1. Ancient conquest accounts use the language of slaughtering women and children as hyperbole (see K. Lawson Younger, Ancient Conquest Accounts: A Study in Ancient Near Eastern and Biblical History Writing [Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1990]). It's somewhat equivalent to someone playing a game of basketball and saying to his opponent, "We're going to annihilate you." The language isn't literal.
2. What proves the above is the fact that there are tons of Canaanites left over from the conquest after Joshua and that generation dies. The Israelites have continual problems with them, and as I argued before and will say again below, if one does not wipe out the entire tribe of his enemy, the children of that tribe will rise up and wipe out your children according to the ancient commitment to fulfilling familial vendettas.
3. The purpose of God is to wipe out the Canaanites eventually in His judgment of their sins, as according to Scripture, when one practices chaos, chaos is then turned in on him. If he wishes to participate in practices that kill children, his children will be killed and his line snuffed out from the earth. Hence, even if it is not fulfilled in the conquest accounts, God made it clear via revelation that it was His goal to bring judgment upon the various tribes lumped together as "Canaanites." If God does not have the right to end the lives of men, women, and children according to His terms, then one needs to make an argument that He doesn't have the right to do it now, as according to the Bible, He ends the life of every man, woman, and child who dies on the planet by deciding that their time has come to an end here.
Furthermore, if He does not work toward the goal of wiping out the Canaanites, then His establishment of the Israelites is all for nothing, as the people He saves today will simply be annihilated tomorrow (according to ancient Near Eastern tribal thinking concerning vendettas), defeating His whole purpose to save Israel.
4. His purpose is to give birth to the nation of Israel, and in so doing, teach them to defend themselves in war. If we are to understand what is going on, we have to cooperate with the biblical narrative. They have lived their whole lives as slaves in Egypt. They have never fought or defended themselves from any harm. It seems necessary, therefore, to include them in their own reacquiring of the land and the defense of their own people.
5. The account says that God kills more Canaanites than the Israelites do. Even though he involves them, the judgment of the Canaanites is primarily His work. We only know this because God spoke to Moses and Joshua and told them audibly that this was the case. One cannot make an argument that he or she is fulfilling God's judgment upon a people unless God has specifically given that person such a revelation, and many orthodox Christians don't believe revelation of such a thing is still given, nor do they (and this is the really important point) believe that the Church, which is the only institution that would receive revelation from God if He still communicated that way, has authority to enact God's physical judgment upon a person or group. The sword is given to nations, not to the Church. The Bible separates the sphere of authority between church and state, one governing the spiritual war and the other governing what may occur physically. Hence, there are numerous applications to be made of the Conquest Accounts into the believer's life today, but participating in physical judgment of a person or group as God's emissary is not one of them.
I'll say again what I said before. You cannot judge an ancient people in a completely different context than your own. In tribal life, a tribe is in continual struggle with any other tribe(s) it may rub the wrong way. The context is unique by that alone, but what makes it even more unique is God's divine commands concerning it. Making judgments from the Lazyboy only furthers the apathy toward such a way of thinking, as one's life, family, community is in no danger from another community that wishes to take his life, the lives of his family members, and annihilate his community. But in this ancient setting, that's exactly what the Israelites had to worry about, daily. "And God saw their affliction and had pity on them."
Thursday, February 7, 2013
Wednesday, February 6, 2013
Disturbing Messianic Behavior: Troubling Images of Jesus in the New Testament
Neo-errantists like to focus on the Old Testament passages concerning violence, and then say that their model for judging those passages is Jesus Himself as He is represented in the New Testament. So let's look at Jesus in the New Testament.
Jesus is depicted as one who turns over the tables in the temple and beats the animals/people? (the reference is vague) with a whip.
He declares that He came to split up families and told His followers to take God's commands and truth more seriously than their most valued relationships with people, including their parents.
He continually labels people with all sorts of insulting names: brood of vipers, white-washed tombs, children of the devil, etc.
He tells His disciples to buy and carry a sword.
He tells Pilate that the only reason why His followers are not fighting in a war against Rome and killing off her soldiers is, not because He's against violence, but because His kingdom is not of this world.
Jesus continually tells us that it is necessary for Him to participate in His own violent bloody death by placing Himself on the cross.
He continually talks about the wrath of God remaining on everyone who does not receive Him.
He says of one of His disciples, Judas, that it would have been better if he were never born.
He implies that God kills off a bunch of people by having a tower fall on them, and then warns that a violent death awaits all of those who do not repent.
He tells everyone that when He comes again He's going to slaughter all of His enemies and throw them into hell (talk about the Canaanite Conquest redivivus). In fact, this is the one image above all others that is repeated of Jesus throughout the New Testament (in the Gospels, in Paul's epistles, in Jude, in the Apocalypse of John, etc.).
If all of this isn't violent enough, He tells us that He is the God as the Old Testament depicts Him, none of which He has come to abolish but rather to fulfill, and that this God is a fuller expression of the God of the Old Testament, not a contradictory expression. That means that Jesus, as God the Son, ordered the slaughter of the Canaanites and their babies. Yikes, that's a much more violent Jesus than that picture of a mild-mannered Jesus petting a lamb at the Christian bookstore.
How do we deal with this violent Jesus? I find that we must critique Jesus with Jesus, and in order to do this, I must judge what is Jesus and what is not Jesus. How do I accomplish this divine feat? Easy, I use my own views and those of my culture to judge what Jesus should be like. Then I can impose that on Jesus, divide the bad and violent Jesus (i.e., the one who doesn't act in a manner acceptable to my thinking) from the good and loving Jesus (i.e., the one that does act in a manner I find acceptable). So you see, I'm simply using Jesus as my standard, and that Jesus just happens to look and act according to me, my ideals. After all, God is really just a more perfect version of me and my ideals.
Some naysayers might say that I'm not using Jesus as a standard at all, or else I wouldn't be able to divide Jesus up this way. They would say that I'm just using myself and not Jesus; but they're just traditionalist meanies who are stuck in their violent (i.e., non conformity to my image) ways. Anyone with the great sensitivity that I have to love would bow down and worship me by emulating me. Anyone who is a horrible human being deserving of my wrath will continue to disregard me and the ideas I value within my culture as the standard to judge what God and Jesus would really do.
In fact, everyone should shun WWJD? and God and Jesus should ask themselves instead WWBD? (What would Bryan do?). Only then can we find what God is really like. Treating the Bible as revelatory that can somehow speak things that are totally foreign to my thinking will inevitably lead to the diminishing of myself and my own ideas and the exaltation of ideas that I, as a sinless omniscient and omnibenevolent being, find to be disturbing.
So you see, Jesus doesn't have to be disturbing if everyone just condemns the biblical portrait of Jesus and follows mine (mine being the product of the Western zeitgeist). My Jesus is the standard because I and my modern sensibilities are the standard. And if you disagree with that, then you should be called violent names and your reputation beaten to a bloody pulp.
Jesus is depicted as one who turns over the tables in the temple and beats the animals/people? (the reference is vague) with a whip.
He declares that He came to split up families and told His followers to take God's commands and truth more seriously than their most valued relationships with people, including their parents.
He continually labels people with all sorts of insulting names: brood of vipers, white-washed tombs, children of the devil, etc.
He tells His disciples to buy and carry a sword.
He tells Pilate that the only reason why His followers are not fighting in a war against Rome and killing off her soldiers is, not because He's against violence, but because His kingdom is not of this world.
Jesus continually tells us that it is necessary for Him to participate in His own violent bloody death by placing Himself on the cross.
He continually talks about the wrath of God remaining on everyone who does not receive Him.
He says of one of His disciples, Judas, that it would have been better if he were never born.
He implies that God kills off a bunch of people by having a tower fall on them, and then warns that a violent death awaits all of those who do not repent.
He tells everyone that when He comes again He's going to slaughter all of His enemies and throw them into hell (talk about the Canaanite Conquest redivivus). In fact, this is the one image above all others that is repeated of Jesus throughout the New Testament (in the Gospels, in Paul's epistles, in Jude, in the Apocalypse of John, etc.).
If all of this isn't violent enough, He tells us that He is the God as the Old Testament depicts Him, none of which He has come to abolish but rather to fulfill, and that this God is a fuller expression of the God of the Old Testament, not a contradictory expression. That means that Jesus, as God the Son, ordered the slaughter of the Canaanites and their babies. Yikes, that's a much more violent Jesus than that picture of a mild-mannered Jesus petting a lamb at the Christian bookstore.
How do we deal with this violent Jesus? I find that we must critique Jesus with Jesus, and in order to do this, I must judge what is Jesus and what is not Jesus. How do I accomplish this divine feat? Easy, I use my own views and those of my culture to judge what Jesus should be like. Then I can impose that on Jesus, divide the bad and violent Jesus (i.e., the one who doesn't act in a manner acceptable to my thinking) from the good and loving Jesus (i.e., the one that does act in a manner I find acceptable). So you see, I'm simply using Jesus as my standard, and that Jesus just happens to look and act according to me, my ideals. After all, God is really just a more perfect version of me and my ideals.
Some naysayers might say that I'm not using Jesus as a standard at all, or else I wouldn't be able to divide Jesus up this way. They would say that I'm just using myself and not Jesus; but they're just traditionalist meanies who are stuck in their violent (i.e., non conformity to my image) ways. Anyone with the great sensitivity that I have to love would bow down and worship me by emulating me. Anyone who is a horrible human being deserving of my wrath will continue to disregard me and the ideas I value within my culture as the standard to judge what God and Jesus would really do.
In fact, everyone should shun WWJD? and God and Jesus should ask themselves instead WWBD? (What would Bryan do?). Only then can we find what God is really like. Treating the Bible as revelatory that can somehow speak things that are totally foreign to my thinking will inevitably lead to the diminishing of myself and my own ideas and the exaltation of ideas that I, as a sinless omniscient and omnibenevolent being, find to be disturbing.
So you see, Jesus doesn't have to be disturbing if everyone just condemns the biblical portrait of Jesus and follows mine (mine being the product of the Western zeitgeist). My Jesus is the standard because I and my modern sensibilities are the standard. And if you disagree with that, then you should be called violent names and your reputation beaten to a bloody pulp.
A New Kind of Human
There are two types of humans, not one. God made them male and female. When you attempt to make them the "same" by diminishing their differences, you inevitably do one of two things: (1) Force everyone to force the puzzle piece of their own gender into another gender's spot, or (2) make a new gender by taking half of each to create a new kind of human. Hence, you either kill off one gender completely or half of each gender in order to make all of humanity the same--thus making a subhuman of one or both of the gendered humans. Any philosophy such as this that argues one must do violence to humanity in order to make it better is suicidal and psychotic. As such, only that which preserves humanity as God made it can be considered Christian and good.
"The rise of women, however long overdue, does not require the fall of men."
Christina Hoff Sommers
And I would argue that the rise of women does not require the fall of womanhood either.
"The rise of women, however long overdue, does not require the fall of men."
Christina Hoff Sommers
And I would argue that the rise of women does not require the fall of womanhood either.
Tuesday, February 5, 2013
The View of Love and Violence from the Lazyboy
Dr. Enns has been showcasing Seibert's view of violent texts in the Old Testament. His final installment, which has, in my opinion, been horribly superficial can be found here:
Seibert's conclusions mimick those of many in the past few years, the most recent being Thom Stark's suggestion that we use such violent texts as texts we should condemn as counterexamples.
However, I'm curious how a pacifist like Seibert answers the following dilemma:
The children of the Canaanites will grow up and look to put the children of the Israelites to death due to the implementation of ancient Near Eastern thinking that children are bound to maintain familial vendettas in order to avenge the deaths of family members.
What I don't think such superficial thinking takes into consideration is the condundrum:
If God does not command the Israelites to wipe out the children of the Canaanites, then he is ensuring the death of the children of the Israelites.
Now, here is the moral dilemma, and why "loving" your way to an acceptable answer doesn't work.
If we understand that loving someone means that we must protect them from the violence of others, then the only way to do that is often to use violence to fulfill that goal.
For instance, I travel through a foreign land with my children. Out walks a local who is intent on murdering my children, for whatever reason (perhaps, he thinks my family is a threat to him by our entering his land). I have a gun. He has a gun. I can choose to allow him to murder my children by doing nothing and "loving" him. But by doing so, I am making a choice to not love my children more than I love the murderer. I let them be murdered even though I have the ability to stop him by killing him first.
Conversely, if I kill him before he murders my children, I am loving my children, but not loving him in that instance by killing him.
Both of these premises assume that loving someone means that you protect them from violence and do not allow them to be murdered (I assume every rational person with even a minute moral compass would agree with that).
Hence, this is the dilemma for Seibert.
If God, and we joining with Him, really loves His children in the situation, then He can only do one of two things: Let the Israelites be murdered, or let the Canaanites, who are under His judgment for their sins, be executed both by Himself (the text actually says that He kills more Canaanites than the Israelites do) and by His people He is training to act as a self-defending nation among other nations in the world.
So here is my question for Siebert: "If you were God, what would you do in that situation?" "What is the most loving course of action in your estimation?"
While we're on that, what is the most loving course of action for the Tutsi when the Hutu man enters their huts intent on slaughtering their families? What if the same spirit of vendetta ruled the hearts of moderns? Would not allowing the children of those who will indeed rise up to murder your children not be an act that sentences your children to death?
You can't merely use our modern context as a backdrop to the divine judgments concerning women and babies in the Old Testament. It's not our world. It's easy to say, "Ooh, I don't like icky violence and condemn the whole lot of it," while you sit safely by the fire in your Lazyboy, sipping your cup of coffee, watching your kids play with their favorite Tonka Toys on the floor. You don't have to make those choices. You can just dumb love down to sympathy toward all people, but that definition of love isn't biblical nor is it practical in the real world of choices when the violence of the world turns in on your children.
I have said many times that God's acts here are acts of love, real-life love, not the pixie dust love of liberal theorists speaking from the safety of their ivory towers. God saves His children by killing the Egyptian children because He loves, not despite of it. God saves His children by killing the Canaanite children because He loves, not despite of it.
Is that our situation? Not in America for the most part (although there are occasional instances where some of us are tested with such a choice to kill a killer and save our loved ones). But we have no voice of God telling us to do so. We have only His example that true love doesn't lay down when one's children are in jeopardy. Only the most hateful and worst element of humanity speak of love for one's enemy when their children's throats are being slit. And that's not even considering that God is timeless, seeing all future events as though they were present---seeing those helpless babies grow up and murder His people all in one moment. What's a loving God to do, Mr. Seibert? What's a loving God to do?
Seibert's conclusions mimick those of many in the past few years, the most recent being Thom Stark's suggestion that we use such violent texts as texts we should condemn as counterexamples.
However, I'm curious how a pacifist like Seibert answers the following dilemma:
The children of the Canaanites will grow up and look to put the children of the Israelites to death due to the implementation of ancient Near Eastern thinking that children are bound to maintain familial vendettas in order to avenge the deaths of family members.
What I don't think such superficial thinking takes into consideration is the condundrum:
If God does not command the Israelites to wipe out the children of the Canaanites, then he is ensuring the death of the children of the Israelites.
Now, here is the moral dilemma, and why "loving" your way to an acceptable answer doesn't work.
If we understand that loving someone means that we must protect them from the violence of others, then the only way to do that is often to use violence to fulfill that goal.
For instance, I travel through a foreign land with my children. Out walks a local who is intent on murdering my children, for whatever reason (perhaps, he thinks my family is a threat to him by our entering his land). I have a gun. He has a gun. I can choose to allow him to murder my children by doing nothing and "loving" him. But by doing so, I am making a choice to not love my children more than I love the murderer. I let them be murdered even though I have the ability to stop him by killing him first.
Conversely, if I kill him before he murders my children, I am loving my children, but not loving him in that instance by killing him.
Both of these premises assume that loving someone means that you protect them from violence and do not allow them to be murdered (I assume every rational person with even a minute moral compass would agree with that).
Hence, this is the dilemma for Seibert.
If God, and we joining with Him, really loves His children in the situation, then He can only do one of two things: Let the Israelites be murdered, or let the Canaanites, who are under His judgment for their sins, be executed both by Himself (the text actually says that He kills more Canaanites than the Israelites do) and by His people He is training to act as a self-defending nation among other nations in the world.
So here is my question for Siebert: "If you were God, what would you do in that situation?" "What is the most loving course of action in your estimation?"
While we're on that, what is the most loving course of action for the Tutsi when the Hutu man enters their huts intent on slaughtering their families? What if the same spirit of vendetta ruled the hearts of moderns? Would not allowing the children of those who will indeed rise up to murder your children not be an act that sentences your children to death?
You can't merely use our modern context as a backdrop to the divine judgments concerning women and babies in the Old Testament. It's not our world. It's easy to say, "Ooh, I don't like icky violence and condemn the whole lot of it," while you sit safely by the fire in your Lazyboy, sipping your cup of coffee, watching your kids play with their favorite Tonka Toys on the floor. You don't have to make those choices. You can just dumb love down to sympathy toward all people, but that definition of love isn't biblical nor is it practical in the real world of choices when the violence of the world turns in on your children.
I have said many times that God's acts here are acts of love, real-life love, not the pixie dust love of liberal theorists speaking from the safety of their ivory towers. God saves His children by killing the Egyptian children because He loves, not despite of it. God saves His children by killing the Canaanite children because He loves, not despite of it.
Is that our situation? Not in America for the most part (although there are occasional instances where some of us are tested with such a choice to kill a killer and save our loved ones). But we have no voice of God telling us to do so. We have only His example that true love doesn't lay down when one's children are in jeopardy. Only the most hateful and worst element of humanity speak of love for one's enemy when their children's throats are being slit. And that's not even considering that God is timeless, seeing all future events as though they were present---seeing those helpless babies grow up and murder His people all in one moment. What's a loving God to do, Mr. Seibert? What's a loving God to do?
Quote of the Decade
One of my old roommates from college shared this on FB, and I thought it was a great quote for those who don't want to believe in the God presented by taking the entire Bible as an accurate picture of God.
"It is less injury to Him to deny His being, than to deny the purity of it; the one makes Him no God, the other a deformed, unlovely, and a detestable God... he that saith God is not holy speaks much worse than he that saith there is no God at all" -Stephen Charnock
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)