Tuesday, February 19, 2013

What Is Love?



I know it seems like I'm always picking on my former professor, but I feel as though he has gone off the mark in his theological trajectory, precisely, because of misunderstandings like this one.


As I've mentioned before, we're going through 1 John right now as a family, and of course, I've been through it when preaching through it, and also in two different Greek Exegesis courses (and beyond that, I've studied it 'til the cows come home). But you don't need all of that to see what I'm going to say. You just need what you always need: context.

So what does John mean by the term "love"? If we fail to answer that question, as Dr. Enns does not answer it above, then we're really just assuming what it is. And, of course, assuming what a word means often means that we're importing a contemporary meaning into the term. And no term has been more confused in biblical study than this one.

Now, I don't fault Dr. Enns for this. I've heard people who are of my theological ilk also distort it by assuming its meaning, so this is just an important point of clarification. So here it is:

Love does not refer to your tone of voice, particular feelings/attitudes you might have toward someone when speaking to them, or keeping the peace between yourself and someone else. If it did, then Dr. Enns' post above would be relevant to the verse.

What John means by love, however, is giving what is needed to those Christians who need it. That's how he defines it. Love is taking from what you have in order to give it to another Christian in need. "Hatred" in John's vocabulary, then, is not harsh tones, a malicious intent, angry feelings, or a combative relationship with someone's ideas. Hatred is having what your brother needs to live and closing your heart toward him so that you do not give it.

What is ironic here is that John includes doctrine in this whole thing. Loving Christians means loving God first. Hence, one must obey God's commands in order to love people, and this is loving God as well. But what if someone does not obey His commands? According to John, rebuke is the right course of action of love. Turning a brother away from sin is loving.

Likewise, throughout his entire epistle, John has argued that defining God and Jesus differently than the apostles have is the spirit of antichrist that replaces the true Father and Son with a false God and a false Christ that cannot save others. Guiding one into orthodox truth, therefore, is a part of John's loving activity. It is part of love's course of action, and in John, love is action, not feeling. It consists of words and deeds, not simply words. 

Hence, surrounding his rebuke of heretical theology is his discussion of loving the Father and the Son and loving fellow Christians. Truth is vital to love. After all, if you give someone some food but do nothing when you see him honor a false Christ and damned by a false gospel, how can you say that you love that person? 

Love is also exclusive, therefore, because it must clearly show what is in and outside the bounds of knowing God and Jesus whom He has sent. It must tell us who is "in" and who is "out," and so John tells us just those things by giving assurance to those who have the marks of being a Christian (i.e., they pursue apostolic orthodoxy and taking care of other Christians who are also children of God), as well as telling us who are out (i.e., those who deny the Father and the Son, who do not adhere to the teaching of the apostles, who do not love in word and deed). 

Now, I'm not saying that all theological debates are displays of love. Some are just displays of one or more of the persons to gain superiority and control over others. But, you see, that is a motivation that cannot be seen. Jesus Himself looks arrogant to many when He spends His life (yes, His entire ministry is spent in debate) debating those who are theologically and ethically wayward. But we know that He is perfect and does this out of love for His people (every debate is a learning opportunity to teach those who belong to God and mark boundary lines of what is pleasing to God for them that they may be wary of crossing them).

So I cannot judge motivations (we are commanded in Scripture not to attempt it anyway), but I can judge whether debating theology, and even spending your life doing so, is consistent with, rather than in contradiction to, love as John defines it. And it is consistent, or John wouldn't be doing it, nor would he condemn the Lord doing it, or the rest of the apostles for doing it (were they not always in the synagogues picking a fight, so it seems to us). Contending for the faith, fighting the good fight, taking every thought captive for the sake of Christ, these are all the flowers of love. Sure, someone can give you flowers and hope you get allergies, or give them to you with false motives; but the flowers themselves cannot be the evidence of someone being unloving, since, indeed, they are often the fruit of it.

So my answer to the question, "What about love?" would have been, "What about it? I just described a life of love to you. It is a life sacrificing time and energy in order to preserve the lives of God's children from chaotic ideologies and ethics that would tear them from Him."

Instead, I would have asked this student, "Why have you chosen this path if you could narrow it down to one reason?" That gets to the motivation, but the act itself cannot be confused with the motivation. That's a common mistake I hear, and have heard, all of my life whenever conflict exists, and that can only be attributed to a culture that confuses love with comfort and maintaining a false peace. As I've said before, love works toward shalom, and shalom throughout the Bible is most often achieved in a chaotic world by going to war with the chaos, not making peace with it. John's concept of love is in continuity with that biblical understanding.

What that all means is that, more often than not, it is the person who does not engage in correcting his brother who needs to be corrected in order to save his life, who is hating his brother rather than loving him. If you want to chew on something profound, chew on that one for awhile. Our problem is that we hold our tongues too often when we need to speak what is true on important matters, and then turn around and let them fly on matters that we could have just let go. That's because our biggest problem is that we love ourselves, and so want ourselves defended and our personal opinions heard, but have little love for God and His revealed concerns, since to be concerned of those things would be to sacrifice our own ideas and concerns so that God might be exalted as true, and that His children might see and fellowship with Him in the truth. Our problem, then, as usual, is that we don't discuss theology and ethics because we love ourselves too much, we want to maintain comfort and false peace, and will only disrupt it when the Self is at stake.

That, to me, is a far more serious concern than someone who commits his life, as the prophets, apostles and the Lord Himself did, to a life of submitting their own ideas to the Father in love and calling others to do the same because you love them too.



 

Sunday, February 17, 2013

Reading the Reasons for the Conquest within, rather than from Outside, the Story



The Bible presents the acts of God in destroying the firstborn in Egypt, the Amalekites in warfare, and the Canaanites as a display of His glory, i.e., His exalted beauty to be admired. It displays His love for His people before the nations, and shows them that God's favor rests upon the people who belong to His covenant. 

So when atheists and liberals present it as something ugly and of which all Christians ought to be ashamed and denounce, they are recasting it into their own narrative. They want to imagine that this is about one group of people seeing themselves as superior and more righteous than another group, and so justify the taking of their land.

But as I have argued, this is an act of divine judgment by God upon a people for whom He waited thousands of years, and then another 400 years after He promised to give Abraham's descendents the land, in order that He might not judge them too quickly for all of their sins. 

And in the process of that, He saves His people who would certainly have come to their end in Egypt, according to the story, their end on the road to Canaan, according to the story, and their end in the land of Canaan, again, according to the story. If one wishes to critique that story, or just disbelieve it, that's fine; but he needs to be honest and present the only text relating the actual historical reasons for the conquest. 

After the LORD your God has driven them out before you, do not say to yourself, "The LORD has brought me here to take possession of this land because of my righteousness." No, it is on account of the wickedness of these nations that the LORD is going to drive them out before you. It is not because of your righteousness or your integrity that you are going in to take possession of their land; but on account of the wickedness of these nations, the LORD your God will drive them out before you, to accomplish what he swore to your fathers, to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. Understand, then, that it is not because of your righteousness that the LORD your God is giving you this good land to possess, for you are a stiff-necked people. (Deut 9:4-6)

God then goes on to tell them that He'll do the same to them if they end up filling the land with the same evil that Canaanites did--thus arguing that this is not a matter of one people being greater than another in and of themselves, but rather that it is a matter of judgment upon one group and giving a chance of life and preservation to another to whom God has promised life and preservation. 

Now, that's the biblical story and reasons for the flood, the plagues, the conquest, etc. If you want to read that in a deconstructionist manner and suppose that those are only justifications for such an act, that's your prerogative, but to conjecture another narrative and reason for the conquest is not based upon any ancient text or tradition relating the event. It's just based on a postmodern skepticism of every detail that sounds too good to be true or too bad to be justified in light of our modern attitudes. Such an enterprise is purely ahistorical and ideological in nature. That's my only point.


Saturday, February 16, 2013

Giving the Text the Benefit of the Doubt



When speaking about how one ought to approach reading Kant's Critique of Pure Reason, Dan Robinson points out the scholarly approach to reading literature by giving the text the benefit of the doubt before leveling the charge of contradiction.

“Kant did not go through two editions of perhaps the greatest metaphysical treatise ever composed while proving how wonderful he was at missing the point and contradicting himself. So what I’m going to presuppose in the lectures is where the text is problematical, there’s a stylistic problem, a translation problem, and to some extent, perhaps, a problem with comprehension. You want to begin with the assumption that if you don’t get what Kant said, it could be that you’re not getting it . . .” (Dan Robinson. Philosophy Lecturer at Oxford University).

This is the way that all literature should be read. Unfortunately, many today read Kant and a host of other literature skeptically and looking for contradictions. It is no wonder that the Bible suffers the same fate in the hands of such ungenerous skeptics.




Friday, February 15, 2013

The Better Way to Learn an Ancient Language




I've noticed this with my children when I teach them Hebrew and Greek as well. This approach helps them remember the language much better than when I just do the old fashioned way. In fact, the words and grammar I vocalize and have them speak, they remember quite well. The others that they merely read are almost immediately forgotten.  

If Christianity Is True, New Atheists Are Committing Genocide

What distinguishes many of the neo-atheists with paleo or classical atheists is (1) that their arguments aren't very weighty (this is probably due to the fact that they just don't have to be careful in what they argue since we live in a post-Christian culture that doesn't force them to be more careful) and (2) they are evangelistic. Their goal is to create an atheistic world, where "reason" (i.e., their personal opinions that are not based upon reason) will rule the world.

If they are wrong, most atheists fall back upon what most fall back upon in our culture: I'm basically a good person, so even if I'm wrong God should excuse my theology or anti-theology. This is why most people think that what we believe is irrelevant. If I'm going to go to heaven anyway, and one pleases God by being a good person, then what you believe in terms of your theology is not important.

Aside from this idea being anti-Christian, undermining the whole necessity of the gospel of salvation, it also does not heed the words of Scripture well when it calls all men in their unredeemed minds "murderers" (Rom 3:9-18).

But all the more so are those who are evangelistic in their efforts to either undermine the importance of theology or present an alternate theology or anti-theology that leads people away from the gospel of life.

If Christianity is true, then it is only through Christ and His gospel that anyone can be saved. To teach something that would lead people away from Christ and His gospel is to ensure their deaths. In other words, it is an act of murder.

Now, we all know of atheist dictators who are mass murderers in this age, and atheism lends itself to dictatorship that must commit genocide in order to conform everyone's opinion to the dictator's "for the common good" and according to his use of "reason"; but if Christianity is true, then the neo-atheist evangelist is far more of a mass murderer than even Stalin, Mao, or Pol Pot. It is one thing to take a man's physical life from him. It is something far worse if what a man is doing robs him of eternal life and damns him to eternal hell.

Every person is guilty of this type of murder, which is really worse than murder, if he undermines or speaks against the gospel of Christ; but the evangelist of false views is far more so than anyone else. He is a mass murderer. He is the hand of genocide.

Hence, atheism needs to bank on the idea that Christianity is not true. If it isn't true, he has nothing to worry about. If it is true, he cannot rely on his being a "good" person, since mass murderers are not good people, and as the Scripture says, "no murderer will enter the kingdom of God."

However, the same above cannot be said of Christianity if atheism is true. If atheism is true, Christians haven't murdered anyone in eternity. In fact, all Christians have done is teach people to have convictions, care for others more than themselves, and be more dedicated to a life well lived. Not that any of that really matters if atheism is true, but Christianity does seem to benefit society in this life and not just in the next.

Hence, to give a modification of Pascal's Wager, not because I think anyone should believe because of it, but merely to show what's at stake:

If atheism is true, Christianity has nothing to lose. If Christianity is true, atheism has everything to lose and nothing to gain. If atheism is true, Christians have committed no eternal crime. If Christianity is true, atheists are worse than murderers and are committing genocide when evangelistic in their atheism.

In essence, neo-atheists are putting all of their eggs in one basket, and better be right, because there is no backup plan of relying upon his goodness. All would be murderers in the eyes of God.

Other Arguments concerning the Canaanite Conquest