is responsible for what he does, and God has no choice in the matter, they argue that man's spiritual nature is free. He is not bound by his love of self in sin to one choice only.
So, of course, when they get mislabled as Arminians, the actual Arminians think that they are either Calvinists, and real Calvinists are Hyper-Calvinists, or they realize they're not Calvinists, but think that they're therefore something in between.
Of course, as I've argued before (and thousands of others have said many times before), there is no in between position that is consistent. When you accept certain elements of a soteriological system, you can't just take out some and leave others that are dependent upon one another. It functions like a stack of cards. You may be able to remove a single one from the top and be OK, but remove any one of the rest, and it's over.
So I actually think that Baptist Churches have a problem. By mislabeling themselves as "In Betweeners" who are not Arminian, they're not dealing with a massive amount of "Arminians" who should be rebuked and placed under church discipline if they do not repent of their heresy. And Pelagianism and Semi-Pelagianism are heresies that undermine the gospel and often contort it into another gospel altogether. It's time to call a spade a spade, an Arminian an Arminian, and a Pelagian a Pelagian, and leave the "sensible" nonexistent "middle" position on the doorstep of reality. You're not being balanced by mislabeling things. You're being unfaithful by not speaking against heresy in your midst. So honesty is the best policy. Learn the positions. Learn what you are, and then you can see what others who do not carry the Christian message in your assemblies really are.
Why is this? Why do so many Baptist ministers hold to Arminian theology, but think they're in the middle? Along these same lines, why do so many think that regular Calvinism is "Hyper-Calvinism"? Well, here's why I think they're confused. It's because the guys who claim to be Arminian, or are at least labeled as such in their churches, are actually full blown Pelagians.
I've talked to A LOT of these "Arminian" baptists who run in these circles, and I've got news for everyone, they're not Arminians. The pastors are usually Arminians, but these guys who have the label hung on them within these churches are usually Pelagians. They believe that man has free will and is capable of choosing good on his own. They don't believe man needs prevenient grace. In an attempt to argue that each man is responsible for what he does, and God has no choice in the matter, they argue that man's spiritual nature is free. He is not bound by his love of self in sin to one choice only.
So, of course, when they get mislabled as Arminians, the actual Arminians think that they are either Calvinists, and real Calvinists are Hyper-Calvinists, or they realize they're not Calvinists, but think that they're therefore something in between.
Of course, as I've argued before (and thousands of others have said many times before), there is no in between position that is consistent. When you accept certain elements of a soteriological system, you can't just take out some and leave others that are dependent upon one another. It functions like a stack of cards. You may be able to remove a single one from the top and be OK, but remove any one of the rest, and it's over.
So I actually think that Baptist Churches have a problem. By mislabeling themselves as "In Betweeners" who are not Arminian, they're not dealing with a massive amount of "Arminians" who should be rebuked and placed under church discipline if they do not repent of their heresy. And Pelagianism and Semi-Pelagianism are heresies that undermine the gospel and often contort it into another gospel altogether. It's time to call a spade a spade, an Arminian an Arminian, and a Pelagian a Pelagian, and leave the "sensible" nonexistent "middle" position on the doorstep of reality. You're not being balanced by mislabeling things. You're being unfaithful by not speaking against heresy in your midst. So honesty is the best policy. Learn the positions. Learn what you are, and then you can see what others who do not carry the Christian message in your assemblies really are.
Monday, August 13, 2012
Fonts
I got a new computer this week after my old one crashed on me, and when I read this blog with it, I realized that none of my Hebrew fonts were readable. I had them on my own computer, so they read fine on that, but never realized that if you don't have those on your computer, it just looks like jibberish. So if you want to read the Hebrew or Greek on here, you need to download SPTiberian, SPIonic, and SPAtlantis, which I believe is available at the SBL site. If you don't read them, then it probably looks just the same to you anyway and you can disregard this message.
A Biblical Environmentalism
I read an article today that some environmentalists wanted to do away with a dam in order to bring back wildlife that had been wiped out a hundred years before in order to give drinking water to the San Francisco area. This similar story, of course, is familiar to most. California was recently plagued by a group that eventually got the government to shut down canals that were the life's blood of crops that feed numerous people around the country, but were threatening a particular species of fish.
Now, let me just say that every Christian should be an environmentalist. I often don't understand the evangelical war on global warming. Yes, from what I've seen, it's probably not the greatest of science; but as I say to everyone, "Even if the science is faulty, is it really that bad to convince people to put less polution in our air?" I mean, I don't think tricking people into doing it is that great, but even if the data is wrong, isn't it a good thing to clean up the air and get poisonous chemicals out of our lungs and lives?
But here's where many environmentalists go wrong. Biblical environmentalism is about us, not the planet. God made the planet for us. He made it for our well-being. So we should take care of it for that reason. We need to cultivate and grow the garden so that it continues to exist as a livable environment for human life and flourishing. When, therefore, environmentalism works against human life and preservation, it becomes a means of chaos rather than creation. And as the people of God, our duty as image bearers is to have an environmentalism that works toward human creation, not against it.
Hence, when you have lunatics who exalt the creation over the Creator and His purposes to fill up the earth with humans, argue that it would be better for humans to be exterminated because the planet would thrive, you are dealing with one who is working against creation, not for it.
This may be hard to hear for some, but humans are actually meant to be the dominant species on the planet. God made them to be just that. And what that means is that when we multiply, we're going to take over areas that were once dominated by another dominant species, and therefore, render them useless, and often, extinct. It may be that dinosaurs existed to care for their respective environments until other species that could be dominated by humans showed up. Who knows?
But it is clear that humans are to subdue and rule over the earth as a part of their divine role. And they do that by multiplying, not diminishing themselves. In fact, in the Genesis narrative, the animals that they rule over are birds, lower lifeforms of the ground, and fish. Wild animals that would characterize larger predators are not mentioned, as it may be that humans had to wipe them out in order to take over the area as the dominant species.
Notice, however, that the other animals are subjugated by humans fulfilling God's desires. Their lives are subjugated to that destiny. They serve many purposes, but all of them should help man in his role to procreate and preserve human life. When they begin to work against that, as is the case of the situations above, it is then that they have become anticreational moves against God's purposes. Animals are to give their lives for us. We do not give ours for them. That is to serve creation rather than the Creator. Although one should never enjoy having to sacrifice animals, because God cares for each one, He has so chosen to make them and lovingly sacrifice them for our survival and thriving upon the earth. Hence, He cares for every sparrow, but we are worth many sparrows to Him.
There is also a delineation of priorities that serve to negate the idea that one must sacrifice humans today in order to thwart what might only theoretically occur in the future to other humans. God tells us to look to today and do what is right within it. We should never do things that destroy the environment for future generations of humans for no good reason but greed and gluttony; but survival today takes precedence over what may only possibly occur in the future. We need to also understand that God is in control of creation and can replenish and restore what may have been necesssary for us to take from it in order to obey Him by performing the creation mandate and filling up and preserving human life upon the earth.
What this means is that the dam stays. The fish are sacrificed. And humans should lock up in mental wards people threatening to wipe out humanity "for the environment's sake." People who destroy the earth for reasons other than the creation mandate are apathetic towards God's sacrifices, self exalting, and are to be placed in the category of all those who work as chaotic agents to reverse human creation.
And that, perhaps, is the great irony. The radical environmentalist who wants to sacrifice human life and preservation to save the environment and the guy who just litters the ground and fills the air with chemicals in order to make more money are two sides of the same coin. They both work against God's purposes in creation, and so they both function as anticreational agents who disregard what is beneficial for human life.
The task of the believer is to work toward human life and preservation in all things, leading up to and pointing back to the gospel that accomplishes this par excellence. We seek to co-create and preserve humanity, and thus, we should be the best environmentalists there are.
God blessed them; and God said to them, "Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth, and subdue it; and rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky and over every living thing that moves on the earth." (Gen 1:28)
Then the LORD God took the man and put him into the garden of Eden to cultivate it and guard it. (Gen 2:15)
"And the nations were enraged, and Your wrath came, and the time came for the dead to be judged, and the time to reward Your bond-servants the prophets and the saints and those who fear Your name, the small and the great, and to destroy those who destroy the earth." (Rev 11:18)
Now, let me just say that every Christian should be an environmentalist. I often don't understand the evangelical war on global warming. Yes, from what I've seen, it's probably not the greatest of science; but as I say to everyone, "Even if the science is faulty, is it really that bad to convince people to put less polution in our air?" I mean, I don't think tricking people into doing it is that great, but even if the data is wrong, isn't it a good thing to clean up the air and get poisonous chemicals out of our lungs and lives?
But here's where many environmentalists go wrong. Biblical environmentalism is about us, not the planet. God made the planet for us. He made it for our well-being. So we should take care of it for that reason. We need to cultivate and grow the garden so that it continues to exist as a livable environment for human life and flourishing. When, therefore, environmentalism works against human life and preservation, it becomes a means of chaos rather than creation. And as the people of God, our duty as image bearers is to have an environmentalism that works toward human creation, not against it.
Hence, when you have lunatics who exalt the creation over the Creator and His purposes to fill up the earth with humans, argue that it would be better for humans to be exterminated because the planet would thrive, you are dealing with one who is working against creation, not for it.
This may be hard to hear for some, but humans are actually meant to be the dominant species on the planet. God made them to be just that. And what that means is that when we multiply, we're going to take over areas that were once dominated by another dominant species, and therefore, render them useless, and often, extinct. It may be that dinosaurs existed to care for their respective environments until other species that could be dominated by humans showed up. Who knows?
But it is clear that humans are to subdue and rule over the earth as a part of their divine role. And they do that by multiplying, not diminishing themselves. In fact, in the Genesis narrative, the animals that they rule over are birds, lower lifeforms of the ground, and fish. Wild animals that would characterize larger predators are not mentioned, as it may be that humans had to wipe them out in order to take over the area as the dominant species.
Notice, however, that the other animals are subjugated by humans fulfilling God's desires. Their lives are subjugated to that destiny. They serve many purposes, but all of them should help man in his role to procreate and preserve human life. When they begin to work against that, as is the case of the situations above, it is then that they have become anticreational moves against God's purposes. Animals are to give their lives for us. We do not give ours for them. That is to serve creation rather than the Creator. Although one should never enjoy having to sacrifice animals, because God cares for each one, He has so chosen to make them and lovingly sacrifice them for our survival and thriving upon the earth. Hence, He cares for every sparrow, but we are worth many sparrows to Him.
There is also a delineation of priorities that serve to negate the idea that one must sacrifice humans today in order to thwart what might only theoretically occur in the future to other humans. God tells us to look to today and do what is right within it. We should never do things that destroy the environment for future generations of humans for no good reason but greed and gluttony; but survival today takes precedence over what may only possibly occur in the future. We need to also understand that God is in control of creation and can replenish and restore what may have been necesssary for us to take from it in order to obey Him by performing the creation mandate and filling up and preserving human life upon the earth.
What this means is that the dam stays. The fish are sacrificed. And humans should lock up in mental wards people threatening to wipe out humanity "for the environment's sake." People who destroy the earth for reasons other than the creation mandate are apathetic towards God's sacrifices, self exalting, and are to be placed in the category of all those who work as chaotic agents to reverse human creation.
And that, perhaps, is the great irony. The radical environmentalist who wants to sacrifice human life and preservation to save the environment and the guy who just litters the ground and fills the air with chemicals in order to make more money are two sides of the same coin. They both work against God's purposes in creation, and so they both function as anticreational agents who disregard what is beneficial for human life.
The task of the believer is to work toward human life and preservation in all things, leading up to and pointing back to the gospel that accomplishes this par excellence. We seek to co-create and preserve humanity, and thus, we should be the best environmentalists there are.
God blessed them; and God said to them, "Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth, and subdue it; and rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky and over every living thing that moves on the earth." (Gen 1:28)
Then the LORD God took the man and put him into the garden of Eden to cultivate it and guard it. (Gen 2:15)
"And the nations were enraged, and Your wrath came, and the time came for the dead to be judged, and the time to reward Your bond-servants the prophets and the saints and those who fear Your name, the small and the great, and to destroy those who destroy the earth." (Rev 11:18)
Sunday, August 12, 2012
I Figured It Out
Have you ever spent countless hours in a conversation with someone, completely come to the obvious conclusion with them that their views have been refuted, only to have the person reassert the same idea that has just been shown to be false via logic and divine revelation? This describes about half of the conversations I get into. And I don't mean that we just disagree. I mean that what they say is clearly fallacious and can be shown to be fallacious, but they just don't care. They keep on keepin' on.
Well, I finally figured it out. I know the secret that so many probably already know. I realize now why my conversations with postmoderns are so frustrating. It takes me longer than most, but I finally got it. Postmoderns don't care about logical argumentation, unless it gives them the upperhand, because they don't think truth can be known that way. If they're arguments are illogical, they just keep trying to press them with the sheer, unrelenting volume of repetition. "Why?" you may ask. Because postmoderns don't believe that truth can be known through anything external to themselves, and so they believe the truth that they have personally come to believe cannot be evaluated that way. They don't believe in logic. They believe in power. Postmodernity has created an environment where might makes right. Majority rules, so postmoderns wish to rule the majority. That's why, for the pomo, everything really is about power. The seek to build an utopian society based upon their ideals, and in order to do that, they need thought control. Whereas ancient kings conquered externally, they wish to conquer from within. They are the Ozymandias of thought control, who can now boast about the expanse of their kingdom. So it doesn't matter if what they are saying is logically or biblically faulty. They just want to win, because they believe that whatever they believe is true because they personally have come to that truth. That's why they don't listen to people when their arguments are refuted. They don't change their minds. They believe they're right and that's all there is to say. If you don't agree, you're clearly not as evolved in your thinking. So they just want to press their opinions on others as much as possible through whatever means possible, whether it has been refuted by vehicles through which one can determine truth that are external to their own subjective experience. They just want the control of Hollywood, the media, politics, churches, law, etc., because it gives their views the dominant voice that would have otherwise been gained by logical argumentation in a society that had cared more about what is true beyond one's own experience. Since postmoderns have abandoned the idea that truth can be evaluated from external criteria, like logical argumentation or divine revelation, and can only be "known" existentially, the only real way to convince a society that one's ideology is better is to force those ideas onto that society using every access to gaining power one has. This is where our style of ridiculous protest largely came about. This is why postmoderns today continue the legacy of protest by carrying signs that are not functional for conversation, shout over people who are trying to speak on college campuses, emote rather than expound upon ideas logically, use ad hominem and invective so much more than actually present an argument. That's because when you get to the end of an argument, and it's clear now that the postmodern has lost the debate, he doesn't care. He just wants to believe what he wants to believe, because he believes he has arrived to that belief through a better way than one who uses logic (i.e., common sense reflective of God's nature) and divine revelation as his guide. He'll use both of those right up until he loses by using them. Then he'll just say something like, "Well, we just need to agree to disagree." Um, yeah, I agree to acknowledge that our disagreement is because you are unwilling to accept what is clearly true.
Of course, to use oneself as the standard is to make oneself the Word of God rather than the Bible and the superior of logical argumentation itself. The Bible gets to be the Word of God as long as it agrees with me. When it doesn't, it's made up of the opinions of the authors. After all, I know the truth and if the Bible disagrees with me, it must be mistaken, and not really the Word of God then, since God would agree with me. The same goes for logic. If logic agrees with me, then great. I'll use it. If suddently I realize that your logic is besting mine in a debate, I'll simply make excuses as to why you're still wrong (maybe it's because you're just obstinate and cannot see the truth with which my experience has blessed me). Even though I can't argue logically, I'm sure your logic is faulty; and even if it isn't, logic isn't the answer anyway, since if it were, it would agree with me. Again, my personal experience is the standard; hence, I am the standard. We see how narcissism then is tied to the postmodern view of truth. Despite the claim that postmoderns are ever so humble now because of their subjective access to truth, it has actually made us a society of people who think that each and everyone is an individual god who gets to be the standard of what is really true and right. Disagree, and show why that person is mistaken, and you will simply be dismissed as unenlightened. If you were more enlightened by experience as I have been, you and your logic and your Bible would be in agreement with me. You will now be placed in the category of one who must be tolerated; and by "tolerated" I mean someone who should be defamed and stripped of any authority to influence, hated with passion, and avoided in terms of any relationship one might have with you. In other words, you can go to a virtual concentration camp, exiled from my life and the lives of others among whom I don't want you to have a voice. That's postmodern tolerance in an age of "diversity" (i.e., everyone having differing secondary views as long as their primary beliefs are exactly the same as mine will be acceptable).
So it doesn't matter how many times you refute something and it should lie dead on the battlefield of ideas. The postmodern will erect it again and again and again and again (ad infinitum) because he thinks he's right and has the right to enter the conversation as the teacher via his personal experience, which if truth be told, is simply what his culture and subcultures have brainwashed him to believe. He'll simply keep pouring it on, again and again, with as much power as he can gain to do so. What he doesn't realize is that he's actually a pawn of the philosophies of other men that have advanced within our culture, and those ideas themselves are a part of the world in conflict with God. His personal experience is nothing more than a facade. His inability to take divine revelation and logic to their ultimate conclusions, to the destruction of his personally acquired ideas showcases that he is a slave to the world and to the one who rules that world with philosophies that lie and refuse to support what is true and God-honoring. So in the pursuit to have power over oneself and others, he actually displays his enslavement and impoverishment in terms of power.
The great illusion is that he who influences the most people wins, and this is why postmoderns want power (they must conform all people to their own image). Of course, the world is already convinced, so he becomes doubly deceived when he accomplishes his task through various mediums of influence and force. But those who truly see the world through a means beyond themselves see the poisoned fruit of such thinking. They realize that he who has exalted God above himself in his use of what God has given him is the one who wins in the end; and so Christ's words ring true that "wisdom is vindicated by her children." It's never obvious to the dense until its too late. People who are blinded by their own cultural ideas don't see how wrong they are. It's the next generation that will manifest how stupid the ideas of the previous generation were (and their children will display how dumb their ideas will be in return--such is the plight of the culturally-bound); but by then the postmoderns will all be gone, their protest signs found in history books will simply serve as their shattered visages lying in a wasteland of their own making.
Well, I finally figured it out. I know the secret that so many probably already know. I realize now why my conversations with postmoderns are so frustrating. It takes me longer than most, but I finally got it. Postmoderns don't care about logical argumentation, unless it gives them the upperhand, because they don't think truth can be known that way. If they're arguments are illogical, they just keep trying to press them with the sheer, unrelenting volume of repetition. "Why?" you may ask. Because postmoderns don't believe that truth can be known through anything external to themselves, and so they believe the truth that they have personally come to believe cannot be evaluated that way. They don't believe in logic. They believe in power. Postmodernity has created an environment where might makes right. Majority rules, so postmoderns wish to rule the majority. That's why, for the pomo, everything really is about power. The seek to build an utopian society based upon their ideals, and in order to do that, they need thought control. Whereas ancient kings conquered externally, they wish to conquer from within. They are the Ozymandias of thought control, who can now boast about the expanse of their kingdom. So it doesn't matter if what they are saying is logically or biblically faulty. They just want to win, because they believe that whatever they believe is true because they personally have come to that truth. That's why they don't listen to people when their arguments are refuted. They don't change their minds. They believe they're right and that's all there is to say. If you don't agree, you're clearly not as evolved in your thinking. So they just want to press their opinions on others as much as possible through whatever means possible, whether it has been refuted by vehicles through which one can determine truth that are external to their own subjective experience. They just want the control of Hollywood, the media, politics, churches, law, etc., because it gives their views the dominant voice that would have otherwise been gained by logical argumentation in a society that had cared more about what is true beyond one's own experience. Since postmoderns have abandoned the idea that truth can be evaluated from external criteria, like logical argumentation or divine revelation, and can only be "known" existentially, the only real way to convince a society that one's ideology is better is to force those ideas onto that society using every access to gaining power one has. This is where our style of ridiculous protest largely came about. This is why postmoderns today continue the legacy of protest by carrying signs that are not functional for conversation, shout over people who are trying to speak on college campuses, emote rather than expound upon ideas logically, use ad hominem and invective so much more than actually present an argument. That's because when you get to the end of an argument, and it's clear now that the postmodern has lost the debate, he doesn't care. He just wants to believe what he wants to believe, because he believes he has arrived to that belief through a better way than one who uses logic (i.e., common sense reflective of God's nature) and divine revelation as his guide. He'll use both of those right up until he loses by using them. Then he'll just say something like, "Well, we just need to agree to disagree." Um, yeah, I agree to acknowledge that our disagreement is because you are unwilling to accept what is clearly true.
Of course, to use oneself as the standard is to make oneself the Word of God rather than the Bible and the superior of logical argumentation itself. The Bible gets to be the Word of God as long as it agrees with me. When it doesn't, it's made up of the opinions of the authors. After all, I know the truth and if the Bible disagrees with me, it must be mistaken, and not really the Word of God then, since God would agree with me. The same goes for logic. If logic agrees with me, then great. I'll use it. If suddently I realize that your logic is besting mine in a debate, I'll simply make excuses as to why you're still wrong (maybe it's because you're just obstinate and cannot see the truth with which my experience has blessed me). Even though I can't argue logically, I'm sure your logic is faulty; and even if it isn't, logic isn't the answer anyway, since if it were, it would agree with me. Again, my personal experience is the standard; hence, I am the standard. We see how narcissism then is tied to the postmodern view of truth. Despite the claim that postmoderns are ever so humble now because of their subjective access to truth, it has actually made us a society of people who think that each and everyone is an individual god who gets to be the standard of what is really true and right. Disagree, and show why that person is mistaken, and you will simply be dismissed as unenlightened. If you were more enlightened by experience as I have been, you and your logic and your Bible would be in agreement with me. You will now be placed in the category of one who must be tolerated; and by "tolerated" I mean someone who should be defamed and stripped of any authority to influence, hated with passion, and avoided in terms of any relationship one might have with you. In other words, you can go to a virtual concentration camp, exiled from my life and the lives of others among whom I don't want you to have a voice. That's postmodern tolerance in an age of "diversity" (i.e., everyone having differing secondary views as long as their primary beliefs are exactly the same as mine will be acceptable).
So it doesn't matter how many times you refute something and it should lie dead on the battlefield of ideas. The postmodern will erect it again and again and again and again (ad infinitum) because he thinks he's right and has the right to enter the conversation as the teacher via his personal experience, which if truth be told, is simply what his culture and subcultures have brainwashed him to believe. He'll simply keep pouring it on, again and again, with as much power as he can gain to do so. What he doesn't realize is that he's actually a pawn of the philosophies of other men that have advanced within our culture, and those ideas themselves are a part of the world in conflict with God. His personal experience is nothing more than a facade. His inability to take divine revelation and logic to their ultimate conclusions, to the destruction of his personally acquired ideas showcases that he is a slave to the world and to the one who rules that world with philosophies that lie and refuse to support what is true and God-honoring. So in the pursuit to have power over oneself and others, he actually displays his enslavement and impoverishment in terms of power.
The great illusion is that he who influences the most people wins, and this is why postmoderns want power (they must conform all people to their own image). Of course, the world is already convinced, so he becomes doubly deceived when he accomplishes his task through various mediums of influence and force. But those who truly see the world through a means beyond themselves see the poisoned fruit of such thinking. They realize that he who has exalted God above himself in his use of what God has given him is the one who wins in the end; and so Christ's words ring true that "wisdom is vindicated by her children." It's never obvious to the dense until its too late. People who are blinded by their own cultural ideas don't see how wrong they are. It's the next generation that will manifest how stupid the ideas of the previous generation were (and their children will display how dumb their ideas will be in return--such is the plight of the culturally-bound); but by then the postmoderns will all be gone, their protest signs found in history books will simply serve as their shattered visages lying in a wasteland of their own making.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
