I've only been in one church in my life where tithing was seen as a mark of good Christian conduct to the point to where if you didn't do it, you were judged for it. Unfortunately, it was one of the churches at which I was a minister. I neither encouraged it nor observed it. Hence, we were judged for not participating. Of course, little did the people who were judging us for our lack of participation in it realize that they were never doing it either. I say this because there is a lot of confusion about what the tithe actually was in the Bible and how we are to apply the principle of the tithe in the modern church (I do think the right principle is a necessity, but the wrong one is evil and a sin). What I always wanted to ask them is, Did Christ tithe? We are told that He became poor for our sakes, and that the foxes have holes and the birds have nests, but He had nowhere to lay His head. He was given gifts and money to live (they had a treasury to live off of), but we are never told that He tithes from it (nor should He have if we know the law of tithing).
So what we need to first do is ask two questions, What was a tithe in the Bible, and What is it for? If we fail to ask these two questions, we fail to have anything to correctly apply to our modern day, and then, the word "tithe" is just a falsely defined word that is being used to manipulate people.
So let's answer the first question, What was a tithe? The first thing about the tithe is likely something you already know. It was ten percent, but ten percent of what? This might surprise you to know, but a tithe was not money. It was food. The Israelites were to gather ten percent of whatever livestock they raised (Lev 27:32) or crops they grew (v. 30) and give it to its recipients (also see Deut 14:22). If the journey to the temple was too far, the Israelite was allowed to sell his tithe (i.e., food) and buy a variety of food for himself and eat as a feast to the Lord (Deut 14:24-28). If the tithe had anything to do with money, one would find it odd to suggest that someone sell money to get money. Of course, the tithe was never money. Even in Christ's day, the Pharisees are tithing, not just main food products, but even mint, dill, and cummin, which are spices. So the number one reason people today don't tithe is because the tithe is food. When is the last time you saw someone dump ten percent of the contents in their refrigerator in the offering plate? It would be a great statement about the tithe if you ever wanted to do it. The next time a televangelist tells you to send him ten percent, send him a bushel of wheat and a cow.
Now, you might say, but that was their form of money back then, so we now give ten percent of our form of money today. Actually, that is the furthest thing from the truth. Their form of money is our form of money. We just saw that a person could sell his tithe to get money. If you wanted to buy food, you needed money. If you wanted to buy property, you needed money. If you wanted to buy clothes, you needed money. Slaves cost twenty shekels. The earliest documents we have from the ancient Near East are accounting texts, where money transactions are being recorded. It's simply false to say that it was different then because of money. So what we can glean from this is that we do not tithe today. The tithe no longer exists.
But why might this be? Are we in sin because we don't tithe anymore? I think we need to answer the second question first before we answer that. So who was the tithe for? It was for three groups of people: the Levitical Priests (Num 18:26-28), the Levites as a tribe (Neh 10:37; Num 18:21-24), and the poor (Deut 14:27-29). The tithe of all of Israel was first given to the Levites as a tribe, since they had no land inheritance given to them. They had no way of raising livestock or farming. They were not given land because the tabernacle was their inheritance. Even though all Levites didn't take care of the tabernacle/temple, God set the tribe apart because it is from them that the priests would be chosen. Hence, their lives could be sustained by the tithing of food that was brought in. The tribe then gave a tenth of that tenth (a tithe of the tithe) to those serving in the Priesthood, so that the priests had food to eat (Neh 10:38-39). The poor were taken care of by going to those farms that were too far from the temple, and would store up food at their own residence, allowing both Levites and the poor (i.e., the traveler, the widow, the fatherless, as examples of those who have no food) who lived by to come and get food for themselves (Deut 14:29). The only one of these three groups that further tithe what they are given is the Levitical tribe, since they are the mediators between the people and the priests. The final recipients of the tithe do not tithe. They eat it.
So the tithe is food for the Levites and the priests, and the poor benefit as well from it. The questions are these: Do we have Levites anymore? The answer is, No. Do we have Levitical priests anymore? The answer is, No. Do we have the poor still? The answer is, Yes. Now, in application, we need to ask, Do we have something equivalent to the Levites today? The answer is, No. Do we have something equivalent to priests today? The answer is, Yes. So we have something like priests and the poor still with us. So why not still have a tithe?
I would answer by saying, We need to look to the New Testament as our guide in order to know what we should be doing with the tithe, since the group through which the tithe was given (i.e., the Levites) no longer exists as a tribe that Christians support.
In the New Testament, there is no mention of tithing as a requirement for Christians, likely because the Levitical tribe and priesthood are not their responsibility; but the two groups: those who are like priests and the poor are to be taken care of. Hence, we see that the principle of the tithe is that ministers and the poor are to be provided for by those in the Church, as they are without other means to live. This can be done both in sharing possessions and food, as well as giving money to support the lives of these groups.
We are told in Matthew 19:21 that Jesus tells the "Rich Young Ruler" to go sell his possessions and give the money to the poor so that he has treasure in heaven (of course, he doesn't do it). This command, however, is fulfilled by the Lord's church in Acts 2:25. We are told by Paul that churches in Achaia and Macedonia sent contributions to the poor in other churches. We are told that the Jerusalem council's primary exhortation to Paul as he was going out was that he remember the poor (i.e., to remember to take care of them) (Gal 2:9-10). James says that true religion takes care of a family that has lost its bread-winner in some way as long as the duration of this loss lasts (usually until the woman could remarry) (James 1:27--"visiting" in the NT has to do with bringing provisions for someone, not just showing up). John tells us that the love of God is evident only in a person who opens his heart to a fellow Christian in need (1 John 3:17). In fact, this is the reason given to Christians as to why they should work hard if they are able, i.e., so that they can give to anyone who might be in need (Eph 4:28).
But that's the poor. What about ministers? Well, ministers are like priests. They are poor because their lot in life is praying for, and working hard at preaching and teaching the Word of God to, the Church. Hence, Paul, who still works because wicked men attribute false motives to him, still argues that this is a crime against him. Nonetheless, he willing does it, but it is clear that he shouldn't have to. He says in First Corinthians 9:5-14:
Do we not have a right to take along a believing wife, even as the rest of the apostles, and the brothers of the Lord, and Cephas? Or do only Barnabas and I not have a right to refrain from working [implying that the other apostles do not work extra jobs]? Who at any time serves as a soldier at his own expense? Who plants a vineyard, and does not eat the fruit of it? Or who tends a flock and does not use the milk of the flock? I am not speaking these things according to human judgment, am I? Or does not the Law also say these things? For it is written in the Law of Moses, "You shall not muzzle the ox while he is threshing." God is not concerned about oxen, is He? Or is He speaking altogether for our sake? Yes, for our sake it was written, because the plowman ought to plow in hope, and the thresher [to thresh] in hope of sharing [the crops.] If we sowed spiritual things in you, is it too much if we should reap material things from you? If others share the right over you, do we not more? Nevertheless, we did not use this right, but we endure all things, that we may cause no hindrance to the gospel of Christ. Do you not know that those who perform sacred services eat the [food] of the temple, [and] those who attend regularly to the altar have their share with the altar? So also the Lord directed those who proclaim the gospel to get their living from the gospel .
In First Timothy 5:17-18, Paul reiterates this by saying:
Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honor, especially those who work hard at preaching and teaching. For the Scripture says, "You shall not muzzle the ox while he is threshing," and "The laborer is worthy of his wages."
Notice that "honor" here means "money," as it does in Matthew 15:4-6. This is also indicated by the analogy he again uses of the ox at the threshing floor he used in First Corinthians to talk about money. Of course, the phrase, "the worker is worthy of his wages" again highlights that we are talking about money here. The elders, i.e., those who work hard at preaching and teaching, are to receive double the monetary income of the average individual in the congregation (something most churches are not obeying because of their own man-made opinions of what is sufficient for pastors to receive).
So the principle is that the poor and ministers of the gospel should be supported financially and provisionally. What this tell us is that the poor and ministers are not to be the ones doing the giving, since they are not the ones who are able to give. The tithe was given by those who had land to work. The provisions and money in the NT is given by those who have it. It is not a requirement, nor has it ever been a requirement, placed upon the recipients, but upon those who are the ones put in a position to give.
There is no mention of the tithe, however, in the NT texts, so is there a requirement for the church to give a ten percent donation of their earnings to the poor and to ministers? The answer is, No. Paul explains in Second Corinthians 8, that the churches in Macedonia gave according to their ability and even a little beyond on their own accord. He then argues that people give according to what they have, not according to what they do not have. Essentially, he argues, people should give according to what they are able so that "he who [gathered] much did not have too much, and he who [gathered] little had no lack." In other words, giving is in accord with what one has to give.
If someone is poor, let them receive. If someone has little, let them give little. If someone has much, let them give much. It is a sin to tell a poor man, or he who has little, to give much; and it is a crime to tell a man who has much to give little. Hence, the tithe as it is applied today in some churches, is an evil practice, because it rebels against what Paul says, and commands the poor man to give ten percent of his lack (something he needs to survive) and the man who is well off to give no real sacrifice at all (since ten percent of his money doesn't even cut into his living expenses at all--or as Christ told the disciples of lesser sacrifices, "they give from their surplus"). So it has the poor who need the money, give everything, and the rich who don't, give nothing of significance. Instead, the NT would have everyone, who is a giver, give according to what God has entrusted to them, and the recipients simply receive it in order to survive. The way the tithe is practiced today, it robs from the recipients and then judges them for not giving enough, all the while allowing the well off to give chump change to feel good about themselves. Ten percent of an $80,000 income leaves the person with $72,000 to live on. Ten percent of an income of $15,000 leaves $13,500 for the person to live on. So the money given is less, but the ability to live is less as well. The person who makes only $15,000 a year can't survive on that as it is. Is he to be judged by the person living on $72,000 a year after his tithe? Mē genoito!
Now, I am not saying that you should not give ten percent. Maybe that is the amount that allows you to live and give to others on top of that; but ten percent of a giver's income who needs all of it to survive is too much, and ten percent of a well off person's income, who has plenty of excess, is too little when God has given him so much for the very purpose of supporting the poor and ministers of the gospel.
So the principle of the tithe that we should apply today is this: that the poor and ministers should be supported by those who have the ability to take in a sufficient income (or has possessions to share) to support both themselves and others. Whatever that looks like will vary from person to person. As for the actual tithe, no one observes it anymore, not even the legalists who think they are. So let's do away with the law of the tithe, and apply its principle in love. For it is only then that we will show ourselves as lovers of God and His people through tangible means, rather than lovers of self through tangible means. Give until it hurts, but judge not the poor or ministers who give spiritually rather than financially, for they are Christ who, without your support, has nowhere to lay His head.
Monday, September 19, 2011
Saturday, September 17, 2011
A Methodological Flaw in Biblical Interpretation
I remember the song, "Be careful, Little Ears, what you hear" a song that is meant to recount what Christ Himself said, "Be careful how you hear." It tells us to not only be conscious of to what we listen, but how we are interpreting that information as well. A lot of times, scholarship has a great body of data to share, and so a lot of good stuff to which we should listen, but bad methodologies employed to sift the proper meaning of that data often serve to distort that data to where it would have been better not to learn it all. So, ironically, scholars may become an obstacle rather than a help toward real knowledge of what we're studying.
It's, of course, important that you trust good scholars, but the dilemma is knowing who actually is a good scholar you can trust. There are so many. Today, I want to just share with you why you shouldn't always trust what a scholar, or even a group of scholars, says just because of that recognized status. Scholars actually are just like anyone else. Yes, they've read more books on their subject. They know biblical languages, to some degree, better than the average pastor; but they're as bound to their presuppositions and traditional biases (note the difference between the two please) as anyone else may be. If they are good scholars, however, they will make themselves exceptional by noting their presuppositions and biases as the determining factor in their conclusions, rather than just giving an empty nod to the idea or not acknowledging them at all. In fact, if you read someone who says he's just giving you the evidence, or just going where the evidence leads, run quickly screaming ecstatically as far as you can from that "scholar," as he is nothing but a culture-bound apologist who knows nothing of why he really believes what he believes to be true.
One of these methodological presuppositions can be found when scholars attempt to interpret biblical language in its ancient Near Eastern context. Now, I of course do this all the time. It should be done. Understanding the biblical languages is incomplete without understanding the cultural contexts to and within which those languages speak. However, my problem is how these things are often applied to the biblical text. It seems as though many people think that other cultural contexts determine the meaning of a shared language or conceptual framework that the Bible may use. But this is linguistically flawed. Let me give you an example.
Some people make the argument that the Hebrew Bible's use of divine exaltation language, where God is exalted above the other gods as unique, is consistent with the claim that some texts teach polytheism. So, for instance, if YHWH is exalted above all gods, this doesn't mean that YHWH is the only real God versus false ones, but simply that He is being exalted as the current deity that this particular text is choosing to exalt at this time for whatever reason.
Now, here's the problem in methodology that I have. It commits a linguistic fallacy known as illegitimate totality transference. Most scholars are aware of this fallacy when it comes to smaller units of language as when one practices lexicography and seeks to determine the meaning of a word. This fallacy tries to transfer the meaning of a term, or in this case an entire phrase and/or genre, that originally meant one thing in one context, to a foreign context that must be established on its own merits. In other words, it seeks to say that whatever X means in context Y, it means in context Z as well. You begin to see the problem with this already. The logic of the methodology is simply this: B in the context of A = C, so B in the context of D also = C. In other words, AB = C // DB = C. Of course, this is completely fallacious. The context of D may in fact change everything there is to know about A. It could also be so similar that the logic is justified by A = D. The problem in this particular case is that A doesn't equal D. When the phrase appears in a polytheistic context, obviously, it does not teach monotheism; but when it appears in a monotheistic context, it does in fact teach monotheism.
Hence, it cannot be legitimately argued that a biblical book or section of books, and especially the canon as a whole, teaches polytheism by the use of language that once functioned consistently in a polytheistic context, but now functions just as consistently in a monotheistic context. So what scholars need to prove is not how the phrase or genre functions in another context, but that the biblical context is also polytheistic and thus its language functions identically to that in other ancient Near Eastern texts that are polytheistic. In other words, they cannot simply say that AB = C // DB = C without proving that the contexts A and D are parallel as well (i.e., that A = D).
Now, I say this because I'm writing a book on inerrancy and read Thom Stark's book in order to see what he was saying. It was highly praised by certain scholars who frankly make this same argument (in fact, Thom likely gets his argument from them). Thom employs this method in order to bolster the claim that the Bible is an argument with itself (something every inerrantist I know believes, but not in the way Thom lays it out). He uses the idea that divine exaltation language indicates (or, at the very least, cannot be used as evidence to argue against) the idea that polytheism is taught in the Bible. I, of course, agree that it cannot be used as evidence against polytheism by itself, apart from its context, but I've presented other evidence to Thom (to which I haven't heard a response, perhaps, because Thom is getting tired of these discussions--he's had them for awhile now with Richard Hess and others--although it has only had a little of this one with me so far) that he accepts as evidence of Israel's later monotheism and that provides context for the Bible's use of divine exaltation language, but I frankly find him to be confused here, as if this is the case, I'm not sure why he would still hold his conclusions.
I've discussed with Thom before that this is an issue of diachronic (i.e., how a phrase, genre, source text) functioned in various contexts throughout its history and cultural applications) and synchronic (i.e., how it functions within the present text one is studying) methodologies of inquiry. This is where I find his methodology confused. One answers, What is the history of X in various contexts, and the other answers the question, What is the meaning of X in this context? As you can see, they're completely different questions that need different methodologies employed to answer them. Unfortunately, what scholars are doing in their abuse of the ancient Near Eastern data is to use the diachronic to force a foreign meaning on a text that begs for a synchronic methodology in order to answer the question accurately. As one will not understand the meaning of the word "butter" in the compound "butterfly" by studying the history of the word "butter" in various contexts, one cannot determine the meaning of divine exaltation passages in Scripture by studying their ancient Near Eastern parallels as determinative. To put the fallacy of doing so in numerical form, 1 added in the context of 2 equals 3. 1 added in the context of 4 equals 5. So the end result is not the same because of the context. It is simply not enough to argue that 1 is used in both contexts and is symbolically identical language. The context, however, changes the meaning of its signification.
Instead, the context can be compared to those contexts in order to discover continuity and discontinuity between the them, and it is only when context A can be said to parallel context D that such meaning can assumed as common between the two groups of texts. So the question becomes, Are the contexts in which these passages or phrases appear polytheistic or monotheistic? And we should only ask that of the larger work (i.e., the book, the series of books, the canon), as these provide its context. Hence, when we ask if the deuteronomistic historians evidence polytheism or monotheism by the context of their larger works, we can conclude that they in fact are teaching monotheism. Hence, the phrase or genre of divine exaltation, where YHWH is exalted above the gods, etc., which once functioned polytheistically in other contexts (both Israelite and ancient Near Eastern in general) now function monotheistically to teach that there is but one God, and whatever is considered to be a god, whether it be a demon or an object, is not His equal because it is not really a God in the way that YHWH is God.
Hence, to say that the Bible teaches polytheism in certain places simply serves to showcase an erroneous methodology that in reality functions as an apologetic of a particular view of the Bible (i.e., that the Bible is an argument with itself in a thesis-antithesis dichotomous manner rather than in a thesis-thesis-synthesis manner) that is fueled by a desire to diversify the Bible in order to pull the rug out from those who would see it as exclusive truth and destroy modern forms of diversity within our pluralistic society (but that's for another day). For now, I urge you to not buy into this bad form of interpretation, as it serves only to get things wrong by virtue of a bad presupposition (i.e., that when B appears in both A and D, whether or not A = D, B means the same thing).
Now, I realize that one can argue against the fact that all scholars believe that the present context of the deuteronomistic history is monotheistic, as the evidence suggests, but this would be silly. They should just rid themselves of a bad argument and move on; but even if they choose to fight this one out, let it be done with the present context fully in view rather than set aside in a dubious enterprise that seeks to make a false claim about the Bible (and it is false even if we conclude that those texts function polytheistically on their own).
Yet, tons of people now, who trust the wrong scholars, believe something that has undermined their faith in the Bible, and it's not even good scholarship in the first place. So be careful what you hear, Little Ears, because it may sound astute and academic, but be something that is really the furthest thing from it.
It's, of course, important that you trust good scholars, but the dilemma is knowing who actually is a good scholar you can trust. There are so many. Today, I want to just share with you why you shouldn't always trust what a scholar, or even a group of scholars, says just because of that recognized status. Scholars actually are just like anyone else. Yes, they've read more books on their subject. They know biblical languages, to some degree, better than the average pastor; but they're as bound to their presuppositions and traditional biases (note the difference between the two please) as anyone else may be. If they are good scholars, however, they will make themselves exceptional by noting their presuppositions and biases as the determining factor in their conclusions, rather than just giving an empty nod to the idea or not acknowledging them at all. In fact, if you read someone who says he's just giving you the evidence, or just going where the evidence leads, run quickly screaming ecstatically as far as you can from that "scholar," as he is nothing but a culture-bound apologist who knows nothing of why he really believes what he believes to be true.
One of these methodological presuppositions can be found when scholars attempt to interpret biblical language in its ancient Near Eastern context. Now, I of course do this all the time. It should be done. Understanding the biblical languages is incomplete without understanding the cultural contexts to and within which those languages speak. However, my problem is how these things are often applied to the biblical text. It seems as though many people think that other cultural contexts determine the meaning of a shared language or conceptual framework that the Bible may use. But this is linguistically flawed. Let me give you an example.
Some people make the argument that the Hebrew Bible's use of divine exaltation language, where God is exalted above the other gods as unique, is consistent with the claim that some texts teach polytheism. So, for instance, if YHWH is exalted above all gods, this doesn't mean that YHWH is the only real God versus false ones, but simply that He is being exalted as the current deity that this particular text is choosing to exalt at this time for whatever reason.
Now, here's the problem in methodology that I have. It commits a linguistic fallacy known as illegitimate totality transference. Most scholars are aware of this fallacy when it comes to smaller units of language as when one practices lexicography and seeks to determine the meaning of a word. This fallacy tries to transfer the meaning of a term, or in this case an entire phrase and/or genre, that originally meant one thing in one context, to a foreign context that must be established on its own merits. In other words, it seeks to say that whatever X means in context Y, it means in context Z as well. You begin to see the problem with this already. The logic of the methodology is simply this: B in the context of A = C, so B in the context of D also = C. In other words, AB = C // DB = C. Of course, this is completely fallacious. The context of D may in fact change everything there is to know about A. It could also be so similar that the logic is justified by A = D. The problem in this particular case is that A doesn't equal D. When the phrase appears in a polytheistic context, obviously, it does not teach monotheism; but when it appears in a monotheistic context, it does in fact teach monotheism.
Hence, it cannot be legitimately argued that a biblical book or section of books, and especially the canon as a whole, teaches polytheism by the use of language that once functioned consistently in a polytheistic context, but now functions just as consistently in a monotheistic context. So what scholars need to prove is not how the phrase or genre functions in another context, but that the biblical context is also polytheistic and thus its language functions identically to that in other ancient Near Eastern texts that are polytheistic. In other words, they cannot simply say that AB = C // DB = C without proving that the contexts A and D are parallel as well (i.e., that A = D).
Now, I say this because I'm writing a book on inerrancy and read Thom Stark's book in order to see what he was saying. It was highly praised by certain scholars who frankly make this same argument (in fact, Thom likely gets his argument from them). Thom employs this method in order to bolster the claim that the Bible is an argument with itself (something every inerrantist I know believes, but not in the way Thom lays it out). He uses the idea that divine exaltation language indicates (or, at the very least, cannot be used as evidence to argue against) the idea that polytheism is taught in the Bible. I, of course, agree that it cannot be used as evidence against polytheism by itself, apart from its context, but I've presented other evidence to Thom (to which I haven't heard a response, perhaps, because Thom is getting tired of these discussions--he's had them for awhile now with Richard Hess and others--although it has only had a little of this one with me so far) that he accepts as evidence of Israel's later monotheism and that provides context for the Bible's use of divine exaltation language, but I frankly find him to be confused here, as if this is the case, I'm not sure why he would still hold his conclusions.
I've discussed with Thom before that this is an issue of diachronic (i.e., how a phrase, genre, source text) functioned in various contexts throughout its history and cultural applications) and synchronic (i.e., how it functions within the present text one is studying) methodologies of inquiry. This is where I find his methodology confused. One answers, What is the history of X in various contexts, and the other answers the question, What is the meaning of X in this context? As you can see, they're completely different questions that need different methodologies employed to answer them. Unfortunately, what scholars are doing in their abuse of the ancient Near Eastern data is to use the diachronic to force a foreign meaning on a text that begs for a synchronic methodology in order to answer the question accurately. As one will not understand the meaning of the word "butter" in the compound "butterfly" by studying the history of the word "butter" in various contexts, one cannot determine the meaning of divine exaltation passages in Scripture by studying their ancient Near Eastern parallels as determinative. To put the fallacy of doing so in numerical form, 1 added in the context of 2 equals 3. 1 added in the context of 4 equals 5. So the end result is not the same because of the context. It is simply not enough to argue that 1 is used in both contexts and is symbolically identical language. The context, however, changes the meaning of its signification.
Instead, the context can be compared to those contexts in order to discover continuity and discontinuity between the them, and it is only when context A can be said to parallel context D that such meaning can assumed as common between the two groups of texts. So the question becomes, Are the contexts in which these passages or phrases appear polytheistic or monotheistic? And we should only ask that of the larger work (i.e., the book, the series of books, the canon), as these provide its context. Hence, when we ask if the deuteronomistic historians evidence polytheism or monotheism by the context of their larger works, we can conclude that they in fact are teaching monotheism. Hence, the phrase or genre of divine exaltation, where YHWH is exalted above the gods, etc., which once functioned polytheistically in other contexts (both Israelite and ancient Near Eastern in general) now function monotheistically to teach that there is but one God, and whatever is considered to be a god, whether it be a demon or an object, is not His equal because it is not really a God in the way that YHWH is God.
Hence, to say that the Bible teaches polytheism in certain places simply serves to showcase an erroneous methodology that in reality functions as an apologetic of a particular view of the Bible (i.e., that the Bible is an argument with itself in a thesis-antithesis dichotomous manner rather than in a thesis-thesis-synthesis manner) that is fueled by a desire to diversify the Bible in order to pull the rug out from those who would see it as exclusive truth and destroy modern forms of diversity within our pluralistic society (but that's for another day). For now, I urge you to not buy into this bad form of interpretation, as it serves only to get things wrong by virtue of a bad presupposition (i.e., that when B appears in both A and D, whether or not A = D, B means the same thing).
Now, I realize that one can argue against the fact that all scholars believe that the present context of the deuteronomistic history is monotheistic, as the evidence suggests, but this would be silly. They should just rid themselves of a bad argument and move on; but even if they choose to fight this one out, let it be done with the present context fully in view rather than set aside in a dubious enterprise that seeks to make a false claim about the Bible (and it is false even if we conclude that those texts function polytheistically on their own).
Yet, tons of people now, who trust the wrong scholars, believe something that has undermined their faith in the Bible, and it's not even good scholarship in the first place. So be careful what you hear, Little Ears, because it may sound astute and academic, but be something that is really the furthest thing from it.
Friday, September 16, 2011
Cursing and the Christian
There seems to be an outbreak of professing Christians these days who think it's OK to curse. They almost wear it on their sleeves as a badge of maturity. They're so sophisticated, they're not bound to the rules they once were as children. They're cool Christians, not one of those legalistic and uptight varieties. But what it really says about them is something quite different. It actually indicates the presence of demonic activity in his or her life, and likely indicates either spiritual immaturity or false Christianity altogether. Since this describes my friends on the more liberal side of evangelicalism and a large portion of the emerging church, let me share an experience in my journey before I share what Scripture has to say about it.
When I was 10, I supposedly became a Christian. I went forward at an altar call, having had a deep emotional experience and believed everything about the gospel I had been told at that time (although repentance wasn't a part of that message). I read my Bible a bit, but it was just a picture Bible, not the actual Bible. Still, it gave me a good framework for the biblical story.
Now, as the years past, my language got worse. If it was clean in the beginning of my "Christian" walk, it certainly wasn't as I approached my teen years. If a sentence didn't have at least three "F" words in it, I considered it incomplete. To let you know how bad it was, I once was rebuked by my atheist friend that I cursed too much (and he cursed all the time). I was constantly thrown out of my Biology class for cursing (although my mother never knew because I would never quite make it to the office once I left the classroom). So my language, as a supposed Christian, wasn't clean.
Now, I'm recounting this because when I became a real Christian, my bad language stopped. Immediately. By itself. In other words, I didn't try to quit because now I wanted to be a good Christian. I was a Christian, and without any thinking on the matter, it just stopped on its own. In fact, I remember thinking one day, "Hey, I don't cus anymore." It was kind of a weird experience to tell you the truth. It just left. I had only a couple lapses, where I said a word I shouldn't have (both times in anger, which should be a good indicator of what spirit this sort of language is from) after that, but that was it.
I truly believe that my language stopped because I had been a false Christian, not a real one. When I became a real Christian, the demonic presence in my life departed. As an aside, this is why I likely harp on false Christianity so much. I have been an unbeliever, a false believer, and a real believer. The difference between the first two is only in what you believe or feel about Christianity, not in a transforming way where Jesus as Lord has greatly influenced your conduct in life. In fact, I think the reason why false Christians have a hard time with the exclusivity of Christianity is because the only difference they see between themselves and unbelievers is what they believe in their heads. Well, of course, that is the only difference, because neither one of them is a Christian. For we who have seen the difference between being an unbeliever and a genuine Christian, there is no comparison to be made, since our lives are characterized by continual repentance from sins (that we still unfortunately, but not wholeheartedly, commit) rather than acceptance and indulgence in them.
But I digress. Now, you may wonder where I'm getting this idea that cursing has to do with demonic activity. Of course, my experience is just that. Someone will just say that's my interpretation of those things, so let's look at what Scripture says.
In Ephesians 4:29, Paul has begun his discussion about what a life that has been saved looks like. He gives directions on what it should:
Let no unwholesome word proceed from your mouth, but only such [a word] as is good for edification according to the need [of the moment,] that it may give grace to those who hear. And do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, by whom you were sealed for the day of redemption.
The word for "unwholesome" here is sapros. It often refers to fruit that is rotten. Like fruit, language can be good or rotten. Hence, other nuances of the word are "bad" and "worthless." Let no bad word proceed from your mouth, but only a word that is good for building up someone's commitment to Christ in holiness and truth (i.e., what edification means in the NT).
Paul continues a more dire warning in 5:3-9:
But do not let immorality or any impurity or greed even be named among you, as is proper among saints; and [there must be no] filthiness and silly talk, or crude language, which are not fitting, but rather giving of thanks. For this you know with certainty, that no immoral or impure person or covetous man, who is an idolater, has an inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and God. Let no one deceive you with empty words, for because of these things the wrath of God comes upon the sons of disobedience. Therefore do not be partakers with them; for you were formerly darkness, but now you are light in the Lord; walk as children of light (for the fruit of the light [consists] in all goodness and righteousness and truth)
There are important factors here to notice. Contrary to popular opinion that cursing is just a minor crime, the Holy Spirit through Paul tells us that it is on par with sexual immorality, impurity, and selfishness, which are themselves things that display that one is not saved. Those who have an inheritance with Christ do not practice these things, but if they fail in them, repent from them. They do not laugh at the puritanical legalists who don't curse. They say, "Amen," with Paul and seek to evaluate their lives as to why cursing is still present even though they are supposedly Christians. It may not be a coincidence that much of our cursing contains words that have to do with an immoral use of sex and sexual organs. The two are tied together.
The first word for filthiness describes what is shameful in the eyes of God. It is not fitting for someone who claims to be a follower of Christ. The second word describes a lack of sobriety and wisdom in one's speech. It is foolish talk, or the way that morons talk, that is devoid of truth. The last word describes what we would call curse words. Paul just calls them "crude language," but it's not just crude in the sense that we think of it. Crude language is inappropriate language. It doesn't fit the claim to follow Christ either. All of this is not redeemed language. It remains the language of the damned, and as such, is not fitting for Christians who proclaim Christ's lordship, not only in deed, but also by the words they choose to speak.
Paul also tells us in Romans 3:14 that they damned/unredeemed (i.e., all of us) have mouths of cursing and bitterness. As with filthy talk and sexual immorality, it may not be a coincidence here, then, that many of our curse words include things about God, Jesus, damning, and hell, as these are all words one invokes in cursing/condemning something or expressing displeasure (only it is done in an unholy manner).
In First Peter 4:10, Peter says, Whoever speaks, [let him speak,] as it were, the utterances of God . . . so that in all things God may be glorified through Jesus Christ, to whom belongs the glory and dominion forever and ever. Amen.
Does your language reflect the holiness of God's character? Is it what you would use in His presence with a full understanding of what it is in light of His displeasure with it, and its association with the demonic denial of Christ?
Now you can understand why I don't like preachers who are crude or use curse words because they're supposedly more sophisticated and have a greater freedom than those restricted legalists who put a reign on their tongues (you know, like the way the Epistle of James tells us to do). I don't care if they agree with me in some of their theology. They are adolescents, who still think its cool to be crude and curse, since cursing gives them a sense of community with the damned. Yet, we are told that the wrath of God comes upon the unredeemed for these things, and that those who practice them are not saved. Forget not being qualified to be an elder, we must take Scripture as our light and ask if this is the behavior of a Christian at all. The condemnation of the church at Pergumum had to do with its moral lax. They had their doctrine straight, but not their morals. Hence, they are in jeopardy of damnation if they do not repent of it (Rev 2:12-17).
My point here is not to attack pastors like this, who often violate pretty much every principle we mentioned above (as well as things I would apply from Second Peter 2 and other texts concerning false teachers and their association with sexual immorality); but to point out that you can't trust the fact that others, who you think are Christians, curse without impunity. In fact, cursing may be an indication that the wrath of God (which is one that gives over the individual to be controlled by their impulses) upon that person's life. Therefore, do not mimic their behavior. Lest you be woken up in the presence of our holy God some day, and say with the condemned Isaiah, "Woe is me, for I am damned! Because I am a man of unclean lips, And I live among a people of unclean lips; For [now I know because] my eyes have seen the King, the Lord of hosts."
To betray Christ with our words is no minor infraction. It exalts the filthy kennel that the devil has made out of the fallen world and the dogs he has made of men as his subjects within that kingdom. It's unbecoming, and a betrayal of highest order, for you to keep the language of the damned when you supposedly have been made new in the kingdom of God. True humanity should not have the gutter language that it once had as false humanity any longer. If it quacks like a duck, it probably is one, and the one who speaks like an unbeliever probably is an unbeliever. Only repentance, or the lack thereof, upon hearing this truth will tell.
When I was 10, I supposedly became a Christian. I went forward at an altar call, having had a deep emotional experience and believed everything about the gospel I had been told at that time (although repentance wasn't a part of that message). I read my Bible a bit, but it was just a picture Bible, not the actual Bible. Still, it gave me a good framework for the biblical story.
Now, as the years past, my language got worse. If it was clean in the beginning of my "Christian" walk, it certainly wasn't as I approached my teen years. If a sentence didn't have at least three "F" words in it, I considered it incomplete. To let you know how bad it was, I once was rebuked by my atheist friend that I cursed too much (and he cursed all the time). I was constantly thrown out of my Biology class for cursing (although my mother never knew because I would never quite make it to the office once I left the classroom). So my language, as a supposed Christian, wasn't clean.
Now, I'm recounting this because when I became a real Christian, my bad language stopped. Immediately. By itself. In other words, I didn't try to quit because now I wanted to be a good Christian. I was a Christian, and without any thinking on the matter, it just stopped on its own. In fact, I remember thinking one day, "Hey, I don't cus anymore." It was kind of a weird experience to tell you the truth. It just left. I had only a couple lapses, where I said a word I shouldn't have (both times in anger, which should be a good indicator of what spirit this sort of language is from) after that, but that was it.
I truly believe that my language stopped because I had been a false Christian, not a real one. When I became a real Christian, the demonic presence in my life departed. As an aside, this is why I likely harp on false Christianity so much. I have been an unbeliever, a false believer, and a real believer. The difference between the first two is only in what you believe or feel about Christianity, not in a transforming way where Jesus as Lord has greatly influenced your conduct in life. In fact, I think the reason why false Christians have a hard time with the exclusivity of Christianity is because the only difference they see between themselves and unbelievers is what they believe in their heads. Well, of course, that is the only difference, because neither one of them is a Christian. For we who have seen the difference between being an unbeliever and a genuine Christian, there is no comparison to be made, since our lives are characterized by continual repentance from sins (that we still unfortunately, but not wholeheartedly, commit) rather than acceptance and indulgence in them.
But I digress. Now, you may wonder where I'm getting this idea that cursing has to do with demonic activity. Of course, my experience is just that. Someone will just say that's my interpretation of those things, so let's look at what Scripture says.
In Ephesians 4:29, Paul has begun his discussion about what a life that has been saved looks like. He gives directions on what it should:
Let no unwholesome word proceed from your mouth, but only such [a word] as is good for edification according to the need [of the moment,] that it may give grace to those who hear. And do not grieve the Holy Spirit of God, by whom you were sealed for the day of redemption.
The word for "unwholesome" here is sapros. It often refers to fruit that is rotten. Like fruit, language can be good or rotten. Hence, other nuances of the word are "bad" and "worthless." Let no bad word proceed from your mouth, but only a word that is good for building up someone's commitment to Christ in holiness and truth (i.e., what edification means in the NT).
Paul continues a more dire warning in 5:3-9:
But do not let immorality or any impurity or greed even be named among you, as is proper among saints; and [there must be no] filthiness and silly talk, or crude language, which are not fitting, but rather giving of thanks. For this you know with certainty, that no immoral or impure person or covetous man, who is an idolater, has an inheritance in the kingdom of Christ and God. Let no one deceive you with empty words, for because of these things the wrath of God comes upon the sons of disobedience. Therefore do not be partakers with them; for you were formerly darkness, but now you are light in the Lord; walk as children of light (for the fruit of the light [consists] in all goodness and righteousness and truth)
There are important factors here to notice. Contrary to popular opinion that cursing is just a minor crime, the Holy Spirit through Paul tells us that it is on par with sexual immorality, impurity, and selfishness, which are themselves things that display that one is not saved. Those who have an inheritance with Christ do not practice these things, but if they fail in them, repent from them. They do not laugh at the puritanical legalists who don't curse. They say, "Amen," with Paul and seek to evaluate their lives as to why cursing is still present even though they are supposedly Christians. It may not be a coincidence that much of our cursing contains words that have to do with an immoral use of sex and sexual organs. The two are tied together.
The first word for filthiness describes what is shameful in the eyes of God. It is not fitting for someone who claims to be a follower of Christ. The second word describes a lack of sobriety and wisdom in one's speech. It is foolish talk, or the way that morons talk, that is devoid of truth. The last word describes what we would call curse words. Paul just calls them "crude language," but it's not just crude in the sense that we think of it. Crude language is inappropriate language. It doesn't fit the claim to follow Christ either. All of this is not redeemed language. It remains the language of the damned, and as such, is not fitting for Christians who proclaim Christ's lordship, not only in deed, but also by the words they choose to speak.
Paul also tells us in Romans 3:14 that they damned/unredeemed (i.e., all of us) have mouths of cursing and bitterness. As with filthy talk and sexual immorality, it may not be a coincidence here, then, that many of our curse words include things about God, Jesus, damning, and hell, as these are all words one invokes in cursing/condemning something or expressing displeasure (only it is done in an unholy manner).
In First Peter 4:10, Peter says, Whoever speaks, [let him speak,] as it were, the utterances of God . . . so that in all things God may be glorified through Jesus Christ, to whom belongs the glory and dominion forever and ever. Amen.
Does your language reflect the holiness of God's character? Is it what you would use in His presence with a full understanding of what it is in light of His displeasure with it, and its association with the demonic denial of Christ?
Now you can understand why I don't like preachers who are crude or use curse words because they're supposedly more sophisticated and have a greater freedom than those restricted legalists who put a reign on their tongues (you know, like the way the Epistle of James tells us to do). I don't care if they agree with me in some of their theology. They are adolescents, who still think its cool to be crude and curse, since cursing gives them a sense of community with the damned. Yet, we are told that the wrath of God comes upon the unredeemed for these things, and that those who practice them are not saved. Forget not being qualified to be an elder, we must take Scripture as our light and ask if this is the behavior of a Christian at all. The condemnation of the church at Pergumum had to do with its moral lax. They had their doctrine straight, but not their morals. Hence, they are in jeopardy of damnation if they do not repent of it (Rev 2:12-17).
My point here is not to attack pastors like this, who often violate pretty much every principle we mentioned above (as well as things I would apply from Second Peter 2 and other texts concerning false teachers and their association with sexual immorality); but to point out that you can't trust the fact that others, who you think are Christians, curse without impunity. In fact, cursing may be an indication that the wrath of God (which is one that gives over the individual to be controlled by their impulses) upon that person's life. Therefore, do not mimic their behavior. Lest you be woken up in the presence of our holy God some day, and say with the condemned Isaiah, "Woe is me, for I am damned! Because I am a man of unclean lips, And I live among a people of unclean lips; For [now I know because] my eyes have seen the King, the Lord of hosts."
To betray Christ with our words is no minor infraction. It exalts the filthy kennel that the devil has made out of the fallen world and the dogs he has made of men as his subjects within that kingdom. It's unbecoming, and a betrayal of highest order, for you to keep the language of the damned when you supposedly have been made new in the kingdom of God. True humanity should not have the gutter language that it once had as false humanity any longer. If it quacks like a duck, it probably is one, and the one who speaks like an unbeliever probably is an unbeliever. Only repentance, or the lack thereof, upon hearing this truth will tell.
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
Will the Real Pharisee Please Stand Up?
If you grew up in the 80's, it's likely you saw the blockbuster, academy award winning film, "Pee-Wee's Great Adventure." In the film, Pee-Wee gets into an argument with his neighborhood nemesis by the ever so intelligent method of name-calling. An insult would be thrown out, and Pee-Wee would respond by saying, "I know you are, but what am I." Although you would expect something more of Christians these days, name-calling remains standard fare in Christian forms of argumentation today that mimics much of the Pee-Wee Herman style of defense.
One of the ways people try to win an argument is by labeling you something shameful. In secular culture, if you are called a racist, that designation (unless it's true) serves only to shut down the conversation, so that the other side does not get a hearing. We have Christian terms that serve the same purpose. One of those labels is the term "Pharisee."
If you've ever had a conversation with an antinomian (i.e., someone who believes that the Christian life is one that is lived without law), then you likely have heard the term "Pharisee" applied to either yourself or someone else who argues that a particular Scripture ought to be observed by Christians. In modern evangelical fiction, the Pharisee is a person who tries to obey the law, and supposedly God doesn't desire that, but faith (which is usually interpreted as a friendship relationship with God). In other words, the good Christian doesn't need to observe the commands in Scripture. That's a legalistic, i.e., Pharisaical, attempt to be pleasing to God. Christ was opposed to the Pharisees. Hence, Christ is opposed to anyone who says we need to obey the Scripture.
All of this stems, of course, from either an illiterate knowledge, or culturally blinded reading, of Scripture. The Gospel of Matthew gives us the exact reason Christ was opposed to the Pharisees, and here it is in a nutshell:
And [thus] you invalidated the word of God for the sake of your tradition . "You hypocrites, rightly did Isaiah prophesy of you, saying, 'This people honors Me with their lips, But their heart is far away from Me. 'But in vain do they worship Me, Teaching as doctrines the precepts of men.'" (15:6b-9)
This is the way the Pharisees are presented throughout the Gospels. In Matthew 3:7-12, John the Baptist chastises the Pharisees as those who do not bear fruit that is worthy/fitting for someone who has supposedly repented. He orders them to do good works, rather than trust in their supposed relationship with God that is void of them if they are to avoid eternal punishment.
When we come to the Sermon on the Mount, the entire sermon is a contrast between the Pharisaical form of righteousness and the form that is acceptable to God. The kind of righteousness performed by Pharisees is only for show. It doesn't stem from their desire for God to rule over all of their lives. Instead, they offer up long prayers, give extra tithes, put on extra special clothing as a sign of their worship toward God, and technically, rather than whole-heartedly, observe only the explicit teaching of the moral law. When they do not observe the moral law, they replace it with ceremony/ritual or cultural ideas. Hence, Christ states in 5:20, "For I say to you, that unless your righteousness surpasses [that] of the scribes and Pharisees, you shall not enter the kingdom of heaven."
Despite what some teach, it is out of context to suggest that the Sermon on the Mount is attempting to show us what we can't do so that we trust in Christ's righteousness. This isn't point at all. One can apply this to the justification issue, but Christ, in Matthew, is specifically speaking here about what ought to come forth from a saved person's life. He is talking about the fruit of a repentant life, the marks of one who has a real relationship with God and is saved. Hence, the Sermon on the Mount is arguing that we need to obey the Scripture to its fullest, applying it anywhere and everywhere in our lives, because it displays God's authority, God's kingdom/rule/dominion, over us. A lawless life is a God-less life, and thus proves that we never knew Christ and He never knew us (7:21-23).
So the Pharisees do not represent the person who tells you to obey Scripture. The irony is that the Pharisees represent the antinomian who is calling you a Pharisee. In other words, the person who is arguing against applying what Scripture teaches is moral and good is something he or she needs to do each day in life is the Pharisee. They're the one who do not do the deeds of Abraham or Moses (John 7:19; 8:39).
The Pharisees are what I call religious rebels. They want some sort of spirituality because it makes them feel acceptable to God, but they don't want God imposing on their lives. They want His blessings, but not the transformation of lifestyle and thought through which blessing from a genuine relationship with God is received. In essence, the want to do what is displeasing to God, but still have Him be pleased with them. After all, if God is not pleased with you, you feel bad about yourself. The Pharisaical quest is a quest to feel good about the self, and is simply another avenue the self takes to toward a pleasure-filled life void of God's rule.
The Pharisee essentially sees God's rule as a burden. He views law as a requirement to be fulfilled in order to feel accepted by God. That's why he fails to obey it to the fullest extent and only technically obeys what he feels he has to. This is a person who wants to preserve as much of his life as he can without giving up his spirituality that gives him some sense of purpose or "righteousness" in his life. But his life remains as untransformed as if he had never known God at all, because in fact he hasn't ever known God. God never came into his life. God's presence is marked by a change in one's disposition toward the Scripture as that which is a vehicle of love rather than burden and obligation. The love of God begins to set one on a path that seeks to let God reign over every aspect of his or her life. Thus, the genuine presence of God in one's life is also marked by both an internal and external obedience to what Christ has commanded. The life that God enters will never be the same again. It is addicted to God's transforming love and rule. In short, it wants God to rule; but the mind of the antinomian, i.e., the Pharisee, does not. It's goal is to preserve the self. It wants to protect whatever pursuits give it the most satisfaction in the moment. It wants a god, to be sure, but not the God. It wants a god who is accommodating to our self directed lives, not one that demands to take the reigns.
Have no doubt, the winds and the rains will come, and the house built on sand will fall. The Pharisee will not enter the kingdom of God, no matter how religious he or she may be, because God doesn't want observe your religion, He wants you to observe His. That is a religion where we love God with everything we've got, our whole, rather than just partial, thoughts and lives.
So the next time you are called a Pharisee for holding someone accountable to Scripture, you can simply reply, "I know you are, but what am I."
One of the ways people try to win an argument is by labeling you something shameful. In secular culture, if you are called a racist, that designation (unless it's true) serves only to shut down the conversation, so that the other side does not get a hearing. We have Christian terms that serve the same purpose. One of those labels is the term "Pharisee."
If you've ever had a conversation with an antinomian (i.e., someone who believes that the Christian life is one that is lived without law), then you likely have heard the term "Pharisee" applied to either yourself or someone else who argues that a particular Scripture ought to be observed by Christians. In modern evangelical fiction, the Pharisee is a person who tries to obey the law, and supposedly God doesn't desire that, but faith (which is usually interpreted as a friendship relationship with God). In other words, the good Christian doesn't need to observe the commands in Scripture. That's a legalistic, i.e., Pharisaical, attempt to be pleasing to God. Christ was opposed to the Pharisees. Hence, Christ is opposed to anyone who says we need to obey the Scripture.
All of this stems, of course, from either an illiterate knowledge, or culturally blinded reading, of Scripture. The Gospel of Matthew gives us the exact reason Christ was opposed to the Pharisees, and here it is in a nutshell:
And [thus] you invalidated the word of God for the sake of your tradition . "You hypocrites, rightly did Isaiah prophesy of you, saying, 'This people honors Me with their lips, But their heart is far away from Me. 'But in vain do they worship Me, Teaching as doctrines the precepts of men.'" (15:6b-9)
This is the way the Pharisees are presented throughout the Gospels. In Matthew 3:7-12, John the Baptist chastises the Pharisees as those who do not bear fruit that is worthy/fitting for someone who has supposedly repented. He orders them to do good works, rather than trust in their supposed relationship with God that is void of them if they are to avoid eternal punishment.
When we come to the Sermon on the Mount, the entire sermon is a contrast between the Pharisaical form of righteousness and the form that is acceptable to God. The kind of righteousness performed by Pharisees is only for show. It doesn't stem from their desire for God to rule over all of their lives. Instead, they offer up long prayers, give extra tithes, put on extra special clothing as a sign of their worship toward God, and technically, rather than whole-heartedly, observe only the explicit teaching of the moral law. When they do not observe the moral law, they replace it with ceremony/ritual or cultural ideas. Hence, Christ states in 5:20, "For I say to you, that unless your righteousness surpasses [that] of the scribes and Pharisees, you shall not enter the kingdom of heaven."
Despite what some teach, it is out of context to suggest that the Sermon on the Mount is attempting to show us what we can't do so that we trust in Christ's righteousness. This isn't point at all. One can apply this to the justification issue, but Christ, in Matthew, is specifically speaking here about what ought to come forth from a saved person's life. He is talking about the fruit of a repentant life, the marks of one who has a real relationship with God and is saved. Hence, the Sermon on the Mount is arguing that we need to obey the Scripture to its fullest, applying it anywhere and everywhere in our lives, because it displays God's authority, God's kingdom/rule/dominion, over us. A lawless life is a God-less life, and thus proves that we never knew Christ and He never knew us (7:21-23).
So the Pharisees do not represent the person who tells you to obey Scripture. The irony is that the Pharisees represent the antinomian who is calling you a Pharisee. In other words, the person who is arguing against applying what Scripture teaches is moral and good is something he or she needs to do each day in life is the Pharisee. They're the one who do not do the deeds of Abraham or Moses (John 7:19; 8:39).
The Pharisees are what I call religious rebels. They want some sort of spirituality because it makes them feel acceptable to God, but they don't want God imposing on their lives. They want His blessings, but not the transformation of lifestyle and thought through which blessing from a genuine relationship with God is received. In essence, the want to do what is displeasing to God, but still have Him be pleased with them. After all, if God is not pleased with you, you feel bad about yourself. The Pharisaical quest is a quest to feel good about the self, and is simply another avenue the self takes to toward a pleasure-filled life void of God's rule.
The Pharisee essentially sees God's rule as a burden. He views law as a requirement to be fulfilled in order to feel accepted by God. That's why he fails to obey it to the fullest extent and only technically obeys what he feels he has to. This is a person who wants to preserve as much of his life as he can without giving up his spirituality that gives him some sense of purpose or "righteousness" in his life. But his life remains as untransformed as if he had never known God at all, because in fact he hasn't ever known God. God never came into his life. God's presence is marked by a change in one's disposition toward the Scripture as that which is a vehicle of love rather than burden and obligation. The love of God begins to set one on a path that seeks to let God reign over every aspect of his or her life. Thus, the genuine presence of God in one's life is also marked by both an internal and external obedience to what Christ has commanded. The life that God enters will never be the same again. It is addicted to God's transforming love and rule. In short, it wants God to rule; but the mind of the antinomian, i.e., the Pharisee, does not. It's goal is to preserve the self. It wants to protect whatever pursuits give it the most satisfaction in the moment. It wants a god, to be sure, but not the God. It wants a god who is accommodating to our self directed lives, not one that demands to take the reigns.
Have no doubt, the winds and the rains will come, and the house built on sand will fall. The Pharisee will not enter the kingdom of God, no matter how religious he or she may be, because God doesn't want observe your religion, He wants you to observe His. That is a religion where we love God with everything we've got, our whole, rather than just partial, thoughts and lives.
So the next time you are called a Pharisee for holding someone accountable to Scripture, you can simply reply, "I know you are, but what am I."
Tuesday, September 13, 2011
The Apostle Peter Converses with American Christianity: PART II
As with the previous post, where I encouraged you to read First Peter before reading it, I would encourage you to read Second Peter before reading this.
The Apostle Peter sits down at a coffee shop with a Postmodern Emergent Teacher (PET from here on out, because he’s missing elements to give him the same faith as Peter), and begins to discuss the nature of the Christian faith in view of our fallen humanity.
Peter: Why do you teach your people that diversity in Christian theology and practice is something to be celebrated?
PET: Because it is. There is no one faith, but many faiths in Jesus. I may express my faith through believing differently, but I still believe in Jesus just like you do.
Peter. Well, actually I believe that there is only one faith, an actual orthodoxy, that genuine Christians must believe in order to be properly called “Christians.” This faith must be the same as mine, as my teaching has been given to me by Christ.
PET: How can that be. Humans are such fallen creatures, given to finitude and sin. We all distort reality in some way according to our sinfulness. There is no way around that. It’s just the predicament we’re in. Hence, God must be fine with our diversity, because diversity is all we can give him in our humanness. So God gives us grace in our diversity, since He understands that we may not come to a proper knowledge of Him in this life due to our condition.
Peter: Well, grace is multiplied through knowledge of God and the Lord Jesus Christ, not apart from it; and I interpret this knowledge as the one faith in which all must trust. So grace comes through the knowledge of the one faith, and that brings unity and agreement in what we believe and practice, not diversity.
PET: But we all have different gifts, and that is diverse.
Peter: But I’m not talking about the expressions of the one faith, but of the one faith itself. Gifts are vehicles to display the one faith. But you are trying to apply diversity to the faith itself when, in fact, we are to be unified in the faith.
PET: But we are so sinful. We are going to distort things for sinful purposes. There is no getting around that. We’re not going to be able to see eye to eye and practice the same things. We just need to try and get along with one another, so the only unity we can have is by accepting diversity in practice with tolerance.
Peter: But you are focusing on our lack of ability to overcome sin, and merely accepting the impossibility of unity because of that lack of ability. What I would tell you is that God has given us everything we need to live a life of godliness through the knowledge He has given us in the Scripture and the divine power He has given us by allowing us to become partakers of the divine nature. Hence, it is not our ability to bring about unity through this knowledge, but God’s ability to accomplish it when we believe. So we are able to practice godliness together as one, and escape the corruptions and distortions of the world, precisely, because He has granted to us the power to achieve it.
PET: Yes, but all of that is moot if we don’t know what we’re supposed to believe and practice. Sure, we may have the ability to believe and practice, but who’s to say what the content of those beliefs and practices should be? That’s where we’re too finite and error-prone humanity comes in again. You say that the Scripture reveals this knowledge to us, but the Scripture is written by humans, and humans are fallible. Hence, Scripture must be fallible too. So we’re in the same boat. Diversity in faith must be the only option for us.
Peter: No, your problem is that you are emphasizing the condition of humanity over the ability of God again. This time you are saying that we cannot trust the Scriptures as an infallible guide because it is written by men; but Scripture is written by prophets, and no prophecy was ever a matter of an opinion of some prophet, but men moved by the Holy Spirit spoke from God. And that Scripture is confirmed by God’s confirmation of Christ who confirmed it. I, and the other apostles, were eyewitnesses to God confirming it btw. So the ability of Scripture to communicate the truth concerning faith and practice does not rest on man’s inability to remain unbiased or inerrant, but on God’s direction of those men to communicate the faith accurately.
PET: That may be ideal. You may be right. I just don’t think it’s necessary to have all our theological and ethical i’s dotted and t’s crossed. We can believe and practice all sorts of different things without getting hung up on who’s right and who’s wrong. Let’s just love one another in tolerance of each other’s ideas and lifestyles.
Peter: Well, to have another belief system and a different lifestyle, other than the one the apostles have preached to you, is heresy and leads to hell, not unity with God and man in heaven. So loving someone would be to set them straight in their knowledge of Christianity, not let them perish in falsehood and wickedness. Heresy denies the Master who bought us, so it in no way glorifies Him to tolerate it. Heresy is a rejection of the faith.
PET: Hey, different strokes for different folks. Some believe one thing and some believe another. One practices heterosexuality and another homosexuality. If everyone is committed to Jesus, it doesn’t matter. We’ll work all of that out in eternity.
Peter: No, you won’t. As I said, heresy, and the apostasy to which it leads, denies Christ as Lord over our lives. We are neither loving nor obeying Him in our minds or in our daily lives with it. And we, therefore, will not be working it out in eternity, as those who do not trust in the one faith and godliness of the Christian life will be going off to the same punishment as the fallen angels have been given.
PET: Well, doesn’t the fact that God hasn’t poured out fire from heaven on me indicate that He isn’t that concerned about what we believe and our personal preferences in lifestyle?
Peter: God is punishing false teachers as we speak. He keeps them under this punishment until the day of judgment. This punishment is evidenced in their being given over to their desires.
PET: I’m sorry but labeling these teachers as false, simply because they recognize the impossibility of our situation, is wrong. We all have sin and it is impossible to escape it.
Peter: Well, as I said, God has given us everything we need to escape it, and knows full well how to help us overcome the enticements and temptations of the world. You are, once again, diminishing God’s abilities and exalting your own lack of ability. In other words, you are arguing that our deficiencies are greater than God’s sufficiency and ability to be efficacious in overcoming sin and falsehood in our lives.
PET: We need to stop focusing on heaven and hell and start focusing on making this world a better place. Sin and false doctrine are apart of that narrative that is connected to heaven and hell. Let’s just be tolerant of one another, realize that everyone is on his or her own journey, and start saving the environment.
Peter: Well, how much of the environment is going to be saved when the Lord comes back and destroys the earth in fire?
PET: Is the Lord really coming back, or is that just a metaphor? I mean, it’s been awhile now. It’s probably the case that the church is meant to be His second coming to earth, and that He’s not actually returning. Even if He is, we shouldn’t draw our attention to the future, but concentrate on making the world better in the present.
Peter: Well, living a godly life in the truth that characterizes a genuine relationship with Jesus as our Master is making the world a better place. Uplifting God’s abilities to communicate to us accurately in Scripture shines a light in a dark place, and makes the world a better place. Setting our minds on His coming as an end to evil and oppression, and giving hope to all who believe is making this world a better place. But as I said before, the world is going to be destroyed in fire, so it’s better to make the world a better place on God’s terms, and look toward a new heaven and a new earth.
PET: Seriously, it’s been a long time. He’s probably not even coming, so it’s likely a metaphor for us to clean up the planet.
Peter: No, He is literally coming. You are emphasizing your finite experience again over God’s perspective. To God, a thousand years is like a day. So it hasn’t been that long in God’s eyes at all. Besides, God is waiting for all of His people to come to repentance. He has not yet caused all of them to be born and born again. So His patience is for the love of His people.
PET: You know, we all distort Scripture in the interpretive phase, so even if God communicates to us in the Bible, we still misinterpret it.
Peter: Yes, but some misinterpret it to their own destruction because they purposely twist it to get what they want out of it instead of trusting in God no matter what to communicate the truth to them that submit their minds and lifestyles to Him as Lord. In other words, our understanding of the truth is also a gift given to us by God, who is able to do so. The only reason others twist it and are not given that gift is because they have rejected the one faith already, seeking to either believe or practice rebellion rather than allegiance toward God.
PET: But what about those who just want to know the truth?
Peter: If they are unstable and untaught, i.e., not guided by the apostolic/historic orthodox witness, then they do not want to know the truth. They have rejected it already. If they wish to know it, they can be guided by it in their interpretations of Scripture. Some things are hard to understand. Other things are not. Either way, let them submit themselves to the instruction of the apostolic/historic orthodox teaching as an interpretive guide. Otherwise, they remain unstable and untutored for selfish reasons, and as such, twist the Scripture to their own destruction.
PET: I’ll have to think about that.
Peter: I pray you do, and once you give glory to God by exalting His abilities over your own, both now and forever, may you grow in the grace and knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ. Amen.
Monday, September 12, 2011
The Apostle Peter Converses with American Christianity: PART I
My plan for this next couple of posts is to address ideas within American Christianity by taking upon the persona of the Apostle Peter according to the First and Second Epistles of Peter in a sort of Ecclesiastes fashion (if you’re not clear on what that means, Ecclesiastes is likely a monologue that takes upon the persona of Solomon in order to show the absurdity and futility of his life if used as a desirable model of the “good” life). Here, I wish to become Peter in a dialogue and to have a couple conversations with two types of American Christianity: Modern Evangelicals, who have adopted all sorts of ideas about what it means to be blessed by God, and their children, the Postmodern Emergings, who have turned Christianity from an outward to an inward focus (or from vertical to horizontal in focus). My suggestion is that you read through First Peter before you read the first post and then Second Peter before you read the second. So here it goes.
The Apostle Peter sits down with a Modern Evangelical (ME from here on out—get it) and begins to have a conversation with him about what it means to be blessed by God.
Peter: Praise God for blessing us, my brother.
ME: Praise God indeed. He has blessed us greatly with so much.
Peter: He has indeed. What specifically did you have in mind?
ME: What hasn’t He? Let me see. Good health, abundant finances, a nice home, a great marriage, many friends, respect in the community . . . You name it. He lavishes His riches on us.
Peter: I’m confused. I asked you about blessing. Why did you give me a list of temporal enticements you’ve been given?
ME: What do you mean by temporal enticements? They’re blessings from God.
Peter: Blessing works toward your eternal preservation and life. You named a bunch of things that serve to take your mind away from blessings to focus on this world as your home. But He has blessed us by causing us to be born again so that we hope for an inheritance that is imperishable and undefiled and will not fade away, reserved in heaven for you. The things you mentioned just exist to sustain your life temporally in order for you to complete your service to God during your very brief stay here, and if you confuse them as blessing, the devil has a great opportunity to use them as temptations to take your mind off of the true blessing you have been given in Christ.
ME: Well, yeah, of course, I believe that I get to go to heaven too. I just get all of this other stuff along the way. I’m blessed now and for all eternity, only now I’m blessed with stuff and a relationship with Christ. I can have both in my life as blessings.
Peter: But the blessings of being in Christ and being born a new creature in this world makes you an alien to this place. That means that it’s going to bring about persecution from others, which of course will produce suffering in your life. You’re likely to lose all of that stuff you think is God’s blessing upon your life. Aren’t you going to become embittered toward God if all of that happens, precisely, because you think that God is cursing you by taking away His blessings?
ME: I don’t believe God is going to take away my blessings. The gifts of God are irrevocable. I just think positively and have faith, and if God challenges me, it will only to be to give me even more on the other side of it. I’ll be a better me than before and maybe have an even bigger house, better marriage, a bigger pocket book, more friends, and more respect than I had before.
Peter: Well, God does put faith to the test to make sure that its focused on the right things. He stresses us with various trials for the purpose of redirecting our focus toward the praise of His honor and glory. So it is His normal practice to destroy the things you named as blessings in order to show us that our true blessing is what He has given us in Christ that is ready to be revealed when He returns.
ME: Well, I don’t think that way. I choose to think positively rather than be a Negative Nelly about losing all of the stuff He has given to me. My life is going great because I’m positive toward the bright future with which He has blessed me in this life and in the next.
Peter: So what positive thoughts will you be thinking when you’re cast into the arena and the lion is tearing your legs off? What bright future will you be imagining when your family has been enslaved for the rest of their lives and you have been sent separately to prison and sentenced to death? What faith will you have when no one will hire you or sell you food or clothing and the government comes to take away your house?
ME: That’s just stuff that happens in your time. Our culture doesn’t do that stuff anymore. God has truly blessed us in this time.
Peter: Well, God doesn’t change, so even if you’re not undergoing persecution and trials, others in the world are.
ME: Yes, people who are less blessed.
Peter: No, people who are actually blessed with a genuine blessing that will preserve their lives forever. Your “blessings” end as soon as you die. You don’t think you’re going to “faith” your way out of dying, do you?
ME: Who knows? It’s going pretty good so far. I’m in great health—another blessing from God.
Peter: Well, if God’s blessings make you a citizen of His eternal kingdom and an alien in this world, a world that belongs to the devil as his hunting ground, and you’re not undergoing the loss of temporal benefits, maybe your blessings have been given to you by the devil in order to keep your mind and spirit bound to this realm that is passing away. In other words, maybe you’re cursed rather than blessed with what you’ve been given.
ME: How is the hardship you’re describing anymore of a blessing than living the good life?
Peter: Because it causes you to look to Christ and what true blessing really is, and true blessing is the salvation of your soul. Instead of giving us stuff because we’ve been good or had good thoughts (i.e., enough faith to receive them), we live a holy life because we realize that we have already been given an inheritance in heaven. Our salvation is our pursuit in life. Our true citizenship in God’s holy kingdom is who we have been born again to be, and as a result, it is that we seek to preserve, as that is who we truly are and forever shall be.
ME: But I thought only people who are bad get bad things in life.
Peter: Bad people do suffer in this life by nature of the destructive practices that erode life; but Christians are to suffer for doing what is right, and they will suffer for it.
ME: But I can’t see the blessings you’re talking about. I can see my stuff. How do I know I’ve received these blessings? Isn’t the fact that I can see the great life that God has given me a better indicator of blessing?
Peter: No, it’s not. As I said, what you see will end when you die, and likely before that, so it only serves to destroy your faith if you confuse it with your true blessings that are eternal in nature. And we know we have received them because the abiding Word of God has promised it to us. It’s through the Word of God that we have been made new creatures, and that promise is eternal and abides forever, unlike the grass that withers and the flower that falls off. Hence, its testimony is a better indicator of blessing in your life. And it is clear that if you love Jesus Christ the Lord, even though you don’t see Him, you have God’s eternal blessing of salvation.
ME: I just think that those who are really blessed get all of it, both here and there, now in this world and then in that one.
Peter: So are you saying that the Lord Jesus wasn’t as blessed as you are?
ME: What do you mean?
Peter: I mean that He was the stone the builders rejected. He committed no sin, nor was any deceit found in His mouth; and while being reviled, He did not revile in return; while suffering, He uttered no threats, but kept entrusting [Himself] to Him who judges righteously. He was not only living a good life, but the best of lives. Yet, He was dishonored among the community, became poor, His friends deserted Him, and His life was taken from Him. According to you, He was less blessed than you are because of this.
ME: Well, He did that for our salvation.
Peter: Exactly. He endured the loss of earthly securities, counting them as curses because a love for these things as blessings became obstacles in the way of the salvation that was before Him. And we are to follow in His footsteps, and all of that starts by seeing blessing correctly. If we do not, the devil prowls around waiting for someone’s mind and heart he can consume in earthly, temporal pursuits. But if Christ endured the loss of these things, even the loss of His life, in view of the true blessing of salvation and heavenly citizenship, then we can endure any loss as well, whether inflicted by a governing authority, community, or situation in this life. But if we see those things you mentioned as blessings to hold onto, then we will try to protect them and be embittered toward God and other for taking them away. Instead, we who know what true blessings we have been given through the Word of God do not need to fight back, revile, or be embittered when they are taken away, but instead can rejoice with a joy inexpressible because God has given mercy to us who had no mercy, and has saved our lives.
ME: But I feel like I’m missing out on something if I don’t scoop up as much in this life as I can. I want to have and experience it all.
Peter: And that is precisely why you will not experience the greatest of all there is to experience. Those who realize what God’s blessing truly is in their lives have no need of scooping up as much stuff, or living as long as they can, or having as many thrills as they can in this life, because they have come to understand that it is all incomparable to the riches we have in Christ. We realize now that we have had plenty of time already to experience the pathetic pursuits of the world that are passing away. We can now pursue only that which matters most: God’s blessing us with salvation. We, therefore, seek to live now as citizens of the great city, and it is so much a blessing indeed to be made a citizen of heaven that we seek to wear the holiness of that place like a badge on our arms.
ME: Thank you so much, Peter. My mind was in the wrong place. The blessings that we have in eternity through Christ make everything else look like a bunch of dried up grass and dead flowers indeed. God bless you for setting me straight.
Peter: Thank you for listening, and praise God that you have now understood that the sign of God's blessing of salvation and caring presence in our lives is loss rather than gain in this world. And please know that after you have suffered for this little while, the God of all grace, who called you to His eternal glory in Christ, will Himself perfect, confirm, strengthen and establish you. May you give to Him (not to temporal pursuits) dominion in your life forever and ever. Amen.
Saturday, September 10, 2011
Hell: A Love Story
We've discussed the flood, Egyptian plague, and Canaanite conquest narratives as stories of God’s love, a love that saves His children from the corruption and destruction of chaotic agents, false humanity, whose actions tend toward a humanless world and work against rather than toward creation and filling up the earth with true humanity, God’s images. We discussed that saving children over destructive agents who would destroy them as the only righteous and loving thing one ought to do in that situation.
Well, now, I want to talk about one more story. It is the most terrifying one of all. It is the story of hell, and it is perhaps more terrifying because we, in one way or another, will all participate in it, either being saved from it or being saved by it. Yes, I said being saved by it. Let me explain what I mean.
The wicked must be removed from the righteous and subdued so that they do not corrupt or destroy the world of God’s children. They cannot be allowed to wreak the havoc in the new creation that they were allowed to do in the old. If they were, God would not be saving His children from an eternity of their oppression, but damning them to an eternity of it. Hence, hell itself functions like the flood, the plagues, the conquest. It is a removal of the destructive influence and oppressive power of the wicked toward the righteous. It saves God’s children from a hellish heaven. Hence, in order for God’s children to be saved, their destroyers must be subdued and imprisoned.
“But wait,” you might say, “Why couldn’t God just provide some other nice place for the wicked and put them there?” We must not forget that the justice and goodness of God requires the punishment of evil. Hence, the wicked must be punished (either through Christ or in hell). Hell, then, must exist for those who have not had their sins removed through Christ’s death. But God’s not going to punish them for no reason. As with the other events of God’s destruction of the wicked, He is going to use it to save His children. By condemning the wicked to hell, therefore, He is saving His children from them, and thus, loving them.
Now, here’s the thing. God could have saved everyone. He could have drawn everyone to Himself, but we are told that He does not. In fact, we are told that He hardens whoever He wishes to harden and has mercy upon whomever He wishes to have mercy. So why not save everyone? If he can’t save them, why not just destroy them? Let me give this illustration as to why I think He cannot, in fact, save everyone (and, No, it has nothing to do with free will), nor destroy the wicked once for all rather than eternally punish them.
When I was younger, I had a bit of a health problem. I believed that I had something that was going to kill me. I’ve often said that the only difference between the feeling that you have before you die and the feeling you have when you think you’re going to die is that you actually die in one them. In other words, the feeling is the same, regardless of the outcome. So imagine the absolute joy and gratitude that I had when the doctor informed me that I wasn’t going to die. I was saved, and I just wanted to shake the doctor’s hand again and again in gratefulness and happiness. Even though he wasn’t the one who saved me (he was just the herald of the news), it bound me to him as though he were my closest friend. Salvation has the affect on us. It gives us gratitude and joy and binds our hearts to the one who saved us. But it’s only short lived. I don’t feel that way toward the doctor now. It was only while I was caught up in the moment of it, when I could see both my possible death and my deliverance from it at once, that such a relationship was possible, and only in that moment was something that transformed me in a way that other events could not. It sobered me up and gave me an appreciation of the life I was given that I didn’t have before.
I recount this for you now because I’m going to say something that you may not have considered before. What I’m going to say is both glorious and terrible, both wonderful and heartbreaking at the same time. What I’m going to say to you is this: that the damnation of the many may serve to save the few. In other words, hell too is a love story, but not for everyone. It is a love story for God’s children, because it serves as an eternal reminder, a constant witness to us of our possible damnation, our horrible fate, and sobers us up, gives us gratitude toward God for our salvation that He provided for us, and binds us to Him in a way that only such a thing could. In other words, the damnation of the many is not simply God judging the wicked, but using their rightful judgment to continue to bind us to Him in gratitude for all eternity. In this way, the moment of our realization of what God has done for us never fades. Our fates are always before us, reminding us of where we should be, and giving us an eternal love for God because of where we are.
Now, this relationship that is created by our understanding of what God has done for us through Christ is what saves us. In other words, what saves us is our being bound to God by a relationship characterized by allegiance, love, and gratefulness. He has justified us, and that has brought us into this saving relationship with Him. So if this type of relationship with Him saves us, as opposed to a faith that is not characterized by love and gratitude, then we cannot be saved without it. Hence, if we need the eternal witness of the damned in order to remember and continue to have this relationship with God, then God cannot save everyone. He must subjugate the existence of the non-elect to the elect in order to save some. In other words, if He were to save everyone, He would save no one.
It also seems like it is not enough to damn a few and save the many, as the point of such a display is the severity and near totality of God’s condemnation of evil and overcoming of chaos. And this is an important point as well, as God reveals Himself, not only in saving us, but in judging chaotic agents from whom we are saved. In other words, we come to know Him through such a huge and powerful subjugation of the wicked (think of the plagues upon Egypt here). Hence, in order to know Him, and knowing Him is to have eternal life and what it means to be saved (John 17:3). We see His justice. We see His greatness in overcoming evil. We see His hatred toward evil as He reveals His good nature in its subjugation. We see His justice in bringing chaotic agents to a rightful punishment, holding them at bay from His ordered world and His people. We, then, come to identify Him correctly through this punishment, and without it, would tend to misidentify and misunderstand who He is—thus keeping us from a genuine relationship with Him. Again, therefore, God must punish the many for eternity if He is to save the few for that same eternity.
In Romans 9:10–24, Paul tells us of God’s purpose in His condemnation of those He hardens as a means of God having mercy upon those He saves:
And not only this, but there was Rebekah also, when she had conceived [twins] by one man, our father Isaac;
for though [the twins] were not yet born, and had not done anything good or bad, in order that God's purpose according to [His] choice might stand, not because of works, but because of Him who calls,
it was said to her, "The older will serve the younger."
Just as it is written, "Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated."
What shall we say then? There is no injustice with God, is there? May it never be!
For He says to Moses, "I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion."
So then it [does] not [depend] on the man who wills or the man who runs, but on God who has mercy.
For the Scripture says to Pharaoh, "For this very purpose I raised you up, to demonstrate My power in you, and that My name might be proclaimed throughout the whole earth."
So then He has mercy on whom He desires, and He hardens whom He desires.
You will say to me then, "Why does He still find fault? For who resists His will?"
On the contrary, who are you, O man, who answers back to God? The thing molded will not say to the molder, "Why did you make me like this," will it?
Or does not the potter have a right over the clay, to make from the same lump one vessel for honorable use, and another for common use?
What if God, although willing to demonstrate His wrath and to make His power known, endured with much patience vessels of wrath prepared for destruction? And [He did so] in order that He might make known the riches of His glory upon vessels of mercy, which He prepared beforehand for glory, [even] us, whom He also called, not from among Jews only, but also from among Gentiles.
Now, this may be a horror if you are prone to lift up the criminal and the wicked above the righteous.judge, but rather than show God’s apathetic punishment of the wicked, it shows His great love for His children in that He was willing to grieve Himself and have His heart broken over the many in order to save forever His people. After all, He does love all people, but as we discussed before, He cannot love everyone the same, since He seeks to save some. Hence, He is willing to bring into existence those whom He loves and knows will perish in order that He might also bring into existence those who He will save from and through their subjugation and eternal imprisonment. That’s how much He loves them. That’s what He’s willing to do. And let us not forget that the wicked belong in hell. It’s just that His children did as well, but He saved them, and continues to do so forevermore by the reminder of their fate. Hence, the punishment of the wicked will always be used as a means to save God’s people, i.e., a means of His love toward His children. And as is the case of the flood, the Egyptian plagues, and the destruction of the Canaanites, the emphasis is on God saving His people and only secondarily about the punishment of the wicked. It is about His love, and what that love is willing to do in order that His children might be delivered from destruction and death. Their murderers and molesters subdued, and peace and safety restored, the children of God can live on forever without the oppression of the wicked any longer. All their wounds healed and all their tears wiped away, they will never again be destroyed by their destroyers. Instead, in a twist of fate that only One as great as God could pull off, they will now be saved by them. Our punishment, like a window allowing us to peak through and show us our alternate fate, is displayed through those in hell; and it continues to show us just how awesome a thing it was that God did for us in Christ. So God isn’t just punishing the wicked in hell for no reason. He’s saving His people, because hell is a love story, and that is all it was ever meant to be.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)