Wednesday, February 8, 2012

Mesopotamian Cosmic Geography

In case you were beginning to fall out of love with Eisenbrauns for putting a $60 price tag on a book we've all been waiting to be re-released for the past few years, let your love be renewed. The 10 day sale ends soon, but you can get it now for a little over $41 plus shipping (of course buy $100 worth and shipping is free).


Actually, There Are Three Out of Ten Good Reasons to Believe in an Historical Adam

Have you ever been in a conversation where one person starts arguing erroneously and then another chimes in to refute him, only to offer up a refutation that is also erroneous? That's what the Historical Adam debate looks like most of the time to me.

Kevin DeYoung posted a "Ten Reasons" list arguing why one should believe in an historical Adam. This is clearly in response to Dr. Enns's denial that a belief in an historical Adam is necessary to the gospel, although I'm sure it also seeks to counter many who believe as he does. James McGrath posted his counter argument called, "Ten Really Bad Reasons to Believe in a Historical Adam." James' arguments consist of a bit of what I might say myself, but I think that his theological position concerning inerrancy and a denial of the Bible as communicating historical reality along with its theological message makes it an argument between one person who believes the Bible literally and one person who believes some of the Bible figuratively and throws out the rest. So let me give you my critique of DeYoung's "Ten Reasons" and then I'll give you my critique of McGrath's.

DeYoung's reasons are as follows (I'll simply offer my response under each one):

1. The Bible does not put an artificial wedge between history and theology. Of course, Genesis is not a history textbook or a science textbook, but that is far from saying we ought to separate the theological wheat from the historical chaff. Such a division owes to the Enlightenment more than the Bible.

This is true, but not in the way that DeYoung seems to be using it. History in the ancient sense (a retelling of history in order to shape the theological and ethical minds of the community) is not the same as history in the modern sense (a report of supposedly uninterpreted facts in the recreation of the event). This is especially true when we speak of the Urgeschichte, or Primeval History (more on that below).

2. The biblical story of creation is meant to supplant other ancient creation stories more than imitate them. Moses wants to show God’s people “this is how things really happened.” The Pentateuch is full of warnings against compromise with the pagan culture. It would be surprising, then, for Genesis to start with one more mythical account of creation like the rest of the ANE.

This is probably the worst of the reasons given, because it assumes precisely what many, even myself who affirms the historical Adam, would consider the point being discussed. In other words, it just begs the question. The question is, What is the text attempting to communicate? And to try and answer this question by asserting a special knowledge of what "Moses wants to show" is a bit absurd. How does DeYoung know what Moses wants to show? Does he have special communication with Moses? The only way to know what the text intends to show is by making a larger literary argument of the text, but it is clear that when one does this, the purpose is to say something about chaos, order and the Sovereignty of God in relation to humanity (see my Revisiting the Days of Genesis).
Second to this, the problem the Torah has with paganism are practices in relation to worshiping other gods, or worshiping God through alternate means, like an idol or omen, etc. The issue is not the use of mythic imagery to present accurate theology about God and man. 
Furthermore, the purpose is not to supplant other creation accounts in terms of their cosmology, but in terms of their theology and ethics. That's an important distinction, since the polemic, then, would use the same material, as polemic often does, but communicate a corrective point through it. Cosmology and history is simply the backdrop to the theology being presented.


3. The opening chapters of Genesis are stylized, but they show no signs of being poetry. Compare Genesis 1 with Psalm 104, for example, and you’ll see how different these texts are. It’s simply not accurate to call Genesis poetry. And even if it were, who says poetry has to be less historically accurate?

Here is where I want to make the point that (1) Yes, DeYoung is right. Although you have arguments made from different scholars that poetry is quite a nebulous term and any text can really be poetic (noted), the text itself isn't the sort of poetry you would get in a Psalm. However, (2) this seems to be based on a false dichotomy. The options are not either poetry or literal historical narrative. The options include a variety of diverse genres that often intermingle. However, when we come to Primeval History, we need to understand that such is a genre unto itself. Primeval History isn't a time that is known to the ancients. They hence filled in that time with a lot of myth, legend, and symbolism with things that likely were true and had been passed down in some way. The cut off, in Mesopotamian history, which is clearly where Genesis 1-11 is situated, is the flood. The closer contemporary history gets to the flood the less known the details of the events become. The events on the other side, of course, are barely known, if at all, to the ancients. Hence, that side is filled with different myths about the gods, how people came to exist, and exaggerated numbers of the reign of monarchs, which seem to be given so that the reader would understand that the actual lengths of their reigns were unknown, but that life was being extended to the kings who had favor with the gods. This does not negate the idea that real history is also presented in Primeval History. It just says that what history is presented is going to be presented in a very symbolic form.


4. There is a seamless strand of history from Adam in Genesis 2 to Abraham in Genesis 12. You can’t set Genesis 1-11 aside as prehistory, not in the sense of being less than historically true as we normally understand those terms. Moses deliberately connects Abram with all the history that comes before him, all the way back to Adam and Eve in the garden.

See the statements above. Genesis, in its ancient Near Eastern context, sets the two apart, and like other texts, would treat the prehistory as history. That's what it's meant to be. It's just not history that is presented in the sense that we usually think of it.

5. The genealogies in 1 Chronicles 1 and Luke 3 treat Adam as historical.

Of course, it is not a surprise that the authors in the Bible treat Adam as historical: (1) Because in the Urgeschichte, he is the beginning of the story. They have no problem with putting him in an historical line up because the Bible has no problem with using prehistory this way; (2) because I think he is historical, I have no problem with this, but neither would someone denying the existence of Adam, since they can affirm the Bible's right use of Adam this way per what I said above.

6. Paul believed in a historical Adam (Rom. 5:12-21; 1 Cor. 15:21-22, 45-49). Even some revisionists are honest enough to admit this; they simply maintain that Paul (and Luke) were wrong.

Of course, I think that Paul and Luke were correct; but inspiration and inerrancy does not give omniscience to the human authors through which it is accomplished. Hence, it does not work to correct every historical or scientific misconception that they might have. That's not the function of inspiration, the historical orthodox claim of inerrancy, nor purpose of the revelation given, which is to bring one to a knowledge of salvation and conform him or her to the image of God's Son. Hence, I have no problem with Paul or Luke being wrong. Paul may have believed in the moveable well that likely didn't exist. So what? That has nothing to do with the point being made by Paul or the Holy Spirit through him in the text of Scripture. I'm not arguing, of course, that this point can't be valid in any way. I think it is valid if combined with 7-9 below.


7. The weight of the history of interpretation points to the historicity of Adam. The literature of second temple Judaism affirmed an historical Adam. The history of the church’s interpretation also assumes it.

Now, here's where I will begin to say that DeYoung is making a better argument than many will attribute to him. The Second Temple comment aside, as many people believe all sorts of odd ideas about the Bible in the Second Temple Period, since there is a move to reconstruct the event more than to interpret the text as we have it. However, the second point about church history is important to me in terms of what it taught theologically when its theology necessarily includes the history of what occurred as reality. I believe the Holy Spirit leads His Church into all truth, and as such, if the historicity of Adam is necessary to understand the gospel as the Church has interpreted it, then I put a lot of stock in that. However, if this comment is simply saying that history has been interpreted this way by the Church, I don't put stock in that, since history is not the domain given to the Church to interpret. Theology and ethics (the mind and character of God in all things) is its domain, and that is to what the Holy Spirit brings clarity. However, when combined with point 9, the point is well made with a "high church" guy like me.


8. Without a common descent we lose any firm basis for believing that all people regardless of race or ethnicity have the same nature, the same inherent dignity, the same image of God, the same sin problem, and that despite our divisions we are all part of the same family coming from the same parents.

This, of course, is a problem for naturalistic evolution, and despite the claim to the contrary, it is quite evident that naturalistic/atheistic forms of evolution quite rightly lead to racism. The early interpreters of evolution were consistent in applying it this way, and modern atheists are completely inconsistent. However, if God is involved, and the worth of humanity is given by Him to each individual that He makes through this process, then this statement really doesn't make it. Likewise, everyone can have the same sin problem by virtue of our common rebellion against God. The issue really becomes the reason for that common rebellion, which in my mind, can only be attributed to our human ontology. As such, I'm not sure how a denial of the historical Adam does not lead to a gnostic worldview.


9. Without a historical Adam, Paul’s doctrine of original sin and guilt does not hold together.

Ergo, as per what I said above, this is really DeYoung's most important argument, and something many others have said before. The doctrine of original sin is necessary to Paul's gospel, which we believe is in fact inspired and inerrant. Hence, the history that is necessary to it must also be inspired and inerrant. This means that an historical Adam must have existed, and the symbolic portrayal of Genesis' Urgeschichte, like Mesopotamian Urgeschichten (cf., for instance, Gilgamesh), although highly symbolic with uses of mythological imagery throughout, paints a picture of an historical person. This is not only true for Paul's gospel but the gospel presented throughout the New Testament that denies that gnosticism is a legitimate interpretation of the gospel message. Hence, warring against the physical nature is worthless to the New Testament authors. It is warring against the spirit of rebellion that was produced by our curse in Adam, the curse that exiled us from God's salvific presence. It is not, therefore, that human nature is merely finite or inherently evil by virtue of its existence, but that it is good, but has been corrupted in rebellion, and now needs to be redeemed in order to regain what was lost in Adam.

10. Without a historical Adam, Paul’s doctrine of the second Adam does not hold together.

This is only partly true. If DeYoung means by this essentially what I say above, then agreed. But if he means that if the analogy of Christ with Adam is to hold, both must be literal persons, that's not actually true. I give an example in my book of comparing Hitler's lust for power with Isildor's in the Lord of the Rings. The analogy is true even if one is real and the other fiction.

So I do think this is a gospel issue, as DeYoung concludes with a quote saying as much from Tim Keller. I just don't think that most of his reasons laid out here are the best. Instead, I would concentrate on 7-9 and possibly 10 if clarified, and I would not pursue them individually, but all of them in conversation with the others.
Now, let me get to McGrath's critique.

It is all well and good to blame things on the Enlightenment. But the truth is that if we are to ask historical or scientific questions, we need to have methods and tools for answering them. Science raised issues for geocentrism, and more recently with a historical Adam, and in neither case can one simply argue that one must keep the Bible and science or the Bible and history in apparent harmony, regardless of the evidence. If one sacrifices the Bible’s teaching about truth and honesty in order to defend the factuality of some of its stories, has one really defended the Bible in any meaningful sense?

This, of course, also begs the question concerning presuppositions and ultimate beliefs that are inseparably linked to, and govern, one's methodology of inquiry. Saying we need to have tools and methods for answering historical questions says nothing toward the point being made. The point is that one must assume a priori a metaphysical position concerning the object, theory, event he is studying, as well to the limitations of his methodologies of inquiry. But I have already critiqued McGrath's lack of awareness in this area on this blog, and don't care to rehash it. My only point here is that this is not an appropriate refutation of what was said, since what was said is true. The wedge between history and theology is a false dichotomy of a refurbished (and reversed) gnosticism that distinguishes between the physical world that can be known and the spiritual world that cannot be known. The Christian message, with which McGrath disagrees, is rooted in history. Where I agree with some of what McGrath is saying here is that the purposes of Scripture are not necessarily historical in all, or even in most, cases. That does not mean that history is not involved simply because that is not the text's primary purpose. It just means that what is secondary will often take a backseat to the primary.


I fully agree with McGrath here. DeYoung should not argue this way.

To call Genesis 1 poetry is certainly an oversimplification, but it does have structure and parallelism which provide internal indicators that its order is about something other than chronology. But even if it is not poetry, who says that prose has to be more historically or scientifically accurate?

I really don't think this hits the mark, even though I agree with its general spirit. My points above are that the only options aren't poetry versus prose, as though prose has no other subcategories that function as their own types of genre (e.g. biographical prose, fictional prose, parabolic prose, etc.).

Ancient literature connects historical figures with prehistorical ones all the time. It is once again modern, post-Enlightenment fundamentalists who say that one cannot do this, seeking to impose their concerns on ancient literature. In the New Testament, two genealogies which do not agree with one another and which selectively omit generations connect Jesus with David, Abraham, and Adam. They provide further confirmation that ancient genealogies do not make the sorts of points or always provide the sorts of historical information that modern readers desire from them.

Agreed, but really, what is McGrath's fascination with calling everyone who is more to the right of him on theological issues "fundamentalists"? He's called me this before, and I just laugh at this. First, is it not also Enlightenment liberals who say that one cannot connect figures in prehistory with historical figures and still be considered accurate history? In fact, isn't the denial of an historical Adam from the text of Scripture based upon the idea that if prehistory isn't literal then the figures themselves did not really exist, and isn't that itself a bogus assessment? This isn't a fundamentalist problem. It's an Enlightenment problem in general. It doesn't matter what camp you're in. Second, this really just seems to be some infatuation of his to act out a vendetta he has against his past, but it not only is unhelpful but it actually makes him seem dishonest, as this issue is common to all in our society.

So what? Genesis 1 treats a dome over the Earth as real. Matthew treats a mountain from which one can see all the kingdoms of the Earth as real. The Bible contains material that does not meet our standards of scientific or historical accuracy, and some of it clearly does not even come close to doing so. By simply pointing to some ancient authors and showing that they shared certain assumptions does not get one any closer to determining whether those assumptions are correct or erroneous.

Agreed.

So here we have the crux of the matter: an unwillingness to accept the Bible’s teaching on human fallibility, or Paul’s own protestation that at times he wrote as a fool.  The fundamental issue is the idolatrous insistence that the Bible’s authors actually shared God’s own attributes such as inerrancy.

1. What does human fallibility and Paul writing as a fool in contexts where neither is applied have to do with it (the biblical authors don't see Scripture as fallible because it was written by humans, nor does Paul say he is writing as an insane man here--that's usually when he is boasting or showing the absurdity of something and he makes that clear)? 2. What a ridiculous assertion concerning inerrancy. No wonder McGrath rejected it. He doesn't even know what it means. The theological and ethical teachings in Scripture, because they are inspired by God, are informed by His omniscience because He is omniscient and the one doing the informing. The authors don't have omniscience. The text doesn't have omniscience. The author is being moved to write something informed by God's omniscience, and therefore, it is without error in what it seeks to communicate from God. Is McGrath saying that God does not have the capability of communicating accurately because nothing can share His essence? So McGrath gives up God's omnipotence for His omniscience? That makes no sense whatsoever. Inerrancy isn't dependent upon the text sharing God's omniscience. It is a sufficient presentation of knowledge informed by God's omniscience, and as such, is completely reliable. The question here is whether what God is communicating is (a) only theology without history, (b) only history without theology, or (c) theology with its necessary historical basis. I choose "c," and so does all of orthodox Christianity on this issue.

Once again, what ancient people assumed or believed is not the issue. The issue is whether we can agree with them, based on the information available to us, much of which was not available to them. We do not determine truth by looking for the consensus of ancient peoples. What do you think the Christian stance on slavery would be if one took this approach?

Again, here's a statement that starts off well and then ends in an odd manner. McGrath is confusing history and ethics here. The inerrantist wants to know what the Bible teaches about slavery because it is a moral guide to him. McGrath doesn't. He's only concerned with what our present culture says. Luckily, I think what our present culture says is what the Bible would affirm here, but my point is that we need to refrain from mixing the issues. No one in my camp is going to listen to a denial of an historical issue when the objection is ethical. I just think that's the wrong way to go there.

No, at least in the form in which this is articulated. Common descent is a well-established scientific conclusion, and so we can make the same point by way of the human genome project. (Ironically, some fundamentalists adamantly deny the scientific basis for this conclusion and deny the scientific conclusion of common ancestry, since it shows that we are related more than to just each other as human beings). On the other hand, people who allegedly adhered to the teaching of Genesis have engaged in slavery, discrimination, and other sorts of racial hatred. And so Genesis is neither necessary for belief in human equality and dignity nor a guarantee that people will adhere to such lofty principles.

Did McGrath actually listen to what DeYoung said here, or is he replaying the same argument he's had with other Christians over in his head. First, is James a scientist who worked on the human genome project? If not, why he is affirming the conclusions of theoretical science by pure faith and then demeaning anyone who doesn't come to that position as factual? Isn't that a bit ironic? Second, DeYoung didn't argue that belief in a literal Adam causes everyone to hold hands and sing, "Kumbaya." He argued that there is no basis for believing that all people are equally God's image, of the same worth, are not of different evolutionary developments and mental capabilities, and have the same sin problem. I disagree, as I said above, with DeYoung's assessment here if it is directed at Christians as opposed to atheists, but McGrath's argument has nothing to do with what he said.

The very terminology of “original sin” itself reflects a theological construction which uses but goes beyond Paul. But if what is meant is the pervasiveness and universality of human nature with all its flaws, then that is something that one can establish through simple observation – and account for in terms of evolution, biology, and psychology. There is no need for a particular mythical explanation in order to view humanity in this way.
Well, technically, yes, the terminology goes beyond Paul, but the theological construct does not. I don't see Paul's federal argument reflected in McGrath's comments here. And, yes, you can just look around, but the argument in Scripture is that the solution counters the source of the problem, and therefore, the problem. It doesn't just counter the symptoms of the disease which are everywhere apparent. So the issue is where does all of this come from? Is it human ontology, which is what McGrath seems to be arguing for here, which ironically makes DeYoung's point (and mine) for him, or is human ontology fine in and of itself, but the issue is one of human condition in terms of relationship (or lack thereof) with God due to an event that occurred where humanity broke, and/or was broken, from that relationship? Accounting for human sin in terms of evolution, biology and psychology means that there is no sin, just human nature. Nothing willful. Just necessary to the human condition. That, again, is gnosticism, not Christianity.

Sure it does, or at least, it does every bit as much as any other doctrine or bit of symbolism that has to be rethought in light of new information or changing context. Paul’s point is not about us being descended from Jesus rather than Adam. Being “in Adam” vs. being “in Christ” is about two different ways of being human and relating to God. To treat it otherwise is to create a hodge-podge of Pauline theology and later scientific information. Paul’s Adam-Christ contrast is based on Jesus, and could easily have been otherwise, had his belief about what God had done to bring salvation differed. If God had sent two saviors, it would have been easy for him to turn to Genesis and say “Just as through two human beings sin entered the world…” If God had sent successive generations of redeemers, Paul could have easily said, “Just as through multiple generations of human existence sin entered the world…” The contrast makes a theological point in a particular way because of Paul’s view of Jesus. The Adam side could easily have differed. And the symbolism of humanity being a certain, expressed through story, way does not automatically become less meaningful simply because we understand the actual course of history of life on this planet differently.

Again, I agree with this assessment for the most part. However, it doesn't deal with the objection of point 9 together with point 10. The federal argument isn't simply one where Paul is drawing an analogy, but one where Paul is supporting the necessity of the gospel, in light of the human condition, with it. However, although I agree here in part, the point seems to be that, given the truth of point 9, Paul would not have made just any argument here. But that may be for another day.

I hope this post has brought some clarity to the issue (probably not). But at least it can get you thinking about good and bad reasons for believing in an historical Adam.
 

Friday, February 3, 2012

The Intolerance of Tolerance

Dr. Carson has a new book, set to be released in March, called The Intolerance of Tolerance. In it he argues that the idea of tolerance has shifted from merely allowing all ideas to be presented in order for discussion to take place and get to the best one to the idea that all ideas should be allowed because no one can really know what is true. Notice that the former seeks truth and the latter seeks only to assert the one truth: that no one can really know what is true when it comes to metaphysical claims (yes, a beauty of a self defeating contradiction that stems from the exclusive claims of radical empirical verificationism).

But in the book Dr. Carson quotes a parable by Gotthold Lessing in his work Nathan the Wise that I think is relevant to what the more liberal side of evangelicalism has and will continue to adopt in the future concerning theological truth claims:


Lessing sets the parable in the twelfth century during the Third Crusade.
The setting is critical to understanding what Lessing was trying
to establish by his parable. This setting is a conversation among three
characters, each of whom represents one of the world’s three monotheistic
religions: Saladin, the Muslim sultan; Nathan the Wise, a Jew;
and a Christian Knight Templar. Saladin says to Nathan, “You are so
wise; now tell me, I entreat, what human faith, what theological law.
hath struck you as the truest and the best?”9 Instead of answering directly,
Nathan tells his parable. A man owned an opal ring of superlative
beauty and extraordinary, not to say magical, powers. Whoever
wore it was beloved by God and by human beings. He had received it
from his father, who had received it from his, and so on—it had been
passed down from generation to generation, from time immemorial.
The man with the ring had three sons, each of whom he loved equally,
and to each of whom he promised, at one time or another, that he
would give the ring. Approaching death, the man realized, of course,
that he could not make good on his promises, so he secretly asked a
master jeweler to make two perfect copies of the ring. The jeweler did
such a magnificent job that the rings were physically indistinguishable,
even though only one had the magical powers. Now on his deathbed,
the man called each of his sons individually to his side and gave
him a ring. The man died, and only then did his sons discover that
each of the sons had a ring. They began to argue about which one now
possessed the original magic ring. In the play, Nathan the Wise describes
their bickering and comments:
[The brothers] investigate, recriminate, and wrangle all in vain
Which was the true original genuine ring
Was undemonstrable
Almost as much as now by us is undemonstrable
The one true faith.10
Wanting to resolve their dispute, the brothers ask a wise judge to settle
the issue, but his ruling refuses to discriminate:
If each of you in truth received his ring
Straight from his father’s hand, let each believe
His own to be the true and genuine ring.11
The judge urges the brothers to abandon their quest to determine
which ring is the magic original. Each brother should instead accept
his ring as if it were the original and in that conviction live a life of
moral goodness. This would bring honor both to their father and to
God.
Lessing’s parable resonated with his eighteenth-century Enlightenment
readers. The three great monotheistic religions were so
similar that each group should happily go on thinking that their religion
was the true one, and focus on lives of virtue and goodness, free
of nasty dogmatism, the dogmatism that was blamed for the bloody
wars of the previous century. What was called for, in other words, was
religious tolerance. There is no harm in believing that your monotheistic
religion is best, provided you live a good life and let others think
that their religion is best.
Small wonder the parable retains its appeal to readers in the
twenty-first century. People today are no less skeptical about claims to
exclusive religious truth than were Lessing’s readers. They will be inclined
to think well of a religion if it produces morally respectable and
religiously tolerant adherents. Today, of course, the parable would
have to be revised: instead of three rings, we would need dozens of
them, if not hundreds, to symbolize the mutual acceptability of the
many religious options, whether monotheistic, polytheistic, or nontheistic.
And, of course, we could not concede today, as Lessing could,
that one of the rings really is the original. (D. A. Carson, The Intolerance of Tolerance [Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2012], 7-9)

Carson points out that the parable doesn't quite work, and this is clear, since it assumes that God is the source of the different religions, etc. However, I wanted you to notice something else here. Notice that this parable is filled with dogmatism that only one view is true. That's the beauty of deceptive rhetoric when people talk about tolerance, or in evangelical circles, "grace" (as it is often redefined to mean "tolerance" in this sense) and "humility" (as it is redefined to mean "one who does not believe or assert that he knows the truth"). The truth is that Lessing has just asserted that his religion is true and that Christianity is false. Did you catch it?

You see, as I've argued before here, there are really only two religions in the world. There are multiple expressions of one of those religions, but only one expression of the other. One religion says that people have the capacity to be good and acceptable to God by living a good moral life. The other, Christianity, says that people do not have the capacity of being good and acceptable to God and must, therefore, turn away from their own self righteousness and receive Christ's, without which, God will reject them, and cast them out from His presence as evildoers. So what Lessing has done, by slight of hand, is to reject orthodox Christianity's claims as false, and asserted over them his religion that believes one can work his way to heaven by being a good person apart from Christ. Remember, the center of Christianity is Christ, His work upon the cross, and His daily work in interceding for us now that He has resurrected and ascended to the Father. It isn't about trying to obtain salvation by living a good moral life. We are told that such is impossible, and that we are self serving people, not people who live true moral lives anyway (although we like to stack the deck in our favor to appear that way to ourselves and others). 

So Lessing's parable is bogus because it does not tolerate any religion but his own. Sure, all other religious expressions of that central idea that one can achieve salvation by a good moral life are acceptable to Lessing, as long as their theological truth claims don't get in the way of their morality; but if salvation is through another, i.e., Christ, and not myself, as Christianity teaches, then the only religion not tolerated by the moralist is Christianity. This is why Christianity appears to be so exclusive and intolerant (in the modern sense) of other beliefs, because other beliefs largely are one and the same belief taking upon different forms. Christianity, however, is the opposite of them. It does not assume man is capable of true good apart from Christ, and it does not teach that one can please God or be reconciled to Him by one's "good" life lived. 

This is why pietism within evangelicalism, the kind we see in liberalism and the emerging church, is heresy. It is a completely different religion, even while claiming to be Christian, as Lessing's moralistic version of Christianity is presented in his parable. But these are two different religions, and to claim that one is being tolerant to others by excluding the very view that opposes them at the get go, without even acknowledging its existence for that matter, is not only intolerant of it, but downright hateful and deceptive toward it.

Now, this stems from the idea that no one can know what theological truth claims are true; but that statement itself is an a priori rejection of the Bible that claims to be revelation from God, who I would assume does know what is theologically true. We can make metaphysical truth claims, not because we have first hand knowledge of them, but because we trust the Scripture as an accurate source of God's revelation to us (i.e., we have true humility that is directed toward God and His revelation, not toward other people's truth claims and their knowledge). That's the humility of faith in Other to which the Bible calls us. Again, those who deny this, whether inside or outside evangelical circles, are simply assuming that the Bible is not true, and again, asserting a dogmatic theological truth claim that could only be known through first hand metaphysical knowledge or by trusting in some other source of divine revelation. In other words, the seemingly tolerant idea that no one can really know what is true, theologically or metaphysically speaking, is completely intolerant of any idea that opposes that view, having assumed itself the superior theological and metaphysical truth claim that the Bible and Christianity are not true at the get go. Hence, such claims are not merely saying that no one can know, since the individual who makes this claim is asserting that he does know, but are in fact seeking to lift up one religious belief above all others by trumping them with the "tolerance/humility/graciousness card." 

This is important to understand, as I and many others have always said, there is no such thing as a non-dogmatic belief. Truth is exclusive by its very nature. As soon as a truth claim is made, it automatically excludes everything that opposes it as being true. That's just the nature of truth claims. The question is not, therefore, whether we are tolerant in the modern senses of the word (as though that has anything to do with being Christ-like, or gracious, or humble, etc.), but whether what we believe is true. Hence, we should know what we believe and why we believe it, and realize that as soon as we do, we are by nature (as all other religions and belief systems are to us) being intolerant by modern standards. That's what persecuted the prophets. That's what killed the apostles. That's what burned our teachers in Church History alive. And that's what crucified our Lord. But that's also what glorifies God, lifting Him up in the sea of alternate claims to be the true Lord of all truth claims. That's what causes Him to shine brightly in a dark place. That's what saves our souls. And that's what leads us home. 

So will you admit your intolerance today, and begin to take all truth claims more seriously in your rhetoric (as seriously as you already take them but don't realize it)? Let us exalt what is true, rather than undermine what is true with a sheep-woven guise of humility and tolerance when what we're all really doing is vying to either make ourselves or Christ as King of the Theological Mountain; but have no illusions, if Christ is not lifted up to the top, each person will lift himself there, as everyman wants his religion to dominate the others. It's just that everyman doesn't want to you to realize that he does.

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Labels and the Downfall of the Evangelical Church

One of the problems we are running into today in evangelicalism (including also the younger evangelicals/emergings) is their overdependence upon labels to identify Christian leaders. Let me give you an example.

Mormonism – teaches that there are many gods and that we may become lesser gods.

Kenneth Copeland – teaches that there are many gods and that we are little gods

Now, many evangelicals will identify the former as heretical, but they do not do so based upon the teaching, but rather based upon the fact that Mormonism is identified as a cult. Hence, Mormonism is bad, along with its teaching, because we have identified Mormonism through a label.
Kenneth Copeland, however, is deemed by many evangelicals as a Christian. Hence, even if what he has said concerning the plurality of gods and people being little gods is bad, we should still give him the slack of being imperfect and growing in Christ, since, after all, he is a Christian.

Do you see what has happened there? We have identified one's relationship to true Christianity through labeling one as a “Christian” first and then concluded that this person should not be disciplined and pronounced a heretic upon his lack of repentance, and we have identified the other as “non-Christian” first and then concluded that we should separate from that group. In both cases, labeling has taken place first in order to evaluate one’s teaching.

Now, I realize most today would label Kenneth Copeland as heretical, largely thanks to Hank Hanegraaf’s efforts to destroy the teachings of the Word-Faith Movement in the nineties, but there were many evangelicals who were, and still are, very upset with Hank, calling him a heretic hunter and whatnot, for calling out Copeland. In fact, it is always the Christian teacher who does not bow to labels who will be attacked as the destructive element within the church, since he is viewed as attacking another Christian in good standing. Yet, these same people would support Hank in his calling out of Mormonism. Why? Because their evaluation of a Christian or Christian ministry is based upon a label rather than on the beliefs held.

But how do certain people get these grand labels of immunity when other groups, like Mormons, get no love? I think it has to do with one thing and one thing only: Person or Group X has said things that resonate with Evangelical/Emerging Y, and hence, their ears have been tickled enough by what is said (whether it is right or wrong doctrine) that they include Group or Person X into the fold. At that point, anyone who would question their Christian stance is questioning another Christian in good standing, and hence, is just being judgmental, arrogant, lifting himself up against another Christian, unloving, ungraceful, etc. Where, if at the same time, he does the same thing against Person or Group Z, which has not been labeled “Christian,” he is a champion of the faith, contending for the gospel.

What we have done by labeling one person as accepted, and therefore, even his teaching that may be off as acceptable, even if not held to be true, is become partial toward certain people and groups. We are playing favorites. We are using faulty weights for our friends, and judging in favor of them against the stranger and the alien. We are letting things that murder the souls of others go because we have an invested interest to protect the reputation of the group or person we consider “Christian,” largely because we like that group or person, as opposed to the other groups or persons we don’t care for.

We love labels because they allow us to reject and accept people on our own terms rather than based on God’s. Once we label someone as a good Christian teacher, he cannot be otherwise. He may compromise, but hey, he’s a good Christian teacher, so nobody’s perfect. He may teach some things that are destructive theologically and immoral, but hey, he’s so and so, that good Christian teacher. God uses vessels of clay, doesn’t He?

But let me ask you this. Why don’t you walk into a Mormon church and let your children be taught by them? Why not start attending the next Kingdom Hall meeting with your kids? After all, God can use the little truth to change lives, can’t He? Obviously, no evangelical in his or her right mind would place his or her children in such harm’s way, spiritually speaking. Yet, if the individual or church they like teaches things that are harmful, they give that individual or church the benefit of the doubt, since God doesn’t need perfect theology to perfect His people (not sure where that one might be in the Bible, since the Bible is perfect teaching, is it not?).

Now, this has been happening within evangelicalism for a long time. It’s just rearing its ridiculous head once again with the issues surrounding the Elephant Room (both 1 and 2). These guys are labeled “in house,” and therefore, to criticize anything they have done to the point of calling for their discipline, is to be judging the work of good Christian leaders, and really to be against a ministry of God. I could have swore that the ministry of God to which we have been called was to “preach the word; be ready in season [and] out of season; reprove, rebuke, exhort, with great patience and instruction. For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine; but [wanting] to have their ears tickled, they will accumulate for themselves teachers in accordance to their own desires, and will turn away their ears from the truth and will turn aside to myths.”

Isn’t that the good Christian ministry? Paul doesn’t say, “but only if you don’t consider these people Christians and in good standing in the first place.” He’s talking about what you do with Christians. This, of course, is consistent throughout. Paul opposes Peter to his face and then lets everyone know that he did based upon the principle that the higher the visibility of the individual within the church, the more public one’s rebuke should be (1 Tim 5:20). Even the Apostle Peter is not immune to criticism and public rebuke, and if anyone has a “good Christian” label on him, it should be Christ’s number one apostle. Yet, Paul has just told us that even if one of the apostles, even himself, or even an angel from heaven (talk about having a good label) preaches a different gospel, that being is to be eternally cursed. The apostle John tells us that those who do not receive the Holy Spirit’s teaching from the apostles are not Christians, period, regardless of their standing in the Christian community (and many of them had great prestige among them).

Hence, in contrast to labeling first and then drawing a conclusion of what to make of someone’s teaching, compromise toward a teaching, or Christian stance in general, we are to evaluate the teaching, the compromise toward a teaching, and the claim to be a good Christian in standing by the Word of God and the orthodox interpretation thereof. To consider the person immune because we like him (apparently more than we love Christ by obeying His commandment to impartially discipline) is an evil that now, John tells us, is our own, since we have now supported and given aid to destructive teachings and stances. Perhaps, then, the theology and Christian claims that we make ourselves need to be evaluated first, so that we can then take the speck out of another’s eye; but have no illusions, the love of Christ seeks to take the speck out, and there is nothing more Christian than having Christ’s love.

What the Church always needs to understand is that Satan is a boomerang deceiver. He puts out more obvious heresy. It's usually rejected by the church, and then he swings around and introduces it in more acceptable ways, through more acceptable people. Look at how much the early church rejected gnosticism, and yet it swung back around in more acceptable forms in the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox view of nature, which then has implications upon the gospel itself. Look at how it has swung back around again in the form of pop-psychology, which has largely been a more acceptable form of it in evangelicalism. Heresy is like the cold. It comes back, and when it does, it has adapted as a more acceptable mutation to the body. To not be on guard against heresy is like a man who gets angry with his immune system for stirring up trouble in the body as it attempts to fight a virus. Is it absurd? Of course it is. But what is even more absurd is labeling the virus as a vital part of the body that should not be attacked. Yet, that is the absurdity of defining by label rather than by truth.

Wednesday, February 1, 2012

Why Is the Trinity and the Deity of Christ Important?

In light of the fact that evangelicalism has lost its way, theologically speaking, and become utterly pietist (a resurgence of anabaptism and nineteenth/early twentieth century liberalism, including all of the cults it produced in between), I wanted to stop for a moment and discuss a little bit of why the Trinity and the Deity of Christ is important (especially in regard to the events of the Elephant Room 2 and the "buddying" up of Mark Driscoll and James MacDonald to a known unrepentant false prophet).

First, we need to understand that even if we can't figure out the Trinity's and Deity of Christ's importance, our faith in what God has revealed needs to submit to His telling us that it is important. So let's begin with what Scripture says by beginning with John, who is the apostle who is specifically given the task in Scripture to preserve the part of the gospel that relies upon believing in the Son of God as God, the Son.

John 8:23-24:   And He was saying to them, "You are from below, I am from above; you are of this world, I am not of this world.`Therefore I said to you that you will die in your sins; for unless you believe that I AM, you will die in your sins."

It's important to understand here what John has been arguing all along: that Jesus is the Son of God, which means God the Son, and is both a distinct Person from the Father, but one with the Father in terms of being equal as God Himself (1:1-14; 5:18; 10:30-31; 20:28; etc.). The term ego eimi "I am" is a reference to the Hebrew term 'eyeh found in Exodus 3:14. It is the first person plural of the verb hayah, which means "to be," or "to exist." The divine name Yahweh, itself, is likely from this verb and means "the one who exists," conveying the idea that Yahweh is the only real God who exists. When Jesus then uses this of Himself, and the Jews finally get what He's saying, they are, of course, offended to the core, and take up stones to kill Him for blasphemy (8:58-59).

1 John 4:1-6: 4:1  Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God, because many false prophets have gone out into the world. By this you know the Spirit of God: every spirit that confesses that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh is from God; and every spirit that does not confess Jesus is not from God; this is the [spirit] of the antichrist, of which you have heard that it is coming, and now it is already in the world. You are from God, little children, and have overcome them; because greater is He who is in you than he who is in the world. They are from the world; therefore they speak [as] from the world, and the world listens to them. We are from God; he who knows God listens to us; he who is not from God does not listen to us. By this we know the spirit of truth and the spirit of error . . . For whatever is born of God overcomes the world; and this is the victory that has overcome the world--our faith. Who is the one who overcomes the world, but he who believes that Jesus is the Son of God?

I think this passage is self explanatory. It is written against what seem to be both docetic and monarchian gnostics who would hold a view is very close to T. D. Jakes, although differs slightly from it. But what is more important here is showing that to deny the deity of Christ, the incarnation of God the Son, or the distinction between the Father and the Son in the Godhead is to promote the spirit of antichrist, which means to promote another Christ as a false prophet.

It is interesting, then, that the offense of the gospel is linked to the exclusive claims about who God is and who Jesus is, rather than just the message of the cross emptied of Trinitarian theology. It is God dying and rising from the dead on behalf of the unacceptable sinner that is so offensive. It says that you are so bad that God had to come Himself and die to save you. It says that, therefore, you're only way of salvation is through faith in this One and Only God and His One and Only Christ. You cannot be saved through any other religion, and that includes an alternate one you make up with your own God the Father and Jesus Christ.

It should be obvious by now that most people, regardless of their religious backgrounds, like certain things about Jesus. If nothing else, as we like to conform God to our image and make up our own versions of God rather than deal with the living God presented to us in Scripture, we also like to make up our own "Jesuses." The Lord Himself warns us that when He leaves, many who call themselves Christians will turn away from Christian orthodoxy and follow other Christs, which no doubt refers to other versions of Christ (Matt 24:4-5, 24). Paul talks about Satan appearing as an angel of light, and his ministers appearing as godly Christians, but present another gospel and another Jesus that cannot save (2 Cor 11:3-4, 13-15).

We can see, then, that the offense of Jesus is not in the name or in portraying some of His loving actions, but is in the demand that He be honored as the Father is honored, and as God incarnate. This is what the Greek philosophers found so foolish about the cross, i.e., that God would come and die and rise up from the dead for the sins of mankind (Acts 17:18). This is what the Jews found so offensive in Christ's message (John 5:18).

It's not, therefore, that the gospel is offensive because any Jesus is offensive, but because the Jesus who is coeternal with the Father, making Himself equal with God, very God of very God, is offensive. It demands that all human forming of gods immediately cease, and the Christ presented to us by the apostles be the only presentation of God we receive. Hence, who Christ is is a very important question, one that Christ Himself will ask of His disciples so that they do not go astray by forever keeping that question at the forefront of their gospel message.

Now, it is easy to spot someone flatly denying, in no uncertain terms, the Trinity and who Jesus really is; but the heresy that concerned the New Testament writers, and the Holy Spirit of God who spoke through them, was subtle heresy (Jude 4 that undermined who Christ was due to some sense that the grace of God gives us license to believe and practice whatever we wish, i.e., to have our own "Jesuses" instead of the one and only Master and Lord presented to us by the Holy Spirit through divine revelation).

So now that we see that denying the Father and Son as distinct Persons of the Godhead, denying that the Son is Yahweh, the great I AM, will leave us to die in our sins, and ends up denying Jesus as our only Master and Lord, we can understand why Satan would send out so many ministers within the Christian community to subtly tweak who Christ is just enough to lead us onto the wrong path. But now we can also further our faith by thinking about why the Scripture says this about distorting Christ and the doctrine of our Triune God.

1. We need to know who God and Jesus really is in order to distinguish Him from other gods and other Christs that cannot save us. We might speculate that serving Baal is just serving Yahweh with a different name and slight variation from who Yahweh presents Himself to be in the Old Testament, but God's take on that is very different than ours. There is no compromise here. If you serve Baal, you will perish. God does not see it as worshiping Him, even if you were to change Baal's name to Yahweh. Yahweh is distinct from Baal, and the revelation we are given in the Old Testament about God becomes vital for us to be saved. Hence, identifying who the real God is, and who the real Christ is, is of the utmost importance if we are being told that we need to trust in Him in order to be saved. Think of religious claims as false ropes sent down to you, as you dangle from a cliff, promising you salvation if you grab one. It does not matter what you label them. What is important is identifying the nature of the rope and its origins, its source, in order to know its ability to save you. As the New Testament will repeat time and again, there is only One God and One Lord Jesus Christ, not many. Hence, there is one faith characterized by allegiance to the only true God and Jesus Christ whom He has sent, and to craft the only true God or Jesus Christ into a false one is to deny the only true God and Christ, and to teach another gospel and to reject the faith.

2. Based on what was previously said, if eternal life is knowing the true God and Jesus Christ who He has sent, and one does not know the true God and Jesus Christ who He has saent, then one does not have eternal life. Hence, to preach a gospel that does not require one to believe in the only true God and Jesus Christ, but allows for other Gods and Christs to be preached, even if the individual preacher himself believes in the true God and Jesus Christ, is to give aid to a false gospel that will damn others, and therefore, to have a ministry of hate rather than love that seeks to save what is lost, even at the cost of support from the multitude that does not concern itself with what it views as fine distinctions of truth.

3. To deny Jesus is eternal God is to deny His ability to save eternally. He cannot take upon Himself an eternal punishment and He is not able to take upon Himself the sins of all who would believe in Him. He is just one man, a human being who has the Father in Him; but cannot be punished by the Father, as then the Father would be punishing Himself, since, in Oneness theology, the Father is the divine nature of the Son, and the Son is the human nature of Jesus; but the Son is not a divine Person with a divine nature distinct from the Father. But John's whole point is that the spirit of antichrist (i.e., the spirit that replaces the true Christ with a false one--as the Greek preposition anti does not mean against in the NT, as many think it does, but "instead of") is to deny that the Son, who in John's presentation is God the Son, has come Himself in the flesh, and is to deny the Father and the Son as distinct Persons. Hence, the one who teaches or supports this (see 2 John 7-11) is not born of God, but is of the spirit of error, and is a false prophet, leading many "Christians" down a path that distorts, waters down, and/or denies the goal of the gospel to reconcile us to the One and Only true living God and our Lord Jesus Christ.

4. Any truth presented to someone from the Holy Spirit, even if we do not see its importance, shines a light upon the person's heart. He or she will accept the truth in repentance, once it has been shown from Scripture and taught by apostolic authority, if the Spirit of God, the Spirit of truth, is in him or her, since he or she has been born of the Spirit. Offense and rebellion will not be the end of their journey. However, offense and rebellion will be there if the spirit that has been accepted in one's religious journey was the spirit of error and antichrist. Then, that person will claim the name of Christ with all of the labels, but either preach what is false himself or give aid to those who do, even while he himself claims to believe the truth. Hence, to reject the teaching concerning who God is and who Christ is, either in theory or in the rebellious unwillingness to part company with friends over the matter, is to evidence a spirit that is contrary to the claim that is being made as to one's legitimate birth in Christ. Hence, even the person who has an orthodox understanding of who God and Christ are, and yet, calls those who deny (subtly or otherwise) who they are "brothers," refusing to part company with them, preaches another god and another Christ by way of implicature, even while what is explicitly said may seem to be its opposite.

All of these call for disciplinary action with all those involved that must not be in secret, since the false teaching and its mutation into more acceptable language, even while maintaining its substance, was communicated to all as an acceptable belief within the faith, and therefore, even if not communicated as a good, it was communicated as a "good enough" rather than the evil that it is and the destructive corrosive ability it has to bring one to another God, another Jesus, and therefore, damn them in another faith that cannot save. The elder who sins must be rebuked in the presence of all so that all might think twice about doing such evil, and the evil of damning men must be seen as the worst of evils committed in the presence of all. These things I submit to the body of Christ for your mature consideration and in your love for the true God, His Christ, and those who would be saved by Him, and damned by those who would replace Him with another.

I would also call upon the church to remember that in the early Arian heresies, there were three individuals who typify all who enter these disputes: Athanasius (the orthodox bishop), Arius (the heretic), and Eusebius (the compromiser who, while affirming the orthodox doctrine of Christ explicitly gave aid to the Arian bishops and caused more harm to the orthodox bishops with his appeals for balance to Constantine than the Arians would have ever been able to muster). We must affirm Athanasius, and can only truly do so if we disavow, not only Arius, but Eusebius who would imply the acceptability of alternate presentations of Christ, which are really only demons and not Christ at all. Deal with Eusebius, and Arius has no more voice among us. Ignore Eusebius, and Arius wins. Evil thrives because good men do nothing. Here is the evil, Good Men. What are you going to do about it?