Thursday, March 7, 2013

Clearing Something Up about the Fall in the Old Testament

It's trendy to deny the fall these days, and thus, to deny that we are under a curse, so let me just clarify two things that I think those who deny the fall/curse often don't consider.

1. Man is cursed, not just the ground. "On the day you eat of it, you will die" is a curse that goes with the disobedience to the law (in this case, the law that forbids eating the fruit). Hence, God curses Adam, not just the ground, when He says, "from dust you came and to dust you will return." This is also clear by the rest of the Book of Genesis when it displays all of the evil that follows because of this event, but because it is a narrative, it's not going to draw out these connections explicitly.

2. One can be guilty of another person's sin because, within the ANE context, families are whole entities. Your father cannot sin and you be free of guilt, unless you do not sin. But if you sin as well, you accumulate sin for yourself starting with his. What this means is that if all mankind sins, or would sin given the chance, they are guilty of their father's sin. That's why you have familial vendettas that take out the murder committed by someone like Saul upon his descendents. That's why God takes out the sin of Jeroboam I on down upon Israel in the deportation or Judah in the exile. Yes, as Ezekiel states, everyone can repent and not be held guilty, but if they continue their father's legacy of sin, the sin accumulates. Hence, Achan's family pays for Achan's sin, precisely because, in the ANE mind, his family is one entity with him. That's why Jesus can put all of the sins of those who murdered the prophets on his current generation.

I say all that to say that this is how the story of Eden would have been read by an ANE reader. The problem is that we read it anachronistically in an individualistic mindset and end up wondering why any of us would be guilty of Adam's sin and if there really is any such thing as a federal sin. That would have already been assumed by the ANE reader.

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Bulletin of the International Organization for Septuagint and Cognate Studies (BIOSCS) Now Online

I really hope that eventually everything will be available online, and I really hope it will be before I purchase everything. ;-)

In any case, this is a great journal. Enjoy!



http://ccat.sas.upenn.edu/ioscs/journal/volumes/

Monday, March 4, 2013

Sheltering Your Children? What Every Hypocrite Needs to Know

It must be a law of the universe that if you reject a necessary practice as legitimate, you are only going to be presenting yourself as an unthoughtful hypocrite.

For instance, when people say or imply, "You are wrong to judge another person's decisions," that person is obviously judging your decision to judge. Hence, they end up breaking the very moral that they're supposedly upholding in theory.

Another example is when people say that they think it's arrogant for claiming absolute certainty of a proposition. Of course, that's a proposition about which they are assuming an absolute certainty.

These same hypocritical self-defeaters abound when people make claims concerning the freedom they give to their children. "Sheltering children is wrong," so they say. And, of course, what is being withheld from these children is not sheltering but a type of sheltering. In other words, they're sheltering their children from a life of protection from certain things all in the name of freedom.

Everyone shelters his or her kids. It's a matter of where the parents draw the boundaries. I once had someone who would not let her kids around me because she was attempting to shelter her children from what I said. Of course, she was the biggest advocate for letting her children choose their own paths and letting them experience and make their own choices in life. So much for that ideal.

In reality, this is another rebellious self deception that allows the individual to shelter his or her kids from what the Bible teaches about sheltering children in an effort to pretend that he or she is really just being more open and liberated with their children. In reality, these people are merely making the choices for their children like any other parent is doing, closing them off from hearing certain things and considering certain things. They're just making different choices for them than those who follow the Scripture.

Hence, they are sheltering their children like anyone else. They're just sheltering them from what is good and brainwashing them in what is evil. Such is the path of all who are hypocrites. When you are not self-critical of your concepts, you will inevitably judge others for the very thing that you practice. The difference is that some of us know we practice it and others think they're more enlightened/mature than everyone else who isn't as duped as they are. As in all things, to the fool, the wise man is foolish.

So do I shelter my kids? Absolutely. Who doesn't? But I shelter them while I train them to think and spiritually deal with the war of ideas and moral choices that they will encounter in the world. Some people supposedly shelter kids from being sheltered, but what they're really doing is just sending them out unprepared to make good choices. Throwing your kids into a battle untrained is about as loving as killing them yourself. I liken it to sacrificing your defenseless children by throwing them to lions.

I allow the world into their lives in doses, so that I can help them address the foolishness of the world with the wisdom of God. Imagine if you had an army waiting outside your walls and you decided to let the entire army into your walls at once. That city would not stand. That people would be utterly destroyed.

Fighting them in smaller battalions allows the city to have a chance. It may stand. It may win. The people may live. The outcome is not a sure thing, but it is a sure thing the other way. So it's not simply a matter of saying, "Well, they're going to have to face it anyway." It's a matter of understanding that how you train them to face it, along with how much you allow them to face, makes all the difference in their survival.

But everyone is sheltering their children. It's only a matter of whether that sheltering is from what is right or wrong, good or evil, and whether it is honest or hypocritical, working with your children to undo the evil with which the world would undo them or working with the world to undo your children.


Train up a child in the way he should go: and when he is old, he will not depart from it. (Prov 22:6)

That verse works either way btw.

Jesus versus the Marcionites

I recently had an email exchange with a neo-Marcionite (i.e., someone who essentially rejects the Old Testament wholistically as a witness to the true character of God). He argued that Jesus is not the God of the Old Testament, who ordered the destruction of the Canaanites, as I argued in another post, but only the Creator God. The Law of Moses, so he argued, was that of a man, not the Word of God. Hence, Jesus never argued that the He was the God of Moses who gave the Mosaic law, and thus, commanded the destruction of the Canaanites, as the Law of Moses does. Hence, Jesus refers to the law as "your law," instead of the God's Word (i.e., God's teaching/Torah).

Of course, if we can establish that, not only the Law of Moses, but the entire Old Testament is the Word of God from Jesus' own lips, then it should be good enough to settle the debate concerning what God Jesus is claiming to be.

Now, first we can say that simply from a lexical referential standpoint, when Jesus says, "God," He means the God of the Old Testament. They don't live in a pluralistic society that has multiple sources for their views of God. One might be able to argue that He is arguing for a correct interpretation of the God of the Old Testament, but one can hardly argue that He is attempting to refer to some other God other than that of the Old Testament.

But now, from His own lips, let's look at John 10:34-36.

Jesus answered, “Is it not written in your law, ‘I said, you are gods’?  If those people to whom the word of God came were called ‘gods’ (and the scripture cannot be broken apart), do you say about the one whom the Father set apart  and sent into the world, ‘You are blaspheming,’ because I said, ‘I AM one nature with God’?

There are three things I'd like to point out about this text that all come together to refute neo-Marcionism.

1. Jesus equates "your law" with "God's Word."  
2. Jesus unites the entire Old Testament by using the least authoritative part of it (i.e., the Ketubim "Writings") and calling it the Word of God that is law and binding over the Jewish religious leaders to whom He is speaking.
3. Jesus states that the Scripture cannot be broken apart, which rejects their notion that some texts of Scripture are more authoritative than others, and therefore, supposedly lesser texts can be discarded rather than integrated into one's theology.

What this means is this: That Jesus is arguing that the entire Old Testament (even from what was considered least inspired) is one inspired Scripture that cannot be broken apart as any more or less God's Word than any other part of it. 

Hence, Jesus is not claiming to be some other God than the one presented from taking the entire Old Testament together as a single picture of God. When Jesus calls Himself the I AM, He is referring to Himself as YHWH, the YHWH of Abraham, who destroys Sodom and Gomorrah, the YHWH of Moses, who orders the destruction of the Canaanites, the YHWH of Armies/Hosts, who wars against the wicked and decimates them, and the YHWH of Israel, who saves His people from others and from themselves.

For the Lord Jesus, there is only one God and only one reference that He would be signifying with His word "God." That is the God to whom Jesus testifies and with whom Jesus identifies Himself as One.