Justin Taylor commented on an interesting exchange between Carl Trueman and some of the T4G guys.
I think it is interesting that if the conference were to be nine local pastors who were solid, you wouldn't have tons of people coming from around the country for it. What does that say about why one might go to this? We can make the argument that we just like what these particular pastors have said, but we've only heard them because of their celebrity status. Their books sell because of their massive churches and their celebrity due largely to those churches or one particular book they've written that propelled them into the spotlight. We can make all of the excuses, and people who want to protect their heroes will always justify it, but the truth of the matter is that we are enamored with celebrity in our culture, and I see it all the time in evangelical circles. Thank Christ through the Holy Spirit for what you learn, and know that the same Spirit who speaks through these pastors speaks through pastors who are lesser known as well. So if He does, why not, at the very least, do as Carl suggested, and have a couple local guys preach there as well? At least that will give the impression that it is the Spirit through the Word that we are seeking rather than to hear our favorite rockstar sing.
Again, I realize that people are attracted to others who stir them emotionally and challenge them spiritually, but I can't help but feel that these pastors and megachurches are simply a sign of the times when Walmart takes over the little shops and people on TV have become our role models rather than the local fireman or teacher. Just my two cents on that.
Thursday, April 12, 2012
The Priority Argument in 1 Timothy 2:11-15
Perhaps the most controversial text within this study is 1 Tim 2:11–15. The text reads as follows:
A woman must learn in silence in complete submission.
Indeed[1], I neither allow a woman to teach nor to exercise authority over a man, but to be in silence.
For it was Adam who was first created, then Eve.
And Adam was not deceived, but the woman, being very deceived, turned into a disobedient person.
But she will be preserved through the bearing of children if they continue in faith and love and sanctity with modesty.
Of course, it must be acknowledged, along with Schreiner, that “[v]irtually every word in verses 11–12 is disputed,”[2] and much the same can be said for verses 13–15 to follow. In such an environment, it is impossible to pursue every controversy to a satisfactory degree, given the limited scope of this work. However, it should be sufficient to acknowledge that significant points have been made on both sides of the issues involved. I simply must choose those positions which I consider to be weightier in their analyses, and are, as said before, more consistent with all of the evidence at hand.
The ga/r in v. 13 gives the reason for the command/prohibition in vv. 11–12. Hence, Paul roots what he says specifically upon the reasoning to follow. It was Adam who was created first, then Eve. By appealing to the creation narrative to support his conclusion, Paul has made a priority argument already. However, he then gives a priority argument within the priority argument by bringing out what God made first as a way to argue for priority among the sexes.
Knight observes that Paul uses the PA both here and in 1 Cor 11:8–9, noting as well that Jesus uses the same argument to demonstrate “that God intends permanence for marriage between men and women.”[3]
In fact, virtually all commentators acknowledge the intent of the author to establish relational roles of men and women upon the Gen 2 creation narrative, as well as its subsequent narrative in Gen 3. Collins states:
The Pastor follows early Christian tradition in seeing the creation narratives of Genesis 1–2 as providing the basic paradigm for the relationship between man and woman (Matt. 19:5; Mark 10:7; 1 Cor. 6:16; Eph 5:31). Early Christian tradition regarded Adam and Eve as the prototypical human beings. In 1 Cor. 11:2–16 Paul uses the creation narratives as a theological warrant for his own exhortation on the type of hairstyle appropriate to men and women at prayer. The apostle inserts the text, “the two shall become one flesh” (Gen. 2:24), in his reflection on men’s use of prostitutes (1 Cor. 6:12–20). In later correspondence with the Corinthians, Paul writes about Eve’s deception (2 Cor. 11:3). The Pastor picks up the same theme in verse 14 . . . Adam possesses relative superiority because he was created before her (prōtos). In rabbinic tradition, that which was first narrated enjoys priority. Paul uses this hermeneutical principle to good advantage when he writes about righteousness and faith in Rom. 4:9–12 and about the promise and the law in Rom. 4:13–15. Similarly, in early rabbinic thought what God first created was more important (see Siphra Deut. 11:10; Str-B 3:256–58; 645–46).[4]
Guthrie, likewise, comments that “the assumption seems to be that the original creation, with the Creator’s own imprimatur upon it, must set a precedent for determining the true order of the sexes.”[5]
As in 2:5 the taproot for the universality of Christian prayer was found in the Deuteronomic Shema( of Israel, so here the directives for a Christian wife are based upon the Torah, specifically the Genesis creation narrative (recall the Pauline appeal to ho nomos in 1 Cor 14:34). The author of PE evinces no hesitation about the value of the created order, about its goodness, about its belonging to the positive will of God for humankind . . . [The creation account in Gen 2] is exploited in two stages, the first fixing on the creation itself on the archetypal man, Adam, and the second drawing upon the history of the primeval violation of God’s command to his creatures . . . The nerve of the argument here is that not only did God freely create both but he chose to create them in the order noted. Consequently, the priority of the husband over wife as God’s original choice is not to be contravened by his creatures.[6]
Quinn and Wacker also note the comparison between what the author of 1 Timothy argues here and the authority and blessing placed upon the firstborn in the ancient world; but insist that the “argument here goes beyond nature to its personal creator, to whom Adam and his wife (unlike the rest of creation) must personally give an accounting.[7]
However, after acknowledging the PA, many commentators go on to argue that such is employed with merely the intent to establish a cultural ideal. In other words, the cultural idea first presents itself and then is read back into the creation account. Hence, Collins states that “as did other authors writing from within Hellenistic Judaism, the Pastor uses the Jewish Scriptures to endorse cultural values.”[8] Likewise, Guthrie suggests that Paul’s reason for rooting the prohibition in Eve’s transgression is due, not to her transgressing her role and being deceived as a result, but to her lack of acquaintance with the subject matter (i.e., the nature of the tree in the Genesis narrative). Hence, the prohibition in 1 Tim 2:12 is “conditioned by the background of the basic lack of education of women in the contemporary world.”[9]
In the discussion concerning Adam and Eve in 1 Tim 2:13, Küchler correctly observes that it was commonplace to understand what was first made as superior to what was made later.
Es ist eine Alltagsweisheit, die aus der literarischen = zeitlichen Priorität der Erschaffung Adams vor Eva eine qualitative Superiorität Adams (und aller Männer) über Eva (und alle Frauen) zu folgern imstande ist : “Der Erste is der Beste.” Dieser Grundsatz, der dem antiken und modernen Menschen gemeinsam ist, lässt sich in den antiken Texten auf ganz verschiedene Weise ausgedrückt vorfinden. Er wird benutzt, sowohl um literarische wie auch um zeitliche Abfolgen in wertmässige Abstufungen zu übertragen.[10]
But he then argues that such an argument has no place in light of the new Christian reality that the “first will be last and last will be first.”[11] Hence, the progressive hermeneutic he adopts seeks to either (1) place what is said in the realm of the temporary situation and circumstance in which they arise by arguing as to whether it is a legitimate interpretation of Genesis 2 and a legitimate argument to make (thus arguing with the author); (2) assuming a priori that such an argument for hierarchy is inconsistent with the humility statements made by Jesus, rather than attempting to understand what Jesus says as a way of understanding how one ought to conduct oneself within those hierarchies; (3) assuming that the author is attempting to maintain a long history of oppression toward women rather than liberate them (contra 2:15, where the author’s purpose is clearly to show the way of salvation for women rather than to prevent her redemption).
All of the above fail to acknowledge the genuine purpose of the PA, and how it is used in the New Testament (in distinction from texts like Jubilees), when it is employed (i.e., the ancient author does not seek to undermine other scriptural passages, but views other Scripture in light of the PA he is making; he views the source text as cryptically teaching by way of his logic or by the details found within that text, rather than simply reading what he wishes to be universal back into the text; and that restoration to the freedom from the deception and oppression of the demonic world [in continuity with Jubilees et al.] or from a wayward understanding of what God has said due to lack of further contextual principles established at the beginning of an institution, is the very goal of the PA).
Hence, although these scholars acknowledge the appeal to the PA, in failing to understand the nature of the PA, they fail to understand the argument that is being made. The author of the Pastorals is surely aware of Jesus’ teaching concerning humility, and hence, as all PA’s used in the New Testament that have been examined thus far, would not be seeking to undermine what he views as Scripture,[12] but rather to interpret those texts in light of the others.
But it is also important to note that the principle was not simply to state that whatever was first was best, but that whatever God ordered or observed first was to be given priority. Since it was believed that God does nothing that is arbitrary, the order He established in creation was the order He intended all to observe. And this order can be gleaned from texts, precisely, because, as inspired texts, they are not arbitrarily ordering the sequence of the creation of the first human couple. Instead, to the ancient author, they must be delineating the same authority that one observes in nature and political history (i.e., that man is meant to lead). This places the woman in the role of following (as her creation followed that of the man’s), rather than in one of leading. It is this order of authority that Paul expresses in 1 Tim 2:13 and elsewhere (e.g., 1 Cor 11:2–9 and 14:34–35), not merely the idea that whatever comes first is better than what comes later.[13]
Elements that May Indicate Cultural Limitations on the PA
There are a few textual objections raised against the idea that with the use of the PA the author of 1 Timothy intends to convey a universal and absolute principle. There are three that I think should be addressed here.
One of these objections is to view the verb e0pitre/pw as expressing a temporal prohibition rather than an ongoing one. It is argued that the word usually appears in contexts where the prohibition is not permanent, and thus, perhaps, it is not permanent here either.
The problem with this argument is that it attempts to import a nuance of the word from another text, and hence, commits an illegitimate transference of meaning. One could argue that the word e0pilamba/nomai is used in narrative always to refer to a physical apprehension of something temporarily. Yet, in the epistles to Timothy and to the Hebrews, the word refers only to a spiritual apprehension of salvation eternally. One would not be able to limit the semantic range in one context with those in another without completely misconstruing the author’s intentions. The situation with the word e0pitre/pw is parallel to this one.[14]
Other arguments in favor of temporal limitations look to the context to discover whether some heresy is afoot, so as to temporarily cause the apostle to limit the woman’s role in that context alone; but these all beg the question in terms of whether the cultural situation is the cause of the prohibition or merely the occasion for Paul to remind Timothy of a universal principle and the absolute application thereof. Such cultural observations, therefore, must remain neutral until the purpose of the PA can be decided, since it is in the PA that Paul roots his reasons for the prohibition (per ga/r in v. 13), not in some cultural circumstance.
Finally, the issue as to what kind of authority and teaching that the apostle prohibits is hotly debated, but this too bases itself off of the assumptions above. If the apostle roots his teaching in creation, it would seem odd to prohibit women from exercising an abusive authority or teach what is false. One would think such a prohibition was for everyone. It also seems that Paul allows the man to do what he prohibits the woman from doing, so arguing that such authority is abusive or teaching is in error lacks any sense here.
The scope of this study, however, is not to argue in favor of one interpretation over another, but to argue that whatever is being said, by virtue of the employment of a PA, the author intends it to be a universal absolute. Hence, the issues that remain at odds, such as whether the designation gunh/ refers to a woman in general or a wife specifically,[15] would only be a matter of limiting the universal principle to the sphere of husbands and wives, rather than place any temporal/cultural limitation upon the principle itself. As such, there is no need to pursue this objection at length here.
Indications of Universal and Absolute Authorial Intention
Instead, one of the very first indications that Paul is attempting to make a universal argument here is the very fact that he attempts to root what is already culturally acceptable in the creation. The evidence overwhelmingly suggests that both Jews and Greeks agreed that the public domain belonged to males, and such “encompassed the role of proclamation and teaching.”[16] Hence, as Luke Timothy Johnson put it, “everywhere in this male-defined Mediterranean world, the submission of women to men was the basic cultural assumption.”[17] Paul is then seen by many as one who is merely following the winds of both his Jewish and Hellenistic cultural heritage.
However, it is interesting that so common a cultural understanding would require him to make such a bold argument. Why argue that the idea that women are not to take upon themselves authority over, and teach, men is rooted in creation if everyone already believes that women ought not to exercise authority over or teach a man? The PA normally exists to override a cultural assumption, not to simply make one more concrete.
I would submit that the mere employment of a PA in such a context indicates that Paul desires to argue the case apart from cultural assumptions. It is possible that an over-realized eschatology, in terms of the roles of men and women, on the part of his recipients, perhaps produced by a misunderstanding of his own statement in Gal 3:28, may have given occasion for his desire to do this, but apart from the texts that we have, his rationale for its employment cannot be rooted in culture, since the very PA employed, as we have seen, argues that, although he may be addressing a cultural concern, his sights are set on a larger understanding of universal principles that override cultural speculations and traditions.
Hence, it is the very fact that Paul does not need to make a PA argument here, and yet does, that may display the intent of his argument to transcend mere culturally induced pragmatic solutions to cultural questions, and to instead address cultural ideas with universal ones.
But such a claim must be bolstered, as I have been attempting to show, by other statements within the text, besides the PA, that indicate Paul is arguing for a universal and absolute principle. I believe there are three of these within this text: (1) The multiple literary devices that exist between vv. 11 and 12 that indicate absoluteness in what is being said; (2) the fact that the prohibition is only given in regard to women over men, not women over women or children; and (3) the idea found within the concept of teknogoni/a, where the woman is saved by taking upon that role in contrast to the role Paul is describing in terms of authority and teaching with the view toward becoming an overseer in 3:1ff.
Universal Indications via Syntactic Structure
The first supporting elements one must evaluate within the text are the various literary devices used within it. Part of the problem within the modern interpretation of this passage is that verses 11 and 12 have often been interpreted in isolation from one another rather than being seen as a contrastive parallelism.[18] A breakdown of the structure will hopefully illumine my point.
A Gunh_ e0n h(suxi/a| manqane/tw
B e0n pa/sh| u(potagh|~
A / dida/skein de\ gunaiki\ ou)k e0pitre/pw
B / ou)de\ au)qentei=n a)ndro/v, a)ll’ ei]nai e0n h(suxi/a|
The above displays the AB::A/B / pattern that then allows one to see the contrastive parallel.
A The woman is to learn in silence
B [she is to be] in complete submission
A / She is not permitted to teach [over a man]
B / Nor is she permitted to exercise authority over a man, but to remain silent in that regard as well
This contrast then sets up a type of merism between the two groups. The woman learning in silence is contrasted with teaching, and her being in complete submission is contrasted with her exercising authority. The merism then displays the absoluteness of what Paul is arguing, since the amount of teaching the woman is to perform over the man is none at all. She is to learn in silence rather than teach anything. To be in silence means one is not teaching anything at all.[19] Likewise, her being in complete submission means that she is not exercising any authority over a man at all. The amount of authority over a man she is given then is nonexistent. If all of that is missed, Paul creates an inclusio with the phrase e0n h(suxi/a|, which could be interpreted as encapsulating everything he says in verses 11 and 12.[20] Hence, silence is to characterize the disposition of the woman rather than one where she voices her opinion through teaching and exercising authority over a man.[21]
What this all means for the reader is that Paul is not simply prohibiting a specific type of teaching or authority over men (i.e., whether it is a heretical teaching or otherwise), but that he is prohibiting any type of teaching and any type of authority that a woman might perform over a man. Such an absolute prohibition already indicates that the particulars of cultural circumstance are not considered.[22] Hence, one must either argue that Paul temporarily prohibits women from all forms of teaching and authority over men, or that he is teaching a universal. The idea that he is merely prohibiting a type of teaching and authority over men, but permitted other types (e.g., women teaching over men in lesser roles than that of the overseer), that limit the prohibition to only certain types of authority and teaching over men, goes against the grain of the literary structure.
The Limitations are not Culturally Produced
The second indication that Paul’s statement is more absolute and universal, stemming from a universal principle rather than a cultural circumstance, is that his prohibition is specifically over a man (a)ndro/v). If the prohibition was due to a cultural circumstance, such as certain women teaching things that were false, either by way of heresy or by way of their lack of education, the limitation of the prohibition to just the relationship between a woman over a man makes no sense whatsoever. Does Paul mean to say that women cannot teach a man false things but she can teach other women and children what is false? This same critique can be made of those who seek to interpret au)qentei=n as a negative authority, such as domineering or usurping authority.[23] A woman can exercise abusive authority over other women and children, but not over men? Again, such interpretations do not take what is said as a whole, and thus miss the universal rationale that Paul makes himself, which is not rooted in temporary deficiencies of the woman’s abilities, but in specific roles God designated in creation to the man and woman. Hence, since the limitations are not culturally produced, as would be the case if the concern were her lack of education or false teaching, it must be taken as universal as the limitation itself (i.e., if she is not to teach or exercise authority over a man, then whenever a man exists in the assembly, the prohibition exists).
The Woman’s Salvation Is Found in Taking Up
Her Role within the Household
Finally, the absolute or universal ethos of the text can be found in the statement that women shall be saved via childbearing as a head attribute of her gendered expression of her humanity. She, in contrast to taking upon herself the teaching and authoritative roles of men, who function much like fathers in the household of the church (cf. 1 Tim 3:2, 4–5), is sanctified instead by becoming a mother.[24] If teknogoni/a, which literally means “childbearing,” is understood to identify the physical role of the woman in order to represent her primary role within the family, then Paul may be arguing here that it is inconsistent to have her play a fatherly role within the church, since it would be contrary to who she is as a woman conditioned for motherhood instead.[25] Her role is one of motherhood, not fatherhood; and as such, to assign her a role where she takes upon the functions of fatherhood (teaching and exercising authority over the entire family) is to assign her a role against her nature and role within society[26]—a nature to which Paul has already sought to establish from the Genesis narratives by his use of the PA.
Given these factors, Paul would not merely be arguing that the identification of the woman’s role, which is based upon her position in the family, as it is evidenced in her biological makeup to bear children, is merely a cultural assignment designated to her by a patriarchal society that sees men as better than women. Instead, her role is consistent with who God made her to be, and this interpretation is more consistent with what we see her assigned elsewhere in the Pastorals.[27]
Hence, these indicators strongly support the idea that the PA Paul uses here is meant to argue that the woman’s subordinate role is instituted by God, as it is evidenced by her late creation in regard to the man (v. 13), and in the Genesis 3 narrative, where those roles were not observed, and chaos ensued because of it (v. 14).[28] Her salvation is to be found in taking upon her role as mother (v. 15), redeeming who she is as Eve, and hence, this must be accomplished by not recommitting the error that Eve committed by seeking to become like Adam in taking upon herself the role reserved for men (vv. 11–12). Hence, Paul’s answer to her fallen predicament is the same as God’s answer to Eve’s in Gen 3:16, where the woman will find redemption in taking upon the role that God gave to her in Genesis 2 (although in a fallen world with greater difficulty now).[29]
These three elements indicate that Paul’s argument is meant to be an absolute and universal one. Hence, the use of the PA here is also meant to serve this purpose. Like the PA’s found within the wider corpus of Second Temple texts, it serves to root what is in what was at the creation of the world. If this is the way things were and are set up by God to function then this is the way things are meant to be ordered always.
Therefore, all questions concerning the sociohistorical background that may have given rise to Paul’s argument are moot if they seek to determine the cultural limitations of Paul’s words here. The point of using the PA is to argue that there are no limitations, for limitations presuppose superiority in authority to delimit, and that which is rooted in creation, and thus shows God’s intended order for all creation, is superior to all ideas that may arise within the cultural circumstances that follow creation.[30]
Thus, whether due to a concern about heresy, making it an odd prohibition, since it only prohibits one gender to exercise authority over, and teach, another rather than anyone teaching heresy, male or female, or due to a concern that cultural sympathies be not disturbed so that the church would not be seen as culturally subversive because of it, although interesting, are wholly irrelevant in light of the use of the PA.[31]
Hence, what one gleans from the passage is that the author intends to make an absolute statement concerning gender roles within the assembly that are based upon gender roles within the family, which are themselves based upon the divinely ordered roles as they are displayed in the creation and fall narratives of Gen 1 and 2. In other words, he supports his already existing argument concerning the absolute boundaries of gender roles within church government by appealing to the beginning of the world. He does so to place a limit upon the notion that equality before Christ means a dissolution of gender distinctions and their respective expressions within the household of God.
[1] I agree with Thomas R. Schreiner, “An Interpretation of 1 Timothy 2:9–15: A Dialogue with Scholarship,” in Women in the Church: A Fresh Analysis of 1 Timothy 2:9–15 (ed. Andreas Köstenberger et al.; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker, 1995), 124, that the de/ might be but a mild adversative here. However, I have translated it here as emphatic simply because I think it fits the absoluteness of Paul’s argument better.
[2] “A Dialogue,” 121.
[3] George W. Knight III, Commentary on the Pastoral Epistles (NIGTC; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 1992), 143.
[4] Collins, I & II Timothy, 70–71.
[5] Guthrie, The Pastoral Epistles, 87.
[6] Quinn and Wacker, 1 Timothy, 226.
[7] Ibid., 226–27.
[8] Collins, I & II Timothy, 72.
[9] Guthrie, The Pastoral Epistles, 88. Although Guthrie does admit that this interpretation of Genesis 3 is somewhat “forced,” he concludes that the “question of women teachers cannot be divorced from the disparity between men and women in the matter of education” (Ibid.). Again, the question as to why this prohibition is only over men, why Timothy’s mother and grandmother are praised for teaching him Scripture, and why it is that Gentiles who had no prior knowledge of the Scripture, but could be taught it, were not excluded from teaching if lack of education of women within the culture was the issue.
[10] Küchler, Schweigen, 21.
[11] Ibid., 32.
[12] e.g., The Gospel of Luke is cited as Scripture in 1 Tim 5:18, and Jesus’ teaching concerning humility can be found in Luke 13:30.
[13] As I have shown, a repudiation of this idea can be found in The Life of Adam and Eve (Vita 14.3), when Satan attempts to make the argument that he was made before Adam and therefore, being superior to him, he will not serve him. This tells us that the ancients did not believe the idea that “Der Erste ist der Beste” in terms of all things, but only in terms of divinely established order within human roles, decrees, rituals, covenants, etc., or in terms of God’s attributes and those things associated with Him (e.g., wisdom).
[14] For a fuller refutation of arguments that center on temporality, see William D. Mounce, Pastoral Epistles (WBC; Nashville, Tenn..: Word, 2002), 120.
[15] Jerome D. Quinn and William C. Wacker, The First and Second Letters to Timothy: A New Translation with Notes and Commentary (ECC; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Eerdmans, 2000), 221, take the term to refer to a “married woman” based upon the switch from the plural in vv. 9–10 to the singular use in vv. 11–12. This is quite a stretch of the grammar, however, as one would wonder why a command, usually framed in terms of singulars (cf. the law codes in Deuteronomy), needs to maintain a plural use, especially since Paul clearly in the context establishes the idea that a singular woman (i.e., Eve) represents all women (as evidenced by the switch back to the plural in v. 15). For arguments in favor of the generic understanding, see Schreiner, “A Dialogue,” 115–17 and Mounce, Pastoral Epistles, 112.
[16] Johnson, Letters, 135. See also Quinn and Wacker, Timothy, 225.
[17] Johnson, Letters, 136.
[18] Although many scholars do understand the two verses as a couplet (e.g., Kuchler, Schweigen, 11), the merism (a contrast of polar opposites to convey totality) is almost universally missed.
[19] In agreement with Andreas Köstenberger, “A Complex Sentence Structure in 1 Timothy 2:12,” in Women in the Church: A Fresh Analysis of 1 Timothy 2:9–15 (Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker, 1995, 81–103, the pattern indicates that the ou)de/ here is coordinating rather than subordinating, and that the evidence points to the two terms having only a positive connotation in this context. This also best explains the qualifying Genitive a)ndro/v, taken in conjunction with the infinitives used, “over a man,” since if the authority or teaching was negative, it would make little sense to use a qualifier at all here.
[20] Köstenberger, “A Complex Sentence Structure,” 91.
[21] The contrastive parallel between verses 11 and 12 here also allow us, therefore, to conclude that interpreting e0n h(suxi/a as “in quietness,” as opposed to “in silence,” makes little sense. As full submission is the opposite of having authority, so learning in silence is the opposite of teaching. This is over and above the fact that what the woman is told to do here is “learn” e0n h(suxi/a, not “teach” e0n h(suxi/a. The prepositional phrase refers to the manner of her learning, then, not her teaching, and learning in silence makes much more sense given both the textual, intertextual (cf. 1 Cor 14:34–35), and historical context. Also see Schreiner, “A Dialogue,” 123–24.
[22] Of course, whether this is applied to a sphere of life outside of the church is a question of application, not exegesiss, as the context here is the ecclesiastical community.
[23] The word has been the primary subject of debate, but it’s meaning is safely established by employing the appropriate linguistic principles to lexicography in terms of the synchronic rather than diachronic method. See H. Scott Baldwin, “A Difficult Word: au)qente/w in 1 Timothy 2:12,” in Women in the Church, and “au)qente/w in Ancient Greek Literature” in Ibid., 269–305.
[24] See Schreiner, “A Dialogue with Scholarship,” 151, who argues that “when Paul says that a woman will be saved through childbearing, he means, therefore, that they will be saved by adhering to their ordained role.” Also see Ronald Y. K. Fung, “Ministry in the New Testament,” in The Church in the Bible and the World (ed. D. A. Carson ; Grand Rapids, Mich.: Baker, 1987), 204.
[25] The familial model upon which this interpretation depends is found throughout the Pastorals. Hence, David G. Horrell, “From a)delfoi/ to oi]koj qeou~: Social Transformation in Pauline Christianity” JBL 120 (2001): 307, states: “This concern for the ‘proper’ and traditional structuring of social relations between household members—the concern central to the household codes of Colossians and Ephesians—appears elsewhere in the Pastoral Epistles, though nowhere is there a concise and complete domestic code comparable to those found in Col 3:18–4:1 and Eph 5:2–6:9. Notable in the Pastoral Epistles is the teaching directed toward the subordinate social parties—women and slaves—that urges these people to remain quietly in their place (1 Tim 2:9–15; 6:1–2; Titus 2:1–10). The male heads of the households are urged to govern their households well—keeping their children submissive, and so on—and thus to qualify as potential leaders over the church itself (1 Tim 3:4–5, 12–13).” See also his further comments in Ibid., 308-9, as well as Vern Poythress, “The Church as a Family: Why Male Leadership In The Family Requires Male Leadership In The Church As Well,” in Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood (ed. John Piper and Wayne Grudem; Wheaton, Ill.: Crossway, 2006), 233–47. See also N. Brox, Die Pastoralbriefe (RNT 7; Regensburg: Pustet, 1969), 157, who states that 1 Tim 3:15, which discusses the “household” of God, is the “zentrale ekklesiologische Stelle der drei Briefe.” For a good summary discussion, see Marshall, Pastoral Epistles, 232–36.
[26] I concur with Schreiner (“A Dialogue,”146–54) that the childbearing here is a reference to the woman fulfilling good works that characterize the means of sanctification within her role. The idea is that she is redeemed by becoming who she was meant to be, not by becoming something else. What Philip A. Harland, “Familial Dimensions of Group Identity (II): ‘Mothers’ and ‘Fathers’ in Associations and Synagogues of the Greek World” JSJ 38 (2007): 57–79, argues is most illuminating as that which provides precedence in the ancient world for seeing family as a foundational pattern for all societal institutions. He concludes: “When authors from Aristotle on discuss the building blocks of society, they stress the household as the basic unit of society, suggesting that good management of the household would mean good management of the polis (πόλις). And when they discuss household management, the father’s rule over the household is oft en taken as an analogy for leadership in society more broadly. The household is, in many ways, a microcosm of society or, as expressed by Philo of Alexandria, “a house is a city compressed into small dimensions, and household management may be called a kind of state management” (On Joseph 38 [trans. LCL]). So comparisons worked both ways. Actual parental leadership was a model for leadership and beneficence in the civic setting and, conversely, leadership or benefaction in civic contexts and associations could be expressed in terms of parental activity” (Ibid., 76).
[27] I. Howard Marshall, The Pastoral Epistles (ICC; Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1999), 604; Horrell, “Social Transformation,” 308, fn. 61.
[28] The reason for the fiasco is thought by many, including the rabbis to be provided by the Genesis narrative itself and is due to the fact that Adam listened to the voice of his wife (3:17). See Thomas C. Oden, First and Second Timothy and Titus (Interpretation; Louisville, Ky.: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1989), 100. It is clear that when Eve was being deceived by the serpent, Adam was present with her, and yet, the narrative portrays him as a silent partner (v. 7). Schreiner (Ibid., 145) concludes: “The significance of the serpent targeting Eve is magnified, for apparently Adam was with Eve (3:6) during the temptation In approaching Eve, then, the serpent subverted the pattern of male leadership and interacted only with Eve during temptation. Adam was present throughout and did not intervene. The Genesis temptation, therefore, is a parable of what happens when male leadership is abrogated.” Although what Schreiner says here is probably too much, the idea that Paul finds significance in the details lends itself to the argument that he is appealing to the temptation in the context of gender roles, precisely, because a confusion of gender roles leads to an unprotected stewardship (e.g., Adam’s wife, the family, the Church). Cf. also Fung, “Ministry in the Church,” 202; Hurley, Man and Woman, 214–16; and Moo, “Rejoinder,” 204.
[29] The word teknogoni/av itself is likely taken by Paul from the phrase Mynb ydlt that is translated in the LXX of Genesis 3:16, as te/ch| te/kna. Paul here turns it into a virtuous aspect of the woman’s character to which the woman is to attain by grammatically forming it as a qualitative noun.
[30] Thus refuting the proposal made by Krister Stendahl, The Bible and the Role of Women (trans. Emilie T. Sander; Philadelphia, Pa.: Fortress, 1966), 34, that New Testament teaching points “beyond and even ‘against’ the prevailing view and practice of the New Testament church,” as the employment of the PA would indicate that Paul intends to instruct the church beyond the limitations of its cultural boundaries.
[31] The question concerning the identification of a)nh/r and gunh/ as either “male” and “female” generically, or “husband” and “wife” specifically is an important one. If the prohibition is merely upon wives concerning their husbands then it is possible to see Paul’s concern as merely one where the roles within marriage are applied everywhere, even in the assembly. However, the context strongly suggests that the more generic “male” and “female” are in view here. Paul has just given instructions to males concerning prayer, not just to husbands. Likewise, he has just given instructions to women concerning their modesty, not just to wives. Furthermore, the woman seems to be excluded from being an overseer in the text that follows on the heals of this one (3:1–7), where the man who desires to be an overseer is to be the husband of one wife and manage his household appropriately in discipline.
Wednesday, April 11, 2012
On Being a Steward and Not a King
One of the great scenes in "The Return of the King" is when Gandalf goes before Denethor, the steward of Gondor, and challenges him to do his duty. Denethor is only concerned at that point of keeping his throne, a throne that does not belong to him in the first place. He is drunk with power (and despair for fear of losing it, since he's been frightened by what he has seen in the seeing stone) and cannot, therefore, see clearly. Gandalf then rebukes him by telling him that he is not the king, but only a steward. He does not have the authority to prevent the return of the king, i.e., the right of the king to take up the throne in place of the steward who must relinquish it.
This scene has some resonance for me, as I have loved the church and have desired Christ to rule over it, but there seem to be far too many who wish to rule over it instead. In fact, I could have simply entitled this post, "A Tale of Two Overseers," since my concern is to lay out what the "desire" of the overseer should be versus what it should never be. Because I have so many friends who have gone into ministry, and have been good friends with virtually all of my pastors, I think I have a bit of an insight into something that I have noticed in many of them, but not in others (others who, unfortunately, are few among their number). And this tendency that I have noticed in them is simply this: a desire for power.
On the one hand, people are going to want to use their gifts, and will seek out the greatest amount of opportunity to do so. That's a good thing. If one is a teacher or pastor, then one will often want to seek out the office of overseer, as it will afford him more opportunity to use those gifts. But one must be very careful that he does not seek it out because he likes to be in front of people, or have control. Controlling people are dangerous people to the ministry. They have a hard time letting Christ lead.
You see, if you have an overseer that starts talking about the church as "his," and that not in a more common way as even layman do (i.e., "I'm going to my church today" --- the possessive pronoun used to convey belonging rather than personally possessing), then you may be encountering one who desires to ascend rather than to serve in humility. This is why hierarchies in the church eldership are so dangerous. They exist when we view elders as senior pastors and associate pastors, or even more subtly, as elders within which a non-labeled hierarchy still exists. There is no hierarchy in the community of elders in the Bible, and when the Corinthians try to pull this even among the apostles, they are rebuked for it (1 Cor 1:12-15). There is only one King. Everyone else is just a steward. There is a hierarchy among God's kingdom for purposes of holding up the truth against heresy and impurity that leads Christ's kingdom to ruin (1 Tim 3:15 in view of the entire letter); but this hierarchy is one of multiple elders who function as authoritative servants who must seek Christ to rule over them and the people, not the desire to rule itself.
The tricky thing is that people often don't realize that they are seeking power, and of course, no one presents it that way to himself. Our desire for power is often hidden in the desire that we do things "the right way," which ends up being what one particular individual wants over the other individuals.
So in light of our own self delusions, let me ask you a series of questions to help you see if you might be seeking more control than stewardship before God.
1. Are you fine with other elders taking the head as preaching and exercising authority instead of you overseeing their overseeing? Obviously, elders should function together, so nothing is simply a one man show, or should be, at any time; but my point here is to ask whether you need to be the one who always gets the veto power or needs to spearhead something. In other words, does it make you uncomfortable, like someone is stealing your power, when another overseer (in continuity with the larger group of course) takes the reigns of something that may not be in your personal control? Does this create an anxiety for you or a relief that you are not the only one working to exalt Christ as King over the congregation?
2. Do you feel like you want more of an inlet into people's lives in your congregation? Now, this one can be tricky (aren't they all?), as it may be that sometimes an overseer is too disconnected from people in the congregation. However, many times this is the subtle desire to get more control/power, so that the more one is in the lives of others, the more one can steer those lives in the direction he wants. Less anxiety then exists if one can see what's going on behind the scenes. This, of course, does not give control and trust to the Holy Spirit who testifies to individuals of Christ who works all things to the glory of the Father, and the Father, in return, exalts Him as King over those people's lives. In other words, it is a sin against the entire Godhead to need such control.
3. Are you continually worried that people will leave if you say or do the wrong thing, even when what you say or do comes from the Bible itself? For example, if you exercise church discipline, do you have such anxiety over it (everyone will have some anxiety over such a difficult thing) that you fail to do it altogether? Do you hold back preaching and teaching certain aspects of the whole counsel of God in Scripture because people might leave or attribute you less authority to say other things to them? This is pure manipulation of your duty in an effort to gain or keep power. It seeks to obtain power through giving people what they want rather than exalting Christ as King through one's teaching and exercise of authority. Hence, in this one, an illusion that one wants less power is created by diminishing one's role as an overseer, but in reality, it is a diminishing of Christ's authority in order that the overseer might grab more authority for himself. The steward is to exalt Christ as King, not himself, and therefore, ought to obey Christ in his making disciples by means of teaching ALL that Christ commanded (Matt 28:19-20).
4. Do you feel jealous when others compliment another overseer for their teaching ability, or what they learned by him, or their show of love for him? Perhaps, they want him to preach for awhile? Are you threatened by that? Perhaps they invite him over to dinner more? Are you offended by that? You should rejoice that the Word of the King is desired through anyone who would preach it accurately. You should rejoice that affection is shown toward anyone representing Christ and His Lordship to the congregation. This is about Christ, not you or that other elder. We are nothing. Christ is everything. We are stewards. Christ is King. We are brothers. He is our Everlasting Father. We are servants. He is Lord.
As Paul said, "Is Christ divided?" Are we all not working toward the result that the people placed under us might exalt Christ as King over them? Some plant. Others water. But it is God who causes growth. It is God who brings the people into His kingdom and keeps them there. It is God who has all power and glory and majesty. We are to be empty vessels for Him to fill in whatever way He desires.
I truly believe that most overseers need to become janitors of the church first. They need to serve as chair stackers and bulletin makers for awhile. They need to understand that every job in the church is a job for a servant, not a king. If you have a lust for power, please don't apply for the job of overseer. God will surely humble you in the most violent of ways if you attempt to do this with the wrong attitude. I have seen it over and over again. The desire for control destroys churches, because it destroys the Lordship of Christ in those churches and replaces it by a self-willed individual who just wants to set up his own little kingdom, using Christ as his means to achieve it.
And what else would be a greater instrument to use? God is the ultimate authority, and so one seeking power over others, over his own kingdom, would seek to use God to boost his power. This makes the church a dangerous place, but one cannot be sanctified without it. What we need to do is not shun the church, as one will only prove that he is not under Christ's Lordship at all, but only seeks to be self-willed in his own life as well. Instead, the answer is to reform the church, and we do that by reforming our understanding of the church from top down. We need to reform the way we think of the eldership. We need to reform the way it functions in the church, and why we desire to be a part of it.
So here are some helpful ways you can reform it:
1. Trade off. Take turns, or just allow for equal say, in where you go as a church. Take turns preaching and teaching, and let each elder choose what he preaches or teaches according to where God is leading him (again, everything being run through the entire group of overseers, as you are a collective). Let others lead, as they should let you lead.
2. Let go. You don't need that much of an inlet into people's lives. You don't see the apostles constantly checking up on people to see if their living according to Christ. Our job is to preach/teach, pray, and discipline (which is an exercise of authority that is a part of teaching/discipleship). God's presence will be manifest among us and among the laity if we are faithful to do that job (and that job alone is overwhelming enough). We don't need to constantly impose ourselves on the laity to ease our anxiety. Let God worry about transforming His children with the Word we are commanded to preach and through our prayers for them, which is our primary means of giving Christ a voice into their lives.
3. Preach the whole counsel of God. This is God's Church, not yours. If people are offended by God and want to leave, even leaving you without a job, it should not be that you withhold the life that is in the whole counsel of God simply because people want to be dead instead. Give the life that is found in all of what Christ commanded, and do not withhold it from the congregation because you are afraid of the repercussions. Have some faith that God will do what is right, even if you end up without a job in the end.
4. Rejoice when the gospel goes forth, regardless whether it has anything to do with you or to your credit. Rejoice when other Christian leaders are spoken of well, if in fact they are busy preaching that Word to others. Rejoice when affection is shown for those who represent Christ, even if you are getting grief by those very people. Be glad that Christ still has an inlet into their lives and they may yet be conformed to His image through it. Hence, He may yet be exalted, and since this is all you seek, not the glory of yourself, this should make you happy.
I know, as I write this, most of my friends in ministry will not like it. There is within all of us the need for vindication for all of the hard work we've done. There is a need to be recognized. There is a desire to have control, as we see ourselves as the protectors of the flock, and we are to a lesser degree. But the great protector is Christ, and He has given us, His stewards, the means through which we give Him a voice to protect His flock, and it is not in the grabbing of power, but in the humility of a shared goal to exalt Him through Word and prayer, even to the sacrifice of our own prestige, our own comfort, and our own security. We are to cast all of our crowns at His feet, and that includes the crown we get when we become an overseer. This kingdom is not ours to keep. It is His to rule through His servants, and that is all we should desire when we desire the office of overseer.
Denethor would have led his people to ruin in seeking to obtain the throne for himself. But it was the return of the true king that brought about victory and salvation to the people, a lesson all overseers, both candidates and well-established, would do well to ponder.
This scene has some resonance for me, as I have loved the church and have desired Christ to rule over it, but there seem to be far too many who wish to rule over it instead. In fact, I could have simply entitled this post, "A Tale of Two Overseers," since my concern is to lay out what the "desire" of the overseer should be versus what it should never be. Because I have so many friends who have gone into ministry, and have been good friends with virtually all of my pastors, I think I have a bit of an insight into something that I have noticed in many of them, but not in others (others who, unfortunately, are few among their number). And this tendency that I have noticed in them is simply this: a desire for power.
On the one hand, people are going to want to use their gifts, and will seek out the greatest amount of opportunity to do so. That's a good thing. If one is a teacher or pastor, then one will often want to seek out the office of overseer, as it will afford him more opportunity to use those gifts. But one must be very careful that he does not seek it out because he likes to be in front of people, or have control. Controlling people are dangerous people to the ministry. They have a hard time letting Christ lead.
You see, if you have an overseer that starts talking about the church as "his," and that not in a more common way as even layman do (i.e., "I'm going to my church today" --- the possessive pronoun used to convey belonging rather than personally possessing), then you may be encountering one who desires to ascend rather than to serve in humility. This is why hierarchies in the church eldership are so dangerous. They exist when we view elders as senior pastors and associate pastors, or even more subtly, as elders within which a non-labeled hierarchy still exists. There is no hierarchy in the community of elders in the Bible, and when the Corinthians try to pull this even among the apostles, they are rebuked for it (1 Cor 1:12-15). There is only one King. Everyone else is just a steward. There is a hierarchy among God's kingdom for purposes of holding up the truth against heresy and impurity that leads Christ's kingdom to ruin (1 Tim 3:15 in view of the entire letter); but this hierarchy is one of multiple elders who function as authoritative servants who must seek Christ to rule over them and the people, not the desire to rule itself.
The tricky thing is that people often don't realize that they are seeking power, and of course, no one presents it that way to himself. Our desire for power is often hidden in the desire that we do things "the right way," which ends up being what one particular individual wants over the other individuals.
So in light of our own self delusions, let me ask you a series of questions to help you see if you might be seeking more control than stewardship before God.
1. Are you fine with other elders taking the head as preaching and exercising authority instead of you overseeing their overseeing? Obviously, elders should function together, so nothing is simply a one man show, or should be, at any time; but my point here is to ask whether you need to be the one who always gets the veto power or needs to spearhead something. In other words, does it make you uncomfortable, like someone is stealing your power, when another overseer (in continuity with the larger group of course) takes the reigns of something that may not be in your personal control? Does this create an anxiety for you or a relief that you are not the only one working to exalt Christ as King over the congregation?
2. Do you feel like you want more of an inlet into people's lives in your congregation? Now, this one can be tricky (aren't they all?), as it may be that sometimes an overseer is too disconnected from people in the congregation. However, many times this is the subtle desire to get more control/power, so that the more one is in the lives of others, the more one can steer those lives in the direction he wants. Less anxiety then exists if one can see what's going on behind the scenes. This, of course, does not give control and trust to the Holy Spirit who testifies to individuals of Christ who works all things to the glory of the Father, and the Father, in return, exalts Him as King over those people's lives. In other words, it is a sin against the entire Godhead to need such control.
3. Are you continually worried that people will leave if you say or do the wrong thing, even when what you say or do comes from the Bible itself? For example, if you exercise church discipline, do you have such anxiety over it (everyone will have some anxiety over such a difficult thing) that you fail to do it altogether? Do you hold back preaching and teaching certain aspects of the whole counsel of God in Scripture because people might leave or attribute you less authority to say other things to them? This is pure manipulation of your duty in an effort to gain or keep power. It seeks to obtain power through giving people what they want rather than exalting Christ as King through one's teaching and exercise of authority. Hence, in this one, an illusion that one wants less power is created by diminishing one's role as an overseer, but in reality, it is a diminishing of Christ's authority in order that the overseer might grab more authority for himself. The steward is to exalt Christ as King, not himself, and therefore, ought to obey Christ in his making disciples by means of teaching ALL that Christ commanded (Matt 28:19-20).
4. Do you feel jealous when others compliment another overseer for their teaching ability, or what they learned by him, or their show of love for him? Perhaps, they want him to preach for awhile? Are you threatened by that? Perhaps they invite him over to dinner more? Are you offended by that? You should rejoice that the Word of the King is desired through anyone who would preach it accurately. You should rejoice that affection is shown toward anyone representing Christ and His Lordship to the congregation. This is about Christ, not you or that other elder. We are nothing. Christ is everything. We are stewards. Christ is King. We are brothers. He is our Everlasting Father. We are servants. He is Lord.
As Paul said, "Is Christ divided?" Are we all not working toward the result that the people placed under us might exalt Christ as King over them? Some plant. Others water. But it is God who causes growth. It is God who brings the people into His kingdom and keeps them there. It is God who has all power and glory and majesty. We are to be empty vessels for Him to fill in whatever way He desires.
I truly believe that most overseers need to become janitors of the church first. They need to serve as chair stackers and bulletin makers for awhile. They need to understand that every job in the church is a job for a servant, not a king. If you have a lust for power, please don't apply for the job of overseer. God will surely humble you in the most violent of ways if you attempt to do this with the wrong attitude. I have seen it over and over again. The desire for control destroys churches, because it destroys the Lordship of Christ in those churches and replaces it by a self-willed individual who just wants to set up his own little kingdom, using Christ as his means to achieve it.
And what else would be a greater instrument to use? God is the ultimate authority, and so one seeking power over others, over his own kingdom, would seek to use God to boost his power. This makes the church a dangerous place, but one cannot be sanctified without it. What we need to do is not shun the church, as one will only prove that he is not under Christ's Lordship at all, but only seeks to be self-willed in his own life as well. Instead, the answer is to reform the church, and we do that by reforming our understanding of the church from top down. We need to reform the way we think of the eldership. We need to reform the way it functions in the church, and why we desire to be a part of it.
So here are some helpful ways you can reform it:
1. Trade off. Take turns, or just allow for equal say, in where you go as a church. Take turns preaching and teaching, and let each elder choose what he preaches or teaches according to where God is leading him (again, everything being run through the entire group of overseers, as you are a collective). Let others lead, as they should let you lead.
2. Let go. You don't need that much of an inlet into people's lives. You don't see the apostles constantly checking up on people to see if their living according to Christ. Our job is to preach/teach, pray, and discipline (which is an exercise of authority that is a part of teaching/discipleship). God's presence will be manifest among us and among the laity if we are faithful to do that job (and that job alone is overwhelming enough). We don't need to constantly impose ourselves on the laity to ease our anxiety. Let God worry about transforming His children with the Word we are commanded to preach and through our prayers for them, which is our primary means of giving Christ a voice into their lives.
3. Preach the whole counsel of God. This is God's Church, not yours. If people are offended by God and want to leave, even leaving you without a job, it should not be that you withhold the life that is in the whole counsel of God simply because people want to be dead instead. Give the life that is found in all of what Christ commanded, and do not withhold it from the congregation because you are afraid of the repercussions. Have some faith that God will do what is right, even if you end up without a job in the end.
4. Rejoice when the gospel goes forth, regardless whether it has anything to do with you or to your credit. Rejoice when other Christian leaders are spoken of well, if in fact they are busy preaching that Word to others. Rejoice when affection is shown for those who represent Christ, even if you are getting grief by those very people. Be glad that Christ still has an inlet into their lives and they may yet be conformed to His image through it. Hence, He may yet be exalted, and since this is all you seek, not the glory of yourself, this should make you happy.
I know, as I write this, most of my friends in ministry will not like it. There is within all of us the need for vindication for all of the hard work we've done. There is a need to be recognized. There is a desire to have control, as we see ourselves as the protectors of the flock, and we are to a lesser degree. But the great protector is Christ, and He has given us, His stewards, the means through which we give Him a voice to protect His flock, and it is not in the grabbing of power, but in the humility of a shared goal to exalt Him through Word and prayer, even to the sacrifice of our own prestige, our own comfort, and our own security. We are to cast all of our crowns at His feet, and that includes the crown we get when we become an overseer. This kingdom is not ours to keep. It is His to rule through His servants, and that is all we should desire when we desire the office of overseer.
Denethor would have led his people to ruin in seeking to obtain the throne for himself. But it was the return of the true king that brought about victory and salvation to the people, a lesson all overseers, both candidates and well-established, would do well to ponder.
Sunday, April 8, 2012
Saturday, April 7, 2012
Friday, April 6, 2012
A Tale of Two Rebels: Which Rebel Are You?
In Matthew's and Mark's Gospel we are told the following:
At that time two robbers were crucified with Him, one on the right and one on the left. And those passing by were hurling abuse at Him, wagging their heads, and saying, "You who [are going to] destroy the temple and rebuild it in three days, save Yourself! If You are the Son of God, come down from the cross." In the same way the chief priests also, along with the scribes and elders, were mocking [Him,] and saying, "He saved others; He cannot save Himself. He is the King of Israel; let Him now come down from the cross, and we shall believe in Him. "He trusts in God; let Him deliver [Him] now, if He takes pleasure in Him; for He said, 'I am the Son of God.'" And the robbers also who had been crucified with Him were casting the same insult at Him.
At that time two robbers were crucified with Him, one on the right and one on the left. And those passing by were hurling abuse at Him, wagging their heads, and saying, "You who [are going to] destroy the temple and rebuild it in three days, save Yourself! If You are the Son of God, come down from the cross." In the same way the chief priests also, along with the scribes and elders, were mocking [Him,] and saying, "He saved others; He cannot save Himself. He is the King of Israel; let Him now come down from the cross, and we shall believe in Him. "He trusts in God; let Him deliver [Him] now, if He takes pleasure in Him; for He said, 'I am the Son of God.'" And the robbers also who had been crucified with Him were casting the same insult at Him.
Notice that the lēstai "insurrectionists" were also those casting the same insult at him. Matthew and Mark present everyone as insulting Christ; but Luke tells us of another detail in order to present us with a picture of all who encounter the crucified Christ. We are told in Luke's Gospel that one of these insurrectionists has a change of heart.
And when they came to the place called The Skull, there they crucified Him and the criminals, one on the right and the other on the left. But Jesus was saying, "Father, forgive them; for they do not know what they are doing." And they cast lots, dividing up His garments among themselves. And the people stood by, looking on. And even the rulers were sneering at Him, saying, "He saved others; let Him save Himself if this is the Christ of God, His Chosen One." And the soldiers also mocked Him, coming up to Him, offering Him sour wine, and saying, "If You are the King of the Jews, save Yourself!" Now there was also an inscription above Him, "THIS IS THE KING OF THE JEWS." And one of the criminals who were hanged [there] was hurling abuse at Him, saying, "Are You not the Christ? Save Yourself and us!" But the other answered, and rebuking him said, "Do you not even fear God, since you are under the same sentence of condemnation? "And we indeed justly, for we are receiving what we deserve for our deeds; but this man has done nothing wrong." And he was saying, "Jesus, remember me when You come in Your kingdom!" And He said to him, "Truly I say to you, today you shall be with Me in Paradise."
Now, Luke presents us with a tale of two rebels. The one continues to mock Christ, even in his last hours. He keeps those few moments left to him all for himself, never acknowledging the Lord and believing in Him. Instead, if he has any religious faith, it is in the false messiah that all of the Jews at that time were looking for, the one who externally saves from outward oppressors, but not the one who saves from the Great Oppressor, i.e., the Self, from the inside out. He thus only insults the real Christ as insufficient and a joke, because He did not deliver to Him or the crowd, what they wanted out of Him (i.e., a mighty display of power to convince all men and take over all things). Instead, He was there to fulfill Isaiah 53, to suffer and die in order to secure a freedom that was greater than the imaginations of myopically focused insurrectionists. This first rebel represents all those who reject the true Christ as insufficient to deliver to them what they want out of their messiahs. To him, this Christ isn't the real one because He doesn't deliver life the way the rebel expects of Him.
But then comes the rebuke of the other rebel. He has finally recognized who Christ really is and why He has come. He acknowledges that Jesus has done nothing wrong, but that they are fully deserving of this horrible death. He calls Him, "Lord" (I believe the the Majority Text reading to be correct here, but both texts indicate that he considers Jesus to be the Lord of Heaven), acknowledging that the heaven He is about to enter belongs to Him. He, in repentance, asks the Lord to remember him there, and the Lord, based upon his repentance and faith, grants him his request. This man represents those who have come to know the true Christ, and now desire the type of kingdom He came to establish in us. This man was a rebel against God, but now turns into a rebel for God and against the mockers that surround Christ. He stands up for the Lord and opens himself up to the same shame as Christ, as if dying such a shameful death was not horrible enough. But seeing who the Lord Jesus truly was causes him to no longer care about the insults of others. It causes him to speak out against those who would not acknowledge the Lord in reverence, who would act as though they have nothing to fear when in fact they, in their sin against and mockery of God, have everything to fear. And most importantly, it causes him to seek Christ and to want to be where Christ is going to be.
This is the tale of two rebels. One that chose to stay the course in thinking he had nothing to fear, that he was good as he was, that he only needed physical deliverance from his oppressors, that he could continue to live for himself, even in those final moments, without consequence and mock anyone, even the Lord Himself, who might convict him to do otherwise. But the other rebel was filled with repentance. He saw who Christ was. He saw his own sin and the rightfulness of his own punishment for it. He feared God, and he desired Christ. And so that is what he received rather than judgment.
One man perished, and the other went to paradise that day. And that is the message of Luke's presentation of this episode. He wants us to ask ourselves, Among these two rebels, which one am I? How will I respond to the crucified Lord? Will I consider His crucifixion as nothing, and look more to His displays of power in miracles or His social redemption of those who are outcasts in society (both things that He indeed did do, but those only meant to represent what He came to do inside of us). Will I receive this Jesus rather than seek another more accommodating to my own views of what a hero should be, or will I reject Him because He didn't give to me what I wanted, and therefore, must not be the true Messiah after all?
Both men are rebels. Both men deserve condemnation. Both men have no clout before God. But one was saved that day. One entered paradise to fellowship with the Lord, His Creator, because, you see, we're all on crosses beside Him, and it doesn't matter which roads of rebellion we took to get there. What matters now is what road we're going to take now that we're there beholding Him and His work on that cross, now that the gospel has been presented to us, now that Christ and Him crucified is before us. Because we're all rebels who deserve to be dying as the condemned people that we are, but there is one kind of rebel who remains damned and one who can still be saved. Which one are you?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)