Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Examples of Redemption via the Acknowledgement of Unworthiness

Then I said,  "Woe is me, for I am ruined!  Because I am a man of unclean lips,  And I live among a people of unclean lips;  For my eyes have seen the King, the Lord of hosts." Then one of the seraphim flew to me with a burning coal in his hand, which he had taken from the altar with tongs. He touched my mouth [with it] and said, "Behold, this has touched your lips; and your iniquity is taken away and your sin is forgiven." (Isa 6:5-7)

"And whoever  exalts  himself shall be humbled; and whoever humbles himself shall be exalted. (Matt 23:12 // Luke 14:7-11)

And a centurion's slave, who was highly regarded by him, was sick and about to die. When he heard about Jesus, he sent some Jewish elders asking Him to come and save the life of his slave. When they came to Jesus, they earnestly implored Him, saying, "He is  worthy  for You to grant this to him; for he loves our nation and it was he who built us our synagogue." Now Jesus [started] on His way with them; and when He was not far from the house, the centurion sent friends, saying to Him, "Lord, do not trouble Yourself further, for I am not  worthy  for You to come under my roof; for this reason I did not even consider myself  worthy  to come to You, but [just] say the word, and my servant will be healed. "For I also am a man placed under authority, with soldiers under me; and I say to this one, `Go!' and he goes, and to another, `Come!' and he comes, and to my slave, `Do this!' and he does it." Now when Jesus heard this, He marveled at him, and turned and said to the crowd that was following Him, "I say to you, not even in Israel have I found such great faith." When those who had been sent returned to the house, they found the slave in good health. Luke 7:2-10 // Matt 8:5-13)

"But when he came to his senses, he said, `How many of my father's hired men have more than enough bread, but I am dying here with hunger! `I will get up and go to my father, and will say to him, "Father, I have sinned against heaven, and in your sight; I am no longer  worthy  to be called your son; make me as one of your hired men." '"So he got up and came to his father. But while he was still a long way off, his father saw him and felt compassion [for him], and ran and embraced him and kissed him. "And the son said to him, `Father, I have sinned against heaven and in your sight; I am no longer  worthy  to be called your son.' "But the father said to his slaves, `Quickly bring out the best robe and put it on him, and put a ring on his hand and sandals on his feet; and bring the fattened calf, kill it, and let us eat and celebrate; for this son of mine was dead and has come to life again; he was lost and has been found.' (Luke 15:17-24)

John answered them saying, "I baptize in water, [but] among you stands One whom you do not know. "[It is] He who comes after me, the strap of whose sandal I am not  worthy  to untie." (John 1:26-27)

And a Canaanite woman from that region came out and [began] to cry out, saying, "Have mercy on me, Lord, Son of David; my daughter is cruelly demon-possessed." But He did not answer her a word. And His disciples came and implored Him, saying, "Send her away, because she keeps shouting at us."  24  But He answered and said, "I was sent only to the lost sheep of the house of Israel." But she came and [began] to bow down before Him, saying, "Lord, help me!" And He answered and said, "It is not good to take the children's bread and throw it to the  dogs ." But she said, "Yes, Lord; but even the  dogs  feed on the crumbs which fall from their masters' table." Then Jesus said to her, "O woman, your faith is great; it shall be done for you as you wish." And her daughter was healed at once. (Matt 15:22-28)

But when Simon Peter saw [that], he fell down at Jesus' feet, saying, "Go away from me Lord, for I am a  sinful  man, O Lord!" For amazement had seized him and all his companions because of the catch of fish which they had taken; and so also [were] James and John, sons of Zebedee, who were partners with Simon. And Jesus said to Simon, "Do not fear, from now on you will be catching men." When they had brought their boats to land, they left everything and followed Him. (Luke 5:8-11)

And one of the criminals who were hanged [there] was hurling abuse at Him, saying, "Are You not the Christ? Save Yourself and us!" But the other answered, and rebuking him said, "Do you not even fear God, since you are under the same sentence of condemnation?  "And we indeed justly, for we are receiving what we deserve for our deeds; but this man has done nothing wrong." And he was saying, "Jesus, remember me when You come in Your kingdom!" And He said to him, "Truly I say to you, today you shall be with Me in Paradise." (Luke 23:39-43)

"Two men went up into the temple to pray, one a Pharisee, and the other a tax-gatherer. "The Pharisee stood and was praying thus to himself, 'God, I thank Thee that I am not like other people: swindlers, unjust, adulterers, or even like this tax-gatherer. 'I fast twice a week; I pay tithes of all that I get.' "But the tax-gatherer, standing some distance away, was even unwilling to lift up his eyes to heaven, but was beating his breast, saying, 'God, be merciful to me, the sinner!' "I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other; for everyone who exalts himself shall be humbled, but he who humbles himself shall be exalted." (Luke 18:10-14)

Now one of the Pharisees was requesting Him to dine with him. And He entered the Pharisee's house, and reclined [at the table.] And behold, there was a woman in the city who was a sinner; and when she learned that He was reclining [at the table] in the Pharisee's house, she brought an alabaster vial of perfume, and standing behind [Him] at His feet, weeping, she began to wet His feet with her tears, and kept wiping them with the hair of her head, and kissing His feet, and anointing them with the perfume. Now when the Pharisee who had invited Him saw this, he said to himself, "If this man were a prophet He would know who and what sort of person this woman is who is touching Him, that she is a sinner." And Jesus answered and said to him, "Simon, I have something to say to you." And he replied, "Say it, Teacher." "A certain moneylender had two debtors: one owed five hundred denarii, and the other fifty. "When they were unable to repay, he graciously forgave them both. Which of them therefore will love him more?" Simon answered and said, "I suppose the one whom he forgave more." And He said to him, "You have judged correctly." And turning toward the woman, He said to Simon, "Do you see this woman? I entered your house; you gave Me no water for My feet, but she has wet My feet with her tears, and wiped them with her hair. "You gave Me no kiss; but she, since the time I came in, has not ceased to kiss My feet. "You did not anoint My head with oil, but she anointed My feet with perfume. "For this reason I say to you, her sins, which are many, have been forgiven, for she loved much; but he who is forgiven little, loves little." And He said to her, "Your sins have been forgiven." And those who were reclining [at the table] with Him began to say to themselves, "Who is this [man] who even forgives sins?" And He said to the woman, "Your faith has saved you; go in peace." (Luke 7:36-50)

And He summoned the multitude with His disciples, and said to them, "If anyone wishes to come after Me, let him  deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow Me. "For whoever wishes to save his life shall lose it; but whoever loses his life for My sake and the gospel's shall save it. (Mark 8:34-35)

Or do you think lightly of the riches of His kindness and forbearance and patience, not knowing that the kindness of God leads you to repentance? But because of your stubbornness and unrepentant heart you are storing up wrath for yourself in the day of wrath and revelation of the righteous judgment of God, who will render to every man according to his deeds: to those who by perseverance in doing good seek for glory and honor and immortality, eternal life; but to those who are selfishly ambitious and do not obey the truth, but obey unrighteousness, wrath and indignation. (Rom 2:4-8)

For while we were still helpless, at the right time Christ died for the ungodly. For one will hardly die for a righteous man; though perhaps for the good man someone would dare even to die. But God demonstrates His own love toward us, in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. Much more then, having now been justified by His blood, we shall be saved from the wrath [of God] through Him. For if while we were enemies, we were reconciled to God through the death of His Son, much more, having been reconciled, we shall be saved by His life. (Rom 5:6-10)

But God, being rich in mercy, because of His great love with which He loved us, even when we were dead in our transgressions, made us alive together with Christ (by grace you have been saved), and raised us up with Him, and seated us with Him in the heavenly [places], in Christ Jesus, in order that in the ages to come He might show the surpassing riches of His grace in kindness toward us in Christ Jesus. (Eph 2:5-7)

We love, because He first  loved  us.(1 John 4:19)






 Now to the one who works, his wage is not reckoned as a favor, but as what is due. But to the one who does not work, but believes in Him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is reckoned as righteousness, just as David also speaks of the blessing upon the man to whom God reckons righteousness apart from works: "Blessed are those whose lawless deeds have been forgiven, And whose sins have been covered. "Blessed is the man whose sin the Lord will not take into account." (Rom 4:4-8)

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Worthless Worthy People Holding Hands, PART II


Now, let's talk about the "holding hands" part of the title. It should be no surprise that the more the majority of a community believes an idea (whether that community is a culture or subculture), as long as the community is accepted, the more you are likely to believe that idea as well. We are communal creatures. We look for the approval of others, and if the majority of others believe such and such, we tend to believe those things too. This is why even the most intelligent of people are susceptible to cults. One only needs to make the cult his or her primary culture/community. Once this is done, ideological assimilation is an easy road to travel. This is why I was so critical of Brown, who in my opinion functions as one more example of a prophet of the cult of postmodernity, which itself is a deep expression of secular humanism, a religion of the self.

Why counterattack Brown? Well, notice I said “counterattack.” That’s because Brown’s lecture is intended to attack the foundations of Christianity (or any religion other than the one she is espousing). People need to realize that what we say voices all sorts of beliefs, and those beliefs work to build one type of humanity versus another. What is said goes into the community and it builds what the belief being espoused views as correct and tears down what the belief views as incorrect. Hence, no proposition is neutral. To just leave it alone is to let it do its destructive work toward other views and build up its own tower in their place. So there can be no “live and let live” mentality when it comes to ideas, and those who are thinking people on all sides realize this. That’s why we don’t live in a freethinking society, but in a cult. Yes, you are a member of a cult. Did you not know that?

The point of the modern university is not to teach your kids about science, literature, etc. It is to use science, literature, etc. to teach them secular humanism, the primary religion of our culture. In fact, the TED Talks are a great display of this, where professors are basically telling you what they really teach your kids without the pretense of doing it through whatever subject matter is purportedly the issue for which the class exists. This is why your kids get thirty minutes of diatribe about religion or politics and fifteen minutes of the actual facts they are supposed to learn. Most professors are more subtle, however, and will brilliantly introduce the religious ideas of the cult through the subject matter rather than as a distinct lecture from it. Don’t think the university functions as a mouthpiece for the cult of our society?

Let me give you some guidelines for identifying a cult:

  1. Disseminate ideas as the primary paradigm without giving other paradigms a fair hearing.
  2. Make your ideas such the norm that the individuals will critique all things with those ideas, but never evaluate those ideas themselves. Take away the ability to question those ideas by viewing other ideas only in relation to them (i.e., how close or far out other ideas in comparison to the ideas of the cult—if too far, other ideas will be viewed as radical in comparison to the ideas of the cult).
  3. If the family unit cannot be assimilated into the cult, break it up. Degrade the parents as ignorant and as people who didn’t know better. Support things that will ensure that the unity a student has with the family in terms of beliefs and morals, which is seen as the greatest threat to the cult, does not survive as the most powerful influence in a person’s life.
  4. Bombard the individual with charismatic leaders who support the cult and become spokespersons for the cult.
  5. Socially discipline those who step out of line and begin to question the beliefs of the cult.

Now, let’s see, in view of what I spoke about in PART I, the cult in our culture seems to be ruling in full force. We are taught to love ourselves, think highly of ourselves, that we can do anything we set our minds to do, that we are capable of knowing the truth for ourselves without any outside help, etc. from day one. In other words, we are taught secular humanism from the get go. Our cartoons teach it to us. Our elementary school teachers teach it to us. Our parents who have been taught by the same teach it to us, and if they do not, they are viewed as radical and evil for not teaching their children these things. Our TV shows, movies, books teach it to us. Our college professors teach it to us. Our psychologists teach it to us. All religions in our culture, except genuine Christianity, teach it to us. Even false Christianities teach it to us. It’s everywhere and we are not taught to question it.

If someone questions the idea that the self should be seen as worthy, and even lives accordingly (perish the thought!), he is chastised as a radical or a fundamentalist or a religious fanatic. But in comparison to what? We often just assume the norm, because the norm is what everyone believes. But everyone believes it because he or she was brainwashed to believe it. The norm is the cult’s norm, not necessarily the norm of reality. Hence, the members of the cult work to keep those who would question the cult in line by socially disciplining them (e.g., by name-calling, shunning, etc.), and if this does not work, the greater authorities in place to support the cult might be called in (e.g., teachers to talk to parents who don’t conform, child services to threaten the family who does not conform, etc.).

Charismatic leaders, like celebrities, professors, etc. take the stage through our various media and educational avenues to woo us with the ideas of the cult. Certainly if so and so believes such and such, and he or she is so smart and likeable, the ideas we already have been taught to believe seem so much more convincing.

But the biggest sign that we live in a cult is the attack upon the family. The family, if it cannot be assimilated, must be destroyed by a cult. In fact, this is the number one goal of any cult, because the family is the last bastion of hope that free thought has. The religious community, if it does not preach the cult of self functions similar to a family, and must likewise be assimilated or destroyed.

I’m not going to go through countless examples where this is clearly the case. Instead, I’m just going to point out that all of this is necessary for the cult to survive, and even though no one in a cult views him or herself as a member of a cult (which is the beauty of brainwashing), nor will the leaders of this particular cult view themselves as even necessarily religious in their ideas concerning secular humanism and the exaltation of the self, it is clear that each individual automatically attacks what he or she sees as a threat to the ideas he or she is espousing, and as such, will automatically attack family and religious institutions that do not conform.

Hence, I’m not talking here about some conspiracy theory, where a bunch of people got together in a room to control the world and everyone else agreed to follow them. That would be absurd. Instead, we are already geared to defend what we believe and attack what threatens it, and as such, we are already inclined to defend any philosophy we have come to believe, in whatever way we have come to believe it.

So when Brown argues against religious certainty, she isn’t doing it because she sees herself as a part of a great conspiracy, but simply thinks it’s true and that it is a good thing to believe in self worth. She, in turn, will then believe that anything that would attack that idea (i.e., Christianity that says otherwise) is bad, and that such a religion should be questioned, and she does this by questioning the foundations of such a religion, which is the idea that one can be certain about what God has said.

My only point here is that our society is set up like one big cult, and in many ways, most societies are set up this way. It’s just in ours, we have come to believe that we are free to believe when in fact we live in a box and have been fed the same cheese over and over again to where we compare and evaluate all other foods to it as strange in terms of how close or far away they are in taste to that cheese. There is no free thought, except that God should enter into a cult with His revelation. I’ve said this many times before. Those who do not allow God to speak are doomed to believe whatever the cult tells them, and in this case, our cult is all about the exaltation of the self.

Its answer to all problems is the exaltation of the self. It must explore the self, stroke the ego, and see all problems as a result of not doing so. If you don’t love others, it’s because you don’t love yourself enough. As I said last time, that’s clearly in contradiction to reality. Love is produced by gratefulness and gratefulness is produced when the self is seen as unworthy and one outside the self loves and receives you in disregard of your unworthiness.

But the cult can’t allow for that paradigm, because ultimately, if the Bible is true, the world, and its cults, belong to the god of this world, the devil; and it is merely one step away from going from the idea of the unworthiness of the self and the need of another to the unworthiness of the self before God and the need of His love and acceptance through the sacrifice of His Son. The further the devil can get from this truth, the better for his kingdom to survive. Hence, the very foundations of Christianity (things like certainty of religious claims and the need of man to be forgiven as one unworthy of forgiveness) must be wiped away.

So we live in the cult of the self, but because of revelation, God sets some free, and they can be free indeed. If nothing else, however, you can see why orthodox Christians seem so critical in our culture. Those who disagree with the cult are always critical of it and painted as the worst of people. After all, they’re the ones not getting along with others. They’re the troublemakers. They’re the ones not playing along, but rather rocking the boat on an otherwise peaceful day. But they do this because they once lived in the cult as a cult member, and now, having been freed, they can no longer stand the sight of those they love in slavery to the cult. They may walk alone, but they have come to realize that it is better to know true love and acceptance and be alone than to walk into damnation holding hands with the masses.

Worthless Worthy People Holding Hands, PART I


I was listening to a TED Talks the other day, and was once again appalled by the false religion of secular humanism that pervaded every sentence in its quest to brainwash the unwary masses. If you’re not familiar with TED Talks, they’re basically all of the stuff you would get in a university, minus the actual facts and critical thinking skills you should be taught to evaluate what’s being said. In other words, it’s everything the modern secular university wants to really teach each student without all of those critical details getting in the way. But we’ll talk about that more in PART II when we discuss the “holding hands” part of the title. Today, I want to talk about what was specifically said by BrenĂ© Brown here (http://www.ted.com/talks/brene_brown_on_vulnerability.html), simply because I find it completely fascinating that despite all of the evidence to the contrary, people still eat this stuff up.

I’ve already spoken many times about the postmodern attack on certainty, and how it is really just a cult tactic to take people away from being certain about what their religion, families, etc. consider important so that they can then be certain about things that the postmodern cult thinks is important instead. However, what I found even more interesting in her lecture was the idea that the best of people are those who find themselves to be most worthy.

I find this to be a complete and utter joke. And yet, people devour this stuff like funnel cake, simply because there is a constant search of the self in our culture, a self that has no place in a world where God has been removed from the center of our being. Hence, people are continually trying to find themselves, and the postmodern narrative can turn no one outward toward God and others, precisely because it is a worldview that traps oneself in oneself. There is no greater reality than the self and what the self perceives and experiences. Hence, there is nothing greater than the self. Because of this, the prophets of postmodernity, i.e., media, professors, school teachers, etc., must always exalt the self as worthy of esteem. This lecture does not depart from that.

But let me give a reason why I think this is such a joke. The examples of the contrary are so numerous that one must truly believe contrary to the evidence in this case. Just watch “American Idol” and contrast those who think they are worthy versus those who are not sure of their worth. We are constantly told by the worthy that they are going to take the world by storm, that they are so much better than the judges and that the judges don’t know what they are talking about. In other words, we get abusive rants that demean others and lift up the self, because the worshiped self has been blasphemed.

Take, as another example, those who have considered themselves worthy in our modern history: Hitler, who believed that he and his pure race were most worthy, and that others were therefore beneath him. This led him to abuse and murder. The same can be said for all revolutionary movements, where the figures, such as Mao or Pol Pot wanted to cleanse society of the less worthy.

Take, as yet another example, the serial killer Ted Bundy. He believed he had the worth of a god. In fact, he once said that he felt like a god when he killed people, and that he didn’t feel guilty at all, but felt sorry for people who felt guilty. In the postmodern paradigm, guilt is just a tool of Christianity to humble the self and place it under its reigns. Hence, guilt, or the feeling of being unworthy, is for lesser beings.

In the film, “Waiting for Superman,” the narrator tells us that Americans basically fall far short of most of the developed world’s education standards. In other words, Americans are some of the most uneducated kids in the developed world. But, as the narrator tells us, they excel to the highest rank in one area: self esteem. They evaluate themselves to be of the highest worth, and believe they are the best of people. A student may flunk out of school, be arrested for drug possession, and beat his girlfriend, but he believes he is a great person.

I’m reminded of the ironic song “We Are Young” by Fun. The song describes the high and drunk young people at a bar, passing out and hooking up. In other words, it describes our generation as a bunch of worthless drunks that need to carry each other home at the end of the night. But what is fascinating about the song is its chorus:

“Tonight, we are young. So let’s set the world on fire. We can burn brighter than the sun.”

From cartoons and elementary school to college professors and psychologists, we are continually given one single message: You are worthy, despite what you are, what you believe, and what you do. You are just inherently worthy. There is no need to seek worth, as you already have it. Hence, you seek greatness, not because you have something great to do or some great idea to put forth, but because you already are great and need the world to know that too.

In other words, the problem, contrary to Brown’s suggestion, isn’t that abusers don’t think they’re worthy enough, but that they think they are more worthy than those they abuse. Hence, the problem is that they think they are worthy in disregard of the unworthy things they believe and do. They have no guilt. They have such a high opinion of themselves that others ought not dare to challenge them on their self evaluation.

You see, what’s missing from Brown’s lecture are genuine examples of people in reality. It sounds nice until you actually apply it to our situation, and then it becomes a narrative that doesn’t make sense, like a puzzle piece that’s being crammed in to fit where it doesn’t.

So, in contrast, I’d like to give the more biblical view that I think accords with reality, and here it is: The best of people are people who know their unworthiness to receive forgiveness and love and are now grateful for having received it. Did you catch that? It’s the polar opposite of the picture Brown paints. The best of people are those who are grateful people, and gratefulness is created by knowing one’s unworthiness to receive acceptance, and yet believing that one has received it anyway.

But such acceptance can only be received by an unworthy person by an outside source. If one is unworthy, then only another can bequeath gratefulness to the individual, and that is why the Christian worldview makes much more sense of our world than one that seeks to locate the answer within. At Christmas, Christians sing a song about Christ that says, “For He alone is worthy.” The Bible tells us that we are not worthy people. In fact, the further one gets from taking his role as the image of God, who views the true God as the only worthy Being that exists, the more the Bible considers him to be a “worthless person” (Deut 13:13; Jud 9:4; 1 Sam 2:12; 2 Sam 23:5-6; Jer 10:14-15; Heb 6:7-8), having lost the worth placed upon him by the outside and now only left with the worthlessness that is false humanity.

Those who don’t think much of themselves, when they are accepted on “American Idol,” are the best of people. Those who don’t seek to ascend to the heights of Olympus in our modern history are they who oppose the dictators of unjust genocides and they who submit themselves to be ruled by a court of law in their dealing with serial killers. They see others more worthy than themselves, and sacrifice themselves for those others. They do not think of themselves as anything, and thus, are filled with love and gratefulness when they receive acceptance. The answer, then, is outside of the self, as the very problem is the exaltation of the self in the first place.

But why does Brown tout this as the answer? Why is this answer what we hear over and over again? Why is the certainty of counter-religious claims brought into question at the end of the lecture? And are we as free to believe otherwise as we have come to think or have we been deceived as a society into thinking we ever really made the choice to believe in the answer Brown, as a prophet of postmodernity, provides as opposed to the Christian paradigm that counters it? We’ll talk about this more in PART II.

Monday, April 30, 2012

Sin Boldly


Luther once said, “Sin boldly, but believe more boldly still.”

This statement has stirred no little controversy today. It is used by Roman Catholics to show that Luther’s theology was bent toward licentiousness rather than holiness. I myself don't like the way that Luther phrased this. It's too close to the line in my opinion. But the interpretation that sees it as a love of licentiousness lacks the context of other statements Luther made that indicate that Luther did not believe that licentiousness, rather than a seeking after holiness, was appropriate for anyone claiming to be a follower of Jesus Christ.

In thinking about our struggle with sin the other day, I was considering how defeated we often feel for not overcoming temptation, but by rather being overcome by it. I was further pondering the nature of salvation, and what it means to be saved here in the “in between,” when we have already been declared to be righteous, but have not yet completely been made righteous. I was further thinking about the nature of reforming the church in doctrine and practice, and thought to myself, “How can I purpose to reform the church if I cannot even reform myself?” We are meant to be beautiful roses to God, but we often feel like very little rose and a whole lot of thorns instead.

But then it occurred to me that my definition of reform was distorted. If by “reform” we mean that we need to try and make the church, and ourselves, perfect, we will end our lives in discouragement, disillusionment, and depression. Perfection is not available to us in this life, not because it is not offered or possible with God to accomplish it, but because of the presence of our former atheistic selves and their continual desire to take hold of us once again.

If, however, by “reform” we mean that we set the church, and ourselves, in a direction that leads toward maturity and holiness in a vital relationship with the Lord Jesus Christ, such a feat is not only possible, but we who are saved are already having this accomplished through us.

You see, if God uses the evil that is done against us as a means to bring us into a closer relationship with Him, He also uses the evil that we do to do the same thing. Hence, “all things,” including even our failures in sin, are producing in us a closer relationship with God and working toward, rather than against, our salvation.

What would become of me if I never sinned again here? Would not my atheistic heart forget about God? Would it not begin to trust in my own goodness, rather than Christ’s? Would not the gospel become a distant need, a secondary thought, something that perhaps others need, but not me? What does my failure in temptation do, then, but remind me of my need for God, my reliance upon Christ and His work? Does it not push me, in a day that a thousand other concerns would cause me to forget, to enter into God’s presence through His mercies and Christ’s sacrifice and mediation that has been, and is being, performed daily on my behalf?

I am not perfect, but I am being perfected through a relationship with God through Christ, and this work of making me like Christ is being performed even in my failure to overcome temptation, even by means of my evil.

Does this mean that we should continue to purposely sin, and not resist temptation with the help of Christ and the power of God given to us to seek holiness, so that God’s work in this way might increase? As Paul said, “May it never be.” We are to work against enslavement, not toward it; but in those times that we fail to work toward it ourselves, we know that God is working toward it even in our failures.

So in this way, we can reform the Church by setting those things in place that seek a relationship with God through the truth and in holiness, but we should not lose heart because it, or we, fail to be the perfect reflection of Christ we wish to be, because if it is set on the path toward a genuine relationship with Him, it is set on the path toward a loving relationship with God that will work toward that goal on its own.

So our true response to our, or the Church’s, failures is to immediately seek out reconciliation with God the Father through Jesus Christ our Lord by the power and drawing of the Holy Spirit. In doing so, sin itself has become a means to our salvation rather than damnation, and so nothing will separate us from the love of God, not even our failure to live up to the standard to which Christ has called us.

I think this is what Luther meant by his statement to “sin boldly, but believe more boldly still.” I think he meant that the question isn’t whether one sins, but whether his sin drives him further toward or away from God. Does it increase or decrease his reliance upon Christ and His work of grace in our lives? Does it call our idolatrous hearts back to remembrance of our need for the only true God to be in our lives daily? It calls us to the throne room of our Father to seek communion with Him with all the more urgency, as we are afraid to be cut off from Him even for a moment. Luther is saying, I believe, that one should focus, not on his failures, but on Christ and His victory. Sin, but let your sin drive you to Christ all the more. In doing so, it is contributing toward its own death. In other words, have a theology of sin and salvation that makes sense of failure in the context of a salvation that is working in you.

If you don't, you're going to simply start believing that the church, and others, and you, are hopeless and damned. Who can be reformed if perfection is the standard? Who is saved if perfection is the evidence of salvation? No one. But salvation comes to us through our working out our salvation in fear and trembling, and part of that includes the times we fail to worship God in doing what is right.

So seek to refrain from evil and do good always, but when you fail, know that if your sin drives you toward Him (as it does Peter after he denied Christ), rather than away from Him (as it did Judas after he betrayed Christ), then even in this, God is working out His victory for you, and there is a need to rejoice even in a life of individual failures, because the whole of the life has sought to please and love God in a relationship with Him through the death and resurrection of His Son. And in doing so, even our thorns will work to guard our roses.

Thursday, April 26, 2012

A Review of My Book




This review appears in the Midwestern Journal of Theology.

 I would like to thank Professor Bechtold for his fine review. First, I would like to thank  Professor Bechtold for pointing out the fact that I should have included some commentary on the New Testament use of the Genesis days. He's right to point out that this was an oversight on my part. Although I do comment upon the Patristic use of 2 Peter 3:8, I could have discussed the NT writers' use of time in the OT more specifically, and especially could have discussed the Auctor's use of the seventh day of Genesis 1 as something that was yet to come in Hebrews 4. If I get a chance to revise the book at some point, I would like to implement Professor. Bechtold's suggestion.

In regard to transliterating the original languages, I simply did that as a personal preference. Often when I am reading a translated ancient text, my immediate thought is, I wonder what that says in the original? Hence, I included a transliteration for scholars who might be equally curious. If I get enough of them who find them unhelpful, however, I have no problem removing those to accommodate the reader.

There are a couple issues I hope to clarify. If I understand Professor Bechtold's criticisms correctly, I believe he thinks that I take the literal line of Cain and Seth as the two seeds of Gen 3:15. Actually, I take them to be used by the author of Genesis to represent two types of humanity, not the literal description of two families. Hence, the line of Seth is taken as the line that represents those who accept the creation mandate as their primary task in life, whereas the line of Cain represents those who follow the serpent's deception in seeking to be like God. Israel is connected to the line of Seth, precisely, because it is viewed as true humanity (at least in its faithful form), so it continues on, but the ending of the line of Cain does not threaten the interpretation, precisely, because the line represents a type of people that is picked up after the flood and largely characterizes much of the world outside of Israel, even after the line of Cain is wiped away.

Another concern that was voiced was that I took death to be merely expulsion, but that is not quite my argument. My argument is that the ancient Near Eastern mind views death in spheres, and so the further one gets from the garden sanctuary, the closer one gets to death/the land of disorder/the netherworld. Hence, to expel the human couple from the sanctuary is to send them into the land of death, where they will no longer have access to immortality, and eventually end up in the netherworld, i.e., physically die. My only point here is that death is a process that proceeds from a sphere of absolute life to lower spheres that eventually bring one to absolute death/the netherworld. This is why Cain is terrified of being sent out even further from the garden than his parents, and fears that he will have no protection out there, likely ending up completely dead. The terminology that presents the picture of being "cut off" from the people (i.e., God's presence and civilization) also holds this idea in later judgment texts. I'll attempt to develop this idea a bit more in my larger book on Genesis.

Another issue I should clarify is that I don't believe the numbers 40 or 7 are always figurative, but that the number 40 is often used figuratively and the number 7, whether figurative or literal, usually represents some sort of cleansing, and often ritual/cultic cleansing. The ancients likely did things literally in sevens because of the symbolism of the number. So I don't necessarily divorce literal and symbolic meaning there, only that it is possible to use the number in particular contexts in terms of what it symbolizes only. As for the number 40, although it can be used literally, I do believe that, in a context of anticipation/testing, it is meant to symbolically represent, rather than describe, the actual time frame in an effort to contribute to the drama of the picture be painted by the narrative. However, having said that, Professor Bechtold is right in saying that my comment concerning Jonah's having waited 40 days should not have implied that this was impossible, only that in view of the way the number is used, it is more likely that the actual time has been traded for this symbolic one to, again, contribute to the overall message being conveyed.


The last issue raised concerns the struggle of YHWH with chaos. Professor Bechtold comments that "Of further note is his reading of Genesis 2-3 in view of God’s struggle over chaos. While there is some evidence for this, Hodge tends to read too much implication into the evidence." I'm not quite sure what statements I've made that would lead to this conclusion, but again, this is actually the larger argument I'm making in my book concerning the theology of Genesis, so I can only assume that I haven't laid out as much as I needed to in order to convince Professor Bechtold of its overwhelming presence within the text. I hope to do a better job of it in the new book.

Again, I very much appreciate Professor Bechtold's review. I think he understands my main argument very well, and am, frankly, just ecstatic that someone actually read the book. I thank him for his kind words and recommendation.



Monday, April 23, 2012

God, Love, Revelation and Certainty


A young man from a secular university visits a seminary professor after a long sociology class, where he learned nothing about sociological method and everything about how to think correctly according to his university professor. He began to object to the absolute claims that Christianity makes, and ask why this seminary professor would bother teaching the Bible as anything other than an opinion among many opinions. The following dialogue is what ensues.

Religion always makes such claims of certainty and absolutism, but we can’t be certain of those things. I think that religious people are just trying to grab onto something more stable because they don’t want to deal with the messiness of life.

Really? That’s interesting. Why do you think that people can’t know anything spiritual with certainty?

Because we’re not God. We can’t know everything about everything, and so that means that we can’t really know anything with absolute certainty.

Fascinating. Can I ask you a question?

Sure.

Do you have exhaustive knowledge of your spouse? Do you know everything there is to know about him or her, every physical, mental, spiritual thing there is to know about him or her, every thought he or she thinks, etc.?

No.

Have you ever accidentally gone to bed with the wrong person, then, thinking that he or she was your spouse?

No.

I don’t understand. Why not? If you don’t have exhaustive knowledge of your spouse, how can you have certainty of who he or she is? If you can’t have certainty of who he or she is, then you can’t be certain that the postman, the girl at the grocery store, or Tom Cruise is not your spouse. How can you be certain that you never actually went to bed with someone you thought was your spouse, but wasn’t?

Because I know enough about him or her to be certain that he or she is the person who is my spouse and not a different person.

In other words, you have sufficient knowledge enough to know your spouse in distinction from other people, and that sufficient knowledge gives you certainty on the matter?

Yes.

Isn’t it the same when we discuss spiritual things?

No.

Why not?

Because I don’t know anything about spiritual things. I know some things about my spouse, enough to know them sufficiently, but that same is not true for spiritual things.

OK. So what certain and absolute belief does your statement assume?

What do you mean?

I mean, you’ve just stated something absolute and certain, and yet, you just said you can’t know anything about the spiritual realm that is absolute and certain, so I’m asking you what beliefs you have acquired with enough certainty to make that statement.

Well, I’m saying that I can’t be certain about spiritual things.

. . .  which is a statement of certainty about spiritual things. I’m now asking upon what belief, what certain assumption about spiritual things you have to believe first in order to make that statement.

Why don’t you tell me?

Sure. If I have someone who has exhaustive knowledge of the spiritual tell me something about what is spiritual, and He will aid me in understanding it, can I know something about the spiritual?

Maybe, but maybe not with certainty, since you do not have exhaustive knowledge yourself.

But we just established that you can have certainty with sufficient knowledge. You don’t need exhaustive knowledge to have certainty, correct?

Well, yes, you’re right on that.

So I can have certainty with sufficient knowledge, and sufficient knowledge can be give by one who has exhaustive knowledge, correct?

I would imagine so.

So what does the agnostic statement that one cannot have certainty about spiritual matters assume?

That God has not spoken sufficiently to people.

In other words, it assumes that the Bible isn’t true.

Well, there are other religions . . .

Yes, but even though other religions make absolute claims, there are only the three main religions who claim to have certainty based upon divine revelation spoken by God who has exhaustive knowledge, and all of them have their roots in the Bible, so really your statement is an attack upon the Bible as God’s revelation, isn’t it?

Well, yes, I suppose so. Perhaps the Bible has some insight, but I guess I’m assuming either that it is either not God telling us about spiritual matters, but humans giving us insightful remarks about spiritual matters, or it is God telling us about spiritual matters, but because we are imperfect, we cannot understand it exhaustively.

Which, again, we covered the latter, since we have already come to an agreement that sufficient knowledge, not exhaustive knowledge, is all that is needed to have certainty about something.

Yes.

So really it comes down to assuming that God has spoken or He has not spoken in the Bible, correct?

I suppose.

So let me ask you this, Do you believe that there is a God?

Yes, I do.

Do you believe that God is loving?

Yes.

Do you believe that with certainty?

I guess.

You guess?

Yes, I do.

How do you know that?

Well, I just believe it.

Based upon what?

I just think that God is loving.

OK, so you do believe something else concerning a spiritual matter with certainty. We just would have to say that you have no basis for believing it without divine revelation; but let’s move on to my next point.

OK.

If someone cannot know anything about spiritual matters, and what one believes about spiritual matters direct one’s life in the right or wrong directions, do you think that is it loving for God to not give us the sufficient knowledge we need to steer our lives in the right direction toward Him and what is spiritually good, but instead to leave us to hopefully stumble upon it in the dark?

Well, maybe it’s just loving to let us search for it?

Really? If your child needed a particular pill to save his life, do you think it is loving to let him search for it in a mountain of other pills that would kill him because you think he’ll benefit from the process? Would he really ever likely find it? How can we say that God is loving if He never gives us what we need to direct our love toward the rightful and worthy objects of that love?

Well, you’ll just know in your heart.

Now I would just give you the argument you first gave me. We are too finite and fallen to know what is true and good with any certainty. We cannot know spiritual matters with certainty, precisely, because our heart is incapable of leading us there. Ted Bundy followed his heart and he became a murderer. Hitler followed his heart and became a murderer. Pedophiles follow their hearts. Adulterers follow their hearts and ruin the lives of their spouses and children. Idolaters follow their hearts and end up worshiping vain gods. What good is the heart? As you admitted at the get go, we cannot know with certainty any of these matters if we only have our finite selfs as our compass, but not knowing will lead us and those we supposedly love (although we have no way of knowing if we actually love them) to complete and utter ruin. So do you really think the heart is the best vehicle we should use to direct us?

Well, when you put it that way, I guess not. But all of those people seemed like bad people who maybe had bad hearts.

How would judge a good from a bad heart without first knowing with certainty what is good and bad? You have to have a standard first, and everyone, even the theoretical agnostic, has absolute standards. The problem is that he says one thing about certainty, but then borrows all of the certainty from the Christian worldview upon which our society has based its moral certainty, only now he has removed the oil from the lamp, even though he still wants the wick to burn brightly. It just isn’t going to work. So I ask you again, if we are lost in the dark, how can we say that God is loving to leave us lost in the dark?

Well, not everyone is saved, so He does leave a lot of people in the dark, doesn’t He?

Sure, but not in the way that you seem to be suggesting. He leaves people in the dark who He has not purposed to save. Those He will leave to their own rebellion, but has more mercy upon, get no revelation at all. This is an act of divine judgment upon their sin against Him, so He is not merely leaving his children to destruction by not giving them revelation, but purposely not giving those He has decreed judgment upon without the revelation that would further damn them. Those who He purposes to heap judgment upon, because of the nature of their rebellion, He gives revelation to show that it is the rebellious and self-pleasing heart of man that is the problem in his quest for “truth,” not the condition of not having the truth. But those He wishes to save, upon whom He places His special love, even using the example of the damned to save and love the redeemed, to them He gives the truth of Scripture and the Holy Spirit through the Church to understand it, and they are directed, with great and absolute certainty, by that sufficient knowledge from an source with exhaustive knowledge, i.e., God.

Well, that doesn’t sound like the God I want to believe in. I want to believe that God is just as loving to all, and don’t believe that He is wrathful toward people.

Wow, for someone who doesn’t know anything about spiritual matters due to such human limitations that do not allow for it, you are pretty certain about quite a bit. But this is a great example of what I’m talking about. This is something we could only know from divine revelation. If we reason within ourselves, we will project our own ideas as true without having any basis for believing that they are, in fact, actually true. In other words, we have everything to suggest that we are self-deceived, and nothing to suggest that our opinions, apart from God’s communication to us via the Scripture, describe reality.

Well, maybe it’s OK to live in delusions if they make you happy and you accept yourself and your own limitations to have things right.

Let me ask you something, would you say the same thing concerning whether you were driving on the right side of the freeway with your kids in the car?

What do you mean?

I mean, you wouldn’t make this argument about any REAL thing. It’s just that you seem to think that spiritual things don’t function as REAL things, which again has a lot of assumptions that supposedly you cannot know. But let’s examine this for a moment. If the Bible is actually God communicating to His people, then will God lie to them?

Well, no, I don’t think He would.

So if He says that what you trust in and do in life matters, not only in this life, but in the next, and it matters so much that you will be eternally saved or damned based upon it, having grabbed hold of the true God’s hand versus slapping it away, do you think it would be wise to ignore that and opt to live in ignorance because it’s more of an exciting journey that way?

Well, no, if what is said is true, then it would be important to know what is true and good so that you didn’t end up wrecking people here and eternally damned.

So, really, if you can know with a certainty based upon sufficient knowledge given from an exhaustive source, and that source can sufficiently convey what is true concerning life and eternity, and there is great peril in not coming to the truth and good of the matter, both in this life (as is self evident) and in eternity to come, then if God exists and is loving toward His people, He has in fact given them revelation in the Bible that is sufficient enough for them to make absolute certain claims about the reality of spiritual matters, and to roll the eyes at this is only to evidence a contrary belief that is self defeating, as it must be certain about uncertainty in order to stand.

Can you run that by me again?

Sure. Let me break it down this way:

  1. Certainty is possible based upon sufficient knowledge.
  2. Humans can obtain sufficient knowledge.
  3. Humans can be certain.
  4. Humans cannot be certain about spiritual matters if they do not have sufficient knowledge concerning the spiritual.
  5. To be uncertain about spiritual matters means that God has left us to fend for ourselves or that He does not exist.
  6. Since we both believe that God exists and that He is loving, unless we are being judged by God in His wrath against those who love evil/that which is contrary to God and His true character, God would not leave us to fend for ourselves in matters that are vital to our life, either here or in eternity.
  7. God has therefore given us sufficient knowledge to believe and act with certainty upon what He has spoken to us.

I obviously believe, and have sometimes shown through different arguments, that the Bible is that source by which God has communicated to us spiritual matters, and therefore, it should be trusted above our human made opinions and religions, especially the postmodern pull to dislodge the Bible’s authority to make such claims via the agnosticism it seeks to paint as a more tolerable expression of humanity. In fact, it is the exact opposite. As humans, we are meant to worship God in truth and good, and without a certainty in what is true and good, our means to worship Him are dismantled. Once this is done, the unbelievers can become our prophets and ascend to the position of dictators of what is true, all the while claiming to not know anything with certainty. It’s a fantastic deception.

Well, that is certainly something to think about (pun intended). Thank you for the conversation.

Anytime.


Friday, April 20, 2012

The Warning Passages in Hebrews: The Means to God's Ends

In light of what I talked about yesterday, I wanted to help elucidate the purpose of the warning passages in the Book of Hebrews.

First, there exist numerous warning passages throughout the text that address both the peril of passively drifting away and actively persisting in rebellion against Christ and the gospel. These warnings all speak of the possibility that one who now believes will not be saved if he or she either drifts away or turns away deliberately (there is no distinction in Hebrews between the two paths for rejecting Christ as Lord).

The solution is to “pay closer attention to what you have heard” (2:1), to meet the gospel that is heard with faith (4:2), to “not harden your hearts” (3:8), to “take care lest their be any among you with an evil, unbelieving heart” (3:12), to “fear” (4:1), to “be diligent to enter God’s rest (4:11), because if we do not we will not escape from a “just retribution” (2:2–3), fall, not enter into His rest (4:1), and be incapable of repentance once again (6:4-8; 10:26-27).

So the question becomes, If the believer has been chosen by God before the foundation of the world to be saved, and no one ever becomes unsaved, why does the author present these warnings in the first place? In other words, there is no possibility for the Christian to lose his salvation, so why paint it this way?

Well, in light of what we spoke about yesterday, there is, in fact, a possibility that a person loses his salvation (from our perspective), and so the passages are being spoken from our perspective. This is very important to understand, from our perspective, we can lose our salvation. We can stop believing. We can let go of the faith. We can do this, because we are choosing to believe and hold on, so we can choose to not believe and let go. Again, this is the view from below. It is our experiential view, and that is what the author here is addressing.

But why bother if all Christians are going to be saved anyway? Because salvation is brought to the Christian through the means of his active participation in believing. God doesn't just decree that we will be saved and zap us into heaven. We are regenerated to believe through the urging of the Holy Spirit through the Word of God. In other words, our decision to believe is the means chosen by God to save us. Hence, we must be convinced by the Holy Spirit via the Word to believe.

This brings us to the next point. If we have to be convinced by the Holy Spirit via the Word to initially believe, we also need to be convinced by the Holy Spirit via the Word to keep believing. This is why the preached Word of God (via the Church) is so vital in a Christian's life, and without it, one falls away from the faith very quickly. What the warning passages in Hebrews amount to, then, is the Holy Spirit's method of convincing us to keep holding onto Christ.

But there is even more of a brilliance to this that often goes unnoticed. God has chosen our decision to have faith as the means through which He will save us, so that means that we must choose to keep that faith, to continually exalt Christ as Lord in our lives. What this means is that we must not turn from it, either slowly or abruptly, because of other concerns in life or death.

This brings us to the warning passages themselves. What is their function then? As we've already discussed, the speak with the perspective from below, but they do so in order to push us to the means of our salvation, i.e., faith.

Let me explain it this way. If you've ever seen the movie, "The Matrix," and liked it a lot, then you're cool. But beyond that, there is a great scene where Neo goes into see the Oracle, and as he enters the room, she says to him, "Don't worry about the vase." He then turns around to see what she is talking about, and in so doing, he knocks over the vase and breaks it. He then asks her, "How did you know?" She replies, "Ohh, What's really going to bake your noodle later on is, would you have broken it if I hadn't said anything?"

I love this scene because it brings out the purpose of Scriptural warnings well. Our salvation is through the convincing of the Holy Spirit through the Word of God, and if God had not convinced us through the Word of God, we would not have believed. Hence, the warning passages speak with the voice the view from below precisely because it is one of the means through which God convinces us to believe and to hold onto that faith.

In other words, we can ask God, "How did you know I would be saved," but He could just respond to us and say, "What's really going to bake your noodle later on is, whether you would have believed had I not said anything, had I not warned you that you could be lost, had I not said things in the way that I did."

Hence, the warning passages warn us of a reality within our experience: we might lose our faith and not be saved; but the irony is that these warnings are only effective in stirring those who are truly saved to keep the faith. In other words, they sober up true believers, and cause them to hold on tighter than before to Christ, not knowing if they have been elected for salvation or not. In this way, they become the vehicle through which God drives us to our destination, a destination of which He was always in control.

And that must be understood here. As I said yesterday, the view from below is always to be understood in light of the view from above. That's true in Hebrews as well. The author believes that it is God who is in sovereign control of our faith in the ultimate sense, so he is not departing from that, or advocating an alternate Wesleyian theology. He plainly says that it is Christ who is the "Author and Completer of our faith" (12:2). He is the one who authors our faith so that God can bring many sons to glory (2:10). Notice, God brings them there. They do not bring themselves. Even in the most terrifying of warning passages, where we are told that repentance is not possible for those who reject the faith, the idea is that God withholds repentance from them, showing that He is the One who grants or does not grant repentance that leads to faith. And in 13:21, it is God who equips us with every good thing to do His will, working in us that which is pleasing in His sight.

Hence, as Ellingworth notes,

The author . . . maintains a balance between describing his readers as sharing in Christ and in the blessings of faith (3:1, 14) and severely warning them of the dangers of apostasy” (Commentary on Hebrews, 323).

So God is the One who is ultimately saving His people, but His method of saving them is through the means of convincing them to believe and hold onto the vitality of their faith in Christ and the gospel. Without His convincing us through His Word, and specifically here, the warnings laid out for us, the ends would not be accomplished in the way that He has decreed them to be. It is through our choosing that God's choice is brought to fruition, not apart from it. It is, therefore, necessary for us to be alarmed by the warning passages, not knowing whether we will continue on in the faith or not, in order that we might continue on indeed.

Of course, those who reject, in all reality, never were saved, and the author indicates this by his switch of audience (third person for those who reject and second person for the Christians he is addressing); but he does this to use those who reject as a terrifying reminder that, from our perspective, one can strongly believe and then slowly drift or abruptly walk away.

The love of Christ, and the terror of being away from God in eternity, stirs the true believer to the decision to hold on tighter than before, and through his being stirred, God brings him to glory.




Therefore, let us fear lest, while a promise remains of entering His rest, any one of you should seem to have come short of it. For indeed we have had good news preached to us, just as they also; but the word they heard did not profit them, because it was not united by faith in those who heard. (Hebrews 4:1-2)