Monday, October 17, 2011

The Gospel According to King Kong

This is a scene from the movie, “King Kong” from 1976. Jeff Bridges’ and Jessica Lange’s characters are arguing with Charles Grodin’s character about capturing the large ape and taking him away from the island.

Grodin (to Lange’s character): “And before you cry a lot, you ought to ask the natives on that island what they thought of losing Kong.”

Bridges: “Actually, they’ll miss him a lot.”

Grodin: “Like leprosy.”

Bridges: “No, you’re dead wrong. He was the terror, the mystery of their lives, and the magic. A year from now, that’ll be an island of burnt out drunks. When we took Kong, we kidnapped their god.”

This, to me, sounds very Nietzschean, and very true. Nietzsche understood well what his atheism would do to society. He believed it was true anyway, but didn’t try to sell his idea with contradictory ideas of scientific moralities or attempting to argue that there was even more meaning to life in atheism than there is in a theistic world. That is the absurdity of neo-atheism, but Nietzsche wasn’t a neo-atheist. He understood that to take God out of life was like unchaining the earth from the sun. It would destroy any real meaning we once thought life had. Without God, we’re all just a bunch of burnt out drunks, filled with the toxin of our own narcissism, without meaning in life, morality, or thought. Steal God away, steal the world away too. Whether related or not to his outlook on life, Nietzsche eventually went mad.

But I don’t want to simply discuss philosophical atheism, because most people don’t live there. Philosophical atheism is for people who are overly credentialed (in their own minds) and undereducated (in reality). What I want to discuss instead is practical atheism, and how, even though that is where most of us live, it’s not a real option for us.

You see, you can’t just pick and choose between both worlds, the one born of atheistic assumptions and the one born of theistic ones. Either God exists and He is the ultimate purpose of everything, everything has its life and meaning in His presence, or He does not exist and nothing has meaning, and you can go about living life for you and those pets and playthings in life that give you the most pleasure. Either God has communicated to us through revelation what is true and what is good, so as to fill our daily pursuits with meaning, or there is no revelation from God, just the opinions of people seeking to dominate one another in the evolutionary struggle to be king of the hill, so that we can finally do whatever we wish. Freedom is either found in God or in us. There is no in between. I cannot sometimes find life and meaning in God and sometimes find it in a life lived apart from Him. I am switching back and forth between two worlds (one of which does not exist) rather than stop and ask myself which is true.

And maybe that’s it. Maybe, people don’t know what’s true. They’re confused by multiple voices, so that in case there is no God, they don’t want to miss out on the world, and in case there is, they don’t want to take Him out of life either. But all life choices boil down to a decision based upon one of those two worlds. All meaning or lack thereof is gained from one or the other. To dictate which world I wish to choose in the decisions I will make in life is to live a life of practical atheism already. It is to do this because, in a theistic world, God is the center of all things, not some things, nor is choosing whatever you want, and sometimes using God to do so, a theistic practice. It is a narcissistic practice, one that assumes atheism. The idea of God then is just something the individual is blindly toying with, simply because he doesn’t want to lose his backup, but he is, at all times, an atheist when he jumps in between worlds in accordance with his own desires, absent of consideration of the will of that God in whom he occasionally believes.

My point is simply this: If God exists then all meaning is in Him. His will ought to take precedent over every decision in life, not just some.  If He doesn’t, there is no meaning or purpose to life. “Eat, drink, and be merry, for tomorrow you die.” But you’re not really swaying back and forth between the two, because to do so is really to evidence the adoption of the latter philosophy to the rejection of the former.

In other words, you’re either all in or all out. You can’t live your life the way you want to and bring God in the backdoor to give it meaning. Such is the stuff of the mixed, and mixed up, American religion, but it is not the stuff of reality/logical consistency. If God is to be taken out, then you are free to live your worthless life for whatever meaningless and illusory purpose you only perceive as fitting. If God exists, we have obligations to Him, to others, and to ourselves to fill up every part of our lives with Him without fail.

Bridges was right about one thing. We, through our adoption of practical atheism, through our allowing the culture to kidnap God from us, have become an island of burnt out drunks. All hope and meaning has been stolen from us. The transition is complete. We are the perfect consumers now. We can be dominated by more aggressive animals seeking to convince us of our purposelessness, so that we can then fill that void with the next great product. We can live as animals that have no cognitive purpose, only a drive, in their sexual appetites. We can just party until we’re finished and then put a bullet in our brains. You may have sympathy for those who do so, but your sympathy has no sense either. It’s only you empathizing with another human, but what are humans as opposed to fleas? Would you empathize with a flea?

Yet, to those who believe in a theistic world, where God has sent His Son to truly set us free from the enslavement of the narcissism of practical atheism, the world describe above is nothing short of a prison, a hell on earth. And we don’t want to live in hell. And I’ll bet that there is some still small voice that's faintly telling you that you don’t want to live there anymore either. So don’t. Get rid of the swing between two worlds and start moving toward the one that brings life and meaning and hope, not simply because you want to feel better, but because it’s true, and it presents itself as true through the fruit it produces in our lives and in our society. Don’t let God be kidnapped from your world any longer. Don’t let the terror and the mystery and the magic of His reality be diminished by some promise of greater freedom. Freedom and meaninglessness just don’t go together, so stop assuming two contradictory worldviews in your feeble attempt to combine them. You may think that you’re relieving yourself from a life of being dominated, but you’re only relieving yourself of being dominated by a good God that brings life and meaning in His dominion over you. Once you do remove Him, you will still be dominated, only by unreasoning animals who seek to use you for their own purposes and pleasure to the sacrifice of your soul. Better to be unshackled by God’s intimidating presence than to be imprisoned with the freedom of atheism—at least, that’s what all those burnt out drunks would tell you.

No Graven Image: This Includes Jesus

Steve Hays and I started discussing whether images of Jesus violate the 2d Commandment. He seems to argue that they do not (or at least, they don't always do this). I argue that they always violate it, since the very command is to not make an image of deity, rather than existing as a prohibition of using an image of deity inappropriately. My responses are getting too large for the comment boxes, so I just thought I would move it over here. Of course, this is the worst possible time for me to enter into a long discussion (and this discussion likely warrants something that would take more time than I am willing to give it right now), since I need to get all of my stuff into Princeton within three weeks, but Steve is a brilliant young philosopher, and I thought I would see if iron could sharpen iron here. As my time is allotted to other things, however, I may not be able to give it much more than I have already. At some point, I'd like to go through a literary study of the Gospel of John and note the primary argument John is making about how we access Christ in terms of the Sinai Theology of the OT as it is applied to NT revelation. So here is the first of our exchanges and then my latest response.

Blogger B. C. Hodge said:
I'll raise the violation. A picture of Jesus that is not actually Jesus is still a violation of the 2d commandment in the same sense that an image of a golden calf is not an actual image of YHWH, and yet it violates it. This is where speculative philosophy needs to take a backseat to Scripture. The Sinai Theology of Exodus and DtrH is extended to Jesus in the Gospel of John. We cannot truly believe through sight, and it takes our identity as Christ followers gained from following Him through His Words and places it in the imaginative pictures we produce of Him in our mind's eye (which is why YHWH rejected an image as representing Him in the OT.
10/16/2011 4:51 PM  
 
Blogger steve said:
Is the golden calf unlawful because it doesn't actually represent Yahweh, or because it actually misrepresents Yahweh? Keep in mind that a bovine image isn't inherently sacrilegious. For instance, a veterinary school might have diagrams of bovine anatomy. That wouldn't violate the 2nd commandment.
10/16/2011 5:01 PM  
 
Blogger B. C. Hodge said:
It's wrong because it's meant to represent Him, not depict Him (just like most idols in the ancient Near East). So it is the representative role of an image that seeks to fill in for the god's presence, and it is through that image that one carries on the relationship. In biblical religion, YHWH replaces the images with what He speaks, so that people must have a relationship with Him through that instead. Apart from it, a false relationship is formed (and the Bible seems to set these as conflicting trajectories to where we would not be able to combine both together). This is then extended to Jesus (hence, He is called the Word, we are to listen to the words that He speaks, He alone has words of eternal life, we are to obey His commandments, a little while and we will see Him no longer--and then, through His words, we will really "see" Him, we are to be sanctified in truth,which is God's Word, etc.). So the commandment is not the making of any image (as would be the case in the making of a bovine image for medical reasons), but for purposes of knowing something about, and knowing, the deity through representation. The golden calf doesn't misrepresent the aspect about YHWH it attempts to convey. It's actually the perfect image for what God has been telling them thus far about Himself (He is strong and will bring them into a fertile land--i.e., strength and fertility are its primary aspects and they represent YHWH well). The problem is that they take men away from worshiping God in spirit and in truth (i.e., through what He has spoken).
10/16/2011 5:10 PM   
Blogger steve said:
B. C. HODGE SAID: "It's wrong because it's meant to represent Him, not depict Him." That distinction is not self-explanatory. Are you using "represent" in a symbolic rather than descriptive sense? I.e. the image plays a surrogate function? "In biblical religion, YHWH replaces the images with what He speaks, so that people must have a relationship with Him through that instead. Apart from it, a false relationship is formed (and the Bible seems to set these as conflicting trajectories to where we would not be able to combine both together). This is then extended to Jesus (hence, He is called the Word, we are to listen to the words that He speaks, He alone has words of eternal life, we are to obey His commandments, a little while and we will see Him no longer--and then, through His words, we will really "see" Him, we are to be sanctified in truth,which is God's Word, etc.)." But in the Gospels we have event-media as well as word-media. Christ reveals himself through emblematic miracles as well as spoken words. Dominical miracles are a type of sign language. Concrete, enacted parables "The golden calf doesn't misrepresent the aspect about YHWH it attempts to convey. It's actually the perfect image for what God has been telling them thus far about Himself (He is strong and will bring them into a fertile land--i.e., strength and fertility are its primary aspects and they represent YHWH well). The problem is that they take men away from worshiping God in spirit and in truth (i.e., through what He has spoken)." But in Exodus-Deuteronomy, Yahweh also reveals himself through theophanies and emblematic miracles. Not to mention the tabernacle, furnishings thereof, priestly vestments, &c. So it's directed at the eye no less than the ear. As such, I don't see any trajectory away from the visual.
10/16/2011 6:43 PM  
 
Blogger steve said:
Likewise, take the Apocalypse. That's the capstone of progressive revelation, so it comes at the tail-end of any trajectory. Yet it's a throwback to visionary revelation. Yes, it's a verbal record, but the words form word-pictures. Appealing to the reader's imagination. And that includes pictorial descriptions of Jesus, beginning with the graphic Christophany in Rev 1, as well as the warrior-king in Rev 19.
10/16/2011 7:21 PM  
I missed this objection before. Note that I make a distinction between image and imagery, one of sight and one of hearing. Both place images in the mind, but one causes the individual to have to hear it. In Sinai Theology, the act of hearing/obeying or adhering to what is spoken is the means provided to know God in relationship. So the issue isn't pictures created in the mind, but how those pictures are created, and whether they replace a relationship with the true God through what is spoken.
 
Blogger B. C. Hodge said:
"That distinction is not self-explanatory. Are you using "represent" in a symbolic rather than descriptive sense? I.e. the image plays a surrogate function?" Well, it depends upon how we define "surrogate" and "symbolic"; but, yes, I'm using "represent" as the vehicle through which one knows and worships the deity. In some cases, it is symbolic. In others (as in our present day), it often is meant to depict. Either one is rejected by Sinai Theology. "But in the Gospels we have event-media as well as word-media. Christ reveals himself through emblematic miracles as well as spoken words. Dominical miracles are a type of sign language. Concrete, enacted parables." Christ actually doesn't reveal Himself through event media (unless you're talking about His work on the cross as a communication of His love, etc., but we know of those works through the spoken Word, and they are interpreted therein for us, so even they are subject to the interpretation of "God's Word" to us, i.e., we must come to them through hearing the Word, not through our sense of sight that takes hold of those events as they are). John's point seems to be that He reveals Himself salvifically through word only. Without word, Jesus is just another miracle worker who was executed by the Romans. Miracles point to Him as verification for those who already believe, but they do not reveal Him. So, of course, they communicate something, but we don't know Jesus from BarJesus through miracles. There are numerous false prophets in the world, who also do miracles. This doesn't reveal who they are. It is the message that accompanies those miracles. This is one of John's main points (throughout his writings). Jesus reveals the Father through His words. Belief in miracles is superficial belief and must come to maturation in believing what is spoken (or it is deemed false). Of course, it would take a commentary to show all of that. I don't expect you to agree with me just by my stating it. I'm only saying that this objection is worked out. In any case, I'm not arguing that the Bible would remove all sight, but all images of God that are meant to function as vehicles through which we commune with God. That which accompanies the Word are images, but not images of God. They are images of other things. (cont.)
10/16/2011 7:52 PM  
Blogger B. C. Hodge said:
(cont.) "But in Exodus-Deuteronomy, Yahweh also reveals himself through theophanies and emblematic miracles. Not to mention the tabernacle, furnishings thereof, priestly vestments, &c. So it's directed at the eye no less than the ear. As such, I don't see any trajectory away from the visual." My argument wasn't that there is a trajectory from all physical symbols that accompany God's revelation, but a incompatible trajectory (for fallen man at least) of worshiping God through both word and image (each attempting to represent His Person and receive His presence). Obviously, the Scripture is filled with reports of physical images, but if they're of God, then they are condemned, not praised. Finally, God's theophanies in the OT are not meant to reveal Him, they are meant to hide Him, and those narratives make that clear (as a side, most of what people consider theophanies in Scripture actually aren't physical appearances, but highly symbolic visions where the reader must hear the prophetically-reported Word to think about them. Hence, when God says in Deuteronomy (4:1-20)that they only saw clouds of smoke and fire (in one of the only real theophanies in the OT), He also says they saw no form--thus making the point that the theophany is not an image, but a cloaking of the divine essence. What you need to do, Steve, is show how your arguments above don't undermine what God is saying in Deut 4. Couldn't I just come back at God and say, "Well, You use images in the tabernacle, so images representing You can't be all bad." But I don't think what God is saying is that we should go blind and use nothing visual. Rather, I think His point is that we should not think of Him in a physical manner, but instead think of Him through what He has revealed about Himself. Hence, the person who thinks he has a relationship with Jesus because he prays to a seventeenth century depiction of a Spaniard as representing Jesus isn't praying to Jesus, not because Jesus may not have looked like that Spaniard, but because Jesus doesn't accept that form of worship. It must be through spirit (i.e., the unseen) and truth (i.e., via hearing). All other visuals must support that trajectory, and according to Scripture, physical images of the divine work against it for us.   My Latest Response:
"Actually, he does reveal himself through event-media. For instance, the miracle of Cana is explicitly said to be revelatory.”
It says that the miracles done in Cana reveal His glory, not His Person and Work. This is like the heavens revealing the glory of God. They don’t reveal God in distinction from any other god, and yet, one must know the true God and Jesus Christ whom He has sent in order to have eternal life (John 17:3). It is through words that this eternal life, i.e., that this relationship must come to us (6:68). Hence, John ends up arguing (and quoting Jesus) that what is seen is a hindrance to true faith that must come through hearing what is spoken.
“To take a few more examples, the multiplication of loaves and fish illustrate the fact that Jesus is the bread of life. The healing of the blind man illustrates the fact that Jesus is the light of the world. The raising of Lazarus illustrates the fact that Jesus is the resurrection and the life."
How do you know any of these events illustrate anything? You're getting that from the Word of God. But, again, I don't want to argue this point, simply because miracles are what accompany the word that serves as YHWH’s/Jesus’ “image.” So let me just concede the point for argument’s sake and ask, So what? Are miracles an image of deity? I've stated that the Bible has a problem with images of deity, not images in general. It has a problem with seeing God, not seeing what God does. I would still maintain that miracles are not sufficiently revelatory (and maybe that was my fault for not including the word “sufficiently,” and making it clear that I’m using “revelatory” in the sense of what reveals in distinction from something else), and "signs" refer to verification of the word to those who already believe, not revelations that point to who Jesus is. John continually contrasts faith in word versus faith by sight (and miracles play a role in faith by sight, which is seen as insufficient and even works against those who do not already believe via word). He doesn’t present them as revealing nothing, but he presents them as insufficient to reveal God, and when one’s faith in miracles is taken apart from that revelation, as evidencing superficial or false belief. But I want to stay on my actual argument. Images of deity are always condemned throughout the OT and NT, as that which leads away from the Word rather than supporting or leading to it.
So miracles like these reveal the person and work of Christ. That’s what makes them “signs.”
Here's where this doesn't logically follow. They don't reveal the Person of Christ. They don't reveal His work either. They can't. They have to be interpreted, and we have that interpretation via the Word of God. Hence, John emphasizes that for us. What do signs point to? They point to the message already received. If that message is rejected, the sign will be interpreted differently (hence, the Jews said the miracles proved that Jesus was a demoniac and in league with the devil).
“That fails to take into account the metaphorical significance of dominical miracles, as well as their evocation of OT types and shadows.”
. . . which we interpret that way through the written report/word given to us. I’m not failing to take their significance into account. I’m arguing that all events and works must be interpreted for us by the Word of God and come to us through that venue if we are to remain faithful to biblical religion.
"That’s reductionistic. Dominical miracles have a purpose beyond attesting Jesus (see above)."
Steve, I have to confess, I’m not sure what a “Dominical miracle” is, except that it may have to do with Jesus’ Lordship (but that would contradict your point). Maybe you can define that for me. Is that a Hayes’ coinage, or am I merely out of the loop on that one? Otherwise, I'm unclear what your argument is at this point. Either way, miracles accompany the Word, but without the Word, they testify that this guy is doing miracles (just like half a dozen other guys).
“You’re erecting a false dichotomy. Word and sign are mutually interpretive.”
I don’t think I am. If we must come to God through spirit and truth, then coming to Him through sight is not a false dichotomy, but a real one. Jesus makes this distinction Himself when He appears to Thomas (and if the resurrection is the uber-miracle, I don’t know what is).
But how are they mutually interpretive? Are you saying that a miracle interprets or must be interpreted? Again, I'm unclear. I'm not arguing any of this. I'm not sure how a miracle interprets anything. It's descriptive data. My point is that John contrasts the two and sets them against each other (not as exclusive to one another in every way, but one as insufficient and the other as sufficient criteria to reveal God and Jesus Christ who must be known to have eternal life). But this is in terms of miracles, not images of deity. Even if I were to grant you the argument about miracles (which I don’t), it is only a side argument, as the main argument concerns images of deity. John just uses all sight to contrast faith in what is spoken in order to highlight that one cannot know God/Jesus through images.
"To the contrary, the narratives indicate the revelatory significance of God’s OT theophanies and miracles. The plagues of Egypt have an explicitly revelatory function (e.g. Exod 7:5; 9:16). The theophanic angelophany in Exod 33 is explicitly revelatory. Theophanies both reveal and conceal."
The narratives do this where? You would say that the plagues in Egypt are a theophany, or are you still discussing the "miracles as revelatory" assertion?
Where does Exod 7:5 and 9:6 tell us that the plagues are revelatory? Exod 7:5 doesn't tell us that the plagues reveal to the Egyptians that He is YHWH. How would they do that as opposed to revealing the power of Re? It is the proclamation of Moses that reveals that. The plagues are interpreted through the words of Moses. That seems to make more logical sense in the context. Pharaoh's never even heard of YHWH before, so the plague events only back up, and are interpreted by, what Moses has told him (and we assume his words have gone out to the Egyptians in general by what is stated there).
9:6 has an important waw in between the two purposes clauses. What I take that to mean is that YHWH allowed them to remain (1) to display His power and (2) to proclaim His name (which, again, in the context, is the interpretation of the displayed power). Again, this is miracle accompanying word, not as something seen that represents or reveals YHWH in distinction from other deities. How do the Egyptians know that this is Amun-Re punishing them for unbalancing ma‘at?
But even if I were to grant you this (arguendo) there is a clear switch in emphasis from the pre-sinaitic emphasis to the post. It may be that God would have let them get away with making the golden calf before He delivered the Ten Commandments on Sinai, but we know He wouldn’t afterward. As Moses can strike a rock to get water, displaying power (and the works of God do display power, so they do reveal something, just nothing sufficient) before Sinai, afterward, he is to speak to the rock to get it. Sinai marks a divide between iconic and aniconic religion for Israel, where general revelation of God’s power is seen as insufficient to know YHWH. But I wouldn’t actually grant that miracles represent Him as an image would be meant to do so.
If I can isolate maybe what you're attempting to argue, it seems to be this: "We see images. We see miracles. Miracles are acceptable forms of revelation (even though they may be insufficient) because they reveal something about God. Images of deity (although they may be insufficient) also reveal something about God. Images of deity, therefore, are acceptable because things we see can be revelatory." But my point wasn't that they don't reveal anything at all. The point from the Sinai Theology (specifically) is that they don't reveal YHWH in distinction from any other deities (just like miracles don't reveal Jesus from BarJesus) AND we (as fallen humans) replace word with image because of our tendency toward idolatry and justification of self worship. We can use an image to worship without ever knowing the deity in truth or changing our lives to accord with His will. The Word provides for us the true means to know Him.  Hence, miracles don't reveal YHWH (or Jesus). Again, how could they? They must be interpreted, and they are interpreted for us, through Scripture (in the OT via Mosaic interpretation and the NT via apostolic).
"A non sequitur if, in fact, a Christian illustrator is illustrating the Gospels. He is using the written record as his primary source of information."
But this begs the question, as the point I'm making is that the Gospel of John, that I think we can agree, gives us a grid through which to interpret the other gospels (and vice versa), tells us that seeing works against the reception and incorporation of the gospel, and that it must be heard instead. It is impossible to illustrate the contrary and still illustrate the Gospels without rejecting the very G of John's message it is supposedly attempting to communicate.
And I'm unclear to what reference you're referring in Exod 33? Where does it indicate that the cloud-pillar is revelatory? Or are you referring to God allowing Moses to see the trailing of Him? What does that reveal? The glory that trails Him? God’s glory is revealed. We both agree on that. How that reveals God specifically is beyond me, and how we can worship God, who is not revealed specifically, through a display of His glory in spirit and truth is also beyond me. 
"That’s reversible. You need to show how your arguments don’t undermine what God is saying about the revelatory function of miracles and theophanies in Scripture."
I have. Scripture doesn't present them as revelatory in the sense that you are presenting them (by "revelatory" I'm assuming you mean that they reveal God or Jesus in distinction from other gods and other miracle workers). If they are not in distinction then how are they revelatory? If you’re only using “revelatory” to refer to revealing something about someone, in distinction from some but not others, then I guess we would agree that they are revelatory in that sense (e.g., the heavens declare the glory of God, His invisible attributes—power and existence—have been known from creation, etc.), but this doesn’t distinguish Him from Amun-Re, Marduk, etc. So what miracles are insufficient revelations as good as any other data in nature that lacks interpretation toward a specific personal deity. But this is exactly what I’ve been arguing. We cannot have a relationship with God through what is physical. We must do so through the Word. The physical gives a false impression of relationship where there is none. The Word is capable of telling us whether we truly have a relationship with Him, and how we might have a relationship with Him if we don’t already. Miracles don’t do that. Images of deity definitely don’t do that. The physical is impotent to communicate, and to provide a vehicle to commune with, a specific invisible God. Jesus, to us, is invisible, and when He wasn’t to the disciples, John makes the argument that His physical presence hindered them from truly knowing Him. Think of it in terms of two ugly people falling in love on the internet. An atmosphere is provided where they can get to know each other without the hindrance of physical obstructions. Of course, their physical presence will reveal what they look like, but it doesn’t sufficiently reveal who they are as individuals. It’s not a perfect analogy, but it merely gives us something similar to what I think God is trying to do with us as idolaters (i.e., move us away from seeing to believe and toward believing to see).
"Moreover, I’ve discussed Deut 4 before."
I'm sorry I missed it. Can you just give me sentence or two that sums up why your argument wouldn't also undermine the explanation of the 2d Commandment there? From what I've read, you agree with me that images of YHWH are prohibited. Is that right? But what you're arguing now seems to argue against that, as the argument in favor of images of Christ can be used in favor of images of YHWH as well.
"That’s a different objection. Moreover, that’s not the only potential motivation for artistic renderings of Jesus. For instance, an artistic rendering of Gospel scenes may be a visual interpretation of the narrative."
But here's the issue. The command is about making any image to represent deity, not just making any image of deity for certain reasons. The reason why is because our minds, both ancient and modern, tend toward idolatry when we see a favorable image of our deity. Hence, even if the intentions are well meant, the artist is taking away from the reception of the gospel rather than aiding it. So it really doesn’t matter what the motivation of creating an image of deity might be, since the commandment deals only in the act that purposes to create an image of deity, not in the further use of the created image. In other words, as long as one intends to create an image of deity, it doesn’t matter what good or bad intentions/purposes he or she may have for it after that point. The motivations for creating it are irrelevant to the commandment.
“This cuts against the grain of John 1:14.”
How so? Do you think v. 14 is saying that Jesus revealed God through His physical form? I think they behold His physical form, but the truth that is revealed comes to us through the Logos, not via the physical. 
Your objection is leveled at my statement, which is almost verbatim John 4:24. So either, John is wrong. I am wrong in my use of John 4:24, or you are wrong in your use of 1:14. Obviously, neither of us thinks that John is wrong, so your objection cannot argue against John's statement that those who worship God "must (dei) worship Him through S/spirit and truth." So in what way can we know Him (in the Johannine sense) through His physical form?
Notice that the word in v. 14 is “glory.” That is what is beheld. That is what is always beheld when man sees something physical “of God.” But seeing and interpreting it are two different things. Everyone sees God’s glory in creation. They interpret it differently and attribute it to different deities. Note also that Jesus’ glory is not what is full of grace and truth, but Jesus (or one could say, the Father here as well) is full of grace and truth. The glory (feminine) doesn’t tell us the truth and give us grace here, because what is full (masculine) of grace and truth is the unique Son (masculine). So grace and truth, with which the unique Son of God is filled, is communicated to us through His unseen words, not through the physical, which Jesus says profits nothing: "It is the S/spirit who/which gives life; the physical profits nothing; the words that I have spoken to you are spirit and are life" (6:63).This is something John works out through the rest of the book. It's all over the place.
Here’s what my argument boils down to: God is spirit and we must worship Him in spirit and truth. Hence, as He is unseen, we relate with Him, not through the visual, but through the unseen. Hence, imagery of God, not physical images of God, in literature work fine for this. What is spoken creates pictures in our heads to where we have to think about what is being said. The image doesn’t do this. It allows us to believe we have a relationship with the deity without ever relating with Him. Hence, we are told to be extremely careful not to make any physical representation of God. John applies this Sinai Theology to Jesus. Jesus is the Word. It’s of benefit that He goes away and sends the Holy (unseen) Spirit as our helper instead of staying here with us. We can then “see” Him once He’s gone (note John’s play on the words for “see” there). Blessed are those who have not seen, but believe (we assume in the narrative that those who see and believe are not blessed, even though logically we could make the argument that those who do not see and believe are “more blessed” than those who believe by sight). We love Jesus by hearing/obeying His commandments (just like YHWH in Deut 4-6). He alone dwells in unapproachable light and no man has ever seen Him nor could they see Him (1 Tim 6:13-16--although this likely refers to the Father in context, the point is that Jesus never revealed YHWH through His physical form. No one has ever seen Him, not even through Jesus. Jesus reveals Him because He (i.e., Himself revealed in the words that He speaks) is the Logos Theou, i.e., the Word of God. That is what John is arguing.

Friday, October 14, 2011

Should We Emulate Biblical Characters?

Every Sunday, it happens in most Sunday Schools around the country. The children go to their respective classes and sit down. Papers are handed out. Crayons are spilled onto the communal table. The teacher wants the kids to color a scene containing a Bible character, because today's lesson will be about that character. "David was a valiant warrior for God. We should all be like David." "Abraham interceded for people in prayer. We should all be like Abraham." "Peter got back up after being tossed down by his sin. We should all be like Peter." Of course, this teaching by emulation of Bible characters often extends into the adult Sunday Schools and even the service. But is that what the Bible is actually teaching us? Is this what God wants us to do with the lives of Bible characters? Is the way that they live and conduct themselves meant to be God's model for us, or is the recounting of their lives for a different reason altogether?

I once said in a Sunday School class (adult), as we were going through the Book of Genesis, that Genesis isn't about Abraham or Isaac or Jacob or Noah or Adam. It's about God in relationship with Abraham and Isaac and Jacob and Noah and Adam. I continued to say that if you want to know the main character in a story, you have to look at who the storyline follows from beginning to end. It's God, not any human. The humans come and go. God is the main character. He is the one the story is communicating to us. The humans are just the supporting cast.

This hits home every time I see another colored picture of Jacob or Joseph and my kids explain to me that the lesson was all about being faithful and having a positive attitude. Hugh? You mean like Jacob the liar? You mean the positive attitude of Joseph the braggard? Sure, in the end, Jacob told the truth and Joseph set his faith on God in a positive manner, but is this the point of the stories? I fear that it is because we do not know the actual points these books are making, we fall back into what we do know, and what we do know is what we were taught in Sunday School (i.e., the Bible is a big moral book that uses characters, like Aesop's Fables, to teach us lessons about life situations). The Bible certainly mimics life situations, but it isn't to teach us about them. It is to teach us about God who has entered into our life situations. The Bible is about God and how we are to view Him and His work in the world. In learning of Him, we emulate Him, and subsequently learn about what we are to do in the world. In other words, it's not that we don't learn how to live through the teaching of the Bible. It's that we don't learn how to live by merely whitewashing Bible characters and trying to emulate them. We learn to live by learning about God. As His images, knowing Him will tell us what we are to be in the world. This prepares us to receive the message of the Bible (Law and Grace) about our relationship with God. The works that are produced in our lives flow from that relationship, not from our attempt to be like Peter or David.

It's not, of course, that you shouldn't emulate godly men. Paul tells us to be imitators of himself, but he also first and foremost tells us to be imitators of God. So we can see that when we first learn of God, we can then go back and learn from godly men. The problem, as I see it, is that we are not learning of God first. We are stuck in a teaching that tells us to look at what we perceive as a positive biblical character and do likewise. This leads to a superficial understanding of the Bible and a moralism that is void of a relationship with the real God as our model. Such moralism has led to people thinking they're just good people, apart from a submissive relationship with Christ, simply because their lives look like the lives of biblical characters. The sins committed by those biblical characters justify, rather than shame, our sins. But, in a relationship with the real God, of whom we have learned in the Scripture, all of our sins are shamed and all our good morals are filthy rags before Him.

This brings me to the Book of Judges. The Book of Judges has been used and abused by so many people in our culture, it's hard to mention all the errors born of such abuse. One of the major abuses is the example of Gideon and the fleece. Gideon is told by God (verbally) that he is to gain victory over Israel's oppressors in battle. Gideon sets out a fleece one night and asks God that if He is really with him, He will make the fleece damp with dew but the ground dry. God does so. The next night, Gideon asks God to do the opposite (i.e., dampen the ground but keep the fleece dry). God does so. People ever since have been talking about putting out their fleeces to confirm God's will. After all, why wouldn't they. They're supposed to mimic Gideon, right? Wrong.

Gideon is sinning here. He's asking for an omen to interpret, rather than trusting in the revelation God has given him. The point of the episode is to show us that there was a decline in godliness in Israel to the point to where "every man did that which was right in his own eyes." Judges begins with judges who would have been viewed as slightly imperfect in regard to their role as a judge (e.g., a left hand, a woman, etc.). Then it degrades into judges who look for omens (i.e., Gideon), are themselves violent murderers (Abimelech), one who sacrifices children (Jepthah), an absolute covenant breaker (i.e., Samson in terms of both his Nazirite vow and especially his shacking up with unbelievers), and men who have become more like those of Sodom than those of God's images in terms of sexual immorality and violence (i.e., all of Israel).

So Gideon is in a long list of people who are sinning against God. Deuteronomy 18:10-14 tells us that God detests those who interpret omens, as the surrounding nations (from whom Israel was to stand apart) practice those things in absence of God's revelation. God is making a concession here, not a sanction. If we learn of God first and then read Judges, we realize the point is not to emulate Gideon, but to show God's faithfulness to His people, even when they do not deserve it. God is determined to free Israel from their oppressors, and hence, as long as they turn to Him in repentance, He is willing to remove their oppressors from them. If we are to apply such a message in light of Christ, we know that, although we are unworthy to receive God's favor upon us, as long as we repent, He is willing (i.e., He is faithful and just) to forgive us of our sins (i.e., remove our sins from us) and cleanse us from all unrighteousness (i.e., our true oppressor). We know this because the picture that Judges gives to us is of a God who does not hold a grudge, but answers us and wants to cleanse and forgive His people when they turn to Him.

So what does Judges teach us? It teaches us about God and His faithfulness to His people. It teaches us about His patience and mercy. By way of application, it teaches us how we ought to approach God (i.e., via repentance) if we want Him to remove our sins from us. But it definitely does not teach us to be like Gideon. It definitely does not tell us we ought to look for omens in interpreting God's will for our lives. We have God's will for our lives. It's called the Bible. In it are contained the revealed things that are for us and for our children forever. Apart from it are the secret things that God reserves for Himself.

Likewise, when we approach Genesis, the book isn't about Noah or Abraham or Joseph. It's about God as the Creator and Sustainer of true humanity, i.e. His images. It's about God's victory over chaos both in the beginning and through the very acts of chaos that are perpetuated by humans. God is one who seeks human life to thrive upon the earth as Creator and Sustainer, and as such, He seeks the good (i.e., the preservation of human life) in and through all things. This, as a result, tells us what we should be doing in the world, as we are to emulate God's actions in the world as His images. We are also to be those who seek the preservation of human life in all things. God, not Jacob, who creates more chaotic situations that would end God's promises at the get go. God, not Joseph, who would have died in prison had God not interceded. God, not Noah, who gets drunk and exposes himself to his children, is the one who preserves humanity in the flood. Genesis is about God. Judges is about God. Samuel is about God. Kings is about God. It's all about God.

Now, I'm not saying that we don't lift up the godly aspects of biblical characters. What I am saying is that the author of Hebrews only gives us a list of all of these characters as those who followed God through faith after he has spent countless statements explaining to us who Christ is and what He has done. The list is a list of examples in how we should respond to the revelation of Him, not a list of people we should go back and emulate. Yeah, it's great to have faith like David, but I don't want his faithlessness too. Samson did respond to God in faith, but only after he led a life of sin. Give me blind and beaten Samson as an example of how we respond to the God that the Book of Judges just communicated to us, and that will be one of many examples of how we should also respond to this God.

Maybe we need to put up the crayons in both our children's and adult's Sunday Schools and start learning what the Word of God is actually trying to tell us. It's about God, not moralism. It's about who He is and what He has done, not what a bunch of people who kind of followed Him did. They are great pictures of us, but we already know what we're like. We need to know who God is, so that we do not remain as they were, but become like Christ is. So let's not argue from the is to the should be when it comes to human characters in the Bible. Let's instead argue from who God is to who we should be in response to such a one, and we will finally be reading the Bible and understanding that it all points us to Christ, because it has always pointed us to the God Christ communicates. Only in emulating Him, can we be truly called "Christians."

Thursday, October 13, 2011

Why Congregationally-Led Churches Are a Bad Idea

I don't know if you've ever seen the movie "Village of the Damned," starring Christopher Reeve. In the movie, these genetically engineered children end up controlling the adults and taking over the town because the actual adults are afraid they might be killed if they step out of line. You might be surprised to know that many pastors experience a somewhat similar situation in their congregations today, only the threat is being fired (i.e., the threat of their livelihood and ability to secure another ministry job after being fired).

The reason why they're in this position is because we have a lot of misguided theology concerning the nature of church leadership. Let me just point out three things:

1. We think that pastors are the employees of the church and that the congregation is made up of his employers.
2. We think that every person in the congregation (usually every official member), as the employer of the pastor, should have an equal say in the direction of the church.
3. We believe that supporting multiple, full-time elders financially is a waste, since the congregation can function as the advisory committee to the pastor.

All of this is neither biblical, nor is it a good idea in attempting to apply biblical ideas that need church leadership to function biblically in order to "work" the way God designed them to do so. So let's take each one at a time.

1. According to Scripture, the elder is not an employee of the church. He is to be supported by the church as a missionary is supported, but the church is under his authority. He is not under theirs (1 Tim 5:17; 1 Pet 5:1-5). Hebrews 13:17 says,

Obey  your leaders, and submit [to them]; for they keep watch over your souls, as those who will give an account. Let them do this with joy and not with grief, for this would be unprofitable for you.

Now I ask, How can you obey your leaders and submit to them if you are their employer who holds their very jobs/livelihood in the balance? How can they shepherd the flock and rule it well if they have to continually consider everyone else's opinion, and be afraid when they go with one opinion over another? Submission is giving up your authority to let another rule in your place. The elder doesn't have jurisdiction over all things, but he does have jurisdiction over sin and falsehood in the lives of his congregants, and unless he is able to function without fear of losing his job, he cannot function as an elder (i.e., he cannot lead).

2. We are told that many congregations in the Scripture are of an immature nature. They don't seem to know their spiritual right hand from their left, and many are just plain not Christians at all, but still seek to be a part of the visible church. If the majority of a congregation is immature, why would it be a good idea to let them lead and direct the church? Why must all of their opinions be heard? Should they not be quiet and learn? Should they not learn submission rather than be attempting an assertion of power? If a congregationally-led church has a majority of immature believers, either in faith/theology or practice, then your church is being led, not by the elders, but by the most unqualified to lead.
According to Scripture, the elders are chosen, precisely, because they are spiritually mature individuals in both faith and practice (1 Tim 3:1-7; Titus 1:5-11). Hence, they are most qualified to lead. Input from the immature usually hurts more than it helps.

3. Hence, congregants can't just fill in to replace a body of full time elders (even picking the more mature men in the congregation often times is not picking those who are qualified biblically to be elders).

According to Scripture, the term "pastor" describes a gift and an activity, not the office of elder. We call the office "pastor," but he is really an elder. Hence, we must ask whether the Scripture indicates that we should have just one or multiple elders. The Scripture seems to indicate in many places that multiple elders are in view within a congregation, not simply one. This gives each elder community (i.e., spiritual support in fellowship and accountability) that he then can extend into the community as a model of the larger community. This gives each elder time to ponder the Scriptures sufficiently to shepherd the flock rather than having to "quickie" study everything in the Bible. This also gives him support in disciplinary matters, as he will need it if he is to guard the congregation from willful rebellion that will lead it to a certain corruption and death.

Some of the problem might be that everyone thinks he or she's called to "help" the elder shepherd the church. So even if others are not, he or she is. This is the problem, I think, that we have reaped from our view of the "calling" I spoke of before. No one is called to the office of elder. People desire it, but must be qualified to fill it. If he is not qualified, he should consider himself under that authority, and not assert himself into the functions of the office.

Multiple (qualified) elders also give the congregation some level of trust with the eldership, as they are not simply trusting one man, but multiple men who have given themselves over to the Word of God and prayer. This doesn't mean that absolute trust will be given in our culture (and I'm not sure if in our culture it is ever possible to not be somewhat congregational because of our radical mistrust of authority), but we should set up the biblical model and teach its truth anyway, as that to which we should aspire.

What congregationally-led churches do is flip this model on its head. They isolate pastors (if they have elders, they are often men, who although are well meant, are simply not qualified or they are elders on a temporal basis--i.e., there is a lesser opportunity for community and shared pulpit ministry). They assert their authority over the pastor, so that he conforms to their will, which is not necessarily the will of God. And, hence, they stunt their own growth. The congregationally-led church is just as good as a church that has no pastor at all. He's just a figure head, a puppet of the congregation. He can neither rebuke in his teaching nor discipline in the life of the congregation. His ministry has been rendered useless to the congregation.

So here's what we need to do: Think biblically. The pastor is one of a plurality of full time elders that you should aspire to install for his sake and for yours. He is not an employee, but a messenger of God to you. In fact, the Book of Revelation refers to him as an angel, and Peter talks about reviling the authority of church leadership as reviling angelic authority. He is a minister of heaven, not your employee. Support him accordingly. And this support needs to be both financial (1 Tim 5:17) and spiritual (through the election of multiple elders).

Now, I realize of course that most churches have a mixture of the two models presented above, but let me ask you this: Shouldn't we do the best thing God has set us to do? Should we really settle for what we're doing now because we think it's fine the way it is? Maybe you just can't see the effects of something that is broken because that snapped wire just hasn't caught on fire yet, but it will in due time.

You may also find this post offensive, as though you need someone to lead you, but be offended by Christ, not me. He's the one who refers to you as sheep (the most dependent domestic animal alive--and I'm putting that nicely). He's the one who set elders over you to shepherd you and commanded you to obey them as they who rule over the congregation and watch over your souls. Are you offended when your heart surgeon tells you can't operate on yourself because you're inadequate for the job? Are you offended when he doesn't ask for the candystriper's advice on how to perform surgery on you? He is uniquely qualified. His job cannot be substituted with lesser qualified candidates without serious consequences occurring. I realize that every person thinks he or she knows what's what in our culture, but that's not the way Scripture presents us. We are in need of elders if we are to grow in Christ. Without them, or without them exercising freely their role to guard our souls, we are left to fend for ourselves. How many sheep do you know are capable of fending off a wolf by themselves? Good luck on that one.

So, no, I don't think it's a good idea to have a congregationally-led church, and I don't think it's just another model absent of devastating repercussions.

You might simply ask, But what if the elders are corrupt? But I would simply say that you have more of a chance of the elders being corrupt if you do not follow the guidelines in Scripture in appointing them and ignore the multiplicity of elders that can keep each other accountable. Elect godly men who are qualified and they won't need your help governing each other. What's the alternative? Being a village of the damned? I've seen it, both on TV and in the church, and it's not something I ever want to go back to.

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Why I Am Not Pleased with Christian Hedonism: Supplementum

In reflecting a bit more on where Piper and I disagree, I think it may have something to do with how we view love. In Piper's view of love, he seems to have no distinction between types of love. It's all one thing. Yet, it seems clear that Piper's view of love is rather romantic. Let me explain.

There are two main ways we see love. The first is the way we behold an object of stimulation and desire it. We say, "I love chocolate," because the chocolate stimulates our senses. We love it for the way it tastes/makes us feel. This, therefore, is the type of love that desires its object because of the way it makes me feel. A wise woman once asked of her beau, "Do you love me or do you love the way I make you feel?" In other words, this love is a love of stimulation, and the object that is seen as delightful and worthy is seen so only in relation to how it stimulates me. The more stimulation it gives, the more worth I assign to it. Hence, it is not the object that is important, it's worth is relative to my tastes and how it serves those tastes, but the fact that it offers me stimulation. We'll call this love, "Love A."

Then there is the second kind of love. This love, what I will call "Love B," has decided to give itself over to the object it loves because it notes that the object is worthy of love in and of itself. This type of love sacrifices all things, including its own satisfaction and stimulation in using the object for its own ends, for the good of the object loved. In this type of love, an emptying, rather than a fulfilling, of one's desire is what is sought. Love sees worth in a worthy object, not relative to oneself, but because its inherent worth and "deservedness" is recognized. This love is of the nature of duty, but because the individual recognizes the worthiness of the object loved, it is a happy duty. In other words, stimulation, e.g., joy and satisfaction, in sacrificing oneself accompanies the sacrifice of self, so that he who loses his life to the object loved still finds it in loving the object.

What I think is the problem I have with Piper's theology is that he is confusing Love A and B, and they are not always compatible. In fact, when we speak of the reason for our pursuit, it is not the pursuit of pleasure (i.e., Love A) that should be our goal. Love B seems much more appropriate to the Bible.

And yet, the problem that leads to all of the confusion (others have been thoroughly confused as well, I'm not the only one) is that Piper makes statements that are meant to clarify that are congruent with Love B, but most of us see Love B as in conflict with Love A at certain points. In other words, both of them may be compatible as long as they do not conflict, but when they do have conflicting allegiances (e.g., Love B calls us to do something that makes us feel bad), one must be given priority over the other.

I'm almost positive, having read numerous statements by Piper, both in Desiring God and elsewhere, that he affirms Love B. The problem is that he makes assertions that place Love A as the central emphasis in his theology. So statements like, ""The term 'hedonism' means 'a living for pleasure'. If the chief end of man is to enjoy God forever, then we should live our lives for pleasure -- the pleasure of knowing God." This is clearly an affirmation of Love A. Likewise, when the pursuit of pleasure is placed as the means through which we must glorify God, we are placing our stimulation of self first as a means to somehow glorify God, but this is saying that glorification of God is accomplished through Love A rather than through Love B.

Now, I'm not arguing, as I've tried to state many times, that the two do not run side by side in us. We are both selfish and selfless and God can use both of those to draw us closer toward Him. My point is that as our ideal emphasis in pursuing God, we need to exalt Love B, as we, by nature, will already be seeking Love A in God and everything else in life. Love B, in my opinion, prioritizes all of those lesser pursuits under our pursuit of God. Piper may argue that Love A will do the same, as one sees eternal joy in God as more important than the lesser pursuits.That's fine. There's a sort of Augustinian "love God more than, not in exclusion to, other objects." and I don't disagree with that. What I do disagree with is that loving God more with Love A is really loving God more than self, since it is the very nature of Love A to pursue the love of self above the object.

So do I think that Piper would agree with me here? I frankly don't know. I think he does in terms of his explanations of Christian Hedonism, but that he doesn't in terms of his assertions of Christian Hedonism. And this is precisely why they remain contradictory points that lead to more confusion rather than points of clarification. You can't clarify X with non-X. That's not clarification, it's contradiction. Simply saying that what one means by asserting Love A is Love B doesn't help any. So, as I said in the previous post, let's drop the language that asserts Love A if in fact what is being communicated as our primary goal is Love B.

And if what is being communicated is really Love B, as I suspect it is, then we are all in agreement that it is through Love B that one accomplishes the glory of God to the utmost, and that is the most satisfying thing in the world to those who love God and are called according to His purposes. So God is most glorified in us when we are most loving of Him, and the fullest joy that he purposed to create in us through such love of Him has been accomplished. At least, I'm hoping we can all agree on that.

Why I Am Not Pleased with Christian Hedonism

I've never liked John Piper's Christian Hedonism idea. It's clearly contradictory to me, even after he tries to explain it as really just God-centered. That's because it really isn't God-centered. It's centered around the pleasure of the individual using God. I had to read the book, Desiring God, for a SysTheo course at Trinity, and when I returned the book, the bookstore cashier was in awe that I would return such an innovative book. I said to him, "Really, I just thought it was more of the same old thing." Clearly, we had different takes on the book.

Bob Gonzales recently attempted to bolster Piper's claim by arguing that the catechism evidences a hendiadys, or at least something like a hendiadys, in the use of the two clauses "to glorify God and enjoy Him forever" (http://drbobgonzales.com/2011/to-enjoy-god-forever-puritan-hedonism-supported/), and that other Puritans saw the idea of glorifying God and enjoying Him forever as one inseparable goal. I don't have a problem with seeing the catechism as one inseparable goal, but I do have a problem with both of these claims as they are presented by Gonzales.

Actually, the phrases are not a hendiadys, nor do they function as such. Hendiadys in the verbal sense exists when the actions describe one motion. You can have different words coupled together, precisely, because they refer to the same thing: e.g., "he arose and went" means "rising he went." In a nominal hendiadys you really need two words that have some sort of semantic overlap or have the second term modify the first. It seems that Gonzales is attempting to do the latter here, or at the very least, imply that it functions "like" a hendiadys. The problem is that it begs the question to say that it is. For one, cases of hendiadys are easier to find in Hebrew and Greek simply because the waw and kai don't strictly function in the same way as our English conjunction does. They simply point out that there is some relationship between two elements, but that relationship must be defined by the words within that context. In English, our conjunction "and" has a stricter meaning. When we are able to find hendiadys in English, it's often some archaic expression that took form either from another language or was a poetic invention. We have many verbal hendiadys in English, but nominal hendiadys are harder to come by. The question becomes as to whether an expression otherwise unknown to be a hendiadys actually functions as one here. I don't think it does. However, having said all that, it is possible that it functions like one (and Gonzales is really arguing that they function as one inseparable idea regardless of whether they are formally a hendiadys), so let's take a look at the theology of it if it does.

Gonzales quotes all of these Puritans in an effort to bolster Piper's claim that "God is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in Him." In fact, Gonzales quotes Thomas Vincent as saying, "And when God shall be most fully enjoyed by the saints in heaven, he will be most highly glorified. ‘He shall come to be glorified in his saints.’" and says, "That sounds an awful lot like Piper’s Christian Hedonism." Actually, I reject Piper's Christian Hedonism and completely agree with Vincent, so what does that mean?

Let's first look at the claim that the two are inseparable. Now, the problem with quoting all of these Puritans to back up Piper's theology is that it's rather deceptive. The issue is not whether glorifying God and enjoying Him forever can be separated, one accomplished without accompanying the other. The issue is the nature of their accompaniment. In other words, do we glorify God and subsequently (logically, not chronologically subsequent) enjoy Him forever as a result of Him being glorified, or do we seek to glorify Him by enjoying Him? In other words, in the latter, the means to the ends of glorifying Him is through enjoying Him. If one does not enjoy Him, one cannot glorify Him either. In the former (the one that I hold) enjoying Him is a result of glorifying Him that then continues on to glorify Him further. It acts in reciprocation. In other words, what we are seeking is to glorify Him, but our motivation is not pleasure of the self, but love for God and our desire to see Him glorified, and from that pursuit, we gain pleasure in Him that glorifies Him even more. Our pleasure in it is just a byproduct of our seeking to glorify Him. Both are God's chief end/goal for humanity (as that is to what the catechism is referring, not Piper's intention to make the catechism refer to our motivations--i.e., the catechism is not telling us why we should pursue God or how He is glorified, but what God has purposed as the end goal for humanity. He wants to see us glorify Him and enjoy Him forever). Hence, I don't disagree with Piper that having pleasure in God shows forth His value to us and through us. My disagreement is of the nature of the pursuit (i.e., that it says it seeks one thing but really seeks its opposite).

Let me first draw out how the phrase,"enjoy Him," is being interpreted in a hedonistic context. Hedonism is the seeking after the pleasure of the self. It is the supreme religion of fallen man. It seeks to fill the self with whatever it can to satisfy the self. Evangelicals have simply replaced all other things that the world uses to fulfill that self-seeking pleasure with God. Hence, to seek God is to seek myself through God. The means of gaining eternal pleasure is glorifying God. This is clearly the fallen religion of man dressed up in Christian clothing. Now, what Piper wants to say is that the means is not God to fulfill our pleasure, but fulfilling our pleasure to glorify God, but this is just semantics. The primary pursuit is the self. The subsequent result is the glory of God. Hence, I have sought the pleasure of the self first, as my chief goal in life (i.e., the chief end) in order to supposedly glorify God.

Now, here is the problem. This is all confused by the language that Piper et al. use that makes it seem that this is a noble pursuit. Of course, I don't disagree with any of the Puritans statements that the two are inseparable. He who seeks the glory of God will in fact also enjoy Him forever. There is joy and fulfillment in glorifying God, but that is a secondary result of the primary goal. The real issue is whether we love God, and love seems to be confused here with pleasure. I would wholeheartedly agree that to glorify God one must do so by means of loving Him, but that's a totally different animal than hedonism. Love sacrifices the self. It doesn't seek the self. But that's precisely what Piper wants to argue against. He doesn't like the dreary monks, hitting their heads with Bibles of Monty Python fame, and neither do I, but his answer to this is all wrong.

Sure, the enjoying God and glorifying Him go together, but how. Justification is inseparable from sanctification, but I wouldn't argue that sanctification, therefore, is the means to justification. One cannot have one without the other, but there is a logical order. One is primary and one is subsequent. The pursuit of one leads to the result of the other, but if we confuse them, we're in trouble. So let me just ask this question that I've asked before:

If God were a friend who invited you over to build a deck with Him, would you go because you thought you'd have a great time with Him, or would you go because you love Him, and you know that you will have a great time with Him because you love Him? In other words, although these two are similar, they are worlds apart. If one answers that his motivation for going is because he will have a good time, then that individual isn't going out of love for his friend, but only for the enjoyment that his friend brings to him (i.e., the self). The Self, then, not God, is the motivating love that moves the friend to go over and build the deck with Him. If the latter, however, we see that the motivation for going is love of the friend, not the enjoyment one would get from having a good time with that friend. It is the difference between seeking God and seeking the enjoyment God gives to me, seeking the Person or the benefit I receive from that person first. In Piper's scenario, the friend is somehow ultimately honored by the person using him for his own pleasure. But this is just silly. Is the friend dense and doesn't understand that he's a means to an end?

Imagine if you told your wife that you kept her around because you received pleasure from her. Is your wife most honored when you use her for your own pleasure, or when you love her, regardless of the benefit of pleasure you receive from having her around? I think the latter. Pleasure is not absent from the relationship, and it should be there, but that's not the reason your there.

It does no good to simply say that Piper is making our pleasure the means and the glory of God the ends, precisely, because we are still holding onto the religion of self worship in the process of supposedly glorifying God. But the motivation isn't love for God, but of self. I pursue God most when I have the most pleasure in Him is a different statement than I pursue God most when I love Him most. One loves the self most and one loves God most. Is this not obvious? Perhaps, I'm misunderstanding Piper, but I don't think I am. I think he's combined evangelical folk religion, which is really all about filling that supposed God-shaped hole in our lives (i.e., it's all about us filling us), with the Reformed tradition which highly honors and exalts God above the self through love. We enjoy God as a result of our love for Him, but it is our love for Him that motivates our exaltation of Him, not the love of self.

Hence, I think the Catechism is referring to two distinct (not separate in the way that Gonzales is using them) elements: "we glorify God and (subsequently) we enjoy Him forever," rather than saying "we glorify God by enjoying Him forever." So God is most glorified when we are most in love with Him, not when we are most satisfied in Him. Is Jesus most satisfied with the Father on the cross? Is He enjoying God there? He is certainly loving the Father, but enjoying Him then and there? We might be able to quibble over that, but my point is that even if Piper's intentions with what he says parallel what I am saying here, his language is just sloppy enough to comfort millions of evangelicals worldwide that their pursuit of loving the self by using God is justified. If hedonism is the seeking of pleasure of the self, because of the love of self, Christianity is the farthest thing from it. Hence, to call something "Christian hedonism" is either just a shock-jock way of selling books, or it's a misguided attempt to combine two religions that are diametrically opposed to one another. If anyone wishes to come after Christ, he must reject his Self, pick up his cross (doesn't sound too pleasurable) and follow Him. Do we have satisfaction as a result of this? Sure, but it is merely a result. Does the fact that we are satisfied in Him glorify Him as well? Sure. But my point is that this is not what we are seeking. We don't tell people to seek themselves. We tell them to seek God because they love Him. If we tell them to seek themselves by masking it as really a pursuit of God, we're just playing semantic games and deceiving them with another religion (and it's the only other religion the world has to offer).

So inseparable? Yes. Are they both the one goal set by God for redeemed humanity? Yes. Can one still use the phrase, "God is most glorified in us when we are most satisfied in Him"? I suppose with a great amount of qualification. But my point is simply that our language should be more careful. They are not a hendiadys. They are not talking about the motivations of man to pursue God. And the Puritans quoted seem to be saying what I'm saying, not what Piper is saying.

We ought to pursue God to the destruction of the self, in pain and in pleasure, in chaos and in order, in peace and in unrest, etc. because we love Him, and have rejected the pursuit to please the self. As a result, only then, ironically, will we truly be pleased in, and enjoy, Him forever. So I'm not seeking to be satisfied in Him. I'm seeking Him. He just makes me satisfied in Him in the process. But love, not pleasure, is the means to the end. Otherwise, we have two contradictory religions trying to make peace with one another in Piper's statement, and that is just not satisfying at all (bad pun intended).

In the end, it seems clear to me that Piper is confusing love with the delight and pleasure that love produces when one sees a loved one get the rewards they deserve. He is also confusing love of self with the love of God, which I think is more dangerous. He says at one point that God’s competitors are idols not pleasure, but this is not the point. God’s primary competitor has always been our pursuit of self pleasure through idols. God just becomes one more idol to fulfill that goal. In fact, he even uses the friend scenario I used above, but concludes that the friend should be happy to have his friend enjoy him. I don’t disagree, but we’re talking about how and why we pursue the friendship, not what comes of the friendship. If the friend were to discover that you just receive a high by hanging out with him, and that’s your reason for doing so, would he come to the conclusion that you loved him, or that you were just using him to love yourself? So pursue God with love and enjoy Him forever, but don’t pursue Him just because you want to be happy (you won’t find Him that way), and rather you’ll find that you’ve never begun your pursuit of Him in the first place. 

So the pursuit of happiness in Him is not the pursuit of Him. It’s the pursuit of happiness. He’s just the means to our end. But the pursuit of Him is an ultimately happy pursuit. Can you see the difference, or have I misunderstood Piper? Either way, the language of hedonism is gimmicky, creates the possibility of steering people into the path of false religion, and has to die the death of a thousand qualifications if it is to be redeemed. So if I have to take it or leave it, I'll just leave it.

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Fooling Hitler: Why Lying Is Sometimes a Good Thing

I'm sure you've seen the movie, "The Diary of Anne Frank," as well as a host of other movies ("Defiance," "The Hiding Place," etc.) where a group of Jewish people are hidden from Nazi soldiers by some hospitable individual or family who is trying to save their lives. Nazi soldiers would come to the house or apartment and search for any Jewish people that may have been there in order to cart them away to their certain torture and death. They would always ask the individual or family whether they were boarding any Jews. The individual and family, of course, would say, No.

I used to ask a question based upon this scenario, because for a long time, I believed that this set up a moral conundrum: If lying is of the devil, as he is the father of all lies, then is it ever right to lie? The answer of whatever person or group I was asking would usually be, No. The second question led me to ask, What if you lived in Nazi Germany and were hiding Jewish people? Would it be morally acceptable to lie? In other words, would the lie, which is always wrong, somehow become right simply because you were trying to save a life? We would usually conclude that it was wrong, but that perhaps because of the intent to save a life, God would have mercy for us not finding a better solution to the problem.

But what is interesting is that, as I taught through the Deuteronomistic History, I began to discover that I had misunderstood a couple of important things. The first one was that lying in the Bible has to do with doing harm to an innocent individual. It does not simply mean "to trick someone." We usually define lying as that which paints a picture to someone that is not true, but this is not what the Bible means by the term. Lying in the Bible is meant to destroy the innocent. That's why the original command is, "Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor" (Exod 20:16; Deut 5:20). In other words, it is deception perpetrated against one's fellow man in good standing in the community. It has nothing to do with what you say to wicked men. The New Testament citations and references to lying then are qualified by the original command in its Old Testament context.

I began to see, as we worked through Joshua, Judges, Samuel and Kings, that God tells his people to distort reality to either destroy or escape from the wicked. The Israelites are told (by God) to trick the inhabitants of Ai to come out of their walled fortress so that the Israelites can then destroy them (Josh 8:1-7). Jael tells Sisera to come into her tent to be safe and then puts a tent peg through his skull (Jud 5:17-21) and this act is praised, not condemned (6:24-27). God tells Samuel to tell a half truth to Saul as to why he is going to Bethlehem (1 Sam 16:1-5). Michal saves David's life by tricking his messengers with a household idol, and then saves her own life by lying and telling Saul that David threatened to kill her if she did not let him go (1 Sam 19:11-17). David fools the king of Achish into believing that he is insane, since the ancients believed that if you harm someone who is not right in their minds, you will incur the wrath of the gods who protect them (1 Sam 21:10-15). God Himself tells a spirit to go be a lying spirit in the mouths of the prophets of Baal, so that Ahab goes up to war and is killed (1 Kgs 22:19-23). Even in the New Testament, God is said to be the one who sends a deluding influence (lit. "God will send a [supernatural] work so that they believe what is a lie"). All of this seems to be through intermediaries, but the point is that God is the one who tells His people (or spirits) to do this.

I then realized that this is all connected to the meta-ethic of the Scripture that I've discussed many times before: what preserves covenant human life is good, and what works against covenant human life and preservation is evil. I say "covenant" human life in order to make the distinction between the righteous and the wicked, but in reality, as we've discussed before, it is the preservation of true humanity against false humanity that is at stake. Lying is a warfare tactic. It works to preserve the righteous and to end the wicked. It's only when that warfare tactic is turned against the righteous that it becomes evil, as it works against the preservation of true humanity, which is why it is evil.

So telling your wife that she doesn't look pretty in a dress because you don't want to sin is misguided. That has nothing to do with the sin of lying in the Bible. You may want to be honest for other reasons (you don't want her to be embarrassed in public, she really wants to know your opinion to make a decision on what to wear, etc.), but this has nothing to do with the biblical ethic of lying. Lying in the Bible is bearing false witness so that the innocent, true humanity, is not destroyed (of course they are innocent because Christ has made them so, not because they are innocent inherently). My point is simply that when the Nazis come knocking at your door, to not lie is to sin. There is no conundrum. There is no moral dilemma. There is only the preservation of true humanity against false humanity. There is only the ethic of creation and that which flows with creation and that which flows against it, that which works toward a human-filled earth and that which works toward a human-less world (in terms of true humanity, i.e., those who have taken upon the role of the image of God as agents of life). Hence, you should lie your butt off when you need to preserve your or someone else's innocent life from being snuffed out. Tickle the ears of the murderer. But bearing false witness to destroy the innocent or preserve the guilty/wicked is a great evil indeed. Hence, it makes the top ten commandments in the Bible, as lying is a war tactic to preserve the innocent and destroy the guilty.

This is one of many instances where the Bible corrects our misconceptions and religious theories that we impose upon the Scripture from our modern culture. It certainly corrected mine (and frankly there's just something intuitive that we were always misreading that in light of the Nazi scenario). It's not that God would have mercy for our lies to dogs. It's that He would have nothing but praise for us. There is no sin committed. There is only the righteous act of preserving human life, His people, and wiping murderers from the face of the earth. Preserving true human life is the very nature of what is "good" in the Bible. Hence, sometimes lying is a good thing.

So the devil is the father of lies in the biblical sense of the word. He works to deceive true humanity to become and remain false humanity. He is the destroyer, the murderer, of true humanity. He is the one who bears false witness against the truth and against the people of God. But God is the father of preserving human life through all sorts of tactics one would employ in warfare, as He is at war in the world with us. Hence, lying in our modern sense can either mimic the former or the latter, and be evil or good, depending upon to whom and for what purpose the lie is being concocted. I would say as a general rule, always tell the truth, but this post is for those extraordinary circumstances you may find yourself in one day that call for a lie of the divine craftiness variety, and you should know that you have God's full support in such a lie as that.

So the Scripture has corrected me, and I stand corrected. And what I learned was far better than what I thought I knew: that God is the trickster who tricks the tricky. He is the one who catches destroyers of the order that brings life and peace to His people in their own web of deception. He sets His people on a hill to shine with the truth of the gospel in order to preserve the lives of all of His elect. We are to speak the truth of the gospel at all times for this purpose, since we do not know from what guilty men God will make into innocent men. But when it comes to civil issues, no one has the right to withhold a lie if it will save an innocent person's life or lead murderers to their end. After all, we are in this epic battle with God to preserve creation and to destroy chaos. Let us then come to the truth about lying, and be ready to fool Hitler to save a saint, precisely, because that's what God would have us do.