Wednesday, December 21, 2011

What It Means to be a Worshiper of Satan

When I was younger, "Satan worship" was a big thing I heard about at church. It was exalted in a lot of Heavy Metal songs, where the artists would pledge their allegiance to the devil or to the beast, etc. They, with mighty towers of hair and pounds of mascara, made their oaths to the devil in song and symbol. Of course, teenagers being the towers of individuality as they are occasionally tried to mimic this in real life by participating in occultic rituals, or at the very least, tattooing occultic symbols on themselves with that "permanent" tattoo ink from what others call a ball point pen. Satan worship, or following Satan, became faddish, of course, for only the most embittered and rebellious. The rest of us went to church and believed in God, so we were free and clear, right?

As I grew older and began to read the Bible more, I realized that this was a complete and utter distortion of what it means to worship the devil. In fact, the characterization above served only as a red-herring so that humanity might lose the scent in mid trail, and come to the conclusion, once again, that they are essentially good people who believe in God. They are certainly not devil worshipers, especially those who go to church and believe that the gospel is true.

The reason why such imagery of a hooded cult, surrounded by candles, pentagrams, and if they were really ambitious enough to secure it, a goat's head, was a distorted depiction of what it means to follow Satan is because it's almost too stupid for anyone to follow it. After all, why follow the devil in such a manner if the payout is not as good? Are you really going to give up yourself for a lesser god? We are rebellious creatures by nature. We don't want any lords. We want to be lord. We want to rule ourselves, and we want no one else making demands upon us. So with this base attitude, it really doesn't make much sense for the devil to set up such an elaborate scheme in duping mankind with such an obvious absurdity.

However, it does make sense to use our base rebellion to want to be our own gods as a means to follow him, and that is in fact the religion of the devil. That is in fact Satan worship.

You see, worship has to do with submitting one's life to a certain path. It has to do with emulation. Notice how Paul says, "Be imitators of God" in the midst of his exhortation of telling us to worship God now that we have been saved by Him through Christ. Imitation is worship, because it displays that we have come to believe that the greatest path is the one we should take, and of course, the greatest path is traveled by the greatest beings, or greatest being. That's all the devil really wants. After all, imitation is the most sincere form of flattery.

He doesn't want your prayers. He just wants you to cease praying and rely upon yourself. He doesn't want your virgin sacrifices. He just wants your virginity and for you to use your sexuality as you so desire. He doesn't want candles, unless they make you feel good. In fact, the "Satanic Bible" isn't really about Satan at all. It's about secular humanism. It's about hedonism. It's about self worship and self pursuit. Anton LaVey didn't even believe in a personal devil. His whole point was that real Satanism is self-worship, not the worship of some other being.

But this is precisely what devil worship is in the Bible as well. No one in Scripture actually worships the devil directly. They worship him by worshiping themselves, by exalting themselves. Even pagan cults existed to secure something for the self. The individual just honored the deity in order to get a better life, a woman he loved, a child he wanted, money, a victory in war, etc. Devil worship has never been about goats' heads, but about following the devil's pattern of life in the world that he wants, the world that he created with the words, "Ye shall be as gods, masters of good and evil." This is accomplished if one just does what he wants and eats of whatever fruit he desires in the moment while disregarding the path set before him by God.

If you look at Christ's temptations, the devil actually tries to get Christ to take what already belongs to Christ, but to do it outside of the will of the Father. He tries to get Him to do what He wishes and to exalt Himself apart from the path the Father has laid out. His attempt to get Him to worship him is through his attempt to get Him to do what He desires: to show Himself to be and be known as the Lord of power and prosperity, the Lord who rules the world. But Christ came to do the Father's will instead, and so off to crucifixion He goes. In this way, the devil wants Christ to bow down to him (as one who loves to be exalted) to show that devil worship is really all about listening to the continual plea of Satan that you should do whatever you see fit in disregard for any obedience toward what God has said (unless what makes you happy sometimes accords with what God wants as well).

My point to you is this: that you may think that you're a pretty good person and that you could never be considered a devil worshiper. You go to church. You believe the gospel is true. But so did we, as we heard about Satanic cults and the wicked who participated in them when I was young, and yet, according to the Bible, we were indulging in true Satanism by disregarding the Word of God that laid out our path, eating the fruit set before us without care, and mimicking the same self-serving spirit evidenced in Satan's rebellion toward God.

In fact, when you see demons in Scripture, they who follow the devil's path, they are seeking to indulge in the pleasure of an individual's body or to be honored and worshiped as gods. The Scripture itself tells us that the gods of other religions are actually demons and not gods at all (and certainly not different manifestations of the One true God either). This is because they want to be exalted as the devil exalts himself. They do not worship the devil in some lair, as is often depicted. They simply follow him through emulation of self-direction and self-exaltation. The honor themselves above God. They honor themselves above others. And we, if we are not careful to pay attention to every word that proceeds from the mouth of God, will do the same. We are self worshipers, not part of us, but the whole of fallen humanity, because our original parents were self-worshipers, and that is precisely what devil worship is.

So we can no longer look at "those" really twisted people who hang up the goat's head and say we are not devil worshipers because we go to church or believe the gospel. On the contrary, the church is filled full of devil worshipers. It makes people feel good to believe in God. It makes them feel good to feel that they are good. And to them, commitment to some religious belief, ritual, or group makes them good. But true worship is that which listens to what God says, does not let anyone confuse it, and seeks to imitate Him in His righteousness. This is why loving God is to obey His commandments. This is why to worship, "to bow down to," God means we believe and live in accordance to what He has said as opposed to exalting our own ideas and opinions about life over what He has said. There are simply too many Satanists in and outside the church for us to pretend that devil worship is a thing of the past or relegated to a small quirky group of adolescents.

The worst of all of this is that this has implications for our destination. The Scripture says that hell itself was made for the devil and his angels, and we are told then that humans, who follow his path, are also being reserved for such a punishment. In fact, in Matthew 25:41, Christ is sending tons of churchgoers into the hell prepared for the devil and his angels, precisely, because they don't emulate Him by doing good to others in their worship of God. So this, one of the harshest and most frightening parts of Scripture, is just referring to people who actually believe the gospel is true. They just use it as a part of their self-serving religion to the exclusion of doing good to others with it.

What this means is far worse than we might first think, as I've written before on this blog about how all religions, except genuine Christianity, are religions of self-worship. But if this is true, then all religions are religions of devil worship, which in turn means that everything that is not done within genuine Christianity is, in fact, devil worship. Satanism is simply another name for the united self-seeking religion of the world, and hell awaits all of the followers of that religion, the whole world.

So now we can see the good news is truly good. Christ alone has come to save us from the devil by saving us from ourselves. He has not come to make you feel good in your Satanism. He has not come to affirm you in your devil worship. He has come to set you free from a life of self-direction, a life that leads to hell and away from the source of true life, which is God Himself. The devil wants us to follow him in emulation, because he's not only honored by it, but he knows, as the agent of chaos, that such a practice will lead to our own destruction. He knows we cannot save ourselves, and that we are no masters of good and evil. We will be overcome, as we were never made to be self-sustaining gods. But Christ has set us free from him. He has come to destroy the works that the devil has wrought in us. He has come to destroy the religion of the devil, and as such, He has come to destroy all of our religions, and to establish His Kingdom, His Lordship, over us instead, because that Kingdom is an eternal one that is sustained by the power of God and is able to deliver us from all evil. He is our Savior from hell, precisely, because He is our Savior from our false religion of self.

This is the reason why the devil doesn't explicitly show up in the Bible all over the place. He's only mentioned here and there. That's because his religion is everywhere in the one religion of self-worship that takes upon itself many expressions. But the religion of Christ spoils the plans of the devil. It ruins his world, as it has been declared that, regardless of the self-exaltation he wrought in us, "every knee shall bow, every tongue shall confess that Jesus Christ is Lord to the glory of God the Father." The question is whether you will be confessing as one who has taken away his allegiance from himself and has given it to Christ or as one of the followers of the devil who has been conquered by Him. I pray you take time today to think about and make sure you are of the former rather than the latter.

[I thought I would add this scene from a children's book I wrote. Don't worry I won't be publishing it and inflicting children with the cruelty of such tortured poetry, but it makes the point I'm trying to convey here. This is meant to be the fall of man from the viewpoint of the animals in the garden. Again, ignore the bad poetry and just think about what is being said]


Whither did the tree which called everlasting its child.
Gone were the gardeners that kept weeds from running wild.
Perched were the many birds of prey,
For the king of order had died that day.

“What shall we do?” said Deer all afraid.
“What will become of our evergreen glade?”
We are left without a guardian who will keep us from the harm
Of Leviathan’s poisonous, villainous charm.

Then monkey howled in with frightful alarm,
“He will tell all to trust in their very right arm.
He will come with his voice so soothing of sound.
He will come with the promise of scepter and crown.
He will tell us to trust in our hearts to perceive.
He will not tell us the truth, but seek to deceive
But truth is known only to those who believe.”

And as the animals gathered and wept,
In came every creeping thing that crept;
And darkness fell upon every eye that could see,
When the birds of prey perched high on the tree.

“What are they here for?” said Squirrel passing by.
“They are followers of the serpent,” said Owl in reply.
“He is well organized then,” said Squirrel, “with army in hand.
“They must serve him in sky over water and land.
He must love for them to worship him as a god in this place.
He must love all those who seek to acknowledge his face.”

“No,” said Owl, “that is not how it sways,
For the serpent does not seek to deceive in such ways.
He does not draw the host in that way to him,
But devises a more clever, idolatrous sin.
He converts the living to the dead
By telling everyone to worship themselves instead.

He tells them to follow their hearts and they’ll know
The right from the wrong to reap and to sow,
To ignore God’s instructive commands,
To follow their own self seeking demands.

He converts, therefore, a soul from life to death.
He places hot air in the stead of God’s breath.
He convinces the creature in himself to trust,
And returns the foolish fellow right back into dust.

The birds of prey, then, follow only his lead
They do what he does and indulge as they feed
They fly where they wish and for themselves alone
They soar and feel free in the world they are shown
Like the serpent who always lives for the day
So also are his followers, the birds of prey.

“So they follow the serpent by following themselves,”
Said Rabbit to Squirrel sitting under the shelves
Of shade that still remained from the trees of bone.
“They do his will because it is their own
And in this way each becomes his self-worshiping drone.

For his will is for all to become like him,
To eat from the tree of his own wisdom,
To ignore the words spoken from on High,
To live for the moment, for tomorrow we die.”

Tuesday, December 20, 2011

The Life and Death of Christ in True Ministry

I remember having conversations in seminary with people who were going to become pastors. Their idea of the pastorate was one with which I was well familiar. It was an easier job, a job that required only some study and sermon preparation, along with the occasional bit of counseling. Beyond that, it was filled with golf, relaxation, and prestige. Indeed, there are many pastors who have worked hard to mold their ministries in this image. Such a pastor usually is in great health and well kept, since his life is that of a star; but this is not the nature of genuine ministry.

Genuine ministry is an incarnation of Christ. One of the many metaphors used to describe the church is "the body of Christ." Those who work hard at preaching and teaching will themselves embody Christ's ministry on earth, but that ministry isn't one filled with lemonade and golf balls, but of sweat, blood, and death.

What the minister of a real ministry soon realizes is that the ministry is the worst job on earth. It will consume your time, your energy, your health, and your dignity. In essence, it will lead you down the same path that Christ upon the earth must always go down in a fallen world: to crucifixion.

If the call of Christ to every believer is to come and die, His call to every preacher is to come show everyone what I mean when I say "die." First, you must die to your pursuit of an easier life, that life that everyone in our culture seeks by looking for easier ways to do this or that, die to making money in order to make finances easier, die to the life of leisure you dreamed of. Then, you must die to the idea that you will have honor in this life, the respect that every man desires to have. You simply cannot give such foreign truths that demand obedience and love from its subjects to hearts that are, in part or in whole, rebellious toward God, and expect that you will be honored for it. You must die to the idea that your time is your own. It will no longer belong to you but to God and to others. If it's a matter between helping a person in need and golfing, someone else will be teeing off that day. In essence, you must die to the life you wanted, because Christ died to the life He could have had as well.

In fact, it reminds me of the film, "The Last Temptation of Christ." I remember that when this film came out it was covered in a blanket of controversy, and for that reason, I stayed away from it, that is, until one day I was challenged to watch it. I decided, however, because of some of the images I heard were in it, just to watch parts of it, but especially made a point to watch the end. I was deeply moved by the film more than any other film about Christ I had ever seen, simply because I got the point it was trying to make.

You see, the film shows Christ indulging in all sorts of pleasures in life. He becomes rich, prestigious, and fulfills the desires of His humanity even in romance. He essentially has every pleasure and desire He could think of. Then, in the end of the film, the world we have just witnessed, the world where Christ indulges in the life everyone would dream of, slowly slips away as the camera pans out from that world. Moving further and further out, we see an eye, and then a face, and then Christ Himself hanging on the cross. And then we realize that the world we have just witnessed in the movie was the last temptation of Christ. It was the devil saying, "You can have all of this, all that you desire. This pain can end. This shame can end. You deserve a better life than this. Just come down and it will be done. Why die when you can live?" And yet, He who with one word can come down and take over all of the armies of the earth, stays there. He who with one word can end all of His suffering and take all of the pleasures of the world to which He alone is due remains to die. And He stays there for one reason only: love. His love to glorify the Father and save us from the coming wrath. The last temptation was his call to disregard love, as Adam had disregarded it, and to indulge in pleasure instead, but He would not be eating that fruit today. He would be dying instead.

And this is what we are to do in ministry. We are to die. We don't tell people truths we know they will pat us on the back for at the end of the sermon. We won't be liked by everyone. Was Christ liked by everyone, or did you fail to notice that He was crucified by His own people? We will be loved by some and hated by others. We will be polarizing figures, as Christ was, not because we love division, but because we love unity in the truth that glorifies God and binds His people together. Christ caused division, and indeed, He says that this is the very reason He came. Hence, it is the very reason He remains through us in the body of Christ. Division is the nature of His ministry through us.

Such division leads to turmoil, not peace. The ministry isn't a picture of Christ sitting by the quiet streams on a warm, inviting summer day, but Christ standing on a violent sea in the midst of a hurricane calling out to His disciples. The ministry is not about winning people. It's about winning souls, and we must understand the difference between the two if we are to participate in a genuine ministry that exalts the word of Christ over the storm and those who wish to serve it rather than Christ.

Ministry will upset your life, not establish it. It will cost you everything you are and everything you hoped to be. Still want to sign up? If you are looking for ease and prestige, probably not. If you are looking to exalt God in love for Him and His people, then I know you'll still sign on the bottom line. That's because real ministry is only for real Christians. It's not for the "religion is my backup" crowd. It exists to call everyone to come and die, and as such, those who enter it must display that death in their delivery of the truth and the sacrifice of the lives they had always wanted.

Ministry after all is ministry, i.e., service, and through it we give our lives over to our Master to do what He will with them. I'm not saying you won't have time for golf balls in ministry, but only that you may have quite a few thrown at you as well. It will be the most stressful job you'll always want to leave and never will, as long as you're there for the right reasons. Someone once said that around 50-60% of those who enter ministry leave it each year. I don't know how accurate that is, but if so many enter it with false hopes, I can see that happening. To be sure, a big part of that deception is what it "looks like" from the outside. The average parishioner has no clue the weight that is placed upon the shoulders of the minister, and as such, they get the sense that it's an easy job--and if you're there to tickle the ears of people, it is. If you're there to glorify Christ by not only lifting Him up in word, but by being lifted up upon the cross yourself in both word and deed, then it's the hardest job on earth. What other job description do you know of that requires you to definitely die to everything you hoped to be (and to perhaps literally die) without even receiving the honor one might think would accompany such a noble commitment?

If ministry is Christ preaching through us, then it will be surrounded by some disciples with a whole lot of Pharisees, Sadducees, scribes, mockers, and even a Judas or two. This isn't abnormal. If you're getting this, this is what you signed up for. You wanted the ministry of Christ and so here it is. Did you think it would all be people gazing at you in awe, receiving your every word, baking you cupcakes?

I'm essentially trying to keep you from becoming bitter, because the soil in which bitterness takes root is false hope that stems from misunderstanding what was promised to you. You have been promised a life of picking up your cross, suffering, and dying, because it is only through such a life that the gospel can be preached both in word and deed. The life of Christ is lived out through your ministry, and that life did not end with parties and the good life. It was on the other side of death that such life exists. It is through dying that we are reborn into the images of God we were always meant to be, and the minister must display this as an example more than anyone else. Thus, he must suffer more than anyone else.

What I wish to tell every young seminarian is that, although many Christians die in persecutions, the main people who are consistently executed throughout are the ministers. The unbelieving government always wants to make examples of them in one way, and so does God in another. I want to tell them this because it serves as a great example of what ministry is really all about.

So the next time you're thinking of not saying what you need to say, or feeling as though you've given enough already, or even find yourself becoming bitter because you think the people around you should have responded more positively toward your sacrifice for them, simply remember that such is not why you're in ministry. You're there to die, and that is exactly what's supposed to happen. So you might as well post a sign above your office door, "Entering Golgotha. Leave golf balls at the door."

Monday, December 19, 2011

To Grow or Not to Grow, PART II: Why Hair Length Is One of the Essentials of the Faith

You might be pretty shocked by that title, or just quickly pass up reading this because of how crazy it sounds, but I do have a point to be made here.

Last time we looked at Paul's use of the priority argument in First Corinthians 11:2-16. Paul actually has four authoritative arguments for why men and women should display distinctions in gender through their hair length, but I only mainly looked at the one, because it is his argument for the universality of what he is saying. The other three arguments are arguments from tradition handed down, the lex naturalis (or what is observed by our natural responses and feelings toward the issue when cultural confusions are not brought in), and what is practiced by the church everywhere. The following are just some thoughts on what this passage says and how we should consider it as something that is more important than we have in the past.

Now, undoubtedly, if you've grown up in the evangelical church as I have you know that there are a group of doctrines considered "the essentials." What people usually mean by this is that there are doctrines in Christianity that one must believe when they are presented to him in order to remain in the Christian faith and evidence his salvation. As I discussed yesterday, orthodoxy (as well as orthopraxis) is evidence of one's claim to have Christ as Lord. His sheep will hear His voice and follow Him, not another. Hence, if one is His sheep, he will espouse what Christ has taught, i.e., he will affirm the orthodox gospel and all that supports it. If he denies it, he evidences rebellion against Christ, and his claim that "Jesus Christ is Lord" is forfeit.

Now, what in the world does that have to do with how long you grow your hair? Here's my point. If hearing Christ's voice and following is evidence of our submissive spirit to Christ, i.e., it evidences that we have truly made Him Lord of our lives, and the Spirit of Christ communicates that He wants us to maintain a certain length of hair for the purposes of gender distinction, will not our willingness to listen and follow (if we so come to the conclusion that this is what Christ is saying) or lack of willingness to hear and follow evidence the truth or falsity of our claim to have Christ as Lord? What I'm saying is that what is essential is any issue put before you that you would not normally believe or practice, likely due to cultural conditioning, but are being called upon to believe or practice by the Word of God in response to your claim that "Jesus Christ is Lord/Master." In other words, the only essential is really that you are in submission to Christ as Lord. It is through His Lordship that we are saved. Hence, the only essential for salvation is repenting and believing Christ, but this makes everything He teaches a potential essential, as our claim can be confirmed or denied by whether we evidence a submissive or rebellious attitude toward Him.

The reason why I say this now is not because I think Christianity is going to rise or fall apart based upon whether you cut your hair or let it grow out, but because the issue of our appearance is usually ignored or rejected once presented by people who clearly cannot even stomach to listen to the possibility that Christ may be commanding him or her to maintain a certain appearance for the purposes of gender distinction (which is really just Christ maintaining His creation, as gender distinction is a part of creation toward a human filled world [Gen 2:18-24] against a chaotic one that cannot produce or prosper humanity).

Instead, it seems to these people that cutting or growing out their hair is possibly the worst thing that Christ could ever ask of them. Of course, they are still willing to give their bodies to be torn apart by wild beasts, dying an unthinkable death in the arena, as lions eat them alive; but to be willing to cut one's hair or grow it out? What is God crazy? Doesn't He know that all the ladies love long hair on boys? Doesn't He know that it takes girls an extra thirty minutes to wash and dry long hair? Throw me on the racks, O God, but do not Thou requirest my hair to be cut or grown long, as that is a fate worse than death.

Can you imagine Shadrach, Meshach, and Abed-nego in front of Nebuchadnezzar, as Nebuchadnezzar tells them that he will not burn them alive in one of the most painful forms of death a man can experience if they do not bow to the idol, but he will make them cut their hair? They then respond, "Surely, we were willing to die today, but you have upped the ante, O King, we will worship your idol, as what God would ask of us is just too much to bear."
Can you imagine God no longer commanding Mary to be the vessel through which the Savior would be born into the world by being disgraced in a premarital pregnancy, but instead asking her to grow her hair long instead, and having Mary respond by saying, "My Soul would rejoice in God My Savior if He had asked me to do something grand, but my hair is so much more manageable when its shorter, so not this time"?

The people are fooling themselves if they claim to have Christ as Lord and are unwilling to even consider the possibility that He might require them to look more masculine or feminine in accordance with their gender. I'm not even talking about adopting the interpretation I've given the passage either. I'm talking about even seriously considering whether they ought to do this or that, as opposed to blowing it off because one is so offended or afraid that God may actually require something more of them than going to church on Sunday.

My wife always makes a great point about these issues, and I hope you'll listen to her wisdom here. People always talk about how they are willing to go to the jungles of Africa for Christ, how they are willing to die for Christ, how they want to live for Christ, but are unwilling to do even the smallest things for Christ that are right in front of them, because all of those claims that supposedly express their desire to live for Christ are hypothetical. They know that, since they won't be going to the jungles of Africa, or being put in the fire anytime soon, and that living for Christ is such a generic declaration of a hypothetical future, there is no need to be afraid of their claims because they'll never have to back them up. They're empty declarations. But put something in front of them, even if ever so small, that would require of them sacrifice for Christ, and it is immediately rejected.

These things that we consider ever so small are evidences to our claim far more than dying or becoming a missionary in the jungles because these things are in front of us and challenge our immediate claim to have accepted Christ as Lord. The other hypotheticals aren't a challenge to the claim because they are no threat to us, as we know that we're not going to do them or be required to really do them (at least not in the immediate future). Hence, one's love for Christ and desire to have Him reign as Lord cannot be expressed by these empty declarations, but by the submission to whatever He presents before us in the moment. Think of all of the little things God asked of the disciples and prophets (like to go get food, or sit on a wall, or go to this geographical location or that one). Do we really believe that anyone receiving these little commands could just refuse to obey God all the while proclaiming his submission to His Lordship? Lord means master. We are His servants. We obey because we love Him more than we love ourselves. That's the foundation of the true claim that one has Christ as Lord, and that's the claim that will evidence itself in how we receive the little things placed before us. But rest assured, you can fancy yourself a martyr, but if you are unwilling to even let Christ speak His Word to you in the little things, then your fantasy that your "all in" for Christ is just that.

Now, having said that, I think some people who ignore this passage may not do so because they are outwardly rebellious, but because they have been duped to believe the false idea that God doesn't really care about appearance, but only your heart (i.e., what's on the inside). Many people pick this up from God's statement to Samuel about the criteria He looks for in a king: "for God sees not as a man sees. Man looks at the outward appearance but God looks at the heart" (1 Sam 16:7)  But does this teach that God doesn't care about how one looks at all or is it teaching, in context, that God isn't fooled by the outward stature of a man, but can see his inward person directly? In other words, is God hereby releasing everyone from being modest or dressing according to their gender, or is He merely telling Samuel not to be fooled by appearances, which is a different issue altogether? I think it's clear that it's the latter.

In any case, the idea that God looks to the heart and does not care about the appearance, of course, is a false dichotomy, as God cares about what's in your heart as it is evidenced by what you say, do, and look like in terms of sexuality. For instance, we know that God wants women to be modestly dressed, so that He actually does care about what you wear. In fact, if immodest dress provides opportunity for crudeness among one's own sex or temptation toward the opposite sex, then He more than just slightly cares about the issue (see, e.g., Mark 9:42), as it displays hatred for others rather than love (again, the heart evidenced by what is worn). We also know that in the Old Testament God wanted His Nazirites to have long hair in order to display their submission to Him in a special covenant He made with them (i.e., they were like the "wives" of God who were married to Him and were especially dedicated to Him). Thus, that is an instance where if a male wanted short hair instead, he would be in rebellion against God for it. But here in First Corinthians, we are told that God desires gender distinction to be displayed by a man's short hair and by a woman's long hair, so the issue before us, the issue that will display our submission or rebellion, is the issue of short hair for men or long hair for women and how we respond to that suggestion.

Are we offended? Do we scoff? Do we roll the eyes? Do we act as though it's such a trivial thing that God surely wouldn't care about it, and thus, excuse ourselves through that means? Surely, we can all be offended that God would require something we deem as trivial, as did the Syrian general with a skin disease who was told to dip himself in the Jordan river seven times, or we can just listen and obey and be healed, because we trust in God and know that even the trivial things He sets before us are better understood by Him than by us. We can all say there is a practical reason for our disobedience, but look what Paul says in the midst of all our excuses: long hair is a shame to a man and long hair is something that makes the woman beautiful. Is that practical enough. I mean, we all know that men don't want respect, so I'm sure that's why they don't want to have short hair. And we certainly know that women don't want to be beautiful, as we can just look at how the beauty industry makes very little money each year, so I'm sure that's why they want short hair. I'm sure hairstyles have nothing to do with cultural philosophies of gender and everything about wanting to look less attractive.

Of course, you may argue with the Bible in your rebellion and say that you like longer hair on men and shorter hair on women, but the text isn’t about your personal preferences. In fact, I don’t even think that reality exists this way, as Paul himself will appeal to the reality of our built in preferences and say that a woman with short hair loses beauty. And I think we respond to the opposite sex in terms of how feminine or masculine one looks, and that is, in fact, tied somewhat to hair length. I think this is what the Spirit of Christ means by saying that it is a shame for a woman to have short hair (1 Cor 11:6). I’m not saying you’ll lose all beauty, but my point is that the girls that guys pin up in their garages in our culture, the girls that other girls are actually jealous of, the girls considered icons of beauty in our culture, have long hair, which means that women aren't chopping off their hair in order to become more beautiful. Likewise, if you're a male, you'll notice that all the people telling you that your long hair looks attractive are women. That's because women also find femininity attractive, which is why they judge each other so much on their looks. Guys don't usually judge the attractiveness of other guys, but they do judge how much a guy should be respected based upon his appearance. My point is simply that we evidence our rebellion even in the face of what we consider to be better by running even against what we would judge to be beautiful or respectful if we were without so many voices telling us to think differently about it, because we aren’t interested in obeying God in terms of gender distinction. Our culture and our cultural tendencies work hard to convince us to blot out our gender distinctions and that we actually still look great doing so. And it does this even against our created, natural response toward the opposite sex which has been created to look more like the opposite sex, and stir a response in us, than to look more like our own. That's why I would say that if you look at models on the runway, who are often styled as the artistic expression of a genderless culture and the models of advertising, i.e., models that are made up to entice us by beauty to buy something, their feminine qualities are emphasized. This is a good expression of the conflict between our cultural philosophies and our divine programming to be attracted to the opposite sex in creation. Of course, people will always say, "Well, I think it looks good and that's why I do it," but is that really true? If you thought wearing a hairdo in the shape of a kangaroo on your head looked great, but everyone made fun of you and thought you were horribly ugly with that look, would you still wear it? Maybe in our culture it is true that people would simply because we are narcissistic and want to be different and stand out, but we usually get our ideas of "what looks good" from others, so our differentiation usually takes upon itself culturally accepted norms; and when it doesn't, there is usually some major mental issue involved with the person (e.g., people who tattoo themselves to look like jungle cats and whatnot).

My point, of course, is not to say that what we prefer ought to be the norm, as preferences can be distorted (which is why Paul’s lex naturalis argument is the weaker one and he therefore starts out with the better priority argument from the creation of Genesis 2). Instead, even if we did not prefer long hair on women in terms of beautification and short hair on men in terms of respect, we ought to let our hairstyles convey the message that the Lord Jesus Christ would have us convey with them because He is our Lord—or, at the very least, make it a serious consideration as we should make anything set before us in Scripture something to be seriously considered. I mean, God actually included this passage in a Scripture where He left out a host of other things. That should make us think as to why among all of these other things, God chose to communicate this passage instead. It’s there for a reason, and I would submit that it’s there both for the purpose of order (displaying our gender distinctions and worshiping God through them rather than in disregard of them), and as with anything else put before us, it displays the truth or falsity of our claim to have made Christ as Lord. 

Again, one can argue over what's considered long and what's considered short, but that too can display a heart of submission versus rebellion, as we are often asking that question to see how far we can get to the outer limits from what is pleasing to Christ rather than asking how far we can get toward what is most pleasing. Obviously, there is a point where long hair and short hair are no longer confused. Maybe that's the boundary line. But, whatever we decide on the matter, we ought to be seeking to obey rather than seeking to get away with as much as we can. One attitude evidences love for Christ more than ourselves and the other evidences obligation toward someone we do not love more than ourselves.

So, you see, hair length is an essential for your salvation, because the truth or falsity of the claim that Christ is Lord of your life is the essential for your salvation, and it is displayed in how you approach the issue. It's not essential because the issue itself is essential, but because, like all issues, it shines a light on the heart. In other words, this isn't really a head issue (pun intended), but a heart issue. If you reject my interpretation of the passage after you have looked long and hard with much study and in much honesty and desire to obey the Lord no matter what the text asks of you, that’s a different issue. My issue is that most who reject what I’m saying blow off the passage completely, or just give it a cursory reading and immediately declare with every pastor who has done the same, “It’s just cultural.” Well, nice of God to include a purely cultural, non-applicable, historical sociology lesson for us in Scripture that has no implications for our lives when He could have included a host of other things more applicable. Or is it that this is applicable in so many ways, as it hits against even our own modern culture in telling us to remain male and female in Christ and to display those distinctions, regardless of the change of fabric in clothing or style, in the length of our hair, because displayed gender distinction, along with modesty, is just that important to God? In fact, maybe we need this passage, not less, but more than any other generation that has existed thus far, simply because our cultural philosophies, working toward the destruction of true humanity, work harder than ever before to reverse our creation as male and female for the propagation of humanity. You decide, but decide with a pure heart toward pleasing the Lord in accordance to what He says in Scripture. If you do so, you may be able to rest assured that you would, perhaps, die in the jungle for Him too.

Saturday, December 17, 2011

Your Church Is Too Big

I had a conversation awhile back with John Armstrong about orthodoxy before his book, Your Church Is Too Small, a title that plays on the well known book, Your God Is Too Small, came out. John’s understanding of what makes a Christian is typical, as his understanding of the nature of the creeds is superficial. John's understanding, as well as many evangelicals like him, is that one who can make a claim to believe the gospel or has a confessional stance based upon Nicea, can be considered a Christian and should be greeted into the church as a Christian. I wish I could find the conversation, but I imagine it was so long ago that it is now lost in cyberspace somewhere. In any case, let me share with you some things about what makes a Christian that I think are vital for everyone to understand.

First, orthodoxy can’t save you. Let me qualify that. Obviously, a little orthodoxy needs to be given to you, i.e., the real gospel, in order for you to believe it and be justified; but merely giving you that little orthodoxy can’t save you by itself. You actually have to believe it. So orthodoxy is needed, but simply being orthodox does not identify you as a Christian.

Second, orthopraxis can’t save you either. We are not saved by good works. Simply being a good citizen in society or the church and helping out doesn’t make you a Christian. But let me qualify that by saying a little orthopraxis is needed in the receiving of the gospel, as to repent and believe is a moral decision as well. The point here is simply that orthopraxis alone does nothing for you toward salvation, and as such, cannot identify you as a Christian.

What does identify a person as a Christian is both orthodoxy and orthopraxis together. One without the other signifies that one never performed the little orthopraxis of repenting and believing the little orthodoxy of the gospel, because the path of the Christian is one that begins and ends with both. Hence, one who truly believes the gospel for justification will continue on in sanctification, and both orthodoxy and orthopraxis are held therein.

Hence, the orthodox who come to Jesus on the day of Judgment and argue that they are to be identified as Christians, but their actions either deny His Lordship by indulging in evil (Matt 7:16-23) or refraining from good (25:31-46) are damned. But the practitioners of orthopraxis who come to Christ on that day without the orthodoxy of the gospel will be eternally damned as well (Rom 3:20; Gal 1:6-9; 5:4).

So it is through the truth that we are made holy (John 17:17-19). If one is to claim to be a Christian, therefore, one cannot exist without the other.

The point is that he who truly begins in the true Faith, evidenced by both orthodoxy and orthopraxis will end there, and because of that truth, the genuine Christian will have as his evidence that he is a Christian both orthodoxy and orthopraxis. If he lacks one, he needs to be corrected. If corrected, and he continues on without repentance, his claim to be a Christian is to be denied, and he is to be put out of the church, lest others be convinced that the heretic and/or the “heteroprax” are Christians too, and that doctrine and practice doesn’t really matter, then, as long as one makes the claim that he or she believed the gospel.

Therefore, based on the above understanding, then, what is orthodox and orthodprax evidences the truth or falsity of one’s claim to have believed. As such, one who lives in one but not the other, or one who lives without either, cannot legitimately make a claim that he or she is a Christian. Notice what Christ says about the nature of His sheep:

"Truly, truly, I say to you, he who does not enter by the door into the fold of the sheep , but climbs up some other way, he is a thief and a robber. "But he who enters by the door is a shepherd of the sheep. "To him the doorkeeper opens, and the sheep hear his voice, and he calls his own sheep by name and leads them out. "When he puts forth all his own, he goes ahead of them, and the sheep follow him because they know his voice." A stranger they simply will not follow, but will flee from him, because they do not know the voice of strangers.

Note that it does not say, “those who hear his voice become his sheep,” but “his sheep hear his voice” and they “follow him because they know his voice” and that “a stranger they simply will not follow.” His sheep are His sheep when they hear the gospel and believe it (exercising the moral decision to repent [orthopraxis] and believe in a gospel filled with right doctrine [orthodoxy]). This is the pattern of the true Christian. He simply will not follow the path of heresy and heteropraxis, as his Master’s voice isn’t in them.

Now, with that in mind, let’s discuss what creeds are actually for, as John’s idea, as well as the continual claim by all sorts of heretical and “heteroprax” groups of people often make the claim that they are Christians because they believe either the Apostle’s Creed or the Nicene Creed, which are supposedly meant to be the summation of what is required to maintain orthodox Christianity. I reject completely that they are.

Instead, the creeds exist to keep the church on the orthodox path, but they are not the sum total of that path. They are the boundary markers against whatever heresy arose at that time, and they can help if that heresy arises again; but they do not make up the sum total of all Christian faith and practice (of course, the creeds themselves do not really contain much practice in them, even though the decisions of the larger Councils do). My point here is that creeds exist to provide boundary markers for the path, not to summarize the path for the entire journey of the church. Let me demonstrate that for you.

The Apostle’s Creed was formed to secure the gospel from the heresies of Gnosticism. Let’s look at it for a moment:

I believe in God the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth, and in Jesus Christ, His Son, our Lord, who was conceived by the Holy Spirit, born of the virgin Mary, suffered under Pontius Pilate, was crucified, dead and buried. On the third day, He rose again from the dead. He ascended into heaven, where He sits at the right hand of God the Father Almighty. From there He will come to judge the living and the dead.
I believe in the Holy Spirit, the holy, historic Christian church, the communion of saints, the forgiveness of sins, the resurrection of the body, and the life everlasting. Amen. 
Now, this does give a good summation of the gospel, so it can be used that way. The problem is that when one takes this as only what is required to remain orthodox that he gets in trouble. Notice, the Gnostics are defeated by the creed in that it is argued that God the Father, not the evil demiurge, is the maker of heaven and earth (i.e., the physical realm and the spiritual realm, not just the spiritual). They are again refuted by the fact that Jesus was really born through the virgin, suffered, died, and was bodily resurrected (which is what resurrected means in early Christianity—i.e., there’s no such thing as a spiritual resurrection). Both spiritual and physical are affirmed as the realm over which Christ will judge, the orthodox church that teaches such is affirmed as the true church, and the necessity for forgiveness of sins committed in the body is affirmed, along with the resurrection of the body and eternal life in that state. This is all countering Gnosticism, and that’s a good thing. It kept Christians who encountered Gnostic heresy from straying from the path. They heard Christ’s voice in the creed, and followed Him rather than another. The heretics followed the stranger.

The problem is that the heretics of the next generation then just affirmed the creed in that they accepted that God was the Creator of the physical realm and that Jesus was born, suffered, and died, but that He was only indwelt by God, but not God Himself (Adoptionism), that He was just a man (Ebionite), or that He was the supremely created being who comes closest to being like God, but is not God Himself (Arianism). Now the Apostle’s Creed, although it is an important creed to set the boundary markers for orthodoxy, no longer is capable of setting the boundary markers. It does not provide a light to the new part of the path that we have come upon along our journey toward Christ.

Hence, the Nicene Creed, building upon the Apostle’s Creed, needed to be set in place to provide those markers who would seek to hear the voice of Christ and follow. So Nicea argued that the Jesus was both God and man, as Christians had been saying for the previous two and a half centuries before it. Here is the main addition:

We believe in one Lord, Jesus Christ,
the only Son of God,
eternally begotten of the Father,
God from God, light from light,
true God from true God,
begotten, not made,
of one Being with the Father;
through him all things were made.
For us and for our salvation
he came down from heaven,
was incarnate of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary
and became truly human.

Notice now that this counters the heresies that Jesus, the man, was adopted by the divine Christ. It counters the heresy that He was just a man, and it counters the heresy that He is a created being by arguing that He is true God from true God, not made and of one being with the Father.
Many will then argue that we can stop here, as though Nicea covered the only bases important enough to be covered (of course, not even the Fathers at the time believed that since it was necessary to convene another council, i.e., Constantinople I, in order to clarify and reaffirm Nicea. Anyone, therefore, who affirms Nicea can be considered a Christian. The problem, of course, is that the heresy simply adapted and accepted Nicea, but then argued that Christ was incarnated as two persons, one divine and one human (Nestorianism), that He had one mixed nature (monophysitism), or that He had only one will (monothelitism).
Nicea didn’t deal with these heresies, and, as such, the creed needed to be fortified again by the councils of Ephesus (contra Nestorianism), Chalcedon (contra monophysitism), and the second (contra assumed-Nestorianism) and third (contra monothelitism and monoenergism—not to be confused with monoergism) councils of Constantinople in order to fortify and reaffirm the creeds.

The point I’m making here is that it is given to the church in every generation to keep the boundary markers for the path of Christ and to affirm the teachings of the orthodox church in setting up other markers as we continue down the path. This doesn’t mean we’re setting up “new” markers, as we are simply reaffirming what Christians have believed everywhere, but that they are things that have not been repudiated by major heresies before.

In other words, it doesn’t really matter that doctrines like the eternality of hell, inerrancy, justification by faith alone through grace alone, etc. don’t appear in the Nicean creed. It only matters that the orthodox have affirmed these throughout their walking along the path, and that they accurately shed light upon the path we are to follow. Nicea does not contain the boundary markers for our new heresies that have simply adapted and taken upon new forms of rebellion against Christ and His gospel.

Hence, it was the task of the Reformers to counter the heresy that a person could work toward his salvation, even with helps from God. It has been our task in recent times to work on bibliology and eschatology (specifically in terms of Christ’s Second Advent and hell), and perhaps, upon the very nature of and ability to know truth itself, as heresy works hard now to undermine, not just individual orthodox doctrines, but all orthodox doctrine. To argue that our “church is too small” because we don’t accept Nicea as the all encompassing creed is to be ignorant of what creeds are for, and as such, will lead to the gates being opened to countless heresies. Indeed, it, therefore, may be a heresy itself that seeks to undermine the importance of these doctrines to the path of the gospel.

Again, the little amount of orthodoxy one needs to know in order to be saved, and what orthodoxy one will affirm once he is given the truth may be two different things, but they are related, as one will always result in the other. Orthodoxy breeds more orthodoxy just as orthopraxis breeds more orthopraxis. We learn. We grow. We listen. We follow. If the voice of the stranger calls us to another path, we will not obey him, for sheep only hear their Master’s voice, and His voice leads us onto the right path.

Again, orthodoxy cannot save you. You must submit your life to Christ as Lord. We must repent of our false doctrine and evil practices, but how, pray tell, will that be possible if we do not know what false doctrines we believe are evil and work to destroy the gospel of salvation? Hence, all of this is connected to the gospel. This isn’t a question of believing different things about celebrating Easter, eschatological timelines, or views of creation days. Orthodoxy affirms our very first creed by expanding upon it against the heresies that are formed to undermine it. And our very first creed is this: “that Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures, and that He was buried, and that He was raised on the third day according to the Scriptures.” All heresy, in one way or another, seeks to undermine this by distorting who the God is who is saving us, who Christ is who is capable of saving us, His work on the cross, His promise of eternal life, etc. Hence, in Scripture, we have numerous statements concerning the damnation of those who distort the nature of God, Christ, His work on the cross, His resurrection, etc.

Why is it important? I don’t know. Why is salvation important? Answer that question and then you have your answer for why orthodoxy is important as the vehicle through which one can be saved and as part of the two pieces of criteria we use to evaluate whether we are saved. I think it’s important, don’t you? If we do begin to see the seriousness of it, maybe we'll be compelled to conclude that our church isn’t too small after all. In fact, maybe it’s too big.

Friday, December 16, 2011

To Grow or Not to Grow: The Priority Argument in First Corinthians 11:2-16

This will be the first of two installments on the issue of head-coverings/hair length as a distinguishing expression of gender. This first is taken from my thesis (that is not even near what the chapter needs to be yet), and the second will be more of my interaction with contemporary Christianity's interaction with the passage and the evangelical idea that physical appearance is not important to God and that anyone who suggests otherwise is being offensive. I thought it was important to discuss the exegesis first (even though my thesis isn't about exegeting the passage for all its worth, it does contain some important insights into the passage).


A “priority argument” is one that appeals to the beginning, or creation, of the world or institution in order to support the universal application of an idea or practice by appealing to the original intent of its originator. In the Bible, God is the originator, and thus, His intent is seen in both the creation of the world and in the creation of Israel. Whenever New Testament authors, then, make an appeal to creation, they are making a priority argument in order to say that what God originally intended overrides anything that originates later from culture or even divine concession toward culture. In the use of such an argument, the New Testament writers call their audience back to what God originally expressed as His desire for His people to believe or practice.

One of the passages that display uses of the priority argument is First Corinthians 11:2–16. A good summary of scholarly commentary on the passage is found in Garland.

The complexity of 11:2–16 continues to vex modern interpreters, and its comments about women rile many modern readers.  Because it contains one of the lengthiest discussions in the NT on the relationship between men and women, it has attracted the attention of many and the indignation of some. The danger lurks that interpreters will try to make it say what they would like it to say. Engberg-Pedersen (1991: 679) observes, “The nonscholarly interest of scholars very often influences heavily their decisions on the exegetical questions.” To penetrate its meaning we need more cultural information. But which bits of cultural information apply to this situation? The most reliable clues to the passage’s meaning lie in its structure.
The problem centers on head attire in worship, but interpreters cannot agree whether it has to do with some kind of head covering, hairstyles, or properly tended hair, and whether it involves both men and women or only women. Many recent interpreters assume that the problem has theological roots. Some imagine that Corinthian spiritualists attempted to blur the distinctions between the sexes to symbolize their new status in Christ. Women prophets either threw off their veils, “symbols of the inferiority and subordination which characterized their day to day living,” to show that they had transcended sexual differentiation (M. MacDonald 1990b: 166) or let their hair down in a deliberate attempt “to discard a traditional marker of gender distinction” (Hays 1997: 183–84). In either case, it is assumed that the Corinthian women got carried away with their transformed spiritual status and carried things too far by breaching sexual decorum. They misapplied Paul’s teaching that in Christ there is neither male nor female (Gal. 3:28) and, influenced by a “realized eschatology,” sought to eradicate any conventional male/female distinctions (see Meeks 1974: 202). Murphy-O’Connor (1980) surmises that the problem involved men as well as women and contends that it centered on hairdos. Women wore their hair in an unfeminine way, and men wore their hair in an unmasculine way. The hairstyle option has gained popularity. Dunn (1998: 590–91) claims that Paul’s circuitous argument is intended primarily to support the custom of bound-up hair for women so that when they prophesy “with a ‘proper’ hairstyle,” they will not be “distracting.” Gielen (1999) modifies the hairstyle hypothesis by contending that the Corinthian women adopted a short, masculine hairstyle and that Paul argues that they should have long hair. Hjort (2001) claims that Paul argues against a form of androgyny in which the differences between the sexes are being neutralized by a kind of transvestism, in which men and particularly women are dressing and cutting their hair according to the customs of the other sex. Hjort attributes it to a carryover from some of the Corinthians’ past participation in the cult of Dionysus and its transgendered revelry. All these views understand Paul’s main point to be that the sexual differences between men and women are part of God’s purposes in creation and that they should not be obscured in worship.[1]

.
The passage is usually translated along the lines of the NASB as follows:

Now I praise you because you remember me in everything and hold firmly to the traditions, just as I delivered them to you. But I want you to understand that Christ is the head of every man, and the man is the head of a woman, and God is the head of Christ. Every man who has [something] on his head while praying or prophesying disgraces his head. But every woman who has her head uncovered while praying or prophesying disgraces her head, for she is one and the same as the woman whose head is shaved. For if a woman does not cover her head, let her also have her hair cut off; but if it is disgraceful for a woman to have her hair cut off or her head shaved, let her cover her head. For a man ought not to have his head covered, since he is the image and glory of God; but the woman is the glory of man. For man does not originate from woman, but woman from man; for indeed man was not created for the woman's sake, but woman for the man's sake. Therefore the woman ought to have [a symbol of] authority on her head, because of the angels. However, in the Lord, neither is woman independent of man, nor is man independent of woman. For as the woman originates from the man, so also the man [has his birth] through the woman; and all things originate from God. Judge for yourselves: is it proper for a woman to pray to God [with her head] uncovered? Does not even nature itself teach you that if a man has long hair, it is a dishonor to him, but if a woman has long hair, it is a glory to her? For her hair is given to her for a covering. But if one is inclined to be contentious, we have no other practice, nor have the churches of God.

            Many of the words, as indicated in brackets, are supplied by the English translations. In reality, much of what is supplied depends upon one’s understanding of what the passage is essentially arguing. Hence, it is important to get a look at the passage as it appears in Greek in order to evaluate what can be gleaned from the text without filling in the gaps first. From what we can see in the bare bones of this passage, Paul makes the following arguments (the “X” in v. 11–12 representing what needs to be supplied):

1)      The delineation of headship is from God to Christ, Christ to man, and man to woman (v. 3).
2)      The man who has kata kefalh “down from a head” is shamed, and the woman who does not have a her head covered is shamed and the same as one who is bald (vv. 4–6).
3)      The man is the glory and image of God, whereas the woman is the glory of man (v. 7).
4)      Man is not from the woman, but the woman is from man (v. 8).
5)      Man is not created on account of the woman, but the woman is created on account of the man (v. 9).
6)      The angels are observing the worship service (v. 10).
7)      Neither is a woman X without man, nor a man X without woman, and this is still true when they are “in the Lord” (v. 11). As the woman X from the man, so also the man X by the woman, and all things X from God.
8)      Nature teaches that it is a shame for a man to have long hair, but that long hair is beautiful on a woman (vv. 14–15a).
9)      Her long hair functions as a veil/covering (v. 15b).
10)  Neither the apostles or the churches of God have a practice that accommodates differing views (v. 16).
11)  Therefore, by both explicit statements within the passage, and by way of implicature, a man is to have short hair and a woman is to have long hair if they are to prophesy and pray in the assembly.

Whether there is more to this passage, i.e., that women are to wear a traditional covering in addition to having long hair, or that what is said should be applied to all spheres of life, not just within the assembly, must be argued from one’s interpretation of these texts. It seems clear that at the very least, the Apostle Paul is implying that hair length is something that distinguishes men from women, and that such a distinction ought to be maintained as ideal within the community. Hence, only those persons that exhibit that distinction should be allowed to represent God to the church (via prophesy) or the church to God (via prayer).
The question one must ask for this study, however, pertains as to whether Paul is presenting an argument simply for his time and culture, or whether it is his intent to relay a universal message to all of the churches, for all time, after him?  In other words, does he intend this argument to be limited to his Corinthian audience, or is this practice to be standard in the churches of God everywhere regardless of cultural practices? 
In order to find the answer one must isolate the basis for Paul’s argument.  Does the language used for the foundation of this argument contain cultural indicators (something that lets the primary, or initial, reader know that the argument is specifically to him or her and not necessarily the relation a universal principle or a specific application of a universal principle), or does it contain universal indicators to let the reader know that there is no argument (cultural or otherwise) to counter either the principle, or perhaps, even the specific application of the principle?
I believe there are four universal indicators, one of which is a priority argument.  In order to display the function of priority arguments as universal reasoning, this work will discuss the other universal indicators, which give credit to it, within the passage.
The first universal indicator is that Paul has delivered (v. 2) the traditions (parado/seij) passed down to him to the Corinthians.  This is often read as a cultural indicator, providing evidence that Paul is simply passing along a non-universal, cultural practice.[2]
 However, that is not the way Paul uses the term.  In fact, the apostle uses the same related terminology of both the Eucharist in 11:23 as well as the central gospel message in 15:1-4 (two very universal teachings).  The terminology denotes that the following argument carries with it apostolic authority passed down to the current day of Paul’s writing.  Therefore, the apostle’s purpose in using this term is to give greater weight of authority to what is being said, not weaken its application as simply a limited cultural opinion.  In fact, this reasoning could be a type of priority argument since it appeals to teachings first taught within the Church and passed down to the contemporary generation as an authority which supersedes any other practice among the Corinthian church.[3]
However, the tradition past down is likely a reference to the equality of the sexes in Christ. This is the tradition to which Paul likely refers here, a tradition based upon the text of Genesis 1, where both man and woman are made in God’s image and have now been liberated to reenter that role of true humanity through Christ. However, the de/ in v. 3 is likely adversative, which means that what follows is a clarification of the previous tradition handed down. What this means is that the general rule needs to be understood within the light that follows. What that means by way of implication is that what follows is as universal as the tradition handed down.
One must note, then, that Paul is specifically interacting with a previous teaching he gave them. In fact, he compliments them for attempting to keep the teaching he handed down to them (which is what para&dosij“tradition” means here).[4] Jervis argues that this previous teaching is similar to that found in Galatians 3:28, where there is neither male nor female in Christ, based upon a teaching that both are restored as the image of God when they become Christians. She argues that Paul, then, seeks to correct the misunderstanding that such a status means that physical symbols that express gender roles and distinctions are obliterated.[5]
The second universal indicator is at the end of the pericope.  Paul states that “if anyone is inclined to be contentious on the issue, we have no other custom [sunh/qeian] nor do the churches of God” (v. 16).  The Greek literally states “if anyone is inclined to be contentious, we have no such custom, nor do the churches of God.”  Hence, the emphasis is placed upon the faulty practice rather than the appropriate practice.  There is no such custom with a woman praying or prophesying without some sort of covering.[6] Hence, the contentious person cannot be accommodated by a variant practice as there is no practice that is in accord with an interpretation of Genesis 1 that does not take Genesis 2 into account.
The universal element here is the word sunh/qeian (custom or practice) and the appeal to the churches of God in relation to it.  In secular Koine, such as in Philo and Josephus, the term sunh/qeian denotes a mutual habit or practice.  Paul uses the term in First Corinthians 8:7 to denote a type of thinking that has been fostered within a person, i.e., something that a person has become convinced of through another.  This is probably the correct interpretation of the word in this context.  Paul is arguing, as before, that the practice fostered among the churches of God is the standard apostolic tradition passed down to them, and no other practice should be set up in opposition to it.  Thus, the last phrase in v. 16 sets up an inclusio for the pericope begun in v. 2, and sandwiches the argument in universal language, where neither we (i.e., the apostles) or the churches of God practice anything resembling a practice that does not maintain gender distinction through, at the very least, hair length.
The third universal indicator upon which this study will focus is a speculative one.  The statement in vv. 11-12 are often taken as indicative of Paul’s balancing out his previous statement concerning the origin of the woman in opposition to the rabbinic interpretation of Genesis 2, which often made women inferior in nature to men.  It is true that the apostle does this elsewhere (Gal 3:28); but the verses actually contain no statement that man “has his birth through the woman.”[7]  The actual statement in the Greek is ou}te gunh\ xwri_j a)ndro_v “neither man apart from woman, nor woman apart from man in the Lord.” He continues by stating, “ For as the woman from the man, so also the man by the woman; and all things from God.” 
Although typically taken as an argument from origins, the phrase may be an argument in favor of Paul’s main thrust that men and women should be distinct because one needs the other to distinguish gender.[8] In fact, Jervis believes that Paul here is correcting a misinterpretation, and subsequent misapplication, of his teaching that all are one “in the Lord” that taught gender distinction to be a thing of the past.[9]
The common understanding in Second Temple Judaism (including Hellenistic Judaism as displayed in authors such as Philo of Alexandria) that the original man of Genesis 1 was androgynous.[10] Thus, if the more spiritual person attains to the image of Genesis 1 then he or she seeks to be an androgynous human without gender distinction in physical appearance. Paul here corrects this misunderstanding by arguing from Genesis 2 that man and woman are to remain distinct in their roles and in their appearances, specifically signified, not simply by clothing, but by the hair lengths given to them. The woman especially ought to keep her hair length long as it distinguishes her from the man and is a specific symbol of her femininity that God intended for her and not for the man. Instead, it represents her delegated authority in creation that she acquires from her relationship with the man, something the angels seek to maintain as the guardians of the created order.[11]
Therefore, the argument Paul is making would sound something like this paraphrase: “neither is man [recognizable] apart from [his distinction] from the woman, nor is woman apart from [her being defined] by the man in the Lord; because just as the woman [gains her identity] from the existence of the masculine gender, so also the man [gains his identity] through the existence of the feminine; and indeed all things are [distinguished] from God.”
The phrase “in the Lord” as it is used by Paul seems to indicate that Christian people are being spoken of here. Hence, it is the distinctions between the Christian man and the Christian woman that are to be maintained, and what distinguishes the Christian man and the Christian woman are head-coverings, here interpreted by Paul as hair lengths. As Jervis notes:

In 1 Cor 11:2–16 Paul is concerned to correct the Corinthinans’ interpretation of his preaching on liberty in Christ and its consequent reprehensible practice. On the basis of their Jewish-Hellenistic approach to Paul’s earlier teaching on the unity of man and woman in Christ, the Corinthian spirituals considered that they had been transformed into the image of the one who is beyond gender. Accordingly, they believed that customary gender-specific hairdressing andn apparel no longer expressed their new life . . . What he highlights through his midrash is that God intended there to be two distinct genders who would live in harmony in the Lord.
While Paul affirms his original proclamation (v. 11), he does not do so until he has clarified the appropriate context in which to understand it.[12]

Hence, Paul is making the argument that to be “in the Lord,” a variation of “in Christ Jesus” found in Galatians 3:28 and mimicked here in v.
This interpretation would make more sense in light of Paul’s larger argument here, as well as offer an interpretation that was consistent with the larger context rather than in opposition to it.[13]
If this interpretation is correct, then there is a third universal indicator here, since Paul would not be arguing that men and women are only distinguishable genders in Corinth.  He is therefore making an argument for a universal distinction.
There is also support for the idea that gender distinction via appearance was a concern in Second Temple Judaism, especially as it clashed with certain elements within Hellenistic culture. Greek culture was itself at odds with the issue. Epictetus remarks on the matter as follows:
Come, let us leave the chief works of nature, and consider merely what she does in passing. Can anything be more useless than the hairs on a chin? Well, what then? Has not nature used even these in the most suitable way possible? Has she not by these means distinguished between the male and the female? Does not the nature of each one among us cry aloud forthwith from afar, ‘I am a man; on this understanding approach me, on this understanding talk with me; ask no further; behold the signs’? Again, in the case of women, just as nature has mingled in their voice a certain softer note, so likewise she has taken the hair from their chins. Not so, you say; on the contrary the human animal ought to have been left without distinguishing features, and each of us ought to proclaim by word of mouth, ‘I am a man.’ Nay, but how fair and becoming and dignified the sign is! How much more fair than the cock’s comb, how much more magnificent than the lion’s mane! Wherefore, we ought to preserve the signs which God has given; we ought not to throw them away; we ought not, so far as in us lies, to confuse the sexes which have been distinguished in this fashion.[14]

But it is clear that some argued that long hair was a majestic quality for certain men, as philosophers often wore their hair this way.[15] Regardless, however, short-hair was the normal hairstyle for men in Greco-Roman culture.[16]

 Philo discusses the man who arranges his hair like a woman (as well as putting on perfume/make-up as an androgynon, who has disgraced himself, society, and nature (H. Philo 1. De Specialibus Legibus 3.37-42). In Vit.Cont. 59-63, he repeats this about the effeminate who he views as androgynous, the distinctions having been destroyed by changes in external appearance.
He calls the woman who does this a gynandros (De Sacrificiis Abelis et Caini 100, Quis Rerum Divinarum Heres sit 274, De Virtutibus 20-21), and states:

The true man should maintain his masculinity, particularly in his clothes, which as he always wears them by day and night ought to have nothing to suggest unmanliness. In the same way he trained the woman to decency of adornment and forbade her to assume the dress of a man, with the further object of guarding against the mannish-woman (hos androgynos houtos kai gynandrous phulaxamenos).

In other words, women and men should not dress in the opposite gender’s clothes in order to guard against a loss of gender distinction. Of course, these arguments are geared toward pederasty, but the point Philo is making is that pederasty is wrong because of its destruction of gender distinction rather than vice versa.
What is interesting about Paul’s argument is that he seems to attribute more to hair length than clothing per se, as he takes for granted the idea that women were meant to have long hair. In verse 15b, Paul states that her hair “has been given (de/dotai) in place of (a)nti/) a covering.” Hence, he argues here that the woman was given hair for an additional purpose to that for which man was given hair (i.e., to function in place of a covering). It is here that one can see that Paul’s argument is not about external head-coverings/head-dresses, but instead concerning the length of one’s hair. The “head-coverings” to which he has been referring throughout the passage is long hair. Thus, kata_ kefalh~j in verse 4 refers to a man who has long hair (lit. “[hanging] down from the head”), coinciding with verse 14, and the covering a woman ought to have upon her head, in contrast to this, that which function as a covering (i.e., koma~|, “to wear one’s hair long”).

Based upon this study, I would propose a translation of First Corinthians 11:2–16 as follows:

Now I praise you because you remember me in everything and hold firmly to the traditions, just as I delivered them to you.
But I want you to understand that Christ is the head of every man, and the man is the head of a woman, and God is the head of Christ.
Every man who has [something] on his head while praying or prophesying disgraces his head.
But every woman who has her head uncovered while praying or prophesying disgraces her head, for she is one and the same as the woman whose head is shaved.
For if a woman does not cover her head, let her also cut off her hair; but since it is disgraceful for a woman to have her hair cut off or her head shaved, she is to cover her head.
For a man ought not to have his head covered, since he is the image and glory of God; but the woman is the glory of man.
For man does not originate from woman, but woman from man;
for indeed man was not created for the woman's sake, but woman for the man's sake.
Therefore the woman ought to have [a symbol of] delineated authority on her head, because of the angels.
However, in the Lord, neither is woman [distinguished] apart from the man, nor is man [distinguished] apart from the woman.
For just as the woman [gains her identity in distinction] from the man, so also the man [gains his distinction] through the woman; and all things [are distinguished] from God.
Judge for yourselves: is it proper for a woman to pray to God without covering?
Does not even nature itself teach you that if a man has long hair, it is a dishonor to him,
but if a woman has long hair, it is a glory to her? For her hair is given to her for a covering.
But if one is inclined to be contentious, we have no other practice, nor have the churches of God.

Thus, Paul’s argument seeks to correct the misinterpretation of his previous teaching that all are one in Christ by clarifying that this does not mean roles and genders have been abandoned, but rather that the new equal status of Christians of both genders before God is one that must be expressed through gender in worship, not apart from it. Paul reminds the Corinthians that Genesis 1 and 2, as the grounds for basing God’s intentions toward humanity, are to be considered authoritative in the discussion, and that this accords with both nature and current church practice. The individual, therefore, who comes to different conclusions is being contentious toward God’s very work in creation and in the church. Thus, Paul employs the priority argument by appealing to creation as the foundation for understanding worship through gender expression rather than in gender suppression, as the Gnostics who argue that it is through the androgynous man that salvation is accomplished.[17]




[1]Garland, David E.: 1 Corinthians. Grand Rapids, Mich. : Baker Academic, 2003 (Baker Exegetical Commentary on the New Testament), 505. Garland himself rejects these in view of a cultural practice where traditional head-coverings were worn.
[2] Although, most egalitarians do see what is being argued as a universal that has something to do with gender distinction. For instance, Craig Blomberg’s reasons for seeing the text as arguing a universal (NIV Application Commentary: 1 Corinthians [Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1995], 216) are typical of both camps:

(1) “Creation ordinances” (arguments based on how God set things up before the Fall of Gen. 3 [what I call “priority arguments”]) are regularly used throughout the New Testament as desirable, timeless principles that all Christians should follow . . . (2) Paul himself supplies verses 8–9 as a rationale for behavior he is commanding of Christians, not unredeemed people. (3) Verses 8–9 would be meaningless and unnecessary if verses 11–12 entirely canceled them out . . . (5) The interdependence that verses 11–12 stress actually reinforces Paul’s insistence in the first half of the passage that wives not dishonor their husbands.

However, what Blomberg gives with one hand he takes away with the other by divorcing the concept of hair length from gender distinction, which ironically, is exactly the opposite of what Paul is arguing as a universal (Ibid., 215).
Such a commitment to modern culture seems to run contrary to his astute observation that the wordplay concerning kefalh& gives us an indication of what Paul is arguing, as he states that “the main point of this paragraph is the claim that what one does or doesn’t put on one’s physical head either honors or dishonors one’s spiritual head” (208). Hence, such argumentation lends credence to the idea that Paul is arguing a universal idea here concerning actual hair length and its relationship with gender distinction.
[3] In this regard, PA’s concerning apostolic tradition will continue into the Patristic period with just such reasoning (as the Patristic period itself will be later used by the Church throughout its history as a beginning point from which to argue doctrine and practice).
[4] Cf. the verbal form in 15:3 as that which pertains to the proclamation of the gospel itself..
[5] J. Ann Jervis, “‘But I Want You to Know . . .’ Paul’s Midrashic Intertextual Response to the Corinthian Worshipers (1 Cor 11:2–16)” JBL 112 (1993) 231–46.
[6] One might conclude that the statement that “there is no such custom” refers to Paul’s argument that women ought to have long hair, but here is one of those places that the use of the PA lends reciprocal support to a particular ambiguity in the text. If Paul’s argument is that God has ordered creation in such a way then the claim that there is no need to practice such in the church, and thus is it not practiced, would essentially argue against God’s intended order. This is surely not what the apostle intended to communicate. Hence, the phrase must refer to the opposing view, i.e., the view of the contentious that is not customarily practiced in the church.
[7] These words are added by the NASB.
[8] This is in fact a primary argument for Gen 1¾ that God makes them male and female to distinguish them from Himself.
[9] Jervis, “‘But I Want You to Know,” 234–35.
[10] See, for instance, Richard A. Baer, Jr., Philo’s Use of the Categories Male and Female (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1970).
[11] Blomberg understands the phrase e0cousi/an e!xein e0pi_ as referring, not to a delegated authority the woman has in prophesying or praying, based upon her status in creation, but simply as an authority over her head, meaning that she ought to control what is on her head (1 Corinthians, 212).
[12] Jervis, “‘But I Want You to Know,” 246.
[13] Thiselton, First Corinthians, 803. However, Thiselton sets up a false dichotomy when he states that “Paul’s concern is not with subordination but with gender distinction” (Ibid., 805), as gender distinction is only important if differing duties/roles exist between them, and a part of those duties may include the subordination of one gender to the other, which seems to be the point made in v. 3.
[14] Epictetus 1.16.9-14. Page, T.E., ed. Oldfather, W.A., trans. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1925.
[15] See, for instance, Dio Chrysostom, who defends his long hair by attributing it to the glory of kings and philosophers, but also declares that it is not a virtue in and of itself (Thirty-fifth Discourse, sect. 10-12. Dio Chrysostom, vol. 3, pp. 401-403).
[16] Thompson, Cynthia L. “Hairstyles, Head-coverings, and St. Paul: Portraits from Roman Corinth.” Biblical Archaeologist, vol. 51, no. 2, June, 1988, p. 100-103. Plutarch argued that it was common in Greece for men to cut their hair short and women to cut their hair long  (Plutarch. Moralia, vol. 4., p. 27 Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1936. A.k.a. Moralia, The Roman Questions 267b).
[17] See, for instance, the androgynous arguments made in the Gospels of Thomas and Philip.