Friday, December 3, 2021

Extreme Makeover: Epistemology Edition

 Modern Evangelicals have a variety of terms they use to shut one another down. They may use the term “racist” themselves but they also have their own home-cooked brew of pejoratives. “Legalist!” “Pharisee!” “Arrogant!” “Extreme/Radical!” It’s this last concept I wish to explore here.

The idea that something is radical or extreme is an interesting one because it assumes a standard of normality that is often under scrutiny at the time one makes this claim. In other words, when one presents a view that the other thinks sounds extreme and is labeled as such, he is likely begging the question by doing so. This is the case because whatever is true should actually be the standard, not whatever one is used to.

Unfortunately, the standard of familiarity tends subjectively to assume that whatever a particular person is most used to is the standard and whatever he is least familiar with is extreme or radical.

Now, if one is making the claim because he is appealing to the revealed Word of God using the objective criteria of exegesis to mark the standard of normality then there is nothing arrogant about claiming that something is extreme or radical. However, this is often said before those arguments are put forth, precisely, because that is not usually the appeal. Rather the person assumes that whatever he is familiar with, whether from tradition, “soundslikegesis,” what he was taught previously by various teachers in the church, etc., is the norm and whatever goes too far beyond it is extreme/radical.

I cannot stress the amount of arrogance that this subjective criteria musters in order to make a claim that is not rooted in exegesis. It is likely the case that we have many blind spots and simply fail to realize in our desire to preserve our personal beliefs we tend to make appeals to things we should not.

Whatever the reason may be, the person doing this, ironically, may actually be the one holding a radical or extreme position that deviates too far from or even completely contradicts the true norm that only has the possibility of being found by employing all of the objective tools of exegesis.

If evangelicals are to get past their cult they must make a radical shift, an extreme makeover, in evaluating how they are actually arriving at their norms.

Discerning Charges of Arrogance in Biblical Interpretation

In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man isn’t king, he’s an arrogant jerk. That’s because if no one sees what he sees then to boldly make a truth claim concerning the nature of reality is to be arrogant in the opinion of the masses if that truth claim should be contrary to what everyone else might believe.

Unfortunately, we are all the products of Enlightenment inclusivism whether we like it or not. What that means is that anyone claiming to know a truth that excludes the opinions of others will be seen as an arrogant tyrant who lifts himself up over others. This is especially true of religious knowledge.

This is because, in the Enlightenment, it was argued that religion cannot be known in any sort of objective manner. Hence, one could only subjectively take hold of what was religiously true based on his or her experience. Since no one could really know what was religiously true, anyone claiming to know it was arrogant, thinking that their subjective experience is better than someone else’s because they must be assuming that they are smarter, more spiritual, more righteous, or more important in some way.

In the Post-Enlightenment Era in which we find ourselves today, this assumption is deeply rooted in our ideas concerning religious truth claims and our concept of arrogance. Religious relativism is the religion of the humble. Exclusive dogma is the religion of the arrogant.

To make any sort of truth claim about religion that excludes and rejects the validity of the religious truth claims of others is to lift oneself up as superior. Hence, what is really important is how one speaks, not the content of what one says. One must speak in a manner that concedes to the validity of other religious truth claims that contradict one’s own. This is what the humble man does because, as said before, only the arrogant man would think that his subjective experience is better than another’s. He must never claim that he knows what is true if that truth should claim that others, especially the majority, are wrong.

Hence, to claim, for instance, that Christ is the only way of salvation will be met with accusations of arrogance toward the one who makes that claim. These accusations run something to this effect: “Who are you that you think you’re so special as opposed to all of these other people, the majority, who don’t believe what you do? You must think you’re better than they are. How could so many others be wrong? Most people in the world don’t believe that. You’re holding a minority view. If you personally believe that, that’s fine; but say it in a way that acknowledges that the ideas of others that contradict yours are just as valid.”

The same conversation can be repeated for virtually any religious belief, since all beliefs automatically infer an exclusion of any truth claims that contradict them.

Evangelicals, although willing to be labeled arrogant for what they consider essential, have largely adopted this stance toward any religious truth claim that falls outside of what they personally think is not only clearly true but in their minds universally held. Hence, to make the claim that one knows the right interpretation of a particular biblical text that falls outside what is considered essential is to be arrogant. The same types of arguments are made but within the framework of Christian essentials. “Who are you to say such and such is true. So and so has a different opinion and so do many others. You must think you’re better than them, smarter than them, godlier than them, but they are really smart and godly too. You must be arrogant for saying that you know what is true and that they are wrong.”

Now, let me say that it is possible that the accusation of arrogance toward such a person is true. However, it is often assumed to be true when, in fact, it is not. What must decide the matter for us are two essentials pieces of knowledge that must be considered first. These are (1) Is the person’s claim to know the religious truth claim that rejects the opinions of others as false based on subjective or objective criteria? And (2) Does the Bible condemn as arrogant exclusive truth claims made upon the basis of objective or only subjective criteria?

Let’s deal with the first question first. There is a stark difference in biblical interpretation when someone practices exegesis as opposed to what I would call “soundslikegesis.”

 Exegesis is when one looks at the objective evidence of lexicography, grammar, syntax, literary context, genre, audience background, and the objective reasoning of logical and linguistic principles in order to interpret a passage. There is no appeal to the self. The interpreter is not saying that he thinks this text says such and such because he is better in some way, smarter, godlier, more important, superior, etc. He is concluding what can and cannot be the correct interpretation of the passage based upon objective evidence and many times that objective evidence excludes other interpretations that have not taken into consideration everything above and have therefore concluded falsely.

Conversely, “soundslikegesis” is where someone believes that his or her interpretation of a passage is just as valid as someone who has used all of the objective tools above to discover the correct interpretation without him or herself using any of those objective tools above to do the same. In other words, this individual is merely looking at the passage and thinking that it sounds like it is saying something to him, and since he is who he is, his interpretation is just as valid as those of anyone else, learned or otherwise.

The first person is using an objective criteria that is outside of himself. The second person is using a subjective criteria that assumes that he has all that he needs to interpret the passage correctly since he is who he is. Whether this is because he is a Christian and he believes all Christians have some special spiritual insight into Scripture, or because his life experiences or traditions put him on par with the scholar using objective criteria, this person thinks that he should be included in the list of those with valid interpretations.

Now let’s answer the second question. What does the Bible consider arrogant? All of the above? None of the above? I would argue that it considers the last man arrogant and not the first. In order to claim this, let me briefly describe what the Bible considers arrogant.

One can be arrogant in one of two ways in the Bible.

The first way that one can be arrogant is that he can think that his opinions are linked to God directly and therefore the Bible is more of a suggestion book than a divine instruction that is absolute. In this regard, this person either ignores a biblical teaching because although he or she does believe it is right, he does not think it is necessary to hold, or he blatantly rejects a biblical teaching as wrong. This is to lift oneself up over God's Word in some way. This man is contrasted with the humble man who trembles at God’s Word (e.g., Isa 66:1-2).

The second way a mere human can be arrogant is by thinking that he is better than other people. He is superior in some way in that he is more important than another Christian (e.g., Phil 2). In this regard, I would say that the man using subjective rather than objective criteria is arrogant for thinking that his opinions and interpretations of Scripture are valid just because he holds them. Since he is just as good as anyone else and maybe even better, his opinions are just as good as anyone else's.

The one using objective criteria isn’t making a claim based on his equality or superiority in some way. It isn’t based on who he is. It is based on the objective criteria of exegesis. The objective criteria functions as an eye in the land of the blind, not some personal trait or quality that he inherently has.

Ironically, it is often the one practicing “soundslikegesis” who is calling the scholar using objective criteria “arrogant” because he is making a religious truth claim that excludes the views of others who may be just as godly, smart, or important. The mistake is in thinking that our biblical interpretations should be rooted in any of these subjective criteria in the first place. One might even say it is arrogant to assume that they are. But there I go again, arrogant jerk that I am, using that one eye of mine to describe reality.

Thursday, December 2, 2021

The Tragedy of Evangelicalism for Those Who Enter Reformed Churches from Their Ranks

 The true tragedy of Evangelicalism and its lack of teaching a full worldview to those who grow up within it is not necessarily that people grow up in it unaware of how much of their lives had been wrecked by not knowing all sorts of biblical things they needed to know. The real tragedy instead is that coupled with the lack of having been taught a full worldview, evangelicals often assume they already have the standards they need to discern what is Christian and what is not, what is right and what is wrong, what is true and what is false. 

In other words, the real tragedy is the assumption of understanding the whole of Christianity when only a part of it has been taught. This is the Dunning-Kruger Effect. It is the tendency for all humans to assume that when they have been given some knowledge of an area of study, when they do not realize the vastness and complexity of the field, they tend to assume that they have a sufficient understanding of that field enough to make all sorts of judgments based upon that now assumed expertise. We see this in college courses where students may take something like Philosophy 101 and suddenly think that they are experts in the field of philosophy, or when seminary students take Greek 101, all of a sudden, they are biblical scholars (which is why you will often hear the statement that a first-year Greek class has enough Greek to be dangerous now).

Even though this can be true of any field (think about how we're all doctors in our own minds because we have so much medical information available to us) it is most true of religion due to arguments given by certain philosophers in the Enlightenment arguing that religion cannot be evaluated empirically but only experientially. We have an assumption that religious opinions can neither be confirmed nor contradicted. Postmodernity has assumed this argument in its general feeling that religion is personal and cannot be judged by anyone outside of oneself. To do so is arrogant because it lifts one's experience over another's. 

What this means for evangelicals is that the little knowledge that has been given to them is assumed to be sufficient to judge any other teaching that comes their way. The problem is that Evangelicalism does not teach a full worldview and what this ultimately means is that where it does not teach a Christian worldview, the culture's worldview remains intact and even syncretized with Evangelicalism. What this further entails is that evangelicals are believing and practicing things that the wicked world practices because they were never taught that these things are not consistent with a Christian worldview.

Now, that is not yet the tragedy. Anyone can recover from being taught falsely. The problem is that many have come to believe that they do not need to be retaught and instead use their culture's beliefs, which they believe are consistent with Christianity, to judge everything that now comes down to them from the pulpit of Reformed churches that are teaching a full Christian worldview. in other words, they have standardized many of their previous beliefs and practices and have made them the measure of anything they hear from now on.

Because they have already come to believe that what they know and practice is Christianity itself, everything else will be pulled through the grid of that insufficient, and often syncretized, worldview. What often happens then is a conflict takes place between the evangelicals and the Reformed churches into which they enter because what they are now being taught is contrary to what they had already thought to be good and true. Some will realize they had not been taught the full counsel of God and avoid this trap. Many others, however, will either cause dust ups in the church or just leave quietly. Either way, these latter two groups will not tolerate the fuller worldview that contradicts their previous one.

The tragedy, therefore, is that Evangelicalism, by teaching people that what they're hearing is Christianity, causes people to believe that they know what Christianity does and should teach, and by doing so, closes them off from being open to a fuller Christian worldview.

The worldview of Christianity that they were taught is normative to them. The worldview of Christianity that they were not taught, and runs counter to things they have already adopted as good or true, sounds crazy to them. It's extreme. It's radical. It sounds like a cult. No one wants to be a part of a crazy cult. They want the normal Christianity with which they are familiar or imagined as ideal based on their present understanding that makes them feel safe. They assume that there is a safety in numbers, so if most evangelicals do or do not believe something, it must be safe to assume that they've landed on the right position. Likewise, many of our reformed churches even are recovering evangelical churches and have themselves not come fully to a Christian worldview. It is thought that there is safety in those numbers as well. 

Instead, I would suggest that evangelicals start with the assumption that they do not understand Christianity rather than with the assumption that they basically have gotten it. This will help with learning new things that may sound crazy if one already assumes the absoluteness of its opposite. In fact, I would suggest that we all do this regardless of how much you think you already know. We are all under God's Word. It is God who grants understanding of it and He does so through the teachers of the church; but those teachers themselves must approach it with fear and trembling. It is no plaything with which he feed our egos. If it says, "Jump," we should say, How high?" not, "I've never heard it tell me to jump before so I think that's nuts and won't do it." 

We are all recovering from a worldview that runs contrary to God's Word and are often unaware of it. The worst thing one can do is dig his heels in before honestly and openly hearing out Christian teachers who are also seeking to believe and present a fuller biblical worldview in their ministries. 

In this regard, even though we often view Evangelicalism as a steppingstone to further growth, it is often a stumbling block instead, and this is the tragedy of those who are brought up in it. It prevents people from being teachable, and tragically, they are often unaware that the previous evangelicalism that had trapped them in false beliefs is still doing so even when the movement has been left behind.

I've often argued that this is really the only way to be a heretic. Most of us believe heretical ideas in our early Christian life simply because we weren't corrected until later concerning them. The heretic, however, is not merely one who believes heresy but rather one who refuses to be corrected in his heresy. In fact, church discipline is only done upon those who are unteachable. They refuse to acknowledge and repent of their sin but if they had been open to the church's teaching about that sin there would be no church discipline needed. We might then say that being unteachable is the only unpardonable sin, as if the Pharisees had been teachable to the Spirit of God they would not have blasphemed Christ. To be unteachable to God's Word through God's church is, therefore, the one sin that Christians should fear the most. It hardened Pharaoh's heart, caused Judas to betray Christ, and has brought about the damnation of Popes. 

So this is a lament, I guess, for the evangelicals caught in the trap of the Evangelicalism that did not provide the needed worldview to create Christian standards of discernment but rather only the illusion that no further or contrary standards are necessary. May God turn all of our hearts of stone into hearts of flesh and open the eyes of the blind that we might truly see the light of His glory in all things. And may He do away with the stumbling block of partial-Christianity and replace it with the fullness of His whole counsel. 

Sunday, November 28, 2021

What Song Is That?

Have you ever had a tune stuck in your head that you just couldn't stop playing in your head? What's worse is when you get an awful song in your head that you can't get out of it. The words are on repeat even when you're not conscious of it. The tune is on your tongue. This is likely why the words of the song that warns children everywhere says, "Oh be careful, Little Eyes what you see. Oh be careful, Little Ears, what you hear." 

In a similar way, we each have songs in our heads that have been taught to us by the world. Everyone is singing one song or another with their explicit ideas or humming one tune or another with their attitudes and actions. 

When it comes to the song that Christian women are to sing and hum, it is made very clear in Titus 2 that it is one of a husband-lover and a child-lover. Look at those words carefully. It does not say to be one who is married and has kids. It says that one is to become the very essence of a husband and child lover. This means that the song that is sung in one's explicit declarations and the tune hummed by one's attitude and actions is the song of love for husband and children. 

This would make sense since the woman is saved through childbearing (1 Tim 2:15), that the command given before all commands is to "be fruitful in order to multiply, multiply in order to fill up the earth, fill up the earth in order to subdue it and subdue it in order to rule over it," and that the very image of God, the instrument of God to accomplish this goal of filling up the earth with covenant children is expressed then in having "other sons and daughters" (Gen 5). 

The world has a different song to sing, however, and it sings it loudly. It wants you to sing along. It is a hater of husbands and children. It wants you to roll your eyes at your pathetic husbands and to express how awful the burden of children is. It may be Ok with your expressing that you think your current children are worth it, you know, after you express what a burden they are; but it wants you to follow that up by statements such as, "I definitely don't want any more." Nothing makes children feel more loved than your saying how much you love them but how awful it would be to have any more of them. I personally say that about things I love too (e.g., time with my wife, money, love itself, the security of having food and shelter, forgiveness and peace with God), you know, all the things we only want a little of because we love them so much. If we love it, our motto is "a little dab will do ya."

It is now the weekend after a holiday we call "Thanksgiving," yet nothing but ingratitude for having children is often expressed by Christian women and far worse than this is that there is little thought of whether one is obeying the command to "teach the younger women to be lovers of husbands and lovers of children," to sing God's song to one another, in what they are communicating to one another. When Christian women get together they have an opportunity to lift up God's Word that proclaims children to be a blessing and that the quiver that is full of them is blessed by God. Instead, it is often used as an opportunity for the world to play its broken record yet again. If the same song you can hear at any pagan gathering is sung at our Christian fellowships something might be off.

I get it. It takes time for Christians in our day to understand what's happening. Many are recovering evangelicals and have been taught worldly ideas through it. Evangelicalism sings the same song as the world because Evangelicalism is a Christian cult, not an orthoprax Christian movement. Like any cult it has incorporated Christian ideas into it but not all Christian ideas. It warps certain ones to give a false worldview that is not consistent with the Christian song that has been sung for two thousand years (and I would argue from the beginning of time among God's people). Evangelicalism simply sings a different song on this matter than the church has always sung. It is incumbent upon recovering evangelicals to relearn that song and to sing and hum it everywhere.

I get that children are hard to bear. They are a burden. The world, however, teaches us that they are a burden not worth bearing and that is what must be corrected by God's Word. I used to be impoverished and went around calling my children "my gold." It is clear, however, that many consider children something much less than that. Whether a burden is worth bearing really depends upon what you think that burden is. Gold is worth bearing. More worthless items may not be. Perhaps if children were seen at least as valuable to women as money, time, and sleep it would be considered an even trade. Perhaps if they saw children as more valuable than those things, there would be a joy and praise in their music that is often otherwise absent. Instead, we get the dirge because children aren’t worth it in the eyes of the world’s fallen composer.

But when Christian women complain about children or bemoan the prospect of having more of them what they inadvertently sing is the world's song and the devil loves it. His goal is less covenant people, not a filling up of the earth with them. Everywhere and always he has tried to convince the world to sing his song. From Atra-Hasis to Margaret Sanger, he is relentless. The hardship of joining with God to create life in this world is brought on by him that we might give up, not only in seeing the good of it in our minds but believing the good of it in our attitudes and actions. 

Let me end with a little biography of myself, since I too have been on this journey out of Kinderhassville. Everywhere I went, whether churches or schools, pastors and professors alike would tell me that my gifting to understand the Bible was not common and that they thought I was meant to do something great in the world because of that ability. Students at my schools would say it. I had an old mentor who was in charge of an international ministry call me out of the blue one day after not seeing him in decades and tell me that he had been praying over a mountain of people in his life and my name came up as one who was supposed to do something great. He died a week later as if it indicate that God had this one thing left for him to tell me. So many people thought I would be this great reformer of the modern church. I believed it myself right up until the point when I was made sick at an early age in my career, impoverished, and thrown into obscurity. While in exile, I tried hard to reestablish that path, thinking that this was simply one more obstacle in the way to this great ministry God had for me. Whether studying or writing, I attempted to reacquire what I thought had been lost. All the while my children would constantly interrupt me with things they thought were important. They would come in and sit on my lap and tell me about something they were doing or ask me a question of some sort. The feeling that I could do so much more and be so much better without these interruptions would constantly come over me. But eventually one's theology trickles down to his attitudes and I began to hum a different tune because I began to have a different song playing in my head. My children were my ministry. They were the place of reformation. Their interruptions were God's regular daily schedule for me, giving me opportunities to teach them the gospel and disciple them. I wish I had understood it earlier. Many a thing was destroyed and many an opportunity wasted because I was confused as to where and upon whom the currency of my time in life was to be spent.

I will not likely be the great reformer everyone thought I was going to be. I'm nowhere near it. I live in obscurity and will likely die there. My reformation is happening at home. My children and the little church at which I shepherd is my ministry, not some global movement. I have been called, not only to sing God's song to them, but to teach them to hum it with joy too. This is my ministry because it is every Christian's ministry, whether they can partake in the act of childbearing and childrearing or not. 

It is my hope that when Christians gather together, especially Christian women, they will be mindful of Titus 2 and sing and hum it to one another, that they would encourage one another in the Lord's creational work rather than discourage one another from it.

The world works hard now to blast its music through whatever speakers it finds willing. It works hard to get Christians to join its choir. All you need to do is to not be critical of its song but to be sympathetic toward it, to basically agree with it, to hum its tune. But be careful, Little Ears, what you hear, and, O Christian, be careful, Little Mouth, what you sing.

Wednesday, October 27, 2021

Which View of the Image of God Is More Consistent with Christian Orthodoxy?

 If the ontological image of God is moral responsibility and decision making, intellect, relational, etc. then is not man also made in the image of anything else that has those qualities? Does he not image the devil? Demons? Angels? Even other men? What special relationship is there between man and God if man also images all of these other beings too? 

Is it not that man is physical and these others are spiritual? Is that not the difference between them all? But is not that also the difference between man and God? So how is it that man's physical nature can be God's image?

Most of these advocates don't believe that man images God physically, as that would make God physical in their minds, since they think that the word "image" means "reflection in some way." But this is part of the problem. The word "image" does not mean "reflects an appearance of" or "looks like in some way" to where we can only look at spiritual qualities of God and see how the relate to us.

The word "image" here refers to a cult image. A cult image is a physical image that provides a medium for the god to work in the world. Through this physical image, the deity uses it to create order in a particular area, in his temple and then in the city in which the temple resides. It represents the deity's domain and sphere of rule. From that sphere, chaos is thwarted by the deity's presence and work through the idol/image. But one would have to say that the image of God is functional and not ontological in order to say that man is God's image in his physical nature. In other words, if man is God's image in his physical nature and the word "image" means "looks like" then either the Mormons are right or the word "image of God" refers to man's function as God's physical medium in the world, not something that evidences that man is like God in his ontology in some way.

I think this is a real problem for those who define the image of God the way that they do. They are essentially arguing that man only images God in some spiritual way. which is the adoption of a gnostic view. Man, in his spirit, reflects the divine, but not in his crude or evil physical form. 

Hence, it seems that the functional view would be the view more in line with orthodoxy and the ontological view assumes a gnostic view of man, where his physical nature must be disregarded when speaking of the image ontologically. 

Tuesday, October 26, 2021

They All Have Become ἄχρηστος

 Romans 3:12 argues that humanity all together has become achreiow, a word translated as "worthless." Someone arguing on FB for the inherent value of man found other English glosses that he thought fit his argument better to where it was translated as "unprofitable" or "unserviceable." 

Now, this is a distinction without a difference if this debate is known well. The entire point is that if man is unusable for any service or unprofitable for any service then the word is conveying the same thing by being translated "worthless." 

Here is the BDAG entry for both the verb and noun.

ἀχρειόω (s. ἀχρεῖος) (t.r., S., Vog.; by-form ἀχρεόω Tdf., W-H., M., Bov., N25; SIG 569, 31; s. B-D-F §30, 2) 1 aor. inf. ἀχρειῶσαι LXX; 3 pl. pf. ἠχρείωκαν Da 6:21. Pass. 1 aor. ἠχρεώθην; pf. ptc. ἠχρειωμένος (Philo Mech. 60, 16; Polyb. 3, 64, 8 al.; Vett. Val. 290, 1; OGI 573, 16: LXX; ἠχρειώθησαν Just., D. 27, 3; Theoph. Ant. 2, 35 [p. 188, 29]) in our lit. only pass.

① make useless, outwardly, in symbolism, of damaged sticks Hs 8, 3, 4.

② of becoming a liability to society because of moral depravity become depraved, worthless of pers. Ro 3:12 (Ps 13:3; 52:4).—M-M.

ἄχρηστος, ον (s. χρηστός, χράομαι; Theognis+) pert. to not serving any beneficial purpose (in Gr-Rom. society gener. pert. to lack of responsibility within the larger social structure, s. antonyms εὔχρηστος, χρηστός) useless, worthless, perh. in wordplay on the name Onesimus and certainly w. the term εὔχρηστος (as Hv 3, 6, 7; cp. Hs 9, 26, 4; Jos., Ant. 12, 61) Phlm 11 τόν ποτέ σοι ἄ. who was once useless to you (ἄ. τινι as EpArist 164); ἄ. of a slave Epict. 1, 19, 19 and 22 (cp. wordplay χρήσιμον ἐξ ἀχηρήστου Pla, Rep. 411a). W. περισσός Dg 4:2.—Hv 3, 6, 2; Hs 9, 26, 4; ὀξυχολία ἄ. ἐστιν ill temper leads to no good m 5, 1, 6.—DELG s.v. χρή. M-M. TW.

Arndt, W., Danker, F. W., Bauer, W., & Gingrich, F. W. (2000). A Greek-English lexicon of the New Testament and other early Christian literature (3rd ed., p. 160). Chicago: University of Chicago Press.


Man is worthless in terms of his function, and is, therefore, worthless in terms of his form. That is the point of it. 

If gold is no longer valuable due to its servicing function, it is no longer valuable, period. But one might say, "If gold were to lose its monetary value, it could still be used for other things. But that is to say that it is not rendered unserviceable but rather merely had a change of service. So this is not what the word means. Another might say, "Well, even though the gold has no other function, it can still be valuable to the owner. But this is a misunderstanding as well. If it is pleasing in its appearance or just in its existence to the owner then it is serving a function and is, therefore, serviceable/functional/valuable. Changing the translation with other synonyms does not help the case. 

Likewise, the Hebrew word it is translating in Psalm 14:1 is the word שָׁחַת, which is something that is ruined in terms of its function. It is rendered useless as it no longer functions for the purpose it was created. 

Man no longer functions in any good way, which is the point of Romans 3:9-18. He, therefore, does not have value as something that is in some way pleasing to God just by virtue of being man (Rom 8:8). He is not pleasing in function, and therefore, has no value in form. 

This may sound awful to our modern ears but I would suggest it is the glory of the gospel of Jesus Christ. We are not like gold that simply has no monetary value but is still valued by its owner due to some inherent worth or delight. We are more like garbage that has no value whatsoever and is good for nothing but to be thrown away.

Instead, God, in His great mercy and love has chosen, without being compelled by some inherent worth or value in man, freely and without attraction to man's worthiness, decided to redeem what was without value and give the worth and value of the Son of God to worthless people. Those who have been redeemed are now the most valuable creatures that could ever exist. Those who are called by the gospel are being offered the inexpressible and exclusive riches of Christ's value to God and may now obtain this free gift through faith in His Son. 

Fallen man is no longer valuable as God's image but he may become so through the One who is most valuable, and as the images of God, instruments of creation and life, Christians, our duty is to express this magnificent offer to everyone everywhere. The barren may become fertile again by the magnificent work of our Lord Jesus Christ.

In this way, I wonder if those who argue so rigorously that man must retain some inherent value realize that they may actually be diminishing the glory of the gospel in doing so. If man is inherently valuable as the image of God then why wouldn't God value him and save him? Who wouldn't buy back some gold? But only a God whose love and mercy is beyond measure buys back garbage and makes it into gold.

Jesus Is More the Image?

 I was reading comments on FB concerning the image of God debate this morning and it seems clear that there is a bit of a confusion concerning ontology and function. The statement was made that Jesus is more the image of God than fallen man, and I immediately thought to myself, "In what way?"

 Likewise, in a recent conversation a couple of my fellow church officer's had at a conference with another conference attendee, I was accused of divorcing ontology/form and function with my view, an accusation of which I was surprised since the exact opposite was going on. It is those who believe that fallen man is God's image who must either slip into a gnostic division between form and function or agree with me that the form should not be called the image of God. Let me explain.

If man is ontologically God's image, he cannot be something else. He can only be what he is ontologically. Since God did not make man in any way the devil's image, he cannot, by nature, be the devil's image, which is to say that he cannot, by nature, be evil.

Now, of course, we do not believe that man's created nature is evil, but this is missing the point. My point is that if man is made as God's image, he can only function that way. He cannot function in any other way.

What this means is that the image must be divorced from any moral quality, as we know that man does become wicked. The image, therefore, cannot have anything to do with God's goodness, a right relationship with God, etc. If it does, then we have a contradiction between form and function. The gills on a fish are breathing air, its fins may fly, and a bird's lungs can breath water. Form and function are linked. No one can act contrary to his ontology because no one has the ability to act beyond his limitations. 

If man is the image of God by nature, however, not only can he not be anything else, he cannot act in accordance with any other nature. That means that if there is a moral quality to the image at all, man must not only remain inherently good, but can do no evil.

This, we know, is not true. So what is really going on here?

I think that what is truly going on is the old "image and likeness" view that some have held in church history due to tacking on an extra image of God to man. The first is that man is the image of God only in certain human abilities. In other words, in a sort of generic humanity. Man can reason, have relationships, make moral decisions, etc. but this generic humanity has no moral quality to it. It is amoral, and therefore, can fall toward the good or the evil. 

Then there is a moral function assigned to the man that is also called the image or likeness of God (some people divorced the words image and likeness in order to support this paradigm), so that man is actually the image of God in two ways, one ontological and one functional. The functional image does not necessarily flow from the formal image because the formal image is generic and we know that man falls and becomes evil in function, so it can only be generic.

Now, here is the issue. If man's abilities, like rationality, being relational, able to make moral decisions, is the ontological or formal image of God, then we must also say that the angels, the devil, demons, etc. are also the formal or ontological image of God. I might even argue that some animals fall into this category, depending upon how we define "moral decision making" and how that might be distinguished from what unbelievers do but I digress. This would be a rather novel doctrine but it follows necessarily if that is the way we define the image. But it also means that saying that someone is the image of God in the formal sense doesn't really mean much. One is merely saying that everyone is a higher created form than anything that does not have those qualities but there is no special relationship in it.

Likewise, I actually affirm that humans are made this way ontologically. My contention has always been that this is never called the image of God in Scripture. Scripture always discusses the image of God as the functional image, so to make up another definition for the term that includes all of humanity is simply applying biblical terminology to something that is never associated with that terminology. 

However, many do not divorce the moral quality of man from the ontological image, and this is both where we have a logical problem and a slip into gnostic thought. Now, to be clear, gnostic thought does not confuse form and function, as these people often do, but rather posits two forms/two ontologies to humanity. Man does evil because he is ontologically evil by nature in his flesh, but he can do good because he is ontologically good in his spirit. So man has two ontological natures, one good and one evil. The reason why this is the case is because he can do good or evil, and since ontology cannot be divorced from function, he must have two ontologies. 

What those who are offering up is that man has an amoral ontology, something with which I would agree, but a moral duty to use that ontology to be in right relationship with God and do good upon the earth as the instrument of God. Again, we all agree. The issue is whether this is also to be called the image of God and only Scripture and logic will help us here.

So what becomes extremely important is understanding what an image is in the ancient Near East rather than assume we know what an image is because our English word for image sounds like Scripture is talking about a reflection or something. An image in the context of a temple (I realize the idea that Genesis 1 is a cosmic temple is another issue) is talking about a cult image of the deity. In fact, leaving behind even the idea that Genesis 1 is a temple, the fact that you would have the phrase "the image of [insert deity]" shows that we are talking about a cultic image. 

So what is a cultic image and how does it function? Imagine someone creating an image for Marduk. He ontologically makes the image in such a way so that it can function as an image. He is making this image for Marduk but let's say someone steals the image and puts it in the temple of Sin, the moon god, in order to function as his image now. It is no longer the image of Marduk even though it was originally made for Marduk. The reason why it can be used this way is because it is not inherently the image of Marduk. It is not ontologically the image of Marduk. It is simply ontologically an image but it can function as either the image of Marduk or the image of Sin or any other god it is used for. 

Now, part of this understanding is knowing that the images in the ancient Near East did not necessarily look like the gods they were imaging. That is why one could have images that were animals that represented various strengths or domains, or it could be made as some sort of human figure that could represent any god, or a combination of both. So the word "image" does not automatically mean "looks like in some way" when we are talking about a cult image. That is an important point that is often misunderstood.

However, if an image was made specifically with ontological qualities where it could only be the image of Marduk and never anything else, then it cannot function as an image for any other god. This is where we run into a problem. If man is the image of God ontologically, then he cannot function as the image of the devil in any way. If man is only an image ontologically, however, who was made to function as the image of God, then man may walk out of God's temple and into the devil's to image him because although the form of being an image is inherent the function of being the image of God is not. The form is being an image so man must image something by nature. Form and function cannot be divorced. But this means that man is not ontologically the image of God but rather an image made to function as the image of God in a right relationship with God as His instrument of creation and good in the world.

This goes back to our FB discussion. If man is formally the image of God, then Jesus cannot be more the image of God in that sense at all. That would mean that He is more than human in His created nature as a man. That would be heresy. Jesus is God as the Creator but He is fully man, not more and not less. 

Likewise, if we are merely saying that Jesus is more the image of God than fallen man because He functions as the image of God, then we would all agree that He is more than but I would say that He is more than fallen man because fallen man does not function as the image of God at all. He functions as the devil's image.

So what is it to really say that Jesus is more the image of God than fallen man but to agree that fallen man is not the image of God? If one says that fallen man still retains some good moral quality to him in his function then we must move on to prove total depravity from Scripture against what is clearly the beginning of Pelagian or Semi-Pelagian anthropology. 

In the mean time, this problem of form and function is resolved by merely allowing Scripture to guide our vocabulary in the matter and categorize the philosophical view of what man is in distinction from other creatures with some other nomenclature.

As a last comment, it is interesting that Reformed folk in general tend to ask the question, "By what standard?" when it comes to legal and ecclesiastical definitions but even if they come to the understanding that the ontological image of God is not biblically attested seem content to use unbiblical definitions of phrases when it comes to this issue.