I wanted to entitle this post, "Why Everyone Is Dogmatic about Everything, but No One Wants to Admit It," but I thought the above title was more explanatory, so I went with it. There is what seems to be an all pervasive trend in our culture to believe that certainty and absolutism are products of the Enlightenment, and now that we are so much the wiser in understanding that the Enlightenment got that wrong, we have embraced what we now call "postmodernism," or post-Enlightenment thinking. The problem with this view is twofold: (1) It is the Enlightenment that created the belief that nothing metaphysically reported can be certain, and therefore, cannot be held as an absolute; and therefore, to claim that one cannot be certain is to fully embrace Enlightenment thinking, not post-Enlightenment thinking. (2) Everyone who takes any position, at all, enough to form an opinion upon which he or she has decided to live his or her life is holding to an idea that one can be certain and absolute in his or her thinking. In other words, everyone is asserting what is absolutely true, even when he or she claims to be asserting only his or her personal opinion.
Let's talk about the first proposition to begin. The idea that one who believes in certainty and absolutism is Enlightenment or Modernist is a complete joke. It is the Enlightenment's emphasis on facts versus faith, or what can be empirically verified versus what must be believed through speculation and existential experience that created the idea that nothing, unless it can be empirically verified, can be known with certainty, and therefore, absolutely.
Now, by "absolutely" I don't mean to say, "exhaustively." Obviously, we are finite and cannot know everything exhaustively or even everything sufficiently, but the pre-Enlightenment understanding of knowledge is that what was essential in knowing God and what is necessary for salvation and living in accordance with the will of God could be known with absolute certainty based, not on empirical verification, but upon faith in the report (specifically, in the Christian context, faith in the report of Scripture). In other words, one did not need to have his own experience with God in order to know the truth or falsity of a metaphysical, theological, or moral claim. He only needed to understand the report correctly, and through the understanding of that report in its epistemological, linguistic, and Christological context, in order to have certainty that what was being said was absolute truth. Hence, one could know based upon his or her faith in the report. If one did not believe, and the report is true, one would not hold the correct view of reality. If one did believe, even though it cannot be empirically verified, one would have the correct view of reality. The certainty of reality, then, depends upon one's faith and sight, not just upon one's faith.
This last point is important, as pre-Enlightenment thinking was not a matter of "faith without reason," but "faith with reason." The Enlightenment, however, fostered in our culture the idea of "reason with or without faith." Reason, empirical reason (i.e., what can be empirically verified) to be exact, was all one needed to understand reality. Anything else was just speculation or personal experience. Hence, revivals came to emphasize, not just the promises of God's Word if one believed and followed Christ, but a personal spiritual experience that one had (a sort of empirical verification to oneself) that was the evidence of the gospel working in one's life. The church, from that point on, became enamored with the idea that one needed a "conversion experience" in order to prove, at least to himself, that he was saved. The church has been enamored with personal spiritual experiences, whether they accord with the report of Scripture or not, ever since. (And such is one of the reasons why the Bible's tests that evidence salvation or lack thereof are taken so lightly in our modern, evangelical context.)
The problem, of course, is that we all live on principles that cannot be empirically verified. In fact, empiricism, as a philosophy by which we assume all inquiry must be made, cannot be verified empirically either. Yet, it is held to such absolute certainty that our entire culture, individually and collectively, all base our lives on its truthfulness. Certainly, no one runs in the road when the Mack truck is roaring down it because he or she can't be certain of its existence. It can be empirically verified; but my point is that no one lives his life apart from dogmatic metaphysical beliefs that he assumes and that are expressed whenever he counters or affirms other worldview, secondary ideas, and ethical principles rooted deeply, and exclusively, within them.
Hence, we are certain that all sorts of things are really, absolutely, and with all certainty, right and wrong. Our list is just different from God's because we are going according to our feelings, speculations about our experiences. Yet, we have no problem judging the rude man in line as being wrong, the woman who kills her five kids as doing something absolutely wrong, etc. We also have all sorts of ideology that we believe to be absolute: racism is wrong because each person has rights as a human being (hence, assuming all sorts of things about what it means to be human and the origins of rights).
My point here is that anyone who has an opinion that he or she uses to argue against another opinion, even if that opinion is that one should not lift his opinions up over other people's opinions, which he himself would be doing in typical hypocritical fashion, displays a dogmatism that evidences a certainty sufficient enough, at least, to function as absolutism. Hence, even in the very argument that one should not believe in certainty and absolutism is a dogmatically held belief in certainty and absolutism. That's because a truth proposition that is made automatically lifts itself up as exclusive to all that which would counter it. A proposition by nature is exclusive and argues on its own against other options as merely opinion or untrue, whereas it exalts itself to the position of judge of all that which would oppose it. This is why one cannot argue against dogmatism, absolutism, and certainty without actually committing the very foible he perceives to exist in doing so.
In fact, it is not merely that one cannot make a propositional statement without being dogmatic and evidencing a certain and absolute belief in metaphysical ideas of reality, but he cannot even think without doing so. This is because our minds are continually selecting and rejecting propositions presented to us, through internal and external thoughts that come to us. What this all means is that one cannot be a thinking human being without being a dogmatic one that believes in certainty and absolute truth. And what that means is that if you are alive, you are a dogmatist.
The real question for us, as opposed to the stupidity of the Enlightenment now embodied in the misnomer "postmodernity," even though it should be called, in Thomas Oden's terms, "ultra-modernity," is, What is true, and how can we know it? As we have seen, the pre-Enlightenment Christian culture believed that what is true must be gained from both belief in a report, transcendent (hence, all knowledge is possible) and human (hence, historical and other types of knowledge that are unavailable to our immediate senses, but existed in our realm, is also possible), along with empirical verification for those things that allow such inquiry, must be adopted to understand reality. It is the sharp contrast between fact and value, or physical versus metaphysical knowledge, one that had to be gained through common, and therefore more objective, experience and one that had to be gained through personal, and therefore more subjective, experience, that led to the logically suicidal claim that one cannot be dogmatic/certain/absolute about what is metaphysical (a claim itself, as we saw before, that is dogmatic/certain/absolute about something that is metaphysical).
So we simply cannot escape the necessity of believing with certainty in something that is understood as absolute. We cannot escape dogmatism. What we can ask, however, is the first question, What is metaphysically true? Now, this question can only be asked of someone who has metaphysical knowledge. We cannot say that it cannot be known, because, again, that is making an absolute and certain claim about the metaphysical. If it cannot be known, then you cannot know that it cannot be known, and in fact, therefore, it may very well be completely accessible for us to know it. In other words, no matter what the claim might be about the metaphysical, it is always and forever an absolute and certain claim that asserts itself dogmatically over all other beliefs that would seek to counter it.
Hence, as I said before, we must ask someone who is transcendent what is metaphysically true, or we will just be holding up speculations as absolute truth by which we judge all other things. As I also said before, opting out is not an option. If you think, i.e., if you are alive, you will already assume certainty in certain metaphysical truth claims. That is how we were made. That is just simply what we do. You cannot, therefore, say that you will just choose not to make those claims. You are already doing it, whether you speak them or not, and if you speak at all, and make any sort of proposition you consider to be true, you will have failed in your own theory that one can just opt out from metaphysical beliefs (which is already a metaphysical belief about the nature of thought btw).
What this means is that we are tied to what we believe, not in a way that an agnostic asserts truth, but in a way that an omniscient being asserts truth. The problem is that we are not omniscient, but by nature assert truth that needs omniscience to hold a view of reality, as we live within whatever metaphysical assumptions we have adopted as absolutely true. We are just THAT certain about them. We are dogmatists, precisely, because we are human; but our need for omniscience in order to be dogmatists cannot be fulfilled through us, as, again, we are human.
Hence, the only way to know reality is really by seeking an authority beyond the physical, an authority that knows the metaphysical through omniscience. That authority is God, but God must now communicate that to me, lest His truth and what He desires of me become part of the larger trend of my human nature to speculate concerning the metaphysical. Without revelation from Him, we are back in the same boat. This is why the pre-Enlightenment understanding concerning our apprehension of metaphysical knowledge, sufficient enough to be considered absolute, and therefore, upon which we can root our certainty and dogmatism, must be correct, and the modern (Enlightenment oriented)/postmodern (i.e., ultra-modern) view of metaphysical knowledge as unreliably uncertain and subjective to the individual must be completely rejected as an exploration in stupidity (i.e., a darkening rather than an enlightenment).
But this post was not just concerning the false idea that only some people are dogmatic, but others are more "enlightened" in their thinking, making lesser assertions when they think and speak than these others do (such is posturing nonsense to make oneself feel more intellectual within his or her own dogmatism), but also why no one wants to admit that they are dogmatists.
The reason why no one wants to admit it is rooted in the false dichotomy of the Enlightenment as we saw above. The idea that no one can know the metaphysical, and can only share his or her opinion of any subjective experience in that area, has bred the further idea that to express one's metaphysical opinion as absolute is to be arrogant.
In fact, since no one can know metaphysical truth with certainty, the person making any claim toward that end is thought to be of the worst of people, not joining in our reindeer games that allow us to puff ourselves up in our supposed assertive neutrality. Hence, no one wants to be seen as arrogant, imposing his ideas on another, as his ideas are his opinion, and therefore, he is merely, aggressively imposing himself upon others in an oppressive manner, using ideas to do it.
But my point here, in light of what I said above, is that such an analysis is true of everyone, except the individual who submits himself to the transcendent Someone who has given revelation sufficiently decided from His omniscient will to supply us with enough knowledge of the metaphysical so as to be certain and functionally absolute. In other words, it is impossible for the one who appeals to that transcendent revelation to be arrogant, as the one who does so is the only one thinking of and speaking truth claims that are not of himself, and therefore, not an assertion of himself. In other words, everyone who is merely appealing to his or her own experience, including the person claiming that another is oppressive for asserting his or her opinion upon him or her, is the oppressive agent, asserting his or her dogmatic certainty of absolute truth on others, and is therefore arrogant. The only one who can escape such a claim is the one asserting another who is not in our predicament, the One who knows the metaphysical through His "empirically verified experience" (although God's knowledge is much more sophisticated than that description).
The person using the Bible, then, is not arrogant in asserting its claims over all other claims, because he is asserting God over others, not himself. Now, he may be using the Bible to assert himself, but this is a motivational judgment, where the other party is merely attempting (once again) to know something metaphysical (in this case, the internal motivation of someone else). The point here is simply to say that in a clash of ideas, the only one who cannot be accused of being arrogant is the one appealing to a higher authority than himself. He is, therefore, asserting God, not himself. Hence, the claim that he is arrogant is unfounded and hypocritical, especially since it is the pot calling the kettle black.
In reality, it is a move of humility to assert the truth of Scripture over all other speculative opinions, as their origin has only a claim to be of the individual and made within the individual, but the assertion of the Scripture has its claim as being rooted in what God Himself (i.e., the only One who would actually know what is true metaphysically) has spoken.
What we have now, then, is tons of people thinking that they are humble in their opinions that reject the absolute certainty of God's Word, a certainty gained, not from empirical verification of the physical or a subjective empirical verification of the metaphysical (i.e., not by sight), but by believing what is reported therein (i.e., by faith); and ironically turning on those who would truly humble themselves to God's Word by allowing it to be in the chair of judgment over all other ideas by calling them arrogant for doing so.
Of course, the claim of arrogance comes in a variety of synonymous expressions: "who do you think you are?" "who made you our judge?" "you just think you know better than everyone else" etc. These are all assertions that attempt to paint the speaker of the Word of God as arrogant, as one asserting himself, ironically, when he is actually attempting (whether successful or not) to assert God over both himself and the speculations of others.
So we live in a mixed up world and a mixed up church that has been led down the wrong path by it. Certainty is the product of both faith in the report and/or empirical verification, depending upon what we're attempting to know. The attempt of the American Christian to make him or herself appear less dogmatic is nothing more than evidence that those individuals have been poisoned with Enlightenment-oriented distinctions between fact and value, what can be known versus what must be speculatively believed. But, as I've tried to argue, this dichotomy is false, the person who attempts to present him or herself as less dogmatic is only attempting to fool himself and the others around him. There is just no such thing as thinking and speaking without metaphysical certainty. And you can be dogmatically certain about that absolute truth.
Thursday, January 12, 2012
Monday, January 9, 2012
Why Revelation Is All We Have to Know God's Will and Why It Matters
I remember being in numerous churches where the pastor would turn to the Book of Judges and use Gideon as an example of someone who was faithful because he wanted to make sure of the will of God in order to do it. We were then told to put out our fleeces to figure out the will of God for ourselves as well. I find it amazing that we were never told to use other figures in Judges as examples to mimic. For instance, why not tell us to sacrifice our children or be captured by our enemies so we can take them down? Why not tell us to slaughter our siblings to secure our inheritance? Why? Because the judges in the Book of Judges are doing things that are wrong. That's the whole point. We weren't meant to mimic them, but to shake our heads and NOT do the same; but rather use our faith to know the will of God through what He has revealed. Hence, in Deuteronomy 18:10-13, we are told that God detests anyone who interprets omens.
An omen was a sign to which someone looked to interpret an event, present, past or future. It was seeking to know God's will through an alternate means of interpreting events. Our modern omens are the ideas we have gained through our lives that function as interpretive guides to our experiences. In fact, we just mesh them all together and call them "experience," when we really mean what we have learned by applying external grids of ideas to our experience. In any case, trying to read experience through alternate means other than the Word of God is really what the prohibition against omens is all about.
This is really important to understand. You see, according to Deuteronomy 32:7-14, Israel alone was set apart as God's people. The rest of the nations were given over to the rule of demons who then create their own religions through which men might pay homage to them (v. 17; see also Rev 9:20). In the New Testament, we see the same thing. The people of God's family are extended through Christ to all who believe. It is over them that He rules; but the rest of the world remains as that which was given over to the devil as his domain. He is called the ruler of this world (John 14:30), the god of this world (2 Cor 4:3-4), and the prince of the power of the air (Eph 2:1-3), which refers to both his invisible presence and influence in the world. Consider Paul's words in First Corinthians 10:20:
[No,] but [I say] that the things which the Gentiles [i.e., those who do not believe and belong to the world] sacrifice, they sacrifice to demons, and not to God; and I do not want you to become sharers in demons.
Notice here that the world, then, is ruled by the demonic; but why is this important for us to know? Because this is why omens, i.e., trying to figure out God's will by reading what goes on in the world, what goes on in our lives, etc. with the worldview given to us by the god of this world, are bad and will lead us to what is false. If we attempt to read our experience, we are attempting to know the will of God, i.e., what is right and wrong, true and false, through this world's system, which is based on the influence of our adversary. How do you think that's going to work out for you?
Hence, we are told that the spirit of the age is one that leads to a life without God in Ephesians 2:1-3, 11-12
And you were dead in your trespasses and sins, in which you formerly walked according to the course of this world, according to the prince of the power of the air, of the spirit that is now working in the sons of disobedience. Among them we too all formerly lived in the desires of a this-worldly life, indulging the desires of a this-worldly life and of a this-worldly mind, and were by nature children of wrath, even as the rest . . . Therefore remember that formerly you, the Gentiles in the flesh, who are called "Uncircumcision" by the so-called "Circumcision," [which is] performed in the flesh by human hands --[remember] that you were at that time separate from Christ, excluded from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world.
Notice that we were without God in the world as unbelievers because we were excluded from the covenants of promise and had not hope. We did not know God's will because we did not know God through other religions and/or through our personal experience. We did not, because we could not. This world belongs to the devil. The spirit of the age, i.e., the way that we think, the way that our culture thinks, the way that our religious culture thinks, if it is not saturated with what is transcendent revelation from God, is what we have to interpret this world's experiences with. Because of this, apart from the Word of God, we will always misconstrue events in our lives and misinterpret them with a demonically inspired worldview. In other words, there is no neutrality. If we do not use what has been given to us in God's Word to understand the world, the spirit of the age that is produced by the ruler of this world will automatically be our default position and we will interpret all things accordingly.
This is precisely why God commanded His people to not seek out His will through omens, but through what He had given them. Hence, in Deuteronomy 29:29, we are told:
"The secret things belong to the Lord our God, but the things revealed belong to us and to our sons forever, that we may observe all the words of this law."
This is the only way to escape the redrawn shades of meaning the devil's light provides for us to interpret our experience in the world. Otherwise, if we seek out to understand on our own, he already has us, as he has been training us through our culture, and through fanning our disbelieving nature, since birth. We will misread this world because it is his world to be misread. Whatever we need in our lives to complete that deception, he is more than willing to provide it. He desires our sorrow and damnation, as "wretches find comfort in the fellow sufferings of others."
But God who rules His people has called them out, not through the spirit of this age, but by His Holy (distinct and set apart) Spirit by giving us the word of His gospel and the Word of God that this gospel message calls us toward. He seeks the renewing of our minds that our continually reinfected with the interpretations of life the devil wants to give them. He seeks to wash us with the Word, and to give the Word to others that they too may be washed from the demonic filth of this world's thinking.
Let me put this in application to myself. If I were to try to read my experience as an indication of God's favor upon me, I would conclude that He has no favor upon my life. I have lost jobs, health, finances, many of my possessions, friends, my dad, and now my mother's life is threatened. Prayers have not been answered in many of these things. Should I be given over to attempting to read God's will for my life through these things, I would surely conclude that either God has forsaken me, God never knew me, or that He does not exist in the first place.
Now, I have a choice to make. I can interpret my experiences through the spirit of this age, or I can throw myself into the Word of God and let the Spirit of God interpret my experiences through it. If I choose the former, it will either lead to my rejection of the Bible as the Word of God, as it tells me something quite different than what I have come to believe as true through the spirit of the age, or it will lead to my rejection of the idea that God exists. Either way, I will make some sort of move to undermine the Scripture and the truth due to my alternate means of interpreting all things. And that's exactly what the devil wants of all of this. It's his world, so all roads lead to unbelief therein.
But if I trust in God's Word, then I have an interpretation of life that runs counter the spirit of the age. The things in my life have not necessarily occurred because of God's nonexistence or disfavor, but precisely because of His favor. I am told that every child of God is disciplined in order that he might become a partaker in God's holiness, see God, and bear more fruit. I am told that this pattern is normative for every Christian, not just the really bad ones that God doesn't like (as if there are any of that sort). In other words, as long as I am following Christ in a life of repentance and faith, I can trust the promises given in the Word of God that God is saving me and those around me through suffering and tragedy. It is not to give me a better life here. It is to work toward the holiness of both myself and His people. But you're not going to get that from reading your experience with the spirit of the age. Only false beliefs reside within that worldview. It will take you away from the will of God, not toward it, and it will inevitably lead to darkness and despair in the world to come when the spirit of this age falls apart with the passing world to which it was a part.
Hence, reading omens in Scripture is said to be an evil thing. It distrusts God's ability to communicate sufficiently to His people, and it takes us away from the truth of God's salvation. It calls us to the winds and waves of this world, and will bring us to despair; but God calls us to His Word, to faith, hope, and love in and of His revealed will. It is the lifeline in a sea of trouble, the light that shines in a very, very dark place (much darker than we imagine it to be, as the spirit of this age convinces us of its bright future).
If I interpret the will of God by the way I feel, by the events that take place within the day, by the tragedies that occur, by even the claiming of my own life, I will be brought to think that God favors me when things are going well and disfavors me when things go awry; but this is the stupidity of false religion, as though God is so fickle to constantly change His mind day to day. We cannot let experience be our guide, because we cannot let the devil and our disbelieving nature be our guide. We must put our hope and trust in what God has spoken, as our experiences will come and go, but what He has declared stands both now and forever. Revelation is all we've got, and to ignore it, diminish it's authority, or even put it on par with our experience is to give the devil a great foothold on your life, and once he has that, the door of your life is much easier to open, so that he can come in and rule you as he does the rest of the world. But God has shown us mercy by creating and preserving this Word for us that he might not overcome us. It carries the message of our salvation, our adoption, our hope in a dying world. It is where we must go to interpret the significance of all things, especially the will of God. Ask, "Why?" but ask it of Scripture, not into the air or in attempting to make sense of things by yourself, for left on your own, the devil has you; but God has set down this beacon of light for you that you might not be his captive anymore.
If you are a Christian, stop interpreting your experience with the spirit of this age, with your culture, with your religious traditions, with what mom and dad or your teachers taught you, and put your faith in the Scripture that is a lamp unto your feet and a light unto your path. If you are not a Christian, come away from the darkness of being without God in the world, interpreting all experiences through a continually moving grid of faddish philosophies and man-made ideals, and believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and be saved from this wicked generation.
Without the Word of God, we don't have God's influence in our thoughts. We have only the devil's; but the good news is that we can come to Christ, and through Him can be restored to God that we might claim all of the promises of our salvation, promises revealed within the His Word, and begin to be washed and renewed in our minds by the power therein. And that alone will save us in the day when this life falls apart and the spirit of this age can no longer fill our heads with false hopes. Instead, we say to Christ, as His disciples have always said, Where else shall we go? You have words of eternal life (John 6:68).
Heaven and earth shall pass away, but My words shall never pass away. (Matt 24:35)
The grass withers, the flower fades, but the word of our God stands forever. (Isa 40:8)
An omen was a sign to which someone looked to interpret an event, present, past or future. It was seeking to know God's will through an alternate means of interpreting events. Our modern omens are the ideas we have gained through our lives that function as interpretive guides to our experiences. In fact, we just mesh them all together and call them "experience," when we really mean what we have learned by applying external grids of ideas to our experience. In any case, trying to read experience through alternate means other than the Word of God is really what the prohibition against omens is all about.
This is really important to understand. You see, according to Deuteronomy 32:7-14, Israel alone was set apart as God's people. The rest of the nations were given over to the rule of demons who then create their own religions through which men might pay homage to them (v. 17; see also Rev 9:20). In the New Testament, we see the same thing. The people of God's family are extended through Christ to all who believe. It is over them that He rules; but the rest of the world remains as that which was given over to the devil as his domain. He is called the ruler of this world (John 14:30), the god of this world (2 Cor 4:3-4), and the prince of the power of the air (Eph 2:1-3), which refers to both his invisible presence and influence in the world. Consider Paul's words in First Corinthians 10:20:
[No,] but [I say] that the things which the Gentiles [i.e., those who do not believe and belong to the world] sacrifice, they sacrifice to demons, and not to God; and I do not want you to become sharers in demons.
Notice here that the world, then, is ruled by the demonic; but why is this important for us to know? Because this is why omens, i.e., trying to figure out God's will by reading what goes on in the world, what goes on in our lives, etc. with the worldview given to us by the god of this world, are bad and will lead us to what is false. If we attempt to read our experience, we are attempting to know the will of God, i.e., what is right and wrong, true and false, through this world's system, which is based on the influence of our adversary. How do you think that's going to work out for you?
Hence, we are told that the spirit of the age is one that leads to a life without God in Ephesians 2:1-3, 11-12
And you were dead in your trespasses and sins, in which you formerly walked according to the course of this world, according to the prince of the power of the air, of the spirit that is now working in the sons of disobedience. Among them we too all formerly lived in the desires of a this-worldly life, indulging the desires of a this-worldly life and of a this-worldly mind, and were by nature children of wrath, even as the rest . . . Therefore remember that formerly you, the Gentiles in the flesh, who are called "Uncircumcision" by the so-called "Circumcision," [which is] performed in the flesh by human hands --[remember] that you were at that time separate from Christ, excluded from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers to the covenants of promise, having no hope and without God in the world.
Notice that we were without God in the world as unbelievers because we were excluded from the covenants of promise and had not hope. We did not know God's will because we did not know God through other religions and/or through our personal experience. We did not, because we could not. This world belongs to the devil. The spirit of the age, i.e., the way that we think, the way that our culture thinks, the way that our religious culture thinks, if it is not saturated with what is transcendent revelation from God, is what we have to interpret this world's experiences with. Because of this, apart from the Word of God, we will always misconstrue events in our lives and misinterpret them with a demonically inspired worldview. In other words, there is no neutrality. If we do not use what has been given to us in God's Word to understand the world, the spirit of the age that is produced by the ruler of this world will automatically be our default position and we will interpret all things accordingly.
This is precisely why God commanded His people to not seek out His will through omens, but through what He had given them. Hence, in Deuteronomy 29:29, we are told:
"The secret things belong to the Lord our God, but the things revealed belong to us and to our sons forever, that we may observe all the words of this law."
This is the only way to escape the redrawn shades of meaning the devil's light provides for us to interpret our experience in the world. Otherwise, if we seek out to understand on our own, he already has us, as he has been training us through our culture, and through fanning our disbelieving nature, since birth. We will misread this world because it is his world to be misread. Whatever we need in our lives to complete that deception, he is more than willing to provide it. He desires our sorrow and damnation, as "wretches find comfort in the fellow sufferings of others."
But God who rules His people has called them out, not through the spirit of this age, but by His Holy (distinct and set apart) Spirit by giving us the word of His gospel and the Word of God that this gospel message calls us toward. He seeks the renewing of our minds that our continually reinfected with the interpretations of life the devil wants to give them. He seeks to wash us with the Word, and to give the Word to others that they too may be washed from the demonic filth of this world's thinking.
Let me put this in application to myself. If I were to try to read my experience as an indication of God's favor upon me, I would conclude that He has no favor upon my life. I have lost jobs, health, finances, many of my possessions, friends, my dad, and now my mother's life is threatened. Prayers have not been answered in many of these things. Should I be given over to attempting to read God's will for my life through these things, I would surely conclude that either God has forsaken me, God never knew me, or that He does not exist in the first place.
Now, I have a choice to make. I can interpret my experiences through the spirit of this age, or I can throw myself into the Word of God and let the Spirit of God interpret my experiences through it. If I choose the former, it will either lead to my rejection of the Bible as the Word of God, as it tells me something quite different than what I have come to believe as true through the spirit of the age, or it will lead to my rejection of the idea that God exists. Either way, I will make some sort of move to undermine the Scripture and the truth due to my alternate means of interpreting all things. And that's exactly what the devil wants of all of this. It's his world, so all roads lead to unbelief therein.
But if I trust in God's Word, then I have an interpretation of life that runs counter the spirit of the age. The things in my life have not necessarily occurred because of God's nonexistence or disfavor, but precisely because of His favor. I am told that every child of God is disciplined in order that he might become a partaker in God's holiness, see God, and bear more fruit. I am told that this pattern is normative for every Christian, not just the really bad ones that God doesn't like (as if there are any of that sort). In other words, as long as I am following Christ in a life of repentance and faith, I can trust the promises given in the Word of God that God is saving me and those around me through suffering and tragedy. It is not to give me a better life here. It is to work toward the holiness of both myself and His people. But you're not going to get that from reading your experience with the spirit of the age. Only false beliefs reside within that worldview. It will take you away from the will of God, not toward it, and it will inevitably lead to darkness and despair in the world to come when the spirit of this age falls apart with the passing world to which it was a part.
Hence, reading omens in Scripture is said to be an evil thing. It distrusts God's ability to communicate sufficiently to His people, and it takes us away from the truth of God's salvation. It calls us to the winds and waves of this world, and will bring us to despair; but God calls us to His Word, to faith, hope, and love in and of His revealed will. It is the lifeline in a sea of trouble, the light that shines in a very, very dark place (much darker than we imagine it to be, as the spirit of this age convinces us of its bright future).
If I interpret the will of God by the way I feel, by the events that take place within the day, by the tragedies that occur, by even the claiming of my own life, I will be brought to think that God favors me when things are going well and disfavors me when things go awry; but this is the stupidity of false religion, as though God is so fickle to constantly change His mind day to day. We cannot let experience be our guide, because we cannot let the devil and our disbelieving nature be our guide. We must put our hope and trust in what God has spoken, as our experiences will come and go, but what He has declared stands both now and forever. Revelation is all we've got, and to ignore it, diminish it's authority, or even put it on par with our experience is to give the devil a great foothold on your life, and once he has that, the door of your life is much easier to open, so that he can come in and rule you as he does the rest of the world. But God has shown us mercy by creating and preserving this Word for us that he might not overcome us. It carries the message of our salvation, our adoption, our hope in a dying world. It is where we must go to interpret the significance of all things, especially the will of God. Ask, "Why?" but ask it of Scripture, not into the air or in attempting to make sense of things by yourself, for left on your own, the devil has you; but God has set down this beacon of light for you that you might not be his captive anymore.
If you are a Christian, stop interpreting your experience with the spirit of this age, with your culture, with your religious traditions, with what mom and dad or your teachers taught you, and put your faith in the Scripture that is a lamp unto your feet and a light unto your path. If you are not a Christian, come away from the darkness of being without God in the world, interpreting all experiences through a continually moving grid of faddish philosophies and man-made ideals, and believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and be saved from this wicked generation.
Without the Word of God, we don't have God's influence in our thoughts. We have only the devil's; but the good news is that we can come to Christ, and through Him can be restored to God that we might claim all of the promises of our salvation, promises revealed within the His Word, and begin to be washed and renewed in our minds by the power therein. And that alone will save us in the day when this life falls apart and the spirit of this age can no longer fill our heads with false hopes. Instead, we say to Christ, as His disciples have always said, Where else shall we go? You have words of eternal life (John 6:68).
Heaven and earth shall pass away, but My words shall never pass away. (Matt 24:35)
The grass withers, the flower fades, but the word of our God stands forever. (Isa 40:8)
Saturday, January 7, 2012
Does Repentance Bring Forgiveness in and of Itself?
I watched “Cowboys and Aliens” the other night, and the recurring theme was summed up in the words of a dying preacher to the main protagonist of the story, who had been trying to remember who he was for the entire movie, and finally found out he was a low-life criminal. What the preacher said to him was this:
“God doesn’t care who you were, Boy. He only cares who you are.”
This is a recurring theme in movies and tv shows, i.e., the bad guy that turns into a good guy. I imagine, if there is a biblical reference here, this would refer to Ezekiel 18. However, this needs to be clarified, as we tend to think that one can become a good person after being a bad person apart from a means to be forgiven by a Just and Holy God.
In one sense, then, this statement isn’t really true. God isn’t bound by time, and so there is no “were/are” distinction with Him. Hence, who you were is who you are, since sin just doesn’t disappear over time all by itself. My point here is simply that repentance needs a means to be forgiven. It is not cleansing within itself. A payment must be made in order for repentance to be real. The payment must equal the required penalty, and not be less than what is required. In our case, the penalty is eternal death and curse. But how does one restore his relationship with God if, in fact, he must forever pay a penalty that separates Him from that salvific relationship?
We also cannot pay for what we've done by doing good, because, to take some good thoughts from Anselm, we owe our entire lives to God, not just some of it. What this means is that we already owed God, as our Maker, every good work possible to be performed. If we just do good works for the last half of our lives after doing bad ones for the first half, we've still only give God half of what we owe Him. Hence, we cannot pay for the bad with the good because the good already was due God. What this means is that our good cannot be the basis for why we are forgiven by God in repentance, but neither, as we see above, can forgiveness be arbitrary. Hence, the holiness and justice of God must be satisfied by something other than what we can do.
We also cannot pay for what we've done by doing good, because, to take some good thoughts from Anselm, we owe our entire lives to God, not just some of it. What this means is that we already owed God, as our Maker, every good work possible to be performed. If we just do good works for the last half of our lives after doing bad ones for the first half, we've still only give God half of what we owe Him. Hence, we cannot pay for the bad with the good because the good already was due God. What this means is that our good cannot be the basis for why we are forgiven by God in repentance, but neither, as we see above, can forgiveness be arbitrary. Hence, the holiness and justice of God must be satisfied by something other than what we can do.
Hence, in another sense, this statement is absolutely true, as Christ has made restoration to God possible through repentance. Forgiveness has a basis. It isn’t arbitrary and it would not exist without the full penalty having been paid. Since the penalty has been paid in full, the individual can repent and enjoy a restored relationship with God immediately upon his repentance. Hence, Ezekiel 18 is possible because of the work of Christ, but apart from Him, it is not.
What this means is that there is no other religion in which men can repent and be saved. They may feel sorry for what they have done. They may try to do better. But in the end, they are who they were, because God sees only now, not past and present in distinction. It is our sin that has happened now, and it is Christ’s payment that has satisfied God now for it, and it is now that we are who we are in Him. We are His sons and daughters now, because we have always been His sons and daughters. In time and our experience, we became so, but in God's eyes we were chosen and loved as such before the foundation of the world. Hence, with Christ, through the good news of His work, repentance and forgiveness is possible, and God only cares who we are now, but without Him, forgiveness is impossible and these people remain now the same people they once were.
Of course, if biblical repentance is a turning away from a Christless life to a Christ-filled life, then no one can repent and become a different person apart from receiving Christ as Lord and Savior.
We're going through Ephesians in our family morning devotion time right now, and it is amazing how many times the phrase "in Him," "in/through Christ," or "in the Beloved One." is repeated throughout Chapter 1:3-15. Take a look:
Blessed [be] the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly [places] in Christ, just as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we would be holy and blameless before Him. In love, He predestined us to adoption as sons through Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the kind intention of His will, to the praise of the glory of His grace, which He freely bestowed on us in the Beloved One.
In Him we have redemption through His blood, the forgiveness of our trespasses, according to the riches of His grace which He lavished on us. In all wisdom and insight He made known to us the mystery of His will, according to His kind intention which He purposed in Him with a view to an administration suitable to the fullness of the times, [that is], the summing up of all things in Christ, things in the heavens and things on the earth. In Him also we have obtained an inheritance, having been predestined according to His purpose who works all things after the counsel of His will, to the end that we who were the first to hope in Christ would be to the praise of His glory. In Him, you also, after listening to the message of truth, the gospel of your salvation--having also believed, you were sealed in Him with the Holy Spirit of promise, who is given as a pledge of our inheritance, with a view to the redemption of [God's own] possession, to the praise of His glory.
We're going through Ephesians in our family morning devotion time right now, and it is amazing how many times the phrase "in Him," "in/through Christ," or "in the Beloved One." is repeated throughout Chapter 1:3-15. Take a look:
Blessed [be] the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly [places] in Christ, just as He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we would be holy and blameless before Him. In love, He predestined us to adoption as sons through Jesus Christ to Himself, according to the kind intention of His will, to the praise of the glory of His grace, which He freely bestowed on us in the Beloved One.
In Him we have redemption through His blood, the forgiveness of our trespasses, according to the riches of His grace which He lavished on us. In all wisdom and insight He made known to us the mystery of His will, according to His kind intention which He purposed in Him with a view to an administration suitable to the fullness of the times, [that is], the summing up of all things in Christ, things in the heavens and things on the earth. In Him also we have obtained an inheritance, having been predestined according to His purpose who works all things after the counsel of His will, to the end that we who were the first to hope in Christ would be to the praise of His glory. In Him, you also, after listening to the message of truth, the gospel of your salvation--having also believed, you were sealed in Him with the Holy Spirit of promise, who is given as a pledge of our inheritance, with a view to the redemption of [God's own] possession, to the praise of His glory.
So it is true, when qualified, that God doesn't care who you were (in terms of who you were in your sin nature for a short time), He only cares who you are, because, in Christ, you have and always will be, His child. And we have been made His child in Christ, chosen in love from long before we ever existed, long before the world existed. It is through Christ, then, that repentance is effective, and we are restored to that relationship we were always meant to have, and to that person we were always meant to be.
[To make clear: We become saved as His child when we put our trust in Christ in time and space, but we were always loved and chosen to be so from the foundation of the world. So, to God, we have always been His. To us (i.e., when salvation is applied and we receive the Spirit of God), we have only been His since the time we believed]
[To make clear: We become saved as His child when we put our trust in Christ in time and space, but we were always loved and chosen to be so from the foundation of the world. So, to God, we have always been His. To us (i.e., when salvation is applied and we receive the Spirit of God), we have only been His since the time we believed]
Thursday, January 5, 2012
The Unpleasant Message about Being Christ's Disciples
We’re going through “Christianity Explored,” an evangelistic Bible Study that goes through the Gospel of Mark, right now, and the passage we read last night, I thought, was a profound one. I’ve preached through the Gospel of Mark before, and was often struck by all of the things I was missing in the Gospel back when I had given it a simple reading before.
First, we need to understand that Christ’s miracles, in Mark, represent the miracle Christ will do in each of us who believe. The miracle is a the miracle of life, healing, and transformation. Most people associate this with Christ already, but what Christ tells us is that these miracles are only for His disciples, i.e., those who follow Him. As such, His teaching/words of life are for them alone (not for the masses to whom He speaks in purposely confusing parables). In fact, He is seen throughout the Gospel telling people to say nothing about Him. He expresses this, knowing that His works will definitely be reported, not because He thinks He will stop people from doing so (God is certainly able to do that if He so desired), but as to teach that what He says and does is only for those who follow Him, and no one else.
Now, having understood that life and the healing of one’s relationship with God and man is granted only to Christ’s disciples, it then becomes imperative that we answer the question, “How do I become a disciple of Christ?”
This is what Mark 7–8 highlight, even though the same appears throughout the Gospel. Chapter 7 begins with the Pharisees, who believe that by ordering their external lives in what they deem to be an acceptable manner, begin a dispute with Christ for not making His disciples ritually wash their hands before they eat. Christ then proceeds to rebuke them by telling them that their real problem isn’t the arrangement of their external lives, but their rebellion toward the Word of God. He, then, tells these people, people who think they are good people who are good enough to be acceptable to God, that they are not acceptable, but in fact, evil men. In vv. 14–23, Christ tells His disciples that no food that goes into their mouths can make them unclean (i.e., unacceptable to God), but what comes from within the man is what makes him unacceptable to God. In vv. 21–23, the text states:
And He was saying, "That which proceeds out of the man, that is what defiles the man. "For from within, out of the heart of men, proceed the evil thoughts, fornications, thefts, murders, adulteries, deeds of coveting [and] wickedness, [as well as] deceit, sensuality, envy, slander, pride [and] foolishness. "All these evil things proceed from within and defile the man."
In other words, you’re not good people. You’re not acceptable to God, even though you think you are because you’re an upright citizen and a religious/spiritual person. You can perform whatever ritual you want, but the problem is inside of you; and that problem is you.
Now, many will not accept this message, and that is what makes the rest of the chapter so brilliant. What the Lord Jesus says here is followed by numerous instances of miracles that He performs, and it is through the narration of these miracles that we begin to understand how we must become a disciple of Christ and receive our own life-giving miracle.
The first miracle performed is for a Syro-Phoenician woman, a Gentile. If you’re not aware, Christ’s ministry on earth was reserved only for His people, the Jews. The gospel comes to them first, but of course, it really comes to those who are His true disciples within that larger group. And in comes this unclean woman asking Him to rid her daughter of an unclean spirit. Notice that this is not your father’s “Mr. Rogers, everybody’s welcome to the neighborhood” Jesus.
And He was saying to her, "Let the children be satisfied first, for it is not good to take the children's bread and throw it to the dogs."
Now, if you came to someone for help, and they told you, No, and called you a “dog,” I’m guessing you might be a little offended by that. Even moreso, if you were a first century Palestinian woman, you would understand that designation as saying that you were essentially “trailer trash,” and not worthy to even be in God’s presence. So, seeking to lift yourself back up from such a humiliation, you would likely just yell and scream and give Christ a piece of your mind to make yourself feel better by tearing Him down. But herein is the lesson. The woman doesn’t do that. She actually, in agreement, acknowledges that she is a dog and begs for Christ to have mercy on her. Now, this is the response He wanted from her. He wanted her humility to see that she was not acceptable as she was, and come to Him acknowledging such. Once she did, He says to her, “"Because of this answer go; the demon has gone out of your daughter” (v. 29) “And going back to her home,” verse 30 says, “she found the child lying on the bed, the demon having left.”
What we have just witnessed here is that one who wishes to become a disciple of Christ cannot ignore His teaching that he or she is not acceptable to God as they are, and that God considers them unclean and unworthy of His presence. It is only through this acknowledgement that one becomes a disciple of Christ, because one will not/cannot, receive the gospel fully without it. In other words, there is no point in just making disciples out of prideful people who already feel that they are acceptable to God, as they cannot submit themselves to Christ as Lord and the necessity of His work on the cross on their behalf in order to be saved. This can only happen through humiliation, and humiliation is unpleasant. The road to salvation, then, is through repentance, but before one can repent, he or she must be rebuked from thinking that he or she is acceptable before God, and it is that rebuke, that proclamation that one is a dog and unworthy to ever be considered by God as someone for whom the miracle of eternal life should be performed, that is either received as a shameful truth or rejected as an offensive lie. The road to Christ must come through the gates of spiritual humility. It is the poor in spirit who will inherit the kingdom of God, not the ones who think they belong there whether they have decided to follow Christ or not.
Mark continues to show this pattern of the unpleasant humiliation that precedes life and exaltation as one of Christ’s disciples. He does by showing Christ putting His fingers in a deaf and mute man’s ears and spitting, touching his tongue with His spit. Mark also shows Christ rubbing spit in a blind man’s eyes.
If someone spit on you today, you would take major offense; but it was even worse in Christ’s day. Spitting on someone is the ultimate act of disfavor. It is done when the one who spits wants to communicate the complete and utter rejection of another. Hence, they spit on Christ at His crucifixion. It is the ultimate rejection of the person, and as such, it is the ultimate humiliation of that person. Being spat upon is offensive. Being told you are a dog is offensive. Being told you are evil and not acceptable to God is offensive, that is, if you believe otherwise. But these men receive what would otherwise be offensive, what is unpleasant, nonetheless, and when they do, they hear, speak, and see, i.e., they are given new life, they are healed as a result.
Mark also brings the feeding of the crowds in at this point in order to show that it is Christ, who is God (the One who gave manna in the wilderness and saved the lives of His people when they followed Him), who alone has the power to give life and provide what is needed for true life. He thus does the impossible by producing more food out of a little food, i.e., He takes life and makes life from it, but life must be there in the first place, and that must come through the humility of repentance and the denial of the idea that one is acceptable enough to be saved “as is.”
The pericope ends with Christ’s statements concerning what it means to be a disciple, and that only a true disciple will receive life from Him by letting go of the self, letting my pride die, letting my dreams die, letting all that I am be humiliated as Christ tells me that I am unacceptable to God, and will not be saved without following Him. So I leave you with His words, of which should never be viewed as shameful in a wicked generation that postures itself as good.
And He summoned the crowd with His disciples, and said to them, "If anyone wishes to come after Me, he must deny himself, and take up his cross and follow Me. "For whoever wishes to save his life will lose it, but whoever loses his life for My sake and the gospel's will save it. "For what does it profit a man to gain the whole world, and forfeit his soul? "For what will a man give in exchange for his soul? "For whoever is ashamed of Me and My words in this adulterous and sinful generation, the Son of Man will also be ashamed of him when He comes in the glory of His Father with the holy angels."
Wednesday, January 4, 2012
Reading without Thinking
One of the difficult things in teaching children to read is to get them to start thinking about what they are reading rather than just parroting the letters on the page. Hence, we measure children in terms of their reading comprehension. However, "reading comprehension" in school often takes the form of just regurgitating what the author has said. This is good. It is reading comprehension, but it isn't critical reading, which is a level of reading comprehension where the child has gone from being a tape recorder to becoming a live human being.
In light of this, I don't think that most people ever reach the level of critical reading, much less reading comprehension when it comes to books about the Bible. I hear a lot of things that are proposed by particular scholars echoed in the lay reader, but it is being recited as though he or she was the scholar's parrot rather than a person.
What got me thinking about this was a book I began to read yesterday at Peter's speech therapy class. Allison and I decided that it would be better for me to bring him because it would help her have a more even flow during the school day with the kids, so I have about an hour to kill while I wait, and it allows me to get some more reading done. The book I chose to read this time is Lee M. McDonald's The Formation of the Christian Biblical Canon (revised and expanded edition). What struck me on every page so far is that McDonald makes a lot of bold statements concerning dating the New Testament and what the Bible says of itself in terms of being Scripture. In fact, he makes a lot of wrong statements concerning these facts, which makes me believe that McDonald merely has a particular belief about the Scripture that causes him to select his data to the exclusion of other data.
For instance, one of the more dogmatic statements he makes is that Second Peter was written around 160 CE, which although falling in the range of where most scholars would put it, isn't obvious at all. This is part of an argument that he is making that the New Testament writings are not yet identified as Scripture until a much later time than the first couple centuries. He does allude to Irenaeus's reference of the fourfold Gospels in the second century, but seems to leave out references such as those in the Pastorals, which he dates later than Paul, which place a citation of Luke alongside a citation of Deuteronomy in First Timothy 5:18 and calls both of them "Scripture." Even if we were to grant McDonald that the more liberal view of the authorship and dating of the Pastorals was correct, this is surely evidence that within the second century, Luke was considered to be Scripture. And if, as most scholars will agree, Luke-Acts are works that go together, as they are written by the same author, then the Book of Acts must have also been seen as Scripture by that time. So here we have Irenaeus and the Pastorals affirming that the Gospels and Acts were identified by the early church as Scripture. But that's not all. Second Peter, even if we gave it the late date of AD 160, affirms that the Pauline corpus is also identified as Scripture by the time of the second century..
Now, to be fair to McDonald, he does say that when the New Testament documents came to be viewed on par with the Old Testament Scripture is difficult to determine; but this is largely undermined by his argument that implies that it was not until a later date. Well, which is it? Is it difficult to determine or can it be dogmatically argued that it was not viewed this way in the first century?
My point in all of this is simply this. When another scholar reads this work, there are going to be numerous objections that pop into his head. He'll likely refute, qualify, or affirm what is being said with other knowledge that is left out. But what does the lay reader do with this? What can he do? Is he not left to merely taking everything said as a fact? How can he argue with it? He can choose not to believe it, but this book is a very scholarly book. It's big. It has numerous footnotes. The author is a scholar. He obviously has more interaction with the material than the average layman does. So the tendency is simply to take what is said as fact. The employment of critical reading skills at this point is impossible.
So what would I suggest for the layman? I would suggest not reading these kinds of books until you have read the arguments of scholars that will give you more of a solid orthodox foundation of these issues first. I would read books like Carson and Moo's Introduction to the New Testament first. But aside from this, try to communicate to laymen that they're not going to be able to assess what is said by their own knowledge, and this is where they just need to trust that God has preserved His witness on the earth through the Scripture. In other words, the layman, as does the Christian scholar, needs to first have faith in God's ability and desire to communicate primarily and sufficiently through His canon, and as such, has brought His church to the right place in determining what was and was not Scripture. In other words, as in all things, faith first, then reason, since the reasons cannot be evaluated critically by the layman, and the scholar always starts his reasoning from a faith position (no matter what those presuppositions/ultimate beliefs might be).
So as I read McDonald's statement below, I meet it with faith and then reason:
What makes it difficult to believe that the Gospels were viewed as scripture from the first is the liberty that the evangelists took in changing their sources. Matthew and Luke evidently felt free to adapt, change, and smooth out the Gospel of Mark as well as a "Q" source (p. 10).
I find this statement remarkable. For one, Matthew and Luke aren't "changing" Mark. They have different theological purposes in their presentation of the material. That's like saying that "West Side Story" attempts to change "Romeo and Juliet" when its attempt is not to change but to emphasize or reemphasize something about the story. In other words, it doesn't seek to edit "Romeo and Juliet," but rather to use material and the basic storyline from it in order to communicate both the original message and a specific nuance to that message that he original story did not contain. As such, all three: Matthew, Mark, and Luke stand in Scripture to this day because they each contribute something uniquely theological to the larger picture that they all capture in their main storyline. Hence, Mark is its own distinct work. It is a rougher draft of Luke and Matthew.
For another, what does this have to do with one viewing the text as Scripture? I can only conclude that McDonald's view of Scripture is a bit off. The view of certain books as sacred Scripture did not prevent people from presenting those stories and the elements of the Scripture in different forms for different purposes. Is he unaware that the Chronicler likely saw Samuel-Kings as sacred Scripture, and that is the reason why he uses it in his presentation? Is he unaware that Genesis and Exodus is viewed as sacred Scripture by the second century BC, and yet, that is the very reason it is reimagined in Jubilees and First Enoch? He refers to Tatian's Diatesseron again as an example that the Gospels must have not been viewed as sacred Scripture, since Tatian wouldn't have tried to have harmonized them if they were, but that is completely the other way around. The very reason Tatian tries to harmonize these texts and not the bazillion others is because they are recognized as sacred Scripture, and as such, he seeks to harmonize them. How many harmonies of the Gospels have been created since by people who viewed the four Gospels as sacred Scripture? This argument isn't merely weak, it's the complete polar opposite of the truth.
Yet, would a layman be able to note this? No. So what is he left with? He is left with believing or disbelieving based upon his faith and desire for the Scriptures either to have authority in themselves or to be undermined as documents that were merely given authority later on. He is either in rebellion against God and wants the Scripture to be diminished as Scripture, or he, in submission toward God, wants to see His Scriptures held high as that which is obviously Scripture and given witness to God's people by the Holy Spirit. The point that McDonald is attempting to argue here, of course, is that early Christianity is not a religion of the book but a religion of the Spirit. This is a false dichotomy, of course, and a conclusion based upon a predetermined belief, not on the data we actually have (cf. his statement that we do not see the Scriptures as the prominent authority in the Book of Acts with the continual appeal to Scripture as authoritative in the sermons given, as well as the statements made in Acts 17:2, 11; 18:24, 28 and its intimate connection to the message of God the apostles are proclaiming).
I have no doubt that McDonald would take issue with what I'm saying, but my point is simply this: When you read books like this as a layman, or books put out by Bart Ehrman, or books put out by Friedman, or Finkelstein, etc., you need to realize that you don't have the knowledge base in the field that critical reading requires. You can either begin to get it, or you can choose to believe in favor of, or contrary to, what is being said. But don't take these things as solid facts. They're not solid facts. In fact, often scholars make all sorts of assertions that are not necessarily supported by the data. My point here is just to be careful what you read and how you read it.
And if you'll notice, a lot of what I've said above is simply by virtue of knowing the Scripture well enough to object when it is misused. A lot of our theology is false because it is not qualified with other knowledge gained from other texts of Scripture. Hence, it may be backed up by verse X, but needs a qualification supplied by verse Y, without which verse X goes unqualified and is misunderstood. This leads to a false view. Hence, every Christian, scholar or not, should strive to know the Scripture well enough to read someone's theology critically.
In the end, however, the Christian life is about trust, and in trusting, you may lose out, but what I am really saying here is that it's all that you have anyway. Hence, make your heart right with God if you want Him to lead you into the everlasting way, and trust Him that He will do so if you seek Him with all of your heart. Your critical thinking skills may fail you, but if you are drawing near to Him, God never will.
In light of this, I don't think that most people ever reach the level of critical reading, much less reading comprehension when it comes to books about the Bible. I hear a lot of things that are proposed by particular scholars echoed in the lay reader, but it is being recited as though he or she was the scholar's parrot rather than a person.
What got me thinking about this was a book I began to read yesterday at Peter's speech therapy class. Allison and I decided that it would be better for me to bring him because it would help her have a more even flow during the school day with the kids, so I have about an hour to kill while I wait, and it allows me to get some more reading done. The book I chose to read this time is Lee M. McDonald's The Formation of the Christian Biblical Canon (revised and expanded edition). What struck me on every page so far is that McDonald makes a lot of bold statements concerning dating the New Testament and what the Bible says of itself in terms of being Scripture. In fact, he makes a lot of wrong statements concerning these facts, which makes me believe that McDonald merely has a particular belief about the Scripture that causes him to select his data to the exclusion of other data.
For instance, one of the more dogmatic statements he makes is that Second Peter was written around 160 CE, which although falling in the range of where most scholars would put it, isn't obvious at all. This is part of an argument that he is making that the New Testament writings are not yet identified as Scripture until a much later time than the first couple centuries. He does allude to Irenaeus's reference of the fourfold Gospels in the second century, but seems to leave out references such as those in the Pastorals, which he dates later than Paul, which place a citation of Luke alongside a citation of Deuteronomy in First Timothy 5:18 and calls both of them "Scripture." Even if we were to grant McDonald that the more liberal view of the authorship and dating of the Pastorals was correct, this is surely evidence that within the second century, Luke was considered to be Scripture. And if, as most scholars will agree, Luke-Acts are works that go together, as they are written by the same author, then the Book of Acts must have also been seen as Scripture by that time. So here we have Irenaeus and the Pastorals affirming that the Gospels and Acts were identified by the early church as Scripture. But that's not all. Second Peter, even if we gave it the late date of AD 160, affirms that the Pauline corpus is also identified as Scripture by the time of the second century..
Now, to be fair to McDonald, he does say that when the New Testament documents came to be viewed on par with the Old Testament Scripture is difficult to determine; but this is largely undermined by his argument that implies that it was not until a later date. Well, which is it? Is it difficult to determine or can it be dogmatically argued that it was not viewed this way in the first century?
My point in all of this is simply this. When another scholar reads this work, there are going to be numerous objections that pop into his head. He'll likely refute, qualify, or affirm what is being said with other knowledge that is left out. But what does the lay reader do with this? What can he do? Is he not left to merely taking everything said as a fact? How can he argue with it? He can choose not to believe it, but this book is a very scholarly book. It's big. It has numerous footnotes. The author is a scholar. He obviously has more interaction with the material than the average layman does. So the tendency is simply to take what is said as fact. The employment of critical reading skills at this point is impossible.
So what would I suggest for the layman? I would suggest not reading these kinds of books until you have read the arguments of scholars that will give you more of a solid orthodox foundation of these issues first. I would read books like Carson and Moo's Introduction to the New Testament first. But aside from this, try to communicate to laymen that they're not going to be able to assess what is said by their own knowledge, and this is where they just need to trust that God has preserved His witness on the earth through the Scripture. In other words, the layman, as does the Christian scholar, needs to first have faith in God's ability and desire to communicate primarily and sufficiently through His canon, and as such, has brought His church to the right place in determining what was and was not Scripture. In other words, as in all things, faith first, then reason, since the reasons cannot be evaluated critically by the layman, and the scholar always starts his reasoning from a faith position (no matter what those presuppositions/ultimate beliefs might be).
So as I read McDonald's statement below, I meet it with faith and then reason:
What makes it difficult to believe that the Gospels were viewed as scripture from the first is the liberty that the evangelists took in changing their sources. Matthew and Luke evidently felt free to adapt, change, and smooth out the Gospel of Mark as well as a "Q" source (p. 10).
I find this statement remarkable. For one, Matthew and Luke aren't "changing" Mark. They have different theological purposes in their presentation of the material. That's like saying that "West Side Story" attempts to change "Romeo and Juliet" when its attempt is not to change but to emphasize or reemphasize something about the story. In other words, it doesn't seek to edit "Romeo and Juliet," but rather to use material and the basic storyline from it in order to communicate both the original message and a specific nuance to that message that he original story did not contain. As such, all three: Matthew, Mark, and Luke stand in Scripture to this day because they each contribute something uniquely theological to the larger picture that they all capture in their main storyline. Hence, Mark is its own distinct work. It is a rougher draft of Luke and Matthew.
For another, what does this have to do with one viewing the text as Scripture? I can only conclude that McDonald's view of Scripture is a bit off. The view of certain books as sacred Scripture did not prevent people from presenting those stories and the elements of the Scripture in different forms for different purposes. Is he unaware that the Chronicler likely saw Samuel-Kings as sacred Scripture, and that is the reason why he uses it in his presentation? Is he unaware that Genesis and Exodus is viewed as sacred Scripture by the second century BC, and yet, that is the very reason it is reimagined in Jubilees and First Enoch? He refers to Tatian's Diatesseron again as an example that the Gospels must have not been viewed as sacred Scripture, since Tatian wouldn't have tried to have harmonized them if they were, but that is completely the other way around. The very reason Tatian tries to harmonize these texts and not the bazillion others is because they are recognized as sacred Scripture, and as such, he seeks to harmonize them. How many harmonies of the Gospels have been created since by people who viewed the four Gospels as sacred Scripture? This argument isn't merely weak, it's the complete polar opposite of the truth.
Yet, would a layman be able to note this? No. So what is he left with? He is left with believing or disbelieving based upon his faith and desire for the Scriptures either to have authority in themselves or to be undermined as documents that were merely given authority later on. He is either in rebellion against God and wants the Scripture to be diminished as Scripture, or he, in submission toward God, wants to see His Scriptures held high as that which is obviously Scripture and given witness to God's people by the Holy Spirit. The point that McDonald is attempting to argue here, of course, is that early Christianity is not a religion of the book but a religion of the Spirit. This is a false dichotomy, of course, and a conclusion based upon a predetermined belief, not on the data we actually have (cf. his statement that we do not see the Scriptures as the prominent authority in the Book of Acts with the continual appeal to Scripture as authoritative in the sermons given, as well as the statements made in Acts 17:2, 11; 18:24, 28 and its intimate connection to the message of God the apostles are proclaiming).
I have no doubt that McDonald would take issue with what I'm saying, but my point is simply this: When you read books like this as a layman, or books put out by Bart Ehrman, or books put out by Friedman, or Finkelstein, etc., you need to realize that you don't have the knowledge base in the field that critical reading requires. You can either begin to get it, or you can choose to believe in favor of, or contrary to, what is being said. But don't take these things as solid facts. They're not solid facts. In fact, often scholars make all sorts of assertions that are not necessarily supported by the data. My point here is just to be careful what you read and how you read it.
And if you'll notice, a lot of what I've said above is simply by virtue of knowing the Scripture well enough to object when it is misused. A lot of our theology is false because it is not qualified with other knowledge gained from other texts of Scripture. Hence, it may be backed up by verse X, but needs a qualification supplied by verse Y, without which verse X goes unqualified and is misunderstood. This leads to a false view. Hence, every Christian, scholar or not, should strive to know the Scripture well enough to read someone's theology critically.
In the end, however, the Christian life is about trust, and in trusting, you may lose out, but what I am really saying here is that it's all that you have anyway. Hence, make your heart right with God if you want Him to lead you into the everlasting way, and trust Him that He will do so if you seek Him with all of your heart. Your critical thinking skills may fail you, but if you are drawing near to Him, God never will.
Tuesday, January 3, 2012
A Tale of Two Disputers
I've gotten into a lot of arguments with people over the course of my Christian life. I actually don't tend to argue over anything I don't think is important, so my arguments are not a result of my being argumentative. In fact, before I became a Christian, I was very passive among friends and strangers. I argued at home with family, but that was about it. When I became a Christian, I guess you could say my family became larger and so did my responsibilities, but it was really the Spirit of Christ in me that caused me to argue more boldly and actually take a stand, because it caused me to care about other people. It was through caring, ironically, that caused me to argue with people about what was true. I realized that before I became a Christian, I didn't argue with others because I didn't care. Still today, however, I stay out of, or even try to calm, disputes that I think are without merit. However, having been in so many, there is one thing I have learned above all else: not everyone wants to know what is true.
Now, many people would just say that observation is simply my perspective. I'm merely believing that my view is true and whenever anyone doesn't hold my view, it's because he doesn't want to come to the truth. But it's not the truth. It's just my opinion.
Here is why I think this is false. I actually don't often have a problem with someone who very thoughtfully disagrees with me. I just can't stand illogical and inconsistent stances of people who believe what they do and have no clue as to why they believe it. So my issue in arguing is not so much that I think everyone will come to my position (which I obviously want and hope for, as I think it is the truth), but that they would understand and consider what I believe God has declared to be true. Only God can actually bring someone to the truth, however, so there is no point of me getting frustrated when someone does not come to it. What does frustrate me is false argumentation.
Let me explain. There are really two types of arguments, because there are two types of people (and this accords with what I wrote yesterday). There are those who enter arguments to test claims, evaluate the options, are aware of their foundational belief systems that filter everything, and seek to know the truth by choosing which option is best in terms of consistency and logical probability in light of all of the arguments. These people want to argue because they want to know the truth.
But there is the other group of those who enter arguments, and these are perhaps much more numerous than the first, in order to defend what they believe and practice no matter what is really true. They will attempt to undermine truth by appealing to a relativism that is neither logically consistent/viable nor even held by them on other subjects in life. They will attempt to argue from personal experience, which any basic philosophy course, i.e., a basic course in cognitive argumentation or logical analysis will tell you is the weakest form of argumentation, as one can establish anything based on self interpretations of personal experience. And when all else fails, when all of the logic and evidence is against them, when they have not succeeded in undermining the nature of authority and truth itself, they almost always resort to an ad hominem fallacy, i.e., they start to attack you personally. As Steve Hays in a post today recalled a common thought:
This goes hand in hand with my post concerning people who are unteachable. That's what these people are. They are apologists for their positions. They're just bad ones, because real apologists can at least make logical arguments and know why they believe what they believe. These are lay apologists, defending their wayward beliefs at the cost of logic and at the cost of your dignity, as they are not afraid to slander your character, even though that is not the topic at hand, in order to raise themselves back up, as they now, down deep, understand that they have been refuted and humiliated by what has more support in the light of logical argumentation.
Now, many people would just say that observation is simply my perspective. I'm merely believing that my view is true and whenever anyone doesn't hold my view, it's because he doesn't want to come to the truth. But it's not the truth. It's just my opinion.
Here is why I think this is false. I actually don't often have a problem with someone who very thoughtfully disagrees with me. I just can't stand illogical and inconsistent stances of people who believe what they do and have no clue as to why they believe it. So my issue in arguing is not so much that I think everyone will come to my position (which I obviously want and hope for, as I think it is the truth), but that they would understand and consider what I believe God has declared to be true. Only God can actually bring someone to the truth, however, so there is no point of me getting frustrated when someone does not come to it. What does frustrate me is false argumentation.
Let me explain. There are really two types of arguments, because there are two types of people (and this accords with what I wrote yesterday). There are those who enter arguments to test claims, evaluate the options, are aware of their foundational belief systems that filter everything, and seek to know the truth by choosing which option is best in terms of consistency and logical probability in light of all of the arguments. These people want to argue because they want to know the truth.
But there is the other group of those who enter arguments, and these are perhaps much more numerous than the first, in order to defend what they believe and practice no matter what is really true. They will attempt to undermine truth by appealing to a relativism that is neither logically consistent/viable nor even held by them on other subjects in life. They will attempt to argue from personal experience, which any basic philosophy course, i.e., a basic course in cognitive argumentation or logical analysis will tell you is the weakest form of argumentation, as one can establish anything based on self interpretations of personal experience. And when all else fails, when all of the logic and evidence is against them, when they have not succeeded in undermining the nature of authority and truth itself, they almost always resort to an ad hominem fallacy, i.e., they start to attack you personally. As Steve Hays in a post today recalled a common thought:
It’s like the old adage of the crooked lawyer: when you have the facts on your side, argue the facts. When you have the law on your side, argue the law. When you don’t have either one, attack the witness.
This sadly often works, as one must remember the purpose of this person is not to know the truth, but to win the argument in the popular eye. Hence, name-callling, painting the person as arrogant, which is the worst sin in our culture (you can kill babies or sleep around but don't be arrogant about it), say they're being judgmental, as people usually think Jesus commanded everyone to not judge truth claims or warn people of the consequences of their obvious sin. In other words, you have called their beliefs into question. Rather than consider the possibility that their beliefs are wrong by looking deeply at the arguments and the reasons for which they hold those beliefs, they would rather protect those beliefs by attacking you. Because everyone is a sinner, whether guilty of the actual claim they're making against you or not, their accusations are easily believed. The problem is that they have nothing to do with the arguments being made, or the truth or falsity of the positions being held.
Hence, what this person is really doing, to the trained eye, is conceding that they have no basis for believing what they do, and in all actuality, they're wrong. In other words, when you see an attack of the person in an argument that carries no real argument with it, that is a white flag sent up saying, "I surrender. You're completely right, but I hate the truth and don't want to have anything to do with it, and don't like you for making me face it." If they had a real argument, and actually knew why they believed what they believed, they would have presented it, as they really want to win the argument.
This goes hand in hand with my post concerning people who are unteachable. That's what these people are. They are apologists for their positions. They're just bad ones, because real apologists can at least make logical arguments and know why they believe what they believe. These are lay apologists, defending their wayward beliefs at the cost of logic and at the cost of your dignity, as they are not afraid to slander your character, even though that is not the topic at hand, in order to raise themselves back up, as they now, down deep, understand that they have been refuted and humiliated by what has more support in the light of logical argumentation.
Even when people say things like, "That's just your opinion," and "Let's just agree to disagree," or "You think you're so smart," or "You think you're better than everyone else." These are all deflections, red herrings, meant to take everyone off topic, precisely, because the individual knows they have and will lose the argument if they stay on topic. In reality, the person just wants to shut you up, because if you keep talking, they'll have to think about what is being said more, and they don't want to. They want to believe what they want to believe, even at the expense of all things. If they really had a solid reason for believing what they do, however, they would in fact shut you up by refuting you. There would be no need to try and end the argument by attacking you or just getting everyone to stop talking, even though nothing had been resolved (i.e., the truth was not vindicated and God was not exalted). In reality, most of these types of people do want to continue the argument, because they want to feel vindicated. They just don't want to continue it with you involved in the conversation. They'd rather just continue behind your back. It's just easier to win that way.
Others, however, get into arguments because they want to know the truth. They don't mind being humiliated by being wrong. Well, OK, everyone minds, but they are appreciative of it after all is said and done. In fact, they will often thank the person who corrects them. They will, in fact, often become a friend to that person and seek him out when he or she needs some counsel when seeking the truth on other matters.
Do both of these people get into arguments? Yes. Do both of these people argue the same way? No. Because the trajectory of their argumentation follows the reasons for which they are arguing in the first place. They want to be validated in their making truth claims out of false assertions, but they don't want that examined. They want their listeners to just affirm it. In essence, this type of person doesn't really want friends, he or she just wants fans, i.e., drinking buddies but not thinking buddies, as thinking buddies challenge and question in order to come to the truth. Drinking buddies just want someone to hang out with while they booze themselves up, so they'll just try to get you to stay longer by telling you whatever you want to hear.
It would be great if all of those who just want to believe whatever they wish kept quiet and didn't try to evangelize everyone with the gospel of self, but that is not the nature of self worshiping argumentation. This person wants to exalt their ideas over others. They just don't want reciprocation, and they certainly don't want to have those ideas scrutinized, for that would ruin the lives they're building out of them. So, unfortunately, the war between those who like to enter substantial arguments in order to learn what is true and those who enter them in order to justify what they already believe is true, regardless of whether it can be easily refuted, will rage on. But wisdom is not only vindicated by all of her children, but whenever a person is slandered in place of an argument refuted, as one's intended use of argumentation is revealed therein.
Monday, January 2, 2012
A Tale of Two Sinners
Imagine a slanted field of snow, where the snow has drifted largely down toward the bottom of the field. The further one moves up the field, the less snow he or she encounters on the ground. The top of the field has no snow on it at all.
Now, imagine two children, each with equal sized snowballs of their own making. One snowball is not smaller or larger than the other. However, as one child moves further down the field, his snowball gets larger and larger. He himself is eventually engulfed in the snow. The other child, moving in the opposite direction up the field, accumulates less snow, and in fact, begins to lose some snow off of his snowball as it sticks to the barren ground. Eventually, his snowball is reduced to nothing when he arrives at the top of the field.
This illustration is one where we see that both individuals are equal in terms of the size of their snowballs, but not the same in terms of their movement, which in turn will determine the destiny of their creations. One is working toward the building of his snowball and to be engulfed in it, and the other is working to decrease his snowball and eventually rid himself of it altogether.
Now, let's pursue a common religious myth we hear echoed throughout our culture: "We're all sinners. We all make mistakes. Nobody's perfect." All of these statements are true in and of themselves, that is, if we take only what is explicitly said outside of the context that implies something quite different from the truth. When understood in the context of self-rationalization and justification of sin, they are false statements, precisely, because they mean to assert the claim that all sinners are both equal in terms of the amount of sin they have and are therefore going in the same direction. In other words, we may all be sinners, but we are not all the same kinds of sinners. In fact, there are two kinds of sinners.
One sinner is moving further into sin. He seeks to justify why it's not really a sin for him personally or why it's not a sin at all. He seeks to justify that even if it is a sin, everyone else is also a sinner, and so there is no reason he should seek to rid himself of it. He is moving downhill, accumulating for himself more reasons why he is justified in his decisions to live in sin. He is entrenching himself by saying he is no different than everyone else, and will eventually be completely engulfed by his sin once he reaches his final destination.
The other sinner doesn't want to be a sinner. He wants to decrease it in his life. In fact, he wants to rid himself of it. His sin, in terms of the grossness and the amount of it, does not seem to be any lesser than any other sinner's; yet, when he sins, he seeks forgiveness through repentance. This man's trajectory is set toward God and he uses even the occasions where he sins to pursue a relationship with God. Hence, as he does so, his sin lessens, and eventually is wiped away completely when he reaches his final destination.
You see, there are sinners and there are sinners. One sinner is an unrepentant sinner. He wants his sin. It gives him comfort. It gives him purpose. It gives him pleasure. He doesn't want to rid himself of it, so he uses the excuse that everyone else is a sinner too in order to protect that which he does not wish to lose out on in his life. The other sinner is a repentant sinner. He hates his sin. He realizes it is slavery and he is always seeking to be free of it by pursuing the presence of Christ, even when he fails. When he is dirty, he seeks to become clean. He does not use the fact that others are sinners as an excuse for his own sin. Instead, though the whole world were to be permitted by God to be entrenched in sin, he wishes to be rid of it anyway. For the repentant sinner, the goal is to love God by seeking to become what God has granted him in Christ Jesus. For the unrepentant sinner, however, his goal is to run away from what he could be in Christ, because he knows that in pursuing Christ, he would lose the sin that gives him the life that he loves.
So we are all sinners. We all make mistakes (although mistakes and sins are two completely different things). Nobody is perfect, save God alone. But we are not all the same kinds of sinners. Saved sinners long to be saved from sin completely. Unsaved sinners long to be rid of the voice that calls them to repent, but they wish to keep their sin. This is especially true when we begin to understand that sin is doing what we want to do in contrast to what God wants us to do in any given situation. The unsaved sinner doesn't even want God to define sin this way, as it doesn't allow him to excuse himself by viewing sin as any evil act that is much worse than anything he might do.
We may both be sinners. We may both be on the same path of life. But some are going one way on that path, moving further and further away from a self-worshiping life and others are moving more and more into it. As such, all are sinners, but not all sinners are the same.
For the Christian, God has predestined us from before the foundation of the world to become holy and blameless, and it is in pursuing this vision God has for us that we prove our sinful lives to be moving in a different direction than those who wish to bury themselves in their own vices. As Ephesians 1:6 says, we desire this because of what God has done for us in predestining us for this purpose "to the praise of His glory." This is God's work, lest we ever come to think that although we are sinners, we are better sinners than others because of something within us. It is God drawing us ever to Himself that calls us up the hill, to turn away from moving down the field and begin to move up it toward Him.
Our sins are just as black as the sins of others, but the movement of our lives works against them. They become the vehicles through which we remember our hopelessness without Christ, as we call out for Him in their torment of us; and thus, even our sins become the catalyst for our sanctification from them. But it is not so for the unrepentant sinner whose Christless life is geared toward self. He drinks up sin like water, never seeking to purge it from himself.
Hence, all of humanity is in sin, but true humanity and false humanity are not going in the same direction with their sin, one toward life and one toward death. As such, we should be looking more at the direction we are moving than at the equal size of our snowballs.
But evil men and impostors will proceed [from bad] to worse , deceiving and being deceived. You, however, continue in the things you have learned and become convinced of, knowing from whom you have learned [them], and that from childhood you have known the sacred Scriptures which are able to give you the wisdom that leads to salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus. (2 Tim 3:13-15)
Therefore, since we have so great a cloud of witnesses surrounding us, let us also lay aside every encumbrance and the sin which so easily entangles us, and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us, fixing our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of faith, who for the joy set before Him endured the cross, despising the shame, and has sat down at the right hand of the throne of God. (Heb 12:1-2)
If we say that we have fellowship with Him and [yet] walk in the darkness, we lie and do not practice the truth; but if we walk in the Light as He Himself is in the Light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus His Son cleanses us from all sin. If we say that we have no sin , we are deceiving ourselves and the truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, He is faithful and righteous to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. If we say that we have not sinned, we make Him a liar and His word is not in us. (1 John 1:6-10).
Now, imagine two children, each with equal sized snowballs of their own making. One snowball is not smaller or larger than the other. However, as one child moves further down the field, his snowball gets larger and larger. He himself is eventually engulfed in the snow. The other child, moving in the opposite direction up the field, accumulates less snow, and in fact, begins to lose some snow off of his snowball as it sticks to the barren ground. Eventually, his snowball is reduced to nothing when he arrives at the top of the field.
This illustration is one where we see that both individuals are equal in terms of the size of their snowballs, but not the same in terms of their movement, which in turn will determine the destiny of their creations. One is working toward the building of his snowball and to be engulfed in it, and the other is working to decrease his snowball and eventually rid himself of it altogether.
Now, let's pursue a common religious myth we hear echoed throughout our culture: "We're all sinners. We all make mistakes. Nobody's perfect." All of these statements are true in and of themselves, that is, if we take only what is explicitly said outside of the context that implies something quite different from the truth. When understood in the context of self-rationalization and justification of sin, they are false statements, precisely, because they mean to assert the claim that all sinners are both equal in terms of the amount of sin they have and are therefore going in the same direction. In other words, we may all be sinners, but we are not all the same kinds of sinners. In fact, there are two kinds of sinners.
One sinner is moving further into sin. He seeks to justify why it's not really a sin for him personally or why it's not a sin at all. He seeks to justify that even if it is a sin, everyone else is also a sinner, and so there is no reason he should seek to rid himself of it. He is moving downhill, accumulating for himself more reasons why he is justified in his decisions to live in sin. He is entrenching himself by saying he is no different than everyone else, and will eventually be completely engulfed by his sin once he reaches his final destination.
The other sinner doesn't want to be a sinner. He wants to decrease it in his life. In fact, he wants to rid himself of it. His sin, in terms of the grossness and the amount of it, does not seem to be any lesser than any other sinner's; yet, when he sins, he seeks forgiveness through repentance. This man's trajectory is set toward God and he uses even the occasions where he sins to pursue a relationship with God. Hence, as he does so, his sin lessens, and eventually is wiped away completely when he reaches his final destination.
You see, there are sinners and there are sinners. One sinner is an unrepentant sinner. He wants his sin. It gives him comfort. It gives him purpose. It gives him pleasure. He doesn't want to rid himself of it, so he uses the excuse that everyone else is a sinner too in order to protect that which he does not wish to lose out on in his life. The other sinner is a repentant sinner. He hates his sin. He realizes it is slavery and he is always seeking to be free of it by pursuing the presence of Christ, even when he fails. When he is dirty, he seeks to become clean. He does not use the fact that others are sinners as an excuse for his own sin. Instead, though the whole world were to be permitted by God to be entrenched in sin, he wishes to be rid of it anyway. For the repentant sinner, the goal is to love God by seeking to become what God has granted him in Christ Jesus. For the unrepentant sinner, however, his goal is to run away from what he could be in Christ, because he knows that in pursuing Christ, he would lose the sin that gives him the life that he loves.
So we are all sinners. We all make mistakes (although mistakes and sins are two completely different things). Nobody is perfect, save God alone. But we are not all the same kinds of sinners. Saved sinners long to be saved from sin completely. Unsaved sinners long to be rid of the voice that calls them to repent, but they wish to keep their sin. This is especially true when we begin to understand that sin is doing what we want to do in contrast to what God wants us to do in any given situation. The unsaved sinner doesn't even want God to define sin this way, as it doesn't allow him to excuse himself by viewing sin as any evil act that is much worse than anything he might do.
We may both be sinners. We may both be on the same path of life. But some are going one way on that path, moving further and further away from a self-worshiping life and others are moving more and more into it. As such, all are sinners, but not all sinners are the same.
For the Christian, God has predestined us from before the foundation of the world to become holy and blameless, and it is in pursuing this vision God has for us that we prove our sinful lives to be moving in a different direction than those who wish to bury themselves in their own vices. As Ephesians 1:6 says, we desire this because of what God has done for us in predestining us for this purpose "to the praise of His glory." This is God's work, lest we ever come to think that although we are sinners, we are better sinners than others because of something within us. It is God drawing us ever to Himself that calls us up the hill, to turn away from moving down the field and begin to move up it toward Him.
Our sins are just as black as the sins of others, but the movement of our lives works against them. They become the vehicles through which we remember our hopelessness without Christ, as we call out for Him in their torment of us; and thus, even our sins become the catalyst for our sanctification from them. But it is not so for the unrepentant sinner whose Christless life is geared toward self. He drinks up sin like water, never seeking to purge it from himself.
Hence, all of humanity is in sin, but true humanity and false humanity are not going in the same direction with their sin, one toward life and one toward death. As such, we should be looking more at the direction we are moving than at the equal size of our snowballs.
But evil men and impostors will proceed [from bad] to worse , deceiving and being deceived. You, however, continue in the things you have learned and become convinced of, knowing from whom you have learned [them], and that from childhood you have known the sacred Scriptures which are able to give you the wisdom that leads to salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus. (2 Tim 3:13-15)
Therefore, since we have so great a cloud of witnesses surrounding us, let us also lay aside every encumbrance and the sin which so easily entangles us, and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us, fixing our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of faith, who for the joy set before Him endured the cross, despising the shame, and has sat down at the right hand of the throne of God. (Heb 12:1-2)
If we say that we have fellowship with Him and [yet] walk in the darkness, we lie and do not practice the truth; but if we walk in the Light as He Himself is in the Light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus His Son cleanses us from all sin. If we say that we have no sin , we are deceiving ourselves and the truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, He is faithful and righteous to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. If we say that we have not sinned, we make Him a liar and His word is not in us. (1 John 1:6-10).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)