I've been arguing with an atheist on this blog about God's inability to commit murder. He doesn't seem to grasp my argument, so I'm going to try here one more time to display the distinction in what I'm saying.
He think that I'm saying the following:
Murder is wrong for people to do, but since God has authority, He can do whatever He wants. Hence, it's OK for God to murder.
That, of course, is appealing to authority as the justification of something immoral. That's not my argument. My argument is that God cannot commit murder in the first place, precisely because He has the authority over life and death.
I realize, of course, why this atheist is confused, but I've explained it a number of times. However, here's why he cannot say that I'm saying the former argument while making the latter.
A police officer has the authority to wear his badge and present himself as a police officer to the public, but if I wear a badge and impersonate a police officer, I'm committing a crime and can go to jail for it.
Now, if I were to argue as this lad, I would just complain as he does against God, "Why is it OK for the police officer to commit the crime of acting like a police officer, but it's wrong for me to do so. That must be an appeal to authority. You're just saying that it's OK for him to commit this crime because he's a police officer, but not for me because I'm not a police officer.
Notice the fallacy here. The person is assuming that the authority of the officer to commit a crime comes from his authority, but that isn't the case. The fact is that the authority of the officer dictates that he cannot commit the crime in the first place, precisely because he is a police officer. He has the right and authority to do X, so X is not a crime for him. It is only a crime for those who do not have the authority to do X.
The same goes for my ability to trespass on my own land. A stranger can come trespass on my land, get arrested, and then make his argument to the judge as this atheist has toward God by saying, "Why is it OK for the owner to walk on his own land but it's wrong for me to do so. Why can he commit the crime of trespassing because he owns the land and I cannot because I don't own it?
But again, the fact of the matter is, the position of the landowner makes it impossible for him to commit the crime of trespassing on his own land in the first place. It's not a matter of it being that the landowner has more privilege to commit crimes. It has to do with what is a crime in the first place in relation to beings when it comes to their own property.
Hence, when one says that God cannot murder because He owns all life, and murder is the usurping of God's authority, that isn't an appeal to authority that says that God can commit the crime of murder because He's God. It's saying that God cannot commit the crime of murder in the first place, precisely, because God cannot usurp His own authority over life and death. So my whole point is that God is perfect and doesn't commit crimes, not because everything a being with power might do makes it acceptable even if it's a crime, but because certain rights and authority belong to God so that it is impossible for Him to commit the crime in the first place, since the crime is defined by somehow trespassing on His property and usurping His authority.
Hopefully that distinction is clear now to anyone who may have misunderstood before.
Friday, February 15, 2013
Tuesday, February 12, 2013
How to Have a Practical Divorce
Jesus once told a parable of two sons. A father went to one of his sons and told him to go work the field. He said he would, but then didn't go. He then went to see his other son and told him to go work the field. The son told him that he would not, but then later regretted it and went out and worked the field. Jesus then asks us, "Which one did the will of his father?"
We speak of atheism and practical atheism. The two are brothers but they express themselves differently. The former is an outright declaration that one is an atheist. He is out in the open. His atheism is public knowledge. He admits to what he is. The latter is hidden, and far more subtle in its expression. One can go to church every Sunday and call himself a Christian, but live as though he is an atheist. God does not factor into his decisions and daily life. The person who is a practical atheist may find comfort that he is not a declared atheist. He may condemn those who are declared atheists, but this is truly only hypocritical, as he is every bit an atheist as the one he condemns.
The same can be said for divorce. There are those we considered divorced who have publicly declared it. We know who they are, and may shake our heads at them. We may take comfort in the fact that we are not divorced and feel some satisfaction that we still have a piece of paper that says we're married. But what is far more common, and what no one seems to talk about, is the fact that a marriage can have a practical divorce. In fact, a couple may live with each other for fifty years as officially being married, but in reality have been practically divorced for the past forty-five of those years.
So I would take all of the signs in this article, if these are prolonged practices that are the norm in your marriage, as signs that you and your spouse have been divorced for some time.
You are two people living in a house together. Perhaps you occasionally have deeper talks or even become physical, but not as a normal practice. Many declared divorced people do the same. They occasionally have deeper talks with their exes and are occasionally physical with him or her. But it is the normative nature of your relationship that will tell if you are really living a married or divorced lifestyle.
Now, I say all of this to say that you need to make sure you are actually fulfilling your vows. A piece of paper doesn't fulfill them for you. You swore an oath before God and men, and what God has put together let no man separate. This means you need to be active in your commitment to God to make sure you remain married every day, regardless of what the piece of paper says. Ask yourself daily whether you look like a married couple or a divorced couple living in the same house.
Look at the list in the link. Does your marriage look more like the list, or does that list not look very much like your relationship? If it doesn't, congratulations. You're living a married life. If not, I'm sorry, but you're living a divorced lifestyle, one that does not take your vows to God and the one you committed yourself to love very seriously.
If marriage is a commitment to God and your spouse above yourself, then divorce can be described as a commitment to yourself above God and spouse. What other people think of your marriage is irrelevant. What the state officially says of you on a certificate is irrelevant. Are you married or are you not married according to what makes a marriage a marriage? That is the only question that matters.
I'm sorry to say that, as there are far more practical atheists than declared, theoretical atheists, there are far more practically divorced couples than there are declared divorced couples. Why in the world do these people think that they are more faithful to God than the others? Why is it more godly because you have a piece of paper that says you're married and the others no longer do? It's absurd. A practically divorced couple is no more pleasing to God than a practical atheist. In fact, they may be worse off, since God holds those who know better to a greater accountability.
If we are not merely to love in word, but in word and deed, then practical divorce is a sin of hatred toward God and spouse. It loves in word, but not in deed. It declares itself to be pleasing to God as one thing but lives as something completely unpleasing to Him. It isn't the boy who says, "Yes Father," with his lips. It's the boy who says, "Yes Father" with his actions that does the will of the Father. And the married couple has promised to God that they would say, "Yes Father" with their actions 'til death do they part.
We speak of atheism and practical atheism. The two are brothers but they express themselves differently. The former is an outright declaration that one is an atheist. He is out in the open. His atheism is public knowledge. He admits to what he is. The latter is hidden, and far more subtle in its expression. One can go to church every Sunday and call himself a Christian, but live as though he is an atheist. God does not factor into his decisions and daily life. The person who is a practical atheist may find comfort that he is not a declared atheist. He may condemn those who are declared atheists, but this is truly only hypocritical, as he is every bit an atheist as the one he condemns.
The same can be said for divorce. There are those we considered divorced who have publicly declared it. We know who they are, and may shake our heads at them. We may take comfort in the fact that we are not divorced and feel some satisfaction that we still have a piece of paper that says we're married. But what is far more common, and what no one seems to talk about, is the fact that a marriage can have a practical divorce. In fact, a couple may live with each other for fifty years as officially being married, but in reality have been practically divorced for the past forty-five of those years.
So I would take all of the signs in this article, if these are prolonged practices that are the norm in your marriage, as signs that you and your spouse have been divorced for some time.
You are two people living in a house together. Perhaps you occasionally have deeper talks or even become physical, but not as a normal practice. Many declared divorced people do the same. They occasionally have deeper talks with their exes and are occasionally physical with him or her. But it is the normative nature of your relationship that will tell if you are really living a married or divorced lifestyle.
Now, I say all of this to say that you need to make sure you are actually fulfilling your vows. A piece of paper doesn't fulfill them for you. You swore an oath before God and men, and what God has put together let no man separate. This means you need to be active in your commitment to God to make sure you remain married every day, regardless of what the piece of paper says. Ask yourself daily whether you look like a married couple or a divorced couple living in the same house.
Look at the list in the link. Does your marriage look more like the list, or does that list not look very much like your relationship? If it doesn't, congratulations. You're living a married life. If not, I'm sorry, but you're living a divorced lifestyle, one that does not take your vows to God and the one you committed yourself to love very seriously.
If marriage is a commitment to God and your spouse above yourself, then divorce can be described as a commitment to yourself above God and spouse. What other people think of your marriage is irrelevant. What the state officially says of you on a certificate is irrelevant. Are you married or are you not married according to what makes a marriage a marriage? That is the only question that matters.
I'm sorry to say that, as there are far more practical atheists than declared, theoretical atheists, there are far more practically divorced couples than there are declared divorced couples. Why in the world do these people think that they are more faithful to God than the others? Why is it more godly because you have a piece of paper that says you're married and the others no longer do? It's absurd. A practically divorced couple is no more pleasing to God than a practical atheist. In fact, they may be worse off, since God holds those who know better to a greater accountability.
If we are not merely to love in word, but in word and deed, then practical divorce is a sin of hatred toward God and spouse. It loves in word, but not in deed. It declares itself to be pleasing to God as one thing but lives as something completely unpleasing to Him. It isn't the boy who says, "Yes Father," with his lips. It's the boy who says, "Yes Father" with his actions that does the will of the Father. And the married couple has promised to God that they would say, "Yes Father" with their actions 'til death do they part.
Is Living the Questions a Faith Journey?
Emergings/liberals like to talk about the journey that is the Christian life. No doubt, the Christian life is a journey. It has always been seen as such. The Pilgrim's Progress describes it in allegory. We are moving, but we are moving toward Christ through believing, rather than doubting, the truth the Spirit has revealed in Scripture, and that is something I don't hear often.
The journey is not about discovering what is true. We have revelation for that. The journey is really discovering all of the implications and applications of the truth and how to live them out in our worship toward God in the becoming of the image of His Son.
We know what is true by faith. And this leads to another misunderstanding by the emerging/liberal crowd. They think that not holding to something absolute with certainty is a life of faith, but that's completely backward. Not holding to something revealed in Scripture as an absolute truth with certainty is a lack of faith. It is a life of doubt. That's why all the questions as to what is true come.
The liberals cannot see the truth themselves, and so they cannot be certain, they cannot know something is absolute. This is because they are assuming that certainty of knowledge must come via sight. But it is faith that believes what God says and becomes certain of it, not based upon one's own experience in seeing it, but based upon one's faith/trust in what God has said, believing that He is good and able to communicate what is true to us despite our finitude and sin.
I can know because I believe. I can know with absolute certainty through faith. I cannot know with absolute certainty through sight. The liberal solution to this problem is to say, then, that one cannot know with absolute certainty; but that is to trust in oneself and have humility of truth because the Self does not experience it for itself. The Christian solution is that absolute certainty can be had through faith, and that it is only doubt that gets in the way of living the Christian life, applying the truth and all of its implications in life because one is always second-guessing what the truth is.
The Christian life is one of questioning, but not the type of questioning that liberals do. It is a life of questioning the ability of the self to know the truth apart from revelation. It is not a life of questioning God's ability to give revelation of the truth through His Word. It is a life of questioning how to apply the truth and what it means for every aspect of life. It is not a life of never coming to the truth to begin with because one is too busy questioning whether it is true in the first place.
Since the liberal cannot see, he cannot have absolute certainty that something is true. But to call this a life of faith is odd, since faith is believing that something is true apart from seeing and experiencing it for oneself. One does not need to come to experience that something is true on his journey in order to believe it is true. Otherwise, he is living a life of sight, not faith. He must experience the truth for himself in order to be certain that it is true. This is why liberals are often so certain of physics, but not so much of metaphysics. But this isn't faith toward God and His ability to communicate to His people the truth they need to live the Christian life and know Him. It's doubt that hinders that life. It hinders the journey toward applying and living out the truth.
And of course the obvious observation is this: One must absolutely believe all sorts of things as true and certain in order to use them as the standards by which all other things are questioned. So the whole enterprise is a facade. No one spends his life in the questions when it comes to what is true. He already has all sorts of certain beliefs by which he forms those questions. They determine what else is true or false for him because his life is a matter of working out smaller things he believes with the bigger things he believes. So the real questioning of the Christian should not be a matter of wondering if he can know with absolute certainty, but rather that since he already believes he knows absolute and certain truths, are those absolute and certain truths in accordance with what God has revealed through His Spirit in the Word of God or are they in accordance with the zeitgeist?
One can take a journey anywhere. It doesn't mean they'll all end up in the same destination, since not all paths take a sojourner to the same destination. There is a journey to be had in the Christian life, but not all paths lead to life.
The journey is not about discovering what is true. We have revelation for that. The journey is really discovering all of the implications and applications of the truth and how to live them out in our worship toward God in the becoming of the image of His Son.
We know what is true by faith. And this leads to another misunderstanding by the emerging/liberal crowd. They think that not holding to something absolute with certainty is a life of faith, but that's completely backward. Not holding to something revealed in Scripture as an absolute truth with certainty is a lack of faith. It is a life of doubt. That's why all the questions as to what is true come.
The liberals cannot see the truth themselves, and so they cannot be certain, they cannot know something is absolute. This is because they are assuming that certainty of knowledge must come via sight. But it is faith that believes what God says and becomes certain of it, not based upon one's own experience in seeing it, but based upon one's faith/trust in what God has said, believing that He is good and able to communicate what is true to us despite our finitude and sin.
I can know because I believe. I can know with absolute certainty through faith. I cannot know with absolute certainty through sight. The liberal solution to this problem is to say, then, that one cannot know with absolute certainty; but that is to trust in oneself and have humility of truth because the Self does not experience it for itself. The Christian solution is that absolute certainty can be had through faith, and that it is only doubt that gets in the way of living the Christian life, applying the truth and all of its implications in life because one is always second-guessing what the truth is.
The Christian life is one of questioning, but not the type of questioning that liberals do. It is a life of questioning the ability of the self to know the truth apart from revelation. It is not a life of questioning God's ability to give revelation of the truth through His Word. It is a life of questioning how to apply the truth and what it means for every aspect of life. It is not a life of never coming to the truth to begin with because one is too busy questioning whether it is true in the first place.
Since the liberal cannot see, he cannot have absolute certainty that something is true. But to call this a life of faith is odd, since faith is believing that something is true apart from seeing and experiencing it for oneself. One does not need to come to experience that something is true on his journey in order to believe it is true. Otherwise, he is living a life of sight, not faith. He must experience the truth for himself in order to be certain that it is true. This is why liberals are often so certain of physics, but not so much of metaphysics. But this isn't faith toward God and His ability to communicate to His people the truth they need to live the Christian life and know Him. It's doubt that hinders that life. It hinders the journey toward applying and living out the truth.
And of course the obvious observation is this: One must absolutely believe all sorts of things as true and certain in order to use them as the standards by which all other things are questioned. So the whole enterprise is a facade. No one spends his life in the questions when it comes to what is true. He already has all sorts of certain beliefs by which he forms those questions. They determine what else is true or false for him because his life is a matter of working out smaller things he believes with the bigger things he believes. So the real questioning of the Christian should not be a matter of wondering if he can know with absolute certainty, but rather that since he already believes he knows absolute and certain truths, are those absolute and certain truths in accordance with what God has revealed through His Spirit in the Word of God or are they in accordance with the zeitgeist?
One can take a journey anywhere. It doesn't mean they'll all end up in the same destination, since not all paths take a sojourner to the same destination. There is a journey to be had in the Christian life, but not all paths lead to life.
Monday, February 11, 2013
Predicting Someone's Future
I read everything by everyone, but what I let be positively influential in my life is a different story. If you want to know where people will be in their theological and ethical thinking five years down the line, you don't look at what they say now, but what group of people they're reading and hanging around. As it is said that "bad company corrupts good morals," so it is that a man's fondness of a particular trajectory of literature, a particular church, a particular social group acts as a crystal ball into his future. Our sin nature latches onto rebellion like Venom on Spiderman. In fact, one drifts away merely by no longer being influenced by orthodoxy, much less being influenced by the unorthodox. Though he be a faithful orthodox Christian today, he will be a blasphemer of that tradition tomorrow if his influences are blasphemers of it today. That's just the nature of the beast.
Jesus Ordered the Slaughter of the Canaanites
Arguably, the apostle who speaks of love more than any other is the apostle John. He speaks of God's love for His people and records the commands of Christ that we ought to love one another. In his epistles, he argues that no one who does not love his fellow Christian can be said to love God, and that God is love.
Yet, John also records to us other words of Christ that indicate that Jesus is the God of the Old Testament, that He and the Father are One, that He is the God who existed before Abraham came to be, and most importantly for our discussion, that He is the God who spoke to Moses in the exodus event.
In fact, I want to zero in on that last idea for a moment. In John 8, Jesus identifies Himself as the God of Abraham and Moses by saying that Abraham had a relationship with Him, saw His day, and was glad. He then tells us that even before Abraham He is ego eimi "I AM." This is a clear reference to the I AM statement in Exodus 3, where Moses encounters YHWH, which is likely derived from 'eyeh "I AM."
In that narrative, YHWH tells Moses that He is going to force Pharaoh's hand in giving up His people and will harden his heart to display His glory to the nations over a rebellious people. We all know that this foreshadows His plagues upon Egypt that culminate in the deaths of the firstborn children of the Egyptians (a lex talionis judgment on God's part for Pharaoh's unjust killing of the Israelite baby boys).
It is this YHWH who kills the firstborn sons of the Egyptians, and then proceeds to guide Israel in their war against the Amalekites as well as to instruct them to destroy the Canaanites.
Rather than disassociate Himself from the God of this narrative, Jesus tells us that He is YHWH. In other words, He is the God of that narrative.
In fact, everyone reading John's prologue would understand that when John said that the Logos = the Son was God, that He is to be understood as the God presented in the Old Testament, specifically in the Pentateuch upon which John builds his Gospel. The Son is the God of Abraham and Moses, the God who reigned fire on Sodom and Gomorrah, the God who struck down the firstborn children in Egypt, the God who slew the Canaanites and ordered their destruction as a people.
The argument John makes of the Logos assumes the Wisdom tradition in what I call a "priority argument" that presents the Son as the Personified Divine Wisdom upon which the Torah is based. Hence, Jesus' authority is greater than Moses' authority, not because they teach two different things, but because the Son is the wisdom upon which Moses' commands are rooted. Hence, the Torah is a direct product of the Father through the Divine Person of the Son. That means that the commands therein are not antithetical toward who the Son is and what the Son teaches, but in continuity with who He is and what He teaches. He teaches the fullest expression of it, revealing the Father in fulness, whereas the law was only a partial, not inaccurate, revelation of Him. Hence, the Torah is to be read as rooted in God who is love, rather than read, as many attempt today, as antithetical toward what is loving. The commands in the Torah, even the ones that command the slaughter of enemies, is rooted in the wisdom of the Son and reveals the love of the Father.
John, therefore, isn't saying that Jesus is a different kind of God. He's not another God. Nor is he saying that Jesus is love and the God of the Old Testament is not love. What he is saying is that God is love and the God of love is the same God of the Old Testament, the same God who annihilates the wicked.
This means two things:
(1) That Jesus cannot be used to pit one view of God against the other (i.e., the view of God in the NT versus the view of God in the OT), as they are one and the same. The person who attempts this has, therefore, in the eyes of the Gospels, got his reconciliation of the Old and New Testaments wrong.
and
(2) The terrifying judgments of God in the Old Testament need to be understood in terms of God's love for His people. God is love refers to what God is for His people. Love must choose between agents of life and agents of chaos, and God chooses His people over agents of chaos who would destroy them. Hence, every judgment of God is an act of love toward His people, and to understand them differently is to misunderstand what God is doing, who He is, and what love for a group of people really looks like in threatening situations.
The gnostics tried to create a different God out of Jesus than the one in the Old Testament as well. They wanted to present a Jesus according to their own culturally-derived religious and philosophical sensibilities. But John tells us that this is the spirit of Antichrist (i.e., replacing the real Jesus Christ with a different one). Those who are not born of God attempt to replace Christ with one more philosophically palatable, but those who are born of God know the real Jesus, and therefore, listen to them, not to those who speak "according to the world" (reading 1 John 4:1-6 here would be instructive).
In other words, if one is to "listen to us" (i.e., the apostles), rather than the false prophets of antichrist, who replace the real Christ who is the God of the Old Testament, with another Christ who is a creation of their own lopsided view of what love should always look like, regardless of the situation, then one needs to view Christ as they viewed Him, as they remember His own statements about Himself. He is not a god of the Bible, i.e., the nice loving one as opposed to the mean wrathful one. He is the God of the Bible, and if you are one of His people, He is nothing but love to us; but if you are not, it is a terrible thing to fall into the hands of the living God. And that terrifying God is the Son into whose hands all judgment has been placed, and through whom a terrifying end to the wicked world will be brought about when He returns and slays His enemies and casts them into the fire.
Here, we would be wise to take John's words well. The apostles actually knew Jesus. They saw with their own eyes. They touched Him with their own hands. They heard Him with their own ears. The false prophets have not. They speculate about Him, but John and the other apostles knew Him.
So I ask you this: Are we to understand Jesus as the modern liberal understands Him, as polemical toward the God of the Old Testament, specifically the Pentateuch? Or should we understand Him as the apostles have understood Him, as the God of the Old Testament who does not disassociate Himself from the God of that narrative, but rather identifies Himself as One with the God of that narrative?
As John tells us, he who does not have the Spirit of God will not listen to the apostles. Only he who has the Spirit of God will. Which one are you?
Yet, John also records to us other words of Christ that indicate that Jesus is the God of the Old Testament, that He and the Father are One, that He is the God who existed before Abraham came to be, and most importantly for our discussion, that He is the God who spoke to Moses in the exodus event.
In fact, I want to zero in on that last idea for a moment. In John 8, Jesus identifies Himself as the God of Abraham and Moses by saying that Abraham had a relationship with Him, saw His day, and was glad. He then tells us that even before Abraham He is ego eimi "I AM." This is a clear reference to the I AM statement in Exodus 3, where Moses encounters YHWH, which is likely derived from 'eyeh "I AM."
In that narrative, YHWH tells Moses that He is going to force Pharaoh's hand in giving up His people and will harden his heart to display His glory to the nations over a rebellious people. We all know that this foreshadows His plagues upon Egypt that culminate in the deaths of the firstborn children of the Egyptians (a lex talionis judgment on God's part for Pharaoh's unjust killing of the Israelite baby boys).
It is this YHWH who kills the firstborn sons of the Egyptians, and then proceeds to guide Israel in their war against the Amalekites as well as to instruct them to destroy the Canaanites.
Rather than disassociate Himself from the God of this narrative, Jesus tells us that He is YHWH. In other words, He is the God of that narrative.
In fact, everyone reading John's prologue would understand that when John said that the Logos = the Son was God, that He is to be understood as the God presented in the Old Testament, specifically in the Pentateuch upon which John builds his Gospel. The Son is the God of Abraham and Moses, the God who reigned fire on Sodom and Gomorrah, the God who struck down the firstborn children in Egypt, the God who slew the Canaanites and ordered their destruction as a people.
The argument John makes of the Logos assumes the Wisdom tradition in what I call a "priority argument" that presents the Son as the Personified Divine Wisdom upon which the Torah is based. Hence, Jesus' authority is greater than Moses' authority, not because they teach two different things, but because the Son is the wisdom upon which Moses' commands are rooted. Hence, the Torah is a direct product of the Father through the Divine Person of the Son. That means that the commands therein are not antithetical toward who the Son is and what the Son teaches, but in continuity with who He is and what He teaches. He teaches the fullest expression of it, revealing the Father in fulness, whereas the law was only a partial, not inaccurate, revelation of Him. Hence, the Torah is to be read as rooted in God who is love, rather than read, as many attempt today, as antithetical toward what is loving. The commands in the Torah, even the ones that command the slaughter of enemies, is rooted in the wisdom of the Son and reveals the love of the Father.
John, therefore, isn't saying that Jesus is a different kind of God. He's not another God. Nor is he saying that Jesus is love and the God of the Old Testament is not love. What he is saying is that God is love and the God of love is the same God of the Old Testament, the same God who annihilates the wicked.
This means two things:
(1) That Jesus cannot be used to pit one view of God against the other (i.e., the view of God in the NT versus the view of God in the OT), as they are one and the same. The person who attempts this has, therefore, in the eyes of the Gospels, got his reconciliation of the Old and New Testaments wrong.
and
(2) The terrifying judgments of God in the Old Testament need to be understood in terms of God's love for His people. God is love refers to what God is for His people. Love must choose between agents of life and agents of chaos, and God chooses His people over agents of chaos who would destroy them. Hence, every judgment of God is an act of love toward His people, and to understand them differently is to misunderstand what God is doing, who He is, and what love for a group of people really looks like in threatening situations.
The gnostics tried to create a different God out of Jesus than the one in the Old Testament as well. They wanted to present a Jesus according to their own culturally-derived religious and philosophical sensibilities. But John tells us that this is the spirit of Antichrist (i.e., replacing the real Jesus Christ with a different one). Those who are not born of God attempt to replace Christ with one more philosophically palatable, but those who are born of God know the real Jesus, and therefore, listen to them, not to those who speak "according to the world" (reading 1 John 4:1-6 here would be instructive).
In other words, if one is to "listen to us" (i.e., the apostles), rather than the false prophets of antichrist, who replace the real Christ who is the God of the Old Testament, with another Christ who is a creation of their own lopsided view of what love should always look like, regardless of the situation, then one needs to view Christ as they viewed Him, as they remember His own statements about Himself. He is not a god of the Bible, i.e., the nice loving one as opposed to the mean wrathful one. He is the God of the Bible, and if you are one of His people, He is nothing but love to us; but if you are not, it is a terrible thing to fall into the hands of the living God. And that terrifying God is the Son into whose hands all judgment has been placed, and through whom a terrifying end to the wicked world will be brought about when He returns and slays His enemies and casts them into the fire.
Here, we would be wise to take John's words well. The apostles actually knew Jesus. They saw with their own eyes. They touched Him with their own hands. They heard Him with their own ears. The false prophets have not. They speculate about Him, but John and the other apostles knew Him.
So I ask you this: Are we to understand Jesus as the modern liberal understands Him, as polemical toward the God of the Old Testament, specifically the Pentateuch? Or should we understand Him as the apostles have understood Him, as the God of the Old Testament who does not disassociate Himself from the God of that narrative, but rather identifies Himself as One with the God of that narrative?
As John tells us, he who does not have the Spirit of God will not listen to the apostles. Only he who has the Spirit of God will. Which one are you?
Friday, February 8, 2013
Of Contexts and Continuity: Interpreting the Jots and Tittles of the Bible Accurately
People consider me a stickler when it comes to being precise in one's exegesis. I suppose I'm that way because I grew up among cults and was able to see that the smallest misunderstanding concerning what a text was saying often led to a huge misunderstanding of what theology we should take away from that text.
I've commented before about the misuse of the Sermon on the Mount by pacifists. I had a conversation with Scot McKnight a few years ago about the fact that he was ignoring the context in order to support his preconceived ideas that were largely gained from a dispensational/pacifist tradition that interprets the text in discontinuity with the Old Testament rather than, according to Jesus' very words in the sermon, in continuity with it.
As I've been reading Dr. Enns' blog, he keeps using this same misunderstanding of the text as the means to critique the Old Testament.
Today, he commented on some nut who acted like he was the Lord Jesus leaving a comment on his blog; but although deserving, perhaps, the tone of the response it received by Dr. Enns, one has to note the irony in that both this guy AND Dr. Enns are making absolute statements and speaking for Jesus. Both are putting words in Jesus' mouth--one by pretending to be Jesus and the other by taking Jesus out of context and not permitting Him to speak for Himself.
For instance, he states:
You see—if I may, knowing who you can’t wait to judge us–some of us who are really trying to pay attention to your book get very confused about what exactly it wants from us. For example, why did you and God say in one part of the Bible that killing our enemies–even women and children–was your will, but then, you and God change your mind about all that in other parts (the parts where you are speaking, Jesus)? Also, please clarify, if you would, that part about smashing the heads of Babylonian babies against the rocks, and also the part where drowning everyone on earth was the best way to deal with sin way early in the book you wrote, but later you took a very different approach.
This all assumes that Dr. Enns has gotten Jesus right in the SofM, and yet, the context is very clear that Dr. Enns has not gotten Him right. In my conversation with McKnight years ago, he ended up ignoring my arguments from context and just gave me the "we all have different interpretations" thing. I suppose Dr. Enns might do the same, but that, of course, is a cop out. We're not left to imagine what the context might be. It's right there in front of us. Jesus says that His purpose is not to go against the commandments of the OT, that whoever annuls even the smallest part of the law will be considered least in the kingdom of God, and that those who practice lawlessness rather than God's law will be cast off from Him. He then proceeds to reject interpretive traditions based upon their limiting the applications of the Old Testament law rather than seeking to apply them to every situation in life.
So I have to ask, What's left of this claim that Jesus and God say one thing in part of the Bible and then something different in another part? A major emphasis of the New Testament is that Jesus is coming back to deliver His people by slaughtering all of His enemies and casting them into outer darkness/the gehenna of fire where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. That sounds pretty much in continuity to what God does in the Old Testament with Israel's enemies. So where is the discontinuity?
Now, of course, the Church isn't physical Israel. That's another one of the important points of the New Testament. It is spiritual Israel, but the physical aspect is eschatological and so Christians wait for that fulfillment in resurrection and glorification. But that's not God acting in two different ways. That's God working with two different groups of people in two different situations for two different purposes.
If I "command" my older son to go catch a fish for dinner back when we lived by a pond, it would be absurd to suggest that my younger son now should need to obey that same command even though we now live in a desert and we get our fish now from the grocery store. It would be equally absurd for someone to suggest that I've changed somehow--that one presentation of me is in discontinuity with the other. We're not talking about different Gods and Jesuses when it comes to what the Old Testament commands and what Jesus commands in His interpreting the Old Testament. We're talking about different contexts and different programs; but the one program is virtually the same as the other, i.e., God commands us to destroy chaos among us as He continues to do the same. The difference is that the Church isn't a physical nation that carries the sword because our conquering King, our Divine Warrior, is conquering sin within us first and then will return to do the rest--and that "rest" looks very much like the Canaanite conquest applied to the entire earth (in fact, the NT presents it as such).
So I think the burden of proof rests on the pacifists, who clearly feel they must appeal to neo-errancy in order to make their arguments. They are making the same mistake that many have made throughout church history when allegorizing the conquest accounts, but a far more grievous error when concluding that the Old Testament is wrong in its depiction of God. The former may be a wayward orthodoxy, the latter a Marcionite heresy. And all of it due to ignoring the context of what Jesus actually says in one particular passage, even a single verse that says, "love your enemies." So much destruction is found in the misinterpretation of those three little words.
I've commented before about the misuse of the Sermon on the Mount by pacifists. I had a conversation with Scot McKnight a few years ago about the fact that he was ignoring the context in order to support his preconceived ideas that were largely gained from a dispensational/pacifist tradition that interprets the text in discontinuity with the Old Testament rather than, according to Jesus' very words in the sermon, in continuity with it.
As I've been reading Dr. Enns' blog, he keeps using this same misunderstanding of the text as the means to critique the Old Testament.
Today, he commented on some nut who acted like he was the Lord Jesus leaving a comment on his blog; but although deserving, perhaps, the tone of the response it received by Dr. Enns, one has to note the irony in that both this guy AND Dr. Enns are making absolute statements and speaking for Jesus. Both are putting words in Jesus' mouth--one by pretending to be Jesus and the other by taking Jesus out of context and not permitting Him to speak for Himself.
For instance, he states:
You see—if I may, knowing who you can’t wait to judge us–some of us who are really trying to pay attention to your book get very confused about what exactly it wants from us. For example, why did you and God say in one part of the Bible that killing our enemies–even women and children–was your will, but then, you and God change your mind about all that in other parts (the parts where you are speaking, Jesus)? Also, please clarify, if you would, that part about smashing the heads of Babylonian babies against the rocks, and also the part where drowning everyone on earth was the best way to deal with sin way early in the book you wrote, but later you took a very different approach.
This all assumes that Dr. Enns has gotten Jesus right in the SofM, and yet, the context is very clear that Dr. Enns has not gotten Him right. In my conversation with McKnight years ago, he ended up ignoring my arguments from context and just gave me the "we all have different interpretations" thing. I suppose Dr. Enns might do the same, but that, of course, is a cop out. We're not left to imagine what the context might be. It's right there in front of us. Jesus says that His purpose is not to go against the commandments of the OT, that whoever annuls even the smallest part of the law will be considered least in the kingdom of God, and that those who practice lawlessness rather than God's law will be cast off from Him. He then proceeds to reject interpretive traditions based upon their limiting the applications of the Old Testament law rather than seeking to apply them to every situation in life.
So I have to ask, What's left of this claim that Jesus and God say one thing in part of the Bible and then something different in another part? A major emphasis of the New Testament is that Jesus is coming back to deliver His people by slaughtering all of His enemies and casting them into outer darkness/the gehenna of fire where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth. That sounds pretty much in continuity to what God does in the Old Testament with Israel's enemies. So where is the discontinuity?
Now, of course, the Church isn't physical Israel. That's another one of the important points of the New Testament. It is spiritual Israel, but the physical aspect is eschatological and so Christians wait for that fulfillment in resurrection and glorification. But that's not God acting in two different ways. That's God working with two different groups of people in two different situations for two different purposes.
If I "command" my older son to go catch a fish for dinner back when we lived by a pond, it would be absurd to suggest that my younger son now should need to obey that same command even though we now live in a desert and we get our fish now from the grocery store. It would be equally absurd for someone to suggest that I've changed somehow--that one presentation of me is in discontinuity with the other. We're not talking about different Gods and Jesuses when it comes to what the Old Testament commands and what Jesus commands in His interpreting the Old Testament. We're talking about different contexts and different programs; but the one program is virtually the same as the other, i.e., God commands us to destroy chaos among us as He continues to do the same. The difference is that the Church isn't a physical nation that carries the sword because our conquering King, our Divine Warrior, is conquering sin within us first and then will return to do the rest--and that "rest" looks very much like the Canaanite conquest applied to the entire earth (in fact, the NT presents it as such).
So I think the burden of proof rests on the pacifists, who clearly feel they must appeal to neo-errancy in order to make their arguments. They are making the same mistake that many have made throughout church history when allegorizing the conquest accounts, but a far more grievous error when concluding that the Old Testament is wrong in its depiction of God. The former may be a wayward orthodoxy, the latter a Marcionite heresy. And all of it due to ignoring the context of what Jesus actually says in one particular passage, even a single verse that says, "love your enemies." So much destruction is found in the misinterpretation of those three little words.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)