Wednesday, November 16, 2011

Are You Someone Worth Dying For?

There is a song by Mikeschair entitled, "Someone Worth Dying For" that I think encapsulates the way that modern evangelicals (and emergings/liberals) think about the gospel. Listen to the end chorus:

You're worth it, you can't earn it
Yeah the Cross has proven
That you're sacred and blameless
Your life has purpose

You are more than flesh and bone
Can't you see you're something beautiful
Yeah you gotta believe, you gotta believe
He wants you to see, He wants you to see
That you're not just some wandering soul
That can't be seen and can't be known
Yeah you gotta believe, you gotta believe that you
Are someone worth dying for

You're someone worth dying for
You're someone worth dying for

Now, if you have daily pity parties for yourself because you really believe, down deep, that you are better than the worth others ascribe to you (why feel sorry for yourself if you think you're truly unworthy to be pitied for not achieving something better of yourself?), you may really like this song. If you've ever actually opened the Bible, however, you'd know that this song is evil to the core. Why do I say that? Here's why.

Let's first contrast this song with this scene from the Gospel of Mark:

Now the woman was a Gentile, of the Syrophoenician race. And she kept asking Him to cast the demon out of her daughter. And He was saying to her, "Let the children be satisfied first, for it is not good to take the children's bread and throw it to the dogs." But she answered and ^said to Him, "Yes, Lord, [but] even the  dogs  under the table feed on the children's crumbs." And He said to her, "Because of this answer go your way; the demon has gone out of your daughter." And going back to her home, she found the child lying on the bed, the demon having departed. (7:26-30)


Notice the pattern here: the woman approaches Christ for something. He tells her that she is unworthy to receive it (in fact, he calls her a dog, which is much worse than calling someone a dog in our culture). She responds in agreement with Him that she is unworthy and a dog. He says that because of this answer, He grants her request as His daughter, i.e., as one of His children, even though she originally was not. Hence, it is in the acknowledgment of unworthiness that Christ gives us worth. We are not worthy already.

I posted awhile back about an encounter I had with Allison's grandfather, where he was telling me that God could never forgive him. He was truly feeling unworthy to receive any salvation that God might offer him. I argued there that the only right thing to tell him in that situation was to tell him that he was right. But this song also reminded me of another time I was sitting in my favorite sushi restaurant in MD and overheard a youth pastor comforting a girl who didn't think she was worthy to be saved. The young (misguided) youth pastor was telling her how much she was worth and how valuable she was as a human being. "God doesn't make trash," as they say. I would agree, but people do make trash of themselves after God has made them. 

The call of the gospel is a call of repentance from who we are to trust in Christ and what He has done for us, not a call to lift ourselves up as worthy to be saved. What we are essentially doing when we believe that we are worthy is that God saved us because of our own worth. In other words, God saved us because He should have saved us. Who would throw away gold? Gold is worthy to be saved. And we are gold (at least within this modern theology that has been heavily influenced by pop-psychology).

You see the trend in our culture to make everything about self-esteem has caused us to seek out pop-psychology as the answer to any feeling of unworthiness. The answer of pop-psychology is to counter the feeling of unworthiness with the affirmations of worthiness. In other words, the answer isn't to confirm the feeling as evidence of something true, but to deny its truthfulness and attribute it to one's own upbringing or present situation, but not to the individual himself.

But what does the Bible say? What is the truth that underlies the gospel, the good news about Christ? Well, first the Bible tells us that we are not worthy to be saved. Only the Son is worthy (both explicitly and implicitly asserting that no one else is). Revelation 5 records the scene where an angel calls out, "Who is worthy to open the book [of life, i.e., of salvation/to be saved] and to break its seals?" John begins to weep because no one is worthy, but just then the angel tells him to stop weeping, because Christ is found worthy to open the book because of His work to secure salvation through His death and resurrection (v. 10-11). He is thus ascribed all of the benefits of salvation (v. 12). In other words, Christ alone is worthy to be saved. No one else is. But why is no one else worthy?
Look at Ephesians 2:17-19, where Paul discusses what we are in and of ourselves:

So this I say, and affirm together with the Lord, that you walk no longer just as the Gentiles also walk, in the futility of their mind, being darkened in their understanding, excluded from the life of God because of the ignorance that is in them, because of the hardness of their heart; and they, having become callous, have given themselves over to sensuality for the practice of every kind of impurity with greediness.

"Gentiles," or "nations," refer to those who are not in Christ. Note that they are excluded from the life of God because they are ignorant (unworthy in knowledge), hardhearted (unworthy in willingness), callous (unworthy in feeling), and have given themselves over to their senses to practice every kind of evil (unworthy in their practice). What exactly is worthy to save about us?

The truth of the matter is that, according to Ephesians 2:1-3:

You were dead in your trespasses and sins, in which you formerly walked according to the course of this world, according to the prince of the power of the air, of the spirit that is now working in the sons of disobedience. Among them we too all formerly lived in the lusts of our flesh, indulging the desires of the flesh and of the mind, and were by nature children of wrath, even as the rest.

Again, we are not even worthy in our following, as we follow the devil and the spirit of disobedience, and thus, are worthy only of his punishment. In fact, the text tells us that we were by nature (i.e., in accordance to who we are, not just what we have done) children of wrath. 

So let me ask you, Is a creature unworthy in knowledge (believing what is false), unworthy in willingness, unworthy in feelings, unworthy in practice, and unworthy in his allegiances, and is by nature someone that incurs the wrath of God a worthy creature to save? According to Scripture, No. Look at the way the Scripture describes us (all of us):

There is none who understands,  There is none who seeks for God; All have turned aside, together they have become useless;  There is none who does good,  There is not even one." "Their throat is an open grave,  With their tongues they keep deceiving,"  "The poison of asps is under their lips"; "Whose mouth is full of cursing and bitterness"; "Their feet are swift to shed blood, Destruction and misery are in their paths, And the path of peace they have not known." "There is no fear of God before their eyes." (Rom 3:11-18)

The Book of Job tells us that God is so infinitely perfect and holy that the finite heavens and angels are even unclean in His eyes, how much more filthy is man "who laps up evil like water." Did you hear that? Even the holy angels and the very created dwelling of God within our universe isn't worthy of Him, how much less is man worthy who actually is and does evil? No, you're not worthy, Dude! To thine own self be true.

Now, you may say that God looks over all of that and looks to some small spark of intrinsic worth preserved deep within us, but look at what God says about the matter in the Flood Narrative:

that every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only  evil  continually. And the Lord was sorry that He had made man on the earth, and He was grieved in His heart. And the Lord said, "I will blot out man whom I have created from the face of the land, from man to animals to creeping things and to birds of the sky; for I am sorry that I have made them." (Gen 6:5-7)

Notice that God's response toward who we became and what we have done is to see no value in keeping us any longer (i.e., no value in saving us). In other words, we aren't worthy to be saved. There is no intrinsic spark.

Some argue that we are all made as the image of God, but I have argued time and again that the image is a role we were to play, not something intrinsic about us. We choose to take upon ourselves that role or not. We are certainly given the ability and opportunity to do so, but the Scripture is clear that we all have shunned that role and have decided to follow the serpent's lie instead.

So what are we worthy of? Death, annihilation, exclusion from life, hell. So what is the answer to the feeling of unworthiness? I would argue that it is confirmation that this feeling is the Holy Spirit through various means conveying a truth to you. This should make you sad that you have nothing to offer God, and sorry for what you have become and what you have done. This is the fertile ground to plant the seed of the gospel.

And that's the thing. There is a sorrow that leads to death and one that leads to repentance and life. He who receives the good news and repents accepts a value and worth from Christ that is not of his own. He who does not remains in unworthiness and futility. The latter can go on to deceive himself to make himself feel better by false religion and pop-psychology (as many do) or he will go further into depression and hopelessness like Saul or Judas. But the difference between the sorrow that leads to death or life is in believing or disbelieving the good news. That good news is about Christ and His worth.

In other words, Christ is worthy, and has gained the worth to be saved for us. We become worthy only because His worth is placed upon us. This worth is not of our own. We, in ourselves, are not worthy to have received salvation, and hence, it is described as a gift that is not of yourselves . . . that no one should boast (Eph 2:8-9). It is Christ who has obtained salvation by His worth. It is Christ who moves God to save us. God sees us as He sees Christ and therefore ascribes His infinite worth to us. The good, no, great news is that those who receive the gospel are given not just the worth of an imperfect human being, but the worth and value of the glorious Son of God, will have His salvation lavished upon them, and will inherit the kingdom that He inherited. 

In other words, our emphasis of worth is on Christ, not on ourselves. When we hear someone talking about their unworthiness, we need to lift Christ high up and say, Yes, you are, but do you think that Christ is worthy to be saved? Do you think that Christ is worth anything to God? The answer is, Of course He is. He's worth everything to God. And the good news, my friend, is that you who are not worthy to be saved have been given infinite worth to God in Christ because He is worthy to be saved. Hence, believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and you shall be saved. Believe in yourself and perish. 

So Christ didn't die for you because you were worth dying for. He died for you because of His great love that caused Him to give salvation to those who did not deserve it, to those who were not worthy to receive it. Emphasize Christ's love. Emphasize Christ's worth. But do not exalt yourself, lest you stand before the Judge on that day in your own ragged clothes, attempting to impress Him with foul offerings. 

So you don't need to believe that you are worth saving. In fact, you need to believe the opposite in order to understand what it is exactly that you are receiving in Christ and what the good news really is. We are worthless until His worth is gifted to us, and He offers it to us in love and mercy through acknowledging who we really are without Him in repentance and turning to Him to receive the salvation that only He could have ever been worthy to obtain. In any case, if someone wipes away the bad news of our worthlessness with false promises of our worth, let him know that he wipes away the good news with it.


Tuesday, November 15, 2011

Anger and the Christian

Our culture views anger as evil. It does so because anger is disruptive and uncomfortable and our culture sees anything that is disruptive and uncomfortable as bad. For the most part, our culture is right in saying that most displays of anger within it are wrong, but not for the reasons listed above. So let's look at anger and when it is and is not appropriately displayed in the Christian.

First, we must realize that anger exists in us when we feel an injustice has been committed, and that anger within itself is actually a good and righteous emotion to have. You won't hear that from too many pulpits, but the fact of the matter is that is exactly what anger is all about. Hence, when God is jealous (jealously being a type of anger), this isn't something evil, but good God is expressing, as it is in the context of betraying God to worship other gods, and His anger/jealousy is a result of the injustice being committed. So anger is a good thing, but it can be, and is, easily distorted.

It is distorted, not because there are two kinds of anger, but because our views of justice are warped. Instead of seeing justice in terms of what we do to God and those who represent Him, we view justice selfishly, and as narcissists define it as anything that does not give us what we expected to receive. As the kings and queens that we believe we are, we have a sense of entitlement and have come to believe that others, including God (if not especially God), have the obligation to give us the respect, sacrifice of themselves, and love due to us. When they do not, the feeling of anger begins to rise, as we sense an injustice to have been committed.

Now, notice something about this. Our culture is a very angry culture for one reason alone. We believe that we are gods. We worship ourselves and believe that all others ought to worship us, including God. We believe that when we are not worshiped, we become jealous and angry with our subjects for not fulfilling their obligations to us. Notice, then, that we have stolen the right of God for ourselves. We have reapplied the command to worship no other gods beside Me (YHWH) to worship no other gods beside Me (me). When someone does not act loving toward me, or cuts me off in traffic, or does not show respect in some way toward me, I become angry, as these people are being unjust toward me.

The greatest crime of all, however, is the one that God commits toward me when He does not give me the respect and sacrifice He is so obligated by my divine status to give me. If God does not make my life the way that I had always wanted it to be, or gives me a bad day, month or year, I grow angry at His lack of worship toward me in lavishing upon me the things in life that I wanted. If my life does not look like the American dream, it clearly is God's fault, since He can do anything, and hence, has committed an injustice toward me. I am then justified to go out and sin against God to make up for what He has deprived me, since that will display my anger toward Him for not giving me what I deserve.

Anger, then, is twisted by our false religion of the self. The very reason why people in our culture are so angry is because we are so hedonistic. We are self worshipers. It's not due to too much caffeine, or too much media, or too many people. Don't lie to yourself. It has to do with our view of ourselves and our sense of entitlement. When that is not fulfilled in the way we think it should be, anger, the rightful emotion that is spawned by injustice, is twisted to become unjust.

It is unjust precisely because the rightful heir of all respect, love, sacrifice, and obligation to worship is God, not us. He is the one who is entitled to all of what we think we are entitled. Injustice has to do with Him first and foremost, and if it doesn't, it isn't unjust. That includes the way that other humans are treated by us. We are to treat them as we would be treated (not necessarily as we are by other narcissists), since humans are made to be the image of God and represent Him. We do what is right to God by doing what is right to others.

But what does this mean for our anger? When is anger ever justified? Obviously, if God is the primary recipient of what is just, then when God, or those who represent Him, do not receive justice, our love and worship of God should cause us to become angry. In fact, if we are not angered by injustices toward God and others who represent Him, it means we do not view the world correctly and we are without true love.

In First Corinthians 13:6, Paul tells us that "love does not rejoice in unrighteousness, but rejoices in the truth." Notice, it does not rejoice in unrighteousness (adikia = injustice). It is not happy with injustice, i.e., it is angry with it. Instead, it rejoices in the truth. It is interesting here that Paul contrasts what is unjust with what is true. I believe he does so simply because believing what is true is doing justice to God, which is why so much of the Scripture harps on this point. To believe what is false is to practice injustice toward God, as God is known and glorified in the truth and robbed of what is due Him by the falsehoods we believe.

So it is when God is robbed of what is rightfully due Him that righteous anger occurs. Hence, Christ is not displaying some wayward emotion that is inappropriate to deity when He becomes angry and cleanses the temple from the moneychangers, who have turned that which was meant to be a house of prayer (i.e., a house where people commit themselves in devotion toward God and offer up themselves to Him) into a place for their own profit (i.e., a place to receive for themselves). Instead, Christ rightly becomes angry at seeing the injustice.

Likewise, when we see someone who ought to be treated as the image of God being treated poorly, we ought to become angry. When we see someone turn themselves into a dog and shun the image of God they were meant to be, we ought to become angry. Hence, we may still become angry at the guy who cuts us off in traffic and be justified for it, simply because he is endangering his and other people's lives; but if it is because we think to ourselves, "How dare you cut me off! Who do you think you are (i.e. in relation to me)," then we are exercising an unrighteous anger because it is an anger born of self worship and entitlement, and not of love for God and others.

Hence, when Paul tells false teachers to go castrate themselves (a very angry comment), he is in the right to do so, as these people are both robbing God from the glory He would receive in the truth and damning men to hell with a false gospel. Thus, all who preach a false gospel should enrage us accordingly. All false teachers should bring us to anger in their arrogance. Again, if they do not make you angry, then I would simply ask, Where is your love for God and others? Where is your sense of justice for those you supposedly love to receive what is rightfully due them?

Anger is a reaction toward what is viewed as not right. As such, how we view what is right dictates the reasons for which we become angry. I hope that we do, as Paul commands, and let ourselves "be angry and do not sin" (Eph 4:26, note that this is a conjunctive kai "and," meaning that anger and not sinning are possibly compatible). In other words, be angry for the right reasons, not for unrighteous reasons.

Anger is only blanketed as a sin in our culture because it is viewed as emotionally disruptive to our otherwise tranquil existence, and thus, it is seen as unloving, but this is just false. Anger is not the opposite of love, and is even sometimes the only right response love can give in a particular situation. To be sure, outbursts of anger that are not controlled and are self-focused display no control over ourselves and are evil. Anger born of self love, in conflict with love of God and others, is always wrong, as it evidences our self worship. Anger due to fear of loss for the self also falls into this category. But if anger is born of love, how can it be wrong?

So love God and others and be angry. If you find yourself angry for the wrong reasons, don't try to change the mere practice, as the larger problem is the lack of love and worship of God in your life. Unrighteous anger is only a symptom, then, of our idolatry. Hence, repent of that, turn toward God in faith through Christ and His selfless sacrifice, and receive the grace that gives birth to love of God and others. You may still show anger after you do, but it will be for the right reasons.

Monday, November 14, 2011

Should God Ever Be Called "She"?

There is a trend in both academic and popular circles to refer to God with feminine pronouns (i.e., "she," "her"). The argument is that God is genderless, and since He is spoken of in terms of a mother sometimes, it might be appropriate to refer to Him using feminine pronouns as well.

Let me clarify somethings that I think are important. First, it is not that God is spoken of in feminine terms, but that God displays some of His attributes in our genders, not just in our genderless human natures, if that is even something that can exist. There are aspects of God's authority, strength, wrath, etc. primarily displayed in the male gender, and there are aspects of God's nurture, loving kindness, mercy, etc. displayed primarily in the female gender (I speak in terms of these genders as they are meant to be, not necessarily what they are). Hence, sometimes the analogies used will be of a male warrior who tramples down the vine press where the grapes of wrath are stored, and sometimes it will be as a mother hen who shields her chicks with her wings. Sometimes He is compared to a mother who cannot abandon her children (and even if she does, He will not abandon them) and sometimes He is described as the Father who created all things.

But we don't attribute gender to God because of these analogies, and that isn't the reason why we use masculine pronouns to refer to Him. We use masculine pronouns for two reasons:

(1) The man has been placed into the highest position of authority among all other earthly creatures. Our pronouns do not support any category outside of male, female, or neuter entities. Hence, the pronoun that refers to the entity with the most authority is used to refer to God. In reality, it would be nice if we had a divine pronoun, but we don't. Hence, the male pronoun is the next best thing in terms of relating a respect for God as high above creatures. In other words, it's the best we can do with the language we have. To speak of God using the female pronoun is to lower our respect for His position and to assign Him a subordinate role in terms of the language we are using.

But many don't believe in these roles due to pop-feminism, so that leaves us with the second reason why we use the male pronoun:

(2) The male pronoun in our language does not exclusively refer to the male gender, but often can represent humanity as a whole. In other words, it is not exclusively male to say, "He." When a professor says, "Let the one who cheats know that he will be severely punished," he is not just referring to all of the males in the room, but everyone (both male and female). Hence, the male pronouns do not categorize their referents in and of themselves. They need context to do that. Because of this, context can make the male pronouns refer to beings other than males (i.e., females, angels, God), so that when one says, "He (meaning God) is good," no one necessarily assigns gender to God. This is not equally true of female pronouns. When one refers to God as "she," that pronoun exclusively refers to a female gender and nothing else in our language. Hence, the one using male pronouns is not assigning gender to God in our language and the one using female pronouns (whether intentionally or not) is assigning gender to God, making God a female, and thus, lowering God to a finite being with gender distinction.

Now, one can say that he wants to change our language, but that's not my point. My point is that, as of now, our language has one pronoun that both can refer to God in a genderless way and supports His authoritative position over His creation in the best way that it can, and one that does not. Hence, God should never be called "She," and isn't in Scripture beyond analogies that are meant to convey those attributes that are displayed best within the female gender/role.

Hence, the idea that it is unfair to call God "He" and not "She" is misguided. It may have been that pagans, who once assigned gender to their gods, referred to their male gods with male pronouns, but that is not why our culture, with our modern (at least Western) languages do it.

As a final note, some may bring up the idea that the Spirit in the Old Testament is referred to by using female pronouns, but this is also a misunderstanding of language, as the pronouns in Hebrew and Greek follow the gender of the words used, which have nothing to do with the actual, literal gender of the thing the word describes. Spirit in Hebrew is feminine, but Spirit in Greek is neuter. Did He change genders? Of course not. Hebrew has no neuter, so it describes all animals, even male animals with female pronouns, because the word for animal is feminine. Likewise, the word for spirit/wind (xwr) is feminine in Hebrew, so it's pronouns are feminine. The same word in Greek (pneu~ma) is neuter, so it's pronouns are neuter. This has absolutely nothing to do with actual gender of the referent to which the word refers (obviously). Hence, the word for city is feminine, not because cities are females, but because that is simply the "gender" of the word (not the object the word describes). As such, the grammatical gender does not always (or even usually) coincide with the actual gender classification of the referent. I hope that's clear. 


Hence, the answer to the question as to whether it is ever appropriate to use female pronouns to refer to a genderless God, not merely in analogy, but in direct reference to Him, the answer should be, No. But we should always qualify to those who are unaware of the Bible's teaching that God is not a human, and therefore, neither male nor female in and of Himself. Our male pronouns refer to God for purposes of position and because they do not exclusively refer to a particular gender. One could also discuss the fact that God became a man in Christ Jesus in order to represent all of humanity (male and female) in order to bolster the idea that the male represents both authority and all of humanity, rather than his particular gender, and I think in light of the above, that would be appropriate. Christ redeems all of mankind upon the cross because all of mankind (male and female) is represented by the male, both in terms of authority and gender non-exclusion. 


So, no, not a big fan of the trend, and I'm sure to have a silent backlash for it, but I retain the pronouns that I think best fit God, and refrain from the ones that assign Him exclusive classifications that are only appropriate to a particular gender of one of His creatures and deny Him the analogy of authority that are contained within the use of the pronouns themselves.

Saturday, November 12, 2011

Where Womanhood and Careers Do Mesh

I spoke yesterday about the clash of the woman's role and the pursuit of career (as well as the pursuit of all things male and having to do with the male role). From what I said, you may think that I'm totally against women having jobs, but nothing could be further from the truth. I'm against, as the Bible is against, women shunning their womanhood to pursue a career in conflict with it.

If you notice something about the pop-feminist argument, that argues women must employ reproductive technologies in order to suppress their natural functions so that they can compete in the workplace and be considered of equal value with men, it specifically targets younger women who have the potential of becoming pregnant in a relationship were she to allow her biology to function naturally. In other words, pop-feminism didn't just want women to be represented in the workplace. That's a lie that they tell. Plenty of women were represented and can be represented in the workplace, who are older and can no longer have children, or are not married (or in their minds, in a relationship). Pop-feminism doesn't simply want representation. It genuinely sees, and has attempted to convince, women who take upon their biology as women as being weaker and as of lesser value than men. It thus demeans the traditional role of women and acts as if it is a lower or more unfulfilling path to take. In this latter campaign, it was largely successful, as women who used to seek out fulfillment in family to the exclusion of career, were made to believe that they were wasting their lives. And once that seed is planted, there's virtually no removing it from one's entire view of her life.

However, the Bible, obviously would argue that the woman is most fulfilled when she takes upon the role consistent with her biology, not one that would cause her to reject it. Does this mean that she cannot have a career? Not at all. Let me explain.

First and foremost, the Bible would have women see their primary career as motherhood, even when they are not married. Motherhood is who the woman is, so she must always be in training for it when younger and in practice of it when older. When her children are grown, she can adopt children (either literally or figuratively) to disciple and bring up in the Lord. She is always a mentor, a nurturer of younger women and children. Hence, she is always a mother, and this is where she will find her fulfillment.

So the first thing women need to do is to see motherhood as the ultimate career. The problem is that they don't really, even when they say they do. Our culture has placed too many seeds in their minds for them to fully believe that motherhood is the most honorable and fulfilling job for them to spend their time doing in the world. The reason why I say this, is that if they truly believed that it was the most fulfilling and best job in the world, then that would take priority over all else, and it often doesn't. It would be like my saying that God gave me a job to save the world from Nuclear destruction like Jack Bauer, and it is the most important and fulfilling career I can think of, but I also feel like something's missing if I don't go get a job filling out surveys for a ketchup company. There's a disconnect there. So I realize that women say that motherhood is the most fulfilling thing, but what they have been trained to believe in our culture is something quite the opposite.

But does that mean that they cannot have a career? Well, I think I would call any secondary ":career" they got a job, not a career, simply because I think the word "career" denotes a full-on commitment that places itself in conflict with the having and raising of children if it is not the having and raising of children itself. But can women have a secondary job? Sure.

I would break down the women who can have a career and not be in conflict with who they are according to Scripture into four categories: Women who are not married, women who are married but don't have children, women who no longer have kids in the house, and women who can do their job with their children. The latter is the best, as it uses the woman's secondary job as a vehicle to do her primary career, motherhood. In each of these cases, a job is not in conflict with who she is as a woman, and it does not place the family in peril within itself (although there are jobs where the woman is working with other men that may place it in peril from another angle, but that's a post for another day).

However, I would say that it is possible for women to be training themselves to be secondary career women and shunning their role of motherhood if they put too much time and energy while they are young into seeking a career. They might feel that they are giving up so much work that they have accomplished or schooling they have gained, or just simply get used to fulfilling themselves with that job. But to have the job or seek one in and of itself is not in conflict with who she is, as long as she falls into those categories. Of course, the modern practice of sending kids off to school, I think, is contrary to motherhood, as it just assigns the kids the career that takes them away from being mothered, and the mother is left with no motherhood to do during the day. Hence, she takes a job to fill that gap. If the kids are not home, obviously, there is no conflict with who she is by her getting a job, but the very sending off the kids to school, I would argue, is in conflict with it. Hence, we see that how we view schooling is also linked to how we view the career of motherhood and the role of the woman according to her God-given nature.

But let's look at what I think is the best model of motherhood presented in Scripture that incorporates a secondary job. In fact, I would say the type of motherhood that takes upon a secondary job is the best model of motherhood, period. I think the incorporation of a job that allows the woman to raise her children and mentor them while doing the job is the best model. That doesn't always mean she gets paid for the job. For many women, the job is homeschooling, and there is no pay for it. But for others, who either do both or one, they seek out jobs that allow their children to be with them. The job is not an escape from children because they've been brainwashed to think and speak about children as an insanity from which one must pursue every little moment away from them, but a vehicle through which she can spend time with her children and mentor them with as much time as she can muster.

In Proverbs 31:10-31, we have the model of the excellent woman (the word in Hebrew is "woman," which here can mean wife, but the meanings are not as divorced as they are in our culture--a real woman is a wife because she is on her way to expressing her womanhood through motherhood). Notice her commitment to her household first and foremost, and her pursuit of jobs that support her role in the household (doing good to her husband and raising her children--teaching has to do with a daily/continual instruction through both word and deed in the Israelite mindset, not just a teaching here and there).

A real woman, who can find? For her worth is far above jewels. 
The heart of her husband trusts in her, And he will have no lack of gain. 
She does him good and not evil All the days of her life. 
She looks for wool and flax, And works with her hands in delight. 
She is like merchant ships; She brings her food from afar. 
She rises also while it is still night, And gives food to her household, And portions to her maidens. She considers a field and buys it; From her earnings she plants a vineyard. 
She girds herself with strength, And makes her arms strong. 
She senses that her gain is good; Her lamp does not go out at night. 
She stretches out her hands to the distaff, And her hands grasp the spindle. 
She extends her hand to the poor; And she stretches out her hands to the needy. 
She is not afraid of the snow for her household, For all her household are clothed with scarlet. 
She makes coverings for herself; Her clothing is fine linen and purple. 
Her husband is known in the gates, When he sits among the elders of the land. 
She makes linen garments and sells [them,] And supplies belts to the tradesmen. 
Strength and dignity are her clothing, And she smiles at the future. 
She opens her mouth in wisdom, And the teaching of kindness is on her tongue. 
She looks well to the ways of her household, And does not eat the bread of idleness. 
Her children rise up and bless her; Her husband [also,] and he praises her, [saying:] 
"Many daughters have done nobly, But you excel them all." 
Charm is deceitful and beauty is vain, [But] a woman who fears the Lord, she shall be praised. Give her the product of her hands, And let her works praise her in the gates.

This is a working woman. This is far from the helpless, lazy woman that is often painted by pop-feminists as the typical housewife in our culture. Look at all of the stuff this woman does. Look at all of the jobs she has. She is constantly making and selling things. She is involved in real estate transactions. She is a working woman, but all of it is in support of the household both spiritually and financially, not just financially in contrast to the spiritual and daily mentoring of her children, who rise up and bless her, having been taught by the words of wisdom on her lips and the daily example to them while she is working. Notice, "she looks well to the ways of her household." The word here for "looks well" is tsapha, which means "to watch over something closely," which has the connotation in this passage to mean that she is intimately involved and informed of everything going on in her household. In other words, this passage is not in conflict with Titus 2:3-5 that teaches that what is good is a woman loving her children in relationship and being a worker at home. This doesn't mean she can't have a secondary job. It just means that her secondary job should feed into her primary one, rather than detract from it. If it detracts from it, then what needs to go is that secondary job. If they can exist in harmony, in terms of the woman not having to shun her womanhood, either by having to suppress her biology in terms of reproduction or her role that follows from it, then there is no conflict.

Hence, pop-feminism set its sights on women who are not of these categories, precisely, because it had a disdain for true feminism, a hatred of genuine biblical feminism that expressed womanhood in all of its glory. In short, pop-feminism wasn't just trying to represent women in the workplace. It hates women, and wants a womanless world, precisely, because it is an expression of false humanity, the line of Cain, those who shun the image of God and the role of filling up the earth with humans (which is why pop-feminists were also the biggest supporters of the overpopulation myth that was, and is, constantly circulated and recycled time and again).

So the primary career of the woman is motherhood, but there is no conflict with having a secondary job, or jobs, as long as they help her raise her children and "look well to the ways of her household" above all else. In fact, if they help her do that, according to Proverbs 31, secondary jobs may be the way to go to fulfilling the role of motherhood. But if they are taken because of the lies of pop-feminism, they will be taken for the wrong reasons, and looking to diminish womanhood and to exalt manhood, and this is the gnosticism that Christianity, as the beacon of true humanity (i.e., true manhood and womanhood), must fight forever and always.

Friday, November 11, 2011

Feminism or Misogyny? A Lament for the Death of the Woman

Let me ask you a question. If you were a female that had all of the traditional traits of a female, and someone told you that you needed to rid yourself of as many traits that characterize you as female in order to take upon as many traits that characterize males as you possibly can, would you call it "feminism"?

Let's get our minds around this for a moment. Modern feminism (via Margaret Sanger, Gloria Steinem et al.) essentially argued (although I don't think they ever did so explicitly) that if women were ever to be considered as equally valuable as a man, they must pursue the things that men pursue and take upon the same traits as men, as they would then be capable of the same "successes" as men. Once they did so, they would finally assert themselves as equals in all things.

Now, I think their campaign, for the most part, was successful in terms of convincing our society. Women began to (partially) shun their traditional roles as housewives and mothers, they started to wear pants instead of dresses, they shortened their hair, and (most importantly in the minds of many feminists) they began to practice what they considered their reproductive rights (i.e., contraception and abortion). The last of these was considered an essential for any woman who wanted to compete with men in the work place, or even to live as men live, as Margaret Sanger argued, men can have sex with women without consequence, because he can walk away, but the woman cannot walk away from a pregnancy that results from sex. Hence, men are superior to women in their pursuit of pleasure, and women must be as capable of the same feats as men, or (in Sanger's mind) they would not be of equal value. Although people aren't as explicit with this anymore, I recently heard this argument resurrected by a lawyer who said that unless women can have abortions, and she chooses to do that when her career is on the line, she will never be able to compete with men in the workplace. Hence, abortion is necessary for equality. I would add that this was the primary push for contraception by Sanger as well. Contraception makes us all equals because childbearing hinders a woman's progress to become like the male (obviously).

Now, you may have thoroughly drunk the Kool Aid on this one. In fact, I'd be shocked if you hadn't, since our culture no longer questions any of these things. The movement was so successful that these assumptions and the daily practices built upon them have become the norm. No one questions. Like good little workers, they just go about doing, and leave the thinking to the previous generations in whom they place all of their trust and hope that they were smart enough to get it right.

I don't have such trust in the previous generation, especially since that generation ran counter to the entire history of the world, and especially counter to the Bible and Christian doctrine for its entire existence beforehand. So I do question it. I don't care so much about dresses to jeans, although it can express gender distinction. I care a little about length of hair because it does express a gender distinction according to the Bible; but I care a whole lot (obviously) about biological gender distinction and how it evidences the woman's God-given role to play in the world (which I'll discuss below).

Whether or not one has drunk the Kool Aid, however, is one question; but my main contention here is in the name itself, and whatever you believe, I hope that you agree with me that calling a movement that seeks to annihilate every ounce of what makes a woman distinctly a woman so that distinctions can be turned into similarities with the man, should be called anything but "feminism," as this is not a lifting up of women, but a destruction of womanhood altogether.

Now, I believe it is impossible to destroy it altogether, and our culture proves that. Not all of the women who have been duped by pop feminism have ceased from having all children (just most of the children they would have had). They have not all cut off their hair (only those who are trying to become professors in universities as the ideal feminist consistently keep their hair chopped off). They have not all shunned the home life completely (just in terms of attempting to balance it with a career)--our modern school system, where we send our children off for most of the day, helps the woman to do this. But you do see that women in our culture, in general, have come to pursue traditional male roles much more than they had before, some of the younger generation even seeking to talk "like men," which is always so attractive.

So how is this all feminism? If someone told me that I had to change everything distinctively male about me in order that my male characteristics appeared much closer to female characteristics in order to be equally valued, I don't think I would call this "masculinism." It would be absurd for me to do so.

Now, what most feminists will say is that these roles and traits are only traditional, and were made up by men in order to place women in subordinate roles. Of course, that's complete nonsense, and easily refutable, since it is the biology of the man and woman that set them apart and feeds into their roles, not made up traditions. Women are usually the physically weaker sex and it made sense for them to stay at home and do work that did not require you to lift a 200lbs or hunt large animals (yes, it's still work when you're at home--another debunking of the pop-feminist myth that women who stay home are lazy). Men were also adorned with strength for defense of the household. Hence, it made sense to have him go off to war, and the woman to stay home. But the biggest biological factor for the woman, and Sanger as well as other feminists knew this, is the bearing of children. The role of woman is linked to her biology in terms of bearing and raising children. This is not a made up tradition. It is a massive part of who the woman is as a woman.

So ask yourself for a moment. What would naturally occur in the relations of a man and woman without the unnatural obstruction of a foreign agent to hinder what would occur? The woman, according to her nature (i.e., who she is as a woman) would have children. She would produce milk to rear them. Her superior abilities to oversee a household exists for her to raise her children. They are, hence, wasted on a Fortune 500 company, not because the woman can't run that company equal to, or even better than, a man, but because that is not what she was meant to do with those abilities.

Again, you may not like where this is going, but why in the world would you call a movement that argues against exalting the biology of the woman and supports her suppression of her biology "feminism"? It's simply the opposite. Women today have been trained well that they are worth less than those who make a name for themselves as men do in the workplace, or accentuate their submissive femininity versus being a "smart and strong person" (which I guess means taking a dominant posture like a male), and so they have become true believers, unlikely to ever return to the days when women were most satisfied and pleased to be women.

For those of us who are true feminists, and I have always considered myself as such (having come away from the pop-feminism I thoroughly believed as a child--in fact, I used to believe that women were better than men and hence should run everything), it is truly a sad thing to see angels fall to earth in order to become equals with dogs (no offense intended toward my own gender). But the woman is a sacred creature. Within her alone does the God of the universe still create. I've always said that if we knew where Eden was, the place of God's creation, we would build a shrine around it. Millions, if not billions, would sojourn there for the mere chance to gaze upon it, or even, if they dare, touch it. We would do all this because we would know that the hand of God had touched that sacred place. Yet, that place is gone, but there is one place that remains upon the earth where God still creates, where His hand has still touched, and that is inside the woman when He creates in her a child (Gen 4:1; Exod 4:11; Job 31:15; Ps 139:13). Is her womanhood not sacred, and is it not therefore true that she who accentuates her womanhood is sacred? In other words, isn't it rather true that feminism exalts the woman in her distinctiveness, not in her similarity with the man? Isn't it rather true that she loses her sacredness when she is told to lose her distinctiveness or even to try to hold onto both, as one must give way to the other at any given moment (i.e., you can have children or a career at moment x, y, and z; but most modern careers do not allow you to have both within those same moments of time).

What I'm saying is not going to change our culture. It's not going to change your mind if your life is steeped deep into the muck and mire of pop-feminism (usually in practice, since theory was the duty you gave to your twentieth century forebears). To some extent, there's nothing we can do now in terms of our society as a whole. We simply have to make accommodations for the way things are in our own lives and in the lives of others. We've just lost what was vital to us, and we await its ever increasing consequences. So I'm really just asking you to mourn with me the loss of something sacred-- perhaps, our most sacred creature of all. She was God's final answer to a humanless world when no other creature could accomplish her task. She was the hand that rocks the cradle, and through it, ruled the world in a very different way than the way of the man (a far more powerful way than the path of the man's). Behold, the ruler of the household is gone. The salvation of our children's world is missing. She has left us because we treated her poorly. We knew not what she was, so she became what we are, and now the society fastened by the bolts of her work sinks in ruin. She can do our work better than we can, but we cannot do hers. No one can. There is no replacement that will do. She was unique among all God's creation. And because, as fools, we did not celebrate her, she will no longer hold our world together.

Whatever pop-feminism is, it isn't feminism. One who seeks to annihilate the distinctions of the female can never be considered such by thinking people, but this philosophy thrives upon people not thinking. Our task now, as Christians, is to mourn our losses, seek out a recovery within the Christian subculture that unthinkingly has adopted much of these male chauvinistic assumptions, and begin to celebrate and honor women (starting with our wives) at home. We need to shun all demeaning language or insinuations that would assume the falsehoods of pop-feminism that celebrates every small move a woman makes in becoming more like a man, and begin to speak well of women who do the good of God in the world by having and raising children as the managers of the household. If we fail to exalt the woman in her "distinctives" as a woman, we are no better than the preachers of pop-feminism who worked hard to destroy the ordered world and return it to a less humanly filled (working toward a chaotic/humanless) state.

And that is really the key here. Christianity has always stood against the religion of self that pervades our culture, that gnosticism that seeks to shun the image of God in order to represent itself as superior. It was the much celebrated, gnostic Gospel of Thomas in our culture that argued that women would only be worthy of salvation if they were turned into men. Christianity, of course, would say the exact opposite (1 Tim 2:15; 5:9-10; Titus 2:3-5). The more of a woman she becomes, the more worthy she becomes, because her true humanity (i.e., that which is created to function as a submissive representative of God that works toward a human-filled world) can only be expressed through her femininity (i.e., her female biology). It is the gnostics who wanted to divorce body and soul, the expression of humanity through gender from humanity, which was seen as essentially male, itself). Hence, our gnostic culture hates women because it hates children. It hates children because it hates women. The two are inseparable. In gnosticism, women either comply and refuse their biology in order to become like men, or they are seen as objects, void of souls, to use and abuse for the pleasure of men. Sound familiar? It's not a mere coincidence that you have such an acceptance of pornography in a culture that pushes so forcefully for pop-feminism (even as pop-feminists protest it), since pop-feminism itself feeds into the mentality that creates it. But we who have seen the truth of Scripture are not gnostics, and I refuse to call what is utterly misogynistic "feminism" ever again. I hope you'll join me.

Thursday, November 10, 2011

Some Brief Comments on the Nature of Inspiration and Inerrancy

My little two year old, Andrew, likes this annoying show called "Dino Dan," which is about this 8 year old dinosaur "expert," Dan, who tells everyone about Dinosaurs. Rest assured, if you're with Dan in a conversation about the weather, the economy, or any other subject matter, he'll be sure to turn it into a discussion about dinosaurs. In fact, if you make a comment about a dinosaur, he'll correct you if you make a statement that is not technically correct, even if the assertion you were making wasn't about the nature of the fact. And this is precisely why he's annoying, as language requires a give and take from both the speaker and the listener to grasp the intended assertion being made by the other participant. When one corrects technicalities that have nothing to do with the intended assertion being made, this participant is no longer cooperating, and is only seeking to prove you wrong and puff himself up. In fact, communication at this point becomes nearly impossible, unless both participants are omniscient, and have no need to make room for communicative accommodation for one another.

In other words, we're not 100% correct about everything we say, nor do we have as our purpose to be absolutely 100% correct in every statement made, since multiple statements are made to communicate a single point, not multiple points. Let me give you an example of this from our beloved Dan.

There is one episode where a pterosaur is lose in the Attic, and Dan's Mom comes down to tell Dan by saying, "There's a flying dinosaur lose in the attic." Now, Dan's Mom has just committed the unpardonable sin for Dan and those like him who need omniscience displayed in every assertion made in order to feel right with themselves, so he corrects his Mom by pointing out to her that such an animal is not a dinosaur, but a pterosaur. Forget the fact that Dan's Mom's assertion had nothing to do with classifying the animal. It's almost a shame that it wasn't a T-Rex about to eat Dan, and his Mom had called it a giant lizard.. Dan could then begin to correct his Mom that many paleontologists believe dinosaurs actually are closer to birds than reptiles right before the animal devoured him (I know that's a bit grim, but you need to watch the show to get the full flavor of my disgust).

What Dan is engaging in is a disruption of communication, not a clarification of it. That's why it's so ridiculously annoying. He's setting up rabbit trails that will take more time in the end, and lead people away from the originally intended message of the speaker than if he were to just accommodate the speaker and cooperate with her. Does his mom really need to be corrected about the correct classification of the animal when the intent of her message is to convey that a prehistoric animal is in their attic? Especially so, since Dan knows exactly what she means, and her communication is clear to him, even though it does not display omniscience.

I find this same attitude in discussions of the Bible's inerrancy. When most errantists want to argue that the Bible is errant, they pick up technicalities of language, as though the omniscience of God must be displayed in every statement made by the human author, thus transferring omniscience to the author himself. But this is not what the doctrine of inerrancy requires at all to be true. It has nothing to do with every statement made, but with every truth asserted. That's an important point. Don't miss it. Inerrancy is in the message(s) the Bible teaches, not everything a human author believes about the world, history, lexicographical methodology, authorship, etc. All of these are simply apart of the presentation of the message(s) of Scripture, not the message(s) itself/themselves. In other words, God accommodates to the understanding of the human author and his audience as non-omniscient humans, and participates in cooperation with us in order to convey/assert what is true. What is being asserted as true is the message. Let me give you an example of this from Scripture that some errantists often bring up:

In First Corinthians 10:4, Paul refers to a Second Temple tradition that the Israelites were followed by the rock that produced water in the wilderness. Hence, a rock that Moses strikes to get water appears twice in the journey, even though it is in different places, precisely, because it is following them around. He states:

and all drank the same spiritual drink, for they were drinking from a spiritual rock which followed them; and the rock was Christ.

Now, is the allusion to the tradition the assertion that is being made here? In other words, is that what Paul's point is, or is it something else that is simply presented with the tradition as a point of connection with his audience. In other words, we must find Paul's point first and then ask if what he's purposing to teach the Corinthians in this passage is a history lesson about this rock. The answer is obviously, No. Yet, if that is not his purpose, why would anyone say that the text here is in error? How does one make an error in what he does not seek to communicate, other than a technical error that is irrelevant in terms of what he is communicating? If we look at the whole passage, it clearly is using the tradition to make a point about being in the presence of Christ, and yet not being saved (see vv. 1-12). That's his message. That's the divine message. Not the details he uses to present it. They exist only to communicate the message accurately to the audience that fully understands the point with the language used. And that is the point. Language/communication is filled with technical inaccuracies, mythological allusions, half-truths, simply because we're not omniscient, nor do we all share the same level of knowledge even with each other. Hence, in order to actually communicate with one another, we need to speak each other's language. If we fail to do so, we fail to communicate, and if that communication is important, a matter of life or death, then Dan is, and we are, going to be a snack for Big Bird.

Inspiration, the Scripture as "God-breathed," then, is God directing the words that are used to convey that message accurately, but has nothing to do with conveying it in the same cookie-cutter way, or even in the same place. Since a truth can be communicated in a million different ways, there is no need for absolute conformity in its expression, only success in its communication (which means to not accommodate in one's language is to fail to communicate truth). Likewise, it does not require absolute preservation of the exact wording or placement of the text (as some textual critics who believe in errancy require). Perhaps, the Pericope Adulterae (i.e., the passage about the woman who was caught in adultery) was in John. Maybe it was in Luke. Or maybe it wasn't in the Bible at all. Does that mean that I won't know that Jesus has compassion on sinners, or that He is forgiving, or that He didn't come to condemn the world but to save it? I think you know, if you are even somewhat familiar with the Bible, that all of those things are conveyed all over the place in the Gospels and throughout Scripture, so if the same message is conveyed with the Pericope in John, Luke, or missing, who cares? The point is that the Scripture is fully intact and preserved because it exists in its message(s). Inspiration simply exists to make sure that the ways it is conveyed (and there are many) accurately convey it. Hence, inerrancy is the logical outflow of inspiration.

Now, omniscience is displayed in the message (and we can believe or disbelieve it), as it conveys absolute truth, but it need not be displayed in the process of communication of the message in terms of straightening out every detail, as that would be obstructive to the understanding of both the human author and the reader/hearer, and would lead to an infinitely long book, which is a complete absurdity. God is not a God of confusion and disorder in terms of communication, and hence, He would not be trying to confuse His people with a bunch of (truly) endless rabbit trails/technical corrections. In fact, we must realize that we are not omniscient in everything we believe, and therefore, God's technical corrections have the possibility of being infinite. Try putting that in a book that contains a message necessary for finite beings to grasp in order to be saved by, know, and please God. The mere prospect becomes an absurdity to suggest, and yet, this precisely what many errantists want from the Bible, and if it doesn't produce such a ridiculous thing as an omniscient text, a text that would ultimately damn everyone, since no one would be able to get the necessary message(s) that were hidden in a sea of infinite corrections, then they refuse to give the Bible the status of being inerrant. Bah, Humbug! (I thought that was an appropriate response as we enter the Christmas Season.)

I don't care if Mark cited one author and quoted another. I don't care if Jacob believed painting poles a certain color could change the color of his sheep. I don't care if the biblical authors didn't believe the earth went around the sun instead of vice versa. That has absolutely nothing to do with what these texts are asserting as true in terms of their message. They make up the human package or presentation of the divine message. They are not the divine message in and of themselves, as they are not being asserted as true in context. The divine message(s) are what is inerrant. As long as it is understood within those presentations, whether the presentations are technically correct if we removed them from their purpose and then artificially set them up as individual assertions, is irrelevant to the actual message(s) being conveyed in context. So, no, Dan, I don't care if Jonah was swallowed by a whale or a fish. That's not the point. And btw, a flying dinosaur is swooping down and about to eat you for lunch. Care to correct me on my technical misinformation, or care to participate cooperatively and grasp the intended assertion I'm making in that statement?

It's time for both Dan and errantists to take the GRE exam and learn the difference between the sections on mathematics/analytical thinking and reading comprehension. One is concerned with technicalities and one is concerned with communication. They are not one and the same.

So if Paul actually believes that a rock followed the Israelites around in the desert, or if he's just using that figuratively, so be it. But if we miss the inerrant and authoritative message that he actually intends to convey, then we do so to our own peril (and willful obliviousness to how communication actually works).

As for me, I'd actually like to save myself from being eaten for lunch, so I don't really care if Dan's Mom calls it a dinosaur, pterosaur, or alien-monster with teeth, I choose to participate cooperatively with her and get the message being conveyed, and I'm going to respond accordingly. As for the Dans of this world, who refuse to cooperate and only wish to obstruct communication? Well, animals have to eat, don't they?

In short, when the lifeguard throws me a lifeline, I don't bother correcting him when he says, "Grab the Bobber," rather than "Grab the preserver" by saying, "Well, it's technically not called a 'bobber' per se, so I can't really trust what you've thrown to me will save me." Sounds like a solid argument, Genius, C'est la vie!

It reminds me of a guy who once said that, due to a grammatical error I once made, he couldn't trust that I knew what I was talking about when it came to the Bible. "Really?" I said, "Do you also speed up when the 'p' is missing from the 'Stop' sign?" As we can see, all that is necessary for the Bible to function as the inerrant authority of our lives is the sufficient accessibility of the language used to allow the speaker and listener to cooperate with one another so that what is intended to be communicated actually is. As such, we can easily see why hell is full of grammarians and Dino Dans, who missed the forest because they thought that some of the trees weren't planted as firmly in the ground as they ought to have been.

With my lips I have told of all the ordinances of Thy mouth. (Ps 119:13)

Monday, November 7, 2011

Does the Bible Contradict Itself?

 There is a great scene in "The Lord of the Rings," where Galadriel gives Frodo the light of Eärendil, and blesses him with it so that it may be "a light for you in dark places, when all other lights go out." This light actually saves his life. Even when he no longer holds it, a friend (i.e., Sam) comes and shines it and delivers him from death with it. I've always wondered if Tolkien took this from the Bible, as it says many similar things about itself in terms of being a lamp to our feet and a light in dark places.

The surest path to a forsaken faith (either partially or en toto), or to have your light go out, however, is to believe that the Bible contradicts itself, which is really a transfer of belief from thinking that the Bible is primarily a divine document to a primarily human one. The more human we make the Bible, it seems, the more we feel comfortable dismissing it, or at the very least, diminishing its authority in our lives. But Christianity, and the Bible itself, has never pretended to be anything other than a Divinely inspired book of humans, or a humanly written book of God. When God actually speaks through humans, there is no reason to pretend that it fell out of heaven on golden plates or was written by angels or by men who were seized and merely wrote in a mechanical fashion via dictated words that expressed nothing of themselves in the text. In other words, when you're a document that actually is the Word of God, you don't need to make yourself pretty enough to fool the masses. You have power in and of yourself, and complete confidence and security that you will accomplish exactly what God desires you to accomplish.

This is important to note when we discuss whether the Bible contradicts itself, because in all actuality, it only does so if one believes that it does. In the same way, these variations are complementary only if one believes they are as well. I'm speaking, of course, in the ultimate sense, when the entire canon is considered. Either the variations and diversity complements and clarifies or it contradicts itself. Of course, even contradiction can be used as complementation and clarification, but in the ultimate sense, both take faith as their presupposition.

And that is the point. Both take faith. Neither one can grasp the reality of the text without it. One must disbelieve that the Bible is divinely inspired in everything it teaches, and hence, believe (i.e., have blind faith) that the Bible is a solely or primarily a human document in order to see ultimate contradiction. Likewise, one must believe that it is divinely inspired in all that it teaches and thus believe that it never contradicts itself in the ultimate sense, since God never contradicts Himself and is One in order to see clarification and complementation.

But the question becomes, Why would God fill the Scripture with so much variation that so many unbelievers can just see it as contradiction? Doesn't God want everyone to believe?

Well the short answer to that is, No, He doesn't. That's clear in Scripture. Which leads me to the long answer: The Bible is set up much like the parables are in Jesus' ministry. It functions as a message for the unbelieving who read it to see but not see, to hear but not hear. But let's back up, as you may have not been aware that the parables in Jesus' ministry were meant to hide the truth from the unbelieving, not necessarily in a way that they would not always be able to get what the parable was saying, but in a way of expressing God's rejection of anyone who would approach Him in arrogant self-trust and unbelief.

So let's look at the very reason Christ gives parables to the people, as many believe that parables were meant to clarify truth and help the masses understand God's truths through stories. Christ does use them as such in a way, but only because He clarifies the teachings of the stories with direct propositions that explain them. These explanations, however, are only given to the disciples. To the unbelieving masses, who approach in unbelief and distrust, the parables function only as a condemnation of their unbelief:


And the disciples came and said to Him, "Why do You speak to them in  parables ?" And He answered and said to them, "To you it has been granted to know the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven, but to them it has not been granted. "For whoever has, to him shall [more] be given, and he shall have an abundance; but whoever does not have, even what he has shall be taken away from him. "Therefore I speak to them in  parables ; because while seeing they do not see, and while hearing they do not hear, nor do they understand.  "And in their case the prophecy of Isaiah is being fulfilled, which says,  'You will keep on hearing, but will not understand; And you will keep on seeing, but will not perceive; For the heart of this people has become dull, And with their ears they scarcely hear, And they have closed their eyes Lest they should see with their eyes, And hear with their ears, And understand with their heart and return, And I should heal them.'  "But blessed are your eyes, because they see; and your ears, because they hear. (Matt 13:10-16)

All of the gospels, including John, which is not a Synoptic, repeats this in one way or another. The parables are meant to confuse the unbelieving about the truth. They are not meant to clarify and explain truth to them. God does not give truth to those who do not believe. He causes them to be deceived further. He causes them to be utterly convinced of what is false (2 Thes 2:11-12).
Hence, "he who has an ear to hear, let him hear" is a continual phrase that Christ repeats because what He says concerning God is only for those who have been given an ear to hear, i.e., those who believe. Notice, in the Matthew passage that the disciples, who believe, are said to be blessed because they are allowed to get it. The parables, for them, are clarified and explained by direct propositional statements, not by stories. (As an aside, I find it interesting that the pomo church is so interested in stories, rather than propositions, when the stories without propositions are meant only to confuse the masses.)

Even the signs Christ performed could not open the eyes that God had shut because of their unbelief (John 12:37-43). So it is clear that God Himself does not want to teach truth to everyone. He does not want everyone to "get it." But instead, He only seeks to communicate clearly to those who completely believe, those who trust in Him above themselves.

I would say the same thing for the entire Bible. I think that the Scripture is set up this way, so that there are things in it that cause those who would not completely give themselves over to God to stumble and fall. I think it is written in such a way, through humans, as to be convincing to those who disbelieve to be solely or primarily just a human document, but also written in such a way so as to be primarily a divine document written through humans to those who believe. In other words, it is both a faith builder and a faith destroyer all in itself, depending upon how one approaches it. If approached in faith, it builds and brings one closer to the truth. If approached in disbelief, it destroys and removes one further from it. The man who believes receives all, and the man who doubts (in a way that places faith in himself over God)  receives nothing.

So what is the answer to the question, Does the Bible contradict itself? The answer is, It depends upon who you are, and with what faith or lack thereof you approach it. As James says, "Let not that man [i.e., the man who doubts and does not approach God in trust] expect that he will receive anything from the Lord" (1:7).

For those who believe, however, the Bible's variations function as clarifications and complementations of the other truths that are set beside them. In this way, these clarifications bring us into further truth, because they help us understand other truths more clearly. For those who disbelieve, these are contradictions that confuse and fog up the unbelievers grasp of truth, but for those who believe, they clear up the skies and allow us to see the Son all the more.

For me, the Bible never contradicts itself in what it teaches. It is "a lamp shining in a dark place, until the day dawns and the morning star arises in your hearts" (2 Pet 1:19). As for me, it has always been a brightly shining light in a very dark, dark world; but that's because the Lord has granted belief to me. Without His mercy upon me, I would be lost in confusion and darkness, and the Bible would be a host of human contradiction, making no sense to me. My hope for you is to have the same mercy from God that would grant you belief. So pick up your Bible and believe, so that it may be "a light for you in dark places when all other lights go out."